| Name | Position | Year(s) selected | Franchise(s) represented | Notes |
|---|
| Orlando Pace | T | 1999, 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005 | St. Louis Rams | |
| Alan Page | DT | 1968, 1969, 1970, 1971, 1972, 1973, 1974, 1975, 1976 | Minnesota Vikings | |
| Carson Palmer | QB | 2005, 2006, 2015 | Cincinnati Bengals (2005, 2006) Arizona Cardinals (2015) | 2006—Named MVP of game |
| John Paluck | DE | 1965 | Washington Redskins | |
| Ken Panfil | T | 1959 | Chicago Cardinals | |
| Jack Pardee | LLB | 1963 | Los Angeles Rams | |
| Babe Parilli | QB | 1963 (AFL), 1964 (AFL), 1966 (AFL)# | Boston Patriots | |
| Jim Parker | OT, G | 1958, 1959, 1960, 1961, 1962, 1963, 1964, 1965 | Baltimore Colts | |
| Willie Parker | RB | 2006, 2007 | Pittsburgh Steelers | |
| Cody Parkey | PK | 2014 | Philadelphia Eagles | |
| Dave Parks | WR | 1965, 1966, 1967 | San Francisco 49ers | |
| Bernie Parrish | DB | 1960, [29] 1963 (NFL) [92] | Cleveland Browns | |
| Lemar Parrish | CB, KR | 1970, [15] 1971, [67] 1974, [80] 1975, [79] 1976, [93] 1977, [94] 1979, [95] 1980 [26] | Cincinnati Bengals (1970, 1971, 1974–1977) Washington Redskins (1979, 1980) | |
| Micah Parsons | LB | 2021 †, [90] 2022 † [96] | Dallas Cowboys | |
| Dan Pastorini | QB | 1975 [79] | Houston Oilers | |
| Cordarrelle Patterson | KR, ST | 2013, [58] 2016 †, [38] 2019 †, [32] 2020 † [33] | Minnesota Vikings (2013, 2016) Chicago Bears (2019, 2020) | |
| Jimmy Patton | S | 1958, 1959, 1960, 1961, 1962 | New York Giants | |
| Don Paul | DB | 1953, 1956, 1957, 1958 | Chicago Cardinals (1953) Cleveland Browns (1956-1958) | |
| Dainard Paulson | DB | 1964 (AFL), 1965 (AFL) | New York Jets | |
| Bryce Paup | LB | 1994, 1995, 1996, 1997 | Green Bay Packers (1994) Buffalo Bills (1995-1997) | |
| Walter Payton | RB | 1976, 1977#, 1978, 1979, 1980, 1983, 1984, 1985, 1986 | Chicago Bears | |
| Dave Pear | NT | 1978 | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | |
| Drew Pearson | WR | 1974, [80] 1976, [93] 1977 [94] | Dallas Cowboys | |
| Andrus Peat | G | 2018, [31] 2019, [32] 2020 [33] | New Orleans Saints | 2018—Selected as a replacement for Brandon Brooks [97] 2019—Selected as a replacement for Brandon Scherff [98] |
| Cedric Peerman | ST | 2015 [37] | Cincinnati Bengals | 2015—Selected as a replacement for Matthew Slater [99] |
| Donald Penn | OT | 2010, [56] 2016 ‡, [38] 2017 ‡ [17] | Tampa Bay Buccaneers (2010) Oakland Raiders (2016, 2017) | 2010—Selected as a replacement for Chad Clifton [100] 2016—Did not play in the Pro Bowl due to injury [101] 2017—Did not play in the Pro Bowl due to injury [89] |
| Woody Peoples | G | 1972, [12] 1973 [68] | San Francisco 49ers | |
| Julius Peppers | DE, OLB | 2004, [84] 2005, [20] 2006, [21] 2008 †, [87] 2009 †, [45] 2010 †, [56] 2011, [47] 2012 †, [57] 2015 [37] | Carolina Panthers (2004–2016, 2009) Chicago Bears (2010–2012) Green Bay Packers (2015) | 2011—Selected as a replacement for Jason Pierre-Paul [102] 2015—Selected as a replacement for Von Miller [103] |
| Don Perkins | FB | 1961, 1962, 1963, 1966, 1967, 1968 | Dallas Cowboys | |
