Sknyliv air show disaster

Sknyliv air show disaster

A Sukhoi Su-27UB performing at an air show
Accident
Date	27 July 2002 (2002-07-27)
Summary	Pilot error during aerobatic maneuver
Site	Sknyliv Airfield near Lviv, Ukraine
Total fatalities	77 (on ground)
Total injuries	545
Aircraft
Aircraft type	Sukhoi Su-27UB
Operator	Ukrainian Air Force Ukrainian Falcons
Occupants	2
Crew	2
Fatalities	0
Injuries	2
Survivors	2
Ground casualties
Ground fatalities	77
Ground injuries	543

The damaged IL-76MD (UR-76717)

The Sknyliv air show disaster occurred on 27 July 2002, when a Ukrainian Air Force Sukhoi Su-27UB aircraft, piloted by Volodymyr Toponar (of the Ukrainian Falcons) and co-piloted by Yuriy Yegorov, crashed into spectators during an aerobatics presentation at Sknyliv airfield near Lviv, Ukraine. The accident killed 77 people and injured 543. It is the deadliest air show accident in history.

Crash

More than 10,000 spectators attended the air show, staged to commemorate the 60th anniversary of the Ukrainian Air Force's 14th Air Corps. ^[1] The Su-27 aircraft was flown by two experienced pilots; it entered a rolling maneuver at 12:52 p.m. with a downward trajectory at low altitude. It rolled upright once more and was still descending rapidly when the left wing dropped shortly before it hit the ground, at which point the crew initiated ejection. The aircraft flattened out initially, skidding over the ground towards stationary aircraft and striking a glancing blow against the nose of an Ilyushin Il-76 transport aircraft, before beginning to explode and cartwheel into the crowd of spectators.^{[ citation needed ]}

Both pilots survived with minor injuries, while 77 spectators were killed, including 28 children. ^[2] Another 100 were hospitalized for head injuries, burns, and bone fractures. ^{[1] [3]} Other injuries were less severe and did not require hospitalization. A total of 543 people were injured in the accident. ^[4] Some bystanders suffered serious mental disorders from what they saw. ^[5]

Following the disaster, the pilots stated that the flight map which they had received differed from the actual layout. On the cockpit voice recorder, one pilot asks, "And where are our spectators?". ^[6] Others have suggested that the pilots were slow to react to automated warnings issued by the flight computer. ^[6]

Aftermath

On August 7, an investigation conducted by Yevhen Marchuk, the National Security and Defense Secretary, concluded with the pilots receiving a majority of the blame. In a statement, Marchuk accused Toponar and Yegorov of failing "to respect the flight plan and aerial maneuvers". Marchuk also attributed some blame toward the event organizers and scrutinized them for allowing dangerous stunts to be performed in close proximity to spectators. ^[7] Toponar rejected Marchuk's findings and claimed that technical issues and a faulty flight plan was what led to the crash. ^[8] Prior to the incident, he had requested an additional training flight at the airfield where the display was to be performed, but the request was denied. ^[9]

Ukrainian President Leonid Kuchma publicly blamed the military for the disaster and dismissed the head of the air force, General Viktor Strelnykov. ^[10] Minister of Defense Volodymyr Shkidchenko offered his resignation, but Kuchma rejected it. ^[11]

Prosecution

On 24 June 2005, a military court sentenced pilot Volodymyr Toponar and co-pilot Yuriy Yegorov to fourteen and eight years in prison, respectively. The court found the two pilots and three other military officials guilty of failing to follow orders, negligence, and violating flight rules. Two of the three officials were sentenced to up to six years in prison; the third received up to four years. Toponar was ordered to pay ₴7.2 million (US$1.42 million; €1.18 million) in compensation to the families, and Yegorov ₴2.5 million. The crew's main flight trainer was acquitted for lack of evidence. ^{[12] [13]}

After the verdict was announced, Toponar said that he planned to appeal, insisting that the crash was due to technical problems and a faulty flight plan. Yegorov was released in 2008 after President Viktor Yushchenko issued a decree reducing his sentence to three and a half years. ^[14]

