The Family Circus

Last updated

The Family Circus
1960s-era Family Circus cartoon.png
An early strip featuring (L to R) Daddy (Bil), Dolly, Billy, Mommy (Thel), and Jeffy. A fourth child, P.J., was introduced in 1962.
Author(s) Bil Keane
Jeff Keane
Current status/scheduleRunning
Launch dateFebruary 29, 1960;64 years ago (February 29, 1960)
Alternate name(s)The Family Circle
Family-Go-Round
Syndicate(s) (Current) King Features Syndicate
(Previous) Register and Tribune Syndicate (1960–1986)
Genre(s)Humor, gag cartoon, family values, religious
Preceded by Silly Philly

The Family Circus (originally The Family Circle, also Family-Go-Round) is a syndicated comic strip created by cartoonist Bil Keane and, since Keane's death in 2011, written, inked and rendered (colored) by his son Jeff Keane. The strip generally uses a single captioned panel with a round border, hence the original name of the series, which was changed following objections from the magazine Family Circle . The series debuted February 29, 1960, and has been in continuous production ever since. According to publisher King Features Syndicate, it is the most widely syndicated cartoon panel in the world, appearing in 1,500 newspapers. [1] Compilations of Family Circus comic strips have sold more than 13 million copies worldwide.

Contents

Characters

Family

The central characters of Family Circus are a family whose surname is rarely mentioned (although the cartoon of August 26, 2013, in which Billy refers to "Grandma Keane" and "Grandma Carne" indicates the same surnames as the author's family). The parents, Bil and Thelma (Thel), are modeled after the author and his wife, Thelma Carne Keane. [2] [3] [4] Their four children, Billy, Dolly, Jeffy, and P.J., are fictionalized composites of the Keanes' five children. With the exception of P.J., no characters have aged appreciably during the run of the strip.

Bil (named Steve in the early years of the strip) works in an office, and he is believed to be a cartoonist, most likely based on the writer of the strip because he draws large circles on paper, presumably a cartoon version of the Family Circus. Some panels refer to Bil as a veteran of World War II.

Thel is a college-educated homemaker. The Los Angeles Times ran a feature article on the Thelma character when Keane updated her hairstyle in 1996. [5]

The eldest child is seven-year-old Billy. A recurring theme involves Billy as a substitute cartoonist for a Sunday strip. The strips purportedly drawn by Billy are crudely rendered and reflect his understanding of the world and his sense of humor. The first use of this gag by Keane was in This Week magazine in 1962 in a cartoon titled "Life in Our House" that attributed the childish drawings to his six-year-old son Chris. [6] Keane also modeled Billy after his eldest son Glen, now a prominent Disney animator.

The character of five-year-old Dolly was modeled after Keane's daughter and eldest child Gayle. [7] Dolly was a nickname that Thelma Keane called little girls. [7]

The character of three-year-old Jeffy was named and modeled after Keane's youngest child Jeff. [7]

The comic family's youngest child P.J. (Peter John) was introduced through a series of cartoons about the mother's pregnancy that culminated in the baby's birth on August 1, 1962. [8] P.J. grows to be about one year old and rarely speaks.

Extended family

Bil's mother (Florence, but usually called Grandma) appears regularly in the strip and apparently lives near the family. Bil's father (Al, called Granddad by the kids and Bil) is dead but occasionally appears in the strip as a spirit or watching from heaven. Bil's father (as a spirit) plays a prominent role in the TV special A Family Circus Christmas. Al died after the launch of the feature. However, in the November 25, 2012 strip, it was indicated that he had died before Jeffy was born, although the character Al was featured in strips prior to Granddad's death.

Thel's parents are both alive but apparently live several hundred miles away in a rural area. Strips have mentioned them living in Iowa, but one 2007 strip mentioned Florida. The family occasionally visits them for a vacation.

Pets

The family pets are two dogs—a Labrador named Barfy and a shaggy-haired mutt named Sam, a stray that the children brought home on January 26, 1970—and an orange tabby cat named Kittycat.

