Age of criminal responsibility in Australia

Last updated

The age of criminal responsibility in Australia is the age below which a child is deemed incapable of having committed a criminal offence. In legal terms, it is referred to as a defence of infancy. All states and self-governing territories of Australia have adopted 10 years of age as a uniform age of criminal responsibility, except the NT. As of October 2022, some jurisdictions have made moves towards raising the age to 12 or 14.

Contents

Concerns have been raised about the effects of criminalisation of such young children, and in particular the effects on Aboriginal Australians and Torres Strait Islander people, who are disproportionately represented in the statistics, often reflecting as well as increasing a cycle of disadvantage. In 2019, the Council of Attorneys-General Age of Criminal Responsibility Working Group was tasked with considering submissions from a range of organisations and experts of various backgrounds regarding raising the age to 14. In mid 2020, they indicated that more work was needed to be done on alternative forms of punishment before they could make their recommendations, and in late 2021, the Council of Attorneys-General failed to reach a national consensus.

Background

Doli incapax refers to a presumption that a child is "incapable of crime" under legislation or common law, or rather, the presumption that a child cannot form mens rea as they do not yet have a sufficient understanding of the difference between "right" and "wrong". In the context of Australian law, doli incapax acts as a rebuttable presumption for children aged at least 10 but less than 14. [1]

To rebut this presumption, the prosecution must prove beyond reasonable doubt that the child knew that the act was seriously wrong (not by standards of law, but morally or according to the ordinary principles of reasonable persons) as distinct from an act of "mere naughtiness or childish mischief". [2]

Statistics

According to a 2018 SBS article, around 600 children under 14 are locked up in Australian prisons each year. [3]

On an average night in June 2019, there were 949 young people imprisoned in Australia. Of these: [4]

In the year ending 30 June 2020, there were almost 600 children aged 10 to 13 in detention in Australia. [4]

From June 2015 to 2019, the Northern Territory had the highest rate of young people in detention on an average night. [4]

Although over represented in the incarcerated population, the vast majority of Indigenous youth are law abiding and suffer additionally when indigenous organisations focus on support of the criminal minority.

Calls to raise minimum age

In 2018, legal and medical experts called for the age to be raised to 16. In response, the state and commonwealth Attorneys General decided to investigate the matter, [3] and the Council of Attorneys-General Age of Criminal Responsibility Working Group was established to do this. [5] [6]

According to Australian Medical Association President Dr Tony Bartone, raising the minimum age of criminal responsibility will prevent the unnecessary criminalisation of vulnerable children. In an Australian Medical Association media release, Dr Bartone said: [7]

Australia has one of the lowest ages of criminal responsibility in the world.

The criminalisation of children in Australia is a nationwide problem that disproportionately impacts Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children.

Most children in prison come from backgrounds that are disadvantaged. These children often experience violence, abuse, disability, homelessness, and drug or alcohol misuse.

Criminalising the behaviour of young and vulnerable children creates a vicious cycle of disadvantage and forces children to become entrenched in the criminal justice system.

Children who are forced into contact with the criminal justice system at a young age are also less likely to complete their education or find employment, and are more likely to die an early death.

In November 2019, then Attorney-General of Australia, Christian Porter, was of the opinion that the current system was working well. [8]

In the year ending on 30 June 2020, there were almost 600 children aged 10 to 13 in detention in Australia. [4] Criminologist Chris Cuneen cites a number of well-founded reasons for increasing the minimum age of criminal responsibility in Australia to 14, echoing Dr Bartone's list above. [9] Doctors, lawyers, and a range of experts have called for the minimum age to be raised to 14. [10]

The Australian Human Rights Commission submitted its report, Review of the age of criminal responsibility, to the Working Group on 26 February 2020. [5] The Law Council of Australia submitted its report on 2 March 2020. [6] However in July 2020 the Working Group said that more work needed to be done to determine alternative ways to deal with young offenders, and that the age would remain as it is for at least another year. Both the Attorney General of New South Wales, Mark Speakman, and the Attorney General of South Australia, Vickie Chapman, expressed would not consider passing state laws until the Working Group had finished its review. [11] [12]

