Proto-Cushitic language

Last updated
Proto-Cushitic
Reconstruction of Cushitic languages
Region Northeast Africa
Eraca. 7000–8000 BC [1]
Reconstructed
ancestor

Proto-Cushitic is the reconstructed proto-language common ancestor of the Cushitic language family. Its words and roots are not directly attested in any written works, but have been reconstructed through the comparative method , which finds regular similarities between languages not explained by coincidence or word-borrowing, and extrapolates ancient forms from these similarities.

Contents

There is no consensus regarding the exact location of the Proto-Cushitic homeland; Christopher Ehret hypothesizes that it may have originated in the Red Sea Hills. [2] The Cushitic languages are a branch of the broader Afroasiatic macro-family. [3] [4]

Historical settings

Christopher Ehret argues for a unified Proto-Cushitic language in the Red Sea Hills as far back as the Early Holocene. [5] Based on onomastic evidence, the Medjay and the Blemmyes of northern Nubia are believed to have spoken Cushitic languages related to the modern Beja language. [6] Less certain are hypotheses which propose that Cushitic languages were spoken by the people of the C-Group culture in northern Nubia, [7] or the people of the Kerma culture in southern Nubia. [8]

Phonology

A preliminary phonological reconstruction of Proto-Cushitic was proposed by Ehret (1987).

Consonants

Proto-Cushitic consonants
LabialDentalLateralPostalveolar
/ Palatal		VelarPharyngealGlottal
Plain Labialized
StopsVoiceless(*p)*t(*ts)*tɬ ?*k*kʷ ?*ʔ
Voiced*b*d(*dz)*dɮ /
*tɬʼ ?		*g*gʷ ?
Ejective (*pʼ)*tʼ*tsʼ*tʃʼ*kʼ*kʼʷ ?
FricativesVoiceless*f*s*ɬ ?*ʃ*x*xʷ ?*ħ*h
Voiced*z*ɣ ?*ɣʷ ?*ʕ
Nasals*m*n(*ŋ)(*ŋʷ)
Rhotic*r
Approximants*l*j*w

Ehret notes that in particular the affricates *ts, *dz, and the velar nasals *ŋ, *ŋʷ rely on fairly little evidence, and that *p, *pʼ are difficult to distinguish from other consonants in the comparative material; these are shown on a darker background above.

Most of the remaining consonants have exact equivalents in reconstructed Proto-East Cushitic, with the exception of those marked here with following question mark. A system given by Appleyard [9] as "widely accepted" excludes these questioned segments, but includes *tʃ, *dʒ and a contrast of *ɗ and *tʼ. Bender [10] tentatively supports Ehret's *ts, *dz, *ŋ and labialized velars, but in his survey does not find unambiguous etymologies for these, nor for lateral, velar and pharyngeal fricatives or any ejectives.

The following basic correspondences of obstruent consonants follow Sasse (1979), with Beja and Agaw correspondences from Ehret (1987) and Dahalo correspondences from Tosco (2000): [11]

Proto-Cushitic
(Ehret)		 Beja Proto-Agaw
(Appleyard)		Proto-East
Cushitic (Sasse)		Lowland East Cushitic? H.E.C. Dullay Yaaku Dahalo
Saho–Afar Somali Rendille Arbore Oromo Konso
*bb*b*bbbbbbp*bp, b ¹pɓ-, -b-
*dd*d*ddddddt*dt, d ¹tɗ-, -d̪-
*zd-, -y-*dz, *z*zd, z ²djzdt*dz ²s, z ¹sd̪
*tt*t*ttt, -d-tttt*tt, tʃtt̪
*gg*g*ggggggk*gk, g ¹kg
*kk*k*kkk, -g-kkkk, x ³*kx, h ³k, xk
*tʼs*ts*ɗɖɖɖɗɗɗ*tʼɗɗtʼ
*kʼk*q*kʼk, ∅qxkʼkʼʛ*kʼkʼ, qqkʼ
*ff*f*fffffff*ffpf
*ss*s*sssssf, ss*ssss
*ʃʃ*ts*ʃs*ʃʃ ?
*ħh∅*ħħħħhh, ∅hhħhħ
*h*hhhh∅h
*ʕʔ*ʔ*ʕʕʕʕʔʔ, ∅ʔ, ∅ʔʕʔʕ
*ʔ ⁴*ʔʔʔʔʔ, ∅ʔ
  1. /b/, /d/, /g/, /z/ are preserved in Ts'amakko.
  2. /z/ is preserved in northern Saho. Within Highland East Cushitic, /z/ appears in Alaba and Kambaata, /d/ in other languages. [12]
  3. *k develops in Konso to /x/ before the vowels *a, *o; in the closely related Gidole always to /h/. In Dullay, *k develops to /h/ in Harso, /x/ in Gawwada.
  4. Word-initially, /ʔ/ usually does not contrast with zero.

