6.0 system

Last updated

The 6.0 system of judging figure skating was developed during the early days of the sport, when early international competitions consisted of only compulsory figures. Skaters performed each figure three times on each foot, for a total of six, which as writer Ellyn Kestnbaum states, "gave rise to the system of awarding marks based on a standard of 6.0 as perfection". [1] It was used in competitive figure skating until 2004, when it was replaced by the ISU Judging System in international competitions, as a result of the 2002 Winter Olympics figure skating scandal. British ice dancers Jayne Torvill and Christopher Dean earned the most overall 6.0s in ice dance, Midori Ito from Japan has the most 6.0s in single skating, and Irina Rodnina from Russia, with two different partners, has the most 6.0s in pair skating.

Contents

The 6.0 system was a placement judging system. Judges awarded two marks in both the short program and free skate: one for technical merit and one for presentation, and each mark expressed as a number on a scale from 0 to 6.0. They were assessed in required elements for technical merit in the short program and could perform whatever elements they chose during the free skate, which represented the difficulty of a "well-balanced program". [2] The presentation mark did not include what reporter Sandra Loosemore called "artistry". [3] It also did not include the judges' opinions or a measure of how much they liked a skater's performance, music, costume, or hairstyle. Criticism of the 6.0 system included that it did not provide statistics and points of comparison between skaters' performances and lent itself to judging discrepancies, inconsistencies, and dishonesty. Skating order during competitions, due to the ranking nature of the system, also impacted marks.

History

Torvill and Dean, pictured in 2011. This pair received more perfect 6.0 scores than any other. Jayne Torvill and Christopher Dean - Dancing on Ice 2011.jpg
Torvill and Dean, pictured in 2011. This pair received more perfect 6.0 scores than any other.

The 6.0 system of judging figure skating was developed during the early days of the sport, when skaters would trace figures in the ice. The earliest competitions consisted of only compulsory figures; skaters performed each figure three times on each foot, for a total of six, which as writer Ellyn Kestnbaum states, "gave rise to the system of awarding marks based on a standard of 6.0 as perfection". [1]

British ice dancers Jayne Torvill and Christopher Dean, who earned the most overall 6.0s with 56, earned 19 perfect 6.0s at the 1984 Olympic Winter Games and 29 at the 1984 World Championships. Midori Ito from Japan has the most 6.0s in single skating, with 10. Irina Rodnina from Russia has earned nine 6.0s with two different partners, the most in pair skating. [4] [5]

Hines calls the 6.0 system "age-old" and "unique to figure skating and deeply entrenched". [6] He says that it was a tradition understood and appreciated by skaters, judges, officials, and fans [6] and that fans found it easy to relate to the 6.0 system, which "represented skating perfection and served as every skater's goal". [7]

Description

The 6.0 system was a placement judging system: scores were issued based on how each skater compared to others in the same competition, not on any absolute scale. [8] [9] Judges awarded two marks in both the short program and free skate: one for technical merit, which was an evaluation of the quality of the required elements skated, and one for presentation, which was an evaluation of the program as a whole (composition, utilization of the ice, style, music expression, and originality). [9] [10] The ISU required that each judge, "guided by general criteria in the ISU Special Regulations", [11] award a skater two marks, each expressed as a number on a scale from 0 to 6.0. The ISU calls this system "relative judging" [11] and CBC Sports calls the scores "relative rankings", [10] meaning that the judges had to compare the quality of each skater's performances with the quality of the performance of their competitors. According to the ISU, the marks of the 6.0 system did not express any value, but served the purpose of placing a skater into a "specific ranking position". [11]

An example scoreboard using the 6.0 system 6.0 system in figure skating.png
An example scoreboard using the 6.0 system
Marks scale of the 6.0 system [9]
0not skated
1very poor
2poor
3mediocre
4good
5very good
6outstanding

