May 1924 German federal election

Last updated

May 1924 German federal election
Flag of Germany (3-2 aspect ratio).svg
  1920 4 May 1924 (1924-05-04) Dec 1924  

All 472 seats in the Reichstag
237 seats needed for a majority
Registered38,374,983 (Increase2.svg 6.7%)
Turnout77.4% (Decrease2.svg 1.8pp)
 First partySecond partyThird party
 
SPD 1924 leadership.jpg
Oskar Hergt LCCN2014717414 Trim.jpg
Reichskanzler Wilhelm Marx (cropped).jpg
Leader Hermann Müller
Otto Wels
Arthur Crispien
Oskar Hergt Wilhelm Marx
Party SPD DNVP Centre
Last election39.5%, 186 seats [a] 15.1%, 71 seats13.6%, 64 seats
Seats won1009565
Seat changeDecrease2.svg 86Increase2.svg 24Increase2.svg 1
Popular vote6,008,9055,696,4753,914,379
Percentage20.5%19.5%13.4%
SwingDecrease2.svg 19.0 pp Increase2.svg 4.4 pp Decrease2.svg 0.2 pp

 Fourth partyFifth partySixth party
 
Fischer-Ruth-1924-Bain.jpg
Bundesarchiv Bild 146-1982-092-11, Gustav Stresemann.jpg
Erich Ludendorff 1918.jpg
Leader Ruth Fischer & Arkadi Maslow Gustav Stresemann Erich Ludendorff
Party KPD DVP NSFP
Last election2.1%, 4 seats13.9%, 65 seatsDid not exist
Seats won624532
Seat changeIncrease2.svg 58Decrease2.svg 20New party
Popular vote3,693,2802,694,3811,918,329
Percentage12.6%9.2%6.5%
SwingIncrease2.svg 10.5 pp Decrease2.svg 4.7 pp New party

May 1924 German federal election - Charts.svg
May 1924 German federal election - Choropleth.svg

Government before election

First Marx cabinet
ZDVPBVPDDP

Government after election

Second Marx cabinet
ZDVPDDP

A federal election for the second Reichstag of the Weimar Republic was held in Germany on 4 May 1924. [1] It took place following a series of national crises in 1923, most notably the occupation of the Ruhr by French and Belgian troops and the resulting period of hyperinflation. The election campaign was marked by strong ideological differences over how the government had handled the problems. In the voting, the parties of the far left and far right made significant gains at the expense of the moderate parties that had been in the government or had supported it.

Contents

The splintered party groupings in the new Reichstag made it impossible to form a majority coalition. The government led by Wilhelm Marx of the Centre Party therefore continued in office, but his cabinet – already the eleventh government of the Weimar Republic – lasted only a little over six months before Marx requested a new election.

Background

The election of 4 May 1924 took place in the wake of a number of national crises during the previous year: hyperinflation, the occupation of the Ruhr, the Beer Hall Putsch and conflicts between the federal and state governments, especially in Saxony and Thuringia (the attempted communist takeover known as the German October) and in Bavaria. A national state of emergency was declared on 27 September in response to Bavaria's refusal to implement certain national laws. [2] The hyperinflation was controlled with the introduction of a new currency in November 1923, and the government was able to bring the Allies of World War I to the table on the issue of the Ruhr and Germany's war reparations. When the state of emergency lapsed in March 1924, Chancellor Wilhelm Marx, faced with parliamentary opposition to a number of the decrees issued by his minority centre-right government, requested the dissolution of the Reichstag for a new election. [3] [4] [5]

Campaign

The election campaign brought out the strong differences of opinion among the parties over the government's currency stabilization measures during the state of emergency. The conflicts became even more apparent following the release in mid-campaign of the Dawes Committee's report, which laid out a plan for Germany to pay the war reparations it owed under the Treaty of Versailles. The government, made up of the Catholic Centre Party, the German People's Party (DVP) and the German Democratic Party (DDP), took the opportunity to emphasize the positive aspects of the Dawes Plan, such as its promise that foreign troops would be withdrawn from the Ruhr, and to point out that the currency stabilization program had succeeded. The German National People's Party (DNVP) countered by calling the Dawes Plan a "second Versailles", [6] and the Communist Party of Germany (KPD) denounced it as an "enslavement of the German proletariat". [7] Within the Social Democratic Party (SPD), a group centered around Otto Wels wanted a coalition with the bourgeois parties, but the left wing around Paul Levi saw the role of the SPD in a principled opposition.

