Meatballs (advertisement)

Last updated

"Meatballs"
Pat Buchanan -- Meatball.jpeg
A frame from Meatballs
AgencyLove Advertising
Client Pat Buchanan 2000 presidential campaign
LanguageEnglish
Running time30 seconds
Release date(s)October 9, 2000 (2000-10-09)
Directed byDavid Harrison
Production
company		VTTV, Houston
CountryUnited States

Meatballs (also known as Meatball and For Spanish Press 1) was a political commercial aired during the 2000 United States presidential campaign in support of Reform Party candidate Pat Buchanan. The commercial, which was created by Houston-based agency Love Advertising, depicts a white man choking on a meatball while attempting to dial 9-1-1, but keeling over before the automated menu reaches the option for English. [1] [2] [3] The ad highlighted Buchanan's support for making English the official language of the United States and his opposition to immigration policies of the time. [4] [5] Some analyses questioned the accuracy of the ad's claim that Buchanan's opponents were "writing off English for good". [1] [5]

Contents

The ad aired in 22 states, with an emphasis by the campaign on border states like California and Arizona. [1] The commercial drew criticism from several political figures and media outlets for its message, which some considered racist and xenophobic. [6] [7] Some critics praised the ad's humor and execution. [1] [7] [8] The ad has been unfavorably recognized in retrospect. [9] [10]

Background

Pat Buchanan, the Reform Party nominee for president in 2000, made immigration a central issue of his campaign. Pat Buchanan.jpg
Pat Buchanan, the Reform Party nominee for president in 2000, made immigration a central issue of his campaign.

In the 2000 United States presidential election, former Republican Pat Buchanan sought, and ultimately received, the nomination of Ross Perot’s Reform Party. Buchanan’s campaign themes included opposition to the North American Free Trade Agreement, illegal immigration, and abortion rights. [11] Because of the Reform Party’s showing in the 1996 presidential election, with Perot garnering eight percent of the national popular vote, the party qualified for matching federal campaign funds in 2000. Following a court ruling, Buchanan was awarded $12.6 million in such funds. [12] A stated goal of the campaign was to again attain at least five percent of the national popular vote, so that the Reform Party would maintain its eligibility for matching funds in the 2004 election. [13]

During his campaign, Buchanan and his running-mate, educator and activist Ezola Foster, both frequently called for a reduction in the number of immigrants allowed into America each year, as well as increased assimilation (in both language and culture) of those who enter the country. [14] In a May 2000 interview with National Public Radio, Buchanan claimed that immigration at then current rates was "rapidly changing the nature of the entire country; we speak 300 languages", while in August of that year, his campaign website called for a reduction of legal immigrants to between 250,000 and 300,000 annually, as well as for an implementation of an assimilation program to teach them the English language as well as American customs and history. [14] Foster, meanwhile, had supported California's Proposition 187 in 1994, which sought to deny public services to illegal immigrants, and in her acceptance speech as Buchanan's running-mate in August, urged American immigration policy to "stop being stupid", claiming that illegal immigration had lowered educational quality at the school where she had taught. [15] [16] That month, President Bill Clinton also signed Executive Order 13166, ordering federal agencies to work to accommodate non-English-speaking citizens; the move was regarded as an inspiration for what would become Buchanan's first general-election commercial. [17]

For their first television commercial of the general election campaign, funded partly by the federal matching funds, Buchanan's campaign hired Love Advertising, an agency based in Houston, Texas. [1] [7] Its owner, Brenda Love, reported that her agency had been chosen because Buchanan "wanted a fresh approach" and an agency which would pursue an unconventional media and creative strategy. [2] Buchanan's national campaign finance chairman connected the campaign to Love. [7] The agency's creative director, David Harrison, oversaw the ad. [18] The commercial itself was filmed by Houston-based production company VTTV. Both Love Advertising and VTTV received criticism from some of their clients and Houston commentators for their involvement in an ad perceived to have "anti-Hispanic overtones". [2]