The sonorants *m, *n, *l, *r, *j, *w normally continue unchanged in all Cushitic languages, with the exception of *j, *w > /dʒ/, /v/ in Dahalo and a merger of *l and *r in the Highland East Cushitic language Hadiyya. [12] [a]

Major conditional sound laws involve palatalization, especially in all Somaloid languages as well as Oromo, and several simplifications of consonant clusters.

Glottalized consonants

Ejective and implosive consonants show multifarious correspondences between the Cushitic languages, particularly in Oromo, the Konsoid languages, the Dullay languages and the Highland East Cushitic languages, and it is likely that more segments than *tʼ must be reconstructed, which have however fallen together as /ɗ/ or /ɖ/ in most Lowland East Cushitic languages.

Appleyard [13] does not posit any glottalized consonants for Proto-Agaw, and reconstructs uvular *q, *qʷ for sound correspondences of /kʼ/, /kʼʷ/ in Bilin, respectively, with e.g. /χ/, /χʷ/ or /q/, /qʷ/ in the rest of the subfamily. Fallon (2009) [14] argues that the Bilin value is preserved from Proto-Cushitic and that *kʼ, *kʼʷ should be reconstructed still for Proto-Agaw.

The glottalized bilabials /pʼ/, /ɓ/ are not common in Cushitic. In Oromo, /pʼ/ seems to arise from *b plus a laryngeal consonant, *ʕ or *ʔ, e.g. Oromo /ɲaːpʼa/ 'enemy' < PEC *neʕb-, akin to Saho-Afar /-nʕeb-/ 'to hate'; Oromo /supʼeː/ 'clay', Rendille /sub/ 'mud' < PEC *subʔ-. [15] Ehret finds /pʼ/ in Dahalo as grounds to reconstruct *pʼ for Proto-South Cushitic, and finding moreover /ɓ/ in Yaaku, proposes that it occurred as a rare phoneme already in Proto-Cushitic. Most other languages show /b/. [16] [b]

Additional consonants

Sasse [17] tentatively reconstructs *x as Proto-East Cushitic based on Dullay and Yaaku, but finds correspondences elsewhere to be unclear. Ehret identifies these further with *x, *xʷ occurring in South Cushitic and Agaw, and finds in Beja reflexes as the stops /k/, /kʷ/. For corresponding voiced *ɣ, *ɣʷ in Agaw, which occur only word-medially, he proposes correspondences as Beja /g/, /gʷ/; most East Cushitic *g, but implosive /ɠ/ in Yaaku and Dullay; the voiceless fricatives *x, *xʷ in South Cushitic. A remaining word-initial correspondence of /k-/, /kʷ-/ in Beja and Agaw but again *x, *xʷ in South Cushitic is then assigned to represent Proto-Cushitic *ɣ, *ɣʷ word-initially. [18]

The following are only proposed in detail by Ehret:

  • *p is based on South Cushitic. Ehret proposes it has elsewhere, with a possible exception of Awngi, fallen together with *b. [19]
  • *ts (in nine examples) differs from *s in being preserved in Kw'adza and Dahalo, and in yielding /s/ rather than /f/ in Oromo. [20]
  • *dz (four examples) yields Agaw *ts or *tʃ, East Cushitic *s, South Cushitic *dz. One example suggests /s/ in Beja. [20]
  • *ŋ (ten examples), *ŋʷ (two examples) are again based on South Cushitic, and they merge with *n in most languages, but might be reflected as /ɲ/ in Oromo, Arbore and Yaaku in a few cases. The velar nasal *ŋ is reconstructed also for Agaw, but Ehret finds it mostly unrelated and seems to arise there mainly from Proto-Cushitic *m. [21] [c]

Vowels

Most Cushitic languages agree on a simple vowel system of /a/, /e/, /i/, /o/, /u/ as well as vowel length. This system is reconstructed as already Proto-Cushitic by Ehret. [24] Bender [25] does not find the mid vowels *e, *ee, *o, *oo to be supported by clear etymologies outside of East Cushitic.

