Odantapuri

Last updated
Odantapuri
Old ruined gate of the fort, Bihar.jpg
Photograph of the old ruined gate of the fort at Bihar Sharif in Bihar, taken by Joseph David Beglar in the 1870s. The fort is believed to have been part of the Odantapuri university.
India relief location map.jpg
Archaeological site icon (red).svg
Shown within India
Bihar relief map.svg
Archaeological site icon (red).svg
Odantapuri (Bihar)
Location Bihar, India
Coordinates 25°11′49″N85°31′05″E / 25.197°N 85.518°E / 25.197; 85.518
TypeCentre of learning
History
Founded8th–9th century CE
Abandoned13th century CE
EventsDestroyed by Muhammad bin Bakhtiyar Khalji in the late 12th-century

Odantapuri (also called Odantapura or Uddandapura) was a prominent Buddhist Mahavihara in what is now Bihar Sharif in Bihar, India. It is believed to have been established by the Pala ruler Gopala I in the 8th century. It is considered the second oldest of India's Mahaviharas after Nalanda and was situated in Magadha. [1] Inscriptional evidence also indicates that the Mahavihara was supported by local Buddhist kings like the Pithipatis of Bodh Gaya. [2]

Contents

The vihara fell in decline in the 11th century, and may have been looted and destroyed by Muhammad bin Bakhtiyar Khalji, a Turko-Muslim invader in the late 1100s, when he launched multiple raids on Bihar and adjoining territories. [3] [4]

Location

Joseph David Beglar first identified the city of Bihar (Bihar Sharif) with Odantapuri; as the city used to be called Bihar Dandi or Dand Bihar, which is a contraction of Dandpur Bihar (derived from "Dandpura Vihara"). [5]

A small brass image of Buddha's birth mother Mahamaya, bearing a votive inscription on the back that mentioned the name Uddandapura, was also discovered in Bihar Sharif. [6] Based on inscriptions along with local tradition and literary evidence, it is believed that the modern town of Bihar Sharif is built on the ancient site of Odantapuri. [7]

About the location of Odantapuri, S.C.Das depending on the account by Sumpa Khan-po (18th century Tibetan polymath) thought that it was “erected on a hill near the town of modern Behar.” [8] However, dge-’dun-chos-’phel stated: “On the railway line from Patna to Rajgir, there is a station called Bihar-Sharif. If one looks to the west after reaching the station, one will see a low mound." This is said to contain the ruins of Odantapuri Vihara. [9]

This is likely a reference to the locality of Gadh Par [10] in Bihar Sharif which is a huge mound itself. A number of sculptures of the Pala period and some partial brick structures have occasionally been reported from this mound. [1]

The area around Gadh Par (or Garhpar) used to have the remains of an ancient fort [note 1] surrounded by a wide moat, which was visible till the time Buchanan Hamilton visited it in 1812. [11] According to Hamilton, it was built by a Maga Raja (king of Magadha), and was destroyed by Muhammedans in the 12th century. [12] The fort is believed to have been part of the Odantapuri university.

Over the years many civil and municipal buildings like the Civil Court and Nalanda College were built over it. By the 1960s, the ruins of the fort had almost totally disappeared as the area was occupied by a portion of the town itself. [13] [14] The original campus of Sardar Patel Memorial College was also built in that area, and both the college and the neighbourhood are still called 'Udantpuri' after the name of the ancient university.

