Royal Commission into New South Wales Prisons

Last updated

Royal Commission into New South Wales Prisons
DateMarch 31, 1976 – March 31, 1978 (1976-03-31 – 1978-03-31)
Duration2 years
Location Sydney, Australia
Also known asNagle Royal Commission
Commissioner John Flood Nagle
Counsel Assisting David Hunt
Consultants Sydney Derwent
Alexander Mitchell
Sir Leon Radzinowicz

The Royal Commission into New South Wales Prisons, also known as the Nagle Royal Commission, was established in 1976 to inquire into the management of prisons in the State of New South Wales, Australia. The commission was headed by Supreme Court Justice John Flood Nagle. Nagle's report, handed down in 1978, described "an inefficient Department administering antiquated and disgraceful gaols; untrained and sometimes ignorant prison officers, resentful, intransigent and incapable of performing their tasks." [1] The first of the Royal Commission's 252 recommendations was the dismissal of Corrective Services Commissioner Walter McGeechan [2] – though the Government sacked McGeechan three months before receiving Nagle's final report. [3]

Contents

Background

As Nagle noted in his report, the Royal Commission was by no means the first inquiry into the state of New South Wales prisons. An 1861 select committee, an 1878 Royal Commission, a 1946 committee and a 1973 working party had each produced recommendations that had yet to be fully implemented. [4] [5] Yet despite the deplorable conditions these inquiries had uncovered, public support for the prison system remained strong. A McNair Anderson opinion poll conducted in 1976 found that 40 per cent of NSW residents felt prison conditions were "about what they should be"; a further 29 per cent thought they were "too lenient". [6]

Grafton

Grafton Gaol was designated as a centre for 'intractable' male inmates in 1942. [7] Officers serving at Grafton were entitled to a curiously named "climatic allowance", intended to attract "capable, tactful and robust" men and compensate them for the "arduous nature" of their work. As Nagle was to sensationally uncover, this ardour derived from the frequent and illegal beatings meted out to inmates. This began when the prisoner arrived with a "reception biff" and continued throughout the man's sentence whenever he was thought to breach "written or unwritten rules". One such rule was that inmates were forbidden to make eye contact with staff. [8]

The abuses at Grafton continued undetected for some 30 years, but by the 1970s the prison had acquired a reputation for brutality and questions began to be asked in Parliament and the media. Corrective Services changed its approach to managing the so-called intractables, opening the 40-bed Katingal Special Security Unit at Long Bay in 1975. Katingal replaced a regime of violence with what amounted to sensory deprivation. [9]

Bathurst

But it was events at the much larger Bathurst Gaol that were to force the brutal world of the State's penal system into the public consciousness. In February 1974, an inmate threw a petrol bomb into the prison chapel, sparking a riot. Officers responded with gunfire and, having regained control of the prison, proceeded to inflict retaliatory beatings on the inmates. More than 50 inmates were injured during the riot and its aftermath, and one was paralysed by a bullet lodged in his spine. [10] [11]

In his report, Nagle noted that the Superintendent at Bathurst had also led reprisal beatings against protesting prisoners in 1970. The Department had been aware of the assaults at the time, but had determined that there was insufficient evidence to discipline any individual officer. Like every one of his counterparts, the Superintendent had also failed to act on a Departmental requirement that all prisons have a plan in place for dealing with riots. [12]

Establishment

Following the second Bathurst riot, the Liberal Premier, Sir Robert Askin, promised an inquiry – but this was deferred pending the outcome of criminal charges against the rioters. [13] On 31 March 1976, Askin's successor, Eric Willis established the promised royal commission, with Supreme Court justice John Flood Nagle presiding. Former Macquarie University vice-chancellor Alexander Mitchell and University of New South Wales academic Sydney Derwent were appointed as members of the commission, with Cambridge criminologist Sir Leon Radzinowicz serving as a consultant. [14]