Further instances of long vowels arise in many languages through the vocalization of the laryngeal consonants *ħ, *ʕ, *h, *ʔ and monophthongization of the combinations *ay, *ey, *aw.

A rather different vowel system appears in the Agaw languages, [26] which is identical to the neighboring Ethiopian Semitic languages. [27] Ehret proposes the following development:

Proto-Agaw vowel shift
Proto-CushiticProto-AgawProto-CushiticProto-Agaw
*a*ä [ɐ]*aa*a
*e*a*ee*ə [ɨ]
*o*oo
*i*ə [ɨ]*ii*i
*u*uu*u

At least the distinction between *i and *u often remains in the appearance of palatalization or labialization on adjacent consonants.

Grammar

Personal pronouns

A personal pronoun system with six grammatical persons can be reconstructed, with distinct masculine and feminine forms for at least the third person singular, as well as two distinct forms: an "independent" form, normally used in the nominative case, as well as a "dependent" form, often used as an oblique stem e.g. for the accusative case. This distinction appears to be inherited already from Proto-Afro-Asiatic. [28]

An exclusive "we" pronoun has developed in a number of East Cushitic languages, but cannot be reconstructed even for their common ancestor. [28]

Comparative vocabulary and reconstructed roots

See Proto-Cushitic reconstructions (Appendix in Wiktionary).

Notes

  1. ↑ The result of this merger is l- word-initially, -ll- when geminate, -r- between vowels.
  2. ↑ Examples of suggested Proto-Cushitic reconstructions with *pʼ include e.g. *ginpʼ- 'heel': Dahalo /gìmpʼo/, Yaaku /kimɓa/; Burunge and Alagwa /gobina/; Arbore /ginɓa/, perhaps a borrowing from pre-Yaaku? — *pʼah- or *pʼaħ- 'dikdik': Yaaku /ɓahɓah/, Beja /baha/ — *pʼuʕ- 'to revolve': Dahalo /pʼuʕʕud̪-/ 'to drill a hole', Kw'adza poʔotis- 'to dig a hole', Beja /bʔas-/ 'to turn around'.
  3. ↑ Two cases are suggested by Ehret to be strong examples of retention of *ŋ in Agaw: Proto-Agaw *ŋaar 'head', compared by him with Arbore /ɲaːr/ 'forehead', Oromo /ɲaːra/ 'eyebrow', and Awngi /ŋɨrdʒi/ 'man', compared with Arbore /ɲerɗe/ 'young man'. [22] For the first of these, Appleyard reconstructs instead Proto-Agaw *ŋata, with irregular development *t > /r/ in Awngi /ŋárí/, and compares these with East Cushitic *matħ- 'head', Beja /mat/ 'crown of the head' (not etymologized by Ehret). [23]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Afroasiatic languages</span> Large language family of Africa and West Asia

The Afroasiatic languages are a language family of about 400 languages spoken predominantly in West Asia, North Africa, the Horn of Africa, and parts of the Sahara and Sahel. Over 500 million people are native speakers of an Afroasiatic language, constituting the fourth-largest language family after Indo-European, Sino-Tibetan, and Niger–Congo. Most linguists divide the family into six branches: Berber, Chadic, Cushitic, Egyptian, Omotic, and Semitic. The vast majority of Afroasiatic languages are considered indigenous to the African continent, including all those not belonging to the Semitic branch.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chadic languages</span> Branch of the Afroasiatic languages

The Chadic languages form a branch of the Afroasiatic language family. They are spoken in parts of the Sahel. They include 196 languages spoken across northern Nigeria, southern Niger, southern Chad, and northern Cameroon. By far the most widely spoken Chadic language is Hausa, a lingua franca of much of inland Eastern West Africa, particularly Niger and the northern half of Nigeria. Hausa, along with Mafa and Karai Karai, are the only three Chadic languages with more than 1 million speakers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cushitic languages</span> Branch of Afroasiatic native to East Africa

The Cushitic languages are a branch of the Afroasiatic language family. They are spoken primarily in the Horn of Africa, with minorities speaking Cushitic languages to the north in Egypt and Sudan, and to the south in Kenya and Tanzania. As of 2012, the Cushitic languages with over one million speakers were Oromo, Somali, Beja, Afar, Hadiyya, Kambaata, and Sidama.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Omotic languages</span> Language family of Ethiopia and Sudan

The Omotic languages are a group of languages spoken in southwestern Ethiopia, in the Omo River region and southeastern Sudan in Blue Nile State. The Geʽez script is used to write some of the Omotic languages, the Latin script for some others. They are fairly agglutinative and have complex tonal systems. The languages have around 7.9 million speakers. The group is generally classified as belonging to the Afroasiatic language family, but this is disputed by some linguists.

