Madagascar Plan

See also: Jews in Madagascar

Madagascar lies off the east coast of Africa

The Madagascar Plan (German : Madagaskarplan) was a plan proposed by the Nazi German government to forcibly relocate the Jewish population of Europe to the island of Madagascar. Franz Rademacher, head of the Jewish Department of the German Foreign Office, proposed the idea in June 1940, shortly before the Fall of France. The proposal called for the handing over of control of Madagascar, then a French colony, to Germany as part of the eventual peace terms.

The idea of re-settling Polish Jews to Madagascar was investigated by the French Third Republic and the Second Polish Republic in 1937, ^{[1] [2]} but the task force sent to evaluate the island's potential determined that only 5,000 to 7,000 families could be accommodated, or even as few as 500 families by some estimates. ^[a] As the efforts by the Nazis to encourage the emigration of the Jewish population of Germany before World War II were only partially successful, the idea of deporting Jews to Madagascar was revived by the Nazi government in 1940.

Rademacher recommended on 3 June 1940 that Madagascar should be made available as a destination for the Jews of Europe. With Adolf Hitler's approval, Adolf Eichmann released a memorandum on 15 August 1940 calling for the resettlement of a million Jews per year for four years, with the island being governed as a police state under the SS. They assumed that many Jews would succumb to its harsh conditions should the plan be implemented. ^[5] The plan was not viable when proposed due to the British naval blockade. It was postponed after the Nazis lost the Battle of Britain in September 1940, and it was permanently shelved in 1942 with the commencement of the Final Solution, the policy of systematic genocide of Jews, towards which it had functioned as an important psychological step. ^[6]

Origins

Proposed sites under the 1937 French/Polish version of the plan

In the late nineteenth century and early twentieth century, there were a number of resettlement plans for European Jews that were precursors to the Madagascar Plan. Paul de Lagarde, an antisemitic Orientalist scholar, first suggested evacuating the European Jews to Madagascar in his 1878 work Deutsche Schriften ("German Writings"). ^{[7] [8]} Members of the Zionist movement in 1904–1905 seriously debated the Uganda Scheme, by which Russian Jews, who were in immediate danger from ongoing pogroms in the Russian Empire, would be settled in the East Africa Protectorate (now Kenya), which was part of the British Empire at the time. The plan was later rejected as unworkable by the World Zionist Congress. ^[9]

Adherents of territorialism split off from the main Zionist movement and continued to search for a location where Jews might settle and create a state, or at least an autonomous area. ^[10] The idea of Jewish resettlement in Madagascar was promoted by British antisemites Henry Hamilton Beamish (founder of the British antisemitic society The Britons), Arnold Leese (founder of the Imperial Fascist League), and others. ^[11] With the cooperation of the French, the Polish government commissioned a task force in 1937 to examine the possibility of settling Polish Jews on the island. ^[2] The head of the commission, Mieczysław Lepecki  [ pl ], felt the island could accommodate 5-7000 families, but Jewish members of the group estimated that, because of the climate and poor infrastructure, only 500 or even fewer families could safely be accommodated. ^{[1] [12] [a]}

In Nazi Germany

Racism and antisemitism were basic tenets of the Nazi Party and the Nazi government. ^[13] Discrimination and violent attacks against Jews began immediately after the seizure of power in 1933. ^[14] Violence and economic pressure were used by the Nazis to encourage Jews to voluntarily leave the country. ^[15] By 1939, around 250,000 of Germany's 437,000 Jews had emigrated to the United States, Argentina, the United Kingdom, and other countries, as well as the British Mandate of Palestine. ^{[16] [17]}

The Nazi leadership seized on the idea of deporting the remaining German Jews overseas. Barren, unproductive lands were viewed as appropriate destinations as this would prevent the deportees from flourishing in their new location. ^[18] In his May 1940 memorandum to Hitler, Concerning the Treatment of the Alien Population in the East, Reichsführer-SS Heinrich Himmler declared that he hoped to see "the term 'Jew' [...] completely eliminated through the massive immigration of all Jews to Africa or some other colony". ^[19]

