Odious debt

Last updated

In international law, odious debt, also known as illegitimate debt, is a legal theory that says that the national debt incurred by a despotic regime should not be enforceable. Such debts are, thus, considered by this doctrine to be personal debts of the government that incurred them and not debts of the state. In some respects, the concept is analogous to the invalidity of contracts signed under coercion. [1] Whether or not it is possible to discharge debts in this manner is a matter of dispute.

Contents

History

The concept has antecedents dating back to the 1800s and support from diverse fields such as economics, philosophy, political science, history, and law.[ further explanation needed ]

The concept of odious debt was formalized in a 1927 treatise by Alexander Nahum Sack, a Russian émigré legal theorist. It was based on two 19th-century precedents—Mexico's repudiation of debts incurred by Emperor Maximilian, and the denial by the United States of Cuban liability for debts incurred by the Spanish colonial regime. [2] [3] [4]

Sack wrote:

When a despotic regime contracts a debt, not for the needs or in the state's interests, but rather to strengthen itself, to suppress a popular insurrection, etc, this debt is odious for the people of the entire state. This debt does not bind the nation; it is a debt of the regime, a personal debt contracted by the ruler, and consequently, it falls with the regime's demise. The reason why these odious debts cannot attach to the territory of the state is that they do not fulfill one of the conditions determining the lawfulness of State debts, namely that State debts must be incurred, and the proceeds used, for the needs and in the interests of the State. Odious debts, contracted and utilized for purposes which, to the lenders' knowledge, are contrary to the needs and the interests of the nation, are not binding on the nation – when it succeeds in overthrowing the government that contracted them – unless the debt is within the limits of real advantages that these debts might have afforded. The lenders have committed a hostile act against the people, they cannot expect a nation that has freed itself of a despotic regime to assume these odious debts, which are the personal debts of the ruler. [5]

Sack theorized that such debts are not enforceable when (1) the lender should have known that (2) the debt was incurred without the consent and (3) without benefit to the populace. [6] There are many examples of similar debt repudiation. [7]

Chief Justice William Howard Taft, acting as an arbiter, used the doctrine in 1923 to find that Costa Rica did not have to pay the United Kingdom debts incurred by the Federico Tinoco Granados regime. [8]

Despite such rulings, Mitu Gulati argues that odious debt is not part of international law because "[n]o national or international tribunal has ever cited Odious Debt as grounds for invalidating a sovereign obligation." [9]

Reception

Patricia Adams, executive director of Probe International, a Canadian environmental and public policy advocacy organization and author of Odious Debts: Loose Lending, Corruption, and the Third World's Environmental Legacy, stated: "by giving creditors an incentive to lend only for purposes that are transparent and of public benefit, future tyrants will lose their ability to finance their armies, and thus the war on terror and the cause of world peace will be better served." [10] In a Cato Institute policy analysis, Adams suggested that debts incurred by Iraq during Saddam Hussein's reign were odious because the money was spent on weapons, instruments of repression, and palaces. [11]

A 2002 article by economists Seema Jayachandran and Michael Kremer renewed interest in this topic. [12] They propose that the idea can be used to create a new type of economic sanction to block further borrowing by dictators. [13] Jayachandran proposed new recommendations in November 2010 at the 10th anniversary of the Jubilee movement at the Center for Global Development in Washington, D.C. [14] Subsequently, the loan sanctions model has been adopted by the Centre for Global Developments [15] and has been the base for a number of further suggestions. [16] Some think the doctrine could aid international development. [17] Others think that the doctrine should allow even more kinds of debt to be canceled. [18]

Application

After acquiring Puerto Rico through the Spanish–American War, the United States refused to pay the colony's creditors, asserting they held odious debt. [19]

In December 2008, Ecuadorian President Rafael Correa attempted to default on Ecuador's national debt, calling it illegitimate odious debt, because corrupt and despotic prior regimes contracted it. [20] He succeeded in reducing the price of the debt letters before continuing paying the debt. [21]

After the overthrow of Haiti's Jean-Claude Duvalier in 1986, there were calls to cancel Haiti's debt owed to multilateral institutions, calling it unjust odious debt, and Haiti could better use the funds for education, health care, and basic infrastructure. [22] As of February 2008, the Haiti Debt Cancellation Resolution had 66 co-sponsors in the U.S. House of Representatives. [23] Several organizations in the United States issued action alerts around the Haiti Debt Cancellation Resolution, and a Congressional letter to the U.S. Treasury, [24] including Jubilee USA, the Institute for Justice & Democracy in Haiti and Pax Christi USA.