Technical merit marks in the short program were awarded to skaters when they executed a specified number of required moves (spins, jumps, and step sequences, and in pair skating, lifts and a death spiral). Scores were awarded for required elements and presentation by assigning a base mark determined by the quality and difficulty of the elements, and then applying specific deductions for errors. [2] [11] The ISU's criteria in the assessment of the required elements in the short program included the following: the length, technique, and "the clean starting and landing" [12] of all required jumps; the perfect completion of jump combinations in relation to their difficulty; well-controlled and strong spins; [note 1] the difficulty, swing, carriage, and smooth flow of step and spiral sequences; and the difficulty of the connecting steps and/or movements; and speed. [12] The criteria for presentation marks included: "harmonious composition of the program as a whole" [12] and how well it conformed with the music; variety of speed; the utilization of the ice surface; sureness in time to the music and easy movement; expression of the music's character; carriage and style; and originality. [11] [12] Pair teams were evaluated for their unison in their presentation marks. The criteria for technical merit marks in the free skate included the following: the difficulty of the skaters' performance; cleanness and sureness; variety; and speed. [13]

Skaters could perform whatever elements they chose during the free skating program, which represented the difficulty of the program, and within guidelines for what made up a "well-balanced program". [2] Presentation marks in the free skate represented how well it was performed and encompassed several criteria. [2] [3] The presentation mark did not include what reporter Sandra Loosemore called "artistry". [3] It also did not include the judges' opinions or a measure of how much they liked a skater's performance, music, costume, or hairstyle. According to Loosemore, the presentation mark in the free skate included the following: "harmonious composition" [3] of the skater's program and conformity with their program's music; the expression of the music's character; variation of speed; "utilization of the ice surface"; [3] ease of movement in time to the music; carriage and style; originality; and for pair skaters, unison. Harmonious composition of the program and conformity with the chosen music, which measured the skill of the choreographer as much as the skater, was a consideration of how the steps and movements fit with the style of the music. Skaters had to demonstrate their ability to skate both slow and fast sections and cover the entirety of the ice surface, and not, for example, skate in the middle of the rink directly in front of the judges. Ease of movement in time to the music had to do with the skater's technical ability to perform the movements in a program. Carriage and style also had to do with the technical qualities of the skater's basic technique, such as good posture (a straight back and upright carriage) and smooth skating. [3]

Criticism

The ISU, when switching from the 6.0 system to the IJS in 2003, described what it considered the weaknesses of the 6.0 system. According to the ISU, the 6.0 system did not include statistics for each program component and did not provide feedback and detailed information that allowed skaters, coaches, and judges to compare the quality of competitors' skating. The system did not encourage consistency among judges, since it was difficult for them to remember the performances of all skaters in a competition in order to rank them appropriately. Although the system ranked skaters sequentially, it did not measure exact differences between skaters' performances. [14] Judges were unable to mark the quality of each element of a skater's program, which reduced the scope of analysis of the marks judges awarded and encouraged dishonest judging because judges were not required to explain the reasons for their marks. As the ISU says, "Unless there is overt, demonstrable evidence of misconduct, the judge will continue to officiate at events". [15]

Skating order impacted marks; judges, for example, tended to give lower marks to skaters who performed earlier in the competition, even if they skated better than competitors who performed later on, in order to "leave room" [16] in their markings. Skaters were ranked in comparison to each other, not on their individual performances, based on the assumption, which was "questioned by many observers, and the public", [16] that skaters placed in the final groups during the free skating program were more skilled and would earn higher marks because they earned higher marks in their short programs. The 6.0 system provided few statistics of the best scores of individual skating performances and elements, and of world records. [16]

Replacement

Elena Berezhnaya and Anton Sikharulidze, 2001 Berezhnaya and Sikharulidze 2001 GPF.jpg
Elena Berezhnaya and Anton Sikharulidze, 2001
Jamie Sale and David Pelletier, 2002 Sale pelletier love story.jpg
Jamie Salé and David Pelletier, 2002

The 6.0 system was used in international figure skating competitions until 2004, when it was replaced by the ISU Judging System (IJS). This was in response to two scandals that occurred in 2002.

