Graham and Parks School

Graham and Parks School
Address
44 Linnaean Street Cambridge , Massachusetts 02138
Coordinates	42°22′58″N71°07′26″W / 42.38278°N 71.12389°W / 42.38278; -71.12389
Information
School type	Public
Established	1981
School district	Cambridge Public School District
Principal	Kathleen M. Smith
Grades	Pre-K–5

The Graham and Parks School is a public elementary school in Cambridge, MA. Founded in 1981, the school was originally conceived as an "alternative school" aligned with the progressive education movement. It historically emphasized project-based learning, teacher-led curriculum development, and parent involvement in all aspects of school operation. ^{[1] : 17–18} Since the early 2000s, state curriculum guidelines and local policy changes have diminished these aspects of the school's identity, bringing it in line with city and state standards. ^{[2] [3] : 159–171} The school is named for Rosa Parks and Saundra Graham, a welfare and housing advocate from Cambridge. ^{[3] : 53}

History

The school originated from the merger of two distinct educational institutions in 1981: the Cambridge Alternative Public School (CAPS) and the Webster School. CAPS, established in 1972 by a group of parents, was a small, nationally acclaimed magnet school with a progressive educational philosophy. ^{[3] : 50–53} The Webster School was a traditional neighborhood school. Following their consolidation, the unified school operated on Upton Street from 1982 until 2003, after which it relocated to 44 Linnaean Street. ^[4] The school originally ran from kindergarten through eighth grade; in 2011, the Cambridge School Committee voted to move the sixth through eighth grades into a separate middle school. ^{[3] : 310–312}

Demographics

During the 1980s, the school was approximately half white and half children of color. ^[2] In the 1990s, as Cambridge became more racially diverse, the proportion of children of color in the school rose to about 60%. ^{[1] : 33–34} Approximately half the students at the time were eligible for free or reduced-price lunch. ^[5] In the early 2000s, the school became increasingly white and affluent; by 2007, white families made up more than half the school. ^[6] As of 2023, the school was 50.3% white, 21.5% Asian, 13.9% Black, and 7.3% multi-racial. ^[7]

Curriculum

From its inception, the school prioritized teacher-led curriculum development. Len Solo, who served as the school's principal from its founding until the early 2000s, explained the approach: "We encourage our teachers to develop their own curriculum. In fact, we feel it is a strength of our school. People here have a lot of passion for what they teach. Their excitement inspires kids to learn." ^{[3] : 54}

A key component of the curriculum for the school's first two decades was the Creole bilingual education program serving Haitian immigrants. ^[8] The program ended after a statewide referendum in 2002 barred bilingual education programs across Massachusetts. ^[2]

Since the early 2000s, the curriculum at Graham and Parks has increasingly been determined by district and state mandates. ^[2] A 2013 article on Graham and Parks in the Berkeley Review of Education described how the efforts of teachers to address the "socio-emotional, developmental, and cultural needs" of students were increasingly in tension with the "narrow limits of the traditional mandates" imposed by the district and state. ^[9]

Performance

During the first two decades of its existence, the school did not place an emphasis on standardized test preparation, but its results on statewide tests were nonetheless among the best in Massachusetts. ^{[1] : 14–17  [10]} As of 2024, on the statewide MCAS exams, 54% of students were meeting or exceeding expectations in English language arts and 58% were meeting or exceeding expectations in math. ^[11]

Controversy

In 2024, parents raised concerns about the hiring and conduct of principal Kathleen M. Smith. ^[12] A petition signed by more than 100 parents called for greater transparency in communication from Smith and greater inclusion of both families and teachers in school decision making. ^[13] Parents faulted Smith for creating a "tense" and "toxic" atmosphere, alleging that teachers and staff felt "targeted" and "disrespected" by the principal. ^[14] A public records request revealed that Smith had left her previous position as principal of the Underwood Elementary School in Newton, MA after an investigation concluded that she had created a "toxic working environment" for teachers. ^[15] Parents faulted district leadership for a lack of transparency and rigor in the hiring process for the principal. The district Superintendent, Victoria Greer, was forced to leave her position after facing criticism for her hiring of Smith and other administrators. ^[16] An investigation of Smith commissioned by the district "did not support a finding of a toxic workplace." Interim Superintendent David Murphy announced the placement of a "special advisor to the superintendent" within the school in response to what he described as "a challenging" year. ^[17]

