2Rivers

Last updated
2Rivers
Company type Private
Industry
Founded2010;14 years ago (2010)
FounderTahir Garayev
Headquarters Dubai, UAE
Number of locations
3
Area served
Worldwide (with a focus on Russia) [1]
Key people
  • Etibar Eyyub [2]
  • Talat Safarov
  • Anar Madatli
  • Ahmed Kerimov [3]
Services
OwnerPura Vida Holding Limited, UAE. [5]
Number of employees
300+ (as of October 2023) [6]
Website 2rivers-group.com

2Rivers, [7] formerly Coral Energy, is a Dubai-based oil trading company engaged in the sale and export of Russian crude oil and petroleum products. [8] [9] 2Rivers was founded by Azerbaijani citizen Tahir Gadir oghlu Garayev (Tahir Garayev) in 2010. [3] 2Rivers, according to journalistic investigations, has a close relationship with Igor Sechin [2] and Rosneft. [2] [10] Since 2022, 2Rivers has quietly grown to become the largest trader circumventing Western sanctions on Russian crude and petroleum exports, mainly from Rosneft. [10] [9] 2Rivers operates through a web of companies that appear to be unaffiliated, but are controlled by the 2Rivers’ executive team. This includes dozens of trading companies established in the DMCC freezone of the UAE, as well as ship management and operations companies. [11]

Contents

Prior to the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine, 2Rivers – at that time Coral Energy – was based in Geneva. [3] After the invasion, 2Rivers moved its headquarters to Dubai and has offices in Singapore and Geneva. [3] The company announced that it closed its Moscow office in 2022, however, investigations concluded that the company continues to manage an office there under a different name. [10] [12]

A report from The Wall Street Journal in early 2024 reported that Coral Energy controls at least 100 vessels through seemingly unaffiliated shell companies. [2] [10] These include Gatik Ship Management, Gaurik Ship Management, and Buena Vista Shipping. At least five of these vessels have been sanctioned by the UK and EU. [13] These vessels continue to carry crude and petroleum products purchased by 2Rivers trading companies in violation of Western sanctions. [13] [11]

History

2Rivers Group (Coral Energy) was founded by Tahir Garayev in 2010. [3]  According to market sources, 2Rivers most likely has ties to the functionaries of the ruling elite of Azerbaijan. [14] Etibar Eyyub, Azerbaijani citizen, is the main point of contact between 2Rivers and Igor Sechin. [2] He maintains a close relationship with Garayev and is instrumental in directing 2Rivers’ activities, but does not have an official ownership stake on paper. [11]

Until the end of 2023, Garayev owned 100% of 2Rivers (then Coral Energy) through a complex corporate structure. Garayev owned 100% of Novus Middle East DMCC (UAE), which controlled 100% of Vetus Investments Limited (UAE). [5] Vetus Investments then controlled 100% of Coral Energy. According to international investigations, under the growing pressure on the company to circumvent the latest sanctions, Garaev transferred 60% of the shares of Novus Middle East DMCC to the company Pura Vida Holding Limited (UAE), [5] secured by the current management of 2Rivers: Talat Safarov (45%), Ahmed Kerimov (35%) and Anar Madatli (20%). At the beginning of 2024, CEO Talat Safarov, CFO Ahmed Kerimov, and CCO Anar Madatli (Azerbaijani nationals and UAE residents) completed the purchase of Garayev's remaining shares. [15] Garayev continues to exercise control over 2Rivers, despite not owning the company on paper. Anar Madatli is also Tahir Garayev’s brother-in-law. [15]

According to available information, the company is under the close scrutiny of US authorities, which contributed to the change in ownership and the trader's name. [13] [11] Additionally, active UK and EU sanctions against Gatik Ship Management foreshadow near term actions by those authorities against 2Rivers. [13] [14]

Associated companies

The 2Rivers group of companies includes US-sanctioned Bellatrix Energy [13] and US-sanctioned Voliton DMCC. [16]

