Sunshine & Health

Last updated

Sunshine & Health
Sunshine and Health 1951 01.jpg
Cover of the January 1951 issue of Sunshine & Health
Frequencymonthly
First issue1933
Final issue1963
Based inNew Jersey [1]

Sunshine & Health (originally The Nudist) was an American nudist magazine published from 1933 until 1963. It has been described as the "flagship magazine" of the nudist movement in the US. [2] It was published monthly, and sold at newsstands as well as being distributed by subscription through the mail.

Contents

Though popular, the magazine faced a series of legal challenges relating to obscenity, particularly from the US Post Office, which repeatedly attempted to declare it nonmailable. This culminated in a favourable Supreme Court decision in Sunshine Book Co. v. Summerfield (1958). The subsequent weakening of obscenity enforcement ultimately hurt the magazine's circulation, as more sexually explicit magazines out-competed it, and it went bankrupt in 1963.

Editorial staff

The Nudist was a publication of the International Nudist Conference, which was founded in 1931 and later became the National Nudism Organization. At the launch of the magazine in 1933, Henry S. Huntington (the president of the Conference) served as editor, and Ilsley Boone (secretary of the Conference) was named as managing editor. [3] Later, Boone's daughter, Margaret A. B. Pulis would also serve as editor. [1] [2] As of the early 1950s, the magazine's operations were based in Mays Landing, New Jersey. [2]

Circulation and audience

As of 1938, the magazine was still under the title The Nudist, but included Sunshine & Health as a subtitle. During this era, photographs such as these were airbrushed to avoid visible genitalia and pubic hair. Sunshine and Health 1938 01.jpg
As of 1938, the magazine was still under the title The Nudist, but included Sunshine & Health as a subtitle. During this era, photographs such as these were airbrushed to avoid visible genitalia and pubic hair.

The first issue of The Nudist sold 10,000 copies, and the subsequent issue sold 50,000. [2] Given that the magazine's circulation far exceeded the International Nudist Conference's total membership, and that most copies were sold at newsstands rather than by subscription, it is believed that many readers bought the magazine for sexual titillation, rather than out of an interest in nudism per se. [2] The magazine attempted to gain a more respectable image by changing its name to Sunshine & Health. [2]

The magazine saw a large increase in popularity during World War II, as it was enjoyed by American soldiers as pornographic gratification, and the magazine increasingly used suggestive poses to appeal to this audience. Because it also included nude men, the magazine could also serve as a covert source of gratification for gay soldiers. [2]

Sunshine & Health magazine went bankrupt in 1963. Its decline has been attributed to increasing competition from more explicitly pornographic periodicals which emerged in the wake of a series of court rulings which relaxed the legal definition of obscenity, including its own Supreme Court victory in Sunshine Book Co. v. Summerfield. [2]

Content

The magazine included a combination of reporting related to the nudist movement and photographs of nudist men, women and children engaging in various activities.

In a concession to postal authorities, the magazine initially avoided depictions of visible genitalia or pubic hair, using airbrushing to obscure them as necessary. [2] Beginning around 1943, the magazine gradually relaxed this self-censorship policy, with photos increasingly including visible pubic hair and genitals (initially from a distance). [2]

A judge described the literary content of some 1951 issues of Sunshine & Health and sister publication SUN Magazine (also produced by Boone, but with an international scope) as:

reports of meeting and conventions, reports of officers, the "Olympic Games" of the movement, public relations theories for the expansion of nudism, reports of regional associations and local clubs, conflicts between nudism and the law, expositions of nudism for the advancement of physical and mental health, religious justifications of nudism, etc. [4]

The photographs in the same issues were described as a combination of "action pictures showing nudists in their camp activities, rowing, hitting volley balls, building fires, etc." as well as photos of "shapely and attractive young women in alluring poses". [4] The judge noted that cover photos invariably belonged to the second category. [4]

Sunshine & Health faced a number of legal challenges, particularly from the US Post Office.

In 1946, postal inspectors began an investigation of those placing letters and pen-pal notices in the magazine, suspecting them of sending nude photographs through the mail. [5]

Between 1948 and 1956, the magazine faced three separate investigations by the Post Office, in which issues were seized under suspicion of being nonmailable. Each case was eventually dismissed, but the effect on the magazine's distribution caused a significant financial burden. [1]

In New York City in 1951, several newsstand clerks were arrested for selling copies of Sunshine & Health and SUN Magazine, violating a state statute prohibiting the distribution of obscene materials. Newsstands were subsequently notified by the city's Department of Licenses that continuing to sell the magazines would result in losing their licenses. [1] Initial appeals were unsuccessful, but six years later a New York appeals court found that the city's action was an unconstitutional act of prior restraint, violating the publisher's First Amendment rights.