The commissioners were directed to "inquire into and report upon the general working of the Department of Corrective Services of New South Wales, its policies, facilities and practices in the light of contemporary penal practice and knowledge of crime and its causes." They were asked to specifically consider the relationship between staff and prisoners, as well as the selection and training of prison officers, and to provide recommendations for legislative change. The commissioners initiated preliminary hearings two weeks later. [15]

The Liberals lost power in May 1976, and the new Labor government of Neville Wran sought to put its ideological stamp on the commission. Although Wran did not amend the terms of reference, Mitchell and Derwent were demoted to consultant roles, and Radzinowicz – considered too conservative – was sacked. Nagle continued on as sole commissioner. The Liberal Opposition accused Wran of trying to nobble the inquiry; prisoners' advocates saw it as cost-cutting. [13] [14]

Conduct of the inquiry

Nagle sought written submissions from the Department; the prison officers' union, the Public Service Association (PSA); current and former inmates; and members of the public.

Hearings were conducted in an adversarial manner, with Counsel Assisting the commission, David Hunt, examining Departmental staff, current and former inmates, and other witnesses. Both the Department and, were represented by counsel at the commission's hearings. Five civil-society groups were also given leave to appear: the Council for Civil Liberties, the Penal Reform Council, the Aboriginal Legal Service, Women Behind Bars and the Prisoners Action Group. Prisoners were represented by two lawyers, Merv Rutherford and I.L. Dodd. [16]

For the first 10 months, the commission's hearings focused almost exclusively on Bathurst. Prisoners, prison officers, departmental officials and the PSA all testified. On 1 February 1977, Nagle indicated that future hearings would consider other matters. These included violence at Grafton Gaol, the role of Long Bay's Katingal unit, and allegations of inappropriate behaviour by officers at Goulburn and Milson Island. [17]

The commission also considered more general issues of policy: management, staff conditions, external oversight, classification, security measures, inmate work assignments, education programs, remissions, probation and parole, sentencing, record-keeping, public relations, research, and planning. Prison conditions were also examined at some length, including the particular challenges faced by female, Aboriginal and non-English-speaking inmates. [18]

Nagle conceded that "grave allegations" of illegal use of force at Long Bay and Maitland gaols had not been explored by the commission. Rather, having already uncovered "clear illustrations" that the Department and its officers were using force illegally, he recommended that individual complaints from inmates be referred to an individual appointed for the purpose. [19] (This recommendation was rejected.)

Findings

Nagle presented his report to the Governor, Sir Roden Cutler, on 31 March 1978. Its 630 pages excoriated "an inefficient Department administering antiquated and disgraceful gaols; untrained and sometimes ignorant prison officers, resentful, intransigent and incapable of performing their tasks." [1] The report catalogued poor conditions across the State's prison system, with a particular focus on the events at Bathurst and Grafton. The document also contained an extensive review of the literature on criminology and prison administration. In setting out an agenda for reform, Nagle articulated five principles:

  1. "the loss of liberty is the extent of the punishment"
  2. "the inmate should lose only his liberty and such rights as expressly or by necessary implication result from the loss of that liberty"
  3. imprisonment should only be used as a last resort
  4. those who are gaoled should remain there for as short a time as possible
  5. inmates should be housed in the "lowest appropriate" security classification. [20]

Key recommendations

In all, Nagle made more than 250 general recommendations, of which he considered seven most important:

Other recommendations

The other recommendations included:

Impact

Tony Vinson, who replaced McGeechan as head of the Department of Corrective Services, remarked that prison administrators the world over "invariably know of and allude to the Nagle Report as an important benchmark." [23]

Law reform

NSW was undergoing a period of rapid social liberalisation around the time of Nagle's commission. Vice offences, which had earlier contributed significantly to the prison population, were being punished less severely – or not at all. Under Askin, restrictions on off-track betting had begun to be relaxed with the spread of government-owned totalisator agencies, and a 1971 court decision had effectively legalised abortion. Wran liberalised laws on prostitution, public intoxication, vagrancy and homosexuality. His Government also ended the practice of gaoling fine defaulters.

