The Loves of the Gods

External videos
External videos
	Smarthistory - Carracci's Ceiling of the Farnese Palace

The Loves of the Gods
The Loves of the Gods
	Fresco cycle found on the vault of the Farnese Gallery.
Artist	Annibale Carracci and studio
Year	1597 / 1608
Medium	Fresco
Movement	Baroque
Location	Palazzo Farnese, Rome

Last updated November 23, 2024

The Loves of the Gods is a monumental fresco cycle, completed by the Bolognese artist Annibale Carracci and his studio, in the Farnese Gallery which is located in the west wing of the Palazzo Farnese, now the French Embassy, in Rome. The frescoes were greatly admired at the time, and were later considered to reflect a significant change in painting style away from sixteenth century Mannerism in anticipation of the development of Baroque and Classicism in Rome during the seventeenth century.

Production

Cardinal Odoardo Farnese (cardinal), Pope Paul III's great-great grandson, commissioned Annibale Carracci and his workshop to decorate the barrel-vaulted gallery on the piano nobile of the family palace. Work was started in 1597 and was not entirely finished until 1608, one year before Annibale's death.^[1] His brother Agostino joined him from 1597 to 1600, and other artists in the workshop included Giovanni Lanfranco, Francesco Albani, Domenichino, and Sisto Badalocchio.

Scheme and interpretations

Annibale Carracci had first decorated a small room, the Camerino (1595-7), with scenes from the life of Hercules. The Herculean theme was probably selected because the Farnese Hercules was standing at the time in the Palazzo Farnese.^{[ citation needed ]} This concept of art imitating ancient art seems to have been carried over to the large Gallery. While performing graduate research on the Gallery, Thomas Hoving, later director of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, pointed out many correspondences between the frescoes and items in the famous Farnese Collection of Roman sculpture. Much of the collection is now housed in the Capodimonte Museum and National Archaeological Museum in Naples but, in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, it was arranged according to themes within the Palazzo Farnese. Hoving's suggestion that many details of the frescoes were designed to complement the marbles below has been generally accepted.^[2]

In 1597, Carracci began to decorate the Gallery with scenes depicting the loves of the gods set within frames ( quadri riportati ) and faux bronze medallions painted on an illusionistic architectural framework referred to as quadratura . Ignudi, putti, satyrs, grotesques, and standing Atlas figures (Atlantes) help support the painted framework.

Gian Pietro Bellori, a biographer of seventeenth-century artists and Platonic apologist, called the cycle "Human Love Governed by Celestial Love". This observation was based principally on Carracci's depiction of putti representing Cupid (equated by Bellori with profane love) and Anteros (equated with sacred love) found at the four corners of the vault. For example, Bellori writes:^[3]

The painter wished to represent with various symbols the war and peace between heavenly and common love formulated by Plato. On one side he painted Heavenly Love wrestling with Common Love and pulling him by the hair: this is the philosophy and most sacred law that removes the soul from vice, raising it on high. Accordingly, a crown of immortal laurel is resplendent overhead amid brilliant light, demonstrating that victory over the irrational appetites raises men up to heaven.

Hoving saw it differently. In his memoir, he writes:^[2]

My lucky discovery destroyed the accepted interpretation of Annibale's fresco cycle as a "Neo-Platonic visual essay about celestial love's supremacy over physical passion." The paintings were actually both an entertaining celebration of a bunch of randy Olympians hitting on each other and also an up-scale mind game paying homage to Odoardo's fine antiquities collection.

Scenes on the vault

In addition to the putti shown at the four corners, The Loves of the Gods are depicted on the vault in thirteen narrative scenes. Complementing them, there are twelve medallions painted to appear as bronze reliefs. These medallions portray additional stories of love, abduction, and tragedy. The scenes are arranged as follows:

Central row (from left to right in the accompanying image): Pan and Diana, The Triumph of Bacchus and Ariadne, and Mercury and Paris.

Beginning in the lower left and proceeding counter-clockwise around the vault, the remaining scenes are:

West side (from left to right in the lower portion of the accompanying image): Jupiter and Juno, Marine scene (traditionally The Triumph of Galatea), and Diana and Endymion.
Medallions on the west side (from left to right): Apollo and Marsyas, Boreas and Orithyia, Orpheus and Euridice, and The Rape of Europa.
South side (on the right of the accompanying image): Apollo and Hyacinth above Polyphemus and Galatea.
Medallions on the south side: Possible scene of abduction and Jason and the Golden Fleece.
East side (from right to left in the upper portion of the accompanying image): Hercules and Iole, Aurora and Cephalus, and Venus and Anchises.
Medallions on the east side (from right to left): Hero and Leander, Pan and Syrinx, Salmacis and Hermaphroditus, and Cupid and Pan.
North side (on the left of the accompanying image): The Rape of Ganymede above Polyphemus and Acis.
Medallions on the north side: Judgement of Paris and Pan and Apollo.

