Hatfield rail crash

Last updated

Hatfield rail crash
07-11-05 Hatfield 50.jpg
An InterCity 225 passing a memorial garden for the crash victims
Date17 October 2000 (2000-10-17)
12:23,(UTC) (Z)
Location Hatfield, Hertfordshire
Coordinates 51°45′14″N0°13′18″W / 51.75389°N 0.22167°W / 51.75389; -0.22167 Coordinates: 51°45′14″N0°13′18″W / 51.75389°N 0.22167°W / 51.75389; -0.22167
Line East Coast Main Line
Operator Great North Eastern Railway
CauseBroken rail
InjuredOver 70 [lower-alpha 1]
List of UK rail accidents by year

The Hatfield rail crash was a railway accident on 17 October 2000, at Hatfield, Hertfordshire. It was caused by a metal fatigue-induced derailment, killing four people and injuring more than 70.


The accident exposed major stewardship shortcomings of the privatised national railway infrastructure company Railtrack. Reports found there was a lack of communication and some staff were not aware of maintenance procedures. Railtrack subsequently went into administration and was replaced by Network Rail. The aftermath of the accident saw widespread speed limit reductions throughout the rail network and a tightening of health and safety procedures, the repercussions of which were still felt years later. In 2005, both Railtrack and the contractor Balfour Beatty were found guilty of breaching health and safety laws.


A Great North Eastern Railway (GNER) InterCity 225 train bound for Leeds had left London King's Cross at 12:10, and was travelling along the East Coast Main Line at approximately 115 mph (185 km/h) when it derailed south of Hatfield station at 12:23. [2] The train was in the control of an experienced driver trainer accompanied by a trainee driver. It had been agreed at Kings Cross that the trainee would drive the 12:10 service to Leeds. [3] The primary cause of the accident was later determined to be the left-hand rail fracturing as the train passed over it. [2]

The train travelled a further 1,000 yards (910 m) after derailment. The leading locomotive and the first two coaches remained upright and on the rails. All of the following coaches and the trailing Driving Van Trailer (DVT) were derailed, and the train set separated into three sections. [2] The restaurant coach, the eighth vehicle in the set, overturned onto its side and struck an overhead line gantry after derailing, resulting in severe damage to the vehicle. [4] The whole incident occurred in 17 seconds. [5]

Four passengers died in the accident and a further 33 were initially reported as injured, three seriously. [2] The number of injured was later revised to over 70. [1] [6] Those who died were all in the restaurant coach:

Two of those seriously injured were GNER staff working in the restaurant coach at the time of the accident. [11] Emmerdale actress Anna Brecon was travelling on the train, and suffered minor cuts and bruises. [2] Another passenger was the television reporter Justin Rowlatt, who said he "watched the carriages skid and whip around on the gravel besides the track". [12]

Crash investigators found the British Rail-designed Mark 4 coaches had good structural integrity and, aside from the restaurant coach, remained intact after the accident. [13] Coincidentally, the locomotive in the crash was also involved in the Selby rail crash (where the leading DVT hit a road vehicle on the track) four months later. [14]


A preliminary investigation found a rail had fragmented as trains passed and that the likely cause was "rolling contact fatigue" (defined as multiple surface-breaking cracks). Such cracks are caused by high loads where the wheels contact the rail. [15] [16] Repeated high loading causes fatigue cracks to grow. When they reach a critical size, the rail fails. Portions of the failed track at Hatfield were reassembled and numerous fatigue cracks were identified. They contributed to the spalling of the running surface to around five millimetres (0.2 in) deep and 100 millimetres (3.9 in) long. [17]

The problem was known about before the accident; a letter from the infrastructure company Railtrack in December 1999 warned that the existing Railtrack Line Specification was insufficient to guard against this type of fatigue. [18] Replacement rails were made available but never delivered to the correct location for installation. [19]