Other characters

Location

The Family Circus takes place in Scottsdale, Arizona. They often visit a popular ice cream parlor named the Sugar Bowl (based on a real restaurant of the same name that features many strips signed by Keane), and Jeffy once went to St. Joseph's Hospital for a tonsillectomy. Thel was seen playing tennis with a racket marked "Scottsdale Racket", and Bil mentioned moving up to B class at Scottsdale Racket Club in a 1984 strip. Also, a sign for Paradise Valley, where Bil Keane lived the latter part of his life, is seen in one 1976 strip. Sometimes the family is depicted enjoying snow at their home in the strip, but Scottsdale receives very little snow in the winter. Bil Keane commented that he took aspects of his boyhood in Pennsylvania, such as snow, and added them to the strip.

Themes

Religion

One distinguishing characteristic of the Family Circus is the frequent use of Christian imagery and themes, ranging from generic references to God to Jeffy daydreaming about Jesus at the grocery store. Keane states that the religious content reflects his own upbringing and family traditions. [10] Keane was Roman Catholic, and in past cartoons the children have been shown attending Catholic schools with sisters as teachers and attending Catholic church services, much as Keane did in his childhood years at St. William Parish in Philadelphia. Keane was a frequent contributor to his high school newspaper The Good News at Northeast Catholic High School for Boys in Philadelphia, where he graduated in 1940. [11] Some of his comics with scenes in Billy's bedroom depict a pennant reading "NC" on the wall, a tribute to his alma mater and his Catholic education.

Billy the Substitute Cartoonist

Sometimes Keane's strips would have crude drawings purportedly done by "Billy, Age 7." Some of "Billy's" drawings would be explaining vocabulary, only he does not understand the right word, such as confusing "hysterical" with "historical" or defining "acquire" as "a group of singers in church." The "Billy" drawings would often show a more detailed drawing of Keane's, such as Billy crying over losing a game to his father, and then the next strip saying "This is what really happened, by Billy," showing the crude drawing of Billy winning and an annoyed Bil Keane retorting, "No more games, I gotta draw Sunday's cartoon!" One series of strip for the dailies in 1990 had the father away on a business trip while "Billy" explains a multitude of childish reasons for his father's absence, such as alien abduction or having been baked into a witch's pie. The story arc ended with a drawing showing the father back at home and the kids asking about such preposterous happenings to his befuddlement.

Dotted lines

One of the best-known features of Keane's work is the dotted-line comics, showing the characters' paths through the neighborhood or house with a thick dotted line. The earliest appearance of the dotted line was on April 8, 1962 (an undotted path had first appeared on February 25). This concept has been parodied by other comic strips, including Pearls Before Swine , For Better or For Worse , FoxTrot , Calvin and Hobbes , Garfield , Liō , Marvin and xkcd . In an interview, Jeff Keane, who now produces the strip, described how he creates the line by drawing one continuous black line and then breaking it into segments with white. [12] The dotted line has taken different formats, such as when the family took a vacation to San Francisco and were shown in a dotted line down famous Lombard Street ("the crookedest street in the world"), or Jeffy and his grandfather taking a walk in the park, with Jeffy running around wildly, indicated by an uneven dotted line, with his grandfather's path as a straight dotted line. Other strips would show the dotted line with captions.

Gremlins

In April 1975, Keane introduced an invisible gremlin named "Not Me" who watches while the children try to shift blame for a misdeed by saying, "Not me." Additional gremlins named "Ida Know" (in September 1975), "Nobody," "O. Yeah!" and "Just B. Cause" were introduced in later years. Although it is clear that the parents do not accept the existence of the gremlins, they did include them as members of the family, perhaps tongue-in-cheek, when being interviewed by a member of the U.S. Census Bureau. Another time when Thel was sick of hearing about the gremlins from the kids ("Who's been rummaging in Gramma's purse?" "Not me!"), she asked her mother-in-law if she had ever dealt with such absurdity, causing Florence to remark, "Well, I'm sure that he has been around at least since I was a little girl," in which there is a flashback to Florence's childhood with her father demanding to know, "Who scratched my new Glenn Miller record?," with little Florence firmly stating, "Not me!" and the "Not Me" entity smugly standing by.

