Hesse configuration

Last updated
Hesse configuration
Hesse configuration.svg
The Hesse configuration, with four of its lines (the four broken diagonals of the 3×3 array of points) drawn as curves
Named after Otto Hesse
Vertices 9
Edges 12
Diameter 1
Automorphisms 416
Notation (94 123)
Table of graphs and parameters

In geometry, the Hesse configuration is a configuration of 9 points and 12 lines with three points per line and four lines through each point. It can be realized in the complex projective plane as the set of inflection points of an elliptic curve, but it has no realization in the Euclidean plane. It was introduced by Colin Maclaurin and studied by Hesse  ( 1844 ), [1] and is also known as Young's geometry, [2] named after the later work of John Wesley Young on finite geometry. [3] [4]

Contents

Description

The Hesse configuration has the same incidence relations as the lines and points of the affine plane over the field of 3 elements. That is, the points of the Hesse configuration may be identified with ordered pairs of numbers modulo 3, and the lines of the configuration may correspondingly be identified with the triples of points (x, y) satisfying a linear equation ax + by = c (mod 3). Alternatively, the points of the configuration may be identified by the squares of a tic-tac-toe board, and the lines may be identified with the lines and broken diagonals of the board.

Each point belongs to four lines: in the tic tac toe interpretation of the configuration, one line is horizontal, one vertical, and two are diagonals or broken diagonals. Each line contains three points. In the language of configurations the Hesse configuration has the notation 94123, meaning that there are 9 points, 4 lines per point, 12 lines, and 3 points per line.

With points indexed 1...9 in a 3x3 grid, can have configuration table:

HorizontalVerticalDiag-1Diag-2
147123123123
258456564645
369789978897

Its dual configuration, (123 94), points indexed 1...12 can have configuration table:

111223344
258575667
36989109810
4710111212111211

The Hesse configuration has 18×4! = 432 automorphisms, doubling the symmetries of the related Hessian group.

Related configurations with automorphisms) Hesse configuration hierarchy chart.svg
Related configurations with automorphisms)

Removing any one point and its four incident lines from the Hesse configuration produces self dual configuration (83), the Möbius–Kantor configuration. [5] [6] [7] It has 48 automorphisms.

In the Hesse configuration, the 12 lines may be grouped into four triples of parallel (non-intersecting) lines, (93 33+33+33+33). This is seen as the horizontal, vertical and 2 sets of diagonal lines.

Removing from the Hesse configuration the three lines belonging to a single triple produces a self dual configuration (93), the Pappus configuration. [6] [7] . The Pappus configuration has 18×3! = 108 automorphisms.

Pappas (93) configuration
HorizontalVerticalDiag-1
147123123
258456564
369789978

Removing half of the triples from the Hess configuration leaves (92 63), which is represented in the regular complex polygon 3{4}2, 9 vertices and 6 3-edges. It is also the dual configuration of complete bipartite graph, K3,3, called the utility graph (or Thomsen graph), (63 92), with 2×(3!)2 = 72 automorphisms.

(92 63) configuration
HorizontalVertical
147123
258456
369789

The Hesse configuration may in turn be augmented by adding four points, one for each triple of non-intersecting lines, and one line containing the four new points, to form self dual configuration (134) the set of points and lines of the projective plane over the three-element field. [8] It has 13×416 = 5616 automorphisms.

(134) configuration
11112223334710
24564564565811
37989878796912
12101311111013131110121213

Every pair of points are connected within one line. If each line triples are reduced to three simple edges, it becomes a complete graph K9, configuration (98 362), 9! = 362880 automorphisms.

Realizability

The Hesse configuration can be realized in the complex projective plane as the 9 inflection points of an elliptic curve and the 12 lines through triples of inflection points. [3] If a given set of nine points in the complex plane is the set of inflections of an elliptic curve C, it is also the set of inflections of every curve in a pencil of curves generated by C and by the Hessian curve of C, the Hesse pencil. [9]

The Hessian polyhedron is a representation of the Hesse configuration in the complex plane.

The Hesse configuration shares with the Möbius–Kantor configuration the property of having a complex realization but not being realizable by points and straight lines in the Euclidean plane. In the Hesse configuration, every two points are connected by a line of the configuration (the defining property of the Sylvester–Gallai configurations) and therefore every line through two of its points contains a third point. But in the Euclidean plane, every finite set of points is either collinear, or includes a pair of points whose line does not contain any other points of the set; this is the Sylvester–Gallai theorem. Because the Hesse configuration disobeys the Sylvester–Gallai theorem, it has no Euclidean realization. This example also shows that the Sylvester–Gallai theorem cannot be generalized to the complex projective plane. However, in complex spaces, the Hesse configuration and all Sylvester–Gallai configurations must lie within a two-dimensional flat subspace. [10]

References

  1. Hesse, O. (1844), "Über die Elimination der Variabeln aus drei algebraischen Gleichungen vom zweiten Grade mit zwei Variabeln" (PDF), Journal für die Reine und Angewandte Mathematik (in German), 28: 68–96, doi:10.1515/crll.1844.28.68, ISSN   0075-4102 .
  2. Wallace, Edward C.; West, Stephen F. (2015), Roads to Geometry (3rd ed.), Waveland Press, pp. 23–24, ISBN   9781478632047
  3. 1 2 MacNeish, H. F. (1942), "Four finite geometries", The American Mathematical Monthly , 49: 15–23, doi:10.2307/2303772, MR   0005625
  4. Veblen, Oswald; Young, John Wesley (1910), Projective Geometry, vol. I, Ginn and Company, p. 249
  5. Dolgachev, Igor V. (2004), "Abstract configurations in algebraic geometry", The Fano Conference, Univ. Torino, Turin, pp. 423–462, arXiv: math.AG/0304258 , MR   2112585 .
  6. 1 2 Coxeter, H. S. M. (1950), "Self-dual configurations and regular graphs", Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society , 56 (5): 413–455, doi: 10.1090/S0002-9904-1950-09407-5 .
  7. 1 2 Cullinane, Steven H. (2011), Configurations and squares .
  8. On the Levi graph of point-line configurations, Jessica Hauschild, Jazmin Ortiz and Oscar Vega (2015)
  9. Artebani, Michela; Dolgachev, Igor (2009), "The Hesse pencil of plane cubic curves", L'Enseignement Mathématique, 2e Série, 55 (3): 235–273, arXiv: math/0611590 , doi:10.4171/lem/55-3-3, MR   2583779 .
  10. Elkies, Noam; Pretorius, Lou M.; Swanepoel, Konrad J. (2006), "Sylvester–Gallai theorems for complex numbers and quaternions", Discrete and Computational Geometry , 35 (3): 361–373, arXiv: math/0403023 , doi:10.1007/s00454-005-1226-7, MR   2202107 .