The Nazi Party had been banned by the Reich government following Adolf Hitler's failed Beer Hall Putsch in November 1923, and at the time of the election campaign Hitler was in prison. [8] The Nazis ran as the National Socialist Freedom Movement (NSFP) in a combined electoral list with the German Völkisch Freedom Party (DVFP), which had also been banned after the putsch. The wing of the Nazis centering around Hermann Esser and Julius Streicher opposed both the party union and participation in the election. The majority of the 32 representatives elected by the NSFP in May 1924 were originally members of the DVFP and not the Nazi Party. [9] [10]

Electoral system

The Reichstag was elected via party list proportional representation. For this purpose, the country was divided into 35 multi-member electoral districts. A party was entitled to a seat for every 60,000 votes won. This was calculated via a three-step process on the constituency level, an intermediate level which combined multiple constituencies, and finally nationwide, where all parties' excess votes were combined. In the third nationwide step, parties could not be awarded more seats than they had already won on the two lower constituency levels. Due to the fixed number of votes per seat, the size of the Reichstag fluctuated between elections based on the number of voters. [11]

The voting age was 20 years. People who were incapacitated according to the Civil Code, who were under guardianship or provisional guardianship, or who had lost their civil rights after a criminal court ruling were not eligible to vote. [12]

Results

The election resulted in losses for the parties of the moderate centre that had been part of the government in the previous year, particularly the DVP, which lost 20 seats, and the DDP, which lost 11. The Centre Party managed to hold its own and gained one additional seat. The SPD's loss of just three seats appeared outwardly to have been modest, but behind it lay the fact that in 1922 it had merged with the Independent Social Democrats (USPD), which had won almost five million votes and 83 seats in 1920. The SPD's losses between 1920 and 1924 show that it was unable to retain the former supporters of the USPD. Most of them turned to the KPD. [13]

Parties of the far right and far left made the greatest advances. The radical nationalist German National People's Party (DNVP) with 95 seats very nearly surpassed the SPD's 100. The Agricultural League, a new party with which the DNVP was closely allied, won 19 seats. The National Socialist Freedom Movement, which the banned Nazi Party had joined, picked up 32 seats with 6.5% of the vote. On the left of the spectrum, the KPD, with the help of former USPD voters, won 58 more seats than in 1920 and almost 13% of the vote. [5]

Germany Reichstag Jul 1924.svg
PartyVotes%+/–Seats+/–
Social Democratic Party 6,008,90520.52−1.40100−3
German National People's Party 5,696,47519.45+4.3895+24
Centre Party 3,914,37913.37−0.2765+1
Communist Party of Germany 3,693,28012.61+10.5262+58
German People's Party 2,694,3819.20−4.7045−20
National Socialist Freedom Movement 1,918,3296.55New32New
German Democratic Party 1,655,1295.65−2.6328−11
Bavarian People's Party 946,6483.23−0.9316−4
Agricultural League 574,9391.96New10New
Economic Party of the German Middle Class 500,8201.71New7New
German Social Party 333,4271.14+1.064+4
German-Hanoverian Party 319,7921.09−0.0450
Independent Social Democratic Party 235,1450.80−16.830−83
Bavarian Peasants' League 192,7860.66−0.123−1
Christian Social People's Community124,4510.43New0New
Polish People's Party 100,2600.34New0New
National Freedom Party62,0710.21New0New
Geusen League59,2220.20New0New
Party of Tenants45,9200.16New0New
Republican Party of Germany45,7220.16New0New
German Workers' Party 36,2910.12New0New
Free Economy Union F.F.F.36,0130.12New0New
Socialist League 26,4180.09New0New
Haeusser Alliance24,4510.08New0New
Wendish People's Party 10,8270.04+0.0100
National Block9,5610.03New0New
Schleswig Club7,6200.03+0.0100
Bavarian Middle Class League – Southern Region5,6590.02New0New
Independent Economic Group1,8480.01New0New
Masurian Union1,0290.00New0New
Total29,281,798100.00472+13
Valid votes29,281,79898.56
Invalid/blank votes427,5821.44
Total votes29,709,380100.00
Registered voters/turnout38,374,98377.42
Source: Gonschior.de

Notes

  1. Aggregate results for the Social Democratic Party (21.9%, 103 seats) and the USPD (17.6%, 83 seats). The two parties merged in September 1922.