Beja is an Afroasiatic language of the Cushitic branch spoken on the western coast of the Red Sea by the Beja people. Its speakers inhabit parts of Egypt, Sudan and Eritrea. In 2022 there were 2,550,000 Beja speakers in Sudan, and 121,000 Beja speakers in Eritrea according to Ethnologue. As of 2023 there are an estimated 88,000 Beja speakers in Egypt. The total number of speakers in all three countries is 2,759,000.

The Agaw or Central Cushitic languages are Afro-Asiatic languages spoken by several groups in Ethiopia and, in one case, Eritrea. They form the main substratum influence on Amharic and other Ethiopian Semitic languages.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kuliak languages</span> Family of languages

The Kuliak languages, also called the Rub languages, are a group of languages spoken by small relict communities in the mountainous Karamoja region of northeastern Uganda.

The South Cushitic or Rift languages of Tanzania are a branch of the Cushitic languages. The most numerous is Iraqw, with one million speakers. Scholars believe that these languages were spoken by Southern Cushitic agro-pastoralists from Ethiopia, who began migrating southward into the Great Rift Valley in the third millennium BC.

Dahalo is an endangered Cushitic language spoken by around 500–600 Dahalo people on the coast of Kenya, near the mouth of the Tana River. Dahalo is unusual among the world's languages in using all four airstream mechanisms found in human language: clicks, implosives, ejectives, and pulmonic consonants.

Proto-Afroasiatic (PAA), also known as Proto-Hamito-Semitic, Proto-Semito-Hamitic, and Proto-Afrasian, is the reconstructed proto-language from which all modern Afroasiatic languages are descended. Though estimations vary widely, it is believed by scholars to have been spoken as a single language around 12,000 to 18,000 years ago, that is, between 16,000 and 10,000 BC. Although no consensus exists as to the location of the Afroasiatic homeland, the putative homeland of Proto-Afroasiatic speakers, the majority of scholars agree that it was located within a region of West Asia or Northeast Africa.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Languages of Ethiopia</span>

The languages of Ethiopia include the official languages of Ethiopia, its national and regional languages, and a large number of minority languages, as well as foreign languages.

The Awngi language, in older publications also called Awiya, is a endangered indigenous Central Cushitic language spoken by the Awi people, traditionally living in Central Gojjam in northwestern Ethiopia.

Highland East Cushitic or Burji-Sidamo is a branch of the Afroasiatic language family spoken in south-central Ethiopia. They are often grouped with Lowland East Cushitic, Dullay, and Yaaku as East Cushitic. The most populous language is Sidama, with close to two million speakers.

The Somali languages form a group that are part of the Afro-Asiatic language family. They are spoken as a mother tongue by ethnic Somalis in Horn of Africa and the Somali diaspora. Even with linguistic differences, Somalis collectively view themselves as speaking dialects of a common language.

Proto-Berber or Proto-Libyan is the reconstructed proto-language from which the modern Berber languages descend. Proto-Berber was an Afroasiatic language, and thus its descendant Berber languages are cousins to the Egyptian language, Cushitic languages, Semitic languages, Chadic languages, and the Omotic languages.

David Appleyard is a British academic and an specialist in Ethiopian languages and linguistics.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Proto-Afroasiatic homeland</span> Hypothetical linguistic homeland of the Proto-Afroasiatic language

The Proto-Afroasiatic homeland is the hypothetical place where speakers of the Proto-Afroasiatic language lived in a single linguistic community, or complex of communities, before this original language dispersed geographically and divided into separate distinct languages. Afroasiatic languages are today mostly distributed in parts of Western Asia and North Africa.

