Powers & Perils (P&P) is a fantasy role-playing game published by Avalon Hill in 1984. The highly complex game was Avalon Hill's first foray into the role-playing game market, and proved to be a commercial failure.
Powers & Perils (P&P) is a fantasy role-playing game published by Avalon Hill in 1984. The highly complex game was Avalon Hill's first foray into the role-playing game market, and proved to be a commercial failure.
Powers & Perils is a fantasy role-playing game published as a boxed set that contained five rulebooks, a pad of character sheets, and dice. [1]
The first 44-page booklet, "The Character Book", describes the long character generation process. [2] Unlike Dungeons & Dragons , this game has no specific character classes. [3]
The second 52-page booklet, "The Combat and Magic Book", covers the rules of combat and spellcasting, including how characters can become magicians. [2]
The third 60-page booklet, "The Creature Book", describes the universe — divided into the Upper World, the Middle World and the Lower World — and the creatures and demons that inhabit each. [2]
The fourth 52-page booklet, "The Book of Human Encounters and Treasure", contains information for the gamemaster, including the rules for generating human non-player characters, and tables for generating treasure. [2]
The fifth 24-page booklet, "County Mordara", is an introductory adventure. [2]
Character generation is very involved, with over 40 pages of rules and dozens of tables and charts to reference. [3] The combat system is much simpler, and similar to other role-playing games of the period. [3] Characters playing spellcasters must choose a Magic Path, each featuring its own laws and spells. Like character generation, the act of casting magic requires a complex set of rules. [3]
Avalon Hill was the industry leader in board wargames in the 1960s and 1970s, so when the company announced a foray into the world of role-playing games, their new game generated anticipation. [4] The company announced that their new fantasy role-playing game was being designed by Richard Snider, one of the original players in Dave Arneson's seminal Blackmoor campaign; Snider had also co-authored Adventures in Fantasy with Arneson. Snider's game was supposed to be revealed at Origins 1983, but the product wasn't ready in time, and the rooms in which the game was supposed to have been demonstrated were instead left empty. [5] Powers & Perils was finally published some months after Origins. [5]
Following the release of Powers & Perils, Avalon Hill published three supplements for it: a complete world campaign setting titled The Perilous Lands; an adventure scenario, Tower of the Dead ; and a booklet titled The Book of Tables that was a collection of all of the many charts and formulae required to play the game.
The supplement The Perilous Lands is a boxed set that presents an entire continent called "The Perilous Lands", divided into 26 regions. A 32-page booklet, "The Map Book", displays separate maps of each region. A 68-page booklet, "The Culture Book", describes the 71 different societies or cultures that inhabit the Perilous Lands, including economic and religious details for each as well as enemies and alliances. A 36-page booklet, "The Site Book", lists seventeen notable places in the Perilous Lands, and gives detailed descriptions of fifteen of the seventeen. (One of the missing places, Tower of the Dead, was released as a separate adventure. The other, Doom Manor, was published in the second issue of Avalon Hill's short-lived fantasy magazine Heroes . [6]
Tower of the Dead, the only adventure published for Powers & Perils, is a boxed set designed by Richard Snider, with artwork by Rick Barber, Winchell Chung, Michael Creager, and Bob Haynes that contains a 56-page adventure book and a cardstock gamemaster's screen. [1] Through a four-part adventure, the player characters become aware that the lich Nilgeranthrib seeks to become ruler of Thaliba, and they must endeavor to destroy the creature. [7]
