Barnes vs. Roosevelt libel trial

Last updated

Roosevelt in the courtroom William Barnes vs. Theodore Roosevelt Libel Trial (13566211935).jpg
Roosevelt in the courtroom

The William Barnes vs. Theodore Roosevelt libel trial was a 1915 case between former president Theodore Roosevelt and New York State Republican Party Chairman William Barnes Jr. Barnes sued Roosevelt for libel following accusations of corruption made by Roosevelt against Barnes. [1] The trial became a high-profile news event, and was reported about in newspapers across the country. [2] It ended with Roosevelt's acquittal and played a prominent part in ending Barnes' career as a Republican political leader.

Contents

Background

Barnes as a member of the Republican National Committee at around the time of the trial REPUBLICAN NATIONAL COMMITTEE. BARNES, WILLIAM, JR., OF NEW YORK LCCN2016863913 (cropped).jpg
Barnes as a member of the Republican National Committee at around the time of the trial

Going back to the 1880s, Theodore Roosevelt and William Barnes Jr. had been active in New York's Republican Party politics. [3] Barnes, the grandson of Whig and Republican party leader Thurlow Weed, was a successful newspaper publisher and the "boss" of both the city of Albany and Albany County as the head of a political machine that elected Republicans to office and ran both governments. [3] : 95  Barnes was also an influential figure at the state and national levels as head of the New York State Republican Party from 1911 to 1914 and New York's member of the Republican National Committee from 1912 to 1916. [4] Barnes was conservative while Roosevelt was progressive; they sometimes worked well together, but were frequently at odds because of their different political ideologies. [3] : 96–97  When Roosevelt ran against incumbent Republican William Howard Taft for the presidency in 1912, Barnes played a key role in obtaining the nomination for Taft. [3] : 99  Roosevelt then ran as the candidate of the new Progressive Party, and the split among Republicans enabled the election of Woodrow Wilson. [3] : 99 

In the 1914 election for governor of New York, Roosevelt supported progressive Republican Harvey D. Hinman, a former member of the New York State Senate, while Barnes backed Charles Seymour Whitman. [3] : 99  In July, Roosevelt made a statement that was widely published, in which he accused Barnes of being a corrupt, obnoxious political boss who was in league with Charles Francis Murphy, the leader of New York's Tammany Hall Democratic Party organization. [3] : 95  According to Roosevelt, Barnes And Murphy worked together in secret to thwart the will of the people, preventing the adoption of progressive reforms. [3] : 95  Whitman won the Republican nomination and was elected governor, defeating Democrat Martin H. Glynn and several other candidates. [5]

In response to Roosevelt's accusation of a conspiracy between Barnes and Murphy, Barnes filed a libel suit in which he asked for $50,000 in damages. [3] : 95  Barnes received advice not to follow through, with supporters suggesting that the publicity would breathe life into Roosevelt's now dormant political career while drawing unwanted attention to Barnes' political activities. [3] : 100  Barnes disregarded this counsel, arguing that his honor had been called into question and he needed to reclaim his good name. [3] : 100  Barnes may also have been motivated by a desire to end Roosevelt's career permanently; Barnes was known to have designs on the United States Senate seat that was up for election in 1916, and a politically viable Roosevelt might block a potential Barnes candidacy. [3] : 100 

Trial

Roosevelt as he appeared in 1916, shortly after the end of the trial Roosevelt of to-day LCCN2013650916.jpg
Roosevelt as he appeared in 1916, shortly after the end of the trial

Pretrial activities included a change of venue from Albany to Syracuse, owing to Barnes' supposed control over Albany's government. [6] Roosevelt's chief counsel during the trial was John M. Bowers, while Barnes was represented by William Mills Ivins Sr. [7] The trial began on April 19, 1915, and took five weeks. [1]

With respect to libel, a defendant must prove his innocence; that is, Roosevelt was required to demonstrate that he had not intentionally imparted a malicious public falsehood about Barnes. [3] : 100  Roosevelt testified for eight days. [3] : 100–101  Rather than arguing that he had made a slip of the tongue or misspoken, or had been misquoted or taken out of context, or that what he had said was merely campaign rhetoric not meant to be taken literally, Roosevelt argued that what he had said was true. [3] : 100–101  Roosevelt and his legal team provided details about several incidents which Roosevelt claimed proved that Barnes was an unsavory political boss, and that he did work cooperatively with Murphy. [3] : 101  Two weeks into the trial, Roosevelt contacted Franklin D. Roosevelt for assistance; Franklin, then serving as Assistant Secretary of the Navy, was a former member of the State Senate. [8] Franklin Roosevelt had disputes with Murphy during his senate tenure, and testified on Theodore Roosevelt's behalf. [8]

The jury took several ballots over two days, and returned a verdict of acquittal. [4] After the trial, it was revealed that until the last ballot, the jury consistently voted 11 to 1 for acquittal, with a lone juror arguing that trial costs ought to be divided between Barnes and Roosevelt. [9]

