Jennifer Bates | |
|---|---|
 Jennifer Bates, testifying before Congress in 2021 | |
| Born | 1972or1973(age 51–52) |
| Occupation | Labor organizer |
| Employer | Amazon |
| Known for | Workers' rights activism |
| Notable work | Union organizing at Amazon |
Jennifer Bates (born 1972 or 1973) [1] is an American labor organizer known for her role in leading Amazon worker organization in Bessemer, Alabama.
Bates was heavily involved in ministry and outreach work in her community, and was involved in her church in Marion, Alabama, where she grew up. [1] [2] [3] She started working in an okra field owned by her cousin when she was 13. She says her first "legal job" was working at Hardee's when she was 16. [1] [2] [3]
Her career expanded into foodservice, retail, the automotive industry, emergency dispatch, office work, choir direction, and motivational speaking. [2] [3] [4]
Before returning to Alabama in 2007, Bates married a man in the military and relocated temporarily to South Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. [1]
In 2010, Bates joined a United Steelworkers-backed pipe manufacturing plant and worked there for nearly a decade. [2]
Bates joined Amazon in the fulfillment center (BHM1) in Bessemer, which has a population that is predominantly Black, [2] in May 2020 working in stowing, eventually becoming a learning ambassador. [1] [3] [4] Bates said she believed she was guided to the job at BHM1 for a higher purpose, and that she could not sit back and watch people be mistreated. Her prior experiences told her she knew a union could help the workers. She said, "It's about time somebody really spoke out and said something. Somebody who isn't afraid of the big giant." [2] [5]
A few months into her tenure, Bates and Darryl Richardson, one of her coworkers, contacted Retail, Wholesale and Department Store Union (RWDSU) and in November 2020, announced their intention to unionize the 5,800-employee location. The union drive earned national media attention, and the support of Senators Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren, Representative Stacey Abrams, and President Joe Biden. [1] [3] [6] [7]
Bates criticized Jeff Bezos, saying that he did not care about the employees, and compared the benefits and wages Bezos advertised was akin to giving someone "a wheelbarrow and calling it a car", and workers further criticized Amazon's failure to disclose that similar nearby jobs through union contracts offer much better wages and benefits. [1] [2] Amazon has stated it believes most employees are happy with the working conditions, and that they offer some of the best jobs available in the areas they operate. The workers have stated that it's not just about better compensation, it's about human dignity. [2] [6]
On March 17, 2021, Bates testified before the United States Senate at a "The Income and Wealth Inequality Crisis in America" hearing. [8] [9] Bates testified that she and many of her coworkers were living "paycheck to paycheck", which contrasted the increasing wealth gap amongst the COVID-19 pandemic in the United States. [10] She told congress that within three days of starting her new job she was in physical pain and that her sister, who also worked there, warned it was going to worsen, [1] and compared it to exercising for nine hours a day. [11] [6]
Bates alleges that breaks are irregular, determined by algorithms that monitor the workers by the second, [4] and communicated by a supervisor, and overheard a worker being told by a supervisor, "If you don’t go when I asked you to go, you won’t get a break at all." [1] Bates also alleged that in order to take a break, workers are subjected to a security check that involves some measure of undressing, which Amazon has stated is not company policy. [3] Workers have also referred to BHM1 as a "sweatshop", lodging multiple complaints internally about working conditions. [1] [2] She also said that there were plenty of elevators available, but only one of the many elevators was allowed to be used by the workers in the four-story, 855,000-square-foot facility. [1] [11] [6]
In an interview with Elle, Bates also alleged that people who worked in close contact with coworkers infected with COVID-19 were not alerted about the close contact. [12]
The first election results ended in a decisive vote against unionizing after closing on March 29, 2021. [5] [13] 738 workers voted in support of a union, out of the roughly 2,500 ballots counted, a number staggeringly lower than the petitioned authorization cards reported to be over 3,000. [3] [5] Bates, and others, including legal professionals have accused Amazon of union busting, [1] [3] [14] [7] and RWDSU successfully challenged the results of the vote with the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB), with the agency agreeing that Amazon had illegally interfered with the election. [5] [7]
The company held mandatory "Why You Don’t Need Unions" meetings at BHM1, roundtables featuring anti-union workers, text messaged workers, held unusual one-on-one meetings, posted anti-union signs in the bathrooms, and created a website with the slogan "Do it without dues". [3] [12] [7] Bates alleged that after asking a question about union dues during one of the "anti-union" meetings, she was intimidated by a supervisor. [14] RWSDU argued that the meetings spread misinformation designed to discourage the workers from voting in support of a union, and that the website purposefully misled workers into thinking they would have to pay to join the union. [3] [6] Alabama is a state that prohibits union dues. Bates said that a coworker told her following one of the mandatory sessions, "They said if we could vote the union in, they’re going to shut the plant down." [3] The company has denied all allegations of union busting, but did not appeal the NLRB's decision to allow a re-vote. [3] [5]