Since privatisation, Railtrack had divested the engineering knowledge of British Rail to contractors. While it had comprehensive maintenance procedures that might have prevented the accident if followed appropriately, later investigation showed there was a serious problem with the experience and working knowledge of staff. [20] In a subsequent interview, the Zone Quality Standards Manager said, "I do not have knowledge of railway engineering nor railway safety", which was completely contrary to the written requirements for the role. [21] In May 1999, the Head of Track had said that insufficiently-skilled work was causing more rails to break. [22] Railtrack did not know how many other cases of rail fatigue around the network could lead to a similar accident. [23] It consequently imposed over 1,800 emergency speed restrictions and instigated a costly nationwide track replacement programme. [24] The company was subject to "enforcement" by the Rail Regulator, Tom Winsor. [25]


In 2004, Steve Arthur's widow was awarded £1 million damages in the High Court. The families of the other three fatal casualties received damages out of court. [5] A memorial service was held for the victims on the tenth anniversary of the crash in 2010 at St Etheldreda's Church, Hatfield. A second service was held near the crash site afterwards. Both were conducted by the Rector of Hatfield, who had attended to casualties and the bereaved in the immediate aftermath of the accident in 2000. [6]

The speed restrictions and track replacement works caused significant disruption on a majority of the national network for more than a year. [26] The disruption and Railtrack's spiralling costs eventually caused the company to enter administration at the insistence of Transport Secretary Stephen Byers, [27] and its replacement by the not-for-dividend company Network Rail under Byers's successor Alistair Darling. [28]

Train operating companies were adversely affected by the disruption, losing an estimated 19% of revenue in the year following the crash. Freight operator EWS was cancelling up to 400 trains per week as a result, whilst estimates put Freightliner's resultant losses at £1 million per month. The cost to the entire UK economy of the disruption was estimated at £6 million per day. [29]

The Institute of Rail Welding (IoRW) was set up in 2002 by The Welding Institute (TWI) and Network Rail as a consequence of the recommendations in the investigation report. [30] It provides a focus for individuals and organisations involved in rail welding and facilitates the adoption of best practice. [31]

The aftermath of the crash had long-reaching repercussions in the rail industry. In 2015, at the fifteenth anniversary of the accident, the Rail, Maritime and Transport union (RMT) said a new system for handling maintenance introduced by Network Rail was confusing, and there was the potential for a similar accident. The union's general secretary said that Network Rail needed to act on its concerns, otherwise there would be industrial action. [32]

The Class 91 powering the train involved in the Hatfield rail crash would later be involved in the Selby rail crash four months later, sustaining minor damage. It was repaired again following the accident, and remained in service for a further 20 years, finally being scrapped at Sims Metals Scrapyard in Nottingham in 2021. As a result of its involvement in both accidents, it had gained the unofficial nickname 'Lucky'. [33]

Court case

In 2003, five managers and two companies – Network Rail (as successors of Railtrack) and the division of Balfour Beatty that maintained the track – were charged with manslaughter and breach of health and safety charges in connection with the accident. The managers, Anthony Walker (Balfour Beatty's rail maintenance director), Nicholas Jeffries (its civil engineer), Railtrack's Alistair Cook and Sean Fugill (asset managers for the London North-East zone), and track engineer Keith Lee, all denied the charges. [34] The corporate manslaughter charges against Railtrack/Network Rail and some of its executives were dropped in September 2004, but the other charges stood. [35]

The trial began in January 2005; the judge, Mr Justice Mackay, warned that it could go on for a year. On 14 July, the judge instructed the jury to acquit all defendants on charges of manslaughter. [36] A few days later, Balfour Beatty changed its plea to guilty on the health and safety charges, [37] and on 6 September, Network Rail was found guilty of breaching health and safety law. [38] Network Rail were fined £3.5 million while Balfour Beatty were fined £10 million. [6] All of the manslaughter charges against the executives were dismissed by the judge. [39]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Railtrack</span> British railway infrastructure owner and manager (1994-2002)

