Second Marx cabinet

Last updated

Second Cabinet of Wilhelm Marx
Flag of Germany.svg
11th Cabinet of Weimar Germany
3 June 1924 – 15 December 1924
(until 15 January 1925 as caretaker government)
Reichskanzler Wilhelm Marx (cropped).jpg
Chancellor Wilhelm Marx
Date formed3 June 1924 (1924-06-03)
Date dissolved15 January 1925 (1925-01-15)
(7 months and 12 days)
People and organisations
President Friedrich Ebert
Chancellor Wilhelm Marx
Vice Chancellor Karl Jarres
Member parties Centre Party
German People's Party
German Democratic Party
Status in legislature Minority coalition government
138 / 472(29%)
Opposition parties German National People's Party
Communist Party
National Socialist Freedom Movement
History
Election(s) May 1924 federal election
Legislature term(s)2nd Reichstag of the Weimar Republic
Predecessor First Marx cabinet
Successor First Luther cabinet
Gustav Stresemann (DVP), Foreign Minister Bundesarchiv Bild 146-1989-040-27, Gustav Stresemann.jpg
Gustav Stresemann (DVP), Foreign Minister
Otto Gessler (DDP), Reichswehr Minister Bundesarchiv Bild 146-1968-100-04A, Otto Karl Gessler.jpg
Otto Gessler (DDP), Reichswehr Minister
Eduard Hamm (DDP), Minister of Economic Affairs Ehamm1929.jpg
Eduard Hamm (DDP), Minister of Economic Affairs
Hans Luther (Ind.),Minister of Finance Bundesarchiv Bild 146-1969-008A-07, Hans Luther.jpg
Hans Luther (Ind.),Minister of Finance

The second Marx cabinet, headed by Wilhelm Marx of the Centre Party, was the 11th democratically elected government during the Weimar Republic. It took office on 3 June 1924 when it replaced the first Marx cabinet, which had resigned on 26 May following the unfavourable results of the May 1924 Reichstag election. The new cabinet, made up of the Centre Party, German People's Party (DVP) and German Democratic Party (DDP), was unchanged from the previous one. The three coalition parties ranged politically from centre-left to centre-right.

Contents

During the cabinet's tenure, the Reichstag voted in favour of the Dawes Plan, which resolved important issues regarding the reparations payments that the Treaty of Versailles required Germany to make to the Allied victors of World War I.

Due to the failure of Marx's attempts to expand the cabinet's minority coalition to the right, new elections were held in December 1924. The results provided little help to Marx in his attempt to form a more stable coalition, with the result that his second cabinet resigned on 15 December 1924. It remained in office as a caretaker government until it was replaced on 15 January 1925 by the cabinet of the independent Hans Luther.

Establishment

Following the lapse on 15 February 1924 of the enabling act that had allowed the emergency decrees on which many of the actions of the first Marx cabinet were based, there was no prospect of the Reichstag granting an extension. After the introduction of several draft laws that were aimed at undoing some of the government's decrees, notably on taxes, working hours and cuts to the public workforce, Marx called for new elections in May in order to prevent the Reichstag from undoing what he saw as vital policies.

The election results, which weakened the parties of the political centre and strengthened the extremes of the spectrum, were unfavourable for Marx. Because the need to approve and implement the Dawes Plan, which had been presented in April, would require a government able to act with decision, Marx's first cabinet stayed on until the new Reichstag assembled. After the German People's Party (DVP) forced the cabinet's resignation on 26 May – and faced with unacceptable demands from the newly strengthened German National People's Party (DNVP) – all of the existing ministers were simply reconfirmed in their posts as the second Marx cabinet on 3 June. [1]

Members

The members of the cabinet were as follows: [2]

PortfolioMinisterTookofficeLeftofficeParty
Chancellorship 3 June 192415 January 1925  Centre
Vice-Chancellorship 3 June 192415 January 1925  DVP
Foreign Affairs 3 June 192415 January 1925  DVP
Interior 3 June 192415 January 1925  DVP
Justice
Curt Joël (acting)
3 June 192415 January 1925  Independent
Labour 3 June 192415 January 1925  Centre
Reichswehr 3 June 192415 January 1925  DDP
Economic Affairs 3 June 192415 January 1925  DDP
Finance 3 June 192415 January 1925  Independent
Food and Agriculture 3 June 192415 January 1925  Independent
Transport 3 June 192411 October 1924  DDP
Rudolf Krohne (acting)
12 October 192415 January 1925  DVP
Postal Affairs 3 June 192415 January 1925  Centre
Occupied Territories
Anton Höfle  [ de ] (acting)
3 June 192415 January 1925  Centre

