Plot
Vinnie Antonelli is a former mobster recently inducted into the Witness Protection Program with his wife Linda in the suburbs near San Diego. The two are under the watchful eye of federal agent Barney Coopersmith.
As he is trying to adjust to suburban life, Vinnie easily slips into his usual dishonest ways. In the supermarket, after finding a price gun, he marks down high-end items. Inadvertently stealing a car, Vinnie gets taken into the police station. Assistant DA Hannah Stubbs questions him, and he fabricates a series of elaborate lies to explain himself.
Barney has to swoop in and bail out Vinnie. Flashing his credentials, he insists Hannah cannot arraign him as she wants to due to Vinnie or "Tod's" near-future testimony in mob trials. As Barney is leaving with "Tod," and she is following them out protesting, he calls her a narrow-minded fanatic.
At the shopping center on Thanksgiving, Barney's workmate convinces him to stake out someone who is seeking stolen credit cards, but Barney sees it is "Tod" and sends him home. Meanwhile, "Tod" follows Mrs. Stubbs into a pet store and comes across another ex-mobster.
Vinnie and Barney soon find common ground when they find out both of their wives left them. Linda heads back to New York City because she misses it; Margaret leaves Barney because he is no fun and too methodological.
Introduced to a group of other ex-mobsters, Vinnie finds out the government stipend will be paid only until he testifies. Together, they start hijacking delivery trucks. Alerted to this, Hannah brings "Tod" in for questioning after he is stopped for speeding and contraband is found in his car. While he is spinning his usual tall tale, Barney springs him again as the police did not have a warrant.
Flying to New York City to testify, Vinnie gives Barney the slip, first at the airport, then at the hotel. They end up at a club, where Barney learns to merengue in the tailored suit he is talked into getting. As Vinnie has not been laying low, two mobsters try to take him out, but Barney shoots a chandelier onto them. Both men feel indebted to each other.
Back in San Diego, "Tod" gets Hannah and her sons to go to a baseball game. Inviting Barney as well, he has them sit together. They all enjoy themselves. "Tod" is told by her kids that their baseball field is not so good as it has drainage problems, whereas he suggests they do a fundraiser to pay for it. Barney invites Hannah to a law enforcement cocktail party.
Vinnie meets his kind of woman in the supermarket and they elope in Reno. At the party, Barney shows Hannah the merengue, then they compare notes on how their spouses left them. Taking her home, as the kids are out, he spends the night. The next morning her ex-husband lets himself in, and Barney throws him out.
Although he still has three weeks before his assignment with Vince is completed, Barney and his colleague are put undercover as Canadians, supposedly looking to buy stolen goods from a hijacking ring. As the shipment ends up being a truckload of watercooler bottles, Vinnie disperses them through town, marking them for donations for the little league.
Hannah has Vinnie booked and fingerprinted, but goes along with him to the motel where the fences are waiting. Breaking down their door with officers, they find Barney's FBI sting operation. Hannah insists on using his real name in an indictment, although Barney warns her that he is testifying in New York in three days and she will be summoning many hitmen if she does.
Insisting she is almost always correct, Hannah proceeds. Barney visits Vinnie in his cell, confesses his feelings for Hannah, and is upset that their association has put a rift between them. In court Hannah tries to convince the judge that there is no danger and Vinnie should not be released on bail, when two mafia hitmen open fire.
Crystal, the officer who has had a crush on Vinnie from the start, gets him out of the courthouse, he declares he is in debt to her for life and they kiss. Offering herself to him as a hostage, he drives her to an active worksite. Vinnie has gotten his ex-mob friends to break ground on a new little league ball park. Hannah has to accept defeat.
One year later, everyone is at the town's new ballpark. The new stands are full, and they are selling Vinnie's new book, 'How I Got Here' on the sidelines. He has married Crystal and they have a baby. Barney is the team's coach.
Production
In late 1987, executive producer-screenwriter Nora Ephron presented the concept for My Blue Heaven to actress Goldie Hawn, who initially expressed interest in the role of the district attorney. The project was under development at Warner Bros. with Allyn Stewart when a Writers Guild strike lasting twenty-two weeks began in March 1988, causing a delay in Ephron completing the script. In early 1989, Hawn declined the role, but she and her business partner, Anthea Sylbert, retained their positions as executive producer and producer, respectively. [4]
The search for a prominent actor to lead the film commenced, with Steve Martin expressing interest in portraying the FBI agent. However, after Danny DeVito turned down the gangster role, Ephron suggested Martin consider the lead. At one point, Arnold Schwarzenegger was cast as Antonelli but left the project after receiving the lead role in Kindergarten Cop . After Martin agreed to take his place, producers cast Rick Moranis as Coopersmith. [4] [5] [6]
Director Herbert Ross became available due to a delay in a different project, and production commenced in October 1989. Ross aimed to transcend mere escapist comedy, emphasizing the notion that "safety and comfort [lie in] middle-class values," asserting that fundamentally "everyone is middle class," even the gangster, who transforms into a "pillar of the suburban community." Ephron informed Martin that his character was more about hyperactivity than an accent. A pivotal moment in character creation occurred when Martin introduced an old costume from his former nightclub act—a "shiny, silver-gray jacket." Costume designer Joe Aulisi then crafted twenty-two light-colored designer suits in silks and sharkskins, featuring wide shoulders, lapels, and tight trousers to achieve a distinctive "lounge-lizard look." [4]
The fictional town of Fryburg, California, was crafted using various locations, including San Luis Obispo, San Diego, Los Angeles, Atascadero, and Paso Robles, California. Some exterior scenes were filmed at Jack Murphy Stadium and the Hotel del Coronado terrace in San Diego, as well as the entrance of Atascadero city hall. During post-production, the ending of the story underwent a modification to adopt a "kinder, gentler ending." [4]
