Public transport in action – pedestrians boarding a bus at Canada Water bus station in London.
The public transport accessibility level (PTAL) is a method sometimes used in United Kingdom transport planning to assess the access level of geographical areas to public transport.
PTAL is a simple, easily calculated approach that hinges on the distance from any point to the nearest public transport stop, and service frequency at those stops. The result is a grade from 1–6 (including sub-divisions 1a, 1b, 6a and 6b), where a PTAL of 1a indicates extremely poor access to the location by public transport, and a PTAL of 6b indicates excellent access by public transport.
Background
The PTAL calculation was originally developed by the Borough of Hammersmith and Fulham in 1992, and was later adopted by Transport for London in 2004[1] as the standard method for calculation of public transport access in London. It is not commonly used outside Greater London or the south east of England.
Method
The first stage in PTAL calculation[2] is to calculate the walking distance from the site (known as the point of interest (POI)) to the nearest bus stops and rail stations (where rail can be taken to also include London Underground, DLR and trams). These stops and stations are known as service access points (SAPs). Only SAPs within a certain distance of the POI are included (640m for bus stops and 960m for rail stations, which correspond to a walking time of 8 minutes and 12 minutes respectively at the standard assumed walking speed of 80m/min).
The next stage is to determine the service level during the morning peak (defined as 0815–0915) for each route serving a SAP. Where service levels differ in each direction on a route, the highest frequency is taken. On railways, a route is generally defined as a service with a particular calling pattern – for example, services on the Piccadilly line from Hammersmith could be divided into two "routes": Cockfosters to Heathrow and Cockfosters to Uxbridge.
A total access time for each route is then calculated by adding together the walking time from the POI to the SAP and the average waiting time for services on the route (i.e. half the headway). This is converted to an equivalent doorstep frequency (EDF) by dividing 30 (minutes) by the total access time, which is intended to convert total access time to a "notional average waiting time, as though the route were available at the doorstep of the POI".
A weighting is applied to each route to simulate the enhanced reliability and attractiveness of a route with a higher frequency over other routes. For each mode (e.g. bus, Tube, DLR, tram, rail), the route with the highest frequency is given a weighting of 1.0, with all other routes in that mode weighted at 0.5.
Finally, the EDF and the weighting are multiplied to produce an accessibility index for each route, and the accessibility indices for all routes are summed to produce an overall accessibility index for the POI.
This accessibility index (AI) can then be converted to a PTAL grade (1–6) through a banding system (where AIs 0.00–5.00 are PTAL 1, 5.01–10.00 are PTAL 2, etc. up to PTAL 6 for scores of 25 and above).
TfL introduced the WebCAT automatic calculator in 2015.[3]
Uses
The PTAL is used as a development planning tool in London, to determine both permitted parking standards and development densities. Large site developments (those the London boroughs refer to the Greater London Authority) must follow planning guidelines that allow more parking in areas with low PTALs (i.e., poor public transport) and vice versa—and that also relate the allowed density of development to PTAL (i.e., areas with better public transport may have higher density housing or offices).
TfL also have software to calculate PTALs across wide areas using GIS and timetable data, the typical result being a map with coloured bands relating to PTAL grades.
Application in other areas
Ahmedabad
Ahmedabad PTAL 2014
The London PTAL[4] method was first applied in the Indian context to Ahmedabad in 2014 (see figure Ahmedabad PTAL 2014) by Bhargav Adhvaryu and Jay Shah.[5] PTAL mapping for other Indian cities if under progress. In the London method, points of interest (POIs) were considered by the actual development (e.g., buildings). However, in Ahmedabad, given the lack of availability of building footprint data at the time of the study, the method deviated by construing POIs as centroids of a 1km2 grid. Given that the purpose of the study was to explore implications of PTAL at a macro-scale (i.e., development/ master plan level – the study area being 465km2) and the data constraints, the grid-cell approach seemed justified (comparison for which is discussed in the section on Surat application). In addition, it made the computations much faster.