In office

The most important issue that the cabinet faced was the vote on the Dawes Plan. It had been drafted by a committee of experts from the victorious powers of World War I in an attempt to resolve major questions surrounding Germany's payment of reparations. The report emphasized that Germany must have a stable currency and a balanced budget but did not set a total reparations amount. Germany was to pay one billion gold marks the first year, with the amount rising to 2.5 billion marks per year in 1928. [3] The Reichsbank, Germany's central bank, and its national railway were placed under international control to secure payments. The Plan also provided for the withdrawal of French and Belgian troops from the occupied Ruhr. [4]

In spite of the fact that the political right objected to the Dawes Plan because of its limits on German sovereignty, the Reichstag voted 314 to 117 on 29 August to accept it. The supporters included half of the DNVP party membership, [4] which led to suspicions that they had exchanged their yes votes for promises of cabinet posts. [5] The Plan was formally signed by Germany and the Allied nations the next day.

Resignation

The parties on which the coalition was based had only 138 out of 472 seats in the Reichstag, although the Social Democratic Party (SPD) with its 100 seats for the most part supported the government's foreign policy. The DVP was interested in getting parliamentary support for key decisions from the DNVP and to add them to the coalition. One reason was that the DVP viewed the DNVP as its main rival for the public vote and wanted to include them in the government in order to force them to accept responsibility for the government's policies. Marx asked the DNVP to settle for three seats in the cabinet rather than the four they wanted, and requested that the DDP allow Otto Gessler stay on as Reichswehr minister even if the DDP did not formally take part in the government. In negotiations in October 1924, however, the DDP refused to accept government participation by the DNVP. Marx's attempts to get the DDP to agree to tolerate a cabinet based on the Centre Party, DVP and DNVP also failed. He then asked President Ebert to dissolve the Reichstag (elected not even six months previously), which he did on 20 October. [6]

The economic situation improved considerably in 1924, which was a key factor in the shift of votes from extreme to centrist parties in the election of 7 December. The Communist and Nazi Parties lost votes, whilst both Social Democrats and DNVP posted gains. That made it an open question whether the new government should include the former or the latter. Arithmetically, both an SPD/Centre/DDP/DVP or a Centre/DDP/DVP/DNVP coalition would have been able to rely on a Reichstag majority. When the DVP rejected governing with the SPD, Marx announced the cabinet's resignation on 15 December, although it stayed in office as a caretaker government. Negotiations on a new cabinet proved as difficult as they had been prior to the elections. They were broken off and a resumption postponed until early January 1925. [6]

In the talks, none of the parties moved from their earlier positions. A government based on a parliamentary majority thus proved elusive. Once again, the idea of a "government of personages" was considered, i.e. of individuals not representing parties. Marx offered two politicians of the DNVP seats in a new "non-partisan" cabinet, but both DVP and DNVP rejected the suggestion. A final attempt of Marx's to retain a cabinet based just on the Centre and DDP failed, and on 9 January he informed Ebert that he was unable to form a new government. On 15 January, the independent Hans Luther succeeded in putting together a cabinet of technocrats and "trusted men" based on a loose combination of parties from the Centre Party to the DNVP. The first Luther cabinet replaced Marx's government the same day. [6]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">German People's Party</span> Political party in Germany

The German People's Party was a conservative-liberal political party during the Weimar Republic that was the successor to the National Liberal Party of the German Empire. Along with the left-liberal German Democratic Party (DDP), it represented political liberalism in Germany between 1918 and 1933.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wilhelm Marx</span> German chancellor (1923–1925, 1926–1928)

Wilhelm Marx was a German judge, politician and member of the Catholic Centre Party. During the Weimar Republic he was the chancellor of Germany twice, from 1923–1925 and 1926–1928, and served briefly as the minister president of Prussia in 1925. With a total of 3 years and 73 days, he was the longest-serving chancellor during the Weimar Republic.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hans Luther</span> German politician, banker and diplomat

Hans Luther was a German politician and Chancellor of Germany for 482 days in 1925 to 1926. As Minister of Finance he helped stabilize the Mark during the hyperinflation of 1923. From 1930 to 1933, Luther was head of the Reichsbank and from 1933 to 1937 he served as German Ambassador to the United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Weimar Coalition</span>

