2006 Royal Air Force Nimrod crash

Last updated

2006 Royal Air Force Nimrod crash
Nimrod Waddington 2005 2.jpg
XV230 at the Waddington Airshow, July 2005
Accident
Date2 September 2006 (2006-09-02)
SummaryOn board fire following aerial refuelling
Site Chalaghor in the Panjwaye District of Kandahar, Afghanistan
Aircraft
Aircraft type Nimrod MR2
Operator Royal Air Force
Registration XV230
Crew14
Fatalities14
Survivors0

On 2 September 2006, a Royal Air Force Hawker Siddeley Nimrod suffered an in-flight fire and subsequently crashed in Kandahar, Afghanistan, killing all fourteen crew members on board. The crash, which occurred during a reconnaissance flight, was the biggest single loss of life suffered by the British military since the Falklands War.

Contents

Aircraft

The aircraft involved in the accident was XV230, the first of 38 Nimrod maritime reconnaissance/strike aircraft to enter operational service with the Royal Air Force on 2 October 1969. [1] [2] At a ceremony held at Woodford airfield in Cheshire, the aircraft was handed over by the deputy managing director of Hawker Siddeley Aviation, Sir Harry Broadhurst. Receiving XV230 were the AOC-in Chief of Coastal Command, Air Marshal Sir John Lapsley. At Broadhurst's invitation, Lady Lapsley performed the naming ceremony. Later in the day an RAF crew flew XV230 to its base at RAF St Mawgan, Cornwall, where the Nimrod maritime operational training unit (MOTU) was to be formed. [3]

According to Jane's Information Group, XV230 was one of six Nimrods equipped with an L-3 Wescam MX-15 electro-optical turret in 2003. In June/July 2006 XV230 was given the capability to transmit real-time video imagery from the MX-15 to ground stations and commanders. This was implemented under Project Broadsword. [4]

Crash details

The aircraft is believed to have suffered a fuel leak or overflow during mid-air refuelling while it was monitoring a NATO offensive against Taliban insurgents west of Kandahar. The investigation found that fuel most probably travelled from a fuel tank blow-off valve on the starboard side of the lower-forward fuselage into an aft bay near the root of the starboard wing which contained hot air ducting pipes, where it saturated compressed insulation contained within a shrouding, holding the fuel against a hot air pipe until it reached auto-ignition temperature and caught fire.

The fire was first noted when smoke accumulated in the bomb-bay, leading the pilot to report a fire in his bomb-bay. He tried to reach Kandahar air base, taking the aircraft down from 23,000 to 3,000 feet (7,010 to 910 metres) in 90 seconds. A RAF Harrier GR7 (AV8-B) aircraft followed the Nimrod down and the pilot saw a wing explode, followed a few seconds later by the rest of the aircraft. [5]

The crash site was about 25 miles (40 kilometres) west-north-west of Kandahar Airfield (which is located 10 miles (16 kilometres) south-east of the city of Kandahar) between two villages called Chil Khor and Fatehullah Qala in the Panjwaye District. [6]

The twelve RAF personnel plus a Royal Marine and a British Army soldier aboard Nimrod MR2 XV230 were killed. A board of inquiry report was released in December 2007. [7]

On 23 May 2008 the assistant deputy coroner for Oxfordshire, Andrew Walker, handed down a narrative ruling that it had "never been airworthy from the first time it was released to the service nearly 40 years ago".

"It seems to me that this is a case where I would be failing in my duty if I didn't report action to the relevant authority that would prevent future fatalities,"

"I have given the matter considerable thought and I see no alternative but to report to the secretary of state that the Nimrod fleet should not fly until the ALARP [as low as reasonably practicable] standards are met." [8]

Controversy

There had been concerns in the British media about serviceability of the Nimrod fleet [9] and bereaved families having to wait for years for the Oxfordshire coroner's office to hold inquests into military deaths. [10] Conservative MP Ian Liddell-Grainger called for the MR2's replacement – the BAE MRA4 – to be introduced sooner. [11] That aircraft suffered significant problems during development and construction which resulted in lengthy programme delays and the in-service date slipping nine years from 2003 to 2012. [12] [13] The MR4 replacement aircraft was cancelled entirely following the 2010 Strategic Defence and Security Review. [14]

Concerns were again raised when on 5 November 2007, Nimrod XV235 was reported to have suffered a similar fuel leak. The aircraft landed safely. The Ministry of Defence (MoD) then suspended all in-flight refuelling of the Nimrod fleet.

