Legislative features
The Contraception, Sterilisation, and Abortion (Safe Areas) Amendment Bill is a private member's bill introduced by Labour Party MP Louisa Wall to establish safe zones around abortion clinics and hospitals to protect the safety and privacy of women seeking abortion services in New Zealand. The Bill seeks to provide a regulation-making power to set up safe areas around specific abortion facilities, on a case-by-case basis; and to define behaviours that are prohibited within these safe areas. [2] It amends the Contraception, Sterilisation, and Abortion Act 1977 by inserting section 13A to 13C:
Section 13A prohibits certain behaviours in safe areas including:
- Obstructing a person in a safe area who is approaching, entering, or leaving any building providing abortion services;
- Making a visual recording of another person (Person A) in a safe area in a manner that is likely to cause emotional distress to a person accessing, providing, or assisting with providing abortion services;
- Interfering with another person who may be accessing, providing, or assisting with providing, abortion services in the following ways:
- Advising or persuading another person from accessing or providing abortion services. However, the law provides immunity on the grounds that the advice or persuasion is from an individual who is, with the consent of Person A, accompanying Person A.
- Informing Person A about matters related to the provision of abortion services, other than during the course of providing those services, or assisting with provision of those services. However, the law provides for immunity on the grounds that the information is provided by an individual who is, with the consent of Person A, accompanying Person A.
- Engaging in protest about matters relating to the provision of abortion services.
- Any person who engages in the following prohibited behaviour is liable for a fine not exceeding $1,000. [3]
Section 13B gives police constables the explicit power to arrest those engaging in prohibited behaviours without a warrant. [3]
Section 13C defines "safe areas" as any specified premises at which abortion services are provided; and areas within the vicinity of 150 metres (490 ft) from any part of those premises. [3]
Legislative history
Background
During a parliamentary committee considering the Abortion Legislation Act 2020 on 10 March 2020, ACT Party leader David Seymour had successfully moved an amendment deleting the definition of "safe zones" from the legislation while voting for the proposal to remove the regulatory power to create safe areas. Seymour's amendment was controversial since it had been adopted during a "voting mix-up." [4] [5] [2] The Abortion Legislation Act subsequently passed into law with Seymour's amendment on 18 March, [6] [7] and received royal assent that same month. [2]
In response to the scrapping of the safe area provisions, Labour MP Louisa Wall entered the Contraception, Sterilisation, and Abortion (Safe Areas) Amendment Bill, proposing their restoration, into the member's bill ballot. The bill was drawn from the ballot on 28 July 2020. [1] Wall's bill was drafted in line with the recommendations that were made by the Abortion Legislation Committee when it considered the safe area provisions in the Abortion Legislation Act. [2]
In February 2021, the Attorney-General David Parker released his report on the Contraception, Sterilisation, and Abortion (Safe Areas) Amendment Bill under the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990. While the Attorney-General agreed with the previous vetting advice provided by the Abortion Legislation Committee on safe areas, he expressed concerns that Clause Five providing for safe areas around abortion providers and designating "prohibited behaviour" was inconsistent with the Bill of Rights Act since it criminalised "communicating in a manner that is objectively emotionally distressing." He proposed replacing the offending text with an extended definition of "intimidation" to include communicative acts carried out by anti-abortion activists such as sign-waving, "sidewalk counselling" and video recording. [2]
First Reading
The CSA (Safe Areas) Amendment Bill passed its first reading on 10 March 2021 by a margin of 100 to 15 votes. The Bill was supported by its initiator Louisa Wall, the opposition National Party's spokesperson for women Nicola Grigg, Attorney-General David Parker, Green MP Jan Logie, National MP Barbara Kuriger, and Labour MP Sarah Pallett, who delivered speeches defending women's access to abortion and criticising the conduct of some anti-abortion activists. ACT Party leader David Seymour voted in favour of the bill, stating his party's support for a ban on the intimidation and obstruction of abortion patients but criticised the communication ban as an erosion of free speech. National MP Michael Woodhouse expressed concerns about free speech but supported the passage on the bill on the grounds that the public's voice needed to be heard at the select committee stage. [8] [9]
