Hatuqay

Last updated
Hatuqay
Хьатыкъуайхэр, Хьатыкъоехэр
Shedzheryk'o.svg Circassian flag.svg
The tamga of the ruling Shezheruqo sub-branch of the Cherchanuqo dynasty which ruled the Hatuqay princedom (left). The Circassian flag (right)
Regions with significant populations
Mainly:
Flag of Turkey.svg  Turkey (Pınarbaşı, Bozüyük, Bolu, Hendek) [1] [2]
Small populations:
Flag of Syria (2025-).svg  Syria (Quneitra, Homs) [3]
Flag of Israel.svg  Israel (Kfar Kama) [4]
Flag of Jordan.svg  Jordan
Flag of Russia.svg  Russia (Khatukay)
Languages
Adyghe (Hatuqay dialect), Turkish, Arabic, Hebrew
Religion
Sunni Islam (Hanafi)
Related ethnic groups
Other Adyghe tribes

The Hatuqay or Hatuqway [a] are one of the twelve major Circassian tribes, [5] [6] representing one of the twelve stars on the green-and-gold Circassian flag. [7] [8] They speak the Hatuqay dialect of the Adyghe language. [9] Most of them live in Turkey; a result of the Circassian genocide in the 19th century, the majority of the Hatuqay were killed or deported to the Ottoman Empire, resulting in their virtual extinction in their historical homeland. [10] Historically, they lived in the Hatuqay Principality of Circassia and were known for their martial character, engaging in incessant wars. [6] [11] Hatuqay was marked on period maps with various names (Hatukai, Codioci, Gatyukai), including the 1787 map by Johann Anton Güldenstädt [12] and the 1675 map by Frederik de Wit. [13] [14]

Contents

Distribution

The Hatuqay tribe was originally located near the Black Sea coast, around the Taman peninsula, [15] as well as the southern banks of the Kuban, a little further down from where the Afips (Афыпс) river flows. [6] [16] However, in the late 18th century, the Hatuqay Principality was relocated west of the Temirgoys, in the territory situated between the Belaya (Шъхьагуащэ) and Pshish (Пщыщ) rivers. [6] [16] [9]

Today, nearly all Hatuqays live in the diaspora. There is a small community in Adygea, but today they speak the Temirgoy dialect. In Turkey, there are approximately 20 Hatuqay villages in Kayseri's Pınarbaşı district, mainly in the Çörümşek valley. There are also Hatuqay villages in Biga and Bozüyük. [17] [18] [19] Hatuqays also live in Syria, especially in the Homs district and Quneitra in the Golan heights. [6] Some Hatuqays from Syria repatriated to Karachay-Cherkessia during the Syrian civil war. [20] There are also some Hatuqays in Israel, particularly in Kfar Kama. [6] In Jordan, head of the General Intelligence Department, Ahmad Husni Hatoqay, was a Hatuqay Circassian. [21]

Relief Map of Krasnodarski Krai.png
Clear pog.svg
Adamey
Clear pog.svg
Makhosh
Yellow ffff00 pog.svg
Hatuqay
Clear pog.svg
Adele
Cyan pog.svg
Turquoise pog.svg
Orange pog.svg
Blue pog.svg
Clear pog.svg
Shegak
Pfeil rechts.svg
Tapanta
Clear pog.svg
Anapa-----
Clear pog.svg
Novorossisk-
Clear pog.svg
Gelendzhik-
Clear pog.svg
Tuapse-----
Clear pog.svg
Sochi-----
Clear pog.svg
Gagra-----
Approximate location of Circassian princedoms, Tsutsiev's Atlas

Language

The Hatuqay speak the Hatuqay dialect of Adyghe. [9] Hatuqay is classified as one of the "Steppe dialects", a subgroup of that also includes the Temirgoy, Abzakh and Bzhedug dialects, [9] although it also shares many grammatical and phonological features with the "Coastal Dialects" of Shapsug and Natukhaj. [9] Thus, it can be considered an "in-between" dialect. Although a dialect of Western Circassian (Adyghe), it is considered the closest among the Western dialects to Eastern Circassian. [6] This may be due to frequent interaction with Kabardians in Kayseri, as Hatuqays are a minority among the majority Kabardians.

