Philosophical Explanations

Last updated
Philosophical Explanations
Philosophical Explanations (first edition).jpg
Cover of the first edition
Author Robert Nozick
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish
Subjects Epistemology
Metaphysics
Publisher Harvard University Press
Publication date
1981
Media typePrint (Hardcover and Paperback)
Pages764
ISBN 0-674-66479-5

Philosophical Explanations is a 1981 metaphysical, epistemological, and ethical treatise by the philosopher Robert Nozick.

Contents

The book received positive reviews. Commentators have compared Philosophical Explanations to the philosopher Richard Rorty's Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature (1979) and praised it for Nozick's discussions of the fundamental questions of philosophy and of topics such as epistemology and ethics, and welcomed it as a convincing response to charges that American academic philosophy is overly concerned with technical issues. Nozick's discussions of knowledge and skepticism have received much critical attention.

Summary

Nozick discuses branches of philosophy such as metaphysics, [1] epistemology, [2] and ethics, [3] specific philosophical problems concerning issues such as free will, [4] skepticism, [5] the mind–body problem and the problem of other minds, [6] the nature of personal identity, [7] and the meaning of life, [8] and the work of individual philosophers, such as Immanuel Kant. He discusses Kant's Critique of Pure Reason (1781). [9]

Observing that philosophers often seek to deduce their total view from a few basic principles, showing how everything follows from their intuitively based axioms, Nozick compares such an approach to building a tower by piling one brick on top of another: if the brick at the bottom crumbles or is removed, everything collapses, and even the insights that were independent of the starting point are lost. He suggests instead that the Parthenon should be the model for philosophy, and advocates an explanatory model of philosophical activity rather than an argumentative or coercive one. In the Parthenon model, separate philosophical insights are placed one after another, like columns, and only afterwards are they united under a roof consisting of general principles or themes. That way, when the philosophical ground crumbles, something Nozick regards as likely, something of interest and beauty remains standing. [10]

Publication history

Philosophical Explanations was first published in 1981 by Harvard University Press. By 1994, it was in its eleventh printing. [11]

Reception

Reviews

Philosophical Explanations received positive reviews from the philosopher Alasdair MacIntyre in The New York Times Book Review , [12] the philosopher Ian Hacking in The New Republic , [13] the philosopher David Gordon in Library Journal , [14] the political scientist Mark Lilla in The American Scholar , [15] and the philosopher Stephen F. Barker in Harvard Educational Review . [16] The book was also reviewed by the philosopher Robert Cummings Neville in Modern Age , [17] the philosopher Robert Fogelin in The Journal of Philosophy , [18] Russell Hardin in Ethics , [19] Leslie Stevenson in the British Journal for the Philosophy of Science , [20] George Weckman in the Journal of the American Academy of Religion , [21] Anthony Ellis in Mind , [22] Jeffrey Stout in The Journal of Religion , [23] and by The Economist . [24]

MacIntyre considered the book an important, well-written, and rewarding discussion of the central problems of philosophy, writing that it "communicates its author's own excitement about both the problems and his solutions". MacIntyre credited Nozick with showing "striking and imaginative originality" by proposing that philosophy should replace the ideal of proof with "the notion of explanation", vindicating the importance of technical discussions in the philosophy of language and the philosophy of mind with "the uses he finds for their conceptual end products", and indirectly showing "how Continental philosophers who have been explicitly concerned with human value and significance have too often presented us with impoverished and barren discussions on these great issues because they have neglected the more technical discussions of Anglo-American analytic philosophy." He also praised Nozick's discussions of the identity of the self, knowledge, free will, and skepticism, writing that they provide "splendid insights and arguments". [12]

