Westminster City Council v Duke of Westminster

Last updated

Westminster City Council v Duke of Westminster
Royal Coat of Arms of the United Kingdom (St Edward's Crown).svg
Court High Court of Justice of England and Wales, Chancery Division
Full case name Westminster City Council v Duke of Westminster and Others
Decided26 November 1990
Citation(s)[1991] 4 All ER 136
Case history
Prior action(s)Ruling of Lands Tribunal (unreported)
Appealed to Court of Appeal of England and Wales
Subsequent action(s)[1992] 24 HLR 572 CA (Civ Div) reversal in part on another ground [1]
Case opinions
Decision by Mr Justice Harman
Keywords

Westminster City Council v Duke of Westminster was a case between Westminster City Council and the 6th Duke of Westminster (and fellow family trust co-trustees) heard in November 1990. [2] The dispute concerned 532 flats in Page Street, Vincent Street and Regency Street, Pimlico, London. [3] These had been designed by architect Sir Edwin Lutyens and erected between 1928 and 1930 for the 2nd Duke and the other family trustees. [4] In 1937 the trustees leased them (for a peppercorn rent of 1 shilling) to the council on a 999-year lease containing the stipulation that they be used only as "dwellings for the working classes... and no other purpose." [5] [6]

Contents

In 1990 the Council argued that the term "working class" was now meaningless and that the stipulation should be overturned, allowing them to sell the leaseholds of the flats to anyone, against the Duke's wishes. [5] [7] [8] The Duke maintained that the properties should remain available as low-rent accommodation for those who could not afford to purchase long leaseholds. His freehold interest means the Duke can charge for extensions and structural alterations. [9] If a majority of a block becomes privately owned that majority can pay for and cease his future such rights: via collective enfranchisement. [10] The case was dubbed Westminster v Westminster by the media. [11]

Background

'Building Stable Communities' policy

Local Conservatives formed a reduced majority of 4 on Westminster City Council in the 1986 local council elections. The area split roughly into thirds by ward result: strong Labour, strong Tory and marginal-majority two- or three- councillor wards. [12] Following this and fearing her fellow members would lose control unless there was a radical change in the social composition of the borough, council leader Shirley Porter instituted a secret policy known as 'Building Stable Communities' (BSC), focusing on eight marginal wards where the Conservatives wished to gain votes at the 1990 local council elections. [12] An important part of this policy was the slow renovation and designation of much of Westminster's council housing for open market sale, rather than re-letting whenever a short term tenancy became vacant. [13] The designated housing was concentrated in those wards most likely to change hands to Labour in the elections and the policy was intended to force people on low incomes - perceived to be likely Labour supporters - out of the area by disposing of social housing. [14] [15] The council expected that this would result in more owner-occupiers, rather than renters, "a pattern of tenure which is more likely to translate into Conservative votes." [16]

Grosvenor Estate

Page Street, Pimlico. The flats designed by Lutyens featured a distinctive 'checkerboard' facade. "Checkerboard Flats", Page Street, SW1 - geograph.org.uk - 573512.jpg
Page Street, Pimlico. The flats designed by Lutyens featured a distinctive 'checkerboard' façade.

The properties, collectively known as the Grosvenor Estate, had been built in Pimlico on the instructions of the 2nd Duke of Westminster, who owned the land. [17] Demolished housing on the site had been "dilapidated", prone to flooding and the "densely populated slum" was demolished in 1928 after being condemned by the Westminster Medical Officer of Health. [4] [18] Lutyens, who has been described as "arguably the greatest architect the country has produced", was at the time working as a consultant architect for the nearby Grosvenor House and was asked by the Duke to design new housing for workers on Page Street, Vincent Street and Regency Street. [4] [19]

In 1937 the duke and his family trustees granted leases of the 532 flats to Westminster council for 999 years (retaining the freehold) containing the condition that the flats be used as "dwellings for the working classes... and no other purpose." [7] [20] [21]

