Thinking It Over (album)

Last updated

Thinking It Over
Thinking It Over(Liberty X album) coverart.jpg
Studio album by
Released27 May 2002
RecordedApril 2001 – March 2002
London, England
Genre
Length53:58
Label V2
Producer
Liberty X chronology
Thinking It Over
(2002)
Being Somebody
(2003)
Singles from Thinking It Over
  1. "Thinking It Over"
    Released: 24 September 2001
  2. "Doin' It"
    Released: 3 December 2001
  3. "Just a Little"
    Released: 13 May 2002
  4. "Got to Have Your Love"
    Released: 9 September 2002
  5. "Holding On for You"
    Released: 2 December 2002

Thinking It Over is the debut studio album by British-Irish pop group Liberty X. The album was released on the back of their success on television talent show, Popstars , and was recorded in the year following the series' finale, where the band became runners-up to Hear'Say.

Contents

Originally titled—and released in Japan as—To Those Who Wait, it was released in the United Kingdom on 27 May 2002 under its new title and became the biggest selling album of the band's career, selling nearly 750,000 copies. Five singles were released from the album: "Thinking It Over", "Doin' It", "Just a Little", "Got to Have Your Love" and "Holding On for You". "Just a Little" became Liberty X's only number-one single and won a BRIT Award for Best British Single in 2003. [2]

Background

The band began recording the album under their original name, Liberty, just two weeks after the finale of Popstars . The album's production was overseen by Steve Duberry, while the band co-wrote several songs with writer and producer Tim Laws. The album's lead single, "Thinking It Over", was released on 24 September 2001, to worldwide success, charting high in the United Kingdom, Japan and Europe. Due to its success, the band's record label decided to push the release of the album, then entitled To Those Who Wait, forward by three months, due to be released just four weeks later on 22 October. However, shortly after the announcement, it was revealed the band had become entangled in a legal dispute with a band of the same name, who claimed that the current group did not have the right to use the name Liberty, as it was already being used by another artist. Thus, this prevented the album being released in the United Kingdom as planned. [3]

However, as the lawsuit didn't cover international territory, the Japanese side of the band's record label made the decision to go ahead with the album's release as planned, making To Those Who Wait available from 28 November 2001. [4] The album contained fourteen tracks. Whilst still entangled in the lawsuit, the band released their second single, "Doin' It", on 10 December 2001. It failed to achieve the chart success of its predecessor, but still charted highly in the United Kingdom. On 18 February 2002, the lawsuit was settled, with the current group instead changing their name to Liberty X. It was then decided that the album would revamped for the British market, and the band returned to the studio to record new material. Three new songs were recorded, the first of which, "Just a Little", was released as the band's third single on 13 May 2002. Just a day later, the track listing for the British version of the album was revealed, which contained the three new songs, but removed "Greed" and "Never Meant to Say Goodbye" from the original edition, as they had already been issued as B-sides in the country, and also removed "Practice What You Preach" altogether, meaning it remains unreleased in the country. The album's title was also changed, this time being released under the alias of Thinking It Over. The album was finally released in the UK on 27 May 2002. [5]

The second of the new songs, "Got to Have Your Love", was released as the band's fourth single on 9 September 2002, to moderate success. It also became the band's first cover version to be released as a single. "Holding On for You" was released as the album's fifth and final single on 2 December 2002, followed a week later by a re-release of the album, containing a bonus disc of seven remixes and three music videos, all contained in a gold slipcase. In December 2002, the album was also released in China, reinstating "Never Meant to Say Goodbye", as well as adding two bonus remixes, and the B-side track "Breathe" to the end of the album, making a total of eighteen tracks. The band revealed in an interview in April 2003 that "Wanting Me Tonight" was originally due to be released as the album's third single, but "Just a Little" was released instead, at the request of the record company. A single remix of "Wanting Me Tonight" instead appears as a B-side on the "Just a Little" physical single release.

