1991 British Columbia general election

Last updated

1991 British Columbia general election
Flag of British Columbia.svg
  1986 October 17, 1991 1996  

75 seats of the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia
38 seats were needed for a majority
Turnout64.03% [1] Decrease2.svg 1.77 pp
 First partySecond partyThird party
  Mike Harcourt.jpg
BCL
SC
Leader Mike Harcourt Gordon Wilson Rita Johnston
Party New Democratic Liberal Social Credit
Leader since198719871991
Leader's seat Vancouver-Mount Pleasant Powell River-Sunshine Coast Surrey-Newton (lost re-election)
Last election22 seats0 seats47 seats
Seats won51177
Seat changeIncrease2.svg29Increase2.svg17Decrease2.svg40
Popular vote595,391486,208351,660
Percentage40.71%33.2524.27
SwingDecrease2.svg1.89Increase2.svg26.51Decrease2.svg25.27

BC Legislature 1991.svg

Premier before election

Rita Johnston
Social Credit

Premier after election

Mike Harcourt
New Democratic

The 1991 British Columbia general election was the 35th provincial election in the Province of British Columbia, Canada. It was held to elect members of the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia. The election was called on September 19, 1991, and held on October 17, 1991. The incumbent Social Credit Party of British Columbia, which had been beset by scandals during Bill Vander Zalm's only term as premier, was defeated by the New Democratic Party of Mike Harcourt. Liberal Party leader Gordon Wilson surprised observers by leading his party to winning one-third of the votes cast, and forming the official opposition in the legislature after having held no seats at all since 1979. The new legislature met for the first time on March 17, 1992.

Contents

The election was held at the same time as a referendum on recall and initiative. [2] It was also the first British Columbia general election with only single-member districts. [3]

Background

Under Vander Zalm's leadership, Socred's control shifted from urban fiscal conservatives to social conservatives. Vander Zalm seemingly cruised to victory in the 1986 provincial election, held just a month after he was sworn in. In truth, however, a number of more moderate Socreds were not at home with the party's rightward turn on social issues, and began defecting to the Liberals.

This process was exacerbated by Vander Zalm's eccentricity, and the constant scandals that plagued his government. As well, Vander Zalm allowed his principal secretary, David Poole, to amass a substantial amount of power, despite being unelected.

Vander Zalm resigned in April 1991 amid a conflict of interest scandal surrounding the sale of a theme park that he owned. Socred members elected the lesser-known Deputy Premier Rita Johnston, a close ally of Vander Zalm, to be their new leader, over Grace McCarthy, a longtime associate of former Premier Bill Bennett. Many viewed this as a mistake, as Johnston was close to the Vander Zalm legacy; even NDP leader Mike Harcourt admitted later that he preferred Johnston over McCarthy, as the latter would be a much tougher opponent in an election.

Campaign

Johnston had little time to make up ground in the polls or distance herself from the now-detested Vander Zalm. Additionally, the Socreds were still bitterly divided over the bruising leadership contest. The NDP went into the elections as heavy favourites after leading in opinion polls for almost four years.

The Liberals, who had not been represented in the legislature since 1979, gained slightly in the polls due to great resentment against the ruling Socreds and skepticism towards the NDP. A turning point came when Wilson successfully took legal action to be included in the televised leaders' debate, which took place on 8 October. During the debate Johnston and Harcourt exchanged many bitter attacks, while Wilson, still not considered a serious contender, was able to successfully portray himself as an "outsider" who was above the partisan bickering of the other two parties. Liberal support surged dramatically as a result of Wilson's performance. One of the memorable moments of the debate came as Harcourt and Johnston argued loudly amongst each other, when Wilson pointed towards them and declared, "Here's a classic example of why nothing ever gets done in the province of British Columbia." [4]

Opinion polls

Last day
of poll
New Democratic Liberal Social Credit OthersPollsterSampleMarginSource
Results40.733.324.11.9
10 October 19913830293Angus Reid1,004± 3,1 [5]
25 September 199148
(39)
11
(9)
39
(32)
2
(2)
[6]
15 July 1990478369Angus Reid801± 3,5 [7]
21 January 19904943Angus Reid470± 4,2 [8]
25 April 19895310325Angus Reid807± 3,5 [9]
20 April 19894811356Marktrend [9]
4 November 19884318345Marktrend [9]
1 October 19884123Goldfarb1,000± 3,0 [10]
29 November 198746
(31)
6
(4)
40
(27)
7
(5)
475± 4,5 [11]
1986 Elections 42.66.749.31.4