Nagle argued for an expansion in the use of periodic detention, a recommendation that was accepted. (The practice was abandoned in 2010.) [24]

Personnel

Unimpressed by McGeechan's performance in the witness box, Nagle had intended to make his first recommendation that the Commissioner be dismissed. The Government was unwilling to wait for Nagle's report, however, and sacked McGeechan on 18 January 1978, three months before Nagle published his recommendations. While acknowledging that the dismissal had already occurred, Nagle let his first recommendation stand. McGeechan had served nine and a half years at the helm of the State's prison system. For the next year, the Department was led first by Department of Justice Secretary Les Downs, then Assistant Commissioner Noel Day.

The Government accepted Nagle's view that the Department was too complex to be run by a single individual, and took up his suggestion of a five-person commission. On 19 March 1979, it appointed Vinson as chief commissioner alongside Day, Arnold Bailey, Dr John Ellard and Frank Hayes. Vinson resigned less than three years later, forced out by union opposition to his reforms and a lack of support from the Wran Government. [10] Within 10 years, the five-person commission had been abandoned in favour of a single commissioner once more.

Though he went to some trouble to excoriate McGeechan, Nagle was more forgiving of his subordinates. The report named dozens of officers implicated in violence, dishonesty, corruption and incompetence. Of the union's excuse that its members were simply following orders, the Royal Commissioner thundered "The defence did not succeed in the Nuremberg Trials; it does not succeed here." [25]

Yet there were no recommendations for prosecution or dismissal of officers – with one exception. An officer at Goulburn, Keith Newling, stood accused of making homosexual advances towards a prisoner. Nagle recommended that he face disciplinary action, a recommendation that was accepted. [26] Of the others, including the men who committed the assaults at Bathurst and Grafton, Nagle wrote that he saw "no purpose at this late stage of recommending criminal prosecutions." [27]

Infrastructure

Though he did not accept the Department's estimate that the prison population would grow considerably, Nagle nonetheless threw his support behind a number of construction projects then under consideration. His view was that a newly built prison could be used to decant one of the older gaols, allowing for its upgrade.

Nagle called for the Department to take over the Cumberland Hospital site at North Parramatta, and to proceed with a major expansion of the Bathurst complex. The first of these plans never eventuated; the Government closed Parramatta Gaol altogether in 1999, although the nearby former Parramatta Girls Home was converted for use as a women's prison, the Norma Parker Centre, before closing in 2008. [28] Work to expand Bathurst did not begin until 2018 – a lag of 40 years. Nagle's call for a new high-rise remand centre in central Sydney went unheeded.

Katingal, the special unit at Long Bay which had replaced Grafton as the last stop for high-risk inmates only in 1975, was closed on Nagle's recommendation. The building itself remained empty for many years before being demolished in 2004. [9]

The first new prison to be built following the Nagle report was Parklea Correctional Centre, completed in 1983. Though designed to honour the commission's findings, it too was plagued by problems.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Long Bay Correctional Centre</span> Building

The Long Bay Correctional Complex, commonly called Long Bay, is a correctional facility comprising a heritage-listed maximum and minimum security prison for males and females and a hospital to treat prisoners, psychiatric cases and remandees, located in Malabar, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia. The complex is located approximately 14 kilometres (8.7 mi) south of the Sydney CBD and is contained within a 32-hectare (79-acre) site. The facility is operated by Corrective Services New South Wales, a department administered by the Government of New South Wales.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Grafton Correctional Centre</span> Heritage-listed building in New South Wales, Australia

The former Grafton Gaol, later called the Grafton Correctional Centre and then Grafton Intake and Transient Centre is a heritage-listed former medium security prison for males and females, located in Grafton, Clarence Valley Council, New South Wales, Australia. The centre was operated by Corrective Services NSW an agency of the Department of Attorney General and Justice of the Government of New South Wales. In its last correctional use, the centre detained sentenced and remand prisoners under New South Wales and/or Commonwealth legislation. It was added to the New South Wales State Heritage Register on 2 April 1999.

