HWS Round Robin

Last updated
HWS Round Robin
HostHobart and William Smith Colleges
Established2007
RegionInternational
Format British Parliamentary
Current championStanford University
Website people.hws.edu/barnes/hwsrr/

The HWS Round Robin (HWS RR) is an invitational British Parliamentary (BP) debate tournament hosted annually by the Hobart and William Smith Colleges in Geneva, New York. Participation in the HWS RR is considered prestigious among BP debaters [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] as it is limited to exactly 16 teams that qualify via either an automatic bid given to the champions of major debate tournaments that happen throughout the year, or a competitive application to the tournament's selections committee, with auto-bid teams given priority. [6] [7] [8]

Contents

Unlike most parliamentary debate tournaments, such as the World Universities Debating Championship, which use power-pairing [9] to determine preliminary round matches, the HWS RR uses round-robin scheduling to determine team pairings for each of its five preliminary rounds, before advancing the top four teams to the final. [10] The tournament is also notable for its use of dual judging panels, in contrast to the established practice of allocating just one panel of judges per room. [11] [12]

History

The HWS RR was started in 2007 by the HWS Debate Team, with the intent of designing an annual tournament of champions for BP debate. While the World Universities Debating Championship (WUDC) had already long been established at the time, its open nature meant allowing a significant variation in skill among teams. [13] From 2009 to 2013 the tournament was funded by the Open Society Foundations. [14] [15]

Selection

Each year, invitations are sent to all four teams that make it to the Open Grand Final of the WUDC, as well as to the winning team of each of the following 12 major tournaments:

This means an automatic bid goes to a total of 16 teams, the exact number required for a five-round round robin BP tournament to work. If a team qualifies for more than one auto-bid (by winning more than one of the tournaments listed) or decides not to attend the tournament, then any extra slot is opened up for an at-large bid, where teams that apply are selected based on their achievements in debating. [17]

Structure

The HWS RR is conducted in the British Parliamentary format, the same one used by the WUDC. In BP, there are four teams, of two debaters each, that compete in a single round.

At the end of the round a panel of judges deliberates and ranks each team from first to fourth, with the first-placer receiving the full 3 points and the last-placer receiving no point. Uniquely, the HWS RR uses two panels, which means the maximum number of points a team can theoretically win in a single round is 6 points. Dual rooms began to see use in 2016 as part of research on the reliability of judge decisions. [18]

The tournament has five preliminary rounds and one final round. During the preliminaries, teams are matched in such a way that they are never in the same room as a team they have faced before. The four teams that accrue the most number of points by the end of the fifth round are advanced to the final round. The winners and runners-up of the final are considered winners and runners-up of the HWS RR for that year.