Synopsis

The 30-second TV spot opens with a middle-aged white man sitting in his kitchen, eating a meal of spaghetti and meatballs while watching the news on TV. [1] A newscaster announces that an executive order "say[s] that English is no longer America’s national language". [1] Upon hearing this, the man begins choking on his meatball. However, upon dialing 9-1-1, he has to wait through a recorded menu stating which number to dial for each language, including Spanish, Bengali, Swedish, and Swahili. [1] [10] A voice-over asks "Do you ever miss English? Immigration is out of control". [8] The narrator adds that George W. Bush, the Republican presidential nominee, and Al Gore, the Democratic presidential nominee, "are writing off English for good." [1] Before the recorded menu reaches the option for English, the choking man has fallen, "lifeless", to his kitchen floor. [8] At the end of the ad, the viewer sees the man's dog standing on his stomach, licking the food off his face. [1]

Analysis

The ad's "choking" plot has been interpreted as a metaphor for the idea that immigration will eventually "choke America to death". [3] [10] The Houston Press suggested that the subtext of the ad is that real Americans speak English. [2] The ad's allusion to an executive order deeming English not to be America's official language was regarded as a reference to Executive Order 13166. [17] Regarding the ad's message, Buchanan himself argued that one of the greatest threats to America was its potential to "dissolve" into demographic and cultural subgroups (such as race and language). [4] He further alleged that the Democratic and Republican parties were unwilling to substantively discuss the issues of immigration and English, in spite of voters’ interest in the issue, out of interest in political correctness. [19]

The accuracy of the ad's central claim — that Bush and Gore were not committed to protecting the English language — was questioned in some analyses. [1] [5] In his book Winning Elections: Political Campaign Management, Strategy & Tactics, author John Franzen noted that neither Bush nor Gore had expressed support for removing English's status as America's national language. Franzen concluded that the ad was "very funny", but unethical. [5] Similarly, CBS News deemed the claim that both Gore and Bush "are writing off English for good" to be "a stretch", although noting that both candidates had voiced their opposition to establishing English as the United States' official language. [1]

Release

On October 9, 2000, the commercial began airing in 22 states, including California and Arizona, using a portion of the federal matching funds which the campaign received. [1] [19] It became the first general-election campaign TV ad released by any presidential candidate that year. [7] The ad aired primarily on cable television and during, among other programs, WWF Smackdown . [20] The ad was given particular emphasis in California, airing in every major media market in the state, with a focus on news programs. [6]

CBS News suggested that Buchanan targeted California and Arizona in particular because those two states included many voters who lived near illegal immigrants and supported more government action to combat illegal immigration. [1] Buchanan indicated that he believed the issue would carry relevance for California voters, telling SFGate that, although the issue was not top of mind for many voters, it "still resonates", also citing Proposition 187 as evidence of the issue's continuing resonance. [19] [6] The ad was also aired in Maryland and Iowa media markets, particularly in areas with many immigrant workers. [21] Although it was produced by a Houston-based advertising agency, and the Buchanan campaign ran radio ads in the Houston area, the commercial was not initially aired in any Texas media markets; it was suggested that the ad's perceived anti-Hispanic message would alienate voters in the state. [2]

Reception

Art Torres, then the California Democratic Party chairman, was among the political figures who accused the ad of "fear mongering." Art Torres (48023090513).jpg
Art Torres, then the California Democratic Party chairman, was among the political figures who accused the ad of "fear mongering."