After the widespread interest in Avalon Hill's entry into the role-playing game market, Powers & Perils was received with disappointment by players and critics alike. Fantasy Gamer called it "the target of derision from many quarters within the gaming industry: Its rules are condemned as overly complicated and chart-heavy; its layout and graphics are generously described as uninspired." [8] Reviewer Matthew J. Costello felt "Disappointment because P&P adds nothing to the genre of fantasy roleplaying games. No new and exciting worlds in which to game; no innovative or gameable systems." [5] Game historian Shannon Appelcline called it "a grave disappointment" and ascribed its failure to Avalon Hill's inexperience in the role-playing game, market, "an inexperience that was highlighted by the fact that Powers & Perils included stolen art traced from fantasy artist Frank Frazetta." [4]
Poor sales of Powers & Perils led its rapid discontinuation after only a year. [4]
In Issue 6 of Fantasy Gamer , Matthew J. Costello commented "The game systems remind me of a math text gone awry. Abbreviations — 58 unfamiliar groups of letters — stalk these pages like demons. Formulas of incredible complexity ... are the crux of nearly every skill and procedure ... This is a nightmare." Costello called the time he worked through the booklets "one of the most tedious game activities I've had to do ... the rules start to read like a Mad Math Professor trying desperately to communicate the dizzying complexity of his beloved subject." [5]
In the September 1984 edition of White Dwarf (Issue #57), Adrian Knowles commented, "Overall, P&P introduces some nice ideas which can be adapted readily into other systems. The game is more suited to experienced players and GMs since it is fairly complex." Knowles concluded by giving the game a good rating of 8 out of 10, saying, "In general, a greater amount of work than is normal for an RPG is needed for playing Powers and Perils, but it is a good system." [9]
In the October 1984 edition of Imagine (Issue 19), Mike Dean stated that "I have my doubts as to whether P&P will make it as a widely popular RPG, but I am sure it will gain a considerable and well-deserved following." [10] Several issue later, Mike Dean noted the relatively high price of the adventure Tower of the Dead, but still recommended it, saying "Tower of the Dead is a formidable challenge to any experienced group of P&P players and is recommended in spite of what may seem to be a high price." [7]
In the January–February 1985 edition of Different Worlds (Issue #38), Troy Christensen was unimpressed, saying that the game "is lost in the limbo somewhere between the complexity of Chivalry & Sorcery and the simplicity of Dungeons & Dragons ." Christensen found issues with character generation, which he said: "takes about ten times longer than most fantasy games." In contrast, he found combat too simplistic, and commented that "With a combination of simplicity and complexity mixed so unequally and haphazardly, the game seems ungainly and plays roughly." Christensen concluded by giving the game a below-average rating of 1.5 stars out of 4, saying, "Powers & Perils to me adds nothing beyond what I have found in other more established games." [11]
Rick Swan reviewed Powers & Perils twice:
RuneQuest is a fantasy tabletop role-playing game originally designed by Steve Perrin, Ray Turney, Steve Henderson, and Warren James, and set in Greg Stafford's mythical world of Glorantha. It was first published in 1978 by The Chaosium. Beginning in 1984, publication passed between a number of companies, including Avalon Hill, Mongoose Publishing, and The Design Mechanism, before finally returning to Chaosium in 2016. RuneQuest is notable for its system, designed around percentile dice and an early implementation of skill rules, which became the basis for numerous other games. There have been several editions of the game.
David Lance Arneson was an American game designer best known for co-developing the first published role-playing game (RPG), Dungeons & Dragons, with Gary Gygax, in the early 1970s. Arneson's early work was fundamental to the role-playing game (RPG) genre, pioneering devices now considered to be archetypical, such as cooperative play to develop a storyline instead of individual competitive play to "win" and adventuring in dungeon, town, and wilderness settings as presented by a neutral judge who doubles as the voice and consciousness of all characters aside from the player characters.
Dungeonland (EX1) is a 1983 adventure module for the Dungeons & Dragons (D&D) roleplaying game, written by Gary Gygax for use with the First Edition Advanced Dungeons & Dragons (AD&D) rules. It is an adaptation of Lewis Carroll's 1865 novel Alice's Adventures in Wonderland, with the various characters from the book translated into AD&D terms.
