Committee of Fifteen

Last updated

The Committee of Fifteen was a New York City citizens' group formed in November 1900 to combat prostitution and gambling. Established by influential members of New York's upper class, the Committee aimed to expose and reduce vice within the city, focusing particularly on areas where police corruption and political protection facilitated illegal activities. Through a combination of undercover investigations and public advocacy, the Committee gathered extensive evidence on urban vice, eventually presenting its findings to Governor Benjamin Barker Odell, Jr. in 1901. While the Committee disbanded later that year, its findings influenced the creation of the Committee of Fourteen, which took up the cause. The Committee of Fifteen's report, The Social Evil With Special Reference to Conditions Existing in the City of New York, published in 1902, became a cornerstone document for early 20th-century urban reform. [1]

Contents

Cartoon showing Gambling-House Raid by the Committee of Fifteen, Justice William Travers Jerome, and District Attorney Eugene Philbin, 1901 New York City A Gambling-House Raid in the Year 1901 NYC.png
Cartoon showing Gambling-House Raid by the Committee of Fifteen, Justice William Travers Jerome, and District Attorney Eugene Philbin, 1901 New York City

Formation and Purpose

The Committee of Fifteen was founded during a period of rising concern over urban vice, driven by fears of moral decline and frustrations with police corruption. In 1900, Bishop Henry Codman Potter publicly condemned New York's "red-light" districts, where gambling and prostitution flourished under police protection. In response, Tammany Hall attempted to address the issue by creating a Committee of Five, which proved ineffective due to internal corruption and inaction. [2] This failure led prominent citizens, including William H. Baldwin, Jr., Edwin R. A. Seligman, and George Foster Peabody, to form the Committee of Fifteen as an independent body with greater resources and public support. [3]

The Committee's purpose extended beyond merely closing down brothels and gambling dens. Its founders viewed vice as symptomatic of broader social problems, including poverty, inadequate housing, and political corruption. They believed that targeting prostitution and gambling would expose systemic issues and pressure the government to enforce moral standards. The Committee's investigations aimed to gather empirical evidence, using it to support reform-oriented legislation and pressure public officials into adopting stricter enforcement measures. [4] [5]

Investigative Methods

The Committee of Fifteen employed a comprehensive and structured approach to investigation. Using private detectives, often former law enforcement officers, the Committee's investigators visited saloons, gambling houses, brothels, and tenements, documenting their observations. Investigators typically posed as patrons to gain access to vice establishments and were tasked with gathering specific details about locations, operators, patrons, and police interactions. Reports from these investigations provided insight into the relationship between police officers and vice operators, revealing instances of bribery and extortion. [6]

Investigators also created a “vice map,” a visual representation of areas with high concentrations of illicit activities, particularly the Tenderloin District. By pinpointing these areas, the Committee could focus its efforts on locations most affected by vice, including several immigrant neighborhoods. The Committee's records included forms titled “Disorderly Tenement House in the City of New York,” which documented each establishment's address, activities, and any signs of police collusion. This systematic collection of evidence enabled the Committee to present a comprehensive picture of the vice economy in New York. [7] [8]

Raiding New York City Collier's Weekly May 25, 1901 p.27 Telling the story of the gambling-house raid by the Committee of Fifteen, Justice William Travers Jerome, and District Attorney Eugene Philbin, 1901 New York City Raiding New York City Collier's Weekly May 25, 1901 p.27.png
Raiding New York City Collier's Weekly May 25, 1901 p.27 Telling the story of the gambling-house raid by the Committee of Fifteen, Justice William Travers Jerome, and District Attorney Eugene Philbin, 1901 New York City

Police Raids and Public Response

One of the Committee's most visible tactics was organizing police raids on vice establishments. The first major raid, on February 26, 1901, targeted gambling houses in the Tenderloin District. However, police sergeants reportedly tipped off operators, allowing them to hide evidence and avoid arrest. The *Collier's Weekly* article on the raid described how officers notified establishments of the raid in advance, giving them time to remove illegal items like roulette wheels and gambling chips. [9] [10]