The others adaptation of London method to Ahmedabad included revisiting walk speed and public transport service reliability assumptions. Most of the roads in Ahmedabad do not have footpaths and, if any, are usually occupied by street vendors and parking. Therefore, people are forced to walk on the road (the black-top surface), which creates unsafe and potentially hazardous situations, such that walking is avoided as much as possible, even for short trips. To account for this discomfort walk speed was decreased to 60m/min (based on a few samples) as against 80m/min used in London. The reliability factor added in case of London (to allow for additional wait times) were 2 minutes and 0.75 minutes for buses and rail services, respectively. In Ahmedabad, this was changed to 2.5 minutes for city buses (AMTS) and 1 minute for BRTS (based on empirical observations), and 0.75 minutes was not changed for the proposed metrorail – Ahmedabad Metro (a section of which started operation in March 2019). Lastly, in London 8 minutes (i.e., 640m) and 12 minutes (i.e., 960m) were used as the threshold walk distances to bus and rail SAPs, respectively; SAPs beyond these distances are rejected. However, in Ahmedabad, surveys to determine willingness to walk for public transport were not carried out. Therefore, the farthest SAP from a POI (not accounted for in any other POI) was measured, which turned out to be 993m. At 60m/min, this give as willingness to walk at about 16 minutes, which seemed reasonable.
The Ahmedabad study[5] discussed several uses of PTAL mapping:
Improving existing public transport systems by recognizing areas with poor accessibility, thereby enabling decision makers to prioritize investments in public transport systems and support non-motorized transport infrastructure.
Formulating parking policies, e.g. park-and-ride facilities could be provided to supplement areas with low and medium PTAL and parking may be restricted or charged at a higher rate in areas with high PTAL.
Integrating land use zoning with public transport accessibility. By allowing future transport improvements to be incorporated into PTAL calculations, a future PTAL map becomes an important tool in supporting land use and zoning decisions for local authorities, including introduce transit-oriented development (TOD), as PTALs already incorporate walkability criteria from POIs – an important D (distance to transit) in the 6Ds of TOD. It can also be useful in testing "what if" scenarios using land use – transport interaction models.
PTAL maps could be used by households to inform their residential location choices, especially low-income households that are captive public transport users. Real estate developers (who supply housing and commercial spaces) could use PTAL maps (both existing and future) for locating potential projects (especially low-income housing and industrial), while government agencies could use PTAL maps to locate social housing projects.
Surat
Hubli-Dharwad PTAL 2020 (base year) overlaid on 2011 Census population densitySurat PTAL 2016 v. 2021 (future)
Building from the Ahmedabad case study,[5] PTAL was applied for Surat by Bhargav Adhvaryu, Abhay Chopde, and Lalit Dashora.[6] This application goes beyond the Ahmedabad study in two ways. First, it overlays population density map on PTAL maps (see figure Surat PTAL 2016 overlaid with population density) demonstrating a better way to use PTAL maps to inform public transport investment decisions. Second, it demonstrates the use of PTAL for evaluating future transport investment options. PTAL maps for year 2021 (see figure Surat PTAL 2016 v. 2021 (future)) were generated based on information on future (and committed) proposals to demonstrate PTAL's strategic use to create "what-if" scenarios. The Surat study also explicitly justified the use of 1km2 grid for PTAL mapping in data and resource constrained situation by showing changes in PTAL map resolutions for grid sizes for comparison (see figure Comparison of PTAL map for various grid sizes (Surat)). Of course, smaller grid micro-PTAL maps can be prepared for specific areas of the city which could be used to fine-tuning public transport infrastructure provision at local area level.
Comparison of PTAL map for various grid sizes (Surat)Ahmedabad PTAL 2017 superimposed with slum and chawl location
The Surat study discussed several uses of PTAL mapping such as: [1] prioritising public transport investments [2] Integrating transport in development/master plan [3] informing the parking policy [4] improving residential location choice and optimizing supply of affordable housing, and [5] understanding the mobility needs of the urban poor, which is based on another study in Ahmedabad.[7] It argues that living in high PTAL areas may not necessarily translate to high accessibility to destination by public transport, especially those urban poor with variable job destination by month and season (e.g., construction workers, casual labourers, street vendors, etc.). Superimposing housing location of the urban poor on the PTAL map allows identifying specific areas for enhancing the mobility (see figure Ahmedabad PTAL 2017 superimposed with slum and chawl location).