Railtrack was a group of companies that owned the track, signalling, tunnels, bridges, level crossings and all but a handful of the stations of the British railway system from 1994 until 2002. It was created as part of the privatisation of British Rail, listed on the London Stock Exchange, and was a constituent of the FTSE 100 Index. In 2002, after experiencing major financial difficulty, most of Railtrack's operations were transferred to the state-controlled non-profit company Network Rail. The remainder of Railtrack was renamed RT Group plc and eventually dissolved on 22 June 2010.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Network Rail</span> State-owned company that manages rail infrastructure in Great Britain

Network Rail Limited is the owner and infrastructure manager of most of the railway network in Great Britain. Network Rail is an "arm's length" public body of the Department for Transport with no shareholders, which reinvests its income in the railways.

Eschede derailment 1998 high-speed train crash in Celle, Lower Saxony, Germany

The Eschede derailment occurred on 3 June 1998, near the village of Eschede in the Celle district of Lower Saxony, Germany, when a high-speed train derailed and crashed into a road bridge with 101 people killed and 88 injured. It remains the worst rail disaster in the history of the Federal Republic of Germany and the worst high-speed-rail disaster worldwide. The cause was a single fatigue crack in one wheel that, when it failed, resulted in a part of the wheel becoming caught in a set of points, effectively changing the setting of the points whilst the train was passing over it. This led to the train's carriages going down two separate tracks, causing the train to derail and crash into the pillars of a concrete road bridge, which then collapsed and crushed two coaches. The remaining coaches and the rear power car crashed into the wreckage.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ladbroke Grove rail crash</span> 1999 accident in London

The Ladbroke Grove rail crash was a rail accident which occurred on 5 October 1999 at Ladbroke Grove in London, England, when two passenger trains collided almost head-on after one of them had passed a signal at danger. With 31 people killed and 417 injured, it remains one of the worst rail accidents in 20th-century British history.

Potters Bar rail accidents

There have been four railway accidents at Potters Bar (England). Those in 1898 and 1946 were signals passed at danger. The accident in 2002 led to substantial public debate and a national change in policy relating to maintenance of infrastructure.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Derailment</span> Form of train incident

In rail transport, a derailment occurs when a rail vehicle such as a train comes off its rails. Although many derailments are minor, all result in temporary disruption of the proper operation of the railway system and they are a potentially serious hazard.

Ufton Nervet rail crash Rail crash caused by suicidal car driver

The Ufton Nervet rail crash was a collision between a train and car on a level crossing near Ufton Nervet, Berkshire, England, in 2004. Seven people, including the drivers of the train and the car, were killed. An inquest found that the crash was caused by the suicide of the car driver.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Southall rail crash</span> 1997 high-speed rail crash near London

The Southall rail crash occurred on 19 September 1997, on the Great Western Main Line at Southall, Middlesex. An InterCity 125 high speed passenger train (HST) failed to slow down in response to warning signals and collided with a freight train crossing its path, causing seven deaths and 139 injuries.

The 1996 Stafford rail crash occurred on 8 March 1996 when a Transrail freight train travelling from Mossend, North Lanarkshire, to Willesden, North London, derailed after an axle on a wagon carrying liquid carbon dioxide failed due to fatigue at Rickerscote 1.4 miles (2.2 km) south of Stafford on the West Coast Main Line. Almost immediately after the derailment, a Travelling Post Office mail train hauled by a Rail Express Systems British Rail Class 86 electric locomotive collided with a section of the derailed freight train on the adjacent line and fouled the path of the TPO mail train. One person, a mail sorter, was killed in the crash and twenty others including the driver of the mail train were injured.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Watford rail crash</span>

In the early evening of 8 August 1996, a Class 321 passenger train operated by Network SouthEast travelling from London Euston on the West Coast Main Line Down Slow line at around 110 km/h (68 mph) passed a signal at danger. Having applied the brakes it eventually stopped 203 m past the signal and was traversing the junction between the Down Slow line and the Up Fast line. An empty Class 321 coaching stock train approaching at roughly 80 km/h (50 mph) collided with the stationary passenger train approximately 700 m south of Watford Junction whilst progressing across the connections from the Up Slow line to the Up Fast line.