Broken Hill Correctional Centre, formerly Broken Hill Gaol, is an Australian minimum and medium security prison for men and women located in Broken Hill, New South Wales, around 1,190 km (740 mi) from Sydney. Opened in 1892, it is the fourth-oldest prison still in operation in NSW.

Parklea Correctional Centre, a privately managed Australian maximum and minimum security prison for males, is located at Parklea, in the north-western suburbs of Sydney, New South Wales. The facility is operated by MTC Ventia and has a current capacity for 1,350 inmates. The Centre accepts prisoners charged and convicted under New South Wales and/or Commonwealth legislation and incorporates a minimum-security work-release centre for inmates nearing release with a capacity of 120. A Compulsory Drug Treatment Correctional unit is incorporated within the centre.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Goulburn Correctional Centre</span> Building

The Goulburn Correctional Centre, is an Australian supermaximum security prison for males. It is located in Goulburn, New South Wales, three kilometres north-east of the central business district. The facility is operated by Corrective Services NSW. The Complex accepts prisoners charged and convicted under New South Wales and/or Commonwealth legislation and serves as a reception prison for Southern New South Wales, and, in some cases, for inmates from the Australian Capital Territory.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Parramatta Correctional Centre</span> Building

The Parramatta Correctional Centre is a heritage-listed former medium security prison for males on the corner of O'Connell and Dunlop Streets, North Parramatta, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia. It was in operation between 1798 and 2011. The centre was initially called Parramatta Gaol until its name was changed to Parramatta Correctional Centre in 1992. When in operation, the centre was managed by Corrective Services NSW, an agency of the Department of Communities and Justice of the Government of New South Wales. Immediately prior to its closure, the centre detained short term sentenced and remand inmates, operated as a transient centre, and was the periodic detention centre for metropolitan Sydney.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bathurst Correctional Centre</span> Building

Bathurst Correctional Centre, originally built as Bathurst Gaol in 1888, is a prison for men and women located in the city of Bathurst, New South Wales, Australia, and operated by the Department of Communities and Justice. Bathurst holds inmates sentenced under State or Australian criminal law, along with a small number of remand prisoners.

Francis Greenway Correctional Complex, formerly John Morony Correctional Complex is an Australian minimum security prison complex for males and females located in Berkshire Park, 5 kilometres (3 mi) south of Windsor in New South Wales, Australia. The complex is operated by Corrective Services NSW, an agency of the Department of Communities and Justice, of the Government of New South Wales.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cooma Correctional Centre</span> Prison in New South Wales, Australia

Cooma Correctional Centre, an Australian minimum to medium prison for males, is located in Cooma, New South Wales. The centre is operated by Corrective Services NSW an agency of the Department of Communities and Justice of the Government of New South Wales. The centre detains sentenced prisoners and persons on remand under New South Wales and/or Commonwealth legislation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Maitland Gaol</span> Former prison in East Maitland, New South Wales, Australia

The Old Maitland Gaol, also known as Maitland Correctional Centre, is a heritage-listed former Australian prison located in East Maitland, New South Wales. Its construction was started in 1844 and prisoners first entered the gaol in 1848. By the time of its closure, on 31 January 1998, it had become the longest continuously-run gaol in Australia. It has since been turned into a museum and is a popular tourist attraction. It was added to the New South Wales State Heritage Register on 2 April 1999.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Berrima Correctional Centre</span> New South Wales prison

The Berrima Correctional Centre was an Australian prison, located at Berrima, New South Wales. The Centre was operational between 1839 and 2011 with a number of breaks in between, was re-opened in September 2016 and then permanently closed in 2020. Initially established as Berrima Gaol, the facility closed in 1909 and reopened in 1949 as the Berrima Training Centre. The Centre was the oldest Australian correctional facility in operation. It was added to the New South Wales State Heritage Register on 2 April 1999.