Sunshine Book Co. v. Summerfield

In January 1955, Boone's Sunshine Book Company filed a complaint in US district court seeking an injunction to stop the Post Office's continued seizure of the magazine. They were represented by attorneys O. John Rogge and Josiah Lyman. Judge James Robert Kirkland ruled against the magazine, writing that the "American people are a clothed race", and identifying certain particular photographs as objectionable, such as a side view of a nude man with "the corona of his penis ... clearly discernible". [1] The case was appealed to the District of Columbia Court of Appeals, which overturned the decision by a 2–1 vote in May of 1956. The government petitioned for an en banc review, and the District of Columbia Circuit Court of Appeals again reversed the earlier decision, finding in favour of the government by a 5–3 vote. Finally, the publisher appealed to the US Supreme Court. A short per curiam decision in Sunshine Book Co. v. Summerfield was handed down on January 13, 1958, finding in favour of the publisher, citing the earlier case Roth v. United States . [6] On the same day, the court issued a similar decision in One, Inc. v. Olesen , which concerned similar actions taken by the Post Office against ONE , a magazine dedicated to the homophile movement.

Related Research Articles

Naturism Movement for social nudity and naked lifestyle

Naturism is a lifestyle of non-sexual social nudity, and the cultural movement which advocates for and defends that lifestyle. Both may also be referred to as nudism. Though the two terms are largely interchangeable, nudism emphasizes the practice of nudity, whereas naturism highlights an attitude favoring harmony with nature and respect for the environment, into which that practice is integrated. That said, naturists come from a range of philosophical and cultural backgrounds; there is no single naturist ideology.

Pornographic magazine Magazines that contain content of an explicitly sexual nature

Pornographic magazines or erotic magazines, sometimes known as adult, sex or top-shelf magazines, are magazines that contain content of an explicitly sexual nature. Publications of this kind may contain images of attractive naked subjects, as is the case in softcore pornography, and, in the usual case of hardcore pornography, depictions of masturbation, oral, vaginal or anal sex.

Naked yoga A form of yoga practiced without clothing

Naked yoga is the practice of yoga without clothes. It has existed since ancient times as a spiritual practice, and is mentioned in the 7th-10th century Bhagavata Purana and by the Ancient Greek geographer Strabo.

American Association for Nude Recreation American naturism advocacy organization

The American Association for Nude Recreation (AANR) is a naturist organization based in the United States.

Ed Lange was a nudist photographer, and a publisher of many nudist pamphlets and magazines showing the nudist lifestyle.

Kurt Barthel (1884–1969) is the father of the modern United States nudist movement.

The Reverend IlsleySilias Boone, known to relatives and friends as "Uncle Danny", was born in 1879 in Brooklyn, New York and died in 1968 in Whitehouse, Ohio. He was a charismatic speaker, a powerful organizer, and was the founding father of the American Sunbathing Association (ASA), later reorganized as the American Association for Nude Recreation (AANR).

Freikörperkultur Movement for social nudity and naked lifestyle

The Freikörperkultur (FKK) is a social and health culture that originated in the German Empire, its beginnings were historically part of the Lebensreform social movement in the late 19th century. The Freikörperkultur, which translates to free body culture, consists in the connection of health aspects of being naked in light, air and sun with intentions to reform life and society. It is partially identical with the culture of nudity, naturism and nudism in the sense of communal nudity of people in leisure time, sport and everyday life.

Issues in social nudity

Social nudity is the practice of nudity in relatively public settings not restricted by gender. This occurs both in public spaces and on commercial property, such as at a naturist resort.

Physique magazine

Physique magazines or beefcake magazines were magazines devoted to physique photography — that is, photographs of muscular "beefcake" men – typically young and attractive – in athletic poses, usually in revealing, minimal clothing. During their heyday in North America in the 1950s to 1960s, they were presented as magazines dedicated to fitness, health, and bodybuilding, with the models often shown demonstrating exercises or the results of their regimens, or as artistic reference material. However, their unstated primary purpose was erotic imagery, primarily created by and for gay men at a time when homosexuality was the subject of cultural taboos and government censorship.