Riding-specific polls

Oak Bay-Gordon Head by-election

Evolution of voting intentions at provincial level
Polling firmLast day
of survey
Source BCNDP BCLP BCSC OtherMESample
By-election 1989December 13, 198945.2643.689.111.94
Angus ReidDecember 1989 [12] 5238
Angus ReidDecember 1989 [13] 4541400
McIntyre & MustelDecember 7, 1989 [14] 494445.0350
Election 1986 December 13, 198935.9152.502.389.21

Results

The Socreds were swept from power in a massive NDP landslide. This was not due to the NDP winning a higher percentage of the vote as much as it was due to Socred support collapsing in favour of the BC Liberals, splitting the vote. The defeat was magnified by moderate Socred supporters voting Liberal, continuing a shift that dated to early in Vander Zalm's tenure. The combined effect was to decimate the Socred caucus, which was reduced from 47 members to only seven—only three over the minimum for official party status. Johnston herself lost her own seat in Surrey-Newton to NDP challenger Penny Priddy, and all but five members of her cabinet were defeated.

The Liberals returned to the legislature as the official opposition after a 12-year absence, replacing Social Credit as the main alternative to the NDP in the province.

PartyParty leader# of
candidates
SeatsPopular vote
1986 Elected% Change#%% Change
  New Democrats Michael Harcourt 752251+131.8%595,39140.71%-1.89%
Liberal Gordon Wilson 71-17 486,20833.25%+26.51%
Social Credit Rita Johnston 74477-85.1%351,66024.27%-25.27%
Green  42---12,6500.86%+0.62%
 Independents16---10,2810.70%+0.57%
Reform Ron Gamble 4*-*2,6730.18%*
Family Coalition  8*-*1,3100.09%*
  Libertarian  11---8600.06%+0.04%
  Western Canada Concept Doug Christie 5---6510.04%+0.02%
  Conservative Peter B. Macdonald [15] 4---4260.03%-0.70%
  Human Race  2*-*1100.01%*
  Green Go (Green Wing/Rhino)  1*-*930.01%*
  Communist League  3---920.01%-0.02%
  Interdependence Party  1*-*62x*
Total3176975+8.7%1,462,467100% 
Source: Elections BC

Notes: x - less than 0.005% of the popular vote.

* Party did not nominate candidates in the previous election.

Popular vote
NDP
40.71%
Liberal
33.25%
Social Credit
24.05%
Others
1.99%
Seats summary
NDP
68.00%
Liberal
22.67%
Social Credit
9.33%

Legacy

This was considered a political realignment due to the high turnover in MLAs and the effective end of the Socreds as a political force. The party was completely shut out of the legislature in the 1996 election, never to return. Meanwhile, the Liberals replaced them as the main non-socialist party in British Columbia. The NDP and Liberals would go on to be the two main parties in the province until 2024, when the Liberals, who by then had renamed themselves BC United, withdrew from that year's general election and endorsed the Conservative Party of British Columbia.

However, neither Harcourt, Wilson, or Johnston would contest the subsequent 1996 election as leaders of the major parties, with Johnston and Harcourt having retired from politics by that campaign. Johnston, having lost her seat, resigned the leadership of the Socreds immediately in early 1992. Harcourt resigned as premier in 1996 due to a scandal among the MLAs in his caucus. Wilson proved unable to consolidate the party's leadership due to inexperience and he was eventually deposed in 1993, and he crossed to the NDP in 1997 after a brief spell as founder, leader and sole MLA of the Progressive Democratic Alliance. He served as an MLA and minister until his defeat in 2001. Wilson was also a candidate for the NDP's leadership in 2000, won by Ujjal Dosanjh.

See also

Related Research Articles

BC United (BCU), known from 1903 until 2023 as the British Columbia Liberal Party or BC Liberals, is a provincial political party in British Columbia, Canada. The party has been described as conservative, neoliberal, and occupying a centre-right position on the left–right political spectrum. The party commonly describes itself as a "free enterprise coalition" and draws support from members of both the federal Liberal and Conservative parties. From the 1990s to 2024, BC United was the main centre-right opposition to the centre-left New Democratic Party (NDP). Once affiliated with the Liberal Party of Canada, the British Columbia Liberal Party became independent in 1987. The party changed its name to BC United on April 12, 2023.