However, the location of Odantapuri has not yet been conclusively established. [15]

History

Gopala, the founder of the Pala dynasty, who ascended the throne of Bengal in 750 CE, founded the monastic university at Odantapuri. According to Bu-ston, however, the Odantapuri monastery was built by Gopala's son and successor, Dharmapala; while according to Taranatha, it was founded by either Gopala or Devapala. [16]

Odantapuri was part of a network of five Mahaviharas in eastern India. The others were Nalanda, Vikramashila, Somapura, and Jagaddala. During the Pala period, Vikramshila was the leading monastery; and the state funding to Vikramshila and Odantapuri far exceeded what was granted to Nalanda. As a result, while Nalanda was struggling for survival around the 11th century CE, Odantapuri had a rival institution thriving under the royal patronage of Palas. [17]

Taranatha mentions a king called Mahāpāla, who he claims was Mahipala's son, who mainly honoured the Srāvakas of Odantapuri, maintaining five hundred monks and fifty teachers. As an annexe to Odantapuri, he built a vihara called Uruvasa, to provide livelihood and accommodation to five hundred "Srāvaka Sendhapas" (Srāvaka Saindhavas or Singhala Srāvakas, [18] who were Sthaviravadins). [19] While he allowed Vikramashila to retain its position, he made Uruvasa a centre of great veneration. [20] [21]

According to Taranatha, during the reign of Ramapala, along with fifty teachers in Odantapuri "permanently lived a thousand monks belonging to both Hinayana and Mahayana. Occasionally even twelve thousand monks congregated there." [22] [23]

The temple library of the Odantapuri vihara was loftier than those at Vajrasana (Bodh Gaya) and Nalanda and contained a vast collection of Brahmanical and Buddhist works. It was burnt under the orders of one of the generals of Muhammad bin Bakhtiyar Khalji, when Khalji's army sacked the monastery around the end of the 12th century CE. [24] The monks who survived the massacre fled to Nepal and Tibet. [25]

Legends

Various legends are associated with the establishment of Odantapuri: [9]

The tirthika and the corpse

According to Taranatha and Sumpa, Odantapuri was built using the gold that was miraculously obtained in a mystical process.

A tirthika yogi ( tantrika ) called Narada, who had miraculous powers, sought a strong, brave, and truthful companion versed in all crafts and branches of knowledge, to assist him in a ritual with a corpse ( shava sadhana ). He couldn't find anyone who met the criteria except a Buddhist upasaka. The upaska initially refused to be the assistant to a tirthika, but Narada convinced him by promising him wealth which could be used by the upasaka to spread his religion.

They performed the ritual and as it was reaching fulfilment, Narada said that when the corpse sticks its tongue out, the upasaka must catch it. He told him that if he catches it in the first try, he will attain supreme success ( maha-siddhi ), if he does it in the second try, he will gain intermediate success, and if he catches it in the third try, he will get small success. However, if he failed to catch it even after the third time, the vetala (corpse) will devour them both and then empty the whole world. After failing to catch the tongue twice, the upasaka sat with his own mouth near the corpse's, and caught its tongue with his teeth. Then the tongue became a sword, and the corpse turned into gold. When the upasaka held the sword he began to fly in the sky. He flew to the top of Sumeru and circled it along with the four dvipas and their upa-dvipas. When he returned he gave the sword to Narada, who let him have the gold but warned him not to spend it for immoral purposes.

Narada then flew to heaven, and the upasaka who came to be known as Unna Upasaka built the colossal temple of Odantapuri using the gold. The craftsmen and artists who worked on the building were paid with that gold, and it was also used for maintenance of 500 bhikshus and 500 upasakas. The gold couldn't be used by anyone after Unna's death, so before he died he buried it under the earth praying that it might benefit all living beings in future. Then he handed over the Odantapuri vihara to king Devapala.

Sumpa Khan-po mentioned that Otanta in Otantapuri (Odantapuri) meant "soaring on high". [8] This might be derived from the Sanskrit uddayana, uddyanta meaning "going up or flying". [26] According to the legend, the temple was called so because Unna had flown over Sumeru and seen the mountain along with its four dvipas, and hence built Odantapuri in its model.

Dharmapala and the serpent

In History of Buddhism in India and Tibet , Bu-ston recounts the story of Dharmapala's birth and how he built the monastery at Odantapuri.