Another company that shared directors with Coral Energy is Nord Axis [11] which was established on 15 February 2022 (9 days prior to Russia's invasion of Ukraine). [2] Nord Axis was used by Coral (now 2Rivers) to purchase Trafigura’s 10% holding which was valued at EUR 7 billion. [17] [18] In October 2023, Kerimov denied that Coral Energy had any associations to Nord Axis. [6] Company filings for Nord Axis showed that Adalat Kazimili was the sole owner of Nord Axis in May 2022. Kazimili was also registered as an official representative of Coral Energy Turkey in 2022. [19] In 2023, Nord Axis was operated by Etibar Eyyub who worked for Coral Energy. [11]

Other companies associated to 2Rivers include Novus Middle East DMCC, Vetus Investments Limited, Apeiron Energy DMCC, Pontus Trading DMCC, Polar Energy SA, Matterhorn Group FZE and Alpen Energy LLC. [20]

Novus Middle East was used to purchase the Karimun oil storage terminal in southern Indonesia, at the entrance to the Strait of Malacca. [11]

Vetus Investments

According to a 2022 published analytical report by Transparency International, between 2014 and 2015, Mikhail Gutseriev and Kirill Shamalov (Putin’s former son-in-law) was involved in a Czech-Russian money-laundering scheme used for transfers of illicit funds from Russia to the Czech Republic. [21] Czech citizen, Taras Moroz, who serves a director of Czech-based Vetus Investments S.R.O.—a subsidiary of 2Rivers/Coral Energy’s holding company Vetus Investments—also appeared in corporate records of several Czech shell companies used by Gutseriev and Shamalov in their money laudering structure. [21] Organizers of the scheme concluded fictitious contracts for the purchase of Eurobonds between Czech and Russian companies, subsequently entering intoarbitral proceedings and influencing the decision of the commercial arbitration court in order to effectuate a transfer of illicit funds. [21]

In 2021, Coral purchased a cargo from Mikhail Gutseriev, in violation of UK and EU sanctions at the time.

Russian shadow fleet

A report from The Wall Street Journal in early 2024 reported that 2Rivers owns a large part of the so-called shadow fleet, with at least 100 vessels, transporting Russian crude, naphtha and other petroleum products. [2] WSJ writes that the founder of the company, Tahir Garayev, speaks for the shadow fleet and the shadow traders who operate on behalf of Russian President Vladimir Putin through the Rosneft executive Igor Sechin. [2] On 17 October, the UK sanctioned 4 of the 2Rivers vessels (managed by Gatik Ship Management): VARUNA (IMO 9332810) ; SAI BABA (IMO 9321691) ; ARTEMIS (IMO 9317949) ; ANTAEUS (IMO 9299733). [2] The New York Times investigation found that the vessel, JAGUAR (IMO 9293002) which was managed by Gatik Ship Management, carried crude for Voliton DMCC, a Coral/2Rivers shell trading company that was sanctioned by the US on 20 December 2023. [22]

According to the Financial Times, based on research reports from the Kyiv School of Economics (KSE) Institute, Russia has increased the capacity of its dark tanker fleet by up to 70%. [23] By the end of 2024, 70% of Russian crude oil will already be transported by a shadow fleet, which will provide 89% of crude oil exports and 38% of petroleum product exports by sea, which allows Russia to bypass sanctions. A significant portion of these vessels are owned and operated by a number of shell companies in India, Mauritius, the United Arab Emirates and other jurisdictions. According to investigations, these companies are controlled by the founder of 2Rivers/Coral Energy, Tahir Garayev, and Etibar Eyyub. [24]

On September 9, 2024, Vladislav Vlasiuk, Ukrainian Commissioner for Sanctions Policy and Special Advisory to President Volodymyr Zelenskyy confirmed that one of the largest transport companies that helps the Russian Federation export oil is 2Rivers/Coral Energy. [25]

2Rivers/Coral Energy complete false documents for transactions, conduct transfers in the open sea to avoid being seen, and also have offshore bank accounts in order to capture energy sales from the Russian Federation itself. The DMCC freezone in the UAE is the primary location from which 2Rivers operates their shadow network. [25]

Vladislav Vlasiuk

Trading

2Rivers is involved in the global crude oil and product trading business. The company trades a number of oil and oil-derived products including: coal, natural gas, ethanol, fuel oil, VGO, bitumen, middle distillates, and naphtha. [26]