By late 2021, the Council of Attorneys-General had failed to reach a national consensus on the issue. [13]

As of 2022, the debate continues. Criminologist Terry Goldsworthy points out that the sentencing issue is separate from the age of criminal responsibility, and that the number of children held in custody is "exceedingly small", with custodial sentences having declined significantly since 2010. He also argues that the victims of crime (citing the James Bulger case in the UK) need to be taken into consideration. [14] Those concerned with the health and welfare of the children concerned say that incarcerating them can cause "irreparable harm", especially "those with complex neurodevelopmental and mental health needs, trauma, substance misuse, and social disadvantage, [who] are overly represented in the youth justice system. [15]

There is little evidence that Australians are concerned with the issue, certainly in comparison to the frustration with the Judiciary failing to impose punishments that serve as effective deterrents to delinquency.

Effects on Indigenous children

There has been much commentary on the effect that incarceration of children has on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people's lives, with Indigenous children disproportionately represented in the figures (more than 60% of 10–13-year-olds). The Law Council, the Royal Australasian College of Physicians and others have said that there needs to be more emphasis on "support services, treatment, early intervention, prevention, justice reinvestment initiatives, and community-led diversion programs", built on Indigenous authority and culture. [9] [16] The matter of incarceration of Indigenous adults and children, and a recognition of its relationship to disadvantage, has been recognised and reflected in the 2020 targets of the federal government's Closing the Gap strategy. [17]

A documentary film by Maya Newell called In My Blood It Runs follows a ten-year-old Arrernte/Garrwa boy who got into trouble and was almost imprisoned. As a twelve-year-old, the boy was the youngest person ever to make a speech to the UN Human Rights Council about youth incarceration. [8] [18]

Changes

In August 2020, the Legislative Assembly of the ACT voted to increase the age of criminal responsibility to 14 in line with UN standards, [19] [15] a move welcomed by Indigenous advocates. [20] The support was in principle only. [21] [22]

In October 2021, the Labor Party of Western Australia passed a motion at their state party conference to raise the age to 14. [23]

In March 2022, the Queensland Government rejected a bill to raise the age to 14, with a parliamentary committee recommending a continued national approach to increasing the age to 12. [24]

In June 2022, the Tasmanian Government announced that it would raise the minimum age of detention to 14, but with no change to the age of criminal responsibility. [25] [15]

In July 2022, Greens MLC Robert Simms raised a bill in the South Australian Government to raise the age to 14, with Attorney-General and Aboriginal Affairs Minister Kyam Maher taking much interest in the issue. [13]

On 13 October 2022, legislation was introduced to the Northern Territory Government to raise the age of criminal responsibility to 12 years of age. Instead of children of 10 and 11 entering the criminal justice system, they and their families would be referred to "intensive parenting programs", and the government would be expanding various schemes and family support services. The bill, introduced by Attorney-General Chansey Paech, was expected to pass, making NT the first Australian jurisdiction to raise the age above 10, although the commencement date was expected to be delayed until 2023. [26]

By jurisdiction

JurisdictionDoli incapax

Cannot be charged with a criminal offence

Rebuttable Doli incapax

acts as a rebuttable presumption [27]

Age in adult courtReference
Commonwealth Under 1010 to under 1418 Crimes Act 1914, s4M Criminal Code Act 1995 , s7.1; [28]

Crimes Act 1914, s4N Criminal Code Act 1995 , s7.2 [28]

Australian Capital Territory Under 1010 to under 1418 Criminal Code 2002, s25, s26

Children and Young People Act 1999, Part 1.3 ss7 and 8, and s69

New South Wales Under 1010 to under 1418 Children (Criminal Proceedings) Act 1987, s5; Common law: doli incapax;

