Kirkuk status referendum

Last updated

The Kirkuk status referendum was the Kirkuk part of a planned plebiscite to decide whether the disputed territories of Northern Iraq should become part of the Kurdistan Region. The referendum was initially planned for 15 November 2007, [1] but was repeatedly delayed [2] [3] and ultimately never took place. [4]

Contents

The referendum was mandated by Article 140 of the Constitution of Iraq. Article 140 required that before the referendum, measures had to be taken to reverse the Arabization policy employed by the Saddam Hussein administration during the Al-Anfal Campaign. Thousands of Kurds returned to Kirkuk following the 2003 U.S. invasion of Iraq. The referendum was to decide whether enough had returned for the area to be considered Kurdish. [5]

Kurdish resentment over the government's failure to implement Article 140 was one of the reasons for the 2017 Kurdistan Region independence referendum, [6] which posed the question, "Do you want the Kurdistan Region and the Kurdistani areas outside the Region to become an independent state?" [7] The referendum led to episodes of Iraqi–Kurdish conflict and the government takeover of Kirkuk.

The Iraqi Constitution

Disputed areas in Iraq according to Article 140:
.mw-parser-output .legend{page-break-inside:avoid;break-inside:avoid-column}.mw-parser-output .legend-color{display:inline-block;min-width:1.25em;height:1.25em;line-height:1.25;margin:1px 0;text-align:center;border:1px solid black;background-color:transparent;color:black}.mw-parser-output .legend-text{}
Disputed and part of the Kurdish Regional Government since 1991.
Disputed and in part under the control of central government, although this area has diminished since the events of 2014. Disputed areas in Iraq.svg
Disputed areas in Iraq according to Article 140:
  Disputed and part of the Kurdish Regional Government since 1991.
  Disputed and in part under the control of central government, although this area has diminished since the events of 2014.

Following the invasion of Iraq in 2003 by the United States, the country was under the direct rule of the United States-appointed Coalition Provisional Authority, with advice from selected Iraqi leaders who sat on the Iraqi Governing Council. The IGC approved an interim constitution, the Law of Administration for the State of Iraq for the Transitional Period (Transitional Administrative Law, TAL), which established the framework for the drafting and approval of a permanent constitution.

The TAL included specific clauses providing for the return of and compensation for forced migrants and for the "resolution of disputed territories including Kirkuk" through arbitration:

  • 1. With regard to residents who were deported, expelled, or who emigrated; it shall, in accordance with the statute of the Iraqi Property Claims Commission and other measures within the law, within a reasonable period of time, restore the residents to their homes and property, or, where this is unfeasible, shall provide just compensation.
  • 2. With regard to the individuals newly introduced to specific regions and territories, it shall act in accordance with Article 10 of the Iraqi Property Claims Commission statute to ensure that such individuals may be resettled, may receive compensation from the state, may receive new land from the state near their residence in the governorate from which they came, or may receive compensation for the cost of moving to such areas.
  • 3. With regard to persons deprived of employment or other means of support in order to force migration out of their regions and territories, it shall promote new employment opportunities in the regions and territories.
  • 4. With regard to nationality correction, it shall repeal all relevant decrees and shall permit affected persons the right to determine their own national identity and ethnic affiliation free from coercion and duress.

In 2005, a permanent Constitution was approved which referred back to the TAL and set a deadline of the end of 2007 for completion:

In late 2007, the U.N. Special Representative for Iraq negotiated an extension of the deadline for six months. However, the federal parliament decided to refer the matter to the Constitutional Court to rule whether the article was now expired or how it should be implemented. [8]

De-Arabization

"We shall accept a solution for Kirkuk worked out by the parties inside the city and oppose any solution imported from outside parties that are enemies to the Kurdish people's experiment."

Najat Hassan Karim, senior Kurdish politician. [9]

The government of Nouri al-Maliki appointed a "Commission on the Normalisation of the Status of Kirkuk" to implement the de-Arabization program. The Justice Minister, Hashim Abderrahman al-Shibli, a secular Sunni Arab from the secular Iraqi National List coalition was appointed the head. A program of normalisation was to be followed by a census by July 2007 and a referendum in November 2007.

In April 2007, Turkish intelligence sources claimed that Kurdistan President Barzani had "offered bribes to various Iraqi officials" involved in the Commission, including $500,000 to al-Shibli. [10] Turkey claimed that Kurdistan was planning to annex Kirkuk illegally, and that the rights of Iraqi Turkmen would be violated if Kirkuk joined Kurdistan Region.

