We Were Strangers

Last updated
We Were Strangers
We Were Strangers poster.jpg
Theatrical poster
Directed by John Huston
Written byJohn Huston
Peter Viertel
Based onChina Valdez
1948 novel Rough Sketch
by Robert Sylvester
Produced by Sam Spiegel
Starring Jennifer Jones
John Garfield
Cinematography Russell Metty
Edited by Al Clark
Music by George Antheil
Color process Black and white
Production
company
Distributed by Columbia Pictures
Release date
  • April 27, 1949 (1949-04-27)
Running time
106 minutes
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish

We Were Strangers is a 1949 American adventure drama film directed by John Huston and starring Jennifer Jones and John Garfield. Set in 1933, the film concerns a group of revolutionaries attempting to overthrow the Cuban government of Gerardo Machado. The story is based loosely on an episode in Robert Sylvester's novel Rough Sketch and draws on historical events.

Contents

Background to plot

The story draws on events that occurred as part of the political violence that led to the overthrow of Cuban dictator Gerardo Machado y Morales in 1933. In 1932, a violent opposition group, the ABC (abecedarios), assassinated the President of the Cuban Senate Clemente Vazquez Bello. They had previously constructed a tunnel into the Vazquez family crypt in Havana's Colón Cemetery and planted an explosive device there, anticipating that Machado would attend the funeral. The plan failed when the family decided to bury Vazquez elsewhere. [1]

Plot

A group of revolutionaries plot to bring down their corrupt government. China Valdés is a bank clerk whose brother distributes anti-government flyers. She watches as a plain clothes police officer guns him down on the steps of the University of Havana. She vows to kill his assassin, Ariete. At her brother's funeral, Tony Fenner, an American, asks her to join his anti-government underground group instead of taking revenge on her own.

When he learns that China's house is next to a cemetery, Fenner devises a scheme to dig a tunnel from China's house and under the cemetery, then assassinate a senior government official whose family plot is in that cemetery, and detonate a bomb during the man's funeral, killing the government officials among the mourners. His disparate group of tunnelers includes a dockworker, a bicycle mechanic, and a graduate student. The revolutionaries spend days digging the tunnel, and struggle with the fact that they will kill some officials who are less than entirely evil and also take the lives of innocent bystanders. Ramón goes mad thinking of these issues, and wanders off and dies in a traffic accident.

Meanwhile, Ariete harasses China, jealous of her relationship with Fenner, whom he has learned is actually Cuban by birth.

When the tunnel is ready, a prominent government minister is assassinated as planned. A munitions expert prepares to set the bomb in place, but they learn that the burial will not take place at the family tomb as expected, and their plan has failed.

They make arrangements for Fenner to leave Cuba before he is arrested by Ariete. China is to get the necessary funds from Fenner's account at her bank. Fenner rages about his failure, and the disgrace of returning to the people who funded his trip with small donations, after he had fled as a boy with his father. China declares her love for him.

China obtains the funds but sends a fellow employee with them because she is being tailed by one of Ariete's men. Fenner, unwilling to leave without her, comes to China's house, and they have a gun battle with the police. China takes up a submachine gun and gives cover as Fenner lobs sticks of dynamite. He is mortally wounded but hears the bells ringing for the outbreak of revolution and popular celebration.

Cast

Production

Huston, recognizing the sensitive nature of the film's politics, formed an independent production company, Horizon Films, to finance the film. [2] One critic has noted the film is "a barely disguised indictment of U.S. foreign policy" as well as a study of "the poetry of failure" typical of Huston's style. [3] Huston cast Garfield partly because they shared the same political outlook. [3]

Most of the film was shot at the Columbia Pictures studio in Los Angeles, with additional second unit work done in Havana. The second unit footage employed locally hired doubles for Jennifer Jones and other cast members. [4]

Much of the script was written as filming progressed. According to Peter Viertel, "Huston was going through a lot of personal problems at the time, and he was unable to concentrate on the film" even though it presented serious challenges: "It was a very difficult story with an ending that wasn't exactly considered happy by Hollywood standards." The ending was repeatedly rewritten by a variety of writers, with the final version by Ben Hecht. [5] The title, chosen by the distributor Columbia Pictures in place of Rough Sketch,[ citation needed ] refers to how the revolutionaries come together with no prior associations, sharing only their political principles.