Hacking believed that, like the philosopher Richard Rorty's Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature , Philosophical Explanations had the potential to bring renewed public attention to philosophy in the United States. He believed that the book would also impress philosophy professors. He compared the difficulty of reading it to that of reading the Critique of Pure Reason, writing that in both works there was "apparent indifference to the reader"; he also considered Nozick's philosophical approach in some ways similar to Kant's. [13] Gordon described the book as "amazingly original", and praised the "extraordinary elegance" of Nozick's arguments, as well as his "vigorous and enthusiastic style." [14] Lilla wrote that the book showed the same "intellectual virtues" as Nozick's previous work Anarchy, State, and Utopia (1974), and that it "testifies to the voraciousness of his intellectual appetite." He praised Nozick's chapter on ethics as "probably the most accomplished in the book", and suggested that together with Rorty's Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature, Nozick may have helped achieve "a revival in American academic philosophy." He credited Rorty and Nozick with confronting philosophy's crisis with "careful reason, wit, and a humane concern for the fundamental questions", thereby showing that academic philosophy is still worth studying. He described both their works as "major books" that directly address the "doubt in which academic philosophy finds itself" due to charges that it is overly technical and ignores or misunderstands continental philosophy. [15]

Barker compared the book to Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature and MacIntyre's After Virtue (1981), and described it as "powerful", brilliant, and well-written. He welcomed what he saw as Nozick's call for a "calmer and more tolerant tone in philosophical discussions" and praised Nozick's discussions of "the self" and of the metaphysical question, "Why is there something rather than nothing?". However, he maintained that some of the explanations Nozick advanced of various subjects explained them only to a limited degree. [16]

Other evaluations

Philosophical Explanations was discussed by the National Review , [25] Frederick Kroon in The Philosophical Quarterly , [26] the philosopher Jim Holt in The American Scholar, [27] the criminologist Nigel Walker in Philosophy , [28] the philosopher Alvin Goldman in Philosophy and Phenomenological Research , [29] and St Hope Earl McKenzie in Philosophy and Literature . [30]

Kroon, though expressing sympathy for Nozick's view that the claim that people know many facts about an independently existing world can be reconciled with the position that people do not know that certain skeptical possibilities do not obtain, questioned whether Nozick had correctly identified how to accomplish this, and suggested that a better way was available. [26] Holt credited Nozick with having "clever things to say about every issue in contemporary philosophy". [27] Walker, discussing Nozick's justification of punishment, questioned his "analogy between revenge and retribution", arguing that it created problems that "raise questions about Nozick's attitude to utility." He agreed with Nozick that "satisfaction is the point of revenge" but questioned "whether it is also the point of retribution." [28]

The philosopher Bernard Williams credited Nozick with providing "the most subtle and ingenious discussion of propositional knowledge that I know". [31] The philosopher Jonathan Wolff observed that Nozick's discussions of knowledge and skepticism have received much critical attention. [32] The philosopher A. R. Lacey commented that reviewers generally agree that Nozick's chapter on epistemology is the book's best chapter. He credited Nozick with usefully developing ideas first put forward by the philosopher Fred Dretske a decade or more earlier. [33] The philosopher Michael Bratman described the book as "a rich and wide-ranging exploration of some of the deepest issues in philosophy". He praised Nozick's discussion of free will, describing it as "fascinating" and "suggestive". However, he argued that "Nozick's views about personal identity and value themselves raise a host of difficult questions." [34]

See also

Related Research Articles

<i>Eros and Civilization</i> 1955 book by Herbert Marcuse

Eros and Civilization: A Philosophical Inquiry into Freud is a book by the German philosopher and social critic Herbert Marcuse, in which the author proposes a non-repressive society, attempts a synthesis of the theories of Karl Marx and Sigmund Freud, and explores the potential of collective memory to be a source of disobedience and revolt and point the way to an alternative future. Its title alludes to Freud's Civilization and Its Discontents (1930). The 1966 edition has an added "political preface".

<i>Gay Science</i> 1997 book by Timothy F. Murphy

Gay Science: The Ethics of Sexual Orientation Research is a 1997 book by the philosopher Timothy F. Murphy about scientific research on sexual orientation.

<i>Louis Althusser and the Traditions of French Marxism</i> 2005 book by William S. Lewis

Louis Althusser and the Traditions of French Marxism is a 2005 book about the French philosopher Louis Althusser by William S. Lewis. The book received positive reviews. Lewis was complimented for his inclusion of translated documents of the French Communist Party.

<i>The Philosophic Thought of Ayn Rand</i> 1984 book edited by Douglas Den Uyl and Douglas B. Rasmussen

The Philosophic Thought of Ayn Rand is a 1984 collection of essays on Ayn Rand's philosophy of Objectivism, edited by Douglas Den Uyl and Douglas B. Rasmussen. It includes essays by nine different authors covering Rand's views in various areas of philosophy. The work received positive reviews, crediting it with bringing serious attention by philosophers to Rand and her work. However, reviewers also noted that the work assumed considerable prior knowledge of philosophy on the part of the reader.