Gopala's queen Dedda Devi, who was the daughter of a king of the Bhadra dynasty, [27] had no power over Gopala; and hence asked a Brahmin for some magical power so that she could bring him under her influence. The Brahmin brought an enchanted drug from the Himalayas and gave it to the queen's maidservant. While crossing a bridge, the maidservant fell down and the drug was carried away by the stream to the ocean. It was seized and swallowed by the king of the Nagas, who was the sovereign of the ocean. By the power of the drug, he became subjected to power of the queen, and united with her. From their union, a son named Dharmapala was born.

At an auspicious hour when religious ceremonies for the child were being performed, the head of a serpent haughtily rose up, which caused the king to get enraged. He resolved to cut it off, but a ring was shown to him, on which he beheld the characters of the Nagas. He then continued to worship, and devoted himself to the child's education.

When Dharmapala grew up, he was possessed with a desire to build a temple more magnificent than others and enquired soothsayers on this matter. They said that it was necessary to make a wick out of cotton belonging to ascetics and Brahmins, get oil from houses of kings and merchants, obtain an oil-burner from a place of penance, and burn a lamp using those and place it before the tutelary deity. If the king addressed an entreaty, the serpent of Dharmapala would throw the lamp away, and the temple must be built where the lamp falls.

The lamp was lit, but suddenly a raven appeared and threw the lamp into a lake. Dharmapala was distressed, but that night the king of the Nagas came to him and said — "I am thy father, and I will cause this lake to dry up. Thou shalt build thy temple in the place of it. (In order to bring this about) thou must perform sacrifices for seven weeks." This was accordingly done. On the 21st day the lake was dried up, and in its place the temple of Odantapuri was built. [28]

Influences

Tibetan sources indicate that the 8th century Samye monastery, which was the first Buddhist monastery in Tibet, was modelled upon Odantapuri (which in turn was modelled after Sumeru and the four dvipas). [29]

Destruction

The image, in the chapter on India in Hutchison's Story of the Nations edited by James Meston, depicts the Muslim Turkic general Bakhtiyar Khalji's massacre of Buddhist monks in Bihar, India. Khaliji destroyed the Nalanda, Vikramashila, and Odantapuri universities during his raids across North Indian plains, massacring many Buddhist and Brahmin scholars. The end of Buddhist Monks, A.D. 1193.jpg
The image, in the chapter on India in Hutchison's Story of the Nations edited by James Meston, depicts the Muslim Turkic general Bakhtiyar Khalji's massacre of Buddhist monks in Bihar, India. Khaliji destroyed the Nalanda, Vikramashila, and Odantapuri universities during his raids across North Indian plains, massacring many Buddhist and Brahmin scholars.

In around 1193 CE, Muhammad bin Bakhtiyar Khalji, a Turkic chieftain out to make a name for himself, was in the service of a commander in Awadh. The Persian historian, Minhaj-i-Siraj in his Tabaqat-i Nasiri , recorded his deeds a few decades later. Khalji was assigned two villages on the border of Bihar which had become a political no-man's land. Sensing an opportunity, he began a series of plundering raids into Bihar and was recognised and rewarded for his efforts by his superiors. Emboldened, Khalji decided to attack a fort in Bihar and was able to successfully capture it, looting it with a great booty. [31] The fort was destroyed with all of its inhabitants slaughtered and the library burnt. He later came to know that the fort was a vihara. [32]

Minhaj-i-Siraj wrote of this attack: [33]

Muhammad-i-Bakht-yar, by the force of his intrepidity, threw himself into the postern of the gateway of the place, and they captured the fortress and acquired great booty. The greater number of the inhabitants of that place were Brahmans, and the whole of those Brahmans had their heads shaven, and they were all slain. There were a great number of books there; and, when all these books came under the observation of the Musalmans, they summoned a number of Hindus that they might give them information respecting the import of those books; but the whole of the Hindus had been killed. On becoming acquainted [with the contents of those books], it was found that the whole of that fortress and city was a college, and in the Hindui tongue, they call a college [مدرسه] Bihar.