Effects

The trial essentially ended Barnes' influence; he was not even considered for the 1916 Republican U.S. Senate nomination and soon left his state and national party posts. [3] : 103  He permanently lost his grip on Albany city and county with the 1921 elections, when William Stormont Hackett won the mayor's office and ushered in an era of control by a new machine, this one controlled by Democrat Daniel P. O'Connell. [10]

Roosevelt reclaimed a measure of his status as a national political figure; in 1916, he declined a Progressive presidential nomination and campaigned for Republican nominee Charles Evans Hughes; Hughes narrowly lost to incumbent Woodrow Wilson, but most of Roosevelt's supporters followed him back to the Republican Party. [3] : 102–103  He also advocated for the Preparedness Movement, and when World War I broke out he supported U.S. intervention and made an unsuccessful attempt to raise a volunteer Army unit to command in combat. [11] At the time of his death in 1919, Roosevelt's status had been restored to the point that he was the leading contender for the Republican nomination in the 1920 presidential election. [12]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1912 United States presidential election</span>

Presidential elections were held in the United States on November 5, 1912. Democratic governor Woodrow Wilson of New Jersey unseated incumbent Republican president William Howard Taft while defeating former president Theodore Roosevelt and Socialist Party nominee Eugene V. Debs.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alton B. Parker</span> American judge (1852–1926)

Alton Brooks Parker was an American judge. He was the Democratic nominee in the 1904 United States presidential election, losing in a landslide to incumbent Republican Theodore Roosevelt.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">William Sulzer</span> American politician and governor (1863–1941)

William Sulzer, nicknamed Plain Bill, was an American lawyer and politician. He was the 39th governor of New York serving for 10 months in 1913, and a long-serving U.S. representative from the same state. Sulzer was the first, and to date only, New York governor to be impeached and the only governor to be convicted on articles of impeachment. He broke with his sponsors at Tammany Hall, and they produced convincing evidence that Sulzer had falsified his sworn statement of campaign expenditures.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Frank S. Black</span> American politician and governor of New York (1853–1913)

Frank Swett Black was an American newspaper editor, lawyer and politician. A Republican, he was a member of the United States House of Representatives from 1895 to 1897, and the 32nd governor of New York from 1897 to 1898.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1908 Republican National Convention</span> American political convention

The 1908 Republican National Convention was held in Chicago Coliseum, Chicago, Illinois on June 16 to June 19, 1908. It convened to nominate successors to President Theodore Roosevelt and Vice President Charles W. Fairbanks.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1912 Republican National Convention</span> American political convention

The 1912 Republican National Convention was held at the Chicago Coliseum, Chicago, Illinois, from June 18 to June 22, 1912. The party nominated President William Howard Taft and Vice President James S. Sherman for re-election for the 1912 United States presidential election.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bull Moose Party</span> American political party founded by Theodore Roosevelt

The Progressive Party, popularly nicknamed the Bull Moose Party, was a third party in the United States formed in 1912 by former president Theodore Roosevelt after he lost the presidential nomination of the Republican Party to his former protégé turned rival, incumbent president William Howard Taft. The new party was known for taking advanced positions on progressive reforms and attracting leading national reformers. The party was also ideologically deeply connected with America's radical-liberal tradition. After the party's defeat in the 1912 United States presidential election, it went into rapid decline in elections until 1918, disappearing by 1920. The "Bull Moose" nickname originated when Roosevelt boasted that he felt "strong as a bull moose" after losing the Republican nomination in June 1912 at the Chicago convention.

The Progressive Party was a political party created as a vehicle for Robert M. La Follette, Sr. to run for president in the 1924 election. It did not run candidates for other offices, and it disappeared after the election. The party advocated progressive positions such as government ownership of railroads and electric utilities, cheap credit for farmers, the outlawing of child labor, stronger laws to help labor unions, more protection of civil liberties, an end to American imperialism in Latin America, and a referendum before any president could lead the nation into war.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1914 New York state election</span>

The 1914 New York state election was held on November 3, 1914, to elect the governor, the lieutenant governor, the Secretary of State, the state comptroller, the attorney general, the state treasurer, the state engineer, a U.S. Senator and a judge of the New York Court of Appeals, as well as all members of the New York State Assembly and the New York State Senate, and delegates-at-large to the New York State Constitutional Convention of 1915.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1898 New York state election</span>

The 1898 New York state election was held on November 8, 1898, to elect the governor, the lieutenant governor, the Secretary of State, the state comptroller, the attorney general, the state treasurer and the state engineer, as well as all members of the New York State Assembly and the New York State Senate. This election is the most recent election to feature a candidate for governor of New York who eventually became both Vice President of the United States and President of the United States after serving as Governor of New York.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1912 Republican Party presidential primaries</span> Selection of Republican US presidential candidate

From January 23 to June 4, 1912, delegates to the 1912 Republican National Convention were selected through a series of primaries, caucuses, and conventions to determine the party's nominee for president in the 1912 election. Incumbent president William Howard Taft was chosen over former president Theodore Roosevelt. Taft's victory at the national convention precipitated a fissure in the Republican Party, with Roosevelt standing for the presidency as the candidate of an independent Progressive Party, and the election of Democrat Woodrow Wilson over the divided Republicans.