As part of Porter's policy (later found illegal), the flats, being in swing wards, were selected for Designated Sales. Since 1988 this had enabled anyone working in the City of Westminster to purchase such council homes, generally leasehold, when vacant, at 30% of their true market value. A Home Ownership Centre (operated by estate agents Ellis & Co.) had been opened by the council in Victoria, London to facilitate the sales, described by BBC journalist Hosken as "the council's great machine of social engineering...that would sell thousands of council [homes] to prospective Tory voters." [22] That is, at an unusually generous discount to any local person who could afford them. The council claimed that this would enable first-time buyers and middle-income families to settle in Westminster. The new leases it granted contained a very brief recouping mechanism on resale prices thus "the council's housing stock was wide open to property speculators looking for a quick profit by buying up a council flat at a huge discount and then selling a few years later at full market value." [23] [24] Challenged at the time by Labour councillors, who were just beginning to unravel the conspiracy behind BSC, the council flatly denied that the designated sales were intended "to change the balance of the electorate in marginal wards, or indeed that purchasers were anything other than 'working class'." [25]

Hearing

Sir Gerald Grosvenor, 6th Duke of Westminster, photographed in 1988. The 6th Duke of Westminster Allan Warren.jpg
Sir Gerald Grosvenor, 6th Duke of Westminster, photographed in 1988.

The case was brought by Westminster City Council after Gerald Grosvenor, 6th Duke of Westminster, who at the time the wealthiest man in Britain, refused to withdraw the clause in the lease. As a compromise he would agree to 10% of the properties being offered for sale provided that the remainder were kept as low-rent accommodation, but this was rejected by the council. The council asked that the court set aside the stipulation on the grounds that the term "working classes" had "no meaning in contemporary society." [25] [26] Part of the council's case rested on a precedent set in Guinness Trust (London Fund) Founded 1890, Registered 1902 v Green [1955] [27] in which the Court of Appeal had "unanimously ruled that the working class in Britain had been abolished." [25] [28]

The case was heard before Mr Justice Harman at the High Court of Justice of England and Wales, Chancery Division, over 3 days in November 1990. John Colyer, QC, for the council, told the court: "As of today, the phrase 'dwellings for the working classes', whatever it meant in 1925 or 1937, has fallen out of the legislation." [6]

Judgment

Judgment was passed in the Duke's favour on 26 November 1990. [29] [30] Mr Justice Harman ruled that the clause was "as valid today as when it was made" and that there was no evidence that the term "working class" was now obsolete. [29] He also said that it was "unbecoming for the council to 'blow hot and cold' and seek now to set aside the terms under which it had accepted the second duke's generosity in 1937." Westminster City Council were, he said, under a continuing obligation to house the working class in Pimlico and could not sell the flats to anyone other than sitting tenants. [29]

On a separate issue it was held: where a contract to erect buildings on land and to grant a lease of that land are substantially one transaction (as by the 2nd Duke), the expenditure of money on the buildings would not be past consideration (therefore doubtful) for the execution of the lease, even though the lease was not executed until on or after completion of the buildings. [1]

Reactions

During the hearings the Sunday Correspondent newspaper offered a prize of a crate of brown ale for the best definition of 'working class'. The winning entry was: "Wearing overalls on weekdays, painting somebody else's house to earn money? You're working class. Wearing overalls at weekends, painting your own house to save money? You're middle class." [21]

Dennis Skinner for Bolsover (Lab), said: "There is still a working class. It's exploited every day by people with fancy names such as entrepreneur." [5] His neighbouring MP Joe Ashton for Bassetlaw (Lab), said: "The Lady Porters will always need the working classes to clean up after them. It shows that nobs [slang: nobility] like the Duke know more about how the world ticks than the heiress to a Tesco fortune." [5] Charles Irving for Cheltenham (Con), disagreed with: "We are all working class... Even the rich have to work." [5]

Ex-barrister John Mortimer, playwright and screenwriter of Rumpole of the Bailey quipped that Margaret Thatcher "had already abolished the working class and that these days, people [are] either 'middle-class or sleeping in a cardboard box.'" [21]

The ex-Council leader said: "In a week when the son of a trapeze artist [John Major] has been battling to become [Conservative] Prime Minister... the courts have ruled that we must remain wedded to an outdated class system." [31] Peter Bradley, then the deputy Leader of the Labour Group at Westminster Council, responded:

