Award Recipient Result Ultimate Scream 28 Weeks Later Nominated 300 Won Battlestar Galactica Nominated The Descent Nominated Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix Nominated Heroes Nominated Pan's Labyrinth Nominated Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End Nominated Spider-Man 3 Nominated Transformers Nominated Best Horror Movie 28 Weeks Later Won 1408 Nominated The Descent Nominated Grindhouse Nominated The Host Nominated Hostel: Part II Nominated Best Fantasy Movie Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix Nominated Pan's Labyrinth Won Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End Nominated Spider-Man 3 Nominated Stardust Nominated Best Science Fiction Movie Children of Men Nominated The Fountain Nominated The Prestige Nominated Sunshine Nominated Transformers Won Best TV Show Battlestar Galactica Nominated Doctor Who Nominated Heroes Won Lost Nominated Masters of Horror Nominated Best Comic Book 30 Days of Night Won All-Star Superman Nominated The Boys Nominated Ultimate Fantastic Four Nominated Y: The Last Man Nominated Scream Queen Kate Beckinsale Amy Fox Vacancy Won Jordana Brewster The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning Nominated Rosario Dawson Abernathy "Abbie" Ross Grindhouse Nominated Rose McGowan Cherry Darling Grindhouse Nominated Bijou Phillips Whitney Swerling Hostel: Part II Nominated Mary Elizabeth Winstead Heather Fitzgerald Black Christmas Nominated Scream King Shia LaBeouf as Kale Brecht , Disturbia Won John Cusack as Mike Enslin, 1408 Nominated Samuel L. Jackson , Snakes on a Plane Nominated Angus Macfadyen as Jeff Denlon, Saw III Nominated Freddy Rodriguez , Grindhouse Nominated Luke Wilson as David Fox, Vacancy Nominated Best Superhero Michael Chiklis as The Thing , Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer Nominated Chris Evans as Human Torch , Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer Nominated Tobey Maguire as Spider-Man , Spider-Man 3 Won Masi Oka as Hiro Nakamura , Heroes Nominated Milo Ventimiglia as Peter Petrelli , Heroes Nominated Sexiest Superhero Jessica Alba , Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer Won Ali Larter , Heroes Nominated Hayden Panettiere as Claire Bennet, Heroes Nominated Fantasy Fox Jessica Biel , The Illusionist Won Kirsten Dunst , Spider-Man 3 Nominated Lena Headey , 300 Nominated Keira Knightley , Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End Nominated Evangeline Lilly , Lost Nominated Eva Mendes , Ghost Rider Nominated Sienna Miller , Stardust Nominated Fantasy Hero Gerard Butler , 300 Nominated Johnny Depp , Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End Won Matthew Fox , Lost Nominated Edward Norton , The Illusionist Nominated Daniel Radcliffe , Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix Nominated Sci-Fi Siren Clare-Hope Ashitey , Children of Men Nominated Megan Fox , Transformers Won Scarlett Johansson , The Prestige Nominated Katee Sackhoff , Battlestar Galactica Nominated Rachel Weisz , The Fountain Nominated Sci-Fi Star Christian Bale , The Prestige Nominated Hugh Jackman , The Fountain Nominated Shia LaBeouf , Transformers Won Cillian Murphy , Sunshine Nominated Clive Owen , Children of Men Nominated Best Cameo David Bowie , The Prestige Nominated Jay Hernandez , Hostel: Part II Nominated Keith Richards , Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End Won Quentin Tarantino , Grindhouse Nominated Bruce Willis , Grindhouse Nominated Breakout Performance Clare-Hope Ashitey , Children of Men Nominated Zoë Bell , Grindhouse Nominated Megan Fox , Transformers Nominated Lauren German , Hostel: Part II Nominated Shauna MacDonald , The Descent Nominated Hayden Panettiere , Heroes Won Rodrigo Santoro , 300 Nominated Most Vile Villain Sergi López as Captain