The Scottish National Party's Westminster leader, Angus Robertson, criticised delays in inquiries. He said the wait for the MoD inquiry and a coroner's inquest was a "disgrace" that dates have still to be set for the publication of the board of inquiry's findings and a coroner's inquest into the deaths. He was also quoted as saying "Everybody's thoughts are with the families and friends of those who lost their lives. They are having to wait far too long to receive answers to many questions. A 12-month wait is a disgrace – Publication dates have been put back and put back and the Ministry of Defence should get on with it." [15]

In March 2009, following continued questions about the safety of the Nimrod fleet and despite constantly stating that the aircraft were airworthy, the MoD grounded the Nimrod fleet for "vital safety modification[s]". Engine bay hot air ducts and fuel seals were to be replaced. [16]

There are those who opine that the loss was a foreseeable consequence of design and production failures. [17]

Concerns about the safety of the Nimrod fleet continued to surface after the loss of XV230. In April 2009 it was reported that the Defence Minister had "glossed over Nimrod safety fears". [18] The Independent newspaper claimed that a report into the safety of Britain's ageing fleet of Nimrods, which a defence minister claimed did not reveal "any significant airworthiness issues", exposed almost 1,500 faults – 26 of which threatened the aircraft's safety.

Board of Inquiry findings

On 4 December 2007 the report of the findings of the official Board of Inquiry into the loss of XV230 was published. The Board believed that the No 7 tank dry bay was the most likely location for the seat of the fire, with the most probable cause being escaped fuel having come into contact with a Supplementary Conditioning Pack (SCP) airpipe at 400 degrees Celsius "...after entering a gap between two types of insulation". Four separate factors were listed as contributing to the accident: [19] Age of the aircraft; Maintenance policy; Failure of hazard analysis and lack of a fire detection and suppression system; Not identifying the full implications of successive changes to the fuel system and associated procedures. [20]

Links into the full report on the XV230 accident can be found here. [21]

On 23 May 2008, the coroner who led the inquest into these deaths stated that the entire Nimrod fleet had "never been airworthy from the first time it was released to service" and urged that it should be grounded. [8] Assistant deputy coroner for Oxfordshire Andrew Walker added: "This cavalier approach to safety must come to an end. There were failures...[in monitoring the aircraft's safety]...that should, if the information had been correctly recorded and acted upon, have led to the discovery of this design flaw within the Nimrod fleet." [22]

Nimrod Review

External image
Nimrod MR1 XV230 cutaway and weapon loadout
Searchtool.svgMarsden, John (2006), "An old 1970's cutaway of Nimrod MR1 XV230 retouched by Flight Global in 2006.", Flight Global , archived from the original on 20 October 2012

The Terms of Reference for the Nimrod Review were set out by the Secretary of State for Defence, Des Browne, on 13 December 2007. [23]

It emerged in May 2009 that an RAF commander destroyed a number of official documents after the loss of Nimrod XV230. The Times newspaper, [24] 31 May 2009, reported that all documents relating to the aircraft were immediately impounded but Sqn Ldr Guy Bazalgette, commander of the Nimrod detachment in the Gulf, managed to retrieve one file. Bazalgette subsequently destroyed the document but later told the coroners inquest that none of the shredded documents were relevant to the loss of XV230. However, Bazalgette admitted: "They should not have been shredded and it was my fault that they were."

Also in May 2009, Charles Haddon-Cave, QC, leading the Nimrod Review issued a number of Salmon letters to organisations and senior RAF officers warning them they were likely to be criticised in its formal report. The so-called Salmon letters give those who are likely to be criticised by the inquiry the opportunity to respond to the criticism before the report's publication. The MoD and the Nimrod inquiry team declined to say which senior RAF officers received letters. [24]

On 28 October, Haddon-Cave presented his report, summarised by the statement:

Its [the Nimrod safety case produced by BAE Systems] production is a story of incompetence, complacency and cynicism. The best opportunity to prevent the accident to XV230 was tragically lost

The report:

Haddon-Cave condemned the change of organisational culture within the MoD between 1998 and 2006, when financial targets came to distract from safety, quoting a former senior RAF officer who told the inquiry:

There was no doubt that the culture of the time had switched. In the days of the RAF chief engineer in the 1990s, you had to be on top of airworthiness. By 2004 you had to be on top of your budget if you wanted to get ahead.