References

1. Solo, Len (2010). Making an Extraordinary School: The Work of Ordinary People. Baltimore, MD: PublishAmerica.
2. Solo, Len (2014). "The Un-Making of an Extraordinary School" (PDF). Nonpartisan Education Review. 10 (2): 1–17.
3. Greeley, Kathy (2024). Testing Education: A Teacher's Memoir. University of Massachusetts Press. doi:10.2307/jj.16738702. ISBN   978-1-62534-784-8.
4. "Timeline". grahamandparks.cpsd.us. Retrieved 2024-12-06.
5. Minicucci, Catherine (1996). "Learning Science and English: How School Reform Advances Scientific Learning for Limited English Proficient Middle School Students". Center for Research on Education, Diversity and Excellence.
6. Jan, Tracy. "An Imbalance Grows in Cambridge Schools - Placements Based on Income, Not Race." Boston Globe, Jul 23 2007, ProQuest. Web. 6 Dec. 2024 . https://www.proquest.com/docview/405069077/BB1EF2329114541PQ/102
7. "Enrollment Data (2023-24) - Graham and Parks (00490080)". profiles.doe.mass.edu. Retrieved 2024-12-06.
8. Minicucci, Catherine (2000). "Effective Use of Time in the Education of English Language Learners". The Dimensions of Time and the Challenge of School Reform. State University of New York Press. pp. 60–61.
9. Harouni, Houman (2013). "Lived-in Room: Classroom Space as Teacher". Berkeley Review of Education. 4 (2). doi:10.5070/B84110012.
10. Thomas Duffy "Putting Their Minds to the Test: Schools that Scored Well on Statewide MEAP Tests Last Year Share Their Secrets For Getting Kids to Think." Boston Globe, Mar 07 1993, p. 2. ProQuest. Web. 6 Dec. 2024 . https://www.proquest.com/docview/2921605533/BB1EF2329114541PQ/24?sourcetype=Historical%20Newspapers.
11. "Read MCAS test scores, see ELA, math results by school or district". BostonGlobe.com. Retrieved 2024-12-06.
12. Huffaker, Christopher. "Cambridge Elementary School Parents Criticize Superintendent Over Principal Hiring." Boston Globe (Online), Mar 20, 2024. https://www.bostonglobe.com/2024/03/19/metro/cambridge-superintendent-parent-complaints-graham-parks/
13. Levy, Marc (2024-02-07). "Graham & Parks principal draws an investigation when parents see echoes of problems in Newton". Cambridge Day. Retrieved 2024-12-06.
14. Dippolito, Charlie (2024-03-11). "Letter illustrates a sense of fear and conflict permeating Graham & Parks over principal". Cambridge Day. Retrieved 2024-12-06.
15. Andersen, T. (2024, Feb 27). "Cambridge Elementary School Principal Under Outside Review After Complaints from Parents, Officials Say." Boston Globe. https://www.bostonglobe.com/2024/02/27/metro/cambridge-elementary-school-principal-under-review/
16. Khaw, M., & Huffaker, C. (2024, May 29). "Cambridge School Committee Votes in Favor of Superintendent's Resignation." Boston Globe. https://www.bostonglobe.com/2024/05/29/metro/cambridge-superintendent-resign-victoria-greer/
17. Huffaker, C. (2024, Aug 27). "Investigation Clears Cambridge Principal," Boston Globe, https://www.bostonglobe.com/2024/08/26/metro/cambridge-investigation-graham-parks-kathleen-smith