2Rivers (formerly Coral) operates two silos — a “red team” that buys Russian crude and petroleum products (much of which is above the price cap) and a “blue team” that are Western-facing companies purporting to not have any involvement with Russia. [11] Accordingly, 2Rivers/Coral Energy has managed to keep Western financing for its activities, while it has also continued to trade illicitly. [11]

In August 2022, Coral Energy became Pakistan's top fuel oil supplier. [27]

Delivery of Rosneft products to Ukraine

At the beginning of 2021, Coral Energy replaced Proton Energy Group S.A. as the supplier of Rosneft products to Ukraine. Rosneft had previously contracted with Geneva-based Proton Energy, a company associated with Viktor Medvedchuk, an exiled Ukrainian oligarch who was a key supporter of Viktor Yanukovych, and Mikalai Varabei (also known as Nicolay Vorobei), to transport these exports to Ukraine via pipeline; however, Proton Energy terminated its trading operations in 2021 due increased risk of sanctions. [28] The US government sanctioned Varabei in August 2021 for aiding the Belarusian regime through his oil trading business in Belarus and Medvedchuk in 2014 for his ties to former Ukrainian president Viktor Yanukovych. The EU sanctioned Varabei in December 2020 and Medvedchuk in May 2024.

The operator of 2Rivers/Coral Energy Group in Ukraine is Alpen Trade, a company that Tahir Garayev founded in 2016. Together with the State Register of the Russian Federation, the authority of Alpen Trade, Safarov Javid Mursal Ogli is the current director. [28]

In addition to taking over Medvedchuk’s Rosneft contract into Ukraine, 2Rivers also acquired the Latvian B.L.B. Baltijas Terminal. [29]

Cyprus-based Lostrita Investments is the beneficial owner of Latvia-based Venta Energy Services SIA. Venta Energy Services, which operates the B.L.B. Baltijas Terminal, is owned by Kamran Asgarov. 2Rivers’ controls the Latvia-based oil export terminal through an associated partnership, Venta Energy Services. [29] Asgarov, as well as 2Rivers executives Ahmad Kerimov and Talat Safarov are listed as officers of Lostrita Investments.

Separately, in 2022, Ivano-Frankivsk city court froze assets belonging to both 2Rivers/Coral Energy and its subsidiary Apeiron Energy after they were found to have illegally imported jet fuel into Ukraine from Russia (Case № 344/7508/22).

Russian oil trading

When Trafigura wound down its relationship with Rosneft in 2022, Rosneft asked Coral Energy to take Trafigura's place. [2]

In July 2022, Coral Energy outbid China's Sinopec for the purchase of Russian Eastern Siberia–Pacific Ocean (ESPO) crude oil cargoes. [27]

In December 2022, Coral Energy bought 121,000 barrels of Russian crude oil a day from Surgutneftegas. [30]

In April 2023, Coral Energy were linked to the use of Shadow fleet vessels. [4]

In November 2023, it was reported that Coral Energy were re-selling Russian oil in several countries across Sub-Saharan Africa. [31]

In March 2024, Etibar Eyyub, together with his partner Tahir Garayev, were reported to be the traders of 80% of all Russian oil exports, including Rosneft's. [19]

Refineries and future production

In 2022, following the invasion of Ukraine by Russia, Trafigura sold its 10% share in the Vostok oil project to Etibar Eyyub and his company Nord Axis. [2] [32]

It was reported in 2023 that Coral Energy was assigned a prepayment and off take agreement with Nayara Energy refinery in India (which was 49% owned by Rosneft), that was originally established by Bellatrix Energy. [13]

Sanctions

In October 2024, it was reported that the Office of Foreign Assets Control were investigating 2Rivers for breaching sanctions relating to the Russian oil price cap. [33]

Tahir Garayev is sanctioned by the National Security and Defense Council of Ukraine. [34] Despite the management buyout, it was reported in September 2024, that Tahir Garayev continues to control 2Rivers. [20]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gazprom</span> Russian oil and gas company