Shibli resigned as head of the Commission in March 2007, citing disagreements with his own coalition on Kirkuk. [11] Raed Fahmy Jahid, another Sunni Arab from the INL was appointed his replacement in August 2007. [12]

In February 2007, the Commission adopted a controversial plan, which gave Sunni Arabs $15,000 to relocate back to their towns of origin, plus a plot of land in their new home. [13]

In September 2007, it was reported that the normalization program had been bogged down in technical difficulties. The Kurdish parties were reported to have agreed a delay to the timetable for the census and referendum. [13]

Position of Iraqi parties

The Sadrist Movement called for the referendum to be postponed in June 2007. [14]
Supreme Islamic Iraqi Council: In July 2007 they were reported to have supported a delay. [15]
Massoud Barzani, Kurdistan Democratic Party head has said that a delay of three to four months would be acceptable. [15] In September 2007, a news agency reported that the Kurdish parties had agreed a postponement to May 2008. However, Barzani said that failure to implement the law would "result in real civil war". [13]
The Iraqi National Dialogue Front called for a delay in June. [14]
The Iraqi Accord Front proposed a delay in June, by way of an amendment to the Constitution of Iraq [15]
Saadeddin Arkej, the leader of the Iraqi Turkmen Front said in June that they aimed to save Kirkuk as the capital of Iraqi Turkmens or at least earn it a special status. [16]

International reactions

Mediation

In June 2008 the UNAMI head, Staffan de Mistura recommended that the Akra District of Ninawa Governorate and the Makhmur District of Kirkuk Governorate be incorporated into Kurdistan but that the al-Hamdaniya area of Ninawa Governorate and the Mandali area of Diyala Governorate be excluded. These recommendations were rejected by the Council of Representatives of Iraq. [18]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kirkuk</span> City in Kirkuk Governorate, Iraq

Kirkuk is a city in Iraq, serving as the capital of the Kirkuk Governorate, located 238 kilometres north of Baghdad. The city is home to a diverse population of Kurds, Turkmens and Arabs. Kirkuk sits on the ruins of the original Kirkuk Citadel which sits near the Khasa River.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kirkuk Governorate</span> Governorate of Iraq

Kirkuk Governorate or Kirkuk Province is a governorate in northern Iraq. The governorate has an area of 9,679 square kilometres (3,737 sq mi). In 2017, the estimated population was 1,259,561 people. The provincial capital is the city of Kirkuk. It is divided into four districts.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Iraqi Kurdistan</span> Kurdish-inhabited region in northern Iraq

Iraqi Kurdistan or Southern Kurdistan refers to the Kurdish-populated part of northern Iraq. It is considered one of the four parts of "Kurdistan" in Western Asia, which also includes parts of southeastern Turkey, northern Syria, and northwestern Iran. Much of the geographical and cultural region of Iraqi Kurdistan is part of the Kurdistan Region (KRI), an autonomous region recognized by the Constitution of Iraq. As with the rest of Kurdistan, and unlike most of the rest of Iraq, the region is inland and mountainous.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kurdistan Region</span> Autonomous entity in the Republic of Iraq

Kurdistan Region is an autonomous administrative entity within the Republic of Iraq. It comprises four Kurdish-majority divisions of Arab-majority Iraq: the Erbil Governorate, the Sulaymaniyah Governorate, the Duhok Governorate, and Halabja Governorate. The KRI is bordered by Iran to the east, by Turkey to the north, and by Syria to the west. It does not govern all of Iraqi Kurdistan, and lays claim to the disputed territories of northern Iraq; these territories have a predominantly non-Arab population and were subject to the Ba'athist Arabization campaigns throughout the late 20th century. Though the KRI's autonomy was realized in 1992, one year after Iraq's defeat in the Gulf War, these northern territories remain contested between the Kurdistan Regional Government and the Government of Iraq to the present day. In light of the dispute, the KRI's constitution declares the city of Kirkuk as the capital of Iraqi Kurdistan. However, the KRI does not control Kirkuk, and the Kurdistan Region Parliament is based in Erbil. In 2014, when the Syria-based Islamic State began their Northern Iraq offensive and invaded the country, the Iraqi Armed Forces retreated from most of the disputed territories. The KRI's Peshmerga then entered and took control of them for the duration of the War in Iraq (2013–2017). In October 2017, following the defeat of the Islamic State, the Iraqi Armed Forces attacked the Peshmerga and reasserted control over the disputed territories.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Iraqi–Kurdish Autonomy Agreement of 1970</span> Peace treaty between Iraq and Iraqi-Kurdish forces

Iraqi–Kurdish Autonomy Agreement of 1970 was an agreement, which the Iraqi government and the leader of the Kurdistan Democratic Party Mustafa Barzani reached on March 11, 1970 in the aftermath of the First Iraqi–Kurdish War. It stipulated the creation of an Autonomous Region, consisting of the three Kurdish governorates and other adjacent districts that have been determined by census to have a Kurdish majority. The plan also gave Kurds representation in government bodies, to be implemented in four years. For its time it was the most serious attempt to resolve the long-running Iraqi–Kurdish conflict.