Political figures

The commercial drew criticism from some political figures. California Democratic Party Chairman Art Torres attacked the ad as "pathetic" and called for its condemnation. Torres continued that "English will always be our national language and no amount of fear mongering or clicking of the heels will change that". [7] A spokesman for the California Republican Party concurred, opining that the ad demonstrated Buchanan's lack of understanding of California communities and voters. [6] The deputy vice chair for Latino advocacy organization National Council of La Raza, Lisa Navarrette, remarked that "There is a reason Pat Buchanan is getting 1% of the vote", while the national policy director for the League of United Latin American Citizens voiced concern that the ad could stoke anger and violence towards immigrants. [6] [7] In an interview with The Washington Post , Peter Fenn, a Democratic strategist, singled out Meatballs as his choice for the worst commercial of the 2000 campaign. [22] A profile of Buchanan in the Washington Examiner deemed the ad "hyperbolic" and questioned the political saliency of illegal immigration as a campaign issue, citing a Gallup Poll indicating that the issue ranked twelfth in importance to voters. [11]

Critics

Upon its release, the ad was reviewed by professional advertising critics at several media outlets. [8] [20] [23] A review for Slate , published upon the ad's release as part of the publication's ongoing "Ad Report Card" feature, gave the commercial a letter grade of "D", criticizing its premise as "ludicrous" and highlighting a number of perceived non-sequiturs in the ad, such as the ad's use of a food — spaghetti — associated with immigrants. The review went on to note that if the man were actually choking, then he might not have been able to speak to a 9-1-1 operator even if he had reached the English option in time. [8] Slate also proposed that another moral of the ad might be that "a foreign-food-loving social deviant got what was coming to him". [8] A review by Dan Snierson, writing for Entertainment Weekly , gave the ad a letter grade of "B" for execution and "no comment" for its message. In response to the ad's claim that "immigration is out of control", Snierson quipped that "Yeah, that’s not the only thing". [23]

Writing for Ad Age , Bob Garfield deemed the ad "sort of funny, after a fashion" to its target audience, but also denounced the ad's message as being "inherently jingoistic, intolerant, divisive and [...] racist". Garfield also observed that, whereas "extremists" running for public office often attempt to hide behind a respectable facade and use code words to convey their ideas, Buchanan's ad does not. [20]

Aftermath

The Globe and Mail described the Meatballs ad as the sole point in the campaign that Buchanan's campaign received attention, owing to the widespread backlash and condemnation directed at the spot. [24] Prior to the release of the spot, Buchanan was polling at around one percent in most polls; by the end of the campaign, following the release of Meatballs and a string of other campaign ads, Buchanan was continuing to poll at one percent, far behind Ralph Nader, a fellow third-party candidate who had spent far less money on political advertising. [1] [13] [21] [24] Buchanan's later ads would continue to focus on issues of concern to local audiences, such as "Culture War – Boy Scouts", an ad aired in Vermont (where same-sex civil unions had recently been legalized) in which he defended the Boy Scouts for prohibiting openly gay men from being scout leaders. [21] [25]

In 2001, The American Prospect columnist Dave Denison retrospectively deemed Meatballs one of the two "cheapest and sleaziest" political commercials of the 2000 campaign, while in 2015, Salon ranked the ad at number eight on its list of the "10 of the most fear-mongering political ads in American history", with writer Kali Holloway calling the ad "ridiculous" and "fear-mongering". [9] [10]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Natural Law Party (United States)</span> Political party associated with Transcendental Meditation

The Natural Law Party (NLP) is a political party in Michigan and was a national political party in the United States affiliated with the international Natural Law Party. It was founded in 1992, but beginning in 2004 many of its state chapters dissolved. The party's Michigan chapter is still active as of 2021.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1996 United States presidential election</span> 53rd quadrennial U.S. presidential election

The 1996 United States presidential election was the 53rd quadrennial presidential election, held on Tuesday, November 5, 1996. Incumbent Democratic President Bill Clinton defeated former Senate Majority Leader Bob Dole, the Republican nominee, and Ross Perot, the Reform Party nominee.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Constitution Party (United States)</span> American political party

The Constitution Party, formerly the U.S. Taxpayers' Party until 1999, is a political party in the United States that promotes a religious conservative view of the principles and intents of the United States Constitution. The party platform is based on originalist interpretations of the Constitution and shaped by principles which it believes were set forth in the Declaration of Independence, the Bill of Rights, the Constitution and the Bible.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1856 United States presidential election</span> 18th quadrennial U.S. presidential election