Lucknow
Lucknow PTAL 2020 (baseline scenario) overlaid on population densityLucknow PTAL: Macro v. Micro
The PTAL analysis of Indian cities continued with the application of PTAL to Lucknow.[8] The methodology adopted for the PTAL analysis of Ahmedabad and Surat was used to prepare the PTAL map of Lucknow. The maps of the baseline and the tentatively committed scenarios formed the basis for further research on its applications to improve the urban plan-making process. The first application of PTAL was to enhance the statutory development plan. The PTAL map was superimposed over the proposed development plan to validate the congruity of the land use and transport proposals (see figure Lucknow PTAL 2020 (baseline scenario) overlaid on population density). A new public transport network was recommended to improve PTAL in areas most likely to develop in the near future. The second application was to improve the zoning for transit-oriented development. The third application is aimed at making public transport more inclusive. The study found that the proposed public affordable housing projects are in areas having poor PTAL, which could hamper the occupancy in these projects; the slums, on the contrary, were in high-PTAL areas. Recommendations included proposing affordable housing projects in areas having high-PTAL. The fourth application explored was to enhance micro-level plans. An area of 1 km2 was assessed using 100 m2 grids. The PTAL analysis revealed which areas have poor PTAL. Improvement in the quality of pedestrian infrastructure and street connectivity was recommended; the new PTAL map, thus, generated demonstrated improved PT accessibility (see figure Lucknow PTAL: Macro v. Micro). The authors also proposed combining this tool to develop a holistic dashboard; this could be used by the stakeholders in taking more informed decisions, focused on land use transport integration.
Hubli-Dharwad
The PTAL analysis of Indian cities continued with the application of PTAL to Hubli-Dharwad,[9] a twin-city region that is one of fastest-growing cities in Karnataka State. The analysis was based on the methodology adopted for Ahmedabad[5] and Surat,[6] with new methodological innovations (explain below). The city follows a Master Plan 2031 Revision–II (made in 2017 and approved in 2019), which has opened new areas for development. This established the need to analyse the accessibility of the public transport network in relation to the planned future developments that builds on the analysis of the current situation. The mapping provides a visual representation of the existing accessibility levels (see figure Hubli-Dharwad PTAL 2020 (base year) overlaid on 2011 Census population density) that can further be used to facilitate the decision-making process in master plan preparation and guide future public transport investments, rationalise land use distribution, help decide sites for affordable housing locations, and support the demarcation of transit-oriented development (TOD) zone demarcation. The base year PTAL is also important to compare the PTALs with future year.
In the study, the PTAL map was superimposed with the proposed Master Plan 2031 which envisions Hubli-Dharwad to grow as a compact and equitable city. A key methodological step was to start with the base year PTAL map and overlay layers of existing land use, job density, development and demand potential, PT improvement leading to a robust public-transport centric development plan for 2031 (see figure Methodology to arrive at a robust PT-centric future plan (2031)). Considering this future (2031) PT improvements, the PTAL was then prepared (see figure Hubli-Dharwad PTAL 2031 (future year) with bus rapid transit and mini-bus feeder systems). As can bee seen the average accessibility index in the base year (2020) is 3.6 (buses/hour), which improves to 5.5 buses/hour for 2031.
Recommendations were made to improve public transport infrastructure to ensure synchronisation with the existing job centers and proposed development. The PTAL map was also superimposed on proposed affordable housing locations in the Master Plan to assess accessibility to public transport and hence recommendations were made to improve connectivity to these zones. The proposed TOD zone demarcation along the BRT corridor was also overlaid on the PTAL map to validate accessibility levels in the zone.
Methodology to arrive at a robust PT-centric future plan (2031)
Whilst PTAL is a simple calculation (easily performed by a spreadsheet) that offers an obvious indication of the density of public transport provision in an area, it suffers two key problems:
It does not take into account where services actually go to – for example, a bus that runs every ten minutes to the bottom of the road is considered better than a bus that runs every twelve minutes to the city centre.
The use of arbitrary cut-offs to exclude more distant service access points underestimates the ability to access locations just outside those cut-off distances. For example, a point 960m from King's Cross could have a PTAL of 6, whilst a point 961m from the same station could have a PTAL of 1 or 2.
Accessibility modelling has been proposed as a solution to these problems. It uses GIS to calculate door-to-door travel times by public transport to a grid of points around the point of interest, resulting in a set of isochrone maps – journey time contours – within which the number of workplaces, households or residents can be calculated using census data. This method takes into account many more factors than PTAL, but is much more time-consuming and requires a level of expertise with GIS software and methodologies.