The first government of Iraq led by Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki took office on May 20, 2006 following approval by the members of the Iraqi National Assembly. This followed the general election in December 2005. The government succeeded the Iraqi Transitional Government which had continued in office in a caretaker capacity until the new government was formed and confirmed.

Minorities in Iraq include various ethnic and religious groups.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kurdification</span> Adoption of Kurdish culture or language

Kurdification is a cultural change in which people, territory, or language become Kurdish. This can happen both naturally or as a deliberate government policy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Iraqi Turkmen</span> Third largest ethnic group in Iraq

The Iraqi Turkmen, also referred to as Iraqi Turks, Turkish-Iraqis, the Turkish minority in Iraq, and the Iraqi-Turkish minority are Iraq's third largest ethnic group. They make up to 13% of the Iraqi population and are native to northern Iraq. Iraqi Turkmen share ties with Turkish people, and do not identify with the Turkmen of Turkmenistan and Central Asia.

The government of Iraq has established a committee to consider a proposed amendment to the Constitution of Iraq.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2010 Iraqi parliamentary election</span>

Parliamentary elections were held in Iraq on 7 March 2010. The elections decided the 325 members of the Council of Representatives who would elect the prime minister and president. The elections resulted in a partial victory for the Iraqi National Movement, led by former Interim Prime Minister Ayad Allawi, which won 91 seats, making it the largest alliance in the Council. The State of Law Coalition, led by incumbent Prime Minister Nouri Al-Maliki, was the second largest grouping with 89 seats.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2009 Kirkuk governorate election</span>

Governorate or provincial elections were held in Kirkuk Governorate in 2009 to replace the governorate council elected in the 2005 Iraqi governorate elections. The remaining governorates outside Iraqi Kurdistan held elections on 31 January 2009.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kurdistan Democratic Party</span> Political party in the Kurdistan Region (founded 1946)

The Kurdistan Democratic Party, usually abbreviated as KDP or PDK, is the largest party in Iraqi Kurdistan and the senior partner in the Kurdistan Regional Government. It was founded in 1946 in Mahabad in Iranian Kurdistan. The party states that it combines "democratic values and social justice to form a system whereby everyone in Kurdistan can live on an equal basis with great emphasis given to rights of individuals and freedom of expression."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Iraqi–Kurdish conflict</span> Series of wars and rebellions by ethnic Kurds against successive Iraqi administrations

The Iraqi–Kurdish conflict consists of a series of wars and rebellions by the Kurds against the central authority of Iraq during the 20th century, which began shortly after the defeat of the Ottoman Empire in World War I and lasting until the U.S. invasion of Iraq in 2003. Some put the marking point of the conflict beginning to the attempt by Mahmud Barzanji to establish an independent Kingdom of Kurdistan, while others relate to the conflict as only the post-1961 insurrection by the Barzanis. The conflict lasted until the U.S. invasion of Iraq in 2003, though tensions between the Kurdish autonomy and the central Iraqi government have continued.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Disputed territories of northern Iraq</span> Geographic territories

The disputed territories of northern Iraq are regions defined by article 140 of the Constitution of Iraq as being Arabised during Baath Party rule in Iraq. Most of these regions are inhabited by non-Arabs, including Kurds, Assyrians, Yazidis, Turkmens/Turkomans, and Shabaks.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kurds in Iraq</span> Ethnic group

The Iraqi Kurds are the second largest ethnic group of Iraq. They traditionally speak Kurdish languages of Sorani, Kurmanji, Feyli and also Gorani.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2017 Kurdistan Region independence referendum</span> Referendum for Kurdish Independence

An independence referendum for the Kurdistan Region of Iraq was held on 25 September 2017, with preliminary results showing approximately 92.73 percent of votes cast in favour of independence. Despite reporting that the independence referendum would be non-binding, the autonomous Kurdistan Regional Government (KRG) characterised it as binding, although they claimed that an affirmative result would trigger the start of state building and negotiations with Iraq rather than an immediate declaration of independence of Kurdistan. The referendum's legality was rejected by the federal government of Iraq.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ba'athist Arabization campaigns in northern Iraq</span> Ethnic cleansing of non-Arabs in Iraq (1968–2003)