Aftermath

No clear majority could be formed in the new Reichstag. The German People's Party forced the cabinet's resignation on 26 May, and Marx was faced with what he saw as unacceptable demands from the newly strengthened German National People's Party. Given the stalemate, all of the existing ministers were reconfirmed in their posts as the second Marx cabinet on 3 June. [14]

The following months were dominated by debate over the Dawes Plan, which set out a payment plan for Germany's war reparations. Its passage required a two-thirds majority due to the constitutional amendments necessary, meaning that both SPD and DNVP support was needed. The former favoured the plan, while the latter was deeply divided. After a contentious session, about half of the DNVP delegation voted in support, enough to secure its passage. With that major issue resolved, the cabinet negotiated for the DNVP's entry into the government, but without success. With no prospect of a stable government, the Reichstag was dissolved in October 1924 for a new election in December. [5]

    References

    1. Nohlen, Dieter; Stöver, Philip (2010). Elections in Europe: A data handbook. Baden-Baden: Nomos. p. 762. ISBN   978-3-8329-5609-7.
    2. Winkler, Heinrich August (1993). Weimar 1918–1933. Die Geschichte der ersten deutschen Demokratie[Weimar 1918–1933. The History of the FIrst German Democracy] (in German). Munich: C.H. Beck. p. 210. ISBN   3-406-37646-0.
    3. Nohlen & Stöver 2010, p. 790.
    4. Ogg, Fredericx A.; Shepard, Walter James (1924). "The German Elections". American Political Science Review. 18 (3): 528–533. doi:10.2307/1944174. ISSN   0003-0554. JSTOR   1944174. S2CID   145608013.
    5. 1 2 3 Kolb, Eberhard (2004). The Weimar Republic. Translated by Falla, P. S.; Park, R. J. New York City: Routledge. pp. 72–73. ISBN   0415344417.
    6. "Innenpolitische Entwicklung vom ersten zum zweiten Kabinett Marx" [Domestic Political Developments from the First to the Second Marx Cabinet]. Das Bundesarchiv (in German). Retrieved 11 March 2025.
    7. Losowski, A. (September 1925). "Paris – Breslau – Scarborough" (PDF). Die Kommunistische Internationale. 9: 999.
    8. "Beer Hall Putsch (Munich Putsch)". Holocaust Encyclopedia. 3 November 2023. Retrieved 12 March 2025.
    9. "Nationalsozialistische Freiheitspartei (NSFP)" [National Socialist Freedom Party (NSFP)]. Pacelli Edition (in German). 23 February 2017. Retrieved 14 March 2025.
    10. Döring, Martin (2001). "Parlamentarischer Arm der Bewegung". Die Nationalsozialisten im Reichstag der Weimarer Republik["Parliamentary Arm of the Movement". The National Socialists in the Reichstag of the Weimar Republic] (in German). Düsseldorf: Droste. pp. 48f, 52f. ISBN   3-7700-5237-4.
    11. Aleskerov, F.; Holler, M.J.; Kamalova, R. (21 February 2013). "Power distribution in the Weimar Reichstag in 1919–1933". Annals of Operations Research . 215 (April 2014): 25–37. doi:10.1007/s10479-013-1325-4.
    12. "Reichswahlgesetz. Vom 27. April 1920" [Reich Electoral Law of 27 April 1920]. document Archiv (in German). Retrieved 16 February 2025.
    13. Raithel, Thomas (2005). Das schwierige Spiel des Parlamentarismus: Deutscher Reichstag und französische Chambre des Députés in den Inflationskrisen der 1920er Jahre[The Difficult Game of Parliamentarianism: The German Reichstag and the French Chamber of Deputies during the Hyperinflation Crises of the 1920s] (in German). Munich: Oldenbourg Wissenschaftsverlag. pp. 342–344. doi:10.1524/9783486596311.342. ISBN   978-3-486-57683-2.
    14. "Innenpolitische Entwicklung vom ersten zum zweiten Kabinett Marx" [Domestic Political Development from the First to the Second Marx Cabinet]. Das Bundesarchiv (in German). Retrieved 15 July 2015.

    Further reading