Amazon had pushed to have a United States Postal Service mailbox on the premises, which was monitored by the company's security, and covered the box in a tent with the slogan, "Speak for yourself, mail your ballot here," which RWDSU had argued any reasonable worker would be led to believe the election was being monitored or even run by the tech giant, discouraging voting in support of the union. Bates referred to the mailbox as "stark physical memorial of a tainted election," and "an ominous reminder for all of us of Amazon's surveillance capabilities." The workers filed a request to have the mailbox removed in January 2022, ahead of the upcoming 2022 election vote, which will be counted on March 28, 2022. [5] [15]
Critics have argued that without financial consequences, Amazon is unlikely to engage fairly with the second election. Bates feels the power dynamics in labor organizing are biased against workers, telling The Hill, "If the [NLRB] doesn't change the laws and put a harsher punishment on employers or CEOs of these companies, the bricks will always be stacked against us." [5] Bates said that one union win would be a "fire starter" for the labor movement within Amazon. [13]
In an essay for Newsweek , Bates pointed out the vital nature workers like her in BHM1 perform, and argued that shareholders should vote in favor of Oxfam's shareholder resolution to place an hourly warehouse worker on the board of directors. [16] The proposal was rejected. [17]
Bates has three children and seven grandchildren. [1] [2] [3] [18]
| Outcome | Record | Opponent | Vote Count | Date | Facility | Location | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Defeat | 0-1 | Amazon | 738-1,798 [19] | April 9, 2021 | BHM1 | Bessemer, AL | |
| Defeat | 0-2 | Amazon | 875-993 [20] | March 31, 2022 | BHM1 | Bessemer, AL | NLRB ordered this new election after finding Amazon improperly interfered with the 2021 election [21] |
Mercedes-Benz U.S. International (MBUSI) is a Mercedes-Benz automobile manufacturing plant near Vance, Alabama. It is located about 34 miles (55 km) west of Birmingham and about 19 miles (31 km) east of downtown Tuscaloosa. The factory was announced in 1993 and produced its first vehicle, an ML320, in February 1997.
Retail, Wholesale and Department Store Union (RWDSU) is a labor union in the United States and Canada. Founded in 1937, the RWDSU represents about 60,000 workers in a wide range of industries, including but not limited to retail, grocery stores, poultry processing, dairy processing, cereal processing, soda bottlers, bakeries, health care, hotels, manufacturing, public sector workers like crossing guards, sanitation, and highway workers, warehouses, building services, and distribution.
The history of union busting in the United States dates back to the Industrial Revolution in the 19th century. The Industrial Revolution produced a rapid expansion in factories and manufacturing capabilities. As workers moved from farms to factories, mines and other hard labor, they faced harsh working conditions such as long hours, low pay and health risks. Children and women worked in factories and generally received lower pay than men. The government did little to limit these conditions. Labor movements in the industrialized world developed and lobbied for better rights and safer conditions. Shaped by wars, depressions, government policies, judicial rulings, and global competition, the early years of the battleground between unions and management were adversarial and often identified with aggressive hostility. Contemporary opposition to trade unions known as union busting started in the 1940s, and continues to present challenges to the labor movement. Union busting is a term used by labor organizations and trade unions to describe the activities that may be undertaken by employers, their proxies, workers and in certain instances states and governments usually triggered by events such as picketing, card check, worker organizing, and strike actions. Labor legislation has changed the nature of union busting, as well as the organizing tactics that labor organizations commonly use.
Amazon has been criticized on many issues, including anti-competitive business practices, its treatment of workers, offering counterfeit or plagiarized products, objectionable content of its books, tax and subsidy deals with governments.
Colectivo Coffee Roasters is a specialty coffee roaster based in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Until July 2013, the company was known as Alterra Coffee Roasters. Colectivo roasts its coffee and makes all its food products in Milwaukee and is known nationwide as a wholesale coffee supplier.
Tensions between the multinational technology company Google and its workers escalated in 2018 and 2019 as staff protested company decisions on a censored search engine for China, a military drone artificial intelligence, and internal sexual harassment.
Christian Smalls is an American labor organizer known for his role in leading Amazon worker organization in Staten Island, a borough in New York City. He is a co-founder and the former president of the Amazon Labor Union (ALU) (2021-24).