Grown children

One theme that Keane tried occasionally was to picture the children as adults, or what might come of it. One time when Billy had been asked by Thelma not to leave the house until he finished his homework, she told him, "One day when you are grown up you will thank me for this!," causing Billy to imagine the absurdity of himself as a fully grown man visiting his elderly mother just to thank her for telling him that as a child. Other adult ideas included the parents telling Jeffy not to be shy when they invited friends to the house, and then he is pictured 25 years later as an outgoing late-night talk-show host akin to Jay Leno. Another example showed P.J. not wishing to be introduced to the toddler daughter of family friends, only to show 30 years later that both are now grown and are celebrating their wedding day. Yet another had Thel telling Billy that she cannot clean his messes for his whole life, then imagining a fully grown Billy as a businessman running a chain of "High Hat Hotels" and an aged, weary Thel working as one of the maids.

Family car

For the first 25 years, the family car was a station wagon, first based on Keane's own 1961 Buick. [13] In 1985, a year after the introduction of the Plymouth Voyager and the Dodge Caravan, the family appears in a series of cartoons trading the station wagon for a new minivan (when the salesman assures Mom and Dad that "Lee Iacocca stands behind every vehicle we sell," the children look behind the van to see if Mr. Iacocca is back there). The family's minivan resembles the Dodge/Plymouth twins and includes the Chrysler corporate pentastar logo on its hood. The children enjoy showing the new van to their friends: "And it has a sliding door, like an elevator." Early strips also showed the family in a small convertible, a caricature based on Keane's Sunbeam Rapier. [13]

Format

Daily strip

The daily strip consists of a single captioned panel with a round border. The panel is occasionally split in two halves. One unusual practice in the series is the occasional use of both speech balloons within the picture and captions outside the circle. The daily strip does not generally follow a weekly story arc, with the exception of family vacations.

Sunday strip

The format of the Sunday strip varies considerably from week to week, although there are several well-known recurring themes. One recurring theme is a single picture surrounded by multiple speech balloons, representing the children's response to a given scenario, although the speaker of any given speech balloon is never explicitly shown (this format began on May 30, 1965).

Other media

Book collections

There are 89 compilations of Family Circus cartoons. For a full list of book titles, see Family Circus collections .

Television

The Family Circus characters appeared in animated form in three television holiday specials, all broadcast on NBC:
A Special Valentine with the Family Circus (1978), [14]
A Family Circus Christmas (1979), [15]
A Family Circus Easter (1982). [16]
The Easter special featured jazz musician Dizzy Gillespie as the Easter Bunny. This special is a musical and features Dolly singing "Hey There, Easter Bunny". [16]

Feature film

In October 2010, 20th Century Fox and Walden Media announced that they had acquired the film rights for a live-action feature film based on the Family Circus cartoon. [17] Nichole Millard and Kathryn Price have been hired to adapt the comic strip as a live-action project. [18]

Video game

An educational video game was released for home computers in 1992. Called Our House featuring the Family Circus (a.k.a. Now and Then), the game compares life in modern times to those when the parents, grandparents and other ancestors of the comic were young.

Parodies

The Family Circus has been widely satirized in film, television, and other daily comic strips. In an interview with The Washington Post , Keane said that he was flattered and believed that such parody "...is a compliment to the popularity of the feature..." [19] The official Family Circus website contains a sampling of syndicated comic strips from other authors which parody his characters. [20]

Some newspaper comic strips have included entire storylines using Family Circus characters. In 1994, the surreal Zippy the Pinhead comic strip made multiple references to the Family Circus, including an extended series during which the titular character, a pinhead, sought "Th' Way" to enlightenment from Bil, Thel, Billy, and Jeffy. [21] Bil Keane was credited as "guest cartoonist" on these strips, drawing the characters exactly as they appear in their own strip, but in Zippy's world as drawn by Zippy creator Bill Griffith. [21] Griffith described the Family Circus as "the last remaining folk art strip." Griffith said, "It's supposed to be the epitome of squareness, but it turns the corner into a hip zone." [22]

For the 1997 April Fools' Day comic strip switcheroo, Dilbert creator Scott Adams swapped cartoons with Keane; [23] and Stephan Pastis drew a series in which Family Circus "invaded" Pearls Before Swine in 2007. Pastis, who had a close relationship with Bil and Jeff Keane, created numerous parodies of Family Circus "because it was an icon." [24]

The Dysfunctional Family Circus was a satire website which paired Keane's illustrations with user-submitted captions. Keane claimed to have found the site funny at first.[ citation needed ] However, disapproving feedback from his readership, coupled with the website's use of double entendre and vulgarity, prompted Keane to request that the site be discontinued.