Critical reception

Professional ratings
Review scores
SourceRating
AllMusic Star full.svgStar full.svgStar full.svgStar full.svgStar empty.svg [6]
The Guardian Star full.svgStar full.svgStar full.svgStar empty.svgStar empty.svg [7]
NME (positive) [8]
PopMatters (mixed) [9]

Allmusic editor Jon O'Brien called Thinking It Over "a master class in how to bury the reality pop tag," citing it "a strong collection of pop songs incorporating garage, R&B, and soul. Indeed, listening to the album, you begin to wonder how none of the members managed to be selected in the Popstars show, as vocally they are head and shoulders above their rivals, particularly Kevin Simm and Kelli Young, whose honey-smooth tones work together brilliantly [...] Several tracks toward the end are distinctly filler-ish [...] but this is a refreshing attempt at R&B-infused pop that never once tries to imitate its U.S. counterparts but does leave its U.K. contemporaries trailing in its wake." [6] Peter Robinson from NME declared the ablbum "something of a triumph." He found that "the people who do that sort of thing have assembled 14 strong, solid tracks across R&B, ’80s electro funk, 2-step and straightforward pop, and married them to spot-on production values. Result? The most 2002 pop album of 2002." [8]

In his review for PopMatters , Duncan White found that Thinking It Over "has been well planned [and] catchy songs have been written." He remarked that the album is "expertly targeted. Bland and spineless, Liberty X disguise themselves in the sham clothes of their more credible "peers". I'm not going to dip into the predictable rant on manufactured pop, but I do find it sinister that, like a "smart" bomb, a band can be so precisely targeted." [9] The Guardian journalist Caroline Sullivan wrote that "the future appears brighter for losing Popstars finalists Liberty X than for the winning Hear'Say [...] The single "Just a Little" is a poised wispette rooted in the same slinky pop/R&B soil that produced All Saints and Sugababes. Other bits of "Thinking It Over" pull off the same feat, making potentially cheesy songs sound almost cool through the use of sparse beats and composed vocals dominated by the band's three girls. The inevitable cover version isn't, for once, a 1970s standard but Mantronix's 1990 hit "Got to Have Your Love." So: not bad." [7]

Track listing

Standard edition
No.TitleWriter(s)Producer(s)Length
1."Thinking It Over"
  • Devereux
  • The Wideboys
4:09
2."Just a Little"
  • Michelle Escoffery
  • George Hammond Hagan
  • John Hammond Hagan
The BigPockets3:58
3."Doin' It"
  • Stephen Duberry
  • Steve Hart
  • John McLaughlin
  • Duberry
  • McLaughlin
3:51
4."Wanting Me Tonight" K-Gee 4:28
5."Got to Have Your Love"
Rod Gammons3:55
6."No Clouds"
Mushtaq3:56
7."Everyday" Goldust 4:49
8."Saturday"
  • Escoffery
  • Uddin
Tim Laws3:47
9."Holding On for You"
  • Martin Prime
  • Simm
  • Lundon
  • Taylor
  • Young
  • Laws
  • Frazer Hurrell
Laws3:30
10."I Got What You Want"
  • Taylor
  • Young
  • Alan Glass
  • David Brant
  • Maryanne Morgan
Brant3:44
11."Feel the Rush"
  • Henrik Andersson
  • Martin Ankelius
  • McLaughlin
  • McLaughlin
  • Duberry
3:36
12."Right Here Right Now"
  • Lundon
  • Simm
  • Hart
  • Harwood
  • Keynes
  • O'Mahony
  • Andrea Remanda
Goldust4:21
13."Dream About It"
  • Simm
  • Young
  • Taylor
  • Heaton
  • Lundon
  • Laws
  • Hurrell
  • Laws
  • Hurrell
3:47
14."Never Give Up"
  • Simm
  • Lundon
  • Taylor
  • Young
Goldust1:30
Chinese edition bonus tracks
No.TitleWriter(s)Producer(s)Length
15."Never Meant to Say Goodbye"
  • Lundon
  • Simm
  • Young
  • Taylor
Goldust4:45
16."Thinking It Over" (Pete Devereux & The Wideboys Club Vocal Remix)
  • Lundon
  • Young
  • Hart
  • Hart
  • Applegate
  • Sullivan
  • Craig
  • Devereux
  • Devereux
  • The Wideboys
 