Past Tournaments

YearWinnersRunners-upFinalistsBest SpeakerTopic of Final
2024 [19] Cambridge/Stanford (Ashish Kumar & Tejas Subramaniam) Chicago/Sydney (Aditya Dhar & Ellie Stephenson) McGill (Max Rosen & Reana Yan), Chicago/Princeton (Devesh Kodnani & Xiao-ke Lu)Max Rosen & Tejas Subramaniam"This House, as the chemist, would take the chemical weapons job." [lower-alpha 1]
2023 [20] Stanford (Tejas Subramaniam & Arthur Lee) LSE (Matt Caito & Ahmed Elsammak)Princeton (Jane Mentzinger & Greg Weaving), Princeton (Xiao-ke Lu & Isaac Cape)Tejas Subramaniam"This House believes that feminist movements in developing nations should prioritize the strategy of advocating for carceral feminism."
2022 [21] McGill (Naomi Panovka & Max Rosen) Oxford (Rachel O'Nunain & Oskar Sherry) Harvard (Hamza Chaudhry & Aditya Dhar), Princeton (Xiao-ke Lu & Greg Weaving)Hamza Chaudhry"This House supports increased military spending and rearmament plans announced by Germany and other EU countries."
2021 Zagreb (Tin Puljić & Lovro Šprem)LSE (Abhinav Bathula & Trenton Sewell) Ateneo (David Africa & Luigi Alcaneses), Harvard (Aditya Dhar & Asher Spector)Abhinav Bathula"This House believes that the legacy of historical figures should not suffer due to those figures' immoral actions, if those actions were generally seen as morally unproblematic by their own society."
2020 [22] Yale (David Edimo & Eva-Marie Quinones)Cambridge (Lucía Arce & Tudor Musat) IBA Dhaka (Sajid Khandaker & Sourodip Paul), Harvard (Aditya Dhar & Michael Nehme)Lucía Arce"This House believes that individuals have a moral obligation to not have biological children."
2019Oxford (Kit Mercer & Jason Xiao) Melbourne (Stuart Dixon & Connor O'Brien)Harvard (Danny DeBois & Mars He), Harvard (John Hunt & Michael Nehme)Danny DeBois"This House believes that the Black Lives Matter movement should embrace open carry gun laws and engage in armed community patrols."
2018Cambridge (Alasdair Donovan & Ian Wu)Oxford (Jason Xiao & Lee Chin Wee)Stanford (Harry Elliott & Bobbi Leet), Tel Aviv (Noam Dahan & Tom Manor)Lee Chin Wee"This House believes that the interests of the Chinese people would be better served by a peaceful transition into a democracy, rather than a continuation of the one-party rule."
2017Tel Aviv (Dan Lahav & Sella Nevo)Harvard (Danny DeBois & Archie Hall) Cornell (Enting Lee & Adrian Muttalib), Yale (Evan Lynyak, Henry Zhang)Danny DeBois"This House believes that governments should abandon the strategy of decapitation in fighting terrorism."
2016Cambridge (Ashish Kumar & Michael Dunn-Goekjian)Tel Aviv (Ayal Hayut-Man & Dan Lahav)Cambridge (George Clay & Etsuko Lim), Yale (Tony Nguyen, Henry Zhang)Michael Dunn-Goekjian"This House supports health insurance companies offering optional lump sum payments to terminally ill patients who choose to forgo expensive life extending medical treatments."
2015 Hart House (Joe McGrade & Veenu Goswami)Cambridge (Ashish Kumar & Michael Dunn-Goekjian)Harvard (Bo Seo & Fanele Mashwama), Hart House (Lex Sundarsingh, Aislin Flynn)Michael Dunn-Goekjian"This House believes that prominent civil society activists should choose not to run for elected office."
2014 Sydney (Chris Bisset & Daniel Swain)Yale (Zach Bakal & Nick Cugini)Cambridge (Ashish Kumar & Kitty Parker-Brooks), Cambridge (Michael Dunn-Goekjian, Freddy Powell)Daniel Swain"This House believes that, within broad budgetary constraints, environmental policy should be decided by unelected scientific experts selected by their peers."
2013 Lincoln's Inn (James Hardy & Harish Natarajan)Cornell (Alex Bores & Danny Blackman) Loyola Marymount (James Kilcup & James Molison), Yale (Sam Ward-Packard & Andrew Connery)Harish Natarajan"This House would use diversity quotas for university admissions."
2012Stanford (Michael Baer & Shengwu Li)Oxford (Will Jones & Ben Woolgar)Sydney (Dominic Bowes & Paul Karp), Yale (Nick Cugini & Ben Kornfeld)Ben Woolgar"This House believes that the government should subsidise newspapers."
2011Stanford (Alexander Campbell & Anish Mitra)Oxford (Stephanie Bell & Ben Woolgar)Hart House (Veenu Goswami & Steve Penner), MIT (Adam Goldstein & Peter McKee)Ben Woolgar"This House believes that whenever individuals have a choice between spending money on luxuries or donating it to ameliorating suffering, morality demands donating."
2010 TCD Hist (Niamh Ni Mhaoileoin & Niall Sherry) Queen's (Adam Hetherington & Cristine Wadsworth)Sydney (Bronwyn Cowell & Tim Mooney), Cornell (Ryan Yeh & Alex Bores)Tim Mooney"This House would ban parents from genetically selecting children who lack a predisposition to homosexuality."
2009Oxford (Jonathan Leader Maynard & Alexander Worsnip)Hart House (Richard Lizius & Ian Freeman)Loyola Marymount (Kevin Kiley & Alexander Schwab), Middle Temple (Douglas Cochran & Daniel Warents)Jonathan Leader Maynard"This House would eliminate executive pardons."
2008Harvard (Cormac Early & Lewis Bollard) Claremont (Charlie Sprague & Kari Wohlschlegel)Hart House (John Ashbourne & Alexander Levy), Oxford (Lewis Turner & Alexander Worsnip)Lewis Turner"This House would establish an international force to arrest those indicted by the International Criminal Court."
2007Yale (Adam Chilton & David Denton)Harvard (Cormac Early & Allen Ewalt)Harvard (Lewis Bollard & Rezwan Haque), McGill (Leon Grek & Susannah Patton)Adam Chilton"This House supports requiring community service for graduation from high school."