[Porter] says that the council's housing policies are intended "to enable less well-off families to become better off." She makes no mention of those Westminster people who are forced to raise their families in inadequate housing or, worse still, have become homeless as a direct consequence of her politically motivated depletion of the council's housing stock." [32]

In May 1996, after long investigations, the District Auditor concluded that the 'Building Stable Communities' policy had been illegal. [12]

See also

Regarding the secret, politicised underlying housing policy of the City: Porter v Magill [2002] 2 AC 357

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mayfair</span> Area of central London, England

Mayfair is an area in London, England and is located in the City of Westminster. It is in Central London and part of the West End. It is between Oxford Street, Regent Street, Piccadilly and Park Lane and one of the most expensive districts in the world.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pimlico</span> Human settlement in England

Pimlico is an area of Central London in the City of Westminster, built as a southern extension to neighbouring Belgravia. It is known for its garden squares and distinctive Regency architecture. Pimlico is demarcated to the north by Victoria Station, by the River Thames to the south, Vauxhall Bridge Road to the east and the former Grosvenor Canal to the west. At its heart is a grid of residential streets laid down by the planner Thomas Cubitt, beginning in 1825 and now protected as the Pimlico Conservation Area. The most prestigious are those on garden squares, with buildings decreasing in grandeur away from St George's Square, Warwick Square, Eccleston Square and the main thoroughfares of Belgrave Road and St. George's Drive. Additions have included the pre–World War II Dolphin Square and the Churchill Gardens and Lillington and Longmoore Gardens estates, now conservation areas in their own right. The area has over 350 Grade II listed buildings and several Grade II* listed churches. At the western edge of Pimlico, on the borders of Chelsea, Pimlico Road has become known in recent years for its interiors and design stores.

Millbank is an area of central London in the City of Westminster. Millbank is located by the River Thames, east of Pimlico and south of Westminster. Millbank is known as the location of major government offices, Burberry headquarters, the Millbank Tower and prominent art institutions such as Tate Britain and the Chelsea College of Art and Design.

Dame Shirley, Lady Porter DBE, is a British politician who led Westminster City Council in London from 1983 to 1991, representing the Conservative Party. She is the daughter and heiress of Sir Jack Cohen, the founder of Tesco supermarkets. She was appointed Dame Commander of the Order of the British Empire in 1991 by John Major after delivering victory in Westminster for the Conservatives in the 1990 local elections. While leader of Westminster City Council, Porter oversaw the "Building Stable Communities" policy — later described as the "homes for votes scandal" — and was consequently accused of gerrymandering. The policy was judged illegal by the district auditor, and a surcharge of £27m levied on her in 1996. This was later raised to £42 million with interest and costs. She eventually settled in 2004, paying a final settlement of £12.3 million.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dolphin Square</span> Block of private apartments and business complex in Pimlico, London

Dolphin Square is an estate of private flats with some ground floor business units near the River Thames in Pimlico, Westminster, London built between 1935 and 1937. Until the building of Highbury Square, it was the most developed garden square in London built as private housing. At one time, it was home to more than 70 MPs and at least 10 Lords.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Westminster City Council</span> Local authority for the City of Westminster in Greater London, England

Westminster City Council is the local authority for the City of Westminster in Greater London, England. It is a London borough council, one of 32 in London. The council has been under Labour majority control since 2022. Full council meetings are generally held at Westminster Council House, also known as Marylebone Town Hall, and the council has its main offices at Westminster City Hall on Victoria Street.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Grosvenor Group</span> British property corporation

Grosvenor Group Limited is an internationally diversified property group, which traces its origins to 1677 and has its headquarters in London, England. It has a global reach, now in 62 international cities, with offices in 14 of them, operated on behalf of its owners, the Duke of Westminster and his family. It has four regional development and investment businesses and a portfolio of indirect investments. Its sectors include residential, office, retail, industrial, along with hotels.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cities of London and Westminster (UK Parliament constituency)</span> UK Parliament constituency in England, created 1950

Cities of London and Westminster is a constituency returning a single Member of Parliament (MP) to the House of Commons in the United Kingdom Parliament. It is a borough constituency for the purposes of election expenses and type of returning officer. As with all constituencies, the election is decided using the first past the post system of election. Since its creation at the 1950 general election, the constituency has always elected the candidate nominated by the Conservative Party.