The Triumph of Bacchus and Ariadne

Prominently displayed in the center panel, the Triumph of Bacchus and Ariadne depicts a both riotous and classically restrained procession which ferries Bacchus and Ariadne to their lovers' bed. Here, the underlying myth is that Bacchus, the god of wine, had gained the love of the abandoned princess, Ariadne. The procession recalls the triumphs of the Republican and Imperial Roman era, in which the parades of victorious leaders had the laurel-crowned ‘imperator’ in a white chariot with two white horses. In Carracci's procession, the two lovers are seated in chariots drawn by tigers^[4] and goats, and accompanied by a parade of nymphs, bacchanti, and trumpeting satyrs. At the fore, Bacchus' tutor, the paunchy, ugly, and leering drunk Silenus, rides an ass. The figures carefully cavort in order to hide most naked male genitals.^[5]

The program refers to Ovid's Metamorphoses (VIII; lines 160-182) and the spirit alludes to contemporary images voiced, for example, in a carnival song-poem written by Lorenzo de' Medici in about 1475, that entreats:^[6]

Quest’è Bacco ed Arïanna,
belli, e l'un de l'altro ardenti:
perché ’l tempo fugge e inganna,
sempre insieme stan contenti.
Queste ninfe ed altre genti
sono allegre tuttavia.
Chi vuol esser lieto, sia:
di doman non c’è certezza.

Here are Bacchus and Ariadne,
Handsome, and burning for each other:
Because time flees and fools,
They stay together always content.
These nymphs and those others
Are ever full of joy.
Let those who wish to be happy, be:
Of tomorrow, we have no certainty.