The 1856 United States presidential election was the 18th quadrennial presidential election, held on Tuesday, November 4, 1856. In a three-way election, Democrat James Buchanan defeated Republican nominee John C. Frémont and Know Nothing nominee Millard Fillmore. The main issue was the expansion of slavery as facilitated by the Kansas–Nebraska Act of 1854.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pat Buchanan</span> American politician and commentator

Patrick Joseph Buchanan is an American paleoconservative political commentator, columnist, politician, and broadcaster. Buchanan was an assistant and special consultant to U.S. Presidents Richard Nixon, Gerald Ford, and Ronald Reagan. He is a major figure in the modern paleoconservative movement in America, and his writings, morals, values, and strategic thinking have continued to influence many paleoconservatives.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Taiwanese Americans</span> Americans of Taiwanese birth or descent

Taiwanese Americans are Americans who carry full or partial ancestry from Taiwan. This includes American-born citizens who descend from migrants from Taiwan.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Reform Party of the United States of America</span> American political party

The Reform Party of the United States of America (RPUSA), generally known as the Reform Party USA or the Reform Party, is a political party in the United States, founded in 1995 by Ross Perot.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ezola Foster</span> American politician, activist, and writer

Ezola Broussard Foster was an American conservative political activist, writer, and politician. She was president of the interest group Black Americans for Family Values, author of the book What's Right for All Americans, and the Reform Party candidate for Vice President in the U.S. presidential election of 2000 with presidential nominee Pat Buchanan. In April 2002, Foster left the Reform Party for the United States Constitution Party.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1994 California Proposition 187</span> Ballot initiative

California Proposition 187 was a 1994 ballot initiative to establish a state-run citizenship screening system and prohibit illegal immigrants from using non-emergency health care, public education, and other services in the State of California. Voters passed the proposed law at a referendum on November 8, 1994. The law was challenged in a legal suit the day after its passage, and found unconstitutional by a federal district court on November 11. In 1999, Governor Gray Davis halted state appeals of this ruling.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1996 Republican National Convention</span> U.S. political event held in San Diego, California

The 1996 Republican National Convention convened at the San Diego Convention Center (SDCC) in San Diego, California, from August 12 to August 15, 1996. The convention nominated former Senator Bob Dole from Kansas, for president and former Representative and secretary of Housing and Urban Development Jack Kemp, from suburban Buffalo, New York, for vice president.

The "Stand By Your Ad" provision (SBYA) of the Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act, enacted in 2002, requires candidates in the United States for federal political office, as well as interest groups and political parties supporting or opposing a candidate, to include in political advertisements on television and radio "a statement by the candidate that identifies the candidate and states that the candidate has approved the communication". The provision was intended to force political candidates running any campaign for office in the United States to associate themselves with their television and radio advertising, thereby discouraging them from making controversial claims or attack ads.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Campaign advertising</span> Use of an advertising campaign through the media to influence a political debate

In politics, campaign advertising is the use of an advertising campaign through the media to influence a political debate, and ultimately, voters. These ads are designed by political consultants and political campaign staff. Many countries restrict the use of broadcast media to broadcast political messaging. In the European Union, many countries do not permit paid-for TV or radio advertising for fear that wealthy groups will gain control of airtime, making fair play impossible and distorting the political debate in the process.

The California Republican Party (CAGOP) is the affiliate of the United States Republican Party in the U.S. state of California. The party is based in Sacramento and is led by chair Jessica Millan Patterson.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2008 United States Senate election in North Carolina</span>

The 2008 United States Senate election in North Carolina was held on Tuesday, November 4, 2008. The Senate election coincided with the presidential, U.S. House elections, gubernatorial, Council of State, and statewide judicial elections. Incumbent Republican U.S. Senator Elizabeth Dole ran for re-election to a second term, but was defeated by Democrat Kay Hagan.