The webcomic Jersey Circus is a mashup of artwork from The Family Circus and dialogue from the reality show Jersey Shore . It juxtaposes the innocent artwork of the comic with the often adult dialogue from the show to parody both media phenomena. [25]

The 1999 novel The Funnies, by J. Robert Lennon, centered around a dysfunctional family whose late patriarch drew a cartoon similar to The Family Circus. Lennon later said that, although there was a "resemblance," he did not "know anything about Bil Keane and made up my characters from scratch." [26]

The cartoon has been the subject of gags on many television sitcoms including episodes of Pinky and the Brain , Mystery Science Theater 3000 , The Simpsons , Friends , Drawn Together , Robot Chicken , Mad , an episode of Family Guy ("Dog Gone") [27] [28] and the 1999 movie Go .

In the Diary of a Wimpy Kid book and film series, the main character, Greg Heffley, and his dad share a common dislike for the comic strip Lil' Cutie, which Greg claims is "for the lameness of a Family Circus knockoff comic." [29]

Some Pearls Before Swine strips include appearances by the Family Circus characters or parodic Family Circus strips. In one series of strips, Rat is captured by Family Circus fans after poking fun at the Family Circus. In the week of June 27, 2005, Stephan Pastis portrayed the cartoon Keane family inviting Osama bin Laden into their house. Bin Laden is captured by the police while following Billy's dotted lines, and the whole family is imprisoned at Guantanamo Bay for harboring a terrorist. [30]

The 2016 graphic novel The Fun Family by Benjamin Frisch tells the dark story of the family of the creator of a Family Circus-like strip. [31]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Comic strip</span> Short serialized comics

A comic strip is a sequence of cartoons, arranged in interrelated panels to display brief humor or form a narrative, often serialized, with text in balloons and captions. Traditionally, throughout the 20th and into the 21st century, these have been published in newspapers and magazines, with daily horizontal strips printed in black-and-white in newspapers, while Sunday papers offered longer sequences in special color comics sections. With the advent of the internet, online comic strips began to appear as webcomics.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cartoon</span> Type of two-dimensional visual art

A cartoon is a type of visual art that is typically drawn, frequently animated, in an unrealistic or semi-realistic style. The specific meaning has evolved, but the modern usage usually refers to either: an image or series of images intended for satire, caricature, or humor; or a motion picture that relies on a sequence of illustrations for its animation. Someone who creates cartoons in the first sense is called a cartoonist, and in the second sense they are usually called an animator.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">National Cartoonists Society</span> Professional organization

The National Cartoonists Society (NCS) is an organization of professional cartoonists in the United States. It presents the National Cartoonists Society Awards. The Society was born in 1946 when groups of cartoonists got together to entertain the troops. They enjoyed each other's company and decided to meet on a regular basis.

Silly Philly was the first comic strip by Bil Keane, most noted for the long-running comic The Family Circus. Silly Philly ran from April 27, 1947, to September 3, 1961.

The Dysfunctional Family Circus was the name of several long-running parodies of the syndicated comic strip The Family Circus, featuring either Bil Keane's artwork with altered captions, or original artwork made to appear like the targeted strips. First distributed anonymously by mail and fax in 1989, by 1994 various versions of it began to appear on the World Wide Web. The most popular version, edited by Greg Galcik, began in 1995 and ceased in 1999 following a telephone conversation between Galcik and Keane.

<i>Pearls Before Swine</i> (comics) Comic strip by Stephan Pastis

Pearls Before Swine is an American comic strip written and illustrated by Stephan Pastis. The series began on December 31, 2001. It chronicles the daily lives of an ensemble cast of suburban anthropomorphic animals: Pig, Rat, Zebra, Goat, and a fraternity of crocodiles, as well as a number of supporting characters, one of whom is Pastis himself. Each character represents an aspect of Pastis's personality and worldview. The daily and Sunday comic strip is distributed by Andrews McMeel Syndication.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stephan Pastis</span> American cartoonist (born 1968)

Stephan Thomas Pastis is an American cartoonist and former lawyer who is the creator of the comic strip Pearls Before Swine. He also writes children's chapter books, commencing with the release of Timmy Failure: Mistakes Were Made. The seventh book, It's the End When I Say It's the End, debuted at #4 on The New York Times Best Seller list for Children's Middle Grade Books.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bil Keane</span> American cartoonist (1922–2011)

William Aloysius Keane was an American cartoonist best known for the newspaper comic strip The Family Circus. He began it in 1960 and his son Jeff Keane continues to produce it.