Additional scenes

Image	Name	Description
Quadri riportati
	Pan and Diana	Pan seduces Diana with a fleece of white wool as described in Virgil's Georgics (Book 3, Lines 384-393).
	Mercury and Paris	Mercury delivers the apple of discord preceding the judgement of Paris (Ovid's Heroides Book 16, Lines 51 ff).
	Jupiter and Juno	The moment in the Iliad (Book 14, Lines 312-351) when Juno seduces Jupiter to distract him from the Trojan War so that Neptune can aid the Greeks. In a humorous fashion, the mask beneath the scene is shown yawning.
	Triumphant marine scene	Painted by Agostino Carracci, this scene was described by Bellori as the triumph (apotheosis) of the nereid Galatea.^[7] Since then, various scholars have postulated that the central couple represent Neptune and Salacia,^[8] Glaucus and Scylla,^[9] Venus and Triton,^[7] and Peleus and Thetis.^[7]^[9] This scene is the most sexually explicit of the whole series because of the placement of the principal male figure's hand on the pubic region of his companion. It is even more explicit in Agostino's cartoon found in the National Gallery in London. In the cartoon, there is no intervening cloth between his groping hand and her flesh. The scowling head of the principal male is a parody of an ancient bust of Emperor Caracalla which would have been found in a niche in the gallery below.^[7]
	Diana and Endymion	Observed by two hidden amoretti, Diana lovingly caresses the sleeping Endymion.
	Apollo and Hyacinth	Apollo carries his dead lover into the sky (Ovid's Metamorphoses Book 10, Lines 162 ff). Annibale portrays the dead youth clutching a bouquet of hyacinths. Two satyrs sitting on the gilded frame of the Polyphemus picture below lean against this picture's frame to support it.
	Polyphemus and Galatea	The cyclops sings a song declaring his love for the nereid (Metamorphoses 13.728ff). Attended by two other sea nymphs, Galatea is shown as a velificans.
	Hercules and Iole	After murdering Iole's family, Hercules took her as his concubine. In revenge, she overcomes him with feminine guile and convinces him to act in an effeminate fashion (Heroides 9 and Tasso's Jerusalem Delivered Book 16, Verse 3). Annibale portrays a reversal of roles: Hercules is in women's garb playing the tambourine while she holds his club and wears the skin of the Nemean lion.
	Aurora and Cephalus	This scene was painted by Agostino Carracci. Aurora places the unwilling Cephalus into her chariot while her old lover, the decrepit but immortal Tithonus lies on the ground (Metamorphoses 7.700ff).
	Venus and Anchises	The seduction of Anchises by Venus is described in the Homeric Hymn to Aphrodite (Lines 45-199). The inscription GENVS VNDE LATINVM (whence came the Latin race) alludes to their offspring, Aeneas. An erotic print by Agostino (part of his so-called Lascivie series) may have been used as a model for this scene.
	Jupiter and Ganymede	The beautiful youth is shown being abducted by Jupiter's eagle (Metamorphoses 10.152ff). This is the pendant to Apollo and Hyacinth on the opposite side of the hall and is depicted being supported by satyrs in a similar fashion.
	Polyphemus and Acis	In this pendant to Polyphemus and Galatea, the furious cyclops is shown hurling the boulder that kills Galatea's lover Acis (Metamorphoses 13.728ff).
Medallions
	Apollo and Marsyas	Apollo flays Marsyas alive because the satyr had the hubris to believe he could defeat the god in a musical contest (Metamorphoses 6.382ff).
	Boreas and Orithyia	Boreas abducts Orithyia by force, wraps her in a cloud, and rapes her (Metamorphoses 6.382ff).
	Orpheus and Euridice	At the gates of Hades, Orpheus turns around to view his beloved wife and, in doing so, loses her to the underworld (Metamorphoses 10.40-63).
	The rape of Europa	In the guise of a beautiful white bull, Jupiter abducts Europa to Crete (Metamorphoses 2.846-875).
	Hero and Leander	Hero swims across the Hellespont to join his lover. Cupid is shown leading the way. One stormy night, Hero drowns and Leander jumps to her death from the tower (Heroides 18).
	Pan and Syrinx	To save her from the amorous Pan, Syrinx is transformed into a water reed (Metamorphoses 1.689ff).
	Salmacis and Hermaphroditus	As Hermaphroditus is embraced by the Naiad Salmacis, they are merged into one being (Metamorphoses 4.285ff).
	Cupid and Pan	Representing the Virgilian phrase Omnia vincit amor (love conquers all), Cupid is shown subjugating Pan.
	Medallions on North and South sides	The remaining four medallions are placed in an illusionistic fashion behind the portraits of Polyphemus. As such, they are barely visible. On the south side, they portray a possible abduction scene and Jason and the Golden Fleece . On the north side, they portray the Judgement of Paris and Pan and Apollo.

Scenes on the walls

Image	Name	Description
Scenes from mythology
	Perseus and Andromeda	Painted by Annibale Carracci and Domenichino.
	Combat of Perseus and Phineas	Painted by Annibale Carracci and Domenichino.
	Virgin with the Unicorn	Painted by Domenichino.
	Hercules liberates Prometheus by Lanfranco Metamorphosis of Callisto into a Bear Hercules slays the Dragon Diana and Callisto Daedalus and Icarus Mercury and Apollo Arion the Citharist is rescued by Dolphins Minerva and Prometheus	Small scenes.
Cardinal virtues
	Fortitude Temperance Justice Charity
Heraldic shields
	Cardinal Alessandro Farnese Duke Alessandro Farnese Cardinal Odoardo Farnese Duke Ranuccio Farnese

Legacy

Annibale Carracci's decorations in the Farnese Gallery demonstrated a new grand manner of monumental fresco painting.^[11] They exerted a powerful formative influence on both canvas and fresco painting in Rome during the seventeenth century. The dual classicizing and baroque tendencies in this work would fuel the debate by the next generation of fresco painters, between Sacchi and Pietro da Cortona, over the number of figures to be included in a painting.^[12] Carracci's treatment of the composition and the disposition and expression of the figures would influence painters such as Sacchi and Poussin, whereas his effervescent narrative manner influenced Cortona.

Annibale Carracci, in his day, was seen as one of the key painters to revive the classical style. In contrast, a few years later, artists such as Caravaggio and his followers would rebel against representing spatial depth in colour and light, and introduce tenebrous dramatic realism into their art instead. But it would be inappropriate to view Annibale Carracci as solely the continuation of an inherited tradition; in his day, his vigorous and dynamic style, and that of his studio assistants, changed the pre-eminent style of painting in Rome. His work would have been seen as liberating for artists of his day, touching on pagan themes with an unconstrained joy. It could be said that while Mannerism had mastered the art of formal strained contraposto and contorsion; Annibale Carracci had depicted dance and joy.