The first scandal arose during the pair skating competition at the 2002 Winter Olympics in Salt Lake City, Utah. After the free skating program, French judge Marie-Reine Le Gougne was overheard saying that she had been "pressured" [17] by the French federation to favor the Russian team, Elena Berezhnaya and Anton Skiharulidze, over the Canadian team, Jamie Salé and David Pelletier. Le Gougne later denied that any pressure had been applied. Media coverage and a protest filed by the Canadian federation led to the organisers declaring a tie; the Canadians and Russians were both awarded gold medals, the first time that duplicate medals were awarded in figure skating. [18] [19]

Less than a month later, at the 2002 World Championships, another judging scandal occurred, surrounding the ice dance competition. The Lithuanian federation protested against the results, and although the protests were denied, figure skating historian James R. Hines states that it "demonstrated again problems stemming from subjective judging", especially in ice dance, and "underscored the need for reevaluation of figure skating's judging system". [6]

The International Skating Union (ISU) president Ottavio Cinquanta promoted a replacement system, the IJS. After two years of testing, IJS was adopted at the ISU Congress in 2004. [6] [8] The last time the 6.0 system was used in the U.S. was at Nationals in 2005, which Lynn Zinser of The New York Times called "an ode to the 6.0" [20] because the judges awarded the competitors so many scores of 6.0.

Notes

  1. The number of rotations in the required position, the speed of rotation, and centering were all criteria taken into consideration in the assessment of spins. For flying spins, the height of the jump and the skater's position in the air and landing were also taken into consideration. [12]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Figure skating</span> Ice sport performed on figure skates

Figure skating is a sport in which individuals, pairs, or groups perform on figure skates on ice. It was the first winter sport to be included in the Olympic Games, when it was contested at the 1908 Olympics in London. The Olympic disciplines are men's singles, women's singles, pair skating, and ice dance; the four individual disciplines are also combined into a team event, which was first included in the Winter Olympics in 2014. The non-Olympic disciplines include synchronized skating, Theater on Ice, and four skating. From intermediate through senior-level competition, skaters generally perform two programs, which, depending on the discipline, may include spins, jumps, moves in the field, lifts, throw jumps, death spirals, and other elements or moves.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ice dance</span> Discipline of figure skating that draws from ballroom dancing

Ice dance is a discipline of figure skating that historically draws from ballroom dancing. It joined the World Figure Skating Championships in 1952, and became a Winter Olympic Games medal sport in 1976. According to the International Skating Union (ISU), the governing body of figure skating, an ice dance team consists of one woman and one man.

Figure skating jumps are an element of three competitive figure skating disciplines: men's singles, women's singles, and pair skating – but not ice dancing. Jumping in figure skating is "relatively recent". They were originally individual compulsory figures, and sometimes special figures; many jumps were named after the skaters who invented them or from the figures from which they were developed. It was not until the early part of the 20th century, well after the establishment of organized skating competitions, when jumps with the potential of being completed with multiple revolutions were invented and when jumps were formally categorized. In the 1920s Austrian skaters began to perform the first double jumps in practice. Skaters experimented with jumps, and by the end of the period, the modern repertoire of jumps had been developed. Jumps did not have a major role in free skating programs during international competitions until the 1930s. During the post-war period and into the 1950s and early 1960s, triple jumps became more common for both male and female skaters, and a full repertoire of two-revolution jumps had been fully developed. In the 1980s men were expected to complete four or five difficult triple jumps, and women had to perform the easier triples. By the 1990s, after compulsory figures were removed from competitions, multi-revolution jumps became more important in figure skating.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Figure skating spins</span> Element in competitve figure skating

Spins are an element in figure skating in which the skater rotates, centered on a single point on the ice, while holding one or more body positions. They are performed by all disciplines of the sport, single skating, pair skating, and ice dance, and are a required element in most figure skating competitions. As The New York Times says, "While jumps look like sport, spins look more like art. While jumps provide the suspense, spins provide the scenery, but there is so much more to the scenery than most viewers have time or means to grasp". According to world champion and figure skating commentator Scott Hamilton, spins are often used "as breathing points or transitions to bigger things"

