Thomas Welsby Clark

Last updated

Thomas Welsby Clark
Thomas Welsby Clark in 1940.jpg
Clark in 1940, as an Ordinary Seaman on HMAS St Giles
Born(1920-01-28)28 January 1920
Brisbane, Queensland, Australia
Diedc. 19 November 1941(1941-11-19) (aged 21)
HMAS Sydney, Indian Ocean
Cause of death Killed in action
Body discovered6 February 1942, off Christmas Island
OccupationSailor
Known forOnly body recovered from sinking of HMAS Sydney; previously unidentified decedent

Thomas Welsby Clark was a sailor in the Royal Australian Navy (RAN), whose body was found on a life raft in the Indian Ocean, near Christmas Island, on 6 February 1942.

Contents

Before his body was identified, he was widely believed to originate from the RAN cruiser HMAS Sydney, which sank off Western Australia in November 1941 after a battle with the German auxiliary cruiser Kormoran . While 318 of 399 Kormoran personnel survived, all 645 members of the Sydney crew were lost. Clark was formally identified by DNA analysis in 2021, and the RAN publicly released his identity on 19 November 2021, the 80th anniversary of the battle.

Background

Clark was born in Brisbane on 28 January 1920. He enlisted in the Royal Australian Navy on 23 August 1940, and was trained as a submarine detector at HMAS Cerberus and on HMAS St Giles. Clark joined Sydney's crew on 19 August 1941, and was promoted to Able Seaman several days later. He was newly engaged at the time of Sydney's sinking. [1] [2]

His body was found on 6 February 1942. It is reported that an inquest was held on Christmas Island, soon afterwards. His remains were buried with military honours, in an unmarked grave, in the Old European Cemetery on the island. At the Battle of Christmas Island on 31 March 1942, Japanese forces captured the island. They remained in control of the island until 1945. Records relating to the inquest were lost or destroyed during the occupation.

Witnesses on Christmas Island believed that the float and sailor had come from Sydney. [3] A RAN investigation after the war included attempts by those who wrote the lost records of the inquest to reconstruct them. This investigation determined it was possible the body was a member of the RAN. [4] Christmas Island's assistant harbour master, Captain E. Craig, stated that "the Carley float was typical of those in service with the RN and RAN". [4] A government inquiry concluded "on the balance of probability, that the body and the carley float ... were most likely from HMAS Sydney." [5]

An archaeological team commissioned by the RAN recovered the body in 2006. A DNA profile and other data about the individual's background were recovered. The remains were then reburied, in the closest Australian war cemetery to the wreck of Sydney, at Geraldton. Due to items found with the body, including clothing, it was considered most likely that he had been an engineering officer or NCO. [6] By 2014 a process of elimination had established that no more than 50 members of the crew could have been the man on the Carley float. [7]

In 2019 it was incorrectly reported by news media that Norman Douglas Foster was most likely to be the Sydney crew member in question. [8] Foster, who was 28 years old at the time of Sydney's sinking, was an Engine Room Artificer, 4th Class (a rank equivalent to Petty Officer). [9]

Discovery of the body

During the late afternoon of 6 February 1942, 79 days after Sydney sank, lookouts on Christmas Island spotted an object out at sea. [10] Initially thought to be a Japanese submarine, closer inspection from a pilot boat found it was a Carley float with a dead person inside. The float was then towed ashore. [10] With the island at risk of invasion, the deceased was quickly examined by the harbour master, the medical officer and the man in charge of the radio station. The body was buried in an unmarked grave near Flying Fish Cove. [11] [12] The examiners wrote reports that were later destroyed when Japanese forces occupied Christmas Island. They would later recreate these reports from memory. [12] [13] An inquest was not convened until mid-February and had not concluded when evacuation began on 17 February in anticipation of Japanese forces occupying the island on 23 March. It is unknown if the doctor on Christmas Island had performed an autopsy as no report of him doing so was found. [14]

Initial investigations and research

A preliminary examination in 1942 by the island's medical officer, Dr J. Scott Clark, found that the deceased was a tall young adult male caucasoid. [15] The remains were partly decomposed, the eyes, nose and all of the flesh from the right arm were missing and believed to have been consumed by fish or birds. [16] According to the Harbour Master, Captain J. R. Smith, the body was clothed in a blue boilersuit which had been bleached white by exposure, with four plain press studs from neck to waist. [16] However, J. C. Baker, who was in charge of the radio station at Christmas Island, stated that the boilersuit was white. [14] The body was not carrying dog tags or personal effects.