The East Cushitic languages are a branch of Cushitic within the Afroasiatic phylum. Prominent East Cushitic languages include Oromo, Somali, and Sidama. The unity of East Cushitic has been contested: Robert Hetzron suggested combining the Highland East Cushitic languages with the Agaw languages into a "Highland Cushitic" branch, while most other scholars follow Martino Mario Moreno in seeing Highland and Lowland as two branches of East Cushitic.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cushitic-speaking peoples</span> Collection of ethnic groups residing in East Africa

Cushitic-speaking peoples are the ethnolinguistic groups who speak Cushitic languages natively. Today, the Cushitic languages are spoken as a mother tongue primarily in the Horn of Africa, with minorities speaking Cushitic languages to the north and south in Egypt, Sudan, Kenya, and Tanzania.

Proto-East-Cushitic is the reconstructed proto-language common ancestor of the Eastern branch of the Cushitic language family. Its words and roots are not directly attested in any written works, but have been reconstructed through the comparative method, which finds systematic regularities between languages not explained by coincidence or word-borrowing, and extrapolates ancient forms from these similarities.

References

  1. ↑ Ehret, Christopher (1979-04-12). "On the Antiquity of Agriculture in Ethiopia". The Journal of African History. 20 (2): 161–177. doi:10.1017/S002185370001700X. ISSN   1469-5138.
  2. ↑ Fahmy, Ahmed G.; Kahlheber, Stefanie; D'Andrea, A. Catherine (2011). Windows on the African Past: Current Approaches to African Archaeobotany. Africa Magna Verlag. pp. 185–189. ISBN   978-3-937248-32-5.
  3. ↑ Ehret, Christopher (2023-06-20), "The Deep Background of Ancient Egyptian History, 20,000–6000 BCE", Ancient Africa, Princeton University Press, pp. 83–100, doi:10.1515/9780691244105-016, ISBN   978-0-691-24410-5
  4. ↑ Appleyard, David (2004-01-01), "BEJA AS A CUSHITIC LANGUAGE", Egyptian and Semito-Hamitic (Afro-Asiatic) Studies in Memoriam Werner Vycichl, pp. 175–194, ISBN   978-90-474-1223-6
  5. ↑ Stevens, Chris J.; Nixon, Sam; Murray, Mary Anne; Fuller, Dorian Q. (July 2016). Archaeology of African Plant Use. Routledge. p. 239. ISBN   978-1-315-43400-1.
  6. ↑ Rilly (2019), pp. 132–133.
  7. ↑ Cooper (2017).
  8. ↑ Bechhaus-Gerst (2000), p. 453.
  9. ↑ Appleyard, David L. (2012). "Semitic-Cushitic/Omotic Relations". In Weninger, Stefan (ed.). The Semitic Languages. An International Handbook. De Gruyter Mouton.
  10. ↑ Bender 2019, pp. 118.
  11. ↑ Tosco 2000, p. 105.
  12. 1 2 Hudson, Grover (1989). Highland East Cushitic Dictionary. Hamburg: Helmut Buske. p. 7.
  13. ↑ Appleyard 2006, pp. 15–16.
  14. ↑ Fallon, Paul D. (2009). "The Velar Ejective in Proto-Agaw". Selected Proceedings of the 39th Annual Conference on African Linguistics. Somerville, MA: Cascadilla Proceedings Project. pp. 10–22.
  15. ↑ Sasse 1979, pp. 14, 23, 53.
  16. ↑ Ehret 1987, p. 34.
  17. ↑ Sasse 1979, pp. 20–21.
  18. ↑ Ehret 1987, pp. 50–51.
  19. ↑ Ehret 1987, pp. 25–27.
  20. 1 2 Ehret 1987, pp. 139–142.
  21. ↑ Ehret 1987, p. 100.
  22. ↑ Ehret 1987, p. 110.
  23. ↑ Appleyard 2006, p. 81.
  24. ↑ Ehret 1987, p. 10.
  25. ↑ Bender 2019, pp. 133, 165.
  26. ↑ Appleyard 2006, pp. 10–11.
  27. ↑ Appleyard, David (2012). "Cushitic". In Edzard, Lutz (ed.). Semitic and Afroasiatic: Challenges and Opportunities. Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz. p. 202.
  28. 1 2 Appleyard, David (2012). "Cushitic". In Edzard, Lutz (ed.). Semitic and Afroasiatic: Challenges and Opportunities. Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz. pp. 206–207.

Literature

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.