This passage refers to an attack on a Buddhist monastery (the "Bihar" or Vihara) and its monks (the shaved Brahmans). The exact date of this event is not known, with scholarly estimates ranging from 1197 to 1206.

While many historians believe that this monastery which was mistaken for a fort was Odantapura, some are of the opinion that it was Nalanda instead; [31] even though the Tabaqat-i-Nasiri mentions "Adwand Bihar" among the conquests of Khalji, [34] which is obviously a corruption of the name "Uddandapura vihara". [35] [36] However, considering that the two Mahaviharas were only a few kilometres apart, both very likely befell a similar fate. [37]

Taranatha writes that the emperor of Magadha had fortified the monastery and stationed some soldiers with whom the monks joined in repulsing the invaders. He mentions that one of the early raids on Odantapuri was repulsed and the Turushka force of five hundreds was defeated. [3] According to the biography of Dharmasvamin, who journeyed to India between 1234 and 1236, Odantapuri was turned into a military headquarters of the Turkic forces after its destruction. [38]

Notes

  1. gaṛh means 'fort' in Hindi (inherited from Ashokan Prakrit) - Wiktionary, 'गढ़'

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nalanda mahavihara</span> Ancient Buddhist monastery-university in India

Nalanda was a renowned Buddhist mahavihara in ancient and medieval Magadha, eastern India. Widely considered to be among the greatest centres of learning in the ancient world, it was located near the city of Rajagriha, roughly 90 kilometres (56 mi) southeast of Pataliputra. Operating from 427 CE until around 1400 CE, Nalanda played a vital role in promoting the patronage of arts and academics during the 5th and 6th century CE, a period that has since been described as the "Golden Age of India" by scholars.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Vihāra</span> Sanskrit and Pāli term for a residence, monastery usually Buddhist

Vihāra generally refers to a Buddhist temple or Buddhist monastery for Buddhist renunciates, mostly in the Indian subcontinent. The concept is ancient and in early Sanskrit and Pali texts, it meant any arrangement of space or facilities for dwellings. The term evolved into an architectural concept wherein it refers to living quarters for monks with an open shared space or courtyard, particularly in Buddhism. The term is also found in Ajivika, Hindu and Jain monastic literature, usually referring to temporary refuge for wandering monks or nuns during the annual Indian monsoons. In modern Jainism, the monks continue to wander from town to town except during the rainy season (chaturmasya), and the term "vihara" refers to their wanderings.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pala Empire</span> Early medieval empire in the Indian subcontinent

The Pāla Empire was an imperial power during the post-classical period in the Indian subcontinent, which originated in the region of Bengal. It is named after its ruling dynasty, whose rulers bore names ending with the suffix Pāla. The empire was founded with the election of Gopāla as the emperor of Gauda in late eighth century CE. The Pala stronghold was located in Bengal and eastern Bihar, which included the major cities of Gauḍa, Vikramapura, Pāṭaliputra, Monghyr, Somapura, Ramavati (Varendra), Tāmralipta and Jagaddala.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Decline of Buddhism in the Indian subcontinent</span> Gradual process of replacement of Buddhism in India, ended around the 13th or 14th century

Buddhism, which originated in India, gradually dwindled there and was replaced by approximately the 12th century. According to Lars Fogelin, this was "not a singular event, with a singular cause; it was a centuries-long process."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Vikramashila</span> Site of a medieval university in India

Vikramashila was a Buddhist monastery situated in what is now modern-day Bihar in India. It was founded by King Dharmapala between the late eighth and early ninth century.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bihar Sharif</span> Sub-metropolitan city in Bihar, India

Bihar Sharif is the headquarters of Nalanda district and the fifth-largest sub-metropolitan area in the eastern Indian state of Bihar. Its name is a combination of two words: Bihar, derived from vihara, also the name of the state; and Sharif. The city is a hub of education and trade in southern Bihar, and the economy centers around agriculture supplemented by tourism, the education sector and household manufacturing. The ruins of the ancient Nalanda Mahavihara, a UNESCO World Heritage Site, are located near the city.