Justice William Travers Jerome, a significant figure in the Committee's work, personally led some raids to ensure warrants were executed without interference. The high-profile raids attracted media attention and sparked public debate over police corruption. While some citizens praised the Committee's efforts, others viewed the failed raids as evidence of entrenched corruption. The Committee's raids continued despite challenges, raising public awareness and pressuring officials to reform the police force. [11] [12]

William Travers Jerome, 1859-1934 William Travers Jerome, 1859-1934 LCCN2002711837.jpg
William Travers Jerome, 1859-1934

William Travers Jerome

Justice William Travers Jerome played a central role in the Committee's efforts, lending legal authority and reformist enthusiasm. Jerome, a respected judge, became known for his outspoken criticism of police corruption and his commitment to urban reform. He led several raids personally, overseeing enforcement to prevent police interference. Jerome's involvement provided the Committee with a crucial ally in the judiciary, bolstering its credibility and impact.

Jerome's outspoken stance and direct involvement in anti-vice operations reflected his dedication to public service and transparency. His presence in high-profile raids underscored the need for judicial oversight and reinforced the Committee's mission to hold law enforcement accountable. However, Jerome's activism attracted opposition from Tammany Hall-backed officials, creating political tensions that challenged his reform efforts. [13] [14]

Eugene A Philbin, NY District Attorney, 1900-1901 Eugene A Philbin, NY District Attorney, 1900-1901.png
Eugene A Philbin, NY District Attorney, 1900-1901

Eugene Philbin

Eugene Philbin, then serving as District Attorney, worked closely with the Committee, using its findings to prosecute cases of vice and corruption. Though not a formal member, Philbin was a strong supporter, and his office frequently collaborated with the Committee, relying on its investigative reports to build cases against vice operators and their protectors within the police force. Philbin's cooperation illustrated the importance of legal support for civic reform efforts, as his prosecutions highlighted the prevalence of corruption and the need for systemic change.

Philbin's work with the Committee underscored the potential for collaboration between civic groups and government agencies. His prosecutions helped legitimize the Committee's mission and bolstered public support for further legal reforms targeting vice-related activities. [15] [16]

Legislative Impact and Social Reforms

The Committee of Fifteen's work laid the groundwork for legislative reforms targeting urban vice. One of its major accomplishments was supporting proposals by the Tenement House Commission to hold landlords accountable for illegal activities on their properties. In 1901, legislation was passed imposing fines on landlords who allowed gambling or prostitution in their tenements. This represented a significant victory for reformers seeking to address vice at a structural level. [17]

Disorderly House Report, NYC Police 1901 from The Committee of Fifteen Records Disorderly House Report, NYC Police 1901 from The Committee of Fifteen Records.png
Disorderly House Report, NYC Police 1901 from The Committee of Fifteen Records

The Committee's findings also influenced public opinion, sparking calls for further action against police corruption. Through publicized reports and media coverage, the Committee fostered a growing awareness of vice as a systemic issue linked to economic exploitation and governmental inaction. By highlighting these connections, the Committee paved the way for future legislative efforts, including restrictions on Raines law hotels that circumvented liquor and vice laws to operate as brothels. [2] [18]

The Social Evil Report

The Committee's 1902 publication, The Social Evil With Special Reference to Conditions Existing in the City of New York, provided an exhaustive account of New York's prostitution and gambling industries. This report exposed the extent of police protection for vice operators and called for stronger regulations. Among its recommendations were stricter enforcement of anti-soliciting laws and harsher penalties for property owners who permitted illegal activities on their premises. [19]

The report influenced the formation of the Committee of Fourteen, which focused on prostitution in Raines law hotels. This follow-up organization built upon the Committee of Fifteen's legacy, targeting loopholes and advocating for more stringent legal controls over establishments that facilitated vice. The Social Evil report became a reference for other reform movements, emphasizing the Committee's lasting influence on social policy. [20] [21]