By contrast, Labour MP Anahila Kanongata'a-Suisuiki and National MP Chris Penk voted against the bill, describing it as an erosion of free speech and expressing concerns about the broad interpretation of "communication." National MP Christopher Luxon also voted against the bill but did not speak during the first reading. [8] [9]
Select committee stage
Following the first reading, the Bill was referred to Parliament's health select committee. Public submissions were open until 28 April 2021. [1] At the time, the health select committee's membership consisted of the chairperson Liz Craig, Chris Bishop, Elizabeth Kerekere, Neru Leavasa, Tracey McLellan, Debbie Ngarewa-Packer, Sarah Pallett, Gaurav Sharma, Penny Simmonds, Tangi Utikere, Brooke van Velden, Simon Watts, and Jan Logie. [10] The Bill received 890 submissions from interested groups and individuals. 97 submitters submitted their petitions either in person at Wellington or via video conference. [11]
The Attorney-General David Parker also advised the Health select committee on the provisions of the Bill. He expressed concerns about the broad scope of the "communicating" provision of the Bill, which in his assessment clashed with Section 14 of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990. As a result, Section 13A of the Bill was amended to narrow the criteria for behaviour prohibited in safe areas including:
- Visually recording people in a safe area; advising or persuading abortion users and providers from accessing or providing abortion services;
- Informing abortion services users and providers about matters relating to the provision of abortion services unless it was when the abortion services were being provided;
- Engaging in protests against abortion services;
- Removing the definitions of "prohibited behaviour" and "protected person."
The Attorney-General subsequently approved the Health select committee's changes to the Bill on 25 August 2021. [10] [11]
Second Reading
The Bill's second reading was first held on 10 November 2021. The bill's initiator Wall outlined the amendments that the Health select committee had made to the bill following advice from the Attorney-General. Labour MP Sarah Pallett also spoke in defence of the bill, asserting that it did not criminalise "peaceful prayer" in a safe area while proscribing intimidatory behaviour such as recording abortion services users and providers. National MP Simon Watts expressed support for the bill on the grounds that it protected women seeking abortion services. [11]
The second reading of the Bill adjourned on 15 February 2022. Several speakers spoke in favour of the Bill while none of its opponents spoke during that debate. Labour MP Vanushi Walters spoke about the harassment, intimidation, and obstruction encountered by women seeking abortion services from anti-abortion activists. [12] [13] Similar sentiments were echoed by fellow Labour MP Rachel Brooking. Both National MP Mark Mitchell and Labour MP Priyanca Radhakrishnan argued that the bill did not infringe on the right to protest but protected the rights of women and families to access abortion services while under extreme stress. [13]
Labour MP Kieran McAnulty argued that anti-abortion opponents were entitled to their views but did not have the right to obstruct others from accessing abortion services. Green MP Jan Logie justified the necessity of the Bill in response to the surge in aggressive anti-abortion activism at abortion providers. She also spoke about the assault on Greens co-leader James Shaw by an anti-abortion activist in 2019. [13] [12]
Labour MPs Willow-Jean Prime, David Clark, and Ginny Andersen argued that the Bill struck the right balance between protecting the rights of women to access abortion services and anti-abortion supporters' right to freedom of expression. [13] Similar sentiments were expressed by ACT Party deputy leader Brooke van Velden and National MP Chris Bishop. The ACT Party and Bishop had both initially opposed the inclusion of safe areas in the Abortion Legislation Act 2020 but had since revised their positions on the grounds the Safe Areas Amendment Bill struck the right balance between protecting individual rights and free speech. [12] [13] National MP Joseph Mooney also spoke in favor of the revisions of the Bill made by the Attorney-General. Satisfied with these changes, Mooney voted in favour of the Bill during its second reading. [13]
Following the debate, support for the Bill among Members of Parliament increased further by a margin of 108–12. The Greens, ACT and Maori Party all bloc-voted for the legislation. While 62 Labor MPs and 24 National MPs voted in favor of the Bill using their conscience votes, three Labour MPs and nine National MPs voting against it when debate ended. [12] Of the Labour caucus, Anahila Kanongata'a-Suisuiki and Jamie Strange maintained their opposition to the bill, while Rino Tirikatene switched from voting against at the first reading to voting in favour, whereas Neru Leavasa changed his vote in the opposite direction. Michael Wood also supported the bill during its second reading, after not casting any vote at the first reading. [13]