Haddon-Cave directly criticised 10 individuals in the report – five at the MoD, three at BAE Systems and two at QinetiQ – while throughout the review BAE Systems had been a company "in denial." Haddon-Cave's report directly criticised two RAF officers:

Defence Secretary Bob Ainsworth said the "rigorous" report would make distressing reading for the relatives of those who died.

On behalf of the MoD and the Royal Air Force, I would like again to say sorry to all the families who lost loved ones. I am sorry for the mistakes that have been made and the lives that have been lost as a result of our failure. Nothing I can say or do will bring these men back.

In December 2008 the Defence Secretary John Hutton was served with a writ by relatives of two of 14 men who died. [25]

In March 2009 in response to the writ, the Ministry of Defence admitted responsibility for the deaths of the 14 servicemen aboard Nimrod aircraft XV230, after two families brought a landmark legal action using human rights law. High Court papers submitted by the MoD in response to the claim accept for the first time that the Nimrod was "not airworthy". The papers added: "The defendant owed to the deceased a duty of care and the accident was caused by this breach of that duty of care." [26]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hawker Siddeley Nimrod</span> Maritime patrol aircraft family by Hawker Siddeley, later British Aerospace

The Hawker Siddeley Nimrod is a retired maritime patrol aircraft developed and operated by the United Kingdom. It was an extensive modification of the de Havilland Comet, the world's first operational jet airliner. It was originally designed by de Havilland's successor firm, Hawker Siddeley; further development and maintenance work was undertaken by Hawker Siddeley's own successor companies, British Aerospace and, later, BAE Systems.

de Havilland Comet First commercial jet airliner

The de Havilland DH.106 Comet is the world's first commercial jet airliner. Developed and manufactured by de Havilland in the United Kingdom, the Comet 1 prototype first flew in 1949. It features an aerodynamically clean design with four de Havilland Ghost turbojet engines buried in the wing roots, a pressurised cabin, and large windows. For the era, it offered a relatively quiet, comfortable passenger cabin and was commercially promising at its debut in 1952.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">RAF Kinloss</span> Former Royal Air Force station in Moray, Scotland

Royal Air Force Kinloss, or more simply RAF Kinloss, is a former Royal Air Force station located near the village of Kinloss, on the Moray Firth in the north east of Scotland, UK.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1994 Mull of Kintyre Chinook crash</span> Helicopter crash in Scotland

On 2 June 1994, a Chinook helicopter of the Royal Air Force (RAF), serial number ZD576, crashed on the Mull of Kintyre, Scotland, in foggy conditions. The crash resulted in the deaths of all twenty-five passengers and four crew on board. Among the passengers were almost all the United Kingdom's senior Northern Ireland intelligence experts. The accident is the RAF's fourth-worst peacetime disaster.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">No. 33 Squadron RAF</span> Flying squadron of the Royal Air Force

Number 33 Squadron of the Royal Air Force operates the Airbus Helicopters Puma HC.2 from RAF Benson, Oxfordshire.

Air Chief Marshal Sir John Romney Day, is a retired senior Royal Air Force commander and a military advisor to BAE Systems.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2005 Royal Air Force Hercules shootdown</span> Shooting down of a Royal Air Force Lockheed C-130K Hercules C1

On 30 January 2005 a Royal Air Force Lockheed C-130K Hercules C1, serial number XV179, callsign Hilton 22, was shot down in Iraq, probably by Sunni insurgents, killing all 10 personnel on board. At the time, the incident was the largest single loss of life suffered by the British military during Operation Telic.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Andrew Walker (barrister)</span>

Andrew Walker is an English barrister and coroner for Northern District of Greater London.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Little Baldon air crash</span> 1965 air crash in the United Kingdom

The Little Baldon air crash occurred on 6 July 1965 when a Handley Page Hastings C1A transport aircraft operated by No. 36 Squadron Royal Air Force, registration TG577, crashed into a field in Little Baldon, near Chiselhampton, Oxfordshire, shortly after taking off from RAF Abingdon. The flight was captained by Flt Lt John Akin. All 41 people aboard, including six crew, perished in the crash, making it the third worst air crash in the United Kingdom at the time.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Military Aviation Authority</span>