Barry Charles Legg is a British politician. A former Conservative Member of Parliament (MP) for Milton Keynes South West from 1992 until the 1997 general election, he was defeated by Labour's Phyllis Starkey. Legg is the chairman of the Eurosceptic Bruges Group.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Grosvenor Canal</span> Former canal in the Pimlico area of London

Grosvenor Canal was a canal in the Pimlico area of London, opened in 1824. It was progressively shortened, as first the railways to Victoria Station and then the Ebury Bridge housing estate were built over it. It remained in use until 1995, enabling barges to be loaded with refuse for removal from the city, making it the last canal in London to operate commercially. A small part of it remains within the Grosvenor Waterside development.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Victoria Square, London</span>

Victoria Square is a small, rectangular garden square in Westminster, Greater London, beginning some 50 metres south of the remaining stables of the Royal Mews and 150 metres north of Victoria bus station, which stands in front of Victoria Station. It has a statue of the young Queen Victoria.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Brown Hart Gardens</span>

Brown Hart Gardens, located off Duke Street, Mayfair, is a 10,000 square feet (929 m2) public garden on top of an electricity substation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ken Livingstone</span> English politician and former Mayor of London (born 1945)

Kenneth Robert Livingstone is an English retired politician who served as the Leader of the Greater London Council (GLC) from 1981 until the council was abolished in 1986, and as Mayor of London from the creation of the office in 2000 until 2008. He also served as the Member of Parliament (MP) for Brent East from 1987 to 2001. A former member of the Labour Party, he was on the party's hard left, ideologically identifying as a socialist.

The homes for votes scandal was a gerrymandering controversy involving the Conservative-led Westminster City Council in London. Having narrowly maintained their control of the council in the 1986 local elections, Conservative councillors initiated a programme of selling off council homes in eight marginal wards, in the belief that owner-occupiers were more likely to vote Conservative than council tenants. Hostels in the marginal wards were closed, with some homeless people moved into condemned accommodation. The policy came to an end after it was exposed on the BBC current affairs programme Panorama in 1989. On investigation, the policy was ruled to be illegal. Former leader of the Council Dame Shirley Porter was found guilty of wilful misconduct and ordered to repay £36.1m. She eventually settled with the council for a sum of £12.3 million.

In London, the Metropolitan Association for Improving the Dwellings of the Industrious Classes (MAIDIC) was a Victorian-era, philanthropically-motivated model dwellings company. The association, established in 1841, was fore-runner of the modern housing association which sought to provide affordable housing for the working classes on a privately run basis, with a financial return for investors. Although not the first society to build such homes, the Association was the first to be founded expressly for this purpose. As such it was one of the earliest adopters of the principal of the five per cent philanthropy model, outlined in the Company's resolution: "that an association be formed for the purpose of providing the labouring man with an increase of the comforts and conveniences of life, with full return to the capitalist."

The Westminster cemeteries scandal was a British political scandal which began in January 1987 when Westminster City Council (WCC) sold three cemeteries, three lodges, one flat, a crematorium and over 12 acres (4.9 ha) of prime development land in London for a total of 85 pence. The three cemeteries – Hanwell Cemetery, East Finchley Cemetery and Mill Hill Cemetery – were sold for 5 pence each. Shortly before the sale was finalised, one building had been withdrawn from the lot – because the council had failed to secure the eviction of a cemetery keeper – so WCC also paid the purchaser £70,000 compensation.

<i>James v United Kingdom</i>

James v United Kingdom [1986] is an English land law case, concerning tenants' (lessees') statutory right to enfranchise a home from their freeholder and whether specifically that right, leasehold enfranchisement, infringes the freeholder's human rights in property without being in a valid public interest.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Eia</span> Former Medieval manor in Middlesex, England

Eia or Eye was an early Medieval manor in Westminster, Middlesex and is now a part of Central London. It was about one mile west of the Palace of Westminster/Whitehall, about 2 miles west-south-west of the walled City of London, and about half a mile north of the River Thames.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Page Street</span>

Page Street is a street in Pimlico, in the City of Westminster, that runs from Regency Street in the west to the junction of John Islip Street and Dean Ryle Street in the east, parallel with Horseferry Road. It is crossed midway by Marsham Street.