Religion

The Hatuqays are Sunni Muslims. They were one of the first Circassian tribes to embrace Islam. [22] Islam entered Circassian culture not directly, but through stories and folk tales: ceremonies celebrating the birth of the Prophet Muhammad played a key role, and a new genre of Circassian epic literature connected with the birth celebration of the Prophet emerged: "Mewlid". [8] [22] Evliya Çelebi, who visited Hatuqay in the late 1600s, wrote that mosques existed in the villages and that the people chanted "la ilahe illallah" (There is no god but Allah), but they failed to fully grasp Islam and continued their old traditions. [22]

History

Almost all knowledge about the founding of the Hatuqay Principality and tribe comes from oral history. According to these oral accounts, the founding dynasty of the Hatuqay Principality descends from king Inal: Prince Hatuqo was the grandson of Inal, son of Chemrug and brother of Prince Boletoqo (Adyghe : Болэтыкъо), the first prince of the Chemguy Principality. In the period following Inal's death, the Chemguy Principality was divided into two principalities. One became the land of Prince Boletoqo, and the other, Prince Hatuqo. The elder brother, Prince Boletoqo, remained in his principality in the region between the Greater Laba and Shkhakoshem rivers, retaining the name Chemguy. Prince Hatuqo, however, moved west and established the new principality of Hatuqay. [6] [16] [23] [24]

A legend describes the separation of the tribes: The Chemguy and Hatuqay were originally one people ruled by three brothers: Boletoqo, Zan, and Hatuqo. The twins Boletoqo and Hatuqo, as infants, were sleeping in the same bed covered by a single fur cloth. In the morning, the cloth was found torn in two, leading their mother to shriek, "Woe unto you, Chemirgoy! They have torn you asunder!". [6] The brothers lived in peace until the younger two, Zan and Hatuqo, decided to separate from the eldest, Boletoqo. Prince Boletoqo punished the separatists by stripping them of their property. Hatuqo, tiring of his brother's authority, took his subjects and migrated west to establish a new principality. [23]

The Hatuqay tribe was originally located near the Black Sea coast, around the Taman peninsula, [15] as well as the southern banks of the Kuban, a little further down from where the Afips (Афыпс) river flows. [6] [16] However, in the late 18th century, the Hatuqay Principality was relocated west of the Temirgoys, in the territory situated between the Belaya (Шъхьагуащэ) and Pshish (Пщыщ) rivers. [6] [16] [9] The Hatuqay absorbed the Sobay, a large Circassian tribe that lived on the Belaya River. The Hatuqay nobles living in the large aul of Sobay were known as Sobe-pshi (Princes of Sobay). [15]

The Hatuqays had a strong army and were known for their warlike character. They were notorious for their incessant wars against other Circassians. [6] They also participated in wars against the Crimean Tatars. One of the Hatuqay princes, nicknamed "The Pale," looted Astrakhan in alliance with the Kabardians. [6]

Turkish explorer Evliya Çelebi compiled the oldest detailed description of the Hatuqay tribe, he wrote: [11]

The Great Province of Hatuqay. Its prince is named Jangirey, that is, Janbe Giray. When Janbe Giray Sultan was a guest there, a child was born to the prince that very night; thus, they named him Jangirey after Janbe Giray Sultan. To this day, Circassian traditions are such that if a son is born while a guest is in the house, they name him after the guest. At that very moment, a wet nurse takes the boy away to another place. She feeds and raises him even better than his own mother and father could. We observed that this is still the case. If there is no guest in the house, they give the boy the name of a neighbor; this is their ancient custom. This Hatuqay prince is wealthy, possessing many livestock and 8,000 fully armed soldiers. Because this province is a vast, fertile, and beautiful homeland, the Nevruz Mirza Tatars—who fled the Muscovite King after he killed his son, fighting their way through the Kalmyk infidels, crossing the Volga River and the Heyhat Plains—have settled here on the banks of the Kuban River in Hatuqay Circassian territory. They became kin. In total, they number 10,000 soldiers and 6,000 tents. They are exceedingly skilled with quivers, silver-inlaid gear, and weapons, and are valiant soldiers.