A shoe was found beside the body, which Clark did not believe belonged to the dead man. [10] Later recollections of the shoe varied with Clark stating that it was "probably branded "CROWN BRAND PTY 4", although he had some doubts about "CROWN" and "4". Captain Smith recalled a canvas shoe of a brand named "McCOWAN PTY" or "McEWAN PTY", which carried symbols representing a crown and/or a broad arrow. A sergeant with the party who recovered the raft later contradicted the finding of a shoe, instead stating that a 'pair of boots' were found on the raft. [17]

In Smith's opinion, the life raft was a naval Carley float, which had come from Sydney. [3] The wooden decking was manufactured and branded with the word "PATENT" while the metal framework was branded "LYSAGHT DUA-ANNEAL ZINC. MADE IN AUSTRALIA" inside. [18] The float had been damaged by gun or shellfire, with shrapnel embedded in the outer covering. The underside was covered with barnacles and other marine growth, indicating that it had been at sea for some time. [3]

On 23 April 1949, the Director of Naval Intelligence wrote to the Director of Victualling (DNV) asking if the uniform worn by the dead man and the Carley float were consistent with the crew and equipment of Sydney. The DNV replied that while boilersuits with press studs had not been issued by the RAN at the time, officers could purchase their own boilersuits, usually white or brown, with press studs. The Navy issue boilersuits worn by ratings were blue, but did not have press studs. The DNV also stated that the shoes could "definitely" have been of RAN issue, especially if they were leather rather than canvas. There is no record of a reply regarding the Carley float. [19]

Controversy regarding raft

The RAN claimed[ when? ] that the covering of the Carley float did not match those used by Australian warships and thus could not have come from Sydney. The historian Tom Frame was also sceptical about the raft and believed that its connections to Sydney were circumstantial. For many years, other authors, such as historian Barbara Winter (1984) and independent researcher Wes Olson (2000), disputed the official view put forward by the RAN. According to Olson, it was unclear how the RAN decided that the float cover was anomalous, as accounts of the float were often vague and contradictory. [4] Olson said that the only detail of the covering in witness descriptions appeared to be that it was grey. [20] Winter suggested that the currents of the Indian Ocean would have propelled a Carley float launched at the location and time of the battle to arrive in the vicinity of Christmas Island at around the time of its discovery. [11] Olson stated that the rope used on the float and markings on the float were of naval origin. He also believed the descriptions of marine growth on the float matched the period that a float from Sydney would have been in the water. [21] In 2000, Olson claimed that evidence presented at the 1998 inquiry had changed Frame's mind. [13] [4]

Investigations since 1998

Recovery of the body

The 1998 Joint Standing Committee for Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade inquiry into the loss of Sydney recommended that attempts be made to find the grave, in order to exhume the body and acquire DNA for comparison with the next of kin of the crew of Sydney. This would determine if the unknown sailor was from the cruiser. [22] The RAN searched the graveyard during August and September 2001 to no avail until a second search in October 2006 found the body. [23] [24] The body was found in an unusually-shaped coffin, which appeared to have been constructed around it as the body was buried "with legs doubled under at the knee." That was same position it had been in when found on the raft, possibly due to mummification. Press studs and small fragments of clothing were found in the coffin. [25] Following an autopsy and sampling from the body for identification, the remains of the still unknown sailor were reburied in the Commonwealth War Graves section in the Geraldton Cemetery in Western Australia with full military honours on 19 November 2008. [26] [27]

Autopsy and subsequent research

Brain trauma caused by a shell fragment of German origin was identified as the cause of death. [28] [29] Bruce Billson (the Minister Assisting the Minister for Defence) reported that a piece of shrapnel struck the front of the skull and lodged in the left forehead. On first examination, it was thought that the fragment might have been a bullet but this hypothesis was later rejected. In addition to this injury, the pathologist identified a second major skull injury of bone loss on the left side, above and behind the left earhole. This injury was believed to have occurred around the time of death. The analysis also identified multiple rib fractures, but it is unknown whether these occurred around the time of death or long after death with the settling of the grave. No other shrapnel or projectiles have been found elsewhere in the remains. [29]

The fragment was found embedded in the man's skull during an autopsy in 2006. Anatomical analysis indicated that the unknown sailor was aged between 22 and 31 when he died, was right-handed, had size 11 feet and was tall for his generation, between 168.2 and 187.8 centimetres (5 ft 6.2 in and 6 ft 1.9 in). Bone isotope analysis showed that he had lived in eastern Australia, probably New South Wales or Queensland, before enlistment and may have grown up on the coast. The unknown sailor had acquired an unusual feature in both ankle joints, known as squatting facets. These indicated that he was more used to squatting than sitting on chairs. [25] As squatting was unusual at the time in urban western communities, it was speculated that the man had spent significant time in a rural area of Australia, amongst members of an ethnic group in which squatting was more common than sitting (such as people from Asia or Eastern Europe), and/or involved in a sporting or similar activity that required the ankles to be flexed towards the back of the thighs for prolonged periods. [30]