17."Just a Little" (Almighty Mix)
  • Escoffery
  • G. Hammond Hagan
  • J. Hammond Hagan
  • The BigPockets
  • Almighty [A]
 
18."Breathe"LundonK-Gee3:51
Special edition bonus disc
No.TitleWriter(s)Producer(s)Length
1."Thinking It Over" (Pete Devereux & The Wideboys Club Vocal Remix)
  • Lundon
  • Young
  • Hart
  • Hart
  • Applegate
  • Sullivan
  • Craig
  • Devereux
  • Devereux
  • The Wideboys
 
2."Doin' It" (The Wideboys Club Mix)
  • Duberry
  • Hart
  • McLaughlin
  • Duberry
  • McLaughlin
  • The Wideboys [A]
 
3."Doin' It" (Blacksmith R&B Rub)
  • Duberry
  • Hart
  • McLaughlin
  • Duberry
  • McLaughlin
  • Blacksmith [A]
 
4."Wanting Me Tonight" (Wookie Full Vocal Mix)
  • Escoffery
  • Gordon
  • Taylor
  • Heaton
  • Lundon
  • Simm
  • Young
  • K-Gee
  • Wookie [A]
 
5."Just a Little" (Bump & Flex Electro Shock Club Mix)
  • Escoffery
  • G. Hammond Hagan
  • J. Hammond Hagan
  • The BigPockets
  • Bump & Flex [A]
 
6."Got to Have Your Love" (Jam & Faces Vamp Mix)
  • Wilson
  • Khaleel
  • Rodriguez
  • Gammons
  • Jam & Faces [A]
 
7."Got to Have Your Love" (Kurtis Matronik's 3 Way Action Mix)
  • Wilson
  • Khaleel
  • Rodriguez
  • Gammons
  • Kurtis Matronik [A]
 
8."Got to Have Your Love" (Video)   
9."Just a Little" (Video)   
10."Thinking It Over" (Video)   
Japanese edition (released as To Those Who Wait)
No.TitleWriter(s)Producer(s)Length
1."Thinking It Over"
  • Lundon
  • Young
  • Hart
  • Applegate
  • Sullivan
  • Craig
  • Devereux
  • Devereux
  • The Wideboys
4:09
2."Doin' It"
  • Duberry
  • Hart
  • McLaughlin
  • Duberry
  • McLaughlin
3:51
3."Wanting Me Tonight"
  • Escoffery
  • Gordon
  • Taylor
  • Heaton
  • Lundon
  • Simm
  • Young
K-Gee4:28
4."No Clouds"
  • Young
  • Taylor
  • Simm
  • Lundon
  • Uddin
Mushtaq3:56
5."Everyday"
  • Simm
  • Lundon
  • O'Mahony
  • Keynes
  • Harwood
Goldust4:49
6."Saturday"
  • Escoffery
  • Uddin
Laws3:47
7."Holding on for You"
  • Prime
  • Simm
  • Lundon
  • Taylor
  • Young
  • Laws
  • Hurrell
Laws3:30
8."I Got What You Want"
  • Taylor
  • Young
  • Glass
  • Brant
  • Morgan
Brant3:44
9."Practise What You Preach"
  • Taylor
  • Simm
  • Young
Laws2:59
10."Greed"
  • Simm
  • Lundon
  • Hart
  • Harwood
  • Laws
  • Hurrell
Laws3:41
11."Right Here Right Now"
  • Simm
  • Lundon
  • Hart
  • Harwood
  • Keynes
  • O'Mahony
  • Remanda
Goldust4:21
12."Dream About It"
  • Simm
  • Young
  • Taylor
  • Heaton
  • Lundon
  • Laws
  • Hurrell
  • Laws
  • Hurrel
3:47
13."Never Give Up"
  • Simm
  • Lundon
  • Taylor
  • Young
Goldust1:30
14."Never Meant to Say Goodbye"
  • Lundon
  • Simm
  • Young
  • Taylor
Goldust4:45