If you were to call this Circassian tribe "infidels," they would grant you neither mercy nor time, but would kill you on the spot. Furthermore, they say "La ilahe illallah" (There is no god but God), yet they eat fat pigs starting from the tail; they do not fast or perform the daily prayers, and they do not allow anyone who does not own a pig into the village. They have absolutely no churches, bazaars, markets, inns, or bathhouses. All travelers and passersby stay in private homes. If you are a guest in a house and leave your goods and property out in the open, not a single scrap will be harmed. Even if you were their enemy, the host and his neighbors would die for your sake. They would not let any harm come to you.

This Circassian language, even now, cannot be written down; it is a language based on listening, produced from the throat, cheeks, and under the tongue, a sound that is like a sparrow's chirp and cannot be committed to paper. This humble servant of God, a traveler of the world and companion to man, the unpretentious Evliya, has traveled for 51 years, setting foot in 18 kingdoms across seven climes, and has written down 147 languages with my gem-scattering pen, including their eloquence, rhetoric, and poems, in order to converse with the people of every region. But I could not write down this Circassian language with its magpie-like sound. By the will of God, we will try to write this language as best as we can. They have a peculiar dialect, for they are not literate. That is why it cannot be committed to paper; it is a bird's language, and that is that.

Evliya Çelebi, the Seyahatnâme

The Hatuqay maintained control over fertile lowlands and crucial trade routes in the northwestern Caucasus, resisting both Tatar incursions and Ottoman-backed pressure. [25] [26] Tensions escalated throughout the 1540s as the Hatuqay leadership increasingly resisted demands for tribute and subordination [27] and sought alliances. Hatuqay princes Elok and Antenuk were involved in these acts. [28] They are quoted as saying the following: [29]

The Khan, they say, is coming to raid us, but we are not like the Zhaney and Kabardians. He is strong because of his zarbuzan cannons, but our cannons and rifles are the steep mountains and the warhorses. We have no need for his cannon carts. Does the Khan have the courage to attack us? If he comes, we will become a curse to him.

[30]

In response, Crimean Khan Sahib I Giray organized a punitive expedition in 1551, aiming to break Hatuqai resistance and reassert Crimean authority in the region. [31] The region faced difficulty with the Crimean campaign in Hatuqay (1551), as the Crimean Tatars defeated the army of the Hatuqay and ravaged the Bzhedug lands. [32] Although the Hatuqay army was defeated, allied Kabardians led by Temruq Idar managed to defeat the Crimeans, thus the war technically ended in a victory. [33] Sahib Giray had inflicted severe blows on almost all major principalities of Circassia: Zhaney, Hatuqay, Bzhedug, Kabardia. It is after this that the Circassians started to seek alliances with Russia to fight against Tatar incursions. [29]

Some historians suggested that the Khegayk tribe was separated from the Hatuqays. [6] [16] [24] The word "Khegayk" means "breakaways". [15] According to Amjad Jaimoukha, it was the Hakuch tribe who split from Hatuqays, which contributed to the weakening of the tribe. [6] In addition, Hatuqay and Hytuk may refer to the same tribe. [15] [24]