Attempts to extract a DNA profile from the remains began around 2009, although the results were not published before the bone analysis. [31] Analysis of the partial genetic profile recovered suggested that the man had red hair, blue eyes and pale skin, and was likely of Irish or Scottish descent. He belonged to a mitochondrial haplogroup (i.e. an ancient matrilineal line of descent) known as haplogroup J1c12. This relatively rare haplogroup has most often been found in people with matrilineal ancestors from various parts of Europe, the Caucasus or Middle East.

The boilersuit and shoe found with the body were, according to evidence provided by the Australian War Memorial, available to ship's officers, commissioned warrant officers, and warrant officers senior enough to have a watch keeping certificate. [6] Tests on the remains of the boilersuit showed that the fabric had never been dyed, was probably white and the press studs were of a type manufactured by Carr Australia Pty Ltd in the 1930s and 1940s. RAN Dress Regulations published in the Navy List of December 1940 do not mention white boilersuits.[ citation needed ] There is evidence that during the period, boilersuits were a popular working dress among RAN personnel. Many RAN engineer officers wore white boilersuits most of the time and other officers, commissioned warrant officers and warrant officers also wore them. Two former RAN officers recalled being issued with a white boilersuit twice a year, that these were fastened with four or five press studs and that some had press studs at the wrist, while others did not. Dress regulations for December 1940 state that RAN personnel on "foreign" (tropical) stations were issued with a pair of white canvas shoes to be worn only on those stations. While veterans did not recall being issued with them or seeing them worn, photographs of RAN personnel from the period show some of them wearing white canvas shoes.[ citation needed ]

By 2014, the identity of the unknown sailor had been narrowed down to 50 members of the crew of Sydney. [7] It had previously been reported in 2007 that the unknown sailor was most likely one of three engineering officers. [32]

Erroneous identification

In August 2019, it was reported by media outlets including Channel 7 News and The West Australian, that the Sydney crew member most likely to have been buried on Christmas Island was Norman Douglas Foster. However this was not confirmed by official sources. [8] Foster (service no. F2147), was an Engine Room Artificer (4th Class); a rank equivalent to Petty Officer. He was born in Perth on 15 April 1913, making him 28 years old at the time of Sydney being lost. [9]

Foster's service record describes him as 5 ft 83⁄4 in (174 cm) tall, with auburn hair, blue eyes and a fair complexion. He had joined the RAN on 2 September 1939 (the day before the war began). After training at HMAS Cerberus, Foster had joined the crew of Sydney on 20 February 1941. [33]

Formal identification

In 2021, DNA testing identified the remains as those of Clark. The identity was revealed at the Australian War Memorial on 19 November 2021, the 80th anniversary of the battle. [1] [34] [2] Clark is the only member of Sydney's crew known to have reached a life raft. [1]

See also

Related Research Articles

German auxiliary cruiser <i>Kormoran</i> Kriegsmarine merchant raider of World War II

The German auxiliary cruiser Kormoran (HSK-8) was a Kriegsmarine merchant raider of World War II. Originally the merchant vessel Steiermark, the ship was acquired by the navy following the outbreak of war for conversion into a raider. Administered under the designation Schiff 41, to the Allied navies she was known as Raider G. The largest merchant raider operated by Germany during World War II, Kormoran was responsible for the destruction of 10 merchant vessels and the capture of an 11th during her year-long career in the Atlantic and Indian oceans.

HMAS <i>AE1</i> E-class submarine of the Royal Australian Navy

HMAS AE1 was an E-class submarine of the Royal Australian Navy (RAN). She was the first submarine to serve in the RAN, and sank with all hands near what is now East New Britain, Papua New Guinea, on 14 September 1914, after less than seven months in service. Search missions attempting to locate the wreck began in 1976. The submarine was found during the 13th search mission near the Duke of York Islands in December 2017.

HMAS <i>Onslow</i> Royal Australian Navy submarine (1969–1999)

HMAS Onslow is one of six Oberon-class submarines, previously operated by the Royal Australian Navy (RAN). The submarine was named after the town of Onslow, Western Australia, and Sir Alexander Onslow, with the boat's motto and badge derived from Onslow's family heritage. Ordered in 1963, Onslow was laid down at the end of 1967 by Scotts Shipbuilding and Engineering Company in Scotland, launched almost a year later, and commissioned into the RAN at the end of 1969.