Near the end of his prison term, Toponar reasserted his innocence in a phone interview. "From the mission briefing it is obvious that the flight area parameters we were given significantly exceeded the safe margin of separation from spectators. What happened is the fault of organizers. Planes must not fly over spectators. During the show, I had to make several advanced maneuvers in a few minutes. During the half-barrel, I noticed decreased thrust of both engines and the airspeed fell. But the cause remains unknown! Ground control ordered us to continue the flight. During the last maneuver—an oblique loop with a turn—the plane became uncontrollable. During the trial they said it was caused by pilot error due to inexperience. I have 27 years in the cockpit with 2,000 hours flying time. I was a member of the Ukrainian Falcons… To the last I struggled to lift the plane, [but] copilot Yuriy Yegorov hit the catapult [triggering ejection] and we two ejected with our seats." ^{[15] [16]}

In popular culture

• The disaster forms the backdrop of an episode in Victoria Amelina's Дім для Дома. ^[17] The main characters of the novel (one of whom is a retired Soviet military pilot) attend the air show and witness the disaster, but none of them is injured.

See also

• Lists of air show accidents and incidents

References

1. Stepanenko, Svetlana (21 August 2002). "Deadly Performance. Ukrainian Militarys Prestige Crashes on Lvov Airfield" . The Current Digest of the Russian Press. 54 (30): 16. Retrieved 24 March 2011. Debris from the exploding SU-27 sprayed across the field for a distance of about 100 meters. As of yesterday, 83 people (19 of them children) were dead, and more than 100 were taken to the hospital with head injuries, burns and fractures.
2. Kozyrieva, Tetiana (8 September 2009). "Two Sknyliv boys seven years later". The Day . Retrieved 27 June 2015.
3. "Pilots blamed for Ukraine air disaster". BBC News. 29 July 2002.
4. Kirillov, Roman (27 July 2005). "Pilots Convicted for Disaster During Air Show". The Current Digest of the Russian Press. 56 (26): 9–10. Archived from the original on 30 March 2012. Retrieved 24 March 2011. While performing an aerobatic maneuver, an SU-27 jet crashed into a crowd of spectators, leaving 77 people dead and another 543 injured. The commander of the plane's crew, Vladimir Toponar, was sentenced Friday to 14 years in prison, and copilot Yury Yegorov got eight years
5. "Історія авіакатастроф у Львові" [History of airplane crashes in Lviv]. lviv-future.com.ua (in Ukrainian). 6 February 2023. Retrieved 13 March 2023.
6. "EVXpress – Ukrainian Pilots Failed to Obey Female Voice – The Current Digest of the Russian Press, 2002, No. 31, Vol. 54". dlib.eastview.com. Retrieved 16 December 2016.
7. Ilenko, Zoriana (August 8, 2002). Dangerous stunt caused Ukrainian crash: report. National Post. Retrieved November 14, 2024.
8. Pilot says technical problems to blame. Pacific Daily News. August 11, 2002. Retrieved November 14, 2024.
9. "Pilots to Blame for Air Show Crash: Top Investigator". People's Daily Online . 8 August 2002.
10. "Ukrainian, Russian papers assess plane crashes". BBC News. 30 July 2002. Retrieved 14 March 2021.
11. "Ukraine crash report blames pilots". BBC News. 7 August 2002.
12. "Air show disaster pilots jailed". CNN . 24 June 2005. Retrieved 15 May 2023.
13. "...As Ukraine Pilots Get Jail Time For Air Show Crash". AVweb. 29 June 2005. Retrieved 15 May 2023.
14. Zawada, Zenon (19 August 2012). "Lviv area residents remember Sknyliv air show disaster of 2002" (PDF). The Ukrainian Weekly . Vol. LXXX, no. 34. pp. 1, 4.
15. "Владимир Топонарь: «За мной вины нет. Меня просто сделали козлом отпущения»" [Vladimir Toponar: "I am not to blame. They just made me a scapegoat."]. Fakty i Kommentarii (in Ukrainian). 20 September 2013. Retrieved 20 October 2022.
16. Wrigley, Sylvia (5 August 2016). "Disaster at the Air Show". Fear of Landing. Retrieved 20 October 2022.
17. Amelina, Victoria (2017). Дім для дома : роман[Dom's Dream Kingdom] (in Ukrainian). Львів: Old Lion Publishing House. ISBN   9786176794165.

External links

• (in Russian) Prosecution's Aerobatics After the Sknyliv Tragedy (2006 journalist investigation of the accident, includes photos of the crash moment)
• (in Ukrainian) 2004 Article in Ukrainian Dzerkalo Tyznhya weekly
• Sydney Morning Herald article
• CNN article Archived 3 April 2013 at the Wayback Machine

49°49′N23°57′E / 49.817°N 23.950°E / 49.817; 23.950