Legacy and Historical Significance

The Committee of Fifteen's brief existence left a significant mark on New York's Progressive Era reform landscape. Its innovative approach—combining undercover surveillance with public advocacy and legal action—served as a model for future reform groups. Historians view the Committee as a crucial component of early 20th-century civic engagement, demonstrating how private citizens could influence urban policy and challenge political corruption. [22] [23]

The Committee's efforts also inspired other cities to establish similar groups, seeking to replicate New York's approach to combating urban vice. Although short-lived, the Committee of Fifteen laid the groundwork for subsequent organizations and reforms, shaping public policy and setting a precedent for civic action against systemic corruption. [14]

Members in 1901

Source: [1]

See Also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tenderloin, Manhattan</span> Area of New York City during the late 19th and early 20th centuries

The Tenderloin was an entertainment and red-light district in the heart of the New York City borough of Manhattan during the late 19th and early 20th centuries.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Progressive Era</span> 1890s–1920s US political reform movement

The Progressive Era (1890s-1920s) was a period in the United States during the early 20th century of widespread social activism and political reform across the country. Progressives sought to address the problems caused by rapid industrialization, urbanization, immigration, and political corruption as well as the enormous concentration of industrial ownership in monopolies. Progressive reformers were alarmed by the spread of slums, poverty, and the exploitation of labor. Multiple overlapping progressive movements fought perceived social, political, and economic ills by advancing good democracy, scientific methods, and professionalism; regulating business; protecting the natural environment; and improving working and living conditions of the urban poor.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Social hygiene movement</span> Public health movement

In the United States, the social hygiene movement was an attempt by Progressive era reformers in the late 19th and early 20th century to control venereal disease, regulate prostitution and vice, and disseminate sexual education through the use of scientific research methods and modern media techniques. Social hygiene as a profession grew alongside social work and other public health movements of the era. Social hygienists emphasized sexual continence and strict self-discipline as a solution to societal ills, tracing prostitution, drug use and illegitimacy to rapid urbanization. The movement remained alive throughout much of the 20th century and found its way into American schools, where it was transmitted in the form of classroom films about menstruation, sexually transmitted disease, drug abuse and acceptable sexual behavior in addition to an array of pamphlets, posters, textbooks and films.

Sin City is a nickname that may be applied to an urban area that caters to various vices. These vices may be legal or illegal activities which are tolerated.

The history of New York City (1855–1897) started with the inauguration in 1855 of Fernando Wood as the first mayor from Tammany Hall, an institution that dominated the city throughout this period. Reforms led to the New York City Police Riot of June 1857. There was chaos during the American Civil War, with major rioting in the New York Draft Riots. The Gilded Age brought about prosperity for the city's upper classes amid the further growth of a poor immigrant working class, as well as an increasing consolidation, both economic and municipal, of what would become the five boroughs in 1898.

Progressivism in the United States is a left-leaning political philosophy and reform movement. Into the 21st century, it advocates policies that are generally considered social democratic and part of the American Left. It has also expressed itself within center-right politics, such as progressive conservatism. It reached its height early in the 20th century. Middle/working class and reformist in nature, it arose as a response to the vast changes brought by modernization, such as the growth of large corporations, pollution, and corruption in American politics. Historian Alonzo Hamby describes American progressivism as a "political movement that addresses ideas, impulses, and issues stemming from modernization of American society. Emerging at the end of the nineteenth century, it established much of the tone of American politics throughout the first half of the century."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">The Levee, Chicago</span> Vice district of Chicago

The Levee District was the red-light district of Chicago from the 1880s until 1912, when police raids shut it down. The district, like many frontier town red-light districts, got its name from its proximity to wharves in the city. The Levee district encompassed four blocks in Chicago's South Loop area, initially between Harrison and Polk, between Clark and Dearborn, and then the newer Levee district, between 18th and 22nd streets. It was home to many brothels, saloons, dance halls, and the famed Everleigh Club. Prostitution boomed in the Levee District, and it was not until the Chicago Vice Commission submitted a report on the city's vice districts that it was shut down.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Charles Becker</span> American police officer

