Comparison of Catharism and Protestantism

Last updated

The Cathars or Albigenses have been identified as proto-Protestant by people such as Jean Duvernoy and John Foxe [1] [2] among others. [3] The debate over the relationship with Albigenses and Protestants has been a matter of theological interest and controversy in history. [3] The comparison of Protestantism and Albigensianism was mainly important among French Protestants while German Protestants rarely discussed the Cathars. [3] Affiliations with Catharism and Protestantism have been criticized by many historians, and those arguing for an affiliation between Protestants and Cathars have historically relied upon the presupposition that Cathar theology has been misinterpreted by the medieval Catholic church. [3]

Contents

John Foxe believed the Cathars to be precursors of the reformation. John Foxe from NPG.jpg
John Foxe believed the Cathars to be precursors of the reformation.

John Foxe believed that the Albigenses were similar to reformed theology; he praised the Albigenses as martyrs. [4] Today the Cathars are still seen as protestant precursors by some Baptists, particularly those who adhere to the theory of Baptist successionism. [5]

Points of Comparison

What has appealed to some Protestants about the Albigenses was their rejection of transubstantiation, purgatory, crucifix, prayers for the dead, the invocation of saints and also that the Cathars held to the unique authority of scripture. [3] Cathars also read the Bible in the vernacular languages and rejected most Catholic sacraments. [6] The Cathars also denied infant baptism, as they felt that infants are not able to understand the meaning of baptism. [7]

The Reformation also spread successfully in areas previously inhabited by Cathars; as an example Protestantism was successful in Toulouse, which was also a stronghold of Albigensianism. Jean Carbonnier used this as evidence of Cathars holding reformation ideas; he argued that "people living in Cévennes have held reformation views for several centuries". [3]

Some have also attempted to link the Petrobrusians, who some see as Protestant forerunners and Cathars, due to both groups sharing iconoclasm, credobaptism and the denial of transubstantiation, however such views have been criticized by many historians. [8] [9]

Dualism

Protestants who have attempted to claim Cathars as their precursors have historically denied any charges of dualism on the Cathars as simply hostile claims. [10] The Cathar views on dualism were against both Roman Catholic and Protestant teachings. Protestant historians such as Jacques Basnage, Mosheim and Shroeck have insisted that the charges of dualism and docetism were not authentic, only hostile claims, [11] [12] with such arguments being criticized by Charles Schmidt. [3]

Arguments against Catharic dualism were the following: there were possibly other neo-Manichean dualists in the Middle Ages, but they were not Cathars; that it was a misinterpration of their theology because they denied religious hierarchy set by man or that the accusation of their dualism was merely a hostile false claim. However each argument has been called "unconvincing" by critics of the theory. [3]

See also

Related Research Articles

Anabaptism is a Christian movement which traces its origins to the Radical Reformation.

Catharism was a Christian dualist or Gnostic movement between the 12th and 14th centuries which thrived in Southern Europe, particularly in northern Italy and southern France. Followers were described as Cathars and referred to themselves as Good Christians; in modern times, they are mainly remembered for a prolonged period of religious persecution by the Catholic Church, which did not recognize their unorthodox Christianity.

The Thirty-nine Articles of Religion, finalised in 1571, are the historically defining statements of doctrines and practices of the Church of England with respect to the controversies of the English Reformation. The Thirty-nine Articles form part of the Book of Common Prayer used by the Church of England, the U.S. Episcopal Church, and the Anglican Church in North America among other denominations in the worldwide Anglican Communion and Anglican Continuum.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Albigensian Crusade</span> 13th-century crusade against Catharism in southern France

The Albigensian Crusade or the Cathar Crusade was a military and ideological campaign initiated by Pope Innocent III to eliminate Catharism in Languedoc, what is now southern France. The Crusade was prosecuted primarily by the French crown and promptly took on a political aspect. It resulted in the significant reduction of practicing Cathars and a realignment of the County of Toulouse with the French crown. The distinct regional culture of Languedoc was also diminished.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Peter Martyr Vermigli</span> Italian Reformed theologian

Peter Martyr Vermigli was an Italian-born Reformed theologian. His early work as a reformer in Catholic Italy and his decision to flee for Protestant northern Europe influenced many other Italians to convert and flee as well. In England, he influenced the Edwardian Reformation, including the Eucharistic service of the 1552 Book of Common Prayer. He was considered an authority on the Eucharist among the Reformed churches, and engaged in controversies on the subject by writing treatises. Vermigli's Loci Communes, a compilation of excerpts from his biblical commentaries organised by the topics of systematic theology, became a standard Reformed theological textbook.