Notes

  1. ↑ The infoslide for this motion reads: "In 1973, philosopher Bernard Williams presents the following example. Kelly is an unemployed chemist who is offered a job developing a new category of chemical weapons (seemingly not prohibited by treaty). Kelly has always been strongly opposed to weapons of mass destruction, but jobs are scarce and Kelly has a family to provide for. Kelly’s spouse makes a very modest salary as a preschool teacher, and has no qualms about Kelly working on these new weapons. If Kelly does not take the job, they are told that someone else without any reservations about the weapons research will take the job and will likely move the development ahead more quickly."

See also

Related Research Articles

The Canadian University Society for Intercollegiate Debate is the national organization which governs all English language competitive university debating and public speaking in Canada. It sanctions several official annual tournaments and represents Canadian debating domestically and abroad. Its membership consists of student debating unions, sanctioned by their respective universities, from across Canada. CUSID has been described as "a student-run, parliamentary debate league with close ties to the American Parliamentary Debate Association".

The American Parliamentary Debate Association (APDA) is the oldest intercollegiate parliamentary debating association in the United States. APDA sponsors over 50 tournaments a year, all in a parliamentary format, as well as a national championship in late April. It also administers the North American Debating Championship with the Canadian University Society for Intercollegiate Debate (CUSID) every year in January. Although it is mainly funded by its member universities, APDA is an entirely student-run organization.

The North American Debating Championship is one of the two official university debate championships of North America. It is sanctioned by the national university debating associations in the United States and Canada, the American Parliamentary Debate Association and the Canadian University Society for Intercollegiate Debate. It has been held each winter on an alternating basis between the United States and Canada since 1992. The host university arranges all judging and is not allowed in the competition. The most frequent hosts have been the University of Toronto and McGill University, which have each hosted the championship three times. Bates College, Cornell University, Johns Hopkins University, and Queen's University have each hosted twice. This tournament, often abbreviated as NorthAms, is not to be confused with the North American Universities Debating Championship, abbreviated as NAUDC, which is hosted separately in the fall of each year as a British Parliamentary Style tournament. The two events are coordinated such that each is hosted by a different country, the United States or Canada, in a given year.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">World Universities Debating Championship</span> International student tournament

The World Universities Debating Championship (WUDC) is the world's largest international debating tournament and one of the largest annual international student events. WUDC is held in the British Parliamentary format.

There are several venues of competition for policy debate in the United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">British Parliamentary Style</span> Style of competitive debate

British Parliamentary style is a major form of academic debate that originated in Liverpool in the mid 1800s. It has gained wide support globally and is the official format of the World Universities Debating Championship (WUDC).

The Tournament of Champions (TOC) is a national high school speech and debate tournament held at the University of Kentucky every year in a weekend in April. Tournament of Champions is considered to be the national championship of the “National Circuit", and is one of the most prestigious and competitive American high school speech and debate tournaments. Tournament of Champions currently holds competition in Policy debate, Lincoln–Douglas debate, Public Forum debate, Congressional Debate, World Schools Debate, Extemporaneous Speaking, Original Oratory, Informative Speaking, Dramatic Interpretation, Duo Interpretation, Humorous Interpretation, Oral Interpretation, and Program Oral Interpretation.

