Past and Present (book)

Last updated
Past and Present
Title page of Past and Present.jpg
Title page of the first English edition
Author Thomas Carlyle
Country England
LanguageEnglish
Subjects
Genre Non-fiction
PublishedApril 1843
Publisher Chapman and Hall

Past and Present is a book by the Scottish essayist, historian and philosopher Thomas Carlyle. [1] It was published in April 1843 in England and the following month in the United States. It combines medieval history with criticism of 19th-century British society. Carlyle wrote it in seven weeks as a respite from the harassing labor of writing Oliver Cromwell's Letters and Speeches . He was inspired by the recently published Chronicles of the Abbey of Saint Edmund's Bury, which had been written by Jocelin of Brakelond at the close of the 12th century. This account of a medieval monastery had taken Carlyle's fancy, and he drew upon it in order to contrast the monks' reverence for work and heroism with the sham leadership of his own day.

Contents

Composition

Carlyle wrote on 27 October 1841 that he had thought of editing a journal, asking James Garth Marshall,

Is it not now that we are to sing and act the great new Epic, not "Arms and the Man," but "Tools and the Man";—to preach and prophesy in all ways that Labor is honorable, that Labor alone is honorable; that Idleness shall and must move out of its way, or be frightfully thrown into the howling dog-kennel? [2]

Having borrowed and read George Calvert Holland's The Millocrat and Marshall's address to the Leeds Parliamentary Reform Association denigrating the "corn-law of aristocracy" while praising industry and industrialists, Carlyle became convinced that "we must have industrial barons, of a quite new suitable sort; workers loyally related to their taskmasters,—related in God (as we may well say); not related in Mammon alone! This will be the real aristocracy, in place of the sham one". [3] The idea of a journal was soon discarded as he turned to writing Oliver Cromwell's Letters and Speeches . Carlyle grew increasingly concerned with the state of England, as he observed widespread hunger and riots in the spring and summer of 1842. In August he wrote to Ralph Waldo Emerson expressing how it distracted him from the writing of Cromwell:

One of my grand difficulties I suspect to be that I cannot write two Books at once; cannot be in the seventeenth century and in the nineteenth at one and the same moment . . . For my heart is sick and sore in behalf of my own poor generation; nay, I feel withal as if the one hope of help for it consisted in the possibility of new Cromwells, and new Puritans: thus do the two centuries stand related to me, the seventeenth worthless except precisely in so far as it can be made the nineteenth; and yet let anybody try that enterprise! Heaven help me. [4]

In the first week of September, Carlyle made a trip to East Anglia for research on Cromwell, in which he observed both the workhouse of St Ives, about which there was "something that reminded me of Dante's Hell", and the ruins of Bury St. Edmunds Abbey, "the Heaven's- Watchtower of our Fathers, the fallen God's-Houses, the Golgotha of true Souls departed". [5] [6] In mid-October 1842 while writing Cromwell, Carlyle read J. G. Rokewood's edition of the Chronica Jocelini de Brakelonda de Rebus Gestis Samsonis Abbatis Monasterii Sancti Edmundi published by the Camden Society in 1840. Carlyle was much taken with Abbot Samson's strong leadership of the Monastery of Bury St. Edmunds Abbey and he planned to contrast it with modern England. During the final two months of 1842, he wrote quickly, and the first portion of the manuscript was sent to the printers in February 1843, completing the book on 9 March. [7] The first autograph of Past and Present is in the British Library while the printer's copy is in the Yale University Library. [8]

Summary

Book 1: Proem

Carlyle expresses his ideas about the Condition of England question in an elevated rhetorical style invoking classical allusions (such as Midas and the Sphinx) and fictional caricatures (such as Bobus and Sir Jabesh Windbag). Carlyle complains that despite England's abundant resources, the poor are starving and unable to find meaningful work, as evinced by the Manchester Insurrection. Carlyle argues that the ruling class needs to guide the nation, and supports an "Aristocracy of Talent". But in line with his concept of "hero-worship", Carlyle argues that first the English must themselves become heroic in order to esteem true heroes rather than quacks.

Book 2: The Ancient Monk

Seal of Abbot Samson Seal of Abbot Samson.jpg
Seal of Abbot Samson

Carlyle presents the history of Samson of Tottington, a 12th-century monk who became Abbot of Bury St. Edmunds, as chronicled by Jocelin of Brakelond. Carlyle describes Samson as a lowly monk with no formal training or leadership experience who, on his election to the abbacy, worked earnestly and diligently to overcome the economic and spiritual maladies that had befallen the abbey under the rule of Hugo, the former abbot. Carlyle concludes from this history that despite the monks' primitive knowledge and superstitions (he refers to them repeatedly as "blockheads"), they were able to recognize and promote genuine leadership, in contrast to contemporary Englishmen:

Here he is discovered with a maximum of two shillings in his pocket, and a leather scrip round his neck; trudging along the highway, his frock-skirts looped over his arm. They think this is he nevertheless, the true Governor; and he proves to be so. Brethren, have we no need of discovering true Governors, but will sham ones forever do for us? (II.ix)

Carlyle presents his history as the narrative of the lives of men and their deeds, rather than as a dry chronicle of external details. To this end, he repeatedly contrasts his history with the style of the fictional historian Dryasdust.