One of the most famous Hatuqay princes was Aslan-Girey (Adyghe: Аслъанджэрый), known for his character and oratorical skill despite being physically weak. The Hatuqay Principality reached its zenith during Aslan-Girey's reign. On his deathbed, surrounded by elders and nobles, Aslan-Girey's will stipulated that every slave in the Hatuqay Principality be freed according to Islamic obligations, and that no Hatuqay would be a slave thereafter. Following this, slave families in the Hatuqay region were emancipated. Hatuqay, which used to be an important Circassian principality of West Circassia, lost this status with Aslan-Girey's death, as the Hatukay Principality split into two warring factions. [6]

By the first quarter of the 18th century, the population of the Hatuqay principality had sharply declined. In the early 19th century, their numbers were further reduced by a plague epidemic. [34]

In the 1840s, the Hatuqay submit to Muhammad Amin, the third Naib of Imam Shamil in the Northwest Caucasus. [35]

In 1863, the Russian military administration dissolved the tribe as a distinct entity in the Caucasus. The surviving Hatuqay were divided into small groups and forcibly resettled into large auls created for the Bzhedug tribe. The Hatuqay population was dispersed, the tribe effectively dissapeared from the map. [10]

Etymology

The name is believed to derive from Prince Hatuqo (Adyghe : Хьатыкъо), who, according to traditional Circassian geneologies, was the founder of the Hatuqay principality, and a prince descended from King Inal. [6] [16] [23]

The name has been the subject of a folk etymology, which explains it as referring to the Hittites ('Son of Hittite'). A study about Circassians in Kayseri found that local Circassians frequently claimed descent from the Hittites. [19] The etymology of Hattusa, capital of the Hittite Empire, is explained with Circassian хьэтӏу (two dogs) + щхьэ (head), which supposedly refers to the two sphinx statues guarding the gate of Hattusa. Some connected the Circassians with the Hattians rather than Hittites; [36] [37] [38] and some authors explained the etymology of "Hatuqay" as "Hatti-Son". [8] [24] The Adyghe Encyclopedia published in Russia compares Hattian mythology and Nart sagas, including stories found in the Hatuqay Nart corpus. [39] The Hittites spoke an Indo-European language, however the possibility of Hattians speaking a Northwest Caucasian language related to Circassian has been considered by linguists, although this is unconfirmed. [40] [41] [42] [43]

Settlements

Below are some of the Hatuqay settlements. [17] [18] [44]

LocationAdyghe name(s)Official name
Adygea, RussiaХьатикъуай Khatukay
Bilecik, TurkeyХьатыкъуае
Пойракъуаджэ
Хьанапщэхьаблэ
Poyra
Bilecik, TurkeyЧэпнэ
Хьанапщэхьаблэ
Yeniçepni
Bolu, TurkeyПэциехьаблэ
Пэдисэй
Elmalık
Kayseri, TurkeyПэдысыешху Akören
Kayseri, TurkeyХъытхьаблэ
Хъытякъуэй
Aygörmez
Kayseri, TurkeyЧэчэнай Beserek
Kayseri, TurkeyИндырэ Burhaniye
Kayseri, TurkeyНыбэрнэкъохьаблэ
Ныбэрынхьаблэ
Ныбэрнэкъуай
Cinliören
Kayseri, TurkeyХьаджэсхьакъуэй
Хьаджыисхьакъ
Demirciören
Kayseri, TurkeyПэдысыежъый Devederesi
Kayseri, TurkeyХэусай İnliören
Kayseri, TurkeyЛыпыйхьаблэ Kavak
Kayseri, TurkeyКъайнар Kaynar
Kayseri, TurkeyКучы Kuşçu
Kayseri, TurkeyБалкъочэй Malak
Kayseri, Turkey? Söğütlü
Kayseri, TurkeyЛакъхьаблэ Tersakan
Sakarya, TurkeyХъанхабьлэ Kargalıhanbaba

Below are some of the Hatuqay clans. [17] [18] [44]