Devapala was the emperor of the Pala Empire of Bengal. He was the third king in the line, and had succeeded his father Dharamapala. Devapala expanded the frontiers of the empire by conquering the present-day Assam and Orissa. The Pala inscriptions also credit him with several other victories.

Gopala was the founder of the Pala dynasty, which was based in the Bengal region of the Indian subcontinent. The last morpheme of his name Pala means "protector" and was used as an ending for the names of all the Pala monarchs. Pala does not suggest or indicate any ethnic or caste considerations of the Pala dynasty. He came to power in later half of eighth century AD in Gaur/Gaud after being elected by a group of regional chieftains.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dharmapala of Bengal</span> Pala emperor from late 8th century

Dharmapala was the second ruler of the Pala Empire of Bengal region in the Indian subcontinent. He was the son and successor of Gopala, the founder of the Pala Dynasty. Dharmapala was mentioned as the great king of Vangala in the Nesari plates of Rashtrakuta dynasty. He greatly expanded the boundaries of the empire, and made the Palas a dominant power in the northern and eastern India.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Muhammad Bakhtiyar Khalji</span> 13th century Turko-Afghan military general of the Ghurid dynasty

Ikhtiyār al-Dīn Muḥammad Bakhtiyār Khaljī, also known as Bakhtiyar Khalji, was a Turko-Afghan military general of the Ghurid ruler Muhammad of Ghor, who led the Muslim conquests of the eastern Indian regions of Bengal and parts of Bihar and established himself as their ruler. He was the founder of the Khalji dynasty of Bengal, which ruled Bengal for a short period, from 1203 to 1227 CE.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of Buddhism in India</span>

Buddhism is an ancient Indian religion, which arose in and around the ancient Kingdom of Magadha. It is based on the teachings of Gautama Buddha, who lived in the 6th or 5th century BCE and was deemed a "Buddha". However, Buddhist doctrine holds that there were other Buddhas before him. Buddhism spread outside of Magadha starting in the Buddha's lifetime.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Buddhist pilgrimage sites in India</span>

In religion and spirituality, a pilgrimage is a long journey or search of great moral significance. Sometimes, it is a journey to a sacred place or to a shrine of importance to a person's beliefs and faith. Members of every major religion participate in pilgrimages. A person who makes such a journey is called a pilgrim.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Somapura Mahavihara</span> Ancient Buddhist monastery in Bangladesh

Somapura Mahavihara or Paharpur Buddhist Vihara in Paharpur, Badalgachhi, Naogaon, Bangladesh is among the best known Buddhist viharas or monasteries in the Indian Subcontinent and is one of the most important archaeological sites in the country. It was designated as a UNESCO World Heritage Site in 1985. It is one of the most famous examples of architecture in pre-Islamic Bangladesh. It dates from a period to the nearby Halud Vihara and to the Sitakot Vihara in Nawabganj Upazila of Dinajpur District.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Haribhadra (Buddhist philosopher)</span> 8th-century Indian Buddhist philosopher

Haribhadra, also known as Shizi Xian or Sengge Zangpo was an 8th-century CE Buddhist philosopher and commentator. He was one of the founding monks of the Vikramashila monastery in modern-day Bihar, India and he was also the preceptor of the Pala Emperor, Dharmapala.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tourism in Bihar</span>

The state of Bihar in eastern India, is one of the oldest inhabited places in the world with a history going back 3000 years. The rich culture and heritage of Bihar is evident from the innumerable ancient monuments that are dotted all over the state. Bihar is home to many tourist attractions and is visited by large numbers of tourists from all over the world. Around total 6 million tourists visit Bihar every year.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jagaddala Mahavihara</span>