The New Democratic Party of British Columbia is a social democratic political party in British Columbia, Canada. The party sits on the centre-left of the political spectrum and is one of the two major parties in British Columbia; since the 1990s, its rival was the business-oriented BC United until the Conservative Party of British Columbia reconstituted itself for the 2024 British Columbia general election, with BC United withdrawing its candidates and endorsing the Conservatives. The party is currently formally affiliated with the federal New Democratic Party and serves as its provincial branch.

William Nicholas Vander Zalm is a Dutch-born Canadian businessman and politician who served as the 28th premier of British Columbia and leader of the British Columbia Social Credit Party from 1986 to 1991. He was a member of the Legislative Assembly (MLA) of British Columbia, representing the riding of Surrey from 1975 to 1983, and the riding of Richmond from 1986 to 1991.

Rita Margaret Johnston is a Canadian politician in British Columbia. Johnston became the first female premier in Canadian history when she succeeded Bill Vander Zalm in 1991 to become the 29th premier of British Columbia, serving for seven months.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">British Columbia Social Credit Party</span> Political party in British Columbia, Canada

The British Columbia Social Credit Party was a conservative political party in British Columbia, Canada. It was the governing party of British Columbia for all but three years between the 1952 provincial election and the 1991 election. For four decades, the party dominated the British Columbian political scene, with the only break occurring between the 1972 and 1975 elections when the British Columbia New Democratic Party governed. Party members were known as Socreds.

Grace Mary McCarthy, OC, OBC, LLD, DTech, FRAIC (Hon.) was a Canadian politician and florist in British Columbia. A high-ranking member of the Social Credit Party of British Columbia, she was largely responsible for rebuilding that party after its defeat in the 1972 provincial election.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Joy MacPhail</span> Canadian politician

Joy Kathryn MacPhail is a former Canadian politician in British Columbia. A longtime member of the British Columbia New Democratic Party, she served as a member of the Legislative Assembly (MLA) from 1991 to 2005 and as a Minister of the Crown from 1993 to 1999, and 2000–2001.

The Conservative Party of British Columbia, commonly known as the BC Conservatives and colloquially known as the Tories, is a provincial political party in British Columbia, Canada. It is the main rival to the governing British Columbia New Democratic Party and forms the Official Opposition in the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia. It is led by John Rustad, who was originally elected as a British Columbia Liberal Party MLA in 2005 before being expelled from the Liberal caucus in 2022.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Reform Party of British Columbia</span> Former political party in British Columbia, Canada

The Reform Party of British Columbia is an unregistered right-wing populist political party in British Columbia, Canada. Although its name is similar to the defunct Reform Party of Canada, the provincial party was founded before the federal party was and it did not have any formal association with it. Their peak of support came in 1996 when they elected two members to the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2001 British Columbia general election</span> Canadian provincial election

The 2001 British Columbia general election was the 37th provincial election in the Province of British Columbia, Canada. It was held to elect members of the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia. The election was called on April 18, 2001 and held on May 16, 2001. Voter turnout was 55.4 per cent of all eligible voters.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1996 British Columbia general election</span> Canadian provincial election

The 1996 British Columbia general election was the 36th provincial election in the Province of British Columbia, Canada. It was held to elect members of the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia. The election was called on April 30, 1996, and held on May 28, 1996. Voter turnout was 59.1 per cent of all eligible voters. The election is notable for producing a "false-winner" outcome, rewarding a party that got second in the popular vote with a majority government.

Gordon Wilson is a former provincial politician in British Columbia, Canada. He served as leader of the Liberal Party of BC from 1987–1993, leader and founder of the Progressive Democratic Alliance from 1993–1999, before joining the NDP where he served in the provincial cabinet. He also ran as a candidate in the 2000 BC New Democratic Party leadership race. During the 2013 British Columbia provincial election, Wilson endorsed Liberal Premier Christy Clark for re-election over the NDP's Adrian Dix.