Planning begins

Initial discussions began to take place in 1938 among Nazi ideologues such as Julius Streicher, Hermann Göring, Alfred Rosenberg, and Joachim von Ribbentrop. ^[20] Ten per cent of Jews under German jurisdiction by that date were Polish nationals. Józef Lipski, the Polish ambassador to Germany, expressed his country's reluctance to take them back, and the Polish government decreed that Polish passport holders would not be permitted to return except under specific conditions. ^[21] When Ribbentrop raised the matter with French foreign minister Georges Bonnet in December of that year, Bonnet expressed French reluctance to receive more German Jews and inquired if measures could be taken to prevent their arrival. France itself was contemplating how to deport some 10,000 Jews and considered whether Madagascar might be an appropriate destination. ^[22] Planning for German deportations to Madagascar formally began in 1940. ^[23] Franz Rademacher, recently appointed head of the Jewish Department of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, forwarded on 3 June to his superior, the diplomat Martin Luther, a memorandum on the fate of the Jews. ^[1] Rademacher said: "The desirable solution is: all Jews out of Europe". ^[19] He briefly considered Palestine as a destination, but deemed it unsuitable, as he considered it undesirable that a strong Jewish state should be created in the Middle East. In addition, Palestine was under British control at the time. ^[24] Rademacher recommended that the French colony of Madagascar should be made available as a destination for the Jews of Europe as one of the terms of the surrender of France, which the Germans had invaded on 10 May 1940. ^[25] The resettled Jews, noted Rademacher, could be used as hostages to ensure "future good behaviour of their racial comrades in America". ^[19] The plan was developed by Referat D III of the Abteilung Deutschland. ^[26]

Luther broached the subject with Foreign Minister Ribbentrop, who was simultaneously developing a similar scheme. By 18 June, Hitler and Ribbentrop spoke of the Plan with Italian leader Benito Mussolini as a possibility that could be pursued after the defeat of France. ^{[19] [20]} Once he learned of the plan, SS- Obergruppenführer Reinhard Heydrich, chief of the Reich Security Main Office (RSHA), insisted that Ribbentrop relinquish any future responsibility for the Plan to that office. As Heydrich had been appointed by Göring in January 1939 to oversee Jewish evacuation from German-occupied territory, the Jewish question was hence under his purview. ^[20] Adolf Eichmann, head of the RSHA Sub-Department IV-B4, which dealt with Jewish affairs and evacuation, soon became involved. On 15 August, he released a memorandum titled Reichssicherheitshauptamt: Madagaskar Projekt (Reich Security Main Office: Madagascar Project), calling for the resettlement of a million Jews per year for four years and abandoning the idea of retaining any Jews in Europe. The RSHA, he emphasised, would control all aspects of the program. ^[27] While Rademacher called for the colony to be under German control but self-governing under Jewish administration, Eichmann made it plain that he intended for the SS to control and oversee every aspect of life on the island, which they would govern as a police state. ^[28] France surrendered on 22 June.

Most Nazi bureaus, including the Foreign Office, the Security Police, and the General Government (the occupied portion of Poland) pinned their hopes on the plan as the last chance to "solve the Jewish problem" through emigration. ^[29] In particular, Hans Frank, governor of the General Government, viewed the forced resettlement to Madagascar as being preferable to the heretofore piecemeal efforts at deportation into Poland. As of 10 July, deportations into Poland were cancelled, and construction of the Warsaw ghetto was halted, since it appeared to be unnecessary. ^[20]

Planning continues

Rademacher envisioned the founding of a European bank that would ultimately liquidate all European Jewish assets to pay for the plan. This bank would then play an intermediary role between Madagascar and the rest of the world, as Jews would not be allowed to interact financially with outsiders. Göring's office of the Four Year Plan would oversee the administration of the plan's economics. ^[30]