Charles Becker was a lieutenant in the New York City Police Department between the 1890s and the 1910s. He was convicted of first-degree murder and executed for the killing of Herman Rosenthal, a bookmaker and gambler, in 1912 near Times Square.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lexow Committee</span> 1894-1895 New York State Senate committee to investigate New York City Police Department corruption

Lexow Committee was a major New York State Senate probe into police corruption in New York City. The Lexow Committee inquiry, which took its name from the committee's chairman, State Senator Clarence Lexow, was the widest-ranging of several such commissions empaneled during the 19th century. The testimony collected during its hearings ran to over 10,000 pages and the resultant scandal played a major part in the defeat of Tammany Hall in the elections of 1894 and the election of the reform administration of Mayor William L. Strong. The investigations were initiated by pressure from Charles Henry Parkhurst.

The Hofstadter Committee, also known as the Seabury investigations, was a joint legislative committee formed by the New York State Legislature on behalf of Governor Franklin D. Roosevelt to probe into corruption in New York City, especially the magistrate's courts and police department in 1931. It led to major changes in the method of arrest, bail and litigation of suspects in New York City. It also coincided with the decline in Tammany Hall's political influence in New York State politics.

Prostitution in Ireland is legal. However, since March 2017, it has been an offence to buy sex. All forms of third party involvement are illegal but are commonly practiced. Since the law that criminalises clients came into being, with the purpose of reducing the demand for prostitution, the number of prosecutions for the purchase of sex increased from 10 in 2018 to 92 in 2020. In a report from UCD's Sexual Exploitation Research Programme the development is called ”a promising start in interrupting the demand for prostitution.” Most prostitution in Ireland occurs indoors. Street prostitution has declined considerably in the 21st century, with the vast majority of prostitution now advertised on the internet.

Ronald Weitzer is an American sociologist specializing in criminology and a professor at George Washington University, known for his publications on police-minority relations and on the sex industry.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alexander S. Williams</span> American police officer

Alexander S. Williams was an American law enforcement officer and police inspector for the New York City Police Department. One of the more colorful yet controversial figures of the NYPD, popularly known as "Clubber Williams" or "Czar of the Tenderloin", he oversaw the Tenderloin and Gas House districts as well as breaking up a number of the city's street gangs, most notably, the Gas House Gang in 1871. He, along with William "Big Bill" Devery and Thomas F. Byrnes, were among several senior NYPD officials implicated by the Lexow Committee during the 1890s.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Frank Moss (lawyer)</span> American political activist and social reformer

Frank Moss was an American lawyer, reformer and author. He was involved in many of the reform movements in New York City shortly before the start of the 20th century up until his death. As a longtime assistant to District Attorney Charles S. Whitman, he was involved in several high-profile criminal cases such as the Rosenthal murder trial in which police detective Charles Becker was found guilty of murder and executed.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Eugene A. Philbin</span> American judge (1857–1920)

Eugene Ambrose Philbin was an American lawyer and politician from New York. He was New York County District Attorney from 1900 to 1901 and later served as a justice on the New York Supreme Court.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of the New York City Police Department</span>

The New York City Police Department (NYPD) originates in the Government of New York City attempts to control rising crime in early- to mid-19th-century New York City. The City's reforms created a full-time professional police force modeled upon London's Metropolitan Police, itself only formed in 1829. Established in 1845, the Municipal Police replaced the inadequate night watch system which had been in place since the 17th century, when the city was founded by the Dutch as New Amsterdam.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of vice in Texas</span>

The history of vice in the U.S. state of Texas has been an important part of the state's past and has greatly influenced its development. Vice activities, such as gambling and prostitution, have historically been a significant facet of both the state's culture and its economy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lola Baldwin</span> Policewoman in Portland, Oregon, US (1860–1957)

Aurora "Lola" Greene Baldwin was an American woman who became one of the first policewomen in the United States. In 1908, she was sworn in by the City of Portland as Superintendent of the Women's Auxiliary to the Police Department for the Protection of Girls, with the rank of detective.