Some warehouse workers of Amazon, the largest American e-commerce retailer with 750,000 employees, have organized for workplace improvements in light of the company's scrutinized labor practices and stance against unions. Worker actions have included work stoppages and have won concessions including increased pay, safety precautions, and time off. There are unionized Amazon workers in both the United States and Europe.
A tech union is a trade union for tech workers typically employed in high tech or information and communications technology sectors. Due to the evolving nature of technology and work, different government agencies have conflicting definitions for who is a tech worker. Most definitions include computer scientists, people working in IT, telecommunications, media and video gaming. Broader definitions include all workers required for a tech company to operate, including on-site service staff, contractors, and platform economy workers.
Alphabet Workers Union (AWU), also informally referred to as the Google Union, is an American trade union of workers employed at Alphabet Inc., Google's parent company, with a membership of over 800, in a company with 130,000 employees, not including temps, contractors, and vendors in the United States. It was announced on January 4, 2021 with an initial membership of over 400, after over a year of secret organizing, and the union includes all types of workers at Alphabet, including full-time, temporary, vendors and contractors of all job types.
Jennifer Ann Abruzzo is an American attorney and government official who serves as General Counsel at the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB). She previously was Special Counsel for Strategic Initiatives for Communications Workers of America (CWA), the largest media and communications union in the United States. She had previously worked for the NLRB for over 20 years in a number of positions, including Deputy General Counsel and Acting General Counsel.
Apple Inc. workers around the globe have been involved in organizing since the 1990s. Apple unions are made up of retail, corporate, and outsourced workers. Apple employees have joined trade unions and or formed works councils in Australia, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, the United Kingdom and the United States.
The Amazon Labor Union (ALU) is a labor union specifically for Amazon workers, created on April 20, 2021. On April 1, 2022, the Amazon workers at a warehouse in Staten Island, JFK8, backed by the ALU became the first unionized Amazon workers recognized by the National Labor Relations Board. In June 2024 the union became affiliated with Teamsters.
As of June 2024, over 10,000 workers at over 400 Starbucks stores in at least 40 states in the United States have voted to unionize, primarily with Workers United. As of March 2023 none have yet enacted a collective bargaining agreement. This unionization effort started at a store in Buffalo, New York. About a third of Starbucks' Chilean workforce is already unionized, as well as 450 workers in New Zealand and eight stores in Canada. The longest Starbucks strike lasted 64 days, took place in Brookline, Massachusetts in September 2022 and resulted in the unionization of the employees at that location.
ABK Workers Alliance is a group of organized workers from video game company Activision Blizzard. Formed in response to a July 2021 state lawsuit against the company for harassment and discriminatory work practices, the worker advocacy group A Better ABK organized walkouts and demonstrations against the company's policy and practices. The quality assurance workers of subsidiary Raven Software went on strike in December after part of the team was fired. The striking workers announced their union as the Game Workers Alliance in late January 2022 and offered to end the strike pending their union's recognition.
Workers at Recreational Equipment, Inc. (REI), an American retail and outdoor recreation services co-op, have one recognized trade union. The company has faced accusations of being anti-union. In 2016, REI workers went public with organization efforts that had been growing over concerns about wages and working conditions in the Pacific Northwest, and the company has since faced increasing public criticism from its employees nationwide over issues including living wages, hourly worker policies, and safety protocols during the COVID-19 pandemic. Workers have organized at least five petitions since 2016. REI has maintained that it is committed to adjusting and improving working conditions for its employees.
Emily Cunningham is an American user experience designer and environmentalist. She is known for co-founding Amazon Employees For Climate Justice and for being illegally terminated by her former employer, Amazon.
Maren Costa is an American user experience designer and environmentalist. She is known for co-founding Amazon Employees For Climate Justice and for being illegally terminated by her former employer, Amazon. She is a principal designer at Microsoft.
Starting in 2022, workers from several Trader Joe's grocery stores have voted on whether to unionize. A store in Hadley, Massachusetts, became the first to unionize and created Trader Joe's United, an independent union unaffiliated with national unions. Stores in Minneapolis, Louisville, and Oakland joined them. Other workers have organized with the United Food and Commercial Workers. Trader Joe's, a chain with over 500 locations and over 50,000 employees, is known for its neighborhood store vibe and over-the-top customer service, which has sometimes clashed with its working conditions. Corporate management has a history of resisting staff unionization efforts. Driven by COVID-19 pandemic working conditions, American service sector organization increased, and Trader Joe's worker concerns over safety, pay, and benefits contributed to their union drive.
The Congress of Essential Workers is an American labour organization co-founded by Chris Smalls in 2020. It has campaigned to raise Amazon's minimum wage.