Corrective Services New South Wales (CSNSW) is a division of the Department of Communities and Justice of the Government of New South Wales, Australia. CSNSW is responsible for the state's prisons and a range of programs for managing offenders in the community. The state has 36 prisons, 33 run by CSNSW and three privately operated. The agency traces its origins back to 1788, when New South Wales was founded as a penal colony.

The Bathurst riots were a series of violent incidents that occurred at Bathurst Gaol, a prison in Bathurst, New South Wales, Australia, in October 1970 and February 1974. On both occasions, a sit-in protest by inmates escalated into a prison riot. Each riot was followed by violent reprisals from prison officers, the so-called Bathurst Batterings. The second outbreak of violence at Bathurst led to the partial destruction and temporary closure of the prison, and ultimately to a Royal Commission into the entire State prison system.

The New South Wales Department of Prisons, later the Department of Corrective Services (DCS), was a State government agency in New South Wales, Australia, that managed prisons, parole and community service. Established in 1874 as the Department of Prisons, DCS was absorbed into the State Department of Justice and Attorney General in 2009.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Punishment in Australia</span>

Punishment in Australia arises when an individual has been accused or convicted of breaking the law through the Australian criminal justice system. Australia uses prisons, as well as community corrections. When awaiting trial, prisoners may be kept in specialised remand centres or within other prisons.

Wellington Correctional Centre, an Australian maximum security prison for males and females, is located in Wellington, New South Wales, Australia, 360 kilometres (220 mi) west of Sydney. The facility is operated by Corrective Services NSW, an agency of the NSW Government Department of Communities & Justice. The Centre accepts sentenced and remand prisoners under New South Wales and/or Commonwealth legislation.

The Honourable John Hailes Flood "Gaffer" Nagle (1913–2009) was a lawyer, soldier and prominent jurist, who served as a justice of the Supreme Court of New South Wales, Australia, from 1960 until 1983. Nagle led high-profile inquiries into the NSW Department of Corrective Services and the assassination of political candidate Donald Mackay.

Periodic detention or weekend detention is a type of custodial sentence under which the offender is held in prison between Friday and Sunday evenings each week, but is at liberty at other times. Promoted by prison reformers as an alternative to imprisonment, periodic detention drew praise for allowing offenders to continue working, maintain family relationships, and avoid associating with more dangerous criminals in traditional prisons. It was also considerably less expensive to administer.

The Commissioner of Corrective Services is a statutory office-holder in the State of New South Wales, Australia, with responsibility for the State's prison, parole and community corrections systems. The Acting Commissioner is Leon Taylor. Since 2009, Corrections has been a division of the State's justice department, currently known as the Department of Communities and Justice. Prior to 2009, the Commissioner managed their own Department of Corrective Services.