Jagaddala Mahavihara was a Buddhist monastery and seat of learning in Varendra, a geographical unit in present north Bengal in Bangladesh. It was founded by the later kings of the Pāla dynasty, probably Ramapala, most likely at a site near the present village of Jagdal in Dhamoirhat Upazila in the north-west Bangladesh on the border with India, near Paharapur. Some texts also spell the name Jaggadala.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ancient higher-learning institutions</span>

A variety of ancient higher-learning institutions were developed in many cultures to provide institutional frameworks for scholarly activities. These ancient centres were sponsored and overseen by courts; by religious institutions, which sponsored cathedral schools, monastic schools, and madrasas; by scientific institutions, such as museums, hospitals, and observatories; and by respective scholars. They are to be distinguished from the Western-style university, an autonomous organization of scholars that originated in medieval Europe and has been adopted in other regions in modern times.

Mahavihara is the Sanskrit and Pali term for a great vihara and is used to describe a monastic complex of viharas.

The Indian subcontinent has a long history of education and learning from the era of Indus Valley civilization. Important ancient institutions of learning in ancient India are Takshashila, Kashmir Smast, Nalanda, Valabhi University, Sharada Peeth, Pushpagiri Vihara, Odantapuri University, Vikramashila, Somapura Mahavihara, Bikrampur Vihara, Jagaddala Mahavihara.

Buddhajñānapāda was an Indian Buddhist monk and scholar. He is associated with the transmission of the Guhyasamāja Tantra of the Vajrayana school of Buddhism.