HMAS <i>Sydney</i> (D48) Modified Leander-class cruiser of the Australian Navy

HMAS Sydney, named for the Australian city of Sydney, was one of three modified Leander-class light cruisers operated by the Royal Australian Navy (RAN). Ordered for the Royal Navy as HMS Phaeton, the cruiser was purchased by the Australian government and renamed prior to her 1934 launch.

HMAS <i>Canberra</i> (D33) Australian heavy cruiser (1928-1943)

HMAS Canberra (I33/D33), named after the Australian capital city of Canberra, was a Royal Australian Navy (RAN) heavy cruiser of the Kent sub-class of County-class cruisers. Constructed in Scotland during the mid-1920s, the ship was commissioned in 1928, and spent the first part of her career primarily operating in Australian waters, with some deployments to the China Station.

Sinking of HMAS <i>Sydney</i> 1941 naval battle during World War II

On 19 November 1941, the Australian light cruiser HMAS Sydney and the German auxiliary cruiser Kormoran engaged each other in a battle off the coast of Western Australia. Sydney, with Captain Joseph Burnett commanding, and Kormoran, under Fregattenkapitän Theodor Detmers, encountered each other approximately 106 nautical miles off Dirk Hartog Island. The single-ship action lasted half an hour, and both ships were destroyed.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Teddy Sheean</span> Royal Australian Navy sailor

Edward "Teddy" Sheean, was a sailor in the Royal Australian Navy during the Second World War. Born in Tasmania, Sheean was employed as a farm labourer when he enlisted in the Royal Australian Naval Reserve in April 1941. Following training at HMAS Derwent and the Flinders Naval Depot, he was posted to Sydney, where he joined the newly commissioned corvette HMAS Armidale in June 1942. Sheean served aboard Armidale as she took part in escort duties along the eastern Australian coast and in New Guinea waters. In October he transferred with the ship to Darwin, where Armidale was tasked with assisting Australian operations in Timor.

HMAS <i>Armidale</i> (J240) Bathurst-class corvette

HMAS Armidale (J240), named for the then town of Armidale, New South Wales, was one of 60 Bathurst-class corvettes constructed during World War II, and one of 36 initially manned and commissioned solely by the Royal Australian Navy (RAN).

HMAS <i>Patricia Cam</i>

HMAS Patricia Cam was an auxiliary vessel operated by the Royal Australian Navy during World War II. She was sunk by a Japanese aircraft in 1943.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">No. 101 Flight RAAF</span> Military unit

No. 101 Flight RAAF was a Royal Australian Air Force fleet co-operation flight equipped with amphibian aircraft. The flight was formed on 1 July 1925, and operated from the Royal Australian Navy seaplane tender HMAS Albatross between 1929 and 1933. After Albatross paid off the flight's aircraft operated from the RAN's heavy cruisers HMAS Australia and HMAS Canberra. No. 101 Flight was expanded to form No. 5 Squadron on 20 April 1936.

Search for HMAS <i>Sydney</i> and German auxiliary cruiser <i>Kormoran</i>

Numerous attempts were made to find the Australian cruiser HMAS Sydney and the German auxiliary cruiser Kormoran, which were both lost in a sea battle in 1941. Efforts immediately after the battle focused on finding Sydney when she failed to return to port. While searchers located over 300 survivors from Kormoran, none of the 645 aboard the Australian warship were found. In March 2008, shipwreck hunter David Mearns commenced a search for the two wrecks. Kormoran was located on 12 March in close proximity to the sinking position given in German accounts. Using the survivor's information on Sydney's last known heading, Mearns and his search team located Sydney on 17 March.

The Melbourne–Voyager collision, also known as the Melbourne–Voyager incident or simply the Voyager incident, was a collision between two warships of the Royal Australian Navy (RAN); the aircraft carrier HMAS Melbourne and the destroyer HMAS Voyager.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bradleys Head Fortification Complex</span> Historic site in New South Wales, Australia

The Bradleys Head Fortification Complex is a heritage-listed former mast and defensive battery and military fortification and now war memorial and recreational area located at Bradleys Head Road within the Sydney Harbour National Park in the Sydney suburb of Mosman, New South Wales, Australia. It was designed by Government engineers and built from 1840 to 1934. It is also known as Bradleys Head Forts and HMAS Sydney 1 Mast and Associated Memorials. The property is owned by the NSW Office of Environment and Heritage, an agency of the Government of New South Wales. It was added to the New South Wales State Heritage Register on 30 August 2010.