| Joe Perry | FB | 1952, 1953, 1954 | San Francisco 49ers | |
| Michael Dean Perry | DT | 1989, 1990, 1991, 1993, 1994, 1996 | Cleveland Browns (1989-1991, 1993, 1994) Denver Broncos (1996) | |
| Rod Perry | CB | 1978, 1980 | Los Angeles Rams | |
| Denzel Perryman | LB | 2021 [34] | Las Vegas Raiders | |
| Floyd Peters | DT | 1964, 1966, 1967 | Philadelphia Eagles | |
| Jason Peters | OT | 2007 ‡, [22] 2008 ‡, [87] 2009 †, [45] 2010 ‡, [56] 2011 †, [47] 2013 ‡, [58] 2014 ‡, [30] 2015 ‡, [37] 2016 ‡ [38] | Buffalo Bills (2007, 2008) Philadelphia Eagles (2009–2011, 2013–2016) | 2007—Did not play in the Pro Bowl due to injury [104] 2008—Did not play in the Pro Bowl due to injury [105] 2010—Did not play in the Pro Bowl due to injury [106] 2013—Did not play in the Pro Bowl due to injury [107] 2014—Did not play in the Pro Bowl due to injury [108] 2015—Did not play in the Pro Bowl due to injury [109] 2016—Did not play in the Pro Bowl due to injury [110] |
| Marcus Peters | CB | 2015, [37] 2016 ‡, [38] 2019 ‡ [32] | Kansas City Chiefs (2015, 2016) Baltimore Ravens (2019) | 2016—Did not play in the Pro Bowl due to injury [111] 2019—Did not play in the Pro Bowl due to injury [112] |
| Tony Peters | SS | 1982 [28] | Washington Redskins | |
| Volney Peters | DT | 1955 [113] | Washington Redskins | |
| Adrian Peterson | RB | 2007 †#, [22] 2008 †, [87] 2009 †, [45] 2010, [56] 2012 †, [57] 2013 ‡, [58] 2015 [37] | Minnesota Vikings | 2007—Named MVP of game 2013—Did not play in the Pro Bowl due to injury [114] |
| Julian Peterson | LB | 2002, [19] 2003, [6] 2006, [21] 2007 †, [22] 2008 [87] | San Francisco 49ers (2002, 2003) Seattle Seahawks (2006–2008) | 2008—Selected as a replacement for Derrick Brooks [115] |
| Patrick Peterson | KR, CB | 2011, [47] 2012, [57] 2013, [58] 2014, [30] 2015 ‡, [37] 2016 †, [38] 2017 †, [17] 2018 † [31] | Arizona Cardinals | 2015—Did not play in the Pro Bowl due to injury [116] |
| Richie Petitbon | S | 1962 (NFL), [71] 1963 (NFL), [92] 1966 (NFL), [74] 1967 (NFL) [23] | Chicago Bears | |
| Gerry Philbin | DE | 1968 (AFL), [10] 1969 (AFL) [11] | New York Jets | |
| Adrian Phillips | ST | 2018 † [31] | Los Angeles Chargers | |
| Jim Phillips | OE | 1960, [29] 1961 (NFL), [70] 1962 (NFL) [71] | Los Angeles Rams | |
| Shaun Phillips | OLB | 2010 [56] | San Diego Chargers | 2010—Selected as a replacement for James Harrison [117] |
| Carl Pickens | WR | 1995, [53] 1996 [54] | Cincinnati Bengals | |
| Antonio Pierce | MLB | 2006 [21] | New York Giants | |
| Jason Pierre-Paul | DE, OLB | 2011, [47] 2012 †, [57] 2020 [33] | New York Giants (2011, 2012) Tampa Bay Buccaneers (2020) | 2011—Did not play in the Pro Bowl because the Giants advanced to Super Bowl XLVI [102] |
| Nick Pietrosante | FB | 1960, 1961 | Detroit Lions | |
| Pete Pihos | TE | 1950, 1951, 1952, 1953, 1954, 1955 | Philadelphia Eagles | |
| Kyle Pitts | TE | 2021 [90] | Atlanta Falcons | |
| Scott Player | P | 2000 | Arizona Cardinals | |
| Milt Plum | QB | 1960, 1961 | Cleveland Browns | |
| Jake Plummer | QB | 2005 | Denver Broncos | |