Book 3: The Modern Worker

Carlyle transitions from discussing a medieval society, imbued with meaning, to the plight of the modern worker who lacks absolute meaning in his own existence. He directs his vitriol across multiple fronts, from the injustices of the Corn Laws to the utilitarian reductionism of laissez-faire thinkers. The British aristocracy is attacked for not performing their traditional obligations in guiding society, and the bourgeois elements of society are attacked for reducing life to a money-driven farce of empty talk. He in fact attacks industrial society more generally, which he sees exuding 'Midas-eared Mammonism'.

Book 4: Horoscope

Carlyle ends the book in proposing what must be done to remedy the faults he sees in society, which he boils down to the problem of governing men and relates closely to the matter of organizing labour. He notes that some combination of aristocracy and priesthood must be restored in society to give it guidance, with the force of a radical rejuvenation of spirit to elevate the working man from his wretched existence and away from the 'anarchy of supply and demand'. This new society would see wise leaders elevate the mob into a firm regimented mass.

Reception and influence

Sculpture of Thomas Carlyle with a quotation from book III of Past and Present by the Industrial Art League, 1902 Sculpture of Thomas Carlyle by the Industrial Art League.jpg
Sculpture of Thomas Carlyle with a quotation from book III of Past and Present by the Industrial Art League, 1902

Lord Acton called it "the most remarkable piece of historical thinking in the language." [9] G. K. Chesterton considered it along with Chartism (1839) to be "the work [Carlyle] was chosen by gods and men to achieve". [10]

Past and Present contributed to several social developments in the 19th and early-20th centuries, including the decline of laissez-faire, the crafting and passage of the Factory Acts, the emigration of labourers from England to the United States during the Great Rapprochement, the rise of practices such as business ethics, profit sharing, and the redistribution of income and wealth, the establishment of state education, and even playgrounds. [11]

Carlyle's influence on modern socialism can be seen most acutely in the response to Past and Present. New Moral World , the official newspaper of the Owenite movement, published a six-part review by then-editor George Fleming between August and November 1843, further issuing an additional excerpt two months afterwards. Fleming expressed "gratification in finding . . . the true philosophy of Socialism . . . arrayed in the gorgeous and striking drapery of Carlyleism." Fleming believed that a "new, unexpected, and powerful ally to our cause has come into the field", finding in the work "identical principles with those of [ Robert Owen]", portraying Carlyle as a covert socialist that has infiltrated the "charmed circle" of high society. [12] In January 1844, Friedrich Engels published an extensive, laudatory review in the Deutsch–Französische Jahrbücher . [13] He wrote that Carlyle's acute analysis of the social question in England made it the only book by a contemporary educated Englishman worth reading. Engels praised Carlyle's humanitarian point of view yet considered it only a nonscientific preliminary to socialism. He characterized Carlyle as a German pantheist and a romantic Tory, a follower of Schelling rather than of Hegel, too hung up on religion and the myth of aristocratic leadership to accept freedom and self-determination as the ultimate aim of history, while expressing hope that Carlyle would overcome these limitations.

The book greatly influenced the development of medievalism and the Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood. John William Mackail wrote that during William Morris and Edward Burne-Jones' days at Oxford, "Carlyle's Past and Present stood alongside of Modern Painters as inspired and absolute truth." [14] John Ruskin gifted his personal, extensively annotated copy to a friend in 1887, along with a letter in which he called it "a book which I read no more because it has become a part of myself, and my old marks in it are now useless, because in my heart I mark it all." [15] Fors Clavigera has been called "in effect the resumption of the concerns of Carlyle's Past and Present in another form." [16]

Related Research Articles

<i>The Communist Manifesto</i> 1848 political publication by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels

The Communist Manifesto, originally the Manifesto of the Communist Party, is a political pamphlet written by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, commissioned by the Communist League and originally published in London in 1848. The text is the first and most systematic attempt by Marx and Engels to codify for widespread consumption the core historical materialist idea that, as stated in the text's opening words, "the history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles", in which social classes are defined by the relationship of people to the means of production. Published against the backdrop of the Revolutions of 1848 and their subsequent repression across Europe, the Manifesto remains one of the world's most influential political documents.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Ruskin</span> English writer and art critic (1819–1900)