HMAS <i>Matafele</i>

HMAS Matafele was a small cargo and passenger vessel which was operated by Burns Philp from 1938 to 1942 and the Royal Australian Navy (RAN) from 1943 until she was lost with all of her crew as a result of an accident in June 1944.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Joseph Burnett</span> Royal Australian Navy officer (1899–1941)

Joseph Burnett was a Royal Australian Navy (RAN) officer most widely known as the captain of the light cruiser HMAS Sydney in the battle between HMAS Sydney and HSK Kormoran on 19 November 1941. He fought in both the First World War and Second World War, serving in the RAN and the Royal Navy (RN), and went down with the Sydney off the coast of Western Australia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Carley float</span> Liferaft design

The Carley float was a form of invertible liferaft designed by American inventor Horace Carley (1838–1918). Supplied mainly to warships, it saw widespread use in a number of navies during peacetime and both World Wars until superseded by more modern rigid or inflatable designs. Carley was awarded a patent in 1903 after establishing the Carley Life Float Company of Philadelphia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Otto Becher</span> Senior officer in the Royal Australian Navy

Rear Admiral Otto Humphrey Becher, & Bar was a senior officer in the Royal Australian Navy (RAN). Born in Harvey, Western Australia, Becher entered the Royal Australian Naval College in 1922. After graduating in 1926, he was posted to a series of staff and training positions prior to specialising in gunnery.

SIEV 36 was a vessel from Indonesia that exploded and sank off Ashmore Reef, Australia on 16 April 2009. The vessel, carrying 47 refugees and two crew, was intercepted by the Royal Australian Navy patrol boat HMAS Albany early on 15 April. A boarding party secured the vessel, but failed to locate two canisters of petrol. Although it was intended to take the crew and passengers to Christmas Island for processing, a notice informing the crew that their vessel may be returned to Indonesia was presented, and the passengers were kept in the dark about their destination. While waiting for transportation to arrive, Albany and SIEV 36 sailed in a holding pattern, with the Indonesian boat taken in tow overnight. A second patrol boat, HMAS Childers, arrived that evening, and was directed to provide a boarding party and take care of the vessel starting at 06:00 on 16 April.

The Slamat disaster is a succession of three related shipwrecks during the Battle of Greece on 27 April 1941. The Dutch troopship Slamat and the Royal Navy destroyers HMS Diamond and HMS Wryneck sank as a result of air attacks by Luftwaffe Junkers Ju 87 dive bombers. The three ships sank off the east coast of the Peloponnese during Operation Demon, which was the evacuation of British, Australian and New Zealand troops from Greece after their defeat by invading German and Italian forces.

Wesley John Olson, known as Wes Olson, is an independent researcher and author based in Perth, the capital of Western Australia. His work has concentrated on Australian military history during both World Wars.

References

  1. 1 2 3 Midena 2021.
  2. 1 2 Swinden 2021.
  3. 1 2 3 Olson 2000, p. 329.
  4. 1 2 3 4 Olson 2000, p. 330.
  5. ↑ Joint Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade 1999, p. 118.
  6. 1 2 Cole 2009, pp. 346–351, volume 2.
  7. 1 2 Brodie 2014.
  8. 1 2 Quekett 2019.
  9. 1 2 Department of Veterans' Affairs 2024.
  10. 1 2 3 Olson 2000, p. 328.
  11. 1 2 Winter 1984, p. 241.
  12. 1 2 Cole 2009, pp. 324–6, volume 2.
  13. 1 2 Frame 1993, p. 203.
  14. 1 2 Cole 2009, pp. 323–7, volume 2.
  15. ↑ Chase 2006.
  16. 1 2 Olson 2000, pp. 328–9.
  17. ↑ Cole 2009, p. 328, volume 2.
  18. ↑ Cole 2009, pp. 325–326, volume 2.
  19. ↑ Cole 2009, p. 327.
  20. ↑ Olson 2000, pp. 329–30.
  21. ↑ Olson 2000, pp. 331–2.
  22. ↑ Cole 2009, pp. 331–2, volume 2.
  23. ↑ Mearns 2009, p. 112.
  24. ↑ Cole 2009, p. 332, volume 2.
  25. 1 2 Cole 2009, pp. 335–6, volume 2.
  26. ↑ Mearns 2009, p. 238.
  27. ↑ Cole 2009, p. 323, volume 2.
  28. ↑ Cole 2009, pp. 336–9, volume 2.
  29. 1 2 Billson 2007.
  30. ↑ Swinden 2009, p. 11.
  31. ↑ Cole 2009, p. 356, volume 2.
  32. ↑ Gilmore & Walker 2007.
  33. ↑ National Archives of Australia 2024.
  34. ↑ Gee 2021.

Sources

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.