The Military Aviation Authority (MAA) is an organisation within the British Ministry of Defence and is the single regulatory authority responsible for regulating all aspects of Air Safety across Defence, with full oversight of all Defence aviation activity. It is part of the MoD, but operates independently, via a Charter signed by the Secretary of State for Defence.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2010 Fox Glacier FU-24 crash</span> Aeroplane crash in New Zealand

On 4 September 2010, a modified Fletcher FU-24 aeroplane on a parachuting flight from Fox Glacier Aerodrome, New Zealand, crashed shortly after take-off, killing all nine people on board.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">BAE Systems Nimrod MRA4</span> British planned maritime patrol and attack aircraft

The BAE Systems Nimrod MRA4 was a planned maritime patrol and attack aircraft intended to replace the Hawker Siddeley Nimrod MR2. The rebuilt aircraft would have extended the operating life of the Nimrod fleet by several decades and significantly improved the aircraft by installing more efficient Rolls-Royce BR700 turbofan jet engines to almost double the flight range. The conversion of the flight deck to a digital glass cockpit would have simplified control operations and reduced crew requirements. New detection systems were to be installed, as well as additional weapons for anti-submarine warfare.

The 1947 Croydon Dakota accident occurred on 25 January 1947 when a Spencer Airways Douglas C-47A Skytrain (Dakota) failed to get airborne from Croydon Airport near London, and crashed into a parked and empty ČSA Douglas C-47 destroying both aircraft and killing 11 passengers and one crew member.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1923 Daimler Airway de Havilland DH.34 crash</span>

The 1923 Daimler Airway de Havilland DH.34 crash occurred on 14 September 1923 when a de Havilland DH.34 of Daimler Airway operating a scheduled domestic passenger flight from Croydon to Manchester crashed at Ivinghoe, Buckinghamshire, England, killing all five people on board.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1924 Imperial Airways de Havilland DH.34 crash</span> 1924 aviation accident

The 1924 Imperial Airways de Havilland DH.34 crash occurred on 24 December 1924 when de Havilland DH.34 G-EBBX of Imperial Airways crashed at Purley, Surrey, United Kingdom killing all eight people on board. The aircraft was operating a scheduled international flight from Croydon, Surrey, to Paris, France. It was the first fatal accident suffered by Imperial Airways and led to the first public inquiry into a civil aviation accident in the United Kingdom. As a result of issues brought up during the inquiry, Croydon Airport was expanded, absorbing most of Beddington Aerodrome.

HMS <i>Richmond</i> helicopter crash 2002 aviation accident

The Westland Lynx helicopter attached to the Royal Navy frigate HMS Richmond crashed into the Atlantic Ocean on 12 June 2002, killing two of the three on board. It had been returning to the ship after an air-to-ship missile live firing exercise, when it suffered a double engine failure.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hawker Siddeley Nimrod R1</span> Type of aircraft

The Hawker Siddeley Nimrod R1 is a signals intelligence (reconnaissance) aircraft formerly operated by the Royal Air Force. The aircraft was a conversion of the existing Nimrod maritime patrol aircraft, with all of the electronic equipment and armament optimised for anti-submarine and anti-ship warfare, and search and rescue, replaced by equipment for the gathering of communications intelligence and electronic intelligence.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1995 Royal Air Force Nimrod R1 ditching</span> Aircraft accident in Scotland

On Tuesday 16 May 1995, a Royal Air Force Nimrod R1 aircraft suffered an in-flight engine fire which led to the aircraft having to ditch in the Moray Firth. This was the first of two Nimrods to be lost in 1995; it was followed by the crash of a Nimrod MR2 in Canada in September.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Death of Sean Cunningham</span> 2011 British Royal Air Force accident

Flight Lieutenant Sean Cunningham was a Royal Air Force pilot on the Red Arrows aerobatics display team, who died when his ejection seat initiated whilst the aircraft he was in was stationary on the ground and he was conducting pre-flight checks. The incident occurred at the Red Arrows' home base, RAF Scampton in Lincolnshire, England. The initiation of the ejection seat was assumed to be by accident. The parachute on the seat did not deploy and Cunningham fell, still strapped to the seat, 220 feet (67 m) to his death 217 feet (66 m) away from the motionless aircraft. In January 2018, in the prosecution brought by the Health and Safety Executive, Martin-Baker, the manufacturers of the seat, pleaded guilty to a breach of health and safety law regarding Cunningham's death. On 23 February 2018, Martin-Baker were fined £1.1 million.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1990 Scotland RAF Shackleton crash</span> RAF Shackleton crash on the Isle of Harris, Scotland

On 30 April 1990, a Royal Air Force Avro Shackleton AEW Mk II aircraft, of No. 8 Squadron RAF, based at RAF Lossiemouth, crashed into a hill on the Isle of Harris whilst attempting to land at RAF Benbecula. All ten crew on board died in the crash, which included the wing commander who was in charge of No. 8 Squadron at the time. The Shackleton was the last of the fleet to be involved in a fatal accident, and the type was withdrawn from RAF service in 1991.