Additionally, Rademacher foresaw roles for other government agencies. Ribbentrop's Foreign Affairs Ministry would negotiate terms with the French for the handover of Madagascar to Germany. It would also play a part in crafting other treaties to deal with Europe's Jews. Its Information Department, along with Joseph Goebbels and his Ministry of Public Enlightenment and Propaganda, would control the flow of information at home and abroad. Viktor Brack, a division chief in the Chancellery of the Führer, would oversee transportation. The SS would undertake the expulsion of the Jews from Europe and govern the island as a police state. ^[31] The Nazis expected that after the invasion of the United Kingdom in Operation Sea Lion that they would commandeer the British merchant fleet to transport the Jews to Madagascar. ^[30] The Nazis expected many deportees to perish in the harsh conditions or die at the hands of the SS. ^[32] The plan has been characterised by the historian Ian Kershaw as genocide by an alternative method. ^[33]

Plan abandoned

With the failure to defeat the Royal Air Force in the Battle of Britain, the proposed invasion of the UK was postponed indefinitely on 17 September 1940. This meant the British merchant fleet would not be at Germany's disposal for use in evacuations, and planning for the Madagascar proposal stalled. ^[30] In late August 1940, Rademacher entreated Ribbentrop to hold a meeting at his ministry to begin drawing up a panel of experts to consolidate the plan. Ribbentrop never responded. Likewise, Eichmann's memorandum languished with Heydrich, who never approved it. ^[30] Establishment of ghettos in Warsaw and other cities in Poland resumed in August 1940. ^[34] The plan was officially shelved within the Foreign Office in February 1942. ^[35] British forces took the island from Vichy France in the Battle of Madagascar in November 1942 and control was transferred to the Free French.

Once planning for Operation Barbarossa commenced, Hitler asked Himmler to draft a new plan for the elimination of the Jews of Europe, and Himmler passed along the task to Heydrich. His draft proposed the deportation of the Jews to the Soviet Union via Poland. ^[36] The later Generalplan Ost (General Plan for the East), prepared by Professor Konrad Meyer and others, called for deporting the entire population of occupied Eastern Europe and the Soviet Union to Siberia, either for use as slave labour or to be murdered after the Soviet defeat. The plan hinged on the rapid defeat of the Soviet forces. ^[37] Once it became apparent that the war against the Soviet Union would drag on much longer than expected, Heydrich revised his plans to concentrate on the Jewish population then under Nazi control. Since transporting masses of people into a combat zone would be impossible, Heydrich decided that the Jews would be killed in extermination camps set up in occupied areas of Poland. ^[38] The total number of Jews murdered during the resulting Holocaust is estimated at 5.5 to 6 million people. ^[39]

See also

• Proposals for a Jewish state
• Uganda Scheme
• Nisko Plan
• Jewish Autonomous Oblast

References

Informational notes

1. According to the 2022 revision of the World Population Prospects ^{[3] [4]} the total population was 28,915,653 in 2021, compared to only 4,084,000 in 1950.

Citations

1. Browning 2004, p. 82.
2. Nicosia 2008, p. 280.
3. "World Population Prospects 2022". United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division. Retrieved 17 July 2022.
4. "World Population Prospects 2022: Demographic indicators by region, subregion and country, annually for 1950-2100" (XSLX) ("Total Population, as of 1 July (thousands)"). United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division. Retrieved 17 July 2022.
5. Longerich 2010, p. 162.
6. Browning 1995, pp. 18–19, 127–128.
7. Gerdmar 2009, p. 180.
8. Ehrlich 2009, p. 452.
9. Telushkin 2001, pp. 280–281.
10. Cesarani 1995, p. 101.
11. Browning 2004, p. 81.
12. Andrews 2015.
13. Longerich 2010, p. 31.
14. Shirer 1960, p. 203.
15. Longerich 2010, pp. 67–69.
16. Longerich 2010, p. 127.
17. Evans 2005, pp. 555–558.
18. Kershaw 2008, pp. 452–453.
19. Longerich 2012, p. 508.
20. Kershaw 2000, pp. 320–322.
21. Hilberg 1973, p. 258.
22. Hilberg 1973, p. 259.
23. Hilberg 1973, p. 260.
24. Longerich 2012, p. 162.
25. Browning 2004, pp. 82–85.
26. Hilberg 1973, pp. 260–261.
27. Browning 2004, p. 87.
28. Kershaw 2008, p. 577.
29. Hilberg 1973, p. 261.
30. Browning 2004, p. 88.
31. Browning 2004, pp. 87–88.
32. Longerich 2012, p. 509.
33. Kershaw 2015, p. 131.
34. Longerich 2010, p. 165.
35. Browning 2004, p. 415.
36. Longerich 2012, p. 511.
37. Snyder 2010, p. 416.
38. Longerich 2010, pp. 309–310.
39. Evans 2008, p. 318.