Notes

Charts

Certifications

RegionCertification Certified units/sales
United Kingdom (BPI) [20] 2× Platinum693,000 [21]

Release history

List of release dates, showing region, formats, label, editions, and reference
RegionDateFormat(s)LabelEdition(s)Ref
Japan28 November 2001CD (To Those Who Wait) V2 Records Standard [1]
Ireland24 May 2002CD
United Kingdom27 May 2002CD, cassette
China11 December 2002CD
United Kingdom9 December 2002CDDeluxe

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Liberty X</span> British-Irish music group

Liberty X are an English/Irish pop group originally consisting of Michelle Heaton, Tony Lundon, Kevin Simm, Jessica Taylor and Kelli Young. Since 2017, Heaton, Taylor and Young have performed as a girl group trio.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hear'Say</span> 2001–2002 British pop group

Hear'Say were a British pop group. They were created through the ITV reality TV show Popstars in February 2001, the first UK series of the international Popstars franchise. The group, who were signed to Polydor Records, originally consisted of Danny Foster, Myleene Klass, Kym Marsh, Suzanne Shaw, and Noel Sullivan.

Jessica Pietersen is an English singer. She is best known as member of the pop group Liberty X.

<i>Sound of the Underground</i> (album) 2003 studio album by Girls Aloud

Sound of the Underground is the debut studio album by English-Irish girl group Girls Aloud, formed through the ITV television series Popstars: The Rivals. It was released in Ireland on 23 May 2003, in the United Kingdom and Europe on 26 May 2003, and reissued on 17 November 2003 through Polydor. Girls Aloud worked with a variety of musicians and producers on Sound of the Underground, which was largely inspired by 1980s music. Comparisons were made with artists such as Bananarama, The Bangles, Blondie and Spice Girls.

Kevin Ian Simm is an English singer and songwriter. He is best known as former member of Liberty X (2001–2007) and current vocalist of Wet Wet Wet. Simm also won The Voice UK in 2016.

Kelli Young is an English singer. She is best known as member of the pop group Liberty X.

<i>Now... Us!</i> 2002 studio album by No Angels

Now... Us! is the second studio album by German girl group No Angels. It was released by Polydor and Cheyenne Records on June 24, 2002, in German-speaking Europe. Recorded after the release of the band's majorly successful debut album Elle'ments (2001), the group consulted work by frequent collaborators Thorsten Brötzmann, Peter Ries, and Leslie Mándoki as well as international songwriters and producers such as Anders Bagge, Figge Boström, Dennis Dowlut, Mousse T., Pontus Söderqvist, and Quiz & Larossi, while taking a wider role in contributing own lyrics and melodies to the album.

<i>Ellements</i> 2001 studio album by No Angels

Elle'ments is the debut studio album by German girl group No Angels. It was first released by Polydor–Zeitgeist and Cheyenne Records on 12 March 2001 in German-speaking Europe. After winning the inaugural season of the reality talent contest Popstars in late 2000, Polydor consulted a small team of German-based musicians to work with the quintet, including Thorsten Brötzmann, Peter Ries, Leslie Mándoki, and Peter Plate. Elle'ments is a pop record with an inclusion of styles such as dance, R&B, Latin and rock. Conceptually, the album centered on the idea of the classical elements, and during that time was compared to English girl group the Spice Girls' Forever (2000) era.