Neale Coleman is a British Labour politician. He is a former senior adviser to Jeremy Corbyn as Leader of the Labour Party, and was a close aide to Ken Livingstone as Mayor of London.

References

  1. 1 2 Chitty on Contracts, 31st edition volumes 1 & 2 at page 313
  2. ↑ "Class revival". The Daily Telegraph . London. 15 April 2002. p. 19.
  3. ↑ Barker, Dennis (27 November 1990). "Fast-moving Duke of charitable bent". The Guardian . Manchester. p. 8.
  4. 1 2 3 Sherwood, Roger (2002). "Page Street". Housing Prototypes. Retrieved 5 November 2013.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 "We are all workers now". The Times . London. 8 October 1990. p. 14.
  6. 1 2 Young, Robin (22 November 1990). "Is 'working class' the passport to Pimlico?". The Times . London. p. 4.
  7. 1 2 "Dukes and Dustmen". The Times . London. 22 November 1990. p. 13.
  8. ↑ Lewthwaite, Gilbert A. (30 October 1990). "British upper crust debates meaning of 'working class'". The Baltimore Sun . Baltimore. p. 3.
  9. ↑ Landlord and Tenant Act 1927
  10. ↑ "Duke's case". The Times . London. 24 November 1990. p. 6.
  11. ↑ Hosken, Andrew (2006). Nothing Like a Dame. London: Granta Books. ISBN   9781862078093. p.286
  12. 1 2 3 "Q&A: Dame Shirley's downfall". BBC News . 24 April 2004. Retrieved 5 November 2013.
  13. ↑ Waugh, Paul (9 July 2009). "'Plot to rid council estates of poor': Dame Shirley's Downfall". London Evening Standard . London.
  14. ↑ "'Homes for votes' inquiry halted". BBC News . 3 February 2004. Retrieved 5 November 2013.
  15. ↑ "Porter pays £12m to Westminster". BBC News . 5 July 2004. Retrieved 5 November 2013.
  16. ↑ Cohen, Nick (16 January 1994). "Dumping the poor". The Independent . London. Retrieved 5 November 2013.
  17. ↑ "MadNaija | Latest Naija Music & Foreign Songs 2020". MadNaija. 12 July 2022. Retrieved 19 July 2022.
  18. ↑ "WESTMINSTER HAS HOUSING SCHEME FOR 2500 PERSONS". The Christian Science Monitor . Boston. 11 January 1929. p. 1.
  19. ↑ Jones, Nigel R. (2005). Architecture of England, Scotland, and Wales. Westport: Greenwood Press. p. 176. ISBN   9780313318504.
  20. ↑ Hosken 2006, p. 286.
  21. 1 2 3 Rule, Sheila (31 October 1990). "Now It's Noblesse Oblige vs. the Trickle-Downers". The New York Times . New York.
  22. ↑ Hosken 2006, p. 179.
  23. ↑ Hosken 2006, p. 180.
  24. ↑ Billen, Andrew (12 January 1988). "Tenants, come on down". The Times . London. p. 8.
  25. 1 2 3 Young, Robin (20 November 1990). "Council and duke in battle over a matter of class". The Times . London. p. 6.
  26. ↑ "Lease hearing". The Times . London. 21 November 1990. p. 6.
  27. ↑ [1955] 1 WLR 872
  28. ↑ Slapper, Gary (2011). How the Law Works (2nd ed.). Abingdon: Routledge. p. 174. ISBN   9780415600101.
  29. 1 2 3 Young, Robin (27 November 1990). "Working class alive and well in Pimlico". The Times . London. p. 1.
  30. ↑ "The Working Class Lives on Says Judge". The Guardian . Manchester. 27 November 1990. p. 8.
  31. ↑ Hosken 2006, p. 287.
  32. ↑ Bradley, Peter (1 December 1990). "Pimlico passport". The Times . London. p. 17.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.