John Ruskin was an English writer, philosopher, art critic and polymath of the Victorian era. He wrote on subjects as varied as geology, architecture, myth, ornithology, literature, education, botany and political economy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thomas Carlyle</span> Scottish essayist, historian and philosopher (1795–1881)

Thomas Carlyle was a British essayist, historian, and philosopher from the Scottish Lowlands. A leading writer of the Victorian era, he exerted a profound influence on 19th-century art, literature, and philosophy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Charles Eliot Norton</span> American art historian

Charles Eliot Norton was an American author, social critic, and Harvard professor of art based in New England. He was a progressive social reformer and a liberal activist whom many of his contemporaries considered the most cultivated man in the United States. He was from the same notable Eliot family as the 20th-century poet T. S. Eliot, who made his career in the United Kingdom.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Captain of industry</span>

In the 19th century, a captain of industry was a business leader whose means of amassing a personal fortune contributed positively to the country in some way. This may have been through increased productivity, expansion of markets, providing more jobs, or acts of philanthropy. This characterization contrasts with that of the robber baron, a business leader using political means to achieve personal ends.

<i>Latter-Day Pamphlets</i>

Latter-Day Pamphlets was a series of "pamphlets" published by Scottish essayist, historian and philosopher Thomas Carlyle in 1850, in vehement denunciation of what he believed to be the political, social, and religious imbecilities and injustices of the period.

<i>Fors Clavigera</i> Pamphlet by John Ruskin

Fors Clavigera: Letters to the Workmen and Labourers of Great Britain was the name given by John Ruskin to a series of letters addressed to British workmen during the 1870s. They were published in the form of pamphlets. The letters formed part of Ruskin's interest in moral intervention in the social issues of the day on the model of his mentor Thomas Carlyle.

Jocelyn de Brakelond or Jocelin de Brakelonde was an English monk and the author of a chronicle narrating the fortunes of the monastery of Bury St. Edmunds Abbey between 1173 and 1202. He is only known through his own work.

<i>The French Revolution: A History</i> Book by Thomas Carlyle

The French Revolution: A History was written by the Scottish essayist, historian and philosopher Thomas Carlyle. The three-volume work, first published in 1837, charts the course of the French Revolution from 1789 to the height of the Reign of Terror (1793–94) and culminates in 1795. A massive undertaking which draws together a wide variety of sources, Carlyle's history—despite the unusual style in which it is written—is considered to be an authoritative account of the early course of the Revolution.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Condition-of-England question</span> Phrase coined by Thomas Carlyle describing an 1839 English political debate

The Condition-of-England question was a debate in the Victorian era over the issue of the English working-class during the Industrial Revolution. It was first proposed by Thomas Carlyle in his essay Chartism (1839). After assessing Chartism as "the bitter discontent grown fierce and mad, the wrong condition therefore or the wrong disposition, of the Working Classes of England", Carlyle proceeds to ask:

What means this bitter discontent of the Working Classes? Whence comes it, whither goes it? Above all, at what price, on what terms, will it probably consent to depart from us and die into rest? These are questions.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jane Welsh Carlyle</span> Scottish writer

Jane Baillie Carlyle was a Scottish writer and the wife of Thomas Carlyle.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thomas Carlyle and His Works</span> 1847 essay by Henry David Thoreau

"Thomas Carlyle and His Works" is an essay written by Henry David Thoreau that praises the writings of Thomas Carlyle.

<i>History of Friedrich II. of Prussia, Called Frederick the Great</i>

History of Friedrich II. of Prussia, Called Frederick the Great is a biography of Friedrich II of Prussia by Scottish essayist, historian and philosopher Thomas Carlyle. It was first published in six volumes from 1858 to 1865.

<i>On Heroes, Hero-Worship, & the Heroic in History</i> 1841 book by Thomas Carlyle

On Heroes, Hero-Worship, & the Heroic in History is a book by the Scottish essayist, historian and philosopher Thomas Carlyle, published by James Fraser, London, in 1841. It is a collection of six lectures given in May 1840 about prominent historical figures. It lays out Carlyle's belief in the importance of heroic leadership.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Utopian socialism</span> Political theory concerned with imagined socialist societies

Utopian socialism is the term often used to describe the first current of modern socialism and socialist thought as exemplified by the work of Henri de Saint-Simon, Charles Fourier, Étienne Cabet, and Robert Owen. Utopian socialism is often described as the presentation of visions and outlines for imaginary or futuristic ideal societies, with positive ideals being the main reason for moving society in such a direction. Later socialists and critics of utopian socialism viewed utopian socialism as not being grounded in actual material conditions of existing society. These visions of ideal societies competed with revolutionary and social democratic movements.