Later followers of Neoclassic formalism and severity frowned on the excesses of Annibale Carracci, but in his day, he would have been seen as masterful in achieving the supreme approximation to classic beauty in the tradition of Raphael and Giulio Romano's secular frescoes in the Loggia of the Villa Farnesina.^[13] Unlike Raphael, though, his figures can display a Michelangelo-esque muscularity, and depart from the often emotionless visages of High Renaissance painting.^[14]

Related Research Articles

Agostino Carracci was an Italian painter, printmaker, tapestry designer, and art teacher. He was, together with his brother, Annibale Carracci, and cousin, Ludovico Carracci, one of the founders of the Accademia degli Incamminati in Bologna. Intended to devise alternatives to the Mannerist style favored in the preceding decades, this teaching academy helped propel painters of the School of Bologna to prominence.

Annibale Carracci was an Italian painter and instructor, active in Bologna and later in Rome. Along with his brother and cousin, Annibale was one of the progenitors, if not founders of a leading strand of the Baroque style, borrowing from styles from both north and south of their native city, and aspiring for a return to classical monumentality, but adding a more vital dynamism. Painters working under Annibale at the gallery of the Palazzo Farnese would be highly influential in Roman painting for decades.

Palazzo Farnese or Farnese Palace is one of the most important High Renaissance palaces in Rome. Owned by the Italian Republic, it was given to the French government in 1936 for a period of 99 years, and currently serves as the French embassy in Italy.

Guido Reni was an Italian Baroque painter, although his works showed a classical manner, similar to Simon Vouet, Nicolas Poussin, and Philippe de Champaigne. He painted primarily religious works, but also mythological and allegorical subjects. Active in Rome, Naples, and his native Bologna, he became the dominant figure in the Bolognese School that emerged under the influence of the Carracci.

LudovicoCarracci was an Italian, early-Baroque painter, etcher, and printmaker born in Bologna. His works are characterized by a strong mood invoked by broad gestures and flickering light that create spiritual emotion and are credited with reinvigorating Italian art, especially fresco art, which was subsumed with formalistic Mannerism. He died in Bologna in 1619.

Domenico Zampieri, known by the diminutive Domenichino after his shortness, was an Italian Baroque painter of the Bolognese School of painters.

Francesco Albani or Albano was an Italian Baroque painter of Albanian origin who was active in Bologna, Rome, Viterbo (1609–1610), Mantua (1621–1622) and Florence (1633).

Odoardo Farnese was an Italian nobleman, the second son of Alessandro Farnese, Duke of Parma and Maria of Portugal, known for his patronage of the arts. He became a Cardinal of the Roman Catholic Church in 1591, and briefly acted as regent of the Duchy of Parma and Piacenza for his nephew Odoardo from 1622 to 1626.

Antonio Marziale Carracci was an Italian painter. He was the natural son of Agostino Carracci.

Giovanni Lanfranco was an Italian Baroque painter.

Carlo Maratta or Maratti was an Italian Baroque painter, active mostly in Rome, and known principally for his classicizing paintings executed in a Late Baroque Classical manner. Although he is part of the classical tradition stemming from Raphael, he was not exempt from the influence of Baroque painting and particularly in his use of colour. His contemporary and friend, Giovanni Bellori, wrote an early biography on Maratta.

The Palazzo Pallavicini-Rospigliosi is a palace in Rome, Italy. It was built by the Borghese family on the Quirinal Hill; its footprint occupies the site where the ruins of the baths of Constantine stood, whose remains still are part of the basement of the main building, the Casino dell'Aurora. Its first inhabitant was the famed art collector Cardinal Scipione Borghese, the nephew of Pope Paul V, who wanted to be housed near the large papal Palazzo Quirinale. The palace and garden of the Pallavicini-Rospigliosi were the product of the accumulated sites and were designed by Giovanni Vasanzio and Carlo Maderno in 1611–16. Scipione owned this site for less than a decade, 1610–16, and commissioned the construction and decoration of the casino and pergolata, facing the garden of Montecavallo. The Roman palace of this name should not be mistaken for the panoramic Villa Pallavicino on the shores of Lake Como in Lombardy. The Palace has also been the scene of important cultural and religious events. On June 6, 1977 Princess Elvina Pallavicini invited in Palazzo Pallavicini Rospigliosi the archbishop monsignor Marcel Lefebvre for a conference on the Second Vatican Council and for the celebration of a Traditiona Mass, under the careful direction of the marquis Roberto Malvezzi, and Frigate Captain marquis Luigi Coda Nunziante di San Ferdinando. Many members of Alleanza Cattolica, the baron Roberto de Mattei, the pharmacologist Giulio Soldani, the sociologist Massimo Introvigne, the psychiatrist Mario Di Fiorino and Attilio Tamburrini and his brother Renato Tamburrini took part to the event.