The supporting players include Mexican film star Pedro Armendáriz as the corrupt police chief, and former silent stars Gilbert Roland and Ramon Novarro as members of the resistance. John Huston makes a cameo appearance as a bank teller. Many of the film's outdoor scenes were shot against rear projections, which are quite noticeable, including views of Havana Harbor, Havana University, Morro Castle, and Colon Cemetery. The film, however, achieves an almost documentary-like feel with its stark black-and-white photography. The film was evidently unavailable for viewing until it was made available for domestic video sale in 2005, long after John Huston's other films became available.

During filming, Huston was asked to give Marilyn Monroe, then unknown, a screen test. As a result, he cast her in a small role in his next film, The Asphalt Jungle . [5]

Reception

John Huston directed the film between two box office successes: The Treasure of Sierra Madre (1948) and The Asphalt Jungle (1950). We Were Strangers was released in April 1949 and received mixed reviews. In The New York Times , Bosley Crowther praised the physical and psychological realism of the conspirators, but he disliked Jennifer Jones' performance and missed a central romance: "the real emotional tinder which is scattered within this episode is never swept into a pyramid and touched off with a quick, explosive spark". [6] Reviews in Time and Collier's were more positive, but The Hollywood Reporter denounced its politics: "a shameful handbook of Marxian dialectics ... the heaviest dish of Red theory ever served to an audience outside the Soviet". [7] The film was withdrawn from theaters shortly after its release. [8] The Communist Party's Daily Worker thought it was "capitalist propaganda." [3] [2]

American audiences were perplexed by it, its largely Hispanic cast did not resonate with white Americans, and its shocking presidential assassination theme may have offended some sensibilities. [3]

Claimed effect on Lee Harvey Oswald

According to Priscilla Johnson McMillan's biography of Lee Harvey Oswald and his wife, Marina, Oswald was "greatly excited" while watching We Were Strangers on television in October 1963, just a few weeks before he assassinated President John F. Kennedy. [9]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cuban Revolution</span> 1955–58 armed rebellion against the Cuban government led by Fidel Castro

The Cuban Revolution was the military and political overthrow of Fulgencio Batista's dictatorship, which had reigned as the government of Cuba between 1952 and 1959. The revolution began after the 1952 Cuban coup d'état, which saw Batista topple the nascent Cuban democracy and consolidate power. Among those opposing the coup was Fidel Castro, then a novice attorney who attempted to contest the coup through Cuba's judiciary. Once these efforts proved fruitless, Fidel Castro and his brother Raúl led an armed attack on the Cuban military's Moncada Barracks on 26 July 1953.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gerardo Machado</span> President of Cuba from 1925 to 1933

Gerardo Machado y Morales was a general of the Cuban War of Independence and President of Cuba from 1925 to 1933.

This article gives an overview of liberalism in Cuba. It is limited to liberal parties with substantial support, mainly proved by having had a representation in parliament. The sign ⇒ means a reference to another party in that scheme. For inclusion in this scheme it isn't necessary so that parties labeled themselves as a liberal party.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Julio Antonio Mella</span> Cuban communist (1903–1929)

Julio Antonio Mella McPartland was a Cuban political activist, journalist, communist revolutionary, and one of the founders of the original Communist Party of Cuba. Mella studied law at the University of Havana but was expelled in 1925. He had worked against the government of Gerardo Machado, which had grown increasingly repressive. Mella left the country, reaching Central America. He traveled north to Mexico City, where he worked with other exiled dissidents and communist sympathizers against the Machado government. He was assassinated in 1929, but historians still disagree on which parties were responsible for his death. The 21st century Cuban government regards Mella as a communist hero and martyr.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ramón Grau</span> Two-time president of Cuba (1881 - 1969)

Ramón Grau San Martín was a Cuban physician who served as President of Cuba from 1933 to 1934 and from 1944 to 1948. He was the last president born during Spanish rule. He is sometimes called Raymond Grau San Martin in English.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bebo Valdés</span> Cuban pianist, bandleader, composer and arranger

Dionisio Ramón Emilio Valdés Amaro, better known as Bebo Valdés, was a Cuban pianist, bandleader, composer and arranger. He was a central figure in the golden age of Cuban music, especially due to his big band arrangements and compositions of mambo, chachachá and batanga, a genre he created in 1952.