Vidal, Pan's Labyrinth Nominated Michelle Pfeiffer , Stardust Nominated Zachary Quinto as Gabriel Gray/Sylar , Heroes Nominated Kurt Russell as Stuntman Mike, Grindhouse Nominated Rodrigo Santoro as Xerxes , 300 Nominated Tobin Bell and Shawnee Smith as Jigsaw Killer , Saw III Nominated Thomas Haden Church as Sandman , Spider-Man 3 Nominated Topher Grace as Eddie Brock /Venom , Spider-Man 3 Nominated Ralph Fiennes as Lord Voldemort , Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix Won Most Memorable Mutilation Battle vs. the Immortals, 300 Nominated Cranial surgery, Saw III Nominated Dismembered in car crash , Grindhouse Won Eaten alive by cannibal , Hostel: Part II Nominated Mouth sliced open and sewn back together, Pan's Labyrinth Nominated Best Comic-to-Screen Adaptation 300 Won Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer Nominated Ghost Rider Nominated Spider-Man 3 Nominated TMNT Nominated Best Sequel 28 Weeks Later Nominated Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix Won Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End Nominated Saw III Nominated Spider-Man 3 Nominated "Jump-From-Your-Seat" Scene of the Year Attack of the Uber Immortal, 300 Nominated Final battle: Megatron vs. Optimus Prime , Transformers Won Mid-Air battle: Spider-Man vs. The New Goblin , Spider-Man 3 Nominated The rain of arrows, 300 Nominated Zombie attacks glass window, 28 Weeks Later Nominated Best Director Michael Bay , Transformers Nominated Danny Boyle , Sunshine Nominated Alfonso Cuarón , Children of Men Nominated Guillermo del Toro , Pan's Labyrinth Nominated Neil Marshall , The Descent Nominated Eli Roth , Hostel: Part II Nominated Zack Snyder , 300 Nominated Sam Raimi , Spider-Man 3 Nominated Quentin Tarantino & Robert Rodriguez , Grindhouse Won Best Scream-Play 300 written by Zack Snyder and Kurt Johnstad Nominated Children of Men written by Alfonso Cuarón , Timothy J. Sexton, David Arata , Mark Fergus , and Hawke Ostby Nominated Grindhouse Robert Rodriguez , Quentin Tarantino , Jeff Rendell , Eli Roth , Edgar Wright , and Rob Zombie Won The Descent written by Neil Marshall Nominated Pan's Labyrinth written by Guillermo del Toro Nominated Sunshine written by Alex Garland Nominated Best F/X 300 Nominated Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix Nominated Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End Nominated Spider-Man 3 Nominated Transformers Won Best Foreign Movie Cello (South Korea )Nominated Death Note (Japan )Nominated The Host (South Korea )Nominated Initial D (Hong Kong )Nominated Pan's Labyrinth Spain )Won Best Comic Book Writer Brian Michael Bendis , Civil War: The Initiative / Daredevil / New Avengers Nominated Garth Ennis , Punisher: Max / The Boys / Ghost Rider / Chronicles of Wormwood / Midnight Nominated Frank Miller , All Star Batman & Robin, the Boy Wonder Frank Miller's RoboCop Won Alan Moore , Lost Girls / Yuggoth Cultures Nominated Brian K. Vaughn , Ex Machina / Runaways / Y: The Last Man Nominated Best Comic Book Artist John Cassady , Astonishing X-Men Won Darwyn Cook , The Spirit Nominated Pia Guerra , Y: The Last Man Nominated Steve McNiven , Civil War Nominated Ben Templesmith , Wormwood: Gentleman Corpse /Fell Nominated Best Screen-to-Comic Adaptation 28 Days Later: The Aftermath Won Army of Darkness Nominated Frank Miller 's RoboCop Nominated George A. Romero's Night of the Living Dead: Back from the Grave Nominated The Hills Have Eyes: The Beginning Nominated Most Shocking Comic Book Twist Alice in Wonderland and Dorothy from Oz have lesbian sex!, Lost Girls Nominated Captain America dies! , Captain America Won Peter Parker reveals that he is Spider-Man !, Civil War Nominated Sabretooth is beheaded by Wolverine !, Wolverine Nominated Superman is killed by Superboy-Prime !, Infinite Crisis Nominated 