References

  1. 1 2 Anupam, Hitendra (2001). "Significance of Tibetan Sources in the Study of Odantapuri and Vikaramsila Mahavihars". Proceedings of the Indian History Congress. 61: 424–428. JSTOR   44148119.
  2. Balogh, Daniel (2021). Pithipati Puzzles: Custodians of the Diamond Throne. British Museum Research Publications. pp. 40–58. ISBN   9780861592289.
  3. 1 2 Singh, Anand (2013). "'Destruction' and 'Decline' of Nālandā Mahāvihāra: Prejudices and Praxis". Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society of Sri Lanka. 58 (1): 23–49. ISSN   1391-720X. JSTOR   43854933.
  4. "Odantapuri". Britannica .
  5. Beglar, J. D. (1878). Report of a Tour Through the Bengal Provinces of Patna, Gaya, Mongir, and Bhagalpur, the Santal Parganas, Manbhum, Singhbhum, & Birbhum, Bankura, Raniganj, Bardwan and Hughli in 1872-73. Office of the Superintendent of Government Printing.
  6. The Indian Antiquary, Vol.47. 1918. pp. 109–110.
  7. Huntington, Susan L. (1984). The "Påala-Sena" Schools of Sculpture. Brill Archive. pp. 116–118. ISBN   978-90-04-06856-8.
  8. 1 2 Sumpa Khan-po Yeçe Pal Jor (1908). Pag Sam Jon Zang. Translated by Das, Sarat Chandra. University of California. Calcutta, Pub. by the Presidency Jail Press. p. 142.
  9. 1 2 Barua, Dipak Kumar (1969). Viharas In Ancient India.
  10. Panth, Rabindra (2001). Nālandā-- Buddhism and the World: Golden Jubilee Volume (in Hindi). Nava Nalanda Mahavihara. p. 304. ISBN   978-81-88242-02-3.
  11. Rajani, M. B. (2020-09-29). Patterns in Past Settlements: Geospatial Analysis of Imprints of Cultural Heritage on Landscapes. Springer Nature. pp. 71–72. ISBN   978-981-15-7466-5.
  12. Jackson, V. H. (1925). Journal of Francis Buchanan (afterwards Hamilton) kept during the survey of the districts of Patna and Gaya in 1811-1812. Superintendent, Govt.Printing, Patna. pp. 89–90.
  13. Patil, D. R. (1963). The Antiquarian Remains in Bihar. Patna: Kashi Prasad Jayaswal Research Institute. pp. 45–46.
  14. Sinha, B. P. (2000). Directory of Bihar Archaeology: Silver Jubilee Year Publication. Patna: Bihar Puravid Parishad. p. 235.
  15. Rajani, M. B.; Kumar, Viraj (2021-09-01). "Where Was Odantapuri Located?". Resonance. 26 (9): 1287–1304. doi:10.1007/s12045-021-1230-0. ISSN   0973-712X. S2CID   240328592.
  16. Majumdar, Ramesh Chandra (1943). The History of Bengal ... University of Dacca.
  17. Patil, D. R. (1963). The Antiquarian Remains in Bihar. p. 326.
  18. Taranatha, Jo Nang (2007-01-01). The Seven Instruction Lineages. Library of Tibetan Works and Archives. ISBN   978-81-86470-65-7.
  19. Bose, Mainak Kumar (1988). Late Classical India. A. Mukherjee & Company.
  20. The History and Culture of the Indian People. Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan. 1964.
  21. Einoo, Shingo. Genesis and Development of Tantra. Рипол Классик. ISBN   978-5-88134-784-0.
  22. Sen, Tansen (2003). Buddhism, Diplomacy, and Trade: The Realignment of Sino-Indian Relations, 600-1400. University of Hawaii Press. ISBN   978-0-8248-2593-5.
  23. Taranatha's History Of Buddhism In India.
  24. Das, Sarat Chandra (1905). Journal of the Buddhist Text & Research Society. Part IV. Vol. VII. Calcutta: The Buddhist Text Society. p. 19.
  25. Scharfe, Hartmut (2002). "From Monasteries to Universities". Handbook of Oriental Studies. BRILL. ISBN   978-90-04-12556-8.
  26. Sastri, Hirananda (1939). "Nalanda and its Epigraphic Material". Memoirs of the Archaeological Survey of India (66).
  27. Sarkar, S. C. (1941). "Notes on a Tibetan account of Bengal". The Journal of the Bihar Research Society. 27: 384.
  28. bu ston rin chen grub. History Of Buddhism In India and Tibet. Translated by Obermiller, Eugene. pp. 156–157.
  29. Powers, John (2007-11-09). Introduction to Tibetan Buddhism. Shambhala Publications. p. 148. ISBN   978-1-55939-282-2.
  30. Sanyal, Sanjeev (15 November 2012). Land of seven rivers: History of India's Geography. Penguin Books Limited. pp. 130–1. ISBN   978-81-8475-671-5.
  31. 1 2 Chandra 2004, p. 41.
  32. Rajani, M. B.; Kumar, Viraj (2021-09-01). "Where Was Odantapuri Located?". Resonance. 26 (9): 1287–1304. doi:10.1007/s12045-021-1230-0. ISSN   0973-712X.
  33. Minhaj-ud-Din 1881, p. 552.
  34. H G Raverty (1873). Tabakat I Nasiri.
  35. Tāranātha (Jo-nang-pa) (1990). Chattopadhyaya, Debiprasad (ed.). Tāranātha's History of Buddhism in India. Translated by Chimpa, Lama; Chattopadhyaya, Alaka. Motilal Banarsidass Publ. p. 442. ISBN   978-81-208-0696-2.
  36. Sarkar, Jadunath (1943). "The Muslim Conquest of Bengal". The History of Bengal. Vol. II. Delhi: B. R. Publishing Corporation. p. 3.
  37. Ghosh 1965, p. 14.
  38. Dutt, Sukumar (1988). Buddhist Monks and Monasteries of India: Their History and Their Contribution to Indian Culture. Motilal Banarsidass Publishers. ISBN   978-81-208-0498-2.

Bibliography