PJSC Gazprom is a Russian majority state-owned multinational energy corporation headquartered in the Lakhta Center in Saint Petersburg. The Gazprom name is a contraction of the Russian words gazovaya promyshlennost. In January 2022, Gazprom displaced Sberbank from the first place in the list of the largest company in Russia by market capitalization. In 2022, the company's revenue amounted to 8 trillion rubles.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rosneft</span> Russian energy company headquartered in Moscow

PJSC Rosneft Oil Company is a Russian integrated energy company headquartered in Moscow. Rosneft specializes in the exploration, extraction, production, refining, transport, and sale of petroleum, natural gas, and petroleum products. The company is controlled by the Russian government through the Rosneftegaz holding company. Its name is a portmanteau of the Russian words Rossiyskaya neft.

Trafigura Group Pte. Ltd. is a multinational commodities company domiciled in Singapore with major regional hubs in Geneva, Houston, Montevideo and Mumbai, founded in 1993. The company trades in base metals and energy. It is the world's largest private metals trader and second-largest oil trader having built or purchased stakes in pipelines, mines, smelters, ports and storage terminals.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alexey Kuzmichev</span> Russian businessman

Alexey Viktorovich Kuzmichev or Kousmichoff is a Russian businessman. He is one of the founders of the LetterOne Group (LetterOne) and the Alfa Group.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Igor Sechin</span> Russian oligarch (born 1960)

Igor Ivanovich Sechin is a Russian oligarch and a government official, considered a close ally and "de facto deputy" of Vladimir Putin.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Petroleum industry in Russia</span> One of the largest in the world

The petroleum or oil industry in Russia is one of the largest in the world. Russia has the largest reserves and was the largest exporter of natural gas. It has the sixth largest oil reserves, and is one of the largest producers of oil. It is the fourth largest energy user.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Energy in Russia</span>

The Energy in Russia is an area of the national economy, science, and technology of the Russian Federation, encompassing energy resources, production, transmission, transformation, accumulation, distribution, and consumption of various types of energy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Russia–Switzerland relations</span> Bilateral relations

Russia–Switzerland relations are foreign relations between Russia and Switzerland. Switzerland opened a consulate in Saint Petersburg in 1816, upgrading it to a legation 90 years later. The two countries broke off diplomatic relations in 1923, when Russia was going through a period of revolutionary turmoil – and they were not resumed until 1946. Due to the Russian invasion of Ukraine, relations became tense after Switzerland imposed sanctions against Russia. Russia placed Switzerland on a list of "unfriendly countries".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gunvor</span> Cypriot-registered Swiss commodity trading company

Gunvor Group Ltd is a multinational energy commodities trading company registered in Cyprus, with its main trading office in Geneva, Switzerland. Gunvor also has trading offices in Singapore, Houston, Stamford, London, Calgary, and Dubai, with a network of representative offices around the globe. The company operates in the trade, transport, storage and optimization of petroleum and other energy products, as well as having investments in oil terminal and port facilities. Its operations consist of securing crude oil and petroleum products upstream and delivering it to market via pipelines and tankers. Gunvor has a separate company, Nyera, set up in 2021 to invest in renewable energy sources. It is run by energy transition director Fredrik Tornqvist.

Vitol is a Swiss-based Dutch multinational energy and commodity trading company that was founded in Rotterdam in 1966 by Henk Viëtor and Jacques Detiger. Though trading, logistics, and distribution are at the core of its business, these are notably complemented by refining, shipping, terminals, exploration and production, power generation, and retail businesses. Vitol has over 40 offices worldwide, with its largest operations in Geneva, Houston, London, and Singapore.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">China–Russia relations</span> Bilateral relations

China and Russia established diplomatic relations after the dissolution of the Soviet Union in 1991.