Hubli-Dharwad PTAL 2031 (future year) with bus rapid transit and mini-bus feeder systems
1 2 Adhvaryu, Bhargav; Chopde, Abhay; Dashora, Lalit (1 June 2019). "Mapping public transport accessibility levels (PTAL) in India and its applications: A case study of Surat". Case Studies on Transport Policy. 7 (2): 293–300. doi:10.1016/j.cstp.2019.03.004. ISSN2213-624X. S2CID169155963.
London Trams, previously Tramlink and Croydon Tramlink, is a light rail tram system serving Croydon and surrounding areas in South London, England. It is the first operational tram system serving the London region since 1952. Tramlink is presently managed by London Trams, a public body part of Transport for London (TfL), and has been operated by FirstGroup since 2017. It is one of two light rail networks in Greater London, the other being the Docklands Light Railway. Tramlink is the fourth-busiest light rail network in the UK behind the Docklands Light Railway, Manchester Metrolink and Tyne and Wear Metro.
Hubli is a city in the Indian state of Karnataka. The twin cities Hubli–Dharwad form the second largest city in the state by area and population and the largest city in North Karnataka. Hubli is in Dharwad district of Karnataka and is the taluk headquarters of Hubli City and Hubli Rural. Although it hosts the HDMC office, the district headquarters is in Dharwad.
Dharwad, also known as Dharwar, is a city located in the northwestern part of the Indian state of Karnataka. It is the headquarters of the Dharwad district of Karnataka and forms a contiguous urban area with the city of Hubballi. It was merged with Hubballi in 1962 to form the twin cities of Hubballi-Dharwad. It covers an area of 213 km2 (82 sq mi) and is located 430 km (270 mi) northwest of Bangalore, on NH-48, between Bangalore and Pune.
Oats Street railway station is a temporarily-closed Transperth suburban railway station in Western Australia, located in the Perth suburbs of Carlisle and East Victoria Park. The station was served by the Armadale and Thornlie lines prior to its closure in November 2023.
Dharwad or Dharawada is an administrative district of the state of Karnataka in southern India. The administrative headquarters of the district is the city of Dharwad, also known as Dharwar. Dharwad is located 425 km northwest of Bangalore and 421 km southeast of Pune, on the main highway between Chennai and Pune, the National Highway 4 (NH4).
Wellard railway station is a railway station in Wellard, a suburb of Perth, Western Australia. It is on the Mandurah railway line, which is part of the Transperth commuter rail network, and is located at the centre of a transit oriented development. It has two side platforms located in a cutting, accessed by a ground-level station concourse. Services run every 10 minutes during peak, and every 15 minutes between peak. The journey to Perth railway station is 37.1 kilometres (23.1 mi), and takes 30 minutes. The station has a bus interchange with four bus stands, and three regular bus routes.
Hubli and Dharwad are twin cities in the Indian state of Karnataka. Hubli-Dharwad form the second-largest municipality and urban agglomeration of Karnataka in terms of population, after the capital Bangalore. While Dharwad is the administrative headquarters, the city of Hubli, situated about 20 km (12 mi) south-east of Dharwad, is the commercial centre and business hub of North Karnataka. The cities have a single municipal corporation called Hubli-Dharwad Municipal Corporation (HDMC).
Hubli Airport is a domestic airport serving the twin cities of Hubballi and Dharwad in the state of Karnataka, India. It is situated in Gandhi Nagar, 8 km (5.0 mi) from Hubballi and 20 km (12 mi) from Dharwad. It is connected with 10 destinations throughout the country. The airport has been made self-reliant in terms of electricity generation, with the commissioning of an 8 megawatt (MW) ground-mounted grid-connected photovoltaic solar plant in April 2021.
Karnataka, a state in South India has a well-developed transport system. Its capital city, Bengaluru is well-connected by air to domestic and international destinations and the Kempegowda International Airport (KIA) in the city is one of the busiest airports in India. It was also the headquarters of the airlines Air Deccan and Kingfisher Airlines. The road transport is also well developed in the state with many National and State highways providing means for fast transportation. The headquarters of the South-Western Railway division of Indian Railways is located at Hubballi and this division governs most of the railway network in the state. Konkan Railway which passes along the coastal region of the state is considered one of the toughest engineering projects being undertaken in India till date. Buses, cars and trains are the means of transport for moving across distant places in Karnataka. For transportation within the city or town limits; motorbikes, cars, autorickshaws and buses are used. With the advent of low-cost airlines, many people are choosing to travel via air as well.