Sir Thomas Philip Winsor is a British arbitrator and mediator, lawyer, consultant and economic regulatory professional.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Grayrigg derailment</span> 2007 rail transport disaster in Grayrigg, England

The Grayrigg derailment was a fatal railway accident that occurred at approximately 20:15 GMT on 23 February 2007, just to the south of Grayrigg, Cumbria, in the North West England region of the United Kingdom. The accident investigation concluded that the derailment was caused by a faulty set of points on the Down Main running line, controlled from Lambrigg ground frame. The scheduled inspection on 18 February 2007 had not taken place and the faults had gone undetected.

2015 Oxnard train derailment 2015 rail transport disaster in Oxnard, California, USA

The 2015 Oxnard train derailment occurred on February 24, 2015, at 5:44 a.m. local time when a Metrolink passenger train collided with a truck that a driver had mistakenly turned from Rice Avenue onto the tracks and became stuck. After impact, the train derailed at Oxnard, California, United States. As a result of the crash, the train engineer died from his injuries a week later and 32 passengers and crew members were injured. The truck driver exited his vehicle and ran from the scene prior to the crash; he sustained minor injuries that were unrelated to the crash sequence.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Impact of the privatisation of British Rail</span>

The impact of the privatisation of British Rail has been the subject of much debate, with the stated benefits including improved customer service, and more investment; and stated drawbacks including higher fares, lower punctuality and increased rail subsidies. The privatisation of British Rail began in the 1990s.

2016 Croydon tram derailment November 2016 fatal derailment in south London

On 9 November 2016, a tram operated by Tramlink derailed and overturned on a sharp bend approaching a junction. Of a total 69 passengers, there were seven fatalities and 62 injured, 19 of whom sustained serious injuries. This was the first tram incident in the United Kingdom in which passengers died since 1959.

Steven Marshall was a British business executive. He studied accountancy and worked in finance at several companies before taking a leading role at Thorn plc in the 1990s. Marshall was finance director of Railtrack and then chief executive from November 2000 until the company was forced into administration in October 2001. He was later chairman of Balfour Beatty and Wincanton plc.

Stonehaven derailment Train derailment in Scotland

The Stonehaven derailment was a fatal railway accident that occurred at 09:38 BST on 12 August 2020, when a passenger train hit a landslip, near Carmont, west of Stonehaven in Aberdeenshire, Scotland, following severe rain. Of the nine people aboard, three were killed, and six were injured.