Young black women of the Harlem Renaissance lived with uncertainty of their rights and their roles at a time in which women began to question their sexuality in fear of facing the scrutiny. The women of Harlem began questioning their equal rights and freedom of sexual expression. One occupation that flourished was prostitution. In the early 1900s, New York City thrived with prostitution. Amidst the artistic spectrum of the Harlem Renaissance, the occupation of prostitution created an underlying tension for African American women and their right to solicit their bodies for profit. Preceding World War One, American ideology of sexuality was restrained by religion and denial. Sex was a private matter and was deemed taboo outside of procreation. Idealized notions of the sexual union, however, made non-procreative sex lustful and demeaning. This way of thinking immediately pushes prostitution into the spectrum of being a sinful act and portraying the act in a demeaning manner.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Austen George Fox</span> American lawyer and philanthropist

Austen George Fox was an American lawyer and philanthropist.

References

  1. 1 2 "Committee of Fifteen records 1900-1901". The New York Public Library. Retrieved December 31, 2022.
  2. 1 2 Gilfoyle, Timothy J. *City of Eros: New York City, Prostitution, and the Commercialization of Sex, 1790-1920*. W.W. Norton & Company, 1992.
  3. Beckert, Sven. *The Monied Metropolis: New York City and the Consolidation of the American Bourgeoisie, 1850-1896*. Cambridge University Press, 2001.
  4. Wiebe, Robert H. *The Search for Order, 1877–1920*. Hill and Wang, 1967.
  5. Reitano, Joanne. *The Restless City: A Short History of New York from Colonial Times to the Present*. Routledge, 2006.
  6. Pascoe, Peggy. Relations of rescue: The search for female moral authority in the American West, 1874-1939. Oxford University Press, 1990.
  7. Burrows, Edwin G., and Mike Wallace. *Gotham: A History of New York City to 1898*. Oxford University Press, 1999.
  8. Monkkonen, Eric. *Police in Urban America, 1860-1920*. Cambridge University Press, 2004.
  9. Fronc, Jennifer. *New York Undercover: Private Surveillance in the Progressive Era*. University of Chicago Press, 2009.
  10. "Collier's Weekly article, May 25, 1901".
  11. Joseph F. Spillane (2000). "Making the Modern Criminal Justice System: Law Enforcement and Criminal Justice in Progressive Era New York". Harvard University Press.
  12. Conboy, Martin. *The Press and Popular Culture*. SAGE Publications, 2002.
  13. Burns, Sarah. *Inventing the Public Enemy: Prostitution and the Progressive Era in New York*. Yale University Press, 1989.
  14. 1 2 Hofstadter, Richard. *The Age of Reform*. Knopf, 1955.
  15. Peterson, Jon A. *The Birth of City Planning in the United States, 1840–1917*. Johns Hopkins University Press, 2003.
  16. Burrows, Edwin G. (1999). Gotham: A History of New York City to 1898. Oxford University Press.
  17. "Tenement House Reform in New York". The New York Times. April 1, 1901.
  18. Pivar, David J. *Purity and Hygiene: Women, Prostitution, and the 'American Plan' 1900-1930*. Greenwood Press, 2002.
  19. Committee of Fifteen. The Social Evil With Special Reference to Conditions Existing in the City of New York. New York, 1902.
  20. Cohen, Nancy. *The Reconstruction of American Liberalism, 1865-1914*. University of North Carolina Press, 2002.
  21. Rosen, Ruth. *The Lost Sisterhood: Prostitution in America, 1900-1918*. Johns Hopkins University Press, 1982.
  22. Boyer, Paul. *Urban Masses and Moral Order in America, 1820-1920*. Harvard University Press, 1978.
  23. Addams, Jane. *Democracy and Social Ethics*. New York: Macmillan, 1902.

Further reading