The comic strip switcheroo was conducted on April 1, 1997, in which several cartoonists, without the foreknowledge of their editors, worked on the other's comic strip for that date, in commemoration of April Fools' Day.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tom Richmond (illustrator)</span> American cartoonist

Tom Richmond is an American freelance humorous illustrator, cartoonist and caricaturist whose work has appeared in many national and international publications since 1990. He was chosen as the 2011 "Outstanding Cartoonist of the Year", also known as "The Reuben Award", winner by the National Cartoonists Society.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Morrie Turner</span> American cartoonist

Morris Nolton Turner was an American cartoonist. He was creator of the strip Wee Pals, the first American syndicated strip with a racially integrated cast of characters.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Richard Thompson (cartoonist)</span> American illustrator and cartoonist

Richard Church Thompson was an American illustrator and cartoonist best known for his syndicated comic strip Cul de Sac and the illustrated poem "Make the Pie Higher". He was given the Reuben Award for Outstanding Cartoonist of the Year for 2010.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">SpinnWebe</span>

SpinnWebe was the personal website of Greg Galcik, also known as "spinn". It gathered the most fame as the home of the Dysfunctional Family Circus, which ran in the late 1990s. The site also included a number of Galcik's other projects, which generally had interactive humor as the unifying theme; in this respect, it anticipated the development of later sites such as Fark and Something Awful. Spinnwebe is a German word for "spider web".

Jeff Keane is an American cartoonist. He is the youngest son of the late cartoonist Bil Keane who, following his father's death in 2011, became inker and colorist of the syndicated comic strip The Family Circus, after having assisted on it since 1981.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thelma Keane</span> Australian-born American businesswoman (1926–2008)

Thelma "Thel" Keane was the Australian-born American wife of The Family Circus newspaper cartoonist, Bil Keane. Keane served as her husband's inspiration and model for the "Mommy" character in his long-running comic strip and was instrumental in restoring the copyrights for The Family Circus to her husband.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">National Cartoon Museum</span> American museum dedicated to cartoons, comic strips and animation

The National Cartoon Museum was an American museum dedicated to the collection, preservation and exhibition of cartoons, comic strips and animation. It was the brainchild of Mort Walker, creator of Beetle Bailey. The museum opened in 1974, and went through several name changes, relocations, and temporary closures, before finally closing for good in 2002.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Billy Ireland Cartoon Library & Museum</span> Cartoon museum located on the Ohio State University campus

The Billy Ireland Cartoon Library & Museum is a research library of American cartoons and comic art affiliated with the Ohio State University library system in Columbus, Ohio. Formerly known as the Cartoon Research Library and the Cartoon Library & Museum, it holds the world's largest and most comprehensive academic research facility documenting and displaying original and printed comic strips, editorial cartoons, and cartoon art. The museum is named after the Ohio cartoonist Billy Ireland.

A zombie strip is a comic strip whose creator has died or retired, but which continues to exist with new installments in syndication done by a succeeding writer or artist, most often relatives of the original creator. Zombie comic strips are often criticized as lacking the "spark" that had originally made the strip successful.