Adyghe nameRussian name
Анзауыр
Анцок
Балкъо
Бжегокъо
Борэн
БрыджБриджов
БэрзэджБерзеков
БзаджБзаджов
ГъучӀэжъ
ГъучӀэпщыкъо
Гусар
Даур
Дахъун
Джэгъащт
ДжэндарДжандаров
Дзэгъащт
Дзэпщ
Драгун
ДышъэчӀ
ДэбракъыкъоДебракиков
Емтыл
ЕутыхЕутыхов
Ечмэкъо
Жане
Жанэкъо
ЖьанэЖанев
Заурым
Иуан
Иуанкъо
ИуаныкъуИваников
ИуныхьЮнихов
Къазаныкъо
КъалэбатэКалибатов
Къандауыр
Къанымэт
Къунчыкъо
Къудэбэрдыкъо
Къуекъо
Къужъэй
Къуйыжъ
Къылыщкъо
Къэлобат
Къэнэмэт
КъочӀас
КъокӏасэКочесеко
Лакъ
Лъэпшъыкъо
ЛӀымафэкъоТлимафов
ЛӀышъхьакъоТлишхаков
ЛӀэрыгъу
Майыис
МастырМастиров
Мед
Мысрэукъо
МэфэшӀукъоМафошов
Мэршэн
Нэгъой
Нэгор
НэжъНажев
Ордэкъо
Пэфыр
ПэдысПадисов
ПчыхьалӀыкъо
Пщыгъусэ
Пщыгъут
ПщыхьачӀэ
ПыхъучӀ
Рыста
Сид
ТакъырыкъоТакириков
Талостэн
Тамбий
Трам
Тыгъужъ
Тыгъурыгъу
ТхьакумачӀэ
Тэмджан
УтыжУтижов
Утыжъый
Хэусай
Хъуран
Хъыт
Хьабачир
ХьабатырХабатыров
Хьажъукъо
Хьаткъо
ХьатыкъоХатиков
Хьацуккъо
ХьачӀэмаф
ХьачӀэмыз
ХьапаеХапаев
Хьэтыжъыкъо
Цагъо
ЦӀэгъошЦегошов
Чыжъэкъо
ЧыназырЧиназиров
Чукъо
Чурмыт
Чэгъэдыу
Чэтыжъ
ЧӀэсэбий
Шегъур
Шермет
Шъанхъо
ШъобаеСобаев
ШэджэрыкъоШегероков
Шэуджен
Шэукъар
Ӏагумкъо
Ӏагъу
Ӏэбатэ
Ӏэжэгъуй
Ӏубжъаукъо

See also

Notes

  1. /ˈhɑːtʊkw/ ; Adyghe: Хьатыкъуай, [ħaːtɘqʷaːj] ; Turkish: Hatukay; Arabic: حتوقاي; Russian: Хатукай