The Otago University Debating Society (OUDS) is a debating society established in June 1878 and is the oldest society of the University of Otago, the first university to be founded in New Zealand. Echoing trends in Australia and the United States, in the latter decades of the nineteenth century debating was seen as an important talent for New Zealand's thought leaders, and was one of the three sports in the New Zealand University Games from 1902.

The Australasian Intervarsity Debating Championships (known colloquially as "Australs") is an annual debating tournament for teams from universities in the Australasian region. It is one of the world's largest debating tournaments, second only in size to the World Universities Debating Championship (WUDC), the European Universities Debating Championships (EUDC) and one of the largest annual student events in the world. Australs follows the Australia-Asian Debating format (three speakers plus replies), rather than the British Parliamentary Style used at WUDC. It is held every year in early-July under the auspices of the Australasian Intervarsity Debating Association (AIDA). The host university is selected a year before at a meeting of the Council of the Australasian Intervarsity Debating Association.

Square Off is a television debate program broadcast on the ABS-CBN News Channel (ANC). It broadcasts every Friday at 6:00 pm PST, with replays throughout the week. The show is hosted by Maiki Oreta and is primarily sponsored by the Philippine Graphic.

The United Asian Debating Championship (UADC) is an annual debating tournament for teams from universities in Asia. It is the largest inter-varsity Parliamentary Debate tournament in Asia, with over 600 participants. The UADC holds debates in the Asian 3-on-3 format Parliamentary Debating. The 1st UADC was hosted by Assumption University, Bangkok in 2010.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Yale Debate Association</span>

The Yale Debate Association (YDA) is Yale University's only competitive intercollegiate debate team. Founded in 1908, it is the most prolific winner of the American Parliamentary Debate Association's Club of the Year award. The YDA was also the first American team to win and have the top speaker at the modern World Championships. Currently, the YDA is the fourth-ranked collegiate debate society in the world, and as of January 2024, the highest ranked in North America.

The Harvard College Debating Union is Harvard University's only internationally competitive debate team. The union has won the most American Parliamentary Debate Association National Championships and the 2014, 2016 and 2018 World Universities Debating Championships.

The Debattierclub Stuttgart (DCS), also known as the Stuttgart Debating Union, is the debating society of the University of Stuttgart. It holds debates in both German and English. It was founded in 2004 and is now one of the internationally most successful German debating societies. The DCS is Vice World Champion and provided the Second Best Speaker of the World in English as a foreign language (EFL) at the World Universities Debating Championship (WUDC) 2010. At WUDC 2011, the DCS provided the Fourth Best Speaker of the World in English as a second language (ESL) as well as the Best Speaker of the World in EFL.

The World Universities Debating Championship in Spanish or Campeonato Mundial Universitario de Debate en Español (CMUDE) is the world's largest and most important debating tournament in Spanish.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">University of Queensland Debating Society</span>

The University of Queensland Debating Society (UQDS) is the debating society of the University of Queensland. It has been recognised as one of the oldest and most active student societies at the University of Queensland and one of the most active and successful university debating societies in the world. The UQ Debating Society was also a founding member of the University of Queensland Union.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Queen's Debating Union</span>

The Queen's Debating Union is the debating society of Queen's University in Kingston, Ontario, Canada. It was founded as Canada's first debating society in 1843 and became one of the four founding organisations of Canadian University Society for Intercollegiate Debate. It continues to be an active club on campus and has a strong presence both domestically and internationally as a competitive parliamentary debating club.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Asociación Mexicana de Debate</span>

The Asociación Mexicana de Debate (AMD) is the regulating body for debate in México, formed by students, former students and debate coaches with experience at the most important debating competitions in the world, such as the World Universities Debating Championship, the World Universities Debating Championship in Spanish and the World Schools Debating Championship, and it is the only body that organizes British Parliamentary, Karl Popper and World Schools debate competitions in the country, including two national championships. AMD has the objective of spreading debate all around the country.

The US Universities Debating Championship (USUDC) is the largest British Parliamentary debating tournament in the United States, and one of the largest debate tournaments in the world. The event is held for college and university students attending school in the United States, and is hosted by a different university each year. The host is selected by the member schools of the US Universities Debate Association. The event determines the National Champions for the year.