Italian Baroque art was a very prominent part of the Baroque art in painting, sculpture and other media, made in a period extending from the end of the sixteenth to the mid eighteenth centuries. The movement began in Italy, and despite later currents in the directions of classicism, the Rococo, Italy remained a stronghold thoughout the period, with many Italian artists taking Baroque style to other parts of Europe. Italian Baroque architecture is not covered.

The Carracci were a Bolognese family of artists that played an instrumental role in bringing forth the Baroque style in painting. Brothers Annibale (1560–1609) and Agostino (1557–1602) along with their cousin Ludovico (1555–1619) worked collaboratively. The Carracci family left their legacy in art theory by starting a school for artists in 1582. The school was called the Accademia degli Incamminati, and its main focus was to oppose and challenge Mannerist artistic practices and principles in order to create a renewed art of naturalism and expressive persuasion.

Giovanni Battista Agucchi was an Italian churchman, Papal diplomat and writer on art theory. He was the nephew and brother of cardinals, and might have been one himself if he had lived longer. He served as secretary to the Papal Secretary of State, then the Pope himself, on whose death Agucchi was made a titular bishop and appointed as nuncio to Venice.

Sleeping Venus is a c. 1603 painting by Annibale Carracci held by the Musée Condé in Chantilly, Oise, France. This oil painting measures 190x328cm. It depicts Venus sleeping with her arm above her head as putti frolic around her. Carracci painted Sleeping Venus for Odoardo Farnese. Giovanni Battista Agucchi wrote an ekphrasis of this painting that Carlo Cesare Malvasia included in his book Life of the Carracci. In The Lives of the Modern Painters, Sculptors and Architects, Giovanni Pietro Bellori wrote a description of the painting that paraphrases Agucchi's ekphrasis without citation.

L'Aurora (Aurora) is a large Baroque ceiling fresco painted in 1614 by Guido Reni for the Casino, or garden house, adjacent to the Palazzo Pallavicini-Rospigliosi, in Rome. The work is considered Reni's fresco masterpiece.

Pietà is a c. 1600 oil on canvas painting by Annibale Carracci, the earliest surviving work by him on the subject, which was commissioned by Odoardo Farnese. It moved from Rome to Parma to Naples as part of the Farnese collection and is now in the National Museum of Capodimonte in Naples. It is one of many 16th century Bolognese paintings dedicated to the theme of the Pietà, and it is counted among Carracci's masterpieces.

The Assumption of the Virgin by Annibale Carracci is the altarpiece of the famous Cerasi Chapel in the church of Santa Maria del Popolo in Rome. The large panel painting was created in 1600–1601. The artwork is somewhat overshadowed by the two more famous paintings of Caravaggio on the side walls of the chapel: The Conversion of Saint Paul on the Road to Damascus and The Crucifixion of Saint Peter. Both painters were important in the development of Baroque art but the contrast is striking: Carracci's Virgin glows with even light and radiates harmony, while the paintings of Caravaggio are dramatically lit and foreshortened.

Christ Crowned with Thorns or Christ Mocked is a 1598–1600 oil on canvas painting by Annibale Carracci, now at the Pinacoteca Nazionale di Bologna.