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Michelle Kwan</span> American figure skater (born 1980)

Michelle Wingshan Kwan is a retired competitive figure skater and diplomat serving as United States Ambassador to Belize. In figure skating Kwan is a two-time Olympic medalist, a five-time World champion and a nine-time U.S. champion. She is tied with Maribel Vinson for the all-time National Championship record.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tara Lipinski</span> American figure skater, television commentator, and actress

Tara Kristen Lipinski is an American former competitive figure skater, actress, sports commentator, and documentary film producer. A former competitor in women's singles, she is the 1998 Olympic champion, the 1997 World champion, a two-time Champions Series Final champion (1997–1998) and the 1997 U.S. national champion. Until 2019, she was the youngest single skater to win a U.S. Nationals and the youngest to become an Olympic and World champion in figure skating history. She is the first woman to complete a triple loop-triple loop combination, her signature jump element, in competition. Starting in 1997, Lipinski had a rivalry with fellow skater Michelle Kwan, which was played up by the American press, and culminated when Lipinski won the gold medal at the 1998 Olympics.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">World Figure Skating Championships</span> Recurring tournament

The World Figure Skating Championships ("Worlds") is an annual figure skating competition sanctioned by the International Skating Union. Medals are awarded in the categories of men's singles, women's singles, pair skating, and ice dance. Generally held in March, the World Championships are considered the most prestigious of the ISU Figure Skating Championships. With the exception of the Olympic title, a world title is considered to be the highest competitive achievement in figure skating.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Synchronized skating</span> Ice skating discipline

Synchronized skating, often called synchro, is an ice skating sport where between 5 and 20 skaters perform together as a team. They move as a flowing unit at high speed over the ice, while performing elements and footwork.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Compulsory figures</span> Element in a figure skating competition

Compulsory figures or school figures were formerly a segment of figure skating, and gave the sport its name. They are the "circular patterns which skaters trace on the ice to demonstrate skill in placing clean turns evenly on round circles". For approximately the first 50 years of figure skating as a sport, until 1947, compulsory figures made up 60 percent of the total score at most competitions around the world. These figures continued to dominate the sport, although they steadily declined in importance, until the International Skating Union (ISU) voted to discontinue them as a part of competitions in 1990. Learning and training in compulsory figures instilled discipline and control; some in the figure skating community considered them necessary to teach skaters basic skills. Skaters would train for hours to learn and execute them well, and competing and judging figures would often take up to eight hours during competitions.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Figure skating at the Olympic Games</span>

Figure skating was first contested in the Olympic Games at the 1908 Summer Olympics. Since 1924, the sport has been a part of the Winter Olympic Games.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pair skating</span> Discipline of figure skating

Pair skating is a figure skating discipline defined by the International Skating Union (ISU) as "the skating of two persons in unison who perform their movements in such harmony with each other as to give the impression of genuine Pair Skating as compared with independent Single Skating". The ISU also states that a pairs team consists of "one Woman and one Man". Pair skating, along with men's and women's single skating, has been an Olympic discipline since figure skating, the oldest Winter Olympic sport, was introduced at the 1908 Summer Olympics in London. The ISU World Figure Skating Championships introduced pair skating in 1908.

The ISU Judging System (or the International Judging System (IJS)), occasionally referred to as the Code of Points (COP) system, is the scoring system that has been used since 2004 to judge the figure skating disciplines of men's and ladies' singles, pair skating, ice dance, and synchronized skating. It was designed and implemented by the International Skating Union (ISU), the ruling body of the sport.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of figure skating</span>

The history of figure skating stretches back to prehistoric times. Primitive ice skates appear in the archaeological record from about 3000 BC. Edges were added by the Dutch in the 13th and 14th century. International figure skating competitions began appearing in the late 19th century; in 1891, the European Championships were inaugurated in Hamburg, Germany, and in 1896, the first World Championship were held in Saint Petersburg, Russian Empire. At the 1908 Summer Olympics in London, England, figure skating became the first winter sport to be included in the Olympics.