References

  1. ↑ "Hawker Siddeley HS.801 Nimrod MR1". Flight Global Archive. Retrieved 28 July 2009.
  2. ↑ RAF Kinloss – Nimrod – Through The Years Archived 14 July 2007 at the Wayback Machine
  3. ↑ "Four-jet Sub-hunter handover" (Digitised PDF). Flight International. Flight Global Archive. 9 October 1969. p. 582. Retrieved 13 May 2015.
  4. ↑ Crashed RAF Nimrod identified Jane's Defence Business News
  5. ↑ Michael Smith (17 June 2007). "Blast fears as Nimrod planes leak fuel on spy missions". The Times . London. Retrieved 28 July 2009.
  6. ↑ Michael Smith (3 September 2006). "Biggest military loss since start of Afghan war is 'terrible accident'". The Times . London. Retrieved 28 July 2009.
  7. ↑ PR Newswire : Release of Nimrod XY230 board of inquiry (BOI) [ permanent dead link ]
  8. 1 2 "Nimrod inquest coroner declares whole fleet 'never airworthy' " The Guardian. 23 May 2008. Retrieved on 24 May 2008
  9. ↑ Smith, Michael (22 April 2007). "MoD accused of costcutting on crash plane". The Times. London. Retrieved 22 May 2010.
  10. ↑ Adams, Stephen (23 August 2007) Attacks on 'appalling' wait for inquests Telegraph, Accessed 25 March 2015
  11. ↑ Dan Sales (23 July 2007). "Air hero's dad and MP call for Nimrod replacements" . Retrieved 28 July 2009.
  12. ↑ "BAe Nimrod MRA4". Archived from the original on 21 September 2007. Retrieved 26 August 2007.
  13. ↑ "Nimrod Aircraft". Hansard (House of Commons Daily Debates). 23 July 2007. Retrieved 28 July 2009.
  14. ↑ Maddox, David (20 November 2010). "RAF Kinloss: Scrapped replacement for Nimrod 'largely completed'". scotsman.com.
  15. ↑ John Ross (1 September 2007). "Nimrod inquiry delays under fire". The Scotsman. Edinburgh. Retrieved 28 July 2009.
  16. ↑ "Nimrod aircraft grounded by MoD". BBC News. 9 March 2009. Retrieved 27 March 2010.
  17. ↑ "Nimrod Losses – XV230". Globalsecurity.org. Retrieved 9 September 2012.
  18. ↑ Andrew Johnson (26 April 2009). "Defence minister glossed over Nimrod safety fears". The Independent. London. Archived from the original on 1 May 2022. Retrieved 27 March 2010.
  19. ↑ "2007-12-04 Final enclosures press pack" (PDF). BBC News. 4 December 2007. Retrieved 28 July 2009.
  20. ↑ Burns, John F., "Cost Cuts Led to British Jet Crash, Study Says", The New York Times , 28 October 2009.
  21. ↑ "XV230 Board of Inquiry Findings". Royal Air Force. Archived from the original on 7 August 2009. Retrieved 28 July 2009.
  22. ↑ "Nimrod fleet 'should be grounded'". BBC News. 23 May 2008. Archived from the original on 26 May 2008. Retrieved 28 July 2009.
  23. ↑ "Terms of Reference" (PDF). nimrod-review.org.uk.[ dead link ]
  24. 1 2 Smith, Michael (31 May 2009). "RAF Commander admits to shredding spy plane documents". The Times. London. Retrieved 27 March 2010.
  25. ↑ "Nimrod victims' families sue MoD". BBC News. 23 December 2008. Retrieved 27 March 2010.
  26. ↑ Bingham, John (30 March 2009). "MoD admits responsibility for Afghanistan Nimrod explosion deaths". The Daily Telegraph. London. Archived from the original on 7 August 2010. Retrieved 27 March 2010.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.