References

↑ When the Farnese frescoes were nearly complete, Cardinal Odoardo paid him an insultingly small sum of 500 scudi d'oro or pieces of gold which were brought to his room on a saucer. Annibale, physically exhausted after his work on the vault and profoundly upset by his brother Agostino's defection, reacted sharply to his patron's callous and ungrateful behavior and fell into a state of depression, lasting until his death in 1609.
1 2 Hoving, Thomas (26 May 2009). "Artful Tom, A Memoir, Chapter 20. Master and Doctor". Artnet. Retrieved February 6, 2018.
↑ Bellori, Giovan Pietro (21 November 2005). Wohl, Hellmut (ed.). Giovan Pietro Bellori: The Lives of the Modern Painters, Sculptors and Architects: A New Translation and Critical Edition. Translated by Wohl, Alice Sedgwick. Cambridge University Press. p. 84. ISBN 0521781876.
↑ "Io Triumpe – Greeting a God". Trionfi.com. Retrieved December 5, 2017.
↑ The painter's cousin Ludovico Carracci engraved uncensored versions in prints of the scenes.^{[ citation needed ]} Also, in contrast to the ceiling's intimation rather than outright depiction of mythological lovemaking, there are erotic engravings by the painter's brother Agostino – the Lascivie.
↑ "Triumph of Bacchus and Ariadne". Trionfi.com. Retrieved December 5, 2017.
1 2 3 4 Dempsey 1995, p. 56.
↑ Reinach, Salomon; Simmonds, Florence (1904). The Story of Art Throughout the Ages: An Illustrated Record. New York: C. Scribner's Sons. p. 217.
1 2 Turner, Nicholas (2001). European Drawings 4: Catalogue of the Collections. Los Angeles: Getty Publications. p. 32. ISBN 0892365846.
↑ "Carracci's Ceiling of the Farnese Palace". Smarthistory at Khan Academy. Retrieved February 7, 2018.
↑ Wittkower, Rudolf. Art and Architecture in Italy 1600–1750, Pelican History of Art, 1985 edn., p. 57.
↑ This debate took place at the Accademia di San Luca , the guild for artists in Rome; see the article on Andrea Sacchi for more discussion.
↑ The Villa Farnesina was acquired by the same family, but built earlier for Agostino Chigi at the foot of the Janiculum Hill.
↑ It has been said that Carracci and his school blended Venetian colorism with the Florentine-Umbrian attention to drawing and design; yet this is best seen in the oil canvases rather than the frescoes in the Farnese.

External links

A paraphrased copy decorates the ceiling of the Blue Drawing Room at West Wycombe Park in England.

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.

[1] When the Farnese frescoes were nearly complete, Cardinal Odoardo paid him an insultingly small sum of 500 scudi d'oro or pieces of gold which were brought to his room on a saucer. Annibale, physically exhausted after his work on the vault and profoundly upset by his brother Agostino's defection, reacted sharply to his patron's callous and ungrateful behavior and fell into a state of depression, lasting until his death in 1609.

[hoving-2] 1 2 Hoving, Thomas (26 May 2009). "Artful Tom, A Memoir, Chapter 20. Master and Doctor". Artnet. Retrieved February 6, 2018.

[bellori-3] Bellori, Giovan Pietro (21 November 2005). Wohl, Hellmut (ed.). Giovan Pietro Bellori: The Lives of the Modern Painters, Sculptors and Architects: A New Translation and Critical Edition. Translated by Wohl, Alice Sedgwick. Cambridge University Press. p. 84. ISBN 0521781876.

[4] "Io Triumpe – Greeting a God". Trionfi.com. Retrieved December 5, 2017.

[5] The painter's cousin Ludovico Carracci engraved uncensored versions in prints of the scenes.^{[ citation needed ]} Also, in contrast to the ceiling's intimation rather than outright depiction of mythological lovemaking, there are erotic engravings by the painter's brother Agostino – the Lascivie.

[6] "Triumph of Bacchus and Ariadne". Trionfi.com. Retrieved December 5, 2017.

[FOOTNOTEDempsey199556-7] 1 2 3 4 Dempsey 1995, p. 56.

[8] Reinach, Salomon; Simmonds, Florence (1904). The Story of Art Throughout the Ages: An Illustrated Record. New York: C. Scribner's Sons. p. 217.

[turner-9] 1 2 Turner, Nicholas (2001). European Drawings 4: Catalogue of the Collections. Los Angeles: Getty Publications. p. 32. ISBN 0892365846.

[smarth-10] "Carracci's Ceiling of the Farnese Palace". Smarthistory at Khan Academy. Retrieved February 7, 2018.

[11] Wittkower, Rudolf. Art and Architecture in Italy 1600–1750, Pelican History of Art, 1985 edn., p. 57.

[12] This debate took place at the Accademia di San Luca , the guild for artists in Rome; see the article on Andrea Sacchi for more discussion.

[13] The Villa Farnesina was acquired by the same family, but built earlier for Agostino Chigi at the foot of the Janiculum Hill.

[14] It has been said that Carracci and his school blended Venetian colorism with the Florentine-Umbrian attention to drawing and design; yet this is best seen in the oil canvases rather than the frescoes in the Farnese.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[12]

[13]

[14]