The membership of the National caucus had changed slightly since the first reading, with Nick Smith, who voted against the bill during its first reading, being replaced by Harete Hipango, who also voted against the bill. Simeon Brown, Simon O'Connor, Chris Penk, Penny Simmonds and Louise Upston continued their opposition to the bill. The party's new leader Christopher Luxon and MPs David Bennett, Jacqui Dean, Mooney, Scott Simpson and Tim van de Molen switched to supporting the bill. Michael Woodhouse switched from support to opposition, while Melissa Lee and Maureen Pugh also voted against, having recorded abstaining votes at the first reading. [13]
Committee of the Whole House stage
The next stage of the legislative process was the Committee of the Whole House, which took place on 2 March 2022. No MPs proposed amendments or sought to debate any clause of the bill, so the Committee rapidly passed it without any changes, with a single vote being held on all clauses. The result of 98 in favour, 12 opposed saw MPs take the same positions that they had for the second reading vote, excepting that ten National MPs (Chris Bishop, Gerry Brownlee, Judith Collins, Matt Doocey, Ian McKelvie, Joseph Mooney, Todd Muller, Shane Reti, Scott Simpson and Erica Stanford) who had voted for the second reading cast no vote on this occasion. [14] The bill proceeded to its third reading. [12] [15]
Third Reading
The CSA (Safe Areas) Amendment Bill was read for its third time on 16 March 2022. National MPs Simon O'Connor and Chris Penk were the only opponents of the bill who spoke in the final debate. The Bill's sponsor Louisa Wall spoke in favour of the Bill. Other MPs who spoke in favour of the Bill included National MP Simon Watts, Labour MPs Liz Craig, Emily Henderson, Camilla Belich, Sarah Pallett, Vanushi Walters, Guarav Sharma, Green MP Jan Logie, ACT leader David Seymour, and fellow ACT MP Karen Chhour. Following the debate, the bill passed by margin of 108 to 12 votes. Twelve MPs (nine from National and three from Labour) voted against the bill while 60 Labour MPs, 24 National MPs, and the entire Green, ACT and Maori Party parliamentary caucuses voted for the bill. [16] [17]
On 18 March 2022, the new legislation received Royal Assent from the Governor General of New Zealand. [1]
The House of Representatives is the sole chamber of the New Zealand Parliament. The House passes laws, provides ministers to form Cabinet, and supervises the work of government. It is also responsible for adopting the state's budgets and approving the state's accounts.
Abortion in New Zealand is available within the framework of the Abortion Legislation Act 2020, which entirely eliminated the criminal status of abortion and allows termination on request during the first 20 weeks of pregnancy. After 20 weeks abortion is permitted only if a health practitioner deems it "clinically appropriate" and consults at least one other health practitioner. However, the law does not specify what the conditions are which constitute "clinically appropriate", and there are no criminal penalties. Abortion is illegal only if a person who is not a licensed health practitioner procures or performs it.
David Allister Bennett is a New Zealand former National Party politician. He was the Member of Parliament for Hamilton East from 2005 to 2020 and a list MP from 2020 to 2023. He was Minister for Food Safety and Minister of Veterans' Affairs in the final year of the Fifth National Government.
The Abortion Law Reform Association of New Zealand (ALRANZ) is New Zealand's national abortion-rights advocacy group in existence since 1971. Since the decriminalisation of abortion in 2020, the organisation continues to monitor and lobby for changes to the law. The organisation is based in Wellington, publishes a quarterly newsletter, and has its own web site.
Voice for Life, formerly known as the Society for the Protection of the Unborn Child (SPUC), is a New Zealand anti-abortion advocacy group. It has also lobbied against infanticide, embryonic stem cell research, cloning and euthanasia. In recent years, it has strongly campaigned against the decriminalisation of euthanasia in New Zealand as well as abortion, but was unsuccessful in preventing the decriminalisation of either in 2020.
Louisa Hareruia Wall is a New Zealand former double international sportswoman, former politician, and human rights advocate. She represented New Zealand in both netball as a Silver Fern from 1989 to 1992 and in rugby union as a member of the Black Ferns from 1995 to 2001, including as a member of the 1991 World Netball Championships runner-up team and 1998 Women's Rugby World Cup winning team.