Children (Criminal Proceedings) Act 1987, s3

Northern Territory Under 12 [29] 10 to under 1418Criminal Code Act, s38(1), s38(2)
Queensland Under 1010 to under 1418 Criminal Code, s29
South Australia Under 1010 to under 1418 Young Offenders Act 1993, s5; Common law doli incapax; Young Offenders Act 1993, s4;
Tasmania Under 1010 to under 1418 Criminal Code Act 1924, s18(1);

Criminal Code Act 1924, s18(2); Youth Justice Act 1997, s3

Victoria Under 1010 to under 1418 Children Youth and Families Act 2005, s344
Western Australia Under 1010 to under 1418Criminal Code Act Compilation Act 1913, s29; [30] Young Offenders Act 1994, s3

See also

Footnotes

    Related Research Articles

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Age of criminal responsibility</span> Minimum age at which a child is capable of committing criminal offences

    The age of criminal responsibility is the age below which a child is deemed incapable of having committed a criminal offence. In legal terms, it is referred to as a defence/defense of infancy, which is a form of defense known as an excuse so that defendants falling within the definition of an "infant" are excluded from criminal liability for their actions, if at the relevant time, they had not reached an age of criminal responsibility. After reaching the initial age, there may be levels of responsibility dictated by age and the type of offense committed.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Australian Human Rights Commission</span> Human rights institution of the Australian Government

    The Australian Human Rights Commission is the national human rights institution of Australia, established in 1986 as the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission (HREOC) and renamed in 2008. It is a statutory body funded by, but operating independently of, the Australian Government. It is responsible for investigating alleged infringements of Australia's anti-discrimination legislation in relation to federal agencies.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Bowraville, New South Wales</span> Town in New South Wales, Australia

    Bowraville is a small town in the Mid North Coast hinterland of New South Wales, Australia in the Nambucca Valley. The town is known for tourism with attractions such as a folk museum, a war museum, a historic theatre, and other historic buildings.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Don Dale Youth Detention Centre</span>

    The Don Dale Youth Detention Centre is a facility for juvenile detention in the Northern Territory, Australia, located in Berrimah, east of Darwin. It is a detention centre for male and female juvenile delinquents. The facility is named after Don Dale, a former Member of the Northern Territory Legislative Assembly from 1983 to 1989 and one-time Minister for Correctional Services.

    Human rights in Australia have largely been developed by the democratically-elected Australian Parliament through laws in specific contexts and safeguarded by such institutions as the independent judiciary and the High Court, which implement common law, the Australian Constitution, and various other laws of Australia and its states and territories. Australia also has an independent statutory human rights body, the Australian Human Rights Commission, which investigates and conciliates complaints, and more generally promotes human rights through education, discussion and reporting.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Aboriginal deaths in custody</span> Political and social issue in Australia

    Aboriginal deaths in custody is a political and social issue in Australia. It rose in prominence in the early 1980s, with Aboriginal activists campaigning following the death of 16-year-old John Peter Pat in 1983. Subsequent deaths in custody, considered suspicious by families of the deceased, culminated in the 1987 Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody (RCIADIC).

    A community legal centre (CLC) is the Australian term for an independent not-for-profit organisation providing legal aid services, that is, provision of assistance to people who are unable to afford legal representation and access to the court system. They provide legal advice and traditional casework for free, primarily funded by federal, state and local government. Working with clients who are mostly the most disadvantaged and vulnerable people in Australian society, they also work with other agencies to address related problems, including financial, social and health issues. Their functions may include campaigning for law reform and developing community education programs.

    Adoption in Australia deals with the adoption process in the various parts of Australia, whereby a person assumes or acquires the permanent, legal status of parenthood in relation to a child under the age of 18 in place of the child's birth or biological parents. Australia classifies adoptions as local adoptions, and intercountry adoptions. Known child adoptions are a form of local adoptions.

    Liberty Victoria, officially the Victorian Council for Civil Liberties (VCCL) and formerly Australian Council for Civil Liberties (ACCL), is a civil liberties group based in Victoria, Australia.

    Indigenous Australians are both convicted