Li Shengwu is a Singaporean economist residing in the United States. He works as an associate professor at Harvard University, conducting research mainly on behavioral economics. Li is also the grandson of Lee Kuan Yew, the first prime minister of Singapore.

References

  1. ↑ Robinson, Melia; Stanger, Melissa (2014-05-24). "Michael Dunn-Goekjian Reached the Finals of the World's Highest-Level Debating Tournament". Business Insider . Retrieved 2023-01-07. ...the final of the HWS Round Robin, a high-level tournament that invites collegiate champions from around the world.
  2. ↑ Trinity Term 2018 Termcard. The Oxford Union Society. 2018. p. 70. ...the highly prestigious Hobart and William Smith Round Robin...
  3. ↑ "Debate teams from 10 countries heading to HWS for Round Robin tourney". Finger Lakes Times. 2017-04-03. Retrieved 2023-01-07.
  4. ↑ "2 Ghanaian students invited to prestigious world debate tournament". Joy FM. 2020-01-13. Retrieved 2023-01-07. The HWS Round Robin is an international tournament of champions hosted in each April which is second only to the World Championships in competitiveness.
  5. ↑ Megha, Momotaz Rahman (2020-09-15). "IBA-DU 1st Asian team to reach finals with Harvard, Cambridge, Yale at prestigious HWS debate". The Daily Star . Retrieved 2023-01-07.
  6. ↑ "Yale Enthusiastically Forays Into BP" (PDF). The Yale Debate Association Newsletter. Yale Debate Association. 2013. p. 8. Retrieved 2023-01-07. ...the HWS Round Robin, an invitational tournament to which only the top 16 teams in the world are invited...
  7. ↑ "HWS Round Robin Results – Tel Aviv Champions & Danny DeBois (Harvard) Top Speaker!". Achte Minute. 2017-04-25. Retrieved 2023-01-07. ...team spots, which can be achieved either through winning a prestigious named tournament or through a competitive at-large bidding process...
  8. ↑ Easter Term 2018 Term Card. The Cambridge Union Society. 2018. p. 6. Retrieved 2023-01-07. ...the HWS round robin - competing against 16 of the most skilled teams in the world.
  9. ↑ "Section 36. Tabulation of the Preliminary Rounds". WUDC Constitution. World Universities Debating Council. Retrieved 2023-01-07. For rounds two through nine, the debates shall be drawn by the Tab Director(s) on a 'power-pairing' basis...
  10. ↑ "Tournament Policies". HWS Round Robin. Retrieved 2023-01-07.
  11. ↑ "Section 34. Overview of the Format". WUDC Constitution. World Universities Debating Council. Retrieved 2023-01-07. An Adjudication Panel shall be allocated by the Adjudication Core to judge each debate...
  12. ↑ "Oxford wins HWS Round Robin 2019". Achte Minute. 2019-04-09. Retrieved 2023-01-07. At the Round Robin, each team is ranked by two judging panels and receives separate adjudications. Speaker points and team points are aggregated across both panels.
  13. ↑ "Trinity College Wins Fourth Annual Debate Tournament". Hobart and William Smith Colleges: The Herald. 2010-04-09. p. 2. Retrieved 2023-01-08.
  14. ↑ "Round Robin Origins". HWS Round Robin. Retrieved 2023-01-07.
  15. ↑ "Students Debate Adapting to Vs. Preventing Climate Change". Open Society Foundations. 2009-04-15. Retrieved 2023-01-07.
  16. ↑ "HWS Round Robin Debate Tournament". Facebook. Retrieved 2024-01-05.
  17. ↑ "Qualifying: How to be Part of the Round Robin". HWS Round Robin. Retrieved 2023-01-07.
  18. ↑ Barnes, Eric; Doak, Christopher (August 2019). Assessing the Reliability of Debate Judges (Thesis). Retrieved 2022-01-07.
  19. ↑ "HWS RR 2024 Tab Site". HWS Round Robin.
  20. ↑ "HWS RR 2023 Tab Site". HWS Round Robin.
  21. ↑ "Tab Sheets". HWS Round Robin.
  22. ↑ "Past Winners". HWS Round Robin.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.