<i>Being Somebody</i> 2003 studio album by Liberty X

Being Somebody is the second studio album by English-Irish pop vocal group Liberty X. It was released on 3 November 2003 via V2 Records. The album was released a year-and-a-half after their debut release, Thinking It Over. The album peaked at number 12 on the UK Albums Chart, selling around 75,000 copies in its first week of release.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Just a Little (Liberty X song)</span> 2002 single by Liberty X

"Just a Little" is a song by English-Irish pop group Liberty X. Written by singer Michelle Escoffery and produced by the BigPockets, it was released on 13 May 2002 as the third single from the group's debut studio album, Thinking It Over. The song proved to be Liberty X's breakthrough to mainstream and critical success, in the process overtaking fellow Popstars alumni Hear'Say in terms of success.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thinking It Over (song)</span> 2001 single by Liberty X

"Thinking It Over" is the debut single of English-Irish pop group Liberty, before they became Liberty X. The garage song was produced by Pete Devereux and the Wideboys. It was co-written by band members Kelli Young and Tony Lundon. In the United Kingdom, the single was a hit, reaching number five, but was not as successful internationally, peaking at number 29 in Ireland and number 81 in Australia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Something About Us (No Angels song)</span> 2002 single by No Angels

"Something About Us" is a song by German female pop band No Angels. It was chiefly written by band member Vanessa Petruo along with frequent collaborator Thorsten Brötzmann and Alexander Geringas for the group's second studio album Now... Us! (2002), and created as a response to what the band felt was intense and sometimes unfair and inaccurate media criticism at the time, predominantly resulting from the clichés and prejudices generally associated with their manufactured band image. Produced by Brötzmann and co-producer Jeo, the uptempo track incorporates elements of both the contemporary R&B and dance-pop genre as well as Latin-pop and church music during the bridge.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pure and Simple (song)</span> 2001 single by HearSay

"Pure and Simple" is a song by British pop group Hear'Say, the winners of the UK version of Popstars. It was a cover of the original version recorded three years earlier by English-Dutch girl group Girl Thing, who were dropped from BMG before the song was given to Hear'Say. It was written by Pete Kirtley, Tim Hawes, and Betty Boo. The song was released on 12 March 2001 as the lead single from Hear'Say's debut studio album, Popstars (2001). The B-side is a cover of Simon & Garfunkel's "Bridge over Troubled Water".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Everybody (Hear'Say song)</span> 2001 single by HearSay

"Everybody" is a song by British pop group Hear'Say, written by Martin Harrington, Ash Howes, Richard Stannard, Julian Gallagher, and Andy Caine. Produced by Harrington and Howes, the track was recorded for the group's second studio album of the same name (2001), released nine months after their debut album, Popstars. "Everybody" was issued as the album's lead single on 26 November 2001 and was the final single released by the band before member Kym Marsh quit. Upon its release, the song peaked at number four on the UK Singles Chart. The song's music video is set inside a space capsule and shows the five band members dancing on a stage.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Liberty X discography</span>

The discography of Liberty X, a British pop band, consists of three studio albums, twelve singles and a number of other appearances. The group's first two singles "Thinking It Over" and "Doin' It" launched them to fame, "Thinking It Over" shot to number 5 and "Doin' It" peaked at number 14. Their third single, "Just a Little" took the band straight to the top of the UK charts, next single "Got to Have Your Love" peaked at number two. This release was preceded by their debut album, Thinking It Over peaking at number 3 in the UK. The final single to be taken from the album was "Holding On for You", released in December 2002 and which debuted and peaked at number 5.

<i>Popstars: The Rivals</i> Spin-off

Popstars: The Rivals is a British television talent show series that was broadcast on ITV in late 2002. It was the second UK series of the international Popstars franchise. Unlike Popstars, which resulted in the formation of one winning group, Hear'Say, Popstars: The Rivals created two rival groups, Girls Aloud and One True Voice, who competed against each other for the Christmas number one spot on the UK Singles Chart. Girls Aloud won and would go on to achieve twenty consecutive top ten hits, four number ones and six top ten albums, two of which reached number one and from that, group member Cheryl would achieve five number-one singles and two number one albums.

<i>Popstars</i> (British TV series) discography

Popstars (UK) is a British reality television show produced for ITV that aired for two series. The first series, Popstars, aimed to find five singers to form a new pop group. During the second series, Popstars: The Rivals, two music groups were formed to compete for the Christmas number-one single in the United Kingdom.