The Weimar Coalition is the name given to the centre-leftist coalition of the Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD), the social liberal German Democratic Party (DDP) and the Christian democratic Centre Party, who together had a large majority of the delegates to the Constituent Assembly that met at Weimar in 1919, and were the principal groups that designed the constitution of Germany's Weimar Republic. These three parties were seen as the most committed to Germany's new democratic system, and together governed Germany until the elections of 1920, when the first elections under the new constitution were held, and both the SPD and especially the DDP lost a considerable share of their votes. Although the Coalition was revived in the ministry of Joseph Wirth from 1921 to 1922, the pro-democratic elements never truly had a majority in the Reichstag from this point on, and the situation gradually grew worse for them with the continued weakening of the DDP. This meant that any pro-republican group that hoped to attain a majority would need to form a "Grand Coalition" with the conservative liberal German People's Party (DVP), which only gradually moved from monarchism to republicanism over the course of the Weimar Republic and was virtually wiped out politically after the death of their most prominent figure, Foreign Minister Gustav Stresemann in 1929.

In the fourteen years the Weimar Republic was in existence, some forty parties were represented in the Reichstag. This fragmentation of political power was in part due to the use of a peculiar proportional representation electoral system that encouraged regional or small special interest parties and in part due to the many challenges facing the nascent German democracy in this period.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Weimar National Assembly</span> 1919–20 German constitutional convention and parliament

The Weimar National Assembly, officially the German National Constitutional Assembly, was the popularly elected constitutional convention and de facto parliament of Germany from 6 February 1919 to 21 May 1920. As part of its duties as the interim government, it debated and reluctantly approved the Treaty of Versailles that codified the peace terms between Germany and the victorious Allies of World War I. The Assembly drew up and approved the Weimar Constitution that was in force from 1919 to 1933. With its work completed, the National Assembly was dissolved on 21 May 1920. Following the election of 6 June 1920, the new Reichstag met for the first time on 24 June 1920, taking the place of the Assembly.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">First Müller cabinet</span> 1920 cabinet of Weimar Germany

The first Müller cabinet, headed by Chancellor Hermann Müller of the Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD), was the third democratically elected government of Germany and the second in office after the Weimar Constitution came into force in August 1919. The cabinet was based on the same three centre-left parties as the preceding Bauer cabinet: the SPD, Centre Party and German Democratic Party (DDP), a grouping known as the Weimar Coalition. It was formed on 27 March 1920 after the government of Gustav Bauer (SPD) resigned as a result of the unsuccessful Kapp Putsch, which it was seen as having handled badly.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fehrenbach cabinet</span> 1920–21 cabinet of Weimar Germany

The Fehrenbach cabinet, headed by Chancellor Constantin Fehrenbach of the Centre Party, was the fourth democratically elected government of the Weimar Republic. It took office on 25 June 1920 when it replaced the first cabinet of Hermann Müller, which had resigned due to the poor showing of the coalition parties in the June 1920 elections to the new Reichstag. The 1920 Reichstag replaced the Weimar National Assembly, which had served as Germany's interim parliament and written and approved the Weimar Constitution.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">First Wirth cabinet</span> 1921 cabinet of Weimar Germany

The first Wirth cabinet, headed by Chancellor Joseph Wirth of the Centre Party, was the fifth democratically elected government of the Weimar Republic. On 10 May 1921 it replaced the Fehrenbach cabinet, which had resigned as a result of differing opinions among its members over the payment of war reparations to the Allied powers. It was based on the Weimar Coalition made up of the Social Democratic Party (SPD), the Centre Party and the German Democratic Party (DDP).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Second Wirth cabinet</span> 1921–1922 cabinet of Weimar Germany

The second Wirth cabinet, headed by Joseph Wirth of the Centre Party, was the sixth democratically elected government of the Weimar Republic. It assumed office on 26 October 1921 when it replaced the first Wirth cabinet, which resigned in protest after the industrially important eastern part of Upper Silesia was awarded to Poland even though the majority of its inhabitants had voted in a plebiscite to remain part of Germany.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cuno cabinet</span> 1922–23 cabinet of Weimar Germany

The Cuno cabinet, headed by Chancellor Wilhelm Cuno, a political independent, was the seventh democratically elected government of the Weimar Republic. It took office on 22 November 1922 when it replaced the second cabinet of Joseph Wirth, which had resigned after being unable to restructure its coalition following the loss of a key vote in the Reichstag.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">First Stresemann cabinet</span> 1923 cabinet of Weimar Germany

The first Stresemann cabinet, headed by Gustav Stresemann of the German People's Party (DVP), was the eighth democratically elected government of the Weimar Republic. The cabinet took office on 13 August 1923 when it replaced the Cuno cabinet under Wilhelm Cuno, which had resigned following a call by the Social Democratic Party for a vote of no confidence which Cuno knew he could not win.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Second Stresemann cabinet</span> 1923 cabinet of Weimar Germany