Lucía is a 1968 Cuban black-and-white drama film directed by Humberto Solás, and written by Solás, Julio García Espinosa and Nelson Rodríguez. It was the winner of the Golden Prize and the Prix FIPRESCI at the 6th Moscow International Film Festival in 1969.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Polita Grau</span>

Polita Grau was the First Lady of Cuba, a Cuban political prisoner, and the "godmother" of Operation Peter Pan, also known as Operación Pedro Pan, a program to help children leave Cuba. Operation Peter Pan involved the Roman Catholic Church and Monsignor Bryan O. Walsh from 1960 to 1962, which were involved in encouraging Cuban parents to send their children to live with U.S families to rescue them from Communism.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Black Spring (Cuba)</span> 2003 crackdown on Cuban dissidents

Black Spring was the 2003 crackdown by the Cuban Government on Cuban dissidents. The government imprisoned 75 dissidents, including 29 journalists on the basis that they were acting as agents of the United States by accepting funds from the US government and George W. Bush's administration at the time. Amnesty International described the 75 Cubans as "prisoners of conscience". The Cuban government stated at the time: "the 75 individuals arrested, tried and sentenced in March/April 2003... are demonstrably not independent thinkers, writers or human rights activists, but persons directly in the pay of the US government. [...] [T]hose who were arrested and tried were charged not with criticizing the [Cuban] government, but for receiving American government funds and collaborating with U.S. diplomats".

<i>Chico and Rita</i> 2010 Spanish film

Chico and Rita is a 2010 adult animated romantic drama film directed by Tono Errando, Fernando Trueba and Javier Mariscal. The story of Chico and Rita is set against backdrops of Havana, New York City, Las Vegas, Los Angeles and Paris in the late 1940s and early 1950s. Chico is a young piano player with big dreams. Rita is a beautiful singer with an extraordinary voice. Music and romantic desire unite them, but their journey—in the tradition of the Latin ballad, the bolero—brings heartache and torment. The film was produced by Fernando Trueba Producciones, Estudio Mariscal, and Magic Light Pictures. It received financing from CinemaNX and Isle of Man Film. It won the Goya Award for Best Animated Film at the 25th Goya Awards and was nominated for Best Animated Feature at the 84th Academy Awards.

Silvia Odio del Torro is a Cuban-American who provided testimony to the Warren Commission investigating the assassination of John F. Kennedy that Lee Harvey Oswald was one of three strangers who visited her Dallas, Texas apartment in September 1963 to solicit money for the anti-Castro counterrevolutionary group JURE.

The Directorio Revolucionario Estudiantil was a Cuban student activist group launched in opposition to Fidel Castro in 1960, based at the United States, where it soon developed links with the Central Intelligence Agency. In August 1962 it carried out an attack on a beachfront Havana hotel. As of 1963, it was the largest anti-Castro student group in Miami; it also had a chapter in New Orleans, where it had contact with Lee Harvey Oswald in mid-1963. Immediately after the November 22, 1963, assassination of John F. Kennedy, it launched a campaign asserting that Lee Harvey Oswald had been acting on behalf of the Cuban government. The group lost its CIA support in December 1966.

Clemente Vázquez Bello was President of the Cuban Senate from 1925 to 1932, throughout the administration of Gerardo Machado, the Cuban President. Vázquez belonged to the Liberal Party of Cuba and was a key figure in the Machado regime during the 1920s and early 1930s.