The 2008 presidential campaign of Tom Tancredo, a Congressman from Colorado began on April 2, 2007 with a formal announcement. The campaign garnered grassroots support and endorsements from conservative Republicans concerned about illegal immigration and border security. However, Tancredo remained low in the polls and was criticized for his nativist campaign, which had been described as "single-issued." Tancredo stated that he probably would not win the nomination but hoped his campaign would bring forth more debate on his issue of concern, immigration. On December 20, 2007 Tancredo withdrew from the presidential race, and endorsed Mitt Romney.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ralph Nader 2000 presidential campaign</span> 2000 U.S. presidential election Green Party Nader/LaDuke ticket

The 2000 presidential campaign of Ralph Nader, political activist, author, lecturer and attorney, began on February 21, 2000. He cited "a crisis of democracy" as motivation to run. He ran in the 2000 United States presidential election as the nominee of the Green Party. He was also nominated by the Vermont Progressive Party and the United Citizens Party of South Carolina. The campaign marked Nader's second presidential bid as the Green nominee, and his third overall, having run as a write-in campaign in 1992 and a passive campaign on the Green ballot line in 1996.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2000 Reform Party presidential primaries</span>

Following Ross Perot's impressive showing during the 1996 presidential election, the Reform Party of the United States of America became the country's largest third party. The party's 2000 presidential candidate would be entitled to $12.5 million in matching funds. Several high-profile candidates vied for the nomination, including Donald Trump, Pat Buchanan, and physicist John Hagelin. For a brief time, Congressman John B. Anderson and Congressman Ron Paul were considered potential candidates, but both ultimately declined to seek the nomination.

Mike Tompkins is a U.S. politician who was the Natural Law Party vice presidential candidate during the 1992 and 1996 presidential elections.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pat Buchanan 2000 presidential campaign</span> United States presidential campaign

The 2000 presidential campaign of Pat Buchanan, conservative pundit and adviser to both President Richard Nixon and Ronald Reagan, was formally launched on March 2, 1999, as Buchanan announced his intention to seek the Republican Party nomination for the presidency of the United States in the 2000 presidential election. It marked Buchanan's third primary campaign for the presidency, following his bids in 1992 and 1996. Although he had not attained the nomination either time, he had been regarded as a consequential figure within the party. Early primary surveys found Buchanan polling in the single digits, and following the publication of his book A Republic, Not an Empire, which generally advocated for noninterventionist and "America first" foreign policy, some within the Republican Party condemned Buchanan's foreign policy views. There began to be speculation that Buchanan would leave the Republican Party in favor of the Reform Party, a third party which qualified for matching federal campaign funds.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Donald Trump 2000 presidential campaign</span> Bid for US Reform Party nomination