Bogomilism was a Christian neo-Gnostic or dualist sect founded in the First Bulgarian Empire by the priest Bogomil during the reign of Tsar Peter I in the 10th century. It most probably arose in the region of Kutmichevitsa, today part of the region of Macedonia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Petr Chelčický</span> 15th century Bohemian Christian radical

Petr Chelčický was a Czech Christian spiritual leader and author in the 15th century Bohemia, now the Czech Republic. He was one of the most influential thinkers of the Bohemian Reformation. Petr Chelčický inspired the Unitas Fratrum who opposed transubstantiation, monasticism and insisted on the primacy of scripture and pacifism. There are multiple parallels with the teachings of the Anabaptists and Petr Chelčický. Czech Baptists have also expressed continuity with the Bohemian reformation by identifying with Petr Chelčický.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Frith (martyr)</span> English Protestant priest, writer, and martyr

John Frith was an English Protestant priest, writer, and martyr.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Smyth (English theologian)</span> English theologian

John Smyth was an English Anglican, Baptist, then Mennonite minister and a defender of the principle of religious liberty.

Baptist successionism is one of several theories on the origin and continuation of Baptist churches. The theory postulates an unbroken lineage of churches which have held beliefs similar to those of current Baptists. Groups often included in this lineage include the Montanists, Paulicians, Cathari, Waldenses, Albigenses, Lollards, and Anabaptists. However most scholars agree that the Baptists originated within 17th-century puritanism.

Protestant Reformers were theologians whose careers, works and actions brought about the Protestant Reformation of the 16th century.

Petrobrusians were a 12th century sect that rejected infant baptism, Catholic mass, veneration of the cross and prayers for the dead. Petrobrusians are sometimes identified as a precursor to the reformation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cathar castles</span> Medieval castles in Languedoc, France

Cathar castles are a group of medieval castles located in the Languedoc region. Some had a Cathar connection in that they offered refuge to dispossessed Cathars in the thirteenth century. Many of these sites were replaced by new castles built by the victorious French Crusaders and the term Cathar castle is also applied to these fortifications despite their having no connection with Cathars. The fate of many Cathar castles, at least for the early part of the Crusade, is outlined in the contemporary Occitan "Chanson de la Croisade", translated into English as the "Song of the Cathar Wars ".

Dualism in cosmology or dualistic cosmology is the moral or spiritual belief that two fundamental concepts exist, which often oppose each other. It is an umbrella term that covers a diversity of views from various religions, including both traditional religions and scriptural religions.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Believer's baptism</span> Person is baptized on the basis of their profession of faith in Jesus Christ

Believer's baptism or adult baptism is the practice of baptizing those who are able to make a conscious profession of faith, as contrasted to the practice of baptizing infants. Credobaptists believe that infants incapable of consciously believing should not be baptized.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Protestantism</span> Form of Christianity

Protestantism is a branch of Christianity that follows the theological tenets of the Protestant Reformation, a movement that began in the 16th century with the goal of reforming the Catholic Church from perceived errors, abuses, and discrepancies.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">British Anabaptism</span>

Anabaptists did not originate in England, but came from continental Europe to escape persecution from Switzerland. English Anabaptism did not touch the country as quickly as other countries since Henry VIII wanted to eradicate heresy quickly and wanted to push a unified religion in England. In fact, during his rule in 1535, Henry VIII had them deported out of England officially with a proclamation that, "Ordered Anabaptists to leave the realm within twelve days after parliament adjourned or suffer the penalty of death." In 1539 he pardoned Anabaptists with a similar proclamation to restore them to the Roman Catholic church. He wanted unity above all. While Henry VIII himself had broken away from the Catholic Church himself, Anabaptists did not face a welcoming country from the beginning of their coming to England. Both Henry and his Tudor successors have charged dissidents on the basis of Anabaptism, some of whom had not such convictions. Looking at primary sources, this means that just because they were charged as an Anabaptist does not mean they were one.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Infant faith</span>