The British Columbia Social Credit Party was a conservative political party in the province of British Columbia, Canada. The provincial Social Credit movement was divided in its early years and was largely under the influence of the Alberta Social Credit League; it did not have a functional leadership before 1952.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1986 British Columbia general election</span> Canadian provincial election

The 1986 British Columbia general election was the 34th general election in the Province of British Columbia, Canada. It was held to elect members of the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia. The sitting Social Credit government was re-elected.

The Politics of British Columbia involve not only the governance of British Columbia, Canada, and the various political factions that have held or vied for legislative power, but also a number of experiments or attempts at political and electoral reform.

Claude Harry Richmond is a former Canadian politician who served as a member of the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia, representing the riding of Kamloops from 1981 to 1991 as part of the British Columbia Social Credit Party (Socred), and from 2001 to 2009 as part of the British Columbia Liberal Party. He held various cabinet positions under premiers Bill Bennett, Bill Vander Zalm, Rita Johnston and Gordon Campbell, and served as Speaker of the Legislative Assembly from 2001 to 2005.

The British Columbia Recall and Initiative Referendum was a referendum held in British Columbia on October 17, 1991. It was concurrent with that year's general election. The referendum posed two questions. They were on whether elected officials should be able to be recalled and whether voters should be given a citizen's initiative. Both questions were decisively approved with over 80% of the electorate voting yes to both questions.

Wilf Hurd is a Canadian politician from British Columbia. He represented the riding of Surrey-White Rock for the Liberal Party as a Member of the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia, and was an unsuccessful candidate in the 1997 federal election.

Graham Preston Bruce is a former Canadian politician who served as a member of the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia, representing the electoral district of Cowichan-Malahat from 1986 to 1991 as part of the Social Credit Party (Socred), and the district of Cowichan-Ladysmith from 2001 to 2005 as a BC Liberal. He was a cabinet minister under premiers Rita Johnston and Gordon Campbell.

Peter Albert Dueck was a politician and cabinet minister in the Canadian province of British Columbia.

References

  1. "B.C. Voter Participation: 1983 to 2013" (PDF). Elections BC. Archived from the original (PDF) on March 28, 2019. Retrieved May 11, 2017.
  2. "Archived copy" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on October 9, 2007. Retrieved April 5, 2008.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: archived copy as title (link)
  3. "Elections BC - SOV91 Forword". Archived from the original on October 4, 2007. Retrieved February 2, 2008.
  4. "Gordon Wilson's debate triumph in B.C." CBC News Archives. Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. October 8, 1991. Retrieved October 25, 2016.
  5. Tom Barrett (October 12, 1991). "Liberals leap into second, poll suggests: Socreds overtaken by narrow margin; NDP still in the lead". Vancouver Star. p. A1.
  6. The Canadian Press (September 28, 1991). "Poll shows NDP lead on decline". Vancouver Star. p. B13.
  7. The Canadian Press (July 29, 1990). "NDP lead widening in B.C., poll finds". Toronto Star. p. A15.
  8. The Canadian Press (January 21, 1990). "Vander Zalm gets boost, poll finds". Toronto Star. p. A15.
  9. 1 2 3 Chris Rose (May 2, 1989). "Harcourt, NDP sweep voter poll: 53 per cent would vote for party to oust Socreds". Vancouver Sun. p. A1.
  10. The Canadian Press (October 19, 1988). "Most in B.C. see Vander Zalm as liability to party, poll shows". Toronto Star. p. A18.
  11. The Canadian Press (November 29, 1987). "Majority unhappy with Vander Zalm B.C. poll finds". Toronto Star. p. A12.
  12. Kieran, Brian (December 12, 1989). "Political pundits pick the NDP, 7 to 5". The Province. p. 6.
  13. Hume, Mark (December 9, 1989). "Poll shows close race in Oak Bay: Generation, gender gaps split conservative riding". The Vancouver Sun. p. A1.
  14. Hauka, Don (December 8, 1989). "Neck and neck in Oak Bay". The Province. p. 1.
  15. Macdonald was not eligible to run as a candidate in 1991. He moved to Canada at the age of 10 and only discovered during the election campaign that he was a British subject and had never obtained his Canadian citizenship. (Matas, Robert, "B.C. Tory leader ineligible for election He discovered just two weeks ago that he isn't a Canadian citizen", Globe and Mail, October 2, 1991

Further reading