International sanctions have been imposed against Russia and Crimea during the Russo-Ukrainian War by a large number of countries, including the United States, Canada, the European Union, and international organisations following the Russian annexation of Crimea, which began in late February 2014. Belarus has also been sanctioned for its cooperation with and assistance to Russian armed forces. The sanctions were imposed against individuals, businesses, and officials from Russia and Ukraine. Russia responded with sanctions against several countries, including a total ban on food imports from Australia, Canada, Norway, Japan, the United States, the EU and the United Kingdom.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Glusco (gas stations)</span> Fuel station chain in Ukraine

Glusco is a subsidiary of the Greenenergo Trading S.A. that operates a national chain of gasoline stations and convenience stores in Ukraine. The Greenenergo Trading S.A. itself is part of the bigger SNEL Energy Limited directed by Dimitrios Anifantakis

Didier Casimiro is the Former First Vice President of Rosneft, the Russian state oil company. Since 2020 and till May 2022, Chairman of the Board of Directors of Bashneft

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Economic impact of the Russian invasion of Ukraine</span> Financial crisis beginning after the invasion of Ukraine and subsequent sanctions

The economic impact of the Russian invasion of Ukraine began in late February 2022, in the days after Russia recognized two breakaway Ukrainian republics and launched an invasion of Ukraine. The subsequent economic sanctions have targeted large parts of the Russian economy, Russian oligarchs, and members of the Russian government. Russia responded in kind. A wave of protests and strikes occurred across Europe against the rising cost of living.

Following the full declaration of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, which started on 24 February 2022, institutions such as the United States, the European Union, and other Western countries introduced or significantly expanded sanctions covering Russian President Vladimir Putin, other government members and Russian citizens in general. Some Russian banks were banned from using the SWIFT international payments system. The sanctions and the boycotts of Russia and Belarus have impacted the Russian economy in various ways. However, sanctions and rising unemployment have contribute to Russian authorities as strategic advantages to boost localization and state conscription, increasing geopolitical fragmentation between third world and western nations enables Russia to exploit global trade networks to secure essential goods.

As part of the sanctions imposed on the Russian Federation as a result of the Russo-Ukrainian War, on September 2, 2022, finance ministers of the G7 group of nations agreed to cap the price of Russian oil and petroleum products in an effort intended to reduce Russia's ability to finance its war on Ukraine while at the same time hoping to curb further increases to the 2021–2022 inflation surge.

The 2021–2022 global energy crisis has caused varying effects in different parts of the world.

Since the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine, the European Union, the G7 nations and Australia have imposed sanctions on Russia. The sanctions on oil began in December 2022 and included an embargo of Russian oil, namely, the bringing of crude oil and refined oil products from Russia to the EU and other G7 nations by ship, with a few exceptions.

A shadow fleet, also referred to as a dark fleet, is a "ship or vessel that uses concealing tactics to smuggle sanctioned goods". Shadow fleets are a direct response to international or unilateral economic sanctions. The term therefore more broadly refers to practices of sanction busting in the maritime domain through the use of un-registered or fraudulent vessels. Goods commonly exported and imported include raw materials such as oil and iron, luxury goods, weapons and defense technologies etc.