A journey planner, trip planner, or route planner is a specialized search engine used to find an optimal means of travelling between two or more given locations, sometimes using more than one transport mode. Searches may be optimized on different criteria, for example fastest, shortest, fewest changes, cheapest. They may be constrained, for example, to leave or arrive at a certain time, to avoid certain waypoints, etc. A single journey may use a sequence of several modes of transport, meaning the system may know about public transport services as well as transport networks for private transportation. Trip planning or journey planning is sometimes distinguished from route planning, which is typically thought of as using private modes of transportation such as cycling, driving, or walking, normally using a single mode at a time. Trip or journey planning, in contrast, would make use of at least one public transport mode which operates according to published schedules; given that public transport services only depart at specific times, an algorithm must therefore not only find a path to a destination, but seek to optimize it so as to minimize the waiting time incurred for each leg. In European Standards such as Transmodel, trip planning is used specifically to describe the planning of a route for a passenger, to avoid confusion with the completely separate process of planning the operational journeys to be made by public transport vehicles on which such trips are made.
The Doncaster railway line was a long-proposed suburban railway in the eastern suburbs of Melbourne, Victoria, Australia, that was anticipated to be built by the late 2020s, as a branch, along with the Hurstbridge line, of the planned future Clifton Hill Loop Line, as part of the 2013 PTV Network Development Plan.
The Bakerloo line extension is a proposed extension of the London Underground Bakerloo line in South London from its current terminus at Elephant & Castle to Lewisham station.
Gujarat State Road Transport Corporation, abbreviated GSRTC, is a Government State Transport Undertaking of Gujarat for passengers facilitating with road public transport in moffusil / city services. GSRTC operates within the state of Gujarat, India and neighboring states. It has a fleet of 8703 buses.
Janmarg, also known as Ahmedabad BRTS, is a bus rapid transit system in Ahmedabad, Gujarat, India. It is operated by Ahmedabad Janmarg Limited, a subsidiary of Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation and others. It is designed by CEPT University. It was inaugurated in October 2009. The network expanded to 89 kilometres (55 mi) by December 2017 and 160 km by March 2023; with daily ridership of 3,49,000 passengers. BRTS won several nation and international awards for design, implementation and operation. It was rated Silver on BRT Standard in 2013.
Hubli-Dharwad Bus Rapid Transit System (HDBRTS) is a bus rapid transit system built to serve the twin cities of Hubali and Dharwad, located in the North-Western part of Karnataka state in India. Hubali-Dharwad BRTS (HDBRTS) project is a Government of Karnataka initiative to foster long-term economic growth in the region. The project promotes fast, safe, comfortable, convenient and affordable public transportation between the twin cities and aims to reduce congestion and air pollution in the region.
Surat City Bus is the name under which city buses are operated in Surat, Gujarat, India. It is operated by a private entity-‘Sitilink’ under a public private partnership model for the Surat Municipal Corporation (SMC). The model is based on an earlier model by the Ahmedabad Municipal Transport Service (AMTS) which operated bus services in Ahmedabad on a public-private partnership, but subsequently failed. In 2012, the Government of Gujarat announced that it would set up similar transport facilities in 180 cities across the state under a public-private partnership.
National Highway 48 is a major National Highway of India that starts at Delhi and terminates at Chennai traversing through seven states of India. It has a total length of 2807 km. NH 48 passes through the states of Delhi, Haryana, Rajasthan, Gujarat, Maharashtra, Karnataka and Tamil Nadu. The stretch between Pune and Bengaluru was known as P.B. Road in olden days.
The Morley–Ellenbrook line is an under construction suburban railway line and service in Perth, Western Australia, which will be operated by the Public Transport Authority as part of the Transperth system. The line diverges from the Airport and Midland lines at Bayswater station and heads north-north-west to serve five new stations along a 21-kilometre-long (13 mi) branch to Ellenbrook. Morley–Ellenbrook line services will continue west of Bayswater station to terminate at Perth station in the central business district.
Lakelands railway station is a railway station along the Mandurah line on the Transperth network in Western Australia. The station is in the Mandurah suburb of Lakelands, 6.5 kilometres (4.0 mi) north of Mandurah station and 64.5 kilometres (40.1 mi) south of Perth Underground station. Construction started in 2021 and it opened on 11 June 2023.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply. Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.