| Sherman Plunkett | OT | 1964 (AFL), 1966 (AFL) | New York Jets | |
| Dontari Poe | NT | 2013, 2014 | Kansas City Chiefs | |
| Jim Podoley | HB | 1957 | Washington Redskins | |
| Troy Polamalu | S | 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2010, 2011, 2013 | Pittsburgh Steelers | 2010—Did not play in the Pro Bowl because the Steelers advanced to Super Bowl XLV |
| Tony Pollard | RB | 2022 [96] | Dallas Cowboys | |
| Fran Polsfoot | E | 1951 | Chicago Cardinals | |
| Ryan Pontbriand | LS | 2007, 2008 | Cleveland Browns | |
| Ray Poole | E | 1950 | New York Giants | |
| Robert Porcher | DE | 1997, 1999, 2001 | Detroit Lions | |
| Joey Porter | LB | 2002, 2004, 2005, 2008 | Pittsburgh Steelers (2002, 2004, 2005) Miami Dolphins (2008) | |
| Rufus Porter | LB | 1988, 1989 | Seattle Seahawks | |
| Clinton Portis | RB | 2003, 2008 | Denver Broncos (2003) Washington Redskins (2008) | |
| Paul Posluszny | LB | 2013 | Jacksonville Jaguars | |
| Dickie Post | RB | 1967 (AFL), [9] 1969 (AFL) [11] | San Diego Chargers | |
| Myron Pottios | MLB | 1961 (NFL), [70] 1963 (NFL), [92] 1964 (NFL) [72] | Pittsburgh Steelers | |
| Maurkice Pouncey | C | 2010 ‡, [56] 2011 ‡, [47] 2012 †, [57] 2014, [30] 2016 ‡, [38] 2017 †, [17] 2018 †, [31] 2019 †‡, [32] 2020 † [33] | Pittsburgh Steelers | 2010—Did not play in the Pro Bowl because the Steelers advanced to Super Bowl XLV [118] 2011—Did not play in the Pro Bowl due to injury [119] 2016—Did not play in the Pro Bowl due to injury [120] 2019—Did not play in the Pro Bowl due to injury [121] |
| Mike Pouncey | C | 2013, [58] 2014, [30] 2015 ‡, [37] 2018 [31] | Miami Dolphins (2013–2015) Los Angeles Chargers (2018) | 2014—Selected as a replacement for Mike Iupati [122] |
| Art Powell | OE | 1963 (AFL), [25] 1966 (AFL), [123] 1965 (AFL), [8] 1966 (AFL) [13] | Oakland Raiders | |
| Marvin Powell | OT | 1979, [95] 1980, [26] 1981, [27] 1982, [28] 1983 [44] | New York Jets | |
| Jordan Poyer | SS | 2022 [35] | Buffalo Bills | |
| Matt Prater | K | 2013 ‡, [58] 2016 [38] | Denver Broncos (2013) Detroit Lions (2016) | 2013—Did not play in the Pro Bowl because the Broncos advanced to Super Bowl XLVIII [124] 2016—Selected as a replacement for Matt Bryant [125] |
| Dak Prescott | QB | 2016 †, [38] 2018, [31] 2021 ‡ [126] | Dallas Cowboys | 2018—Selected as a replacement for Drew Brees [127] 2021—Selected as a replacement for Aaron Rodgers/Tom Brady; Did not play in the Pro Bowl due to injury [126] |
| Roell Preston | WR | 1998 | Green Bay Packers | |
| Luke Prestridge | P | 1982 | Denver Broncos | |
| Eddie Price | FB | 1951, 1952, 1954 | New York Giants | |
| Vince Promuto | G | 1963, 1964 | Washington Redskins | |
| Greg Pruitt | RB | 1973, 1974, 1976, 1977, 1983 | Cleveland Browns (1973, 1974, 1976, 1977) Los Angeles Raiders (1983) | |
| Mike Pruitt | FB | 1979, 1980 | Cleveland Browns | |
| Trevor Pryce | DT, DE | 1999, 2000, 2001, 2002 | Denver Broncos | |
| Duane Putnam | G | 1954, 1955, 1956, 1957, 1958 | Los Angeles Rams | |
| Mike Pyle | C | 1963 | Chicago Bears | |