References

  1. Miyazawa, Eiji (2004). Memory Politics: Circassians of Uzunyayla, Turkey (Thesis).
  2. Şıble, Ferhatıko (2022). Batı Çerkesya'nın Türkiye'deki evlatları (in Turkish). APRA. ISBN   978-605-71993-1-7.
  3. Amjad Jaimoukha (April 7, 2015). The Circassians: A Handbook. Taylor & Francis. ISBN   978-1138874602.
  4. Amjad Jaimoukha (April 7, 2015). The Circassians: A Handbook. Taylor & Francis. ISBN   978-1138874602.
  5. Peoples of the USSR: An Ethnographic Handbook. Taylor & Francis. 2017. p. 79. ISBN   978-1-315-47540-0 . Retrieved 20 July 2018.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 Amjad Jaimoukha (April 7, 2015). The Circassians: A Handbook. Taylor & Francis. ISBN   978-1138874602.
  7. Cunningham, B. (1977). The New Jersey ethnic experience. W. H. Wise. p. 108. Retrieved 20 July 2018. ... or Pontic branch, consisting of Abkhaz, Ubykh, and Circassian proper (or Adyghe). The Circassians themselves are divided into some fifteen different clans, including the Abadsakh, Besliney, Bjedoogh, Hatukay, Kabardey, Kamurggoi, Shapsoogh, and Ubykh.
  8. 1 2 3 Kāzemzāde, Hāmed (2018). The Circassian Question: The Formation of Linguistic and Cultural Identity in the Caucasus from the Mind-nineteenth Century to Modern Times (PhD Thesis thesis).
  9. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Aydın, Şamil Emre (2015). Çerkes Diyalektleri: Çerkes Diyalektlerinin Karşılaştırmalı Analizi (in Turkish). Adana. ISBN   978-605-65691-1-1.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
  10. 1 2 Richmond, Walter (2013-04-09). The Circassian Genocide. Rutgers University Press. ISBN   978-0-8135-6069-4.
  11. 1 2 Evliya Çelebi. Seyahatnâme (PDF) (in Turkish). Archived (PDF) from the original on March 20, 2023. Retrieved March 20, 2023.
  12. «Новая карта Кавказа», составленная Иоганном Антоном Гильденштедтом, академиком-ориенталистом на русской службе. (Neue Carte des Caucasus grostentheils aus Guldenstaedts nachgelassenen handschriftlichen Entwurfen zusammengezetzt. [Санкт-Петербург]: [Географический департамент АН]: [1787]. 1 л.: Грав.; 41х73 (59х81). Масштаб приблизительно 33 версты в 1 дюйме. Российская Национальная Библиотека (Санкт-Петербург). Отдел картографии. К 1-Кав 3/10)
  13. Turcium Imperium. - Amstelodami: apud F. de Wit: [1675].
  14. Samir Khamidovich Khotko (2015). Открытие Черкесии. Картографические источники XIV—XIX вв (in Russian). Archived from the original on May 29, 2018. Retrieved July 2, 2023.
  15. 1 2 3 4 5 Кагазежев, Жираслан Валерьевич (2009). Борьба адыгов (черкесов) за национальную государственность: исторический аспект: XIV - первая половина XVI в. (Thesis). ВЛАДИКАВКАЗ: СЕВЕРО-ОСЕТИНСКИЙ ГОСУДАРСТВЕННЫЙ УНИВЕРСИТЕТ ИМ. КЛ.ХЕТАГУРОВА.
  16. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Хан-Гирей, Султан (1836). Записки о Черкесии (in Russian).
  17. 1 2 3 Şıble, Ferhatıko (2022). Batı Çerkesya'nın Türkiye'deki evlatları (in Turkish). APRA. ISBN   978-605-71993-1-7.
  18. 1 2 3 Kalkan (Çurmıt), Mustafa (2023). Bir Çerkes halkı: Hatıkuaylar (in Turkish). ISBN   978-975-449-346-7.
  19. 1 2 Miyazawa, Eiji (2004). Memory Politics: Circassians of Uzunyayla, Turkey (Thesis).
  20. Gazetesi, Jineps (2014-12-01). "Suriye'den Ersakon'a: Yeni bir yaşam". Jineps Gazetesi (in Turkish). Retrieved 2025-12-27.
  21. "أحمد حسني.. "ظل الملك" لإدارة مخابرات الأردن وحماية حدوده مع سوريا" (in Arabic).