<i>Knowledge and Human Interests</i> 1968 book by Jürgen Habermas

Knowledge and Human Interests is a 1968 book by the German philosopher Jürgen Habermas, in which the author discusses the development of the modern natural and human sciences. He criticizes Sigmund Freud, arguing that psychoanalysis is a branch of the humanities rather than a science, and provides a critique of the philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche.

<i>Freud, Biologist of the Mind</i> 1979 book by Frank Sulloway

Freud, Biologist of the Mind: Beyond the Psychoanalytic Legend is a 1979 biography of Sigmund Freud, the founder of psychoanalysis, by the psychologist Frank Sulloway.

<i>Main Currents of Marxism</i> 1976 book by Leszek Kołakowski

Main Currents of Marxism: Its Origins, Growth and Dissolution is a work about Marxism by the political philosopher Leszek Kołakowski. Its three volumes in English are The Founders, The Golden Age, and The Breakdown. It was first published in Polish in Paris in 1976, with the English translation appearing in 1978. In 2005, Main Currents of Marxism was republished in a one volume edition, with a new preface and epilogue by Kołakowski. The work was intended to be a "handbook" on Marxism by Kołakowski, who was once an orthodox Marxist but ultimately rejected Marxism. Despite his critical stand toward Marxism, Kołakowski endorsed the philosopher György Lukács's interpretation of the philosopher Karl Marx.

<i>Logical Investigations</i> (Husserl) 1900–1901 book by Edmund Husserl

The Logical Investigations are a two-volume work by the philosopher Edmund Husserl, in which the author discusses the philosophy of logic and criticizes psychologism, the view that logic is based on psychology.

<i>Meaning and Necessity</i> 1947 book by Rudolf Carnap

Meaning and Necessity: A Study in Semantics and Modal Logic is a book about semantics and modal logic by the philosopher Rudolf Carnap. The book, in which Carnap discusses the nature of linguistic expressions, was a continuation of his previous work in semantics in Introduction to Semantics (1942) and Formalization of Logic (1943). Considered an important discussion of semantics, it was influential and provided a basis for further developments in modal logic.

<i>The Man of Reason</i> 1984 book by Genevieve Lloyd

The Man of Reason: "Male" and "Female" in Western Philosophy is a book about the association between maleness and reason in western philosophy by the Australian philosopher Genevieve Lloyd. The work received positive reviews. It has been called a twentieth century classic of feminist thought, and is widely read in the Nordic countries.

<i>Religion and Nothingness</i> 1961 book by Keiji Nishitani

Religion and Nothingness is a 1961 book about nihilism by the Japanese philosopher Keiji Nishitani. The book was published in English translation in 1982, and received positive reviews, commending Nishitani for his understanding of both western and eastern philosophy. The appearance of the English translation increased interest in Nishitani's ideas among philosophers.

<i>Nietzsche: Philosopher, Psychologist, Antichrist</i> 1950 book by Walter Kaufmann

Nietzsche: Philosopher, Psychologist, Antichrist is a book about the German philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche by the philosopher Walter Kaufmann. The book, first published by Princeton University Press, was influential and is considered a classic study. Kaufmann has been credited with helping to transform Nietzsche's reputation after World War II by dissociating him from Nazism, and making it possible for Nietzsche to be taken seriously as a philosopher. However, Kaufmann has been criticized for presenting Nietzsche as an existentialist, and for other details of his interpretation.

<i>Homosexuality: A Philosophical Inquiry</i> 1988 book by Michael Ruse

Homosexuality: A Philosophical Inquiry is a 1988 book by the philosopher Michael Ruse, in which the author discusses different theories of homosexuality, evaluates the moral status of homosexual behavior, and argues in favor of gay rights.

<i>Perceiving God</i> 1991 book by William Alston

Perceiving God: The Epistemology of Religious Experience is a 1991 book about the philosophy of religion by the philosopher William Alston, in which the author discusses experiential awareness of God. The book was first published in the United States by Cornell University Press. The book received positive reviews and has been described as an important, well-argued, and seminal work. However, Alston was criticized for his treatment of the conflict between the competing claims made by different religions.