<i>Popstars</i> (British TV series) 2001 British reality television series

Popstars is a reality music competition series that was broadcast on ITV in early 2001. It was the first UK series of the international Popstars franchise, and was billed as a documentary on the formation of a modern pop group. The programme began with audition rounds of aspiring singers performing covers of classic songs before a panel of judges. The best performers were selected to come to London for further rounds of auditions. Over the weeks, the judges eliminated various singers from the auditions until just a few singers were left in contention. In the final weeks, five contestants were chosen by the judges to form the new pop group Hear'Say. The programme then showed the group recording and promoting their first single, documenting their first ventures into the music industry.

Warren Stacey is a British singer from London who came into prominence on the UK television show Popstars, the reality programme that created the pop band Hear'Say. Despite not making it into the group, Stacey went on to be signed by Def Jam Recordings and released his debut single "My Girl, My Girl" in March 2002, which made number 26 on the UK Singles Chart.

<i>Popstars</i> (HearSay album) 2001 studio album by HearSay

Popstars is the debut album by British pop group Hear'Say, formed through the ITV television show Popstars. It was released in the United Kingdom on 26 March 2001. Hear'Say worked with a number of British and Scandinavian producers, including Stargate, and Quiz & Larossi. The album drew comparisons to similarly co-ed pop groups such as S Club 7 and Steps.

References

  1. 1 2 "iTunes – Music – Thinking It Over by Liberty X". Apple Inc. Retrieved 8 May 2013.
  2. "The 10 naffest Brit Award winners: From S Club 7 to Shaggy and Joss Stone - Metro News". Metro.
  3. "Bands Forced To Change Their Names". ShortList Magazine.
  4. "To Those Who Wait by Liberty". MTV Artists.
  5. "Thinking It Over - CD". amazon.co.uk.
  6. 1 2 AllMusic review
  7. 1 2 Sullivan, Caroline (24 May 2002). "Quakes and scorchers". The Guardian . Retrieved 26 August 2020.
  8. 1 2 Robinson, Peter (12 September 2005). "The most 2002 pop album of 2002..." NME . Retrieved 26 August 2020.
  9. 1 2 "Liberty X: Thinking It Over". PopMatters . 7 April 2003. Retrieved 26 August 2020.
  10. "Dutchcharts.nl – Liberty X – Thinking It Over" (in Dutch). Hung Medien. Retrieved 26 August 2020.
  11. "Billboard - Google Books". 15 June 2002. Retrieved 18 August 2010.
  12. "Lescharts.com – Liberty X – Thinking It Over". Hung Medien. Retrieved 26 August 2020.
  13. "Top 75 Artist Album, Week Ending 30 May 2002". GfK Chart-Track. Archived from the original on 20 January 2018. Retrieved 8 August 2022.
  14. "Charts.nz – Liberty X – Thinking It Over". Hung Medien. Retrieved 26 August 2020.
  15. "Official Scottish Albums Chart Top 100". Official Charts Company. Retrieved 16 October 2020.
  16. "Swisscharts.com – Liberty X – Thinking It Over". Hung Medien. Retrieved 26 August 2020.
  17. "Official Albums Chart Top 100". Official Charts Company. Retrieved 16 October 2020.
  18. "UK Year-End Charts 2002" (PDF). UKChartsPlus . p. 4. Retrieved 26 August 2020.
  19. "UK Year-End Charts 2003" (PDF). UKChartsPlus . p. 4. Retrieved 26 August 2020.
  20. "British album certifications – Liberty X – Thinking It Over". British Phonographic Industry . Retrieved 25 July 2012.Select albums in the Format field. Select Platinum in the Certification field. Type Thinking It Over in the "Search BPI Awards" field and then press Enter.
  21. Wade, Ian (30 December 2021). "Iconic albums turning 20 in 2022". Official Charts Company . Retrieved 2 April 2022.