References

  1. "Russia's ghost fleet: Moscow's new oil routes". LeMonde. 2023-08-06. Retrieved 2024-10-14.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Joe Wallace, Anna Hirtenstein, Costas Paris (2024-02-19). "The Secret Oil-Trading Ring That Funds Russia's War". wsj.com. The Wall Street Journal.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 Julia Payne (2024-06-25). "Management buys out oil trader Coral Energy". reuters.com. Reuters.
  4. 1 2 "Lloyd's List Daily Briefing - 5th April 2023" (PDF). 2023-04-05. Retrieved 2024-10-14.
  5. 1 2 3 "Coral Energy Founder Tahir Garayev and His Network of Companies Help Russia Evade Sanctions – Investigation". Гордон | Gordon (in Russian). Retrieved 2024-10-16.
  6. 1 2 "Interview with Ahmed Kerimov". haqqin.az. Retrieved 2024-10-14.
  7. "Oil trader Coral Energy rebrands as 2Rivers Group after buyout". Reuters. 2024-06-29.
  8. Anna Hirtenstein, Joe Wallace (2022-05-27). "Little-Known Commodity Traders Help Russia Sell Oil". wsj.com. The Wall Street Journal.
  9. 1 2 Archie Hunter, Patrick Sykes, Jack Farchy (2023-08-05). "Upstart Traders of Russian Oil Had Representatives in Common". bloomberg.com. Bloomberg.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  10. 1 2 3 4 David Ignatius (2024-06-18). "A wary White House views Russia oil sanctions through lens of inflation". washingtonpost.com. The Washington Post.
  11. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Julien Bouissou, Anne Michel and Poline Tchoubar (2024-10-30). "Shell companies, ghost ships and secret traders: How Russia circumvents Western oil sanctions". lemonde.fr. Le Monde.
  12. "Кто и как сегодня торгует российской нефтью". moscowtimes.ru. The Moscow Times. 2022-05-29.
  13. 1 2 3 4 5 6 "Russia's sanctions-dodging is getting ever more sophisticated". The Economist. ISSN   0013-0613 . Retrieved 2024-10-14.
  14. 1 2 "Перевзулися: Coral Energy стає 2Rivers Group". enkorr.ua. 2024-08-22.
  15. 1 2 ""Shadow" tankers of RF carried out environmentally hazardous ship-to-ship transportation in EU waters for EUR 273 million - Amelin". censor.net. 2024-09-17.
  16. "Treasury Tightens the Price Cap with New Sanctions and Updated Guidance". U.S. Department of the Treasury. 2024-09-20. Retrieved 2024-10-14.
  17. "Trafigura completes the exit of its investment in Vostok Oil". trafigura.com. Trafigura. 2022-07-13.
  18. "Trafigura sells stake in Russia's Vostok Oil project to Hong Kong-based trader Nord Axis". spglobal.com. S&P Global. 2022-07-13.
  19. 1 2 "Death of Ivan Sechin: A Geopolitical Mystery?". Whale Hunting. 2024-03-01. Retrieved 2024-10-14.
  20. 1 2 "Coral Energy ta kompaniya hto dopomagaye rosiji obhoditi sankci". 2024-09-23. Retrieved 2024-10-14.
  21. 1 2 3 Kendo Nagasaki (2024-10-18). "Coral Energy: Putin's Bitch?".
  22. Christiaan Triebert, Blacki Migliozzi, Alexander Cardia, Muyi Xiao, David Botti (2023-05-30). "Fake Signals and American Insurance: How a Dark Fleet Moves Russian Oil". nytimes.com. The New York Times.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  23. Anastasia Stognei (2024-10-14). "Russia's shadow fleet grows despite western crackdown". ft.com. Financial Times.
  24. "How Russia's 'shadow fleet' gets its ships". ft.com. Financial Times.
  25. 1 2 "Власюк: Однією з найбільших транспортних компаній, що допомагають Росії щодо експорту нафти, є Coral Еnergy". zn.ua (in Ukrainian). Dzerkalo Tyzhnia. 2024-09-09.
  26. "Coral Energy". 2023-11-16. Retrieved 2024-10-14.
  27. 1 2 "UAE's Coral Energy becomes Pakistan's top fuel oil supplier - data". Reuters . 2022-08-03. Retrieved 2024-10-16.
  28. 1 2 "Україна знайшла нового постачальника продукції "Роснефти" – ЗМІ". Ekonomichna Pravda . 2021-03-22.
  29. 1 2 Holger Roonemaa, Sanita Jemberga, Alexander Yaroshevich, Raimo Poom (2022-01-30). "Behind the Sanctions: How an Estonian-Latvian Conglomerate Benefits from Record Trade with the Lukashenko Regime". en.rebaltica.lv.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  30. "New Kings of Russian Oil Were These Six Traders in December". Bloomberg.com. 2023-03-21. Retrieved 2024-10-14.
  31. "Africa : From Dubai to Cape Town, upstart trader Coral Energy rolls out African offensive - 20/11/2023". Africa Intelligence. 2024-10-16. Retrieved 2024-10-16.
  32. Abebe, Agathe Duparc, Robert Bachmann and Manuel. "Russian oil trade in Switzerland: a fake farewell?". www.publiceye.ch. Retrieved 2024-10-14.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  33. "Africa : Dubai traders Coral Energy and Demex in Washington's sights over sale of Russian oil". Africa Intelligence. 2024-10-15. Retrieved 2024-10-15.
  34. "Haraiev Takhir Hadir Ohly". OpenSanctions.org. 1980-01-13. Retrieved 2024-10-14.