MANual Enterprises, Inc. v. Day, 370 U.S. 478 (1962), is a decision by the United States Supreme Court which held that magazines consisting largely of photographs of nude or near-nude male models are not obscene within the meaning of 18 U.S.C. § 1461. It was the first case in which the Court engaged in plenary review of a Post Office Department order holding obscene matter "nonmailable."

One, Inc. v. Olesen, 355 U.S. 371 (1958), was a landmark decision of the US Supreme Court for LGBT rights in the United States. It was the first U.S. Supreme Court ruling to deal with homosexuality and the first to address free speech rights with respect to homosexuality. The Supreme Court reversed a lower court ruling that the gay magazine ONE magazine violated obscenity laws, thus upholding constitutional protection for pro-homosexual writing.

The American Gymnosophical Association (AGA) was organized circa 1930 by Herman and Katherine Soshinski. It was one of 3 spin-off groups from the League for Physical Culture that had been organized by Kurt Barthel in 1929. Dr. Maurice Parmelee, Professor of Sociology, City College of New York was its honorary President.

Timeline of social nudity A chronology of the acceptance of nudity in public life

This Timeline of social nudity shows the varying degrees of acceptance given to the naked human body by diverse cultures throughout history. The events listed here demonstrate how various societies have shifted between strict and lax clothing standards, how nudity has played a part in social movements and protest, and how the nude human body is accepted in the public sphere.

Marcus v. Search Warrant, 367 U.S. 717 (1961), full title Marcus v. Search Warrant of Property at 104 East Tenth Street, Kansas City, Missouri, is an in rem case decided by the United States Supreme Court on the seizure of obscene materials. The Court unanimously overturned a Missouri Supreme Court decision upholding the forfeiture of hundreds of magazines confiscated from a Kansas City wholesaler. It held that both Missouri's procedures for the seizure of allegedly obscene material and the execution of the warrant itself violated the Fourth and Fourteenth amendments' prohibitions on search and seizure without due process. Those violations, in turn, threatened the rights protected by the First Amendment.

Richard Ungewitter was a German pioneer of the nudist movement and one of its first organizers. There was a völkisch element in Ungewitter's ideas.

Henry Strong Huntington Jr. (1882-1981), was a Presbyterian minister who advocated the healthful advantages nudism. He established the Burgoyne Trail Nudist Camp near Otis, Massachusetts. He was editor of the magazine, The Nudist. He was also an advocate of eugenics.

Marguerite Agniel

Marguerite Agniel was a Broadway actress and dancer, and then a health and beauty guru in New York in the early 20th century. She is known for her 1931 book The Art of the Body: Rhythmic Exercise for Health and Beauty, one of the first to combine yoga and nudism.

Naturism in New Zealand Lifestyle of living without clothing in New Zealand

Naturism refers to a lifestyle of practising non-sexual social nudity in private and in public, and to the cultural movement which advocates and defends that lifestyle. Both are also known as "nudism". Naturist organisations have existed in New Zealand since the 1930s. Although not a daily feature of public life, social nudity is practised in a variety of other contexts in New Zealand culture.

Naturist resort Clothes-free recreational facility

A naturist resort or nudist resort is an establishment that provides accommodation and other amenities for guests in a context where they are invited to practise naturism – that is, a lifestyle of non-sexual social nudity. A smaller, more rustic, or more basic naturist resort may be called a naturist camp.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 Shepard, Jason M. (2019). "The First Amendment and the Roots of LGBT Rights Law: Censorship in the Early Homophile Era, 1958–1962". William & Mary Journal of Race, Gender, and Social Justice.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Hoffman, B. (2010). "'A Certain Amount of Prudishness': Nudist Magazines and the Liberalisation of American Obscenity Law, 1947–58". Gender & History. doi:10.1111/j.1468-0424.2010.01611.x.
  3. "Nekkid". The New Yorker. July 8, 1933.
  4. 1 2 3 Sunshine Book Co. v. McCaffrey(N.Y. Sup.25 April 1952). Text
  5. Johnson, David K. (2019). Buying Gay: How Physique Entrepreneurs Sparked a Movement. New York: Columbia University Press. ISBN   978-0-231-18911-8.
  6. Anthony Lewis (January 14, 1958). "Nudist Magazines Win Mail Rights". The New York Times.