  22. 1 2 3 Özsaray, Mustafa (2012). Çerkeslerin İslamlaşması (in Turkish). İz Yayıncılık. ISBN   978-975-355-871-6.
  23. 1 2 3 Б, Ногмов Ш. (2013-03-12). История адыхейского народа (in Russian). ООО ДиректМедиа. ISBN   978-5-4460-0029-6.
  24. 1 2 3 4 Кумахов, Мухадин Абубекирович (2006). Адыгская (черкесская) энциклопедия (in Russian). Фонд Им. Б.Х. Акбашева. ISBN   978-5-9900337-1-9.
  25. Кушева Е.Н. Народы Северного Кавказа и их связи с Россией. Вторая половина XVI – 30-е годы XVII века. М.: Изд-во АН СССР, 1963. Стр 137-138
  26. Хотко, Самир Хамидович (2008). Цивилизация Кабарды (in Russian). Санкт-Петербург: Издательство С.-Петербургского университета. ISBN   978-5-288-04689-6.
  27. Некрасов А.М. Международные отношения и народы Западного Кавказа (последняя четверть XV – первая половина XVI в.). М.: Наука, 1990.
  28. Samir Khotko. "Campaigns of Sahib Gerey I to Circassia in 1539–1551 on information of Remmal Khoja" (PDF). Adyghe Republican Institute of Humanitarian Researches (PDF). Retrieved 2025-04-08.
  29. 1 2 Samir Khotko. "Campaigns of Sahib Gerey I to Circassia in 1539–1551 on information of Remmal Khoja" (PDF). Adyghe Republican Institute of Humanitarian Researches (PDF). Retrieved 2025-04-08.
  30. Samir Khotko. "Campaigns of Sahib Gerey I to Circassia in 1539–1551 on information of Remmal Khoja" (PDF). Adyghe Republican Institute of Humanitarian Researches (PDF). Retrieved 2025-04-08.
  31. Кушева Е.Н. Народы Северного Кавказа и их связи с Россией. Вторая половина XVI – 30-е годы XVII века. М.: Изд-во АН СССР, 1963. Стр 137-138
  32. Хотко, Самир Хамидович (2008). Цивилизация Кабарды (in Russian). Санкт-Петербург: Издательство С.-Петербургского университета. ISBN   978-5-288-04689-6.
  33. Некрасов А.М. Международные отношения и народы Западного Кавказа (последняя четверть XV – первая половина XVI в.). М.: Наука, 1990.
  34. Кумахов, Мухадин Абубекирович (2006). Адыгская (черкесская) энциклопедия (in Russian). Фонд Им. Б.Х. Акбашева. ISBN   978-5-9900337-1-9.
  35. Khoon, Yahya (2010). Muhammad Amin: Imam Shamil’s Naib to the Circassians in the Northwest Caucasus
  36. Yıldız, Hüseyin; Üniversitesi, Ordu. "TAVKUL, Ufuk (2009), Kafkasya'da Kültürel Etkileşim – Sosyo-linguistik Bir Araştırma, Türk Dil Kurumu Yayınları, Ankara, 144 s., ISBN: 978-975-16-2206-8".{{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  37. Çurey, Ali (2012). Hatti-Hititler ve Çerkesler (in Turkish). Chiviyazıları Yayınevi.
  38. Berkok, İsmail (1958). Tarihte Kafkasya (in Turkish). İstanbul Matbaası.
  39. Кумахов, Мухадин Абубекирович (2006). Адыгская (черкесская) энциклопедия (in Russian). Фонд Им. Б.Х. Акбашева. ISBN   978-5-9900337-1-9.
  40. Burney, Charles (2004-04-19). Historical Dictionary of the Hittites. Bloomsbury Publishing PLC. ISBN   978-0-8108-6564-8.
  41. Burney 2004, p. 106-107.
  42. Ivanov, Vyacheslav V. (1985). "On the Relationship of Hattic to the Northwest Caucasian languages," in B.B. Piotrovskij, Vyacheslav V. Ivanov, and Vladislav G. Ardzinba (eds.), Anatoliya – Ancient Anatolia, Moscow: Nauka. pp 26–59 (in Russian)
  43. John Colarusso (1997). Peoples of the Caucasus; in Introduction to the Worldmark Encyclopedia of Cultures and Daily Life; Pepper Pike, Ohio: Eastword Publications
  44. 1 2 Hamed-Trojansky, Vladimir (2018). Imperial Refuge: Resettlement of Muslims from Russia in the Ottoman Empire, 1860-1914 (phd thesis). Stanford, CA, USA: Stanford University.