The following is a glossary of figure skating terms, sorted alphabetically.

A figure skating competition is a judged sports competition in figure skating.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Single skating</span> Discipline of figure skating

Single skating is a discipline of figure skating in which male and female skaters compete individually. Men's singles and women's singles are governed by the International Skating Union (ISU). Figure skating is the oldest winter sport contested at the Olympics, with men's and women's single skating appearing as two of the four figure skating events at the London Games in 1908.

The short program of figure skating is the first of two segments of competitions, skated before the free skating program. It lasts, for both senior and junior singles and pair skaters, 2 minutes and 40 seconds. In synchronized skating, for both juniors and seniors, the short program lasts 2 minutes and 50 seconds. Vocal music with lyrics is allowed for all disciplines since the 2014-2015 season. The short program for single skaters and for pair skaters consists of seven required elements, and there are six required elements for synchronized skaters.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Original dance</span> Segment in a ice dancing competition

The original dance (OD) was one of the programs performed by figure skaters in ice dance competitions, in which the ice dancers skated "a dance of their own creation to dance music they have selected for the designated rhythm(s)". It was normally the second of three programs in the competition, sandwiched between the compulsory dance (CD) and the free dance (FD). The rhythm(s) and type of music required for the OD changed every season, and were selected by the International Skating Union (ISU) before the start of the season. The ice dancers were free to choose their own music and choreography and to create their own routines. They were judged on a set of required criteria, including skating skills and how well they interpreted the music and the rhythm.

The Axel jump or Axel Paulsen jump, named after its inventor, Norwegian figure skater Axel Paulsen, is an edge jump performed in figure skating. It is the sport's oldest and most difficult jump, and the only basic jump in competition with a forward take-off, which makes it the easiest to identify. A double or triple Axel is required in both the short program and the free skating segment for junior and senior single skaters in all events sanctioned by the International Skating Union (ISU).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Compulsory dance</span> Segment in an ice dancing competition

The compulsory dance (CD), now called the pattern dance, is a part of the figure skating segment of ice dance competitions in which all the competing couples perform the same standardized steps and holds to the music of a specified tempo and genre. One or more compulsory dances were usually skated as the first phase of ice dancing competitions. The 2009–10 season was the final season in which the segment was included in International Skating Union (ISU) junior and senior level competition. In June 2010, the ISU replaced the name "compulsory dance" with "pattern dance" for ice dance, and merged it into the short dance (SD) beginning in the 2010–11 figure skating season.

References

  1. 1 2 Kestnbaum, p. 82
  2. 1 2 3 4 Kestnbaum, p. 12
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Loosemore, Sandra (2 December 1998). "It's the Presentation, Stupid". CBS SportsLine. Archived from the original on 29 April 1999. Retrieved 1 July 2022.
  4. Hines (2011), p. xxvii
  5. Hines (2006), p. 430
  6. 1 2 3 4 Hines (2011), p. 14
  7. Hines (2011), p. 17
  8. 1 2 Hines (2011), p. xxxv
  9. 1 2 3 "Scoring System". U.S. Figure Skating. Archived from the original on 26 January 2020. Retrieved 1 July 2022.
  10. 1 2 "Numbers About up for Skating's Old Judging System". CBC Sports. 22 March 2004. Archived from the original on 21 July 2021. Retrieved 26 July 2021.
  11. 1 2 3 4 5 ISU FAQ, p. 1
  12. 1 2 3 4 5 Kestnbaum, p. 298
  13. Kestnbaum, p. 299
  14. ISU FAQ, pp. 2–3
  15. ISU FAQ, p. 5
  16. 1 2 3 ISU FAQ, p. 6
  17. Hines (2011), p. 13
  18. Hines (2011), pp. xxxiv–xxxv
  19. Hines (2011), p. 12–14
  20. Zinser, Lynn (17 January 2005). "Final Nod to 6.0 Before Scoring System Is Deep-Sixed". The New York Times. Retrieved 26 July 2021.

Works cited