Michael Allan Woodhouse is a former New Zealand politician. He was a Member of Parliament for the National Party from 2008 to 2023.
Contraception, Sterilisation, and Abortion Act 1977, also known as the CS&A Act 1977, is an Act of Parliament in New Zealand. It was passed shortly following an inquiry by the Royal Commission on Contraception, Sterilisation and Abortion. The legislation established the legal framework for abortion in New Zealand; with abortions being allowed provided the procedure was approved by two certifying consultants and that the circumstances met the criteria of the Crimes Act 1961. In March 2020, several of its provisions were amended by the Abortion Legislation Act 2020, which eased access to abortion and eliminated most of the criteria established by the Crimes Act 1961.
Ian Robert Flockhart McKelvie is a New Zealand politician. He represented the National Party in the New Zealand House of Representatives from 2011 to 2023.
Simeon Peter Brown is a New Zealand politician and Member of Parliament in the House of Representatives for the National Party.
Maria Josina Elisabeth "Marja" Lubeck is a New Zealand politician. She was a member of parliament in the House of Representatives for the Labour Party.
Jamie Ross Strange is a New Zealand politician. He is a Member of Parliament in the House of Representatives for the Labour Party.
Anahila Lose Kanongata'a is a New Zealand social worker and politician. She served as a Member of Parliament for the Labour Party from 2017 to 2023.
The End of Life Choice Act 2019 is an Act of Parliament in New Zealand that gives people with a terminal illness the option of receiving assisted suicide or euthanasia. The act came into force on 7 November 2021, twelve months after the 2020 euthanasia referendum was declared in favour of the legislation.
The Abortion Legislation Act 2020 is an Act of Parliament in New Zealand allowing unrestricted access to abortion within the first 20 weeks of pregnancy, and repealing sections of the Crimes Act 1961 related to unlawful abortion. After the 20-week period, women seeking an abortion must consult a qualified health practitioner who will assess their physical health, mental health, and well-being. The Act also provides provisions for conscientious objection rights for medical practitioners and exempts abortion services from certain Crimes Act provisions, while extending the definition of health services to include abortion services under the Health and Disability Commissioner Act 1994.
Nicola Anna Grigg is a New Zealand politician and Member of Parliament in the House of Representatives representing the Selwyn electorate since October 2020. Since 27 November 2023, she has served as the Minister of State for Trade, Minister for Women, and an Associate Minister of Agriculture in the Sixth National Government. She is a member of the National Party.
The 53rd New Zealand Parliament was a meeting of the legislature in New Zealand. It opened on 25 November 2020 following the 17 October 2020 general election, and dissolved on 8 September 2023 to trigger the next election. It consisted of 120 members of Parliament (MPs) with five parties represented: the Labour and Green parties, in government, and the National, Māori and ACT parties, in opposition. The Sixth Labour Government held a majority in this Parliament. Jacinda Ardern continued as prime minister until her resignation on 25 January 2023; she was succeeded by Chris Hipkins.
Rawiri Wikuki Waititi is a New Zealand politician and co-leader of Te Pāti Māori alongside Debbie Ngarewa-Packer. He has served as the Member of Parliament (MP) for Waiariki since 2020, when his election returned Te Pāti Māori to the New Zealand Parliament following their defeat at the 2017 general election.
Penelope Elsie Simmonds is a New Zealand politician, Member of Parliament and a Minister in the House of Representatives for the National Party. She previously served as the chief executive of the Southern Institute of Technology. Following the 2023 New Zealand general election, Simmonds assumed the disability issues, environmental, tertiary education and skills, and associate social development and employment portfolios in the Sixth National Government.
The Electoral (Integrity) Amendment Act 2018 is an Act of Parliament by the New Zealand Parliament that amends the Electoral Act 1993. The act forces the expulsion of members of the New Zealand Parliament who have left or been expelled from their party. If the member of Parliament was elected as an electorate MP, expulsion triggers a by-election. The bill was passed on 27 September 2018 as part of the coalition agreement between the Labour and New Zealand First parties and the Green Party's confidence-and-supply agreement with Labour. The Bill has been described by the media and public as the "Waka jumping bill."