<i>Oliver Cromwells Letters and Speeches</i> Book by the Scottish essayist, historian and philosopher Thomas Carlyle

Oliver Cromwell's Letters and Speeches: with Elucidations is a book by the Scottish essayist, historian and philosopher Thomas Carlyle. It "remains one of the most important works of British history published in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thomas Carlyle's house, Comely Bank</span> Historic site in Edinburgh, Scotland

Thomas Carlyle's house, Comely Bank is a Category B listed building in Edinburgh, Scotland. It was once the home of Scottish essayist, historian and philosopher Thomas Carlyle. He lived there with his wife Jane Carlyle from October 1826, the time of their marriage, to May 1828, when they moved to Craigenputtock.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Scotsbrig</span> Historic site

Scotsbrig is a farm near Ecclefechan, Dumfries and Galloway, Scotland, and a Category B listed building. Thomas Carlyle lived there with his family in the summer of 1826 before moving to 21 Comely Bank, Edinburgh. Scotsbrig remained a residence of the Carlyle family for decades. The farmhouse underwent numerous additions and renovations in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Philosophy of Thomas Carlyle</span>

Thomas Carlyle's religious, historical and political thought has long been the subject of debate. In the 19th century, he was "an enigma" according to Ian Campbell in the Dictionary of Literary Biography, being "variously regarded as sage and impious, a moral leader, a moral desperado, a radical, a conservative, a Christian." Carlyle continues to perplex scholars in the 21st century, as Kenneth J. Fielding quipped in 2005: "A problem in writing about Carlyle and his beliefs is that people think that they know what they are."

Thomas Carlyle published numerous works, and many more have been written about him by other authors.

References

  1. "Past and Present"  . Encyclopedia Americana . 1920.
  2. Carlyle, T. (1987-01-01). "TC TO JAMES GARTH MARSHALL". The Carlyle Letters Online. 13 (1): 288–290. doi:10.1215/lt-18411027-TC-JGM-01. ISSN   1532-0928.
  3. Carlyle, T. (1987-01-01). "TC TO JAMES GARTH MARSHALL". The Carlyle Letters Online. 13 (1): 316–317. doi:10.1215/lt-18411207-TC-JGM-01. ISSN   1532-0928.
  4. Carlyle, T. (1987-01-01). "TC TO RALPH WALDO EMERSON". The Carlyle Letters Online. 15 (1): 56–59. doi:10.1215/lt-18420829-TC-RWE-01. ISSN   1532-0928.
  5. Ulrich, John M. (1995). ""A Labor of Death and A Labor Against Death": Translating the Corpse of History in Carlyle's "Past and Present"". Carlyle Studies Annual (15): 33–47. ISSN   1074-2670. JSTOR   44946087.
  6. "The Project Gutenberg eBook of Collected Works, Volume XIII. Past and Present, by Thomas Carlyle". www.gutenberg.org. Retrieved 2023-04-08.
  7. Ryals, Clyde de L. (2004). "Past and Present: Composition and Publication". In Cumming, Mark (ed.). The Carlyle Encyclopedia. Madison and Teaneck, NJ: Fairleigh Dickinson University Press. pp. 370–371. ISBN   978-1-61147-172-4.
  8. British Library
  9. Edwards, Owen Dudley (2007). "Carlyle and Catholicism, Part I: Hilaire Belloc and The French Revolution". Carlyle Studies Annual (23): 87. ISSN   1074-2670. JSTOR   26592985.
  10. "The Project Gutenberg eBook of The Victorian Age in Literature, by G. K. Chesterton". www.gutenberg.org. Retrieved 2022-06-30.
  11. Eakins, Mary Eleanor (1914). The medievalism of Carlyle (Master of Arts thesis). University of Iowa. doi:10.17077/etd.594u8rfr.
  12. Allison, Mark (2018). "The Mustard Seed of British Socialism: Carlyle, Robert Own, and "Infallible Influence"". In Kerry, Paul E.; Pionke, Albert D.; Dent, Megan (eds.). Thomas Carlyle and the Idea of Influence . Madison, NJ: Fairleigh Dickinson University Press. pp. 282–283. ISBN   9781683930662.
  13. Marx, Karl, and Friedrich Engels. Collected Works. New York: International Publishers, 1975–2004. 3:444–68.
  14. Mackail, J. W. (2011). The Life of William Morris. New York: Dover Publications. p. 38. ISBN   978-0-486-28793-5.
  15. Ruskin, John (1907). Cook, E. T.; Wedderburn, Alexander (eds.). Fors Clavigera: Letters to the Workmen and Labourers of Great Britain, Volume I (PDF). Vol. XXVII. London: George Allen. p. 179n1.
  16. Mallett, Phillip (2004). "Ruskin, John". In Cumming, Mark (ed.). The Carlyle Encyclopedia. Madison and Teaneck, NJ: Fairleigh Dickinson University Press. p. 404. ISBN   978-1-61147-172-4.