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Economy of Haiti</span>

Haiti is a free market economy with low labor costs. A republic, it was a French colony before gaining independence in an uprising by its enslaved people. It faced embargoes and isolation after its independence as well as political crises punctuated by foreign interventions and devastating natural disasters. Haiti's estimated population in 2018 was 11,439,646. The Economist reported in 2010: "Long known as the poorest country in the Western hemisphere, Haiti has stumbled from one crisis to another since the Duvalier years."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Economy of Iraq</span>

The economy of Iraq is dominated by the oil sector, which has provided about 99.7% of foreign exchange earnings during its modern history. As of 2021, the oil sector provides about 92% of foreign exchange earnings. Iraq's hitherto agrarian economy underwent rapid development following the 14 July Revolution (1958) which overthrew the Hashemite Iraqi monarchy. It had become the third-largest economy in the Middle East by 1980. This occurred in part because of the Iraqi government's successful industrialization and infrastructure development initiatives in the 1970s, which included irrigation projects, railway and highway construction, and rural electrification.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Debt</span> Obligation to pay borrowed money

Debt is an obligation that requires one party, the debtor, to pay money borrowed or otherwise withheld from another party, the creditor. Debt may be owed by sovereign state or country, local government, company, or an individual. Commercial debt is generally subject to contractual terms regarding the amount and timing of repayments of principal and interest. Loans, bonds, notes, and mortgages are all types of debt. In financial accounting, debt is a type of financial transaction, as distinct from equity.

Debt relief or debt cancellation is the partial or total forgiveness of debt, or the slowing or stopping of debt growth, owed by individuals, corporations, or nations.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Holdout problem</span> Economic issue of securities

In finance, a holdout problem occurs when a bond issuer is in default or nears default, and launches an exchange offer in an attempt to restructure debt held by existing bond holders. Such exchange offers typically require the consent of holders of some minimum portion of the total outstanding debt, often in excess of 90%, because, unless the terms of the bond provide otherwise, non-consenting bondholders will retain their legal right to demand repayment of their bonds at par. Bondholders who withhold their consent and retain their right to seek the full repayment of original bonds, may disrupt the restructuring process, creating a situation known as the holdout problem.

The debt of developing countries usually refers to the external debt incurred by governments of developing countries.

Cleary Gottlieb Steen & Hamilton LLP is an American multinational law firm headquartered at One Liberty Plaza in New York City. Known as a white shoe law firm, Cleary employs over 1,200 lawyers worldwide.

Distressed securities are securities over companies or government entities that are experiencing financial or operational distress, default, or are under bankruptcy. As far as debt securities, this is called distressed debt. Purchasing or holding such distressed-debt creates significant risk due to the possibility that bankruptcy may render such securities worthless.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Vulture fund</span> Fund that invests in distressed assets

A vulture fund is a hedge fund, private-equity fund or distressed debt fund, that invests in debt considered to be very weak or in default, known as distressed securities. Investors in the fund profit by buying debt at a discounted price on a secondary market and then using numerous methods to subsequently sell the debt for a larger amount than the purchasing price. Debtors include companies, countries, and individuals.

The United Nations Compensation Commission (UNCC) was created in 1991 as a subsidiary organ of the United Nations Security Council. Its mandate is to process claims and pay compensation for losses and damage suffered as a direct result of Iraq's 1990–1991 invasion and occupation of Kuwait which started the Gulf War. These losses included claims for loss of property, deaths, loss of natural resources, damage to public health and environmental damage.

Debt Justice is a UK-based campaigning organisation that exists to end unjust developing countries' debt and the poverty and inequality it perpetuates. The organisation’s activities include campaigning, advocacy, community organising and activism and aims to build collective power with people most affected by debt to demand a fair economy for all.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">External debt of Haiti</span> Money owed from Haiti to other countries and international institutions to repay loans

The external debt of Haiti is a notable and controversial national debt which mostly stems from an outstanding 1825 compensation to former slavers of the French colonial empire and later 20th century's corruptions.

Tai-Heng Cheng is a Singaporean legal scholar, lawyer, and international arbitrator. He currently resides in United States of America as a permanent resident.

A sovereign default is the failure or refusal of the government of a sovereign state to pay back its debt in full when due. Cessation of due payments may either be accompanied by that government's formal declaration that it will not pay its debts (repudiation), or it may be unannounced. A credit rating agency will take into account in its gradings capital, interest, extraneous and procedural defaults, and failures to abide by the terms of bonds or other debt instruments.

Economic reform in Iraq describes decisions by the Coalition Provisional Authority to dramatically change the economy of Iraq in the aftermath of the 2003 U.S.-led invasion.

Alexander Nahum Sack or Aleksandr Naumovich Zak was a jurisprudence expert and professor of Russian law, specialized in international financial legislation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jubilee USA Network</span>

Jubilee USA Network is a nonprofit financial reform organization based in Washington D.C. Jubilee USA's work began in conjunction with the global Jubilee 2000 movement, founded in the late 1990s to advocate for debt relief for developing countries. It is "an alliance of more than 75 U.S. organizations, 650 faith communities and 50 Jubilee global partners."