  1. The ORR Final Report in 2006 states "over 70" injured; news reports vary, mentioning figures up to "102 injured". [1]


  1. 1 2 ORR 2006, p. 1.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 Cobain, Ian; Harvey, Michael; Bird, Steve (18 October 2000). "Four killed and 33 hurt: mechanical failure blamed" . The Times . Archived from the original on 12 January 2021. Retrieved 16 August 2016.
  3. ORR 2006, p. 45.
  4. ORR 2006, p. 43.
  5. 1 2 "How Hatfield changed the railways". BBC News . 6 September 2005. Archived from the original on 12 January 2021. Retrieved 23 August 2016.
  6. 1 2 3 "Church services mark Hatfield train crash anniversary". BBC News. 17 October 2010. Archived from the original on 12 January 2021. Retrieved 16 August 2016.
  7. Bird, Steve; Wilkinson, Paul; Horsnell, Michael (20 October 2000). "Pilot who flew worldwide met death on train" . The Times. p. 11. Retrieved 21 August 2016.
  8. "British police recommend corporate manslaughter charges (Aucklander Robert Alcorn killed)". New Zealand Herald. 30 July 2001. Archived from the original on 12 January 2021. Retrieved 1 December 2017.
  9. "Family pleased at charges over fatal train crash". New Zealand Herald. 10 July 2003. Archived from the original on 12 January 2021. Retrieved 1 December 2017.
  10. 1 2 3 Cobain, Ian; Horsnell, Michael; Binyon, Michael (19 October 2000). "Railtrack knew about faulty line" . The Times. p. 1. Archived from the original on 12 January 2021. Retrieved 21 August 2016.
  11. ORR 2006, p. 4.
  12. "Hatfield Train Crash". BBC News. Archived from the original on 12 January 2021. Retrieved 12 October 2019.
  13. ORR 2006, p. 34.
  14. Senior, Roger (2016). Train Doctor: Trouble Shooting with Diesel and Electric Traction. Casemate Publishers. p. 20. ISBN   978-1-4738-7045-1.
  15. ORR 2006, p. 16.
  16. Doherty, Andy; Steve Clark; Robert Care; Mark Dembosky (June 2005). "Why Rails Crack?". Ingenia Online. Archived from the original on 24 December 2012. Retrieved 9 December 2008.
  17. ORR 2006, pp. 54–5.
  18. ORR 2006, p. 17.
  19. Benn, Tony (2010). More Time for Politics: Diaries 2001–2007. Random House. p. 364. ISBN   978-1-4090-6320-9.
  20. ORR 2006, pp. 81, 84.
  21. ORR 2006, p. 114.
  22. ORR 2006, p. 107.
  23. ORR 2006, p. 98.
  24. ORR 2006, p. 120.
  25. Pank, Philip (18 October 2010). "Rail safety 'still an issue' 10 years after Hatfield" . The Times. p. 11. Archived from the original on 12 January 2021. Retrieved 22 August 2016.
  26. "Hatfield crash "was disaster waiting to happen"". The Daily Telegraph . 31 January 2005. Archived from the original on 10 February 2018. Retrieved 22 August 2016.
  27. "Railtrack in administration". BBC News. 8 October 2001. Retrieved 22 August 2016.
  28. "Rail privatisation – a short history". Channel 4 News. 1 July 2009. Archived from the original on 12 January 2021. Retrieved 22 August 2016.
  29. Andrew Murray (2001), Off the rails: Britain's great rail crisis : cause, consequences and cure, Verso, "Companies in trouble", pp. 124–129, ISBN   9781859846407
  30. "Mission statement". Institute of Rail Welding. Archived from the original on 12 October 2016. Retrieved 23 August 2016.
  31. "Repairing RCF – The IoRW's 2015 Technical Seminar". Rail Engineer. 21 August 2015. Retrieved 22 August 2016.
  32. "Unions raise safety concerns on Hatfield rail crash anniversary". BT News. 16 October 2015. Archived from the original on 12 January 2021. Retrieved 22 August 2016.
  33. "First LNER Class 91 locomotive set to be scrapped in Nottingham". RailAdvent. 19 March 2021. Retrieved 27 May 2022.
  34. "Hatfield a "disaster in waiting"". BBC News. 31 January 2005. Archived from the original on 12 January 2021. Retrieved 22 August 2016.
  35. "Charges dropped against Railtrack". BBC News. 2 September 2004. Archived from the original on 21 October 2012. Retrieved 4 March 2007.
  36. "Rail killing charges thrown out". BBC News. 14 July 2005. Archived from the original on 24 February 2012. Retrieved 4 March 2007.
  37. "Company admits Hatfield breaches". BBC News. 18 July 2005. Archived from the original on 5 August 2011. Retrieved 4 March 2007.
  38. "Network Rail guilty over Hatfield". BBC News. 6 November 2005. Archived from the original on 25 October 2012. Retrieved 4 March 2007.
  39. Milner, Mark (15 July 2005). "Judge dismisses Hatfield rail manslaughter charges". The Guardian . Archived from the original on 12 January 2021. Retrieved 23 August 2016.