References

  1. 1 2 Nagle, J. F. (31 March 1976). Report of the Royal Commission into New South Wales Prisons. Sydney: New South Wales Government Printer. p. 460.
  2. ↑ "1970s in New South Wales". FamousFix. Retrieved 4 June 2024.
  3. ↑ Nagle, J. F. (31 March 1976). Report of the Royal Commission into New South Wales Prisons (PDF). Sydney: New South Wales Government Printer. Archived from the original (PDF) on 6 May 2018.
  4. ↑ Nagle, J. F. (31 March 1976). Report of the Royal Commission into New South Wales Prisons. Sydney: New South Wales Government Printer. p. 40.
  5. ↑ "Chronology - A History of Australian Prison Reform". Four Corners. Australia: Australian Broadcasting Corporation. 7 November 2005. Retrieved 19 November 2011.
  6. ↑ Australian Law Reform Commission (1980). Sentencing of Federal Offenders, Interim Report no. 15. Canberra: AGPS. p. 144.
  7. ↑ "Grafton Gaol". State Records Authority of New South Wales.
  8. ↑ Nagle, J. F. (31 March 1976). Report of the Royal Commission into New South Wales Prisons. Sydney: New South Wales Government Printer. pp. 16–7.
  9. 1 2 "Final release for Katingal, misguided experiment in extreme jails". Sydney Morning Herald . 19 May 2004. Retrieved 26 January 2019.
  10. 1 2 Grabosky, P. N. (May 1989). Wayward governance : illegality and its control in the public sector - Chapter 2: The abuse of prisoners in New South Wales 1943-76 . Canberra: Australian Institute of Criminology. ISBN   0-642-14605-5 . Retrieved 3 January 2012.
  11. ↑ Nagle, J. F. (31 March 1976). Report of the Royal Commission into New South Wales Prisons. Sydney: New South Wales Government Printer. pp. 18–20.
  12. ↑ Nagle, J. F. (31 March 1976). Report of the Royal Commission into New South Wales Prisons. Sydney: New South Wales Government Printer. p. 18.
  13. 1 2 Prisoners Action Group (1978). "Bathurst gaol and the royal commission into prisons – a summary" (PDF). Alternative Criminology Journal.
  14. 1 2 New South Wales Department of Corrective Services (1976). Report of the Department of Corrective Services for the year ended 30 June 1976 (PDF). New South Wales Government Printer.
  15. ↑ Nagle, J. F. (31 March 1976). Report of the Royal Commission into New South Wales Prisons. Sydney: New South Wales Government Printer. p. 28.
  16. ↑ Nagle, John (1978). Report of the Royal Commission into New South Wales Prisons. Sydney: New South Wales Government Printer. p. 30.
  17. ↑ Nagle, John (1978). Report of the Royal Commission into New South Wales Prisons. Sydney: New South Wales Government Printer. pp. 30–31.
  18. ↑ Nagle, John (1978). Report of the Royal Commission into New South Wales Prisons. Sydney: New South Wales Government Printer. pp. 5–10.
  19. ↑ Nagle, John (1978). Report of the Royal Commission into New South Wales Prisons. Sydney: New South Wales Government Printer. p. 33.
  20. ↑ Nagle, J. F. (31 March 1976). Report of the Royal Commission into New South Wales Prisons. Sydney: New South Wales Government Printer. p. 50.
  21. ↑ Nagle, J. F. (31 March 1976). Report of the Royal Commission into New South Wales Prisons. Sydney: New South Wales Government Printer. pp. 24–5.
  22. ↑ Nagle, J. F. (31 March 1976). Report of the Royal Commission into New South Wales Prisons. Sydney: New South Wales Government Printer. pp. 462–79.
  23. ↑ "The Honourable John Flood Nagle, QC – Citation for the conferral of a Doctor of Letters" (PDF). Charles Sturt University.
  24. ↑ Nicholls, Sean; Jacobsen, Geesche (10 June 2010). "Death sentence for periodic detention". Sydney Morning Herald.
  25. ↑ Nagle, John Flood (31 March 1978). Report of the royal commission into New South Wales prisons. New South Wales Government Printer. p. 77.
  26. ↑ Nagle, J. F. (31 March 1976). Report of the Royal Commission into New South Wales Prisons. New South Wales Government Printer. p. 462.
  27. ↑ Nagle, John Flood (31 March 1978). Report of the royal commission into New South Wales prisons. New South Wales Government Printer. p. 71.
  28. ↑ Tanner Kibble Denton Architects Pty Ltd; UrbanGrowth NSW (17 March 2017). "Parramatta North Historic Sites Consolidated Conservation Management Plan: Part B—Norma Parker Centre/Kamballa Site" (PDF). Retrieved 27 August 2018– via UrbanGrowth NSW.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.