The second Stresemann cabinet, headed by Chancellor Gustav Stresemann of the German People's Party (DVP), was the ninth democratically elected government of the Weimar Republic. It took office on 6 October 1923 when it replaced the first Stresemann cabinet, which had resigned on 3 October over internal disagreements related to increasing working hours in vital industries above the eight-hour per day norm. The new cabinet was a majority coalition of four parties from the moderate left to centre-right.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">First Marx cabinet</span> 1923–24 cabinet of Weimar Germany

The first Marx cabinet, headed by Wilhelm Marx of the Centre Party, was the tenth democratically elected government during the Weimar Republic. It took office on 30 November 1923 when it replaced the Second Stresemann cabinet, which had resigned on 23 November after the Social Democratic Party (SPD) withdrew from the coalition. Marx's new cabinet was a minority coalition of three centre to centre-right parties.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">First Luther cabinet</span> 1925–26 cabinet of Weimar Germany

The first Luther cabinet, headed by the political independent Hans Luther, was the 12th democratically elected government of the Weimar Republic. It took office on 15 January 1925, replacing the second cabinet of Wilhelm Marx, which had resigned when Marx was unable to form a new coalition following the December 1924 Reichstag election. Luther's cabinet was made up of a loose coalition of five parties ranging from the German Democratic Party (DDP) on the left to the German National People's Party (DNVP) on the right.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Second Luther cabinet</span> 1926 cabinet of Weimar Germany

The second Luther cabinet, headed by the independent Hans Luther, was the 13th democratically elected government of the Weimar Republic. On 20 January 1926 it replaced the first Luther cabinet, which had resigned on 5 December 1925 following the withdrawal of the German National People's Party (DNVP) from the coalition in protest against the government's support of the Locarno Treaties. Luther had wanted to build a more stable majority coalition but had to settle for a second minority government with the same parties as his first cabinet but without the DNVP.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Third Marx cabinet</span> 1926–27 cabinet of Weimar Germany

The third Marx cabinet, headed by Wilhelm Marx of the Centre Party, was the 14th democratically elected government during the Weimar Republic. On 17 May 1926 it replaced the second Luther cabinet after the resignation of Chancellor Hans Luther (independent) four days earlier. The Reichstag had passed a vote of censure against him for supporting a decree that permitted flying a German trade flag with the colours of the former German Empire in certain mostly overseas locations. The new Marx cabinet was a four-party centrist minority government.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fourth Marx cabinet</span> 1927–28 cabinet of Weimar Germany

The fourth Marx cabinet, headed by Wilhelm Marx of the Centre Party, was the 15th democratically elected government during the Weimar Republic. On 29 January 1927 it replaced the third Marx cabinet, which had resigned after information concerning clandestine operations by Germany's armed forces, the Reichswehr, had come to light.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Second Müller cabinet</span> 1928–30 cabinet of Weimar Germany

The second Müller cabinet, headed by Hermann Müller of the Social Democratic Party (SPD), was the sixteenth democratically elected government during the Weimar Republic. It took office on 28 June 1928 when it replaced the fourth Marx cabinet, which had resigned on 12 June after failing to pass a promised school law.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">First Brüning cabinet</span> 1930–31 cabinet of Weimar Germany

The first Brüning cabinet, headed by Heinrich Brüning of the Centre Party, was the seventeenth democratically elected government during the Weimar Republic. It took office on 30 March 1930 when it replaced the second Müller cabinet, which had resigned on 27 March over the issue of how to fund unemployment compensation.

References

  1. "Innenpolitische Entwicklung vom ersten zum zweiten Kabinett Marx" [Domestic Political Development from the First to the Second Marx Cabinet]. Das Bundesarchiv (in German). Retrieved 15 July 2015.
  2. "Die Kabinette Marx I und II: 30. November 1923 – 3. Juni 1924; 3. Juni 1924 – 15. Januar 1925". Das Bundesarchiv (in German). Retrieved 14 August 2023.
  3. "Dawes Plan". Encyclopedia Britannica. 9 August 2023. Retrieved 16 August 2023.
  4. 1 2 Scriba, Arnulf (2 September 2014). "Der Dawes-Plan". Deutsches Historisches Museum (in German). Retrieved 16 August 2023.
  5. Schultz, Sigrid (30 August 1924). "Germans O.K. Dawes Plan by Big Majority". Chicago Daily Tribune. p. 1.
  6. 1 2 3 "Die Verhandlungen über eine Umbildung des zweiten Kabinetts Marx" [Negotiations on a Reshuffle of the Second Marx Cabinet]. Das Bundesarchiv (in German). Retrieved 24 July 2015.