The 1911 United States Senate election in New York was held from January 17 to March 31, 1911, by the New York State Legislature to elect a U.S. Senator to represent the State of New York in the United States Senate.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1914 United States Senate election in New York</span>

The 1914 United States Senate election in New York was held on November 3. Incumbent Republican Senator Elihu Root chose not to seek re-election. James Wolcott Wadsworth Jr. was elected to a succeed Root, defeating Democrat James Watson Gerard.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1916 Republican Party presidential primaries</span> Selection of Republican US presidential candidate

From February 9 to June 6, through a series of primaries and caucuses, voters of the Republican Party elected delegates to the 1916 Republican National Convention, held June 7 to June 10, 1916, in Chicago, Illinois to choose the party's nominee for President of the United States. The delegate election process was inconclusive, with a majority of delegates not pledged to any candidate and a small plurality supporting Associate Justice of the Supreme Court Charles Evans Hughes. Hughes eventually secured the nomination at the convention on the third ballot.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">William Stormont Hackett</span> American lawyer

William Stormont Hackett was an American lawyer, banker, businessman and politician. A Democrat, he was most notable for serving as the 70th mayor of Albany, New York after winning an election in 1921 that ended control of Albany by the Republican organization headed by William Barnes Jr., and established the dominance of the Democratic organization led by Daniel P. O'Connell and Edwin Corning.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1934 United States Senate election in New York</span>

The 1934 United States Senate election in New York was held on November 6, 1934, to elect a U.S. Senator. Incumbent Democratic Senator Royal Copeland was re-elected to a third term in office, though he would die in office in 1938.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Al Smith 1928 presidential campaign</span> American political campaign

Al Smith, Governor of New York, was a candidate for President of the United States in the 1928 election. His run was notable in that he was the first Catholic nominee of a major party, he opposed Prohibition, and he enjoyed broad appeal among women, who had won the right of suffrage in 1920.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">William Barnes Jr.</span> American journalist and politician (1866–1930)

William Barnes Jr. was an American journalist and politician. The longtime owner and publisher of the Albany Evening Journal, Barnes was most notable as a major behind the scenes player in state and U.S. politics as a leader of New York's Republican Party.

Oliver Dudley Burden was an American lawyer from New York. He was the United States Attorney for the Northern District of New York from 1923 to 1936.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Louis F. Payn</span> American businessman and politician

Louis Frisbie Payn was an American manufacturer and politician from New York. A Republican, he was most prominent for serving as United States Marshal for the Southern District of New York from 1887 to 1881 and Superintendent of the New York State Insurance Department from 1897 to 1900.

References

  1. 1 2 Teddy Roosevelt Got Sued for Libel. He Said He 'Enjoyed' the Trial
  2. ↑ T. R. Wins; Jury in Libel Trial Out 40 Hrs, Los Angeles Herald, Volume XLI, Number 174, 22 May 1915
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 Greene, John Robert (Winter 1989). "Theodore Roosevelt and the Barnes Libel Case: A Reappraisal". Presidential Studies Quarterly. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley-Blackwell. pp. 95–97. JSTOR   40574567.
  4. 1 2 The Encyclopedia of New York State, p. 151.
  5. ↑ "New York Governor, 1914". Our Campaigns.com. Retrieved September 1, 2019.
  6. ↑ "Theodore Roosevelt Libel Trial in Syracuse Comes to a Close". Today in History. Syracuse, NY: Onondaga Historical Association. May 22, 2015.
  7. ↑ Bowers Sums Up for Roosevelt New York Times, May 20, 1915
  8. 1 2 Hindley, Meredith (September–October 2014). "The Roosevelt Bond: Politics and war brought Teddy Roosevelt and Franklin Delano Roosevelt ever closer". Humanities. Washington, DC: National Endowment for the Humanities.
  9. ↑ Thomas, Krystal (April 19, 2011). "A Trial in Syracuse". Theodore Roosevelt Center. Dickinson, ND: Dickinson State University.
  10. ↑ Kennedy, William (1985). O Albany!: Improbable City of Political Wizards, Fearless Ethnics, Spectacular, Aristocrats, Splendid Nobodies, and Underrated Scoundrels. New York, NY: Penguin Random House. pp. 257–258. ISBN   978-1-1016-6594-7 – via Google Books.
  11. ↑ Peck, Garrett (2018). The Great War in America: World War I and Its Aftermath. New York, NY: Pegasus Books. p. 108. ISBN   978-1-6817-7944-7.
  12. ↑ Bomboy, Scott (January 6, 2019). "On this day, Theodore Roosevelt dies unexpectedly". Constitution Center.org. Philadelphia, PA: National Constitution Center.

Sources

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.