In Christian theology, infant faith is faith in Jesus Christ exercised by infants. Protestant reformer Martin Luther, who emphasized that salvation is attained through faith alone, argued for infant faith using the example of John the Baptist leaping in Elizabeth's womb during the visitation of the pregnant Mary. John Calvin also believed infants were capable of exercising faith, and used this as an argument in favor of infant baptism, though it was not considered essential to his defense of the practice. This was also the view of Reformed orthodox theologians Johannes Wollebius and William Ames.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Siege of Minerve</span> Part of Albigensian Crusade

The siege of Minerve was a military engagement which took place in June and July 1210 during the Albigensian Crusade in the town of Minerve in southern France. It was undertaken by the Catholic Crusaders against the Cathars in southern France, who were regarded as a heretical sect. The Crusaders, led by French nobleman Simon de Montfort, besieged and captured the town. The Crusaders allowed the soldiers defending the town, Catholics, and any Cathars who had not yet reached the status of perfect to go free. Three Cathar perfects who repented were pardoned, but 140 others who refused to do so were burnt at the stake.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Proto-Protestantism</span> Precursors to the Protestant Reformation

Proto-Protestantism, also called pre-Protestantism, refers to individuals and movements that propagated ideas similar to Protestantism before 1517, which historians usually regard as the starting year for the Reformation era. The relationship between medieval sects and Protestantism is an issue that has been debated by historians.

References

  1. 1 2 Pegg, Mark Gregory (2009-01-10). The Corruption of Angels: The Great Inquisition of 1245-1246. Princeton University Press. ISBN   978-1-4008-2475-5.
  2. 1 2 Milbank, Alison (2018-10-18). God & the Gothic: Religion, Romance, & Reality in the English Literary Tradition. Oxford University Press. ISBN   978-0-19-255785-8.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Walther, Daniel (1968-01-01). "Were the Albigenses and Waldenses Forerunners of the Reformation?". Andrews University Seminary Studies (AUSS). 6 (2). ISSN   0003-2980.
  4. Foxe, John. Foxe's Book of Martyrs. The Albigenses were a people of the reformed religion, who inhabited the country of Albi. They were condemned on the score of religion, in the council of Lateran, by order of Pope Alexander III. Nevertheless, they increased so prodigiously, that many cities were inhabited by persons only of their persuasion, and several eminent noblemen embraced their doctrines. Among the latter were Raymond earl of Thoulouse, Raymond earl of Foix, the earl of Beziers, &c.
  5. Hisel, Berlin (2017). Baptist History Notebook. pp. 157–165.
  6. McGlynn, Sean (2015-06-01). Kill Them All: Cathars and Carnage in the Albigensian Crusade. History Press. ISBN   978-0-7509-5194-4.
  7. Swiryn, Robert (November 2010). The Secret of the Tarot. Robert Swiryn. ISBN   978-0-615-30438-0.
  8. History, American Society of Church (1892). Papers of the American Society of Church History. American Society of Church History.
  9. Kim, Elijah Jong Fil (2012-04-06). The Rise of the Global South: The Decline of Western Christendom and the Rise of Majority World Christianity. Wipf and Stock Publishers. p. 201. ISBN   978-1-61097-970-2. Peter bruys became one of the earliest leaders of the Reformation, rejecting images, infant baptism,
  10. Stoyanov, Yuri (2000-08-11). The Other God: Dualist Religions from Antiquity to the Cathar Heresy. Yale University Press. ISBN   978-0-300-19014-4.
  11. Stojanov, Juri P.; Stoyanov, Yuri (2000-08-11). The Other God: Dualist Religions from Antiquity to the Cathar Heresy. Yale University Press. ISBN   978-0-300-08253-1.
  12. Sennis, Antonio (2016). Cathars in Question. Boydell & Brewer. ISBN   978-1-903153-68-0.