The Directorio Estudiantil Universitario (DEU) was founded in 1927 by University of Havana students against the backdrop of a power grab by President Gerardo Machado consisting of constitutional reforms designed to prolong his presidential term by two years, and to promote his reelection to an additional term of six years. In the period between pushing for these reforms and their adoption by the corrupt Constitutional Assembly, a strong opposition composed chiefly of university students formed against this "Machadato".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Merceditas Valdés</span> Cuban singer

Mercedes Valdés Granit, better known as Merceditas Valdés, was a Cuban singer who specialized in Afro-Cuban traditional music. Under the aegis of ethnomusicologists Fernando Ortiz and Obdulio Morales, Valdés helped popularize Afro-Cuban music throughout Latin America. In 1949, she became one of the first female Santería singers to be recorded. Her debut album was released at the start of the 1960s, when the Cuban government nationalized the record industry. She then went on hiatus before making a comeback in the 1980s with a series of albums entitled Aché, in collaboration with artists such as Frank Emilio Flynn and rumba ensemble Yoruba Andabo. She also appeared in Jane Bunnett's Spirits of Havana and continued performing until her death in 1996.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cuban Revolution of 1933</span> Coup detat in Cuba in September 1933

The Cuban Revolution of 1933, also called the Sergeants' Revolt, was a coup d'etat that occurred in Cuba in September 1933. It began as a revolt of sergeants and enlisted men in the military, who soon allied with student activists in the Directorio Estudiantil Universitario.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">ABC (Cuba)</span> Political party in Cuba

The ABC was a Cuban political organization founded in 1931 in opposition to the government of Gerardo Machado. It used a hierarchy of clandestine cells, in which each member would oversee a cell on the next level. The first cell was labeled A; the next tier B; then C, and so forth.

Events in the year 2018 in Cuba.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pantaleón Julian Valdés</span> Cuban medical doctor

Pantaleón Julian Valdés was a Cuban medical doctor, an activist of civil and political rights for black and mulatos in Cuba and a prominent voice for the Afro-Cuban intellectual elite. In 1917, Valdés became the first elected president of the “Club Atenas” a major twentieth-century Afro Cuban cultural and social center. Pantaleón Julian Valdés was a member of the Partido Independiente de Color (PIC) and he was arrested with other Independents in 1910 and 1912. Later when some prominent ex-members of the PIC were reincorporated into the political machinery, he was elected to the Havana Board of Education with the support of the Partido Liberal.

References

  1. Estrada, Alfredo José (2007). Havana: An Autobiography . New York: Palgrave Macmillan. p.  174. ISBN   978-1-4039-7509-6.
  2. 1 2 Auerbach, Janathan (2011). Dark Borders: Film Noir and American Citizenship. Duke University Press. pp. 120–1. ISBN   978-0822350064 . Retrieved January 21, 2016.
  3. 1 2 3 4 Miller, Frank. "We Were Strangers (1949)". Turner Classic Movies. Retrieved January 21, 2016.
  4. Steinhart, Daniel. (2019). Runaway Hollywood: Internationalizing Postwar Production and Location Shooting. University of California Press. p. 152-3. ISBN   978-0-52-029864-4.
  5. 1 2 Nott, Robert (2003). He Ran All the Way: The Life of John Garfield. New York: Limelight Editions. pp. 235–6. ISBN   9780879109851 . Retrieved January 21, 2016.
  6. Crowther, Bosley (April 28, 1949). "We Were Strangers (1949)". The New York Times. Retrieved January 21, 2016.
  7. Gosse, Van (1993). Where the Boys are: Cuba, Cold War America and the Making of a New Left. London: Verso. pp. 42–3. ISBN   9780860916901 . Retrieved January 21, 2016.
  8. Madsen, Axel (1978). John Huston: A Biography. Doubleday. pp. 96ff. ISBN   9781504008587 . Retrieved January 21, 2016.
  9. McMillan, Priscilla Johnson (1977). Marina and Lee: The Tormented Love and Fatal Obsession Behind Lee Harvey Oswald's Assassination of John F. Kennedy. Harpercollins. p. 474. ISBN   978-0060129538.