<i>The Structure of Science</i> 1961 book by Ernest Nagel

The Structure of Science: Problems in the Logic of Scientific Explanation is a 1961 book about the philosophy of science by the philosopher Ernest Nagel, in which the author discusses the nature of scientific inquiry with reference to both natural science and social science. Nagel explores the role of reduction in scientific theories and the relationship of wholes to their parts, and also evaluates the views of philosophers such as Isaiah Berlin.

<i>History, Labour, and Freedom</i> 1988 book by G. A. Cohen

History, Labour, and Freedom: Themes from Marx is a 1988 book by the philosopher G. A. Cohen.

<i>Philosophy of Love</i> 2009 book by Irving Singer

Philosophy of Love: A Partial Summing-Up is a 2009, book by the American philosopher Irving Singer, in which the author summarizes and expands upon the themes of his earlier three-volume works The Nature of Love (1984–1987) and Meaning in Life (1992–1996). The book, which has been described as an "intellectual biography" by its author, received positive reviews.

<i>Reason and Morality</i> 1978 book by Alan Gewirth

Reason and Morality is a 1978 book about ethics by the philosopher Alan Gewirth. The work for which he is best known, it received positive reviews. The work is defended by the legal scholar Deryck Beyleveld in The Dialectical Necessity of Morality (1991).

<i>The Ecology of Freedom</i> 1982 book by Murray Bookchin

The Ecology of Freedom: The Emergence and Dissolution of Hierarchy is a 1982 book by the American libertarian socialist and ecologist Murray Bookchin, in which the author describes his concept of social ecology, the idea that ecological problems are caused by human social problems and can be solved only by reorganizing society along ecological and ethical lines. The book is considered Bookchin's magnum opus, but it has also been criticized as utopian.

<i>Sex and Reason</i> 1992 book by Richard Posner

Sex and Reason is a 1992 book about human sexuality by the economist and federal judge Richard Posner, in which the author attempts to explain sexual behavior in economic terms and discusses a range of controversial subjects related to sex, proposing reforms in American laws.

References

  1. ↑ Nozick 1994, pp. 27–164.
  2. ↑ Nozick 1994, pp. 167–288.
  3. ↑ Nozick 1994, pp. 399–570.
  4. ↑ Nozick 1994, pp. 1–2.
  5. ↑ Nozick 1994, pp. 15–17.
  6. ↑ Nozick 1994, pp. 341, 458–459.
  7. ↑ Nozick 1994, pp. 27–70.
  8. ↑ Nozick 1994, pp. 571–647.
  9. ↑ Nozick 1994, pp. 14, 546.
  10. ↑ Nozick 1994, pp. 3–4.
  11. ↑ Nozick 1994, pp. iii–iv.
  12. 1 2 MacIntyre 1981, p. 7.
  13. 1 2 Hacking 1981, pp. 32–35.
  14. 1 2 Gordon 1981, p. 2142.
  15. 1 2 Lilla 1982, pp. 426–432.
  16. 1 2 Barker 1983, pp. 82–85.
  17. ↑ Neville 1983, pp. 322–325.
  18. ↑ Fogelin 1983, pp. 819–825.
  19. ↑ Hardin 1984, pp. 326–327.
  20. ↑ Stevenson 1984, pp. 83–85.
  21. ↑ Weckman 1984, p. 199.
  22. ↑ Ellis 1984, pp. 450–455.
  23. ↑ Stout 1985, pp. 133–134.
  24. ↑ The Economist 1986, pp. 98–99.
  25. ↑ W. 1981, p. 1029.
  26. 1 2 Kroon 1986, pp. 391–395.
  27. 1 2 Holt 1990, pp. 458–462.
  28. 1 2 Walker 1995, pp. 581–586.
  29. ↑ Goldman 2009, pp. 223–230.
  30. ↑ McKenzie 2016, pp. 34–43.
  31. ↑ Williams 1993, p. 218.
  32. ↑ Wolff 1991, p. 2.
  33. ↑ Lacey 2001, p. 100.
  34. ↑ Bratman 2002, p. 155.

Bibliography

Books
Journals
Online articles
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.