New York real estate magnate Donald Trump announced the creation of a presidential exploratory committee on the October 7, 1999, edition of Larry King Live on CNN. Although Trump had never held elected office, he was well known for his frequent comments on public affairs and business exploits as head of The Trump Organization. He had previously considered a presidential run in 1988 as a Republican, but chose not to run. For 2000, Minnesota Governor Jesse Ventura persuaded Trump to seek the presidential nomination of the Reform Party, which was fracturing despite achieving ballot access and qualifying for matching funds as a result of businessman Ross Perot's 1996 presidential campaign on the party's ticket.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 CBSNews.com Staff (October 10, 2000). "Buchanan serves up a "Meatball"". CBS News. CBS. Retrieved November 15, 2020.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 Fleck, Tim (November 9, 2000). "Of Love & Hate". Houston Press. Retrieved November 15, 2020.
  3. 1 2 Hea Kil, Sang (November 8, 2019). Covering the Border War: How the News Media Creates Crime, Race, Nation, and the USA-Mexico Divide. Lanham, Maryland: Rowman & Littlefield. p. 99. ISBN   978-1498561433 . Retrieved July 1, 2021.
  4. 1 2 "Elections 2000". Migration News. UC-Davis. December 2000. Retrieved November 15, 2020.
  5. 1 2 3 4 Faucheux, John (2003). Winning Elections: Political Campaign Management, Strategy & Tactics. Rowman & Littlefield. p. 403. ISBN   1590770269 . Retrieved November 15, 2020.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 Bailey, Eric (October 10, 2000). "Buchanan Immigration Ad Met with Quick Criticism". LA Times. Retrieved November 15, 2020.
  7. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Teinowitz, Ira (October 16, 2000). "Buchanan Broadside: Anti-Immigration Spot". Ad Age. Archived from the original on December 8, 2020. Retrieved July 4, 2021.
  8. 1 2 3 4 5 6 "Ad Report Card: Use FedEx, Vote Buchanan, or Die". Slate. The Slate Group. October 16, 2000. Retrieved November 15, 2020.
  9. 1 2 Denison, Dave (December 19, 2001). "Political Meatballs". American Prospect. Archived from the original on March 4, 2021. Retrieved November 15, 2020.
  10. 1 2 3 4 Holloway, Kali (April 3, 2015). "10 of the most fear-mongering political ads in American history". Salon. Retrieved November 15, 2020.
  11. 1 2 Rees, Matthew (November 13, 2000). "Put Away Your Pitchforks". Washington Examiner . New York. Archived from the original on November 16, 2020. Retrieved July 13, 2021.
  12. ↑ Franken, Bob; Smith, Matt (September 12, 2000). "FEC awards Reform Party funds to Buchanan". CNN. Retrieved November 15, 2020.
  13. 1 2 Hamburger, Tom (November 6, 2000). "Buchanan, in Reform Party Fade-Out, Is Poised to Fall Short Despite U.S. Funds". Wall Street Journal. Retrieved November 15, 2020.
  14. 1 2 "Pat Buchanan on Immigration". On The Issues. October 2, 2007. Retrieved June 30, 2021.
  15. ↑ Witcover, Jules (August 12, 2000). "Buchanan gets boost in primary by e-mail". Baltimore Sun. Retrieved July 3, 2021.
  16. ↑ Carlson, Peter (September 13, 2000). "Pat Buchanan's Far Right Hand". Washington Post. Retrieved July 3, 2021.
  17. 1 2 "Buchanan Ad Attacks Immigration". New York Times. October 10, 2000. Archived from the original on May 27, 2015. Retrieved June 30, 2021.
  18. ↑ Johnson, Dennis W. (2017). Democracy for Hire: A History of American Political Consulting. Oxford University. p. 185. ISBN   978-0190272692 . Retrieved November 15, 2020.
  19. 1 2 3 Gledhill, Linda (October 10, 2000). "Buchanan Gets Message Out In Plain English / His TV ad blasts other languages". SFGate. Retrieved November 15, 2020.
  20. 1 2 3 Garfield, Bob (October 16, 2000). "Political Ad Review: Buchanan TV spot a sure head turner, and, oh yeah, racist". Ad Age. Retrieved November 15, 2020.
  21. 1 2 3 Kemper, Bob (October 31, 2000). "With Eye on '04, Buchanan Maps Last-Minute Ad Blitz". Chicago Tribune. Retrieved March 11, 2021.
  22. ↑ Levey, Bob (October 31, 2000). "Q&A With Bob Levey". Washington Post. Retrieved November 15, 2020.
  23. 1 2 Snierson, Dan (November 10, 2000). "Ad Shock". Entertainment Weekly. Meredith. Retrieved November 15, 2020.
  24. 1 2 Koring, Paul (October 25, 2000). "Third-Party Fortunes Smile on Bush". The Globe and Mail. Retrieved November 15, 2020.
  25. ↑ "Culture War-Boy Scouts". P2000: Democracy in Action. George Washington University. October 19, 2000. Retrieved July 1, 2021.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.