Seema Jayachandran is an economist who currently works as Professor of Economics at Princeton University. Her research interests include development economics, health economics, and labor economics.

Anna Gelpern is a legal scholar and expert on sovereign debt and financial regulation. She is Professor of Law and the Agnes N. Williams Research Professor at the Georgetown University Law Center, and a nonresident senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics.

References

  1. ↑ Robert Howse (July 2007). The Concept of Odious Debt in Public International Law (PDF). Geneva: UNCTAD.
  2. ↑ Graeme Smith (20 November 2011), "A new euro crisis strategy: Deny the debt", The Globe and Mail
  3. ↑ Sarah Ludington et al., Applied Legal History: Demystifying the Doctrine of Odious Debts, 11 THEORETICAL INQUIRIES L. 247, 253 (2010).
  4. ↑ Developments in the Law — The International Place of Puerto Rico, 130 HARV. L. REV. 1656 (2017).
  5. ↑ "Jubilee Iraq - Odious Debt". Archived from the original on 2011-03-06.
  6. ↑ Patrick Bolton & David Skeel, Odious Debts or Odious Regimes?, 70 LAW & CONTEMP. PROBS. 83 (2007).
  7. ↑ Mitu Gulati; Sarah Ludington; Alfred L. Brophy (January 2010). "Applied Legal History: Demystifying the Doctrine of Odious Debts". Theoretical Inquiries in Law . Walter de Gruyter GmbH. 11 (1): 247–281. doi:10.2202/1565-3404.1242. ISSN   1565-3404. S2CID   201055836.
  8. ↑ Odette Lienau, Who Is the “Sovereign” in Sovereign Debt?: Reinterpreting a Rule-of-Law Framework from the Early Twentieth Century, 33 Yale J. Int'l L. 63 (2008).
  9. ↑ Mitu Gulati, Duke University School of Law; Ugo Panizza, The Graduate Institute Geneva and CEPR. The Hausmann-Gorky Effect. Working Paper No. HEIDWP02-2018. Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies, International Economics Department.
  10. ↑ Patricia Adams (1991). Odious Debts: Loose Lending, Corruption, and the Third World's Environmental Legacy. Earthscan Publications. ISBN   978-1853831225.
  11. ↑ Patricia Adams, "Iraq's Odious Debt" Archived 2006-01-03 at the Wayback Machine , Cato Institute
  12. ↑ Michael Kremer; Seema Jayachandran (Spring 2003). "Odious Debt: When Dictators Borrow, Who Repays the Loan?". Brookings Institution.
  13. ↑ Michael Kremer; Seema Jayachandran (June 2002). "Odious Debt". Finance & Development . IMF. 39 (2).
  14. ↑ "What Ever Happened to the Jubilee? A 10th Anniversary Assessment of the Debt Relief Movement". Center For Global Development. Retrieved 12 January 2020.
  15. ↑ "Prevention of Odious Debt Working Group (June 2009 – November 2010)". Center For Global Development. Retrieved 12 January 2020.
  16. ↑ Schneider, Friedrich Benjamin (2015). "The International Convention on the Prevention of Odious Agreements: A Human Rights-Based Mechanism to Avoid Odious Debts" (PDF). Leiden Journal of International Law. Cambridge University Press. 28 (3): 557–578. doi:10.1017/S0922156515000291. S2CID   151618161.
  17. ↑ Tom Ginsburg & Thomas S. Ulen, Odious Debt, Odious Credit, Economic Development, and Democratization, 70 Law & Contemp. Probs. 115 (2007).
  18. ↑ Christiana Ochoa, From Odious Debt to Odious Finance: Avoiding the Externalities of a Functional Odious Debt Doctrine, 49 HARV. INT’L L.J. 109 (2008).
  19. ↑ "Developments in the Law — Ch. II: The International Place of Puerto Rico" (PDF). Harvard Law Review . 130: 1656. 2017. Retrieved May 5, 2017.
  20. ↑ "Ecuador defaults on foreign debt". BBC News. 13 December 2008.
  21. ↑ "'Avenger against oligarchy' wins in Ecuador", The Real News , 27 April 2009.
  22. ↑ "Jubilee USA Network | take_action | haiti06.html". February 8, 2007. Archived from the original on 2007-02-08.
  23. ↑ "Congresswoman Maxine Waters Introduces Legislation to Cancel Haiti's Debt". Archived from the original on 2012-09-16. Retrieved 2012-05-25.
  24. ↑ "Institute for Justice & Democracy in Haiti". Ijdh.org. 2008-02-12. Retrieved 2012-10-23.[ failed verification ]
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.