Bibliography

• Andrews, Evan (3 June 2015). "Remembering Nazi Germany's Madagascar Plan". History Channel . Retrieved 18 October 2018.
• Browning, Christopher R. (2004). The Origins of the Final Solution : The Evolution of Nazi Jewish Policy, September 1939 – March 1942. Comprehensive History of the Holocaust. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press. ISBN   0-8032-1327-1.
• Browning, Christopher R. (1995). The Path to Genocide: Essays on Launching the Final Solution . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. ISBN   978-0-521-55878-5.
• Cesarani, David (1995) [1995]. The "Jewish Chronicle" and Anglo-Jewry: 1841–1991. Cambridge; New York: Cambridge University Press. ISBN   978-0-521-43434-8.
• Ehrlich, Mark Avrum (2009). Encyclopedia of the Jewish Diaspora: Origins, Experiences, and Culture. Vol. 1. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO. ISBN   978-1-85109-873-6.
• Evans, Richard J. (2005). The Third Reich in Power . New York: Penguin. ISBN   978-0-14-303790-3.
• Evans, Richard J. (2008). The Third Reich at War . New York: Penguin. ISBN   978-0-14-311671-4.
• Gerdmar, Anders (2009). Roots of Theological Anti-Semitism: German Biblical Interpretation and the Jews, from Herder and Semler to Kittel and Bultmann. Studies in Jewish History and Culture. Leiden: Koninklijke Brill. ISBN   978-90-04-16851-0.
• Hilberg, Raul (1973). The Destruction of the European Jews . New York: New Viewpoints.
• Kershaw, Ian (2000). Hitler: 1936–1945: Nemesis. New York: Norton. ISBN   978-0-393-04994-7.
• Kershaw, Ian (2008) [2000]. Hitler: A Biography. New York: Norton. ISBN   978-0-393-06757-6.
• Kershaw, Ian (2015) [1985]. The Nazi Dictatorship: Problems and Perspectives of Interpretation. London; New York: Bloomsbury Publishing. ISBN   978-1-4742-4095-6.
• Longerich, Peter (2010). Holocaust: The Nazi Persecution and Murder of the Jews. Oxford; New York: Oxford University Press. ISBN   978-0-19-280436-5.
• Longerich, Peter (2012). Heinrich Himmler: A Life. Oxford; New York: Oxford University Press. ISBN   978-0-19-959232-6.
• Nicosia, Francis R. (2008). Zionism and Anti-Semitism in Nazi Germany. Cambridge; New York: Cambridge University Press. ISBN   978-0-521-88392-4.
• Shirer, William L. (1960). The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich . New York: Simon & Schuster. ISBN   978-0-671-62420-0.
• Snyder, Timothy (2010). Bloodlands: Europe between Hitler and Stalin. New York: Basic Books. ISBN   978-0-465-00239-9.
• Telushkin, Joseph (2001) [1991]. Jewish Literacy: The Most Important Things to Know About the Jewish Religion, Its People, and Its History. New York: Harper Collins. ISBN   978-0-688-08506-3.

Further reading

• Ainsztein, Reuben (1974). Jewish Resistance in Nazi-Occupied Eastern Europe. London: Elek Books. ISBN   978-0-236-15490-6.
• Brechtken, Magnus (1998). Madagaskar für die Juden: Antisemitische Idee und politische Praxis 1885–1945 (in German). Oldenbourg: Wissenschaftsverlag. ISBN   3-486-56384-X.

External links

• Video overview of the Madagascar Plan on YouTube by the German historian Magnus Brechtken
• Text of the Madagascar Plan