References

  1. ↑ The Family Circus Archived 2004-04-01 at the Wayback Machine , King Features Syndicate, www.kingfeatures.com
  2. ↑ "Inspiration for 'Family Circus' Mommy dies". CNN. Archived from the original on 2008-05-27. Retrieved 2008-05-26.
  3. ↑ Meyers, Amanda Lee (2008-05-27). "Thelma Keane; Wife Of Cartoonist Bil Keane". Associated Press Obituaries. The Washington Post. Retrieved 2008-05-29.
  4. ↑ Inspiration For Circus Mom Dead at 82, United Press International, UPI.com, May 26, 2008
  5. ↑ Baum, Geraldine (May 23, 1996). "Mommy Finally Makes The Cut". Los Angeles Times. Los Angeles. Retrieved May 9, 2021.
  6. ↑ This Week , issue of January 7, 1962, Last Laugh Page
  7. 1 2 3 Keane, Christopher (November 2009). "Raising the Big Top". The Family Circus: Daily and Sunday Comics 1960-1961. The Library of American Comics. Vol. 1. IDW. pp. 22–23. ISBN   9781600105487.
  8. ↑ Keane, Christopher (June 2010). "Adding to the Act". The Family Circus: Daily and Sunday Comics 1962-1963. The Library of American Comics. Vol. 2. IDW Publishing. p. 10. ISBN   9781600106576.
  9. ↑ Chang, Jeff (2009). "Morrie Turner and the Kids". The Believer (November/December). Retrieved 2013-03-18.
  10. ↑ Gunty, Christopher, Bil Keane's Family Circus, Saint Anthony's Messenger, November 2001
  11. ↑ "North Catholic Falcons Merchandise | Celtic Shirts: Your Source for North Catholic Apparel and Merchandise".
  12. ↑ "All in the Family: A Cartooning Roundtable". December 25, 2017.
  13. 1 2 Keane, Christopher (2010). Adding to the Act. The Family Circus: Daily and Sunday Comics. Vol. 1962–1963. IDW Publishing. pp. 7–18. ISBN   978-1-60010-657-6.
  14. ↑ Woolery, George W. (1989). Animated TV Specials: The Complete Directory to the First Twenty-Five Years, 1962-1987. Scarecrow Press. pp. 389–390. ISBN   0-8108-2198-2 . Retrieved 27 March 2020.
  15. ↑ Woolery, pp.139-140
  16. 1 2 Spurgeon, Tom (January 1, 2012). "Bil Keane, 1922-2011". The Comics Reporter. Retrieved 18 April 2015.
  17. ↑ Fleming, Mike (8 October 2010). "Fox, Walden Media Win 'The Family Circus'". Deadline Hollywood . Retrieved 2012-12-27.
  18. ↑ McNary, Dave (October 19, 2012). "Fox, Walden set writers for 'Family Circus' film".
  19. ↑ "Comics: Meet the Artist", Washington Post Online, March 1, 2002
  20. ↑ archive "Take-Offs Archived 2007-04-05 at the Wayback Machine , www.familycircus.com, retrieved 2009
  21. 1 2 Bill Griffith, Still asking, "Are we having fun yet?", Interdisciplinary Comic Studies, Vol. 1 No. 2, 2004, ISSN   1549-6732
  22. ↑ Pat Seremet, "Zippy and The Family Circus--Together again!!", The Hartford Courant, July 11, 2002
  23. ↑ Zitz, Michael (April 1, 1997). "April Fools: This is some funny business". The Free Lance Star. p. D1.
  24. ↑ Pastis, Stephan (November 9, 2011). "The Dotted Line Fades Away — A Few Words About Bil Keane (1922-2011)". The Blog O' Stephan Pastis. stephanpastis.wordpress.com.
  25. ↑ Friedman, Megan (August 30, 2010). "Jersey Circus Gives Family Values Some GTL". Time . Retrieved August 31, 2010.
  26. ↑ J. Robert Lennon, Comment, Rakes Progress, September 29, 2006
  27. ↑ Haque, Ahsan. "Family Guy: "Dog Gone" Review". IGN. Retrieved 2009-12-01.
  28. ↑ "The TV Critic.org - Episode 8 - Dog Gone Review". The TV Critic.org. Retrieved 2009-12-02.
  29. ↑ Horn, John (28 July 2012). "'Wimpy Kid' Greg Heffley isn't your typical summer movie hero". Los Angeles Times.
  30. ↑ "Pearls Before Swine by Stephan Pastis" GoComics, retrieved November 26, 2022
  31. ↑ McMillian Graeme (7 July 2016). "'The Fun Family' Comic Uncovers Darkness Behind Suburban Life (Exclusive Preview)". Hollywood Reporter. Retrieved 2019-03-06.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.