Ravenloft is an adventure module for the Dungeons & Dragons (D&D) fantasy role-playing game. The American game publishing company TSR, Inc. released it as a standalone adventure booklet in 1983 for use with the first edition Advanced Dungeons & Dragons game. It was written by Tracy and Laura Hickman, and includes art by Clyde Caldwell with maps by David Sutherland III. The plot of Ravenloft focuses on the villain Strahd von Zarovich, a vampire who pines for his lost love. Various story elements, including Strahd's motivation and the locations of magical weapons, are randomly determined by drawing cards. The player characters attempt to defeat Strahd and, if successful, the adventure ends.
The Palladium Fantasy Role-Playing Game is a fantasy role-playing game published by Palladium Books in 1983.
Beyond the Supernatural is a horror role-playing game published by Palladium Books. It has seen two editions released, both of which have introduced innovations to Palladium's standard mechanics. A versatile horror-themed game, it lends itself well to wildly different play styles and narrative tones, from schlock splatter-horror to intense psychological horror, with an entire spectrum of terror in between. Beyond the Supernatural is implicitly set in the modern day, wherein magic and psychic powers are real and monsters and demonic cults exist, but out of the public eye. This, however, is not set in stone, and most of the character classes are flexible enough to account for variant settings or time periods.
Bushido is a Samurai role-playing game set in Feudal Japan, originally designed by Robert N. Charrette and Paul R. Hume and published originally by Tyr Games, then Phoenix Games, and subsequently by Fantasy Games Unlimited. The setting for the game is a land called Nippon, and characters adventure in this heroic, mythic, and fantastic analogue of Japan's past.
The original Dungeons & Dragons boxed set by Gary Gygax and Dave Arneson was published by TSR, Inc. in 1974. It included the original edition of the Dungeons & Dragons fantasy role-playing game. Its product designation was TSR 2002.
Dungeons & Dragons Immortals Rules, written by Frank Mentzer, is a boxed set for the Dungeons & Dragons (D&D) fantasy role-playing game first published by TSR in 1986 as an expansion to the Basic Set.
Lords of Creation is a multi-genre tabletop role-playing game published by Avalon Hill in 1983. Although expectations were high when Avalon Hill entered the role-playing game market, the game failed to find an audience and was discontinued relatively quickly.
Dragon Magic is an adventure module published by TSR in 1989 for the Dungeons & Dragons fantasy role-playing game, specifically the Dragonlance campaign setting.
Richard Leonard Snider was a game designer who worked primarily on role-playing games.
The Conan Role-Playing Game is a fantasy role-playing game published by TSR, Inc. in 1985 that is based on the Conan the Barbarian stories by Robert E. Howard, Lin Carter, Andrew J. Offutt. and Robert Jordan.
Lands of Adventure is a role-playing game published by Fantasy Games Unlimited (FGU) in 1983. Although similar to fantasy role-playing games in its scope, the suggested setting is historical rather than pure fantasy.
Adventures in Fantasy is a role-playing game published by Excalibre Games in 1979, designed by Dave Arneson and Richard Snider. The game is a fantasy system, similar to early Dungeons & Dragons (D&D), which Arneson co-created. It received mixed to negative reviews in game periodicals, including The Space Gamer, Ares, and Pegasus, and ultimately flopped. Arneson later bought the rights to Adventures in Fantasy and published a new edition in 1981 through his own company Adventure Games.
Final Challenge is an adventure for fantasy role-playing games published by Mayfair Games in 1984.
Vikings, Nordic Roleplaying for RuneQuest is a boxed tabletop role playing game supplement, written by Greg Stafford and Sandy Petersen, with a cover by Steve Purcell. Published under license by Avalon Hill in 1985 for Chaosium's fantasy role-playing game RuneQuest.
Into the Troll Realms, subtitled "Troll Adventures and Encounters for RuneQuest" is a supplement that includes adventures and material that involve interactions with trolls, published under license by Avalon Hill in 1988 for Chaosium's fantasy role-playing game RuneQuest
Land of Ninja is a supplement published under license by Avalon Hill in 1987 for Chaosium's fantasy role-playing game RuneQuest.
Tower of the Dead is the only adventure published by Avalon Hill in 1984 for the fantasy role-playing game Powers & Perils.