Between 1968 and 2003, the ruling Arab Socialist Ba'ath Party of the Iraqi Republic perpetrated multiple campaigns of demographic engineering against the country's non-Arabs. While Arabs constitute the majority of Iraq's population as a whole, they are not the majority in parts of northern Iraq, and a minority in Iraqi Kurdistan. In an attempt to Arabize the north, the Iraqi government pursued a policy of ethnic cleansing and settler colonialism, killing and forcefully displacing a large number of Iraqi minorities—predominantly Kurds, but also Turkmen, Yazidis, Assyrians, Shabaks, Mandaeans, and Armenians, among others—and subsequently allotting the cleared land to Arab settlers. In 1978 and 1979 alone, 600 Kurdish villages were burned down and around 200,000 Kurds were deported to other parts of Iraq.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Kirkuk (2017)</span> Battle between Kurds and government forces in Iraq

The Battle of Kirkuk (2017), part of the 2017 Iraqi–Kurdish conflict, was a military deployment by the Iraqi Security Forces to retake Kirkuk Governorate from the Peshmerga after the latter ignored repeated warnings to withdraw, sparking clashes between the two forces. The advance began on 15 October 2017, with the city of Kirkuk being retaken the following day. Iraqi central government forces continued their advances in subsequent days, routing the Peshmerga forces across vast swathes of territory in northern Iraq.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2017 Iraqi–Kurdish conflict</span> Armed disputes over Kurdish autonomy and sovereignty

The 2017 Iraqi–Kurdish conflict, also known as the Kirkuk crisis, was a conflict in which the Iraqi government retook disputed territories in Iraq which had been held by the Peshmerga since ISIL's Northern Iraq offensive in 2014. The conflict began on 15 October 2017 after tensions arising from the Kurdistan Region independence referendum of 25 September. The tension between the federal Iraqi government and Kurdistan Region escalated into conflict when the Peshmerga ignored repeated warnings to return Kirkuk to Iraqi government forces. Part of the conflict was the Battle of Kirkuk, when Iraqi forces routed Peshmerga forces from the city in a surprise dawn-offensive, marking the beginning of clashes.

References

  1. Iraqi Council of Ministers Presented to the Parliament by Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki Archived 1 October 2013 at the Wayback Machine www.export.gov/Iraq
  2. 1 2 Iran pleases Ankara, irks Kurds with call for Kirkuk poll delay, The New Anatolian , 2007-11-08, accessed on 1 March 2008
  3. "Kirkuk, Other Iraq Issues to Be Delayed". Archived from the original on 16 September 2017. Retrieved 20 December 2007.
  4. Iddon, Paul. "Iraqi Kurdistan in disarray after the loss of Kirkuk". alaraby. Retrieved 31 October 2017.
  5. 1 2 Iraq: Kurds warn against delaying Kirkuk Referendum RadioFreeEurope/RadioLiberty
  6. "President of Iraqi Kurdistan says independence vote is due to failure of unity". The National. Retrieved 31 October 2017.
  7. "Kurdistan referendum commission reveals four-language sample ballot". Rudaw. Retrieved 31 October 2017.
  8. Kirkuk's Article 140: Expired or Not?, Nazar Janabi, Washington Institute for Near East Policy, 31 January 2008
  9. Kurds, Arabs Maneuver Ahead of U.N. Report on N. Iraq Washington Post, April 17, 2009
  10. Turkish special rep. to Iraq brings documents showing "Barzani bribes" to the US, Hurriyet , 2007-04-11, accessed on 14 September 2007
  11. Iraq's justice minister resigns, BBC , 2007-03-31, accessed on 14 September 2007
  12. Profile of New Head of Iraqi Commission on Normalization of Kirkuk Status Archived 6 October 2007 at the Wayback Machine , BBC Monitoring via IndustryWatch, 2 August 2007 accessed on 5 August 2007
  13. 1 2 3 Iraq: Kirkuk Referendum Likely To Be Delayed, Radio Free Europe , 2007-09-13, accessed on 14 September 2007
  14. 1 2 Muqtada: Postpone Kirkuk Referendum, Sawt al-Iraq translated by Informed Comment, 2007-06-10, accessed on 10 June 2007
  15. 1 2 3 Sectarian disputes delay constitution, Gulf News, 2007-07-09, accessed on 9 July 2007
  16. Turkmen Front delegation in New York, wants special status for Kirkuk, The New Anatolian, 2007-06-29, accessed on 17 August 2007
  17. Saudi Arabia offers Kurds 2 billion dollars to give up Kirkuk Archived 20 March 2008 at the Wayback Machine , Middle East Online, 2007-04-03, accessed on 1 March 2008
  18. Iraqi Kurds await U.N. regional recommendations Archived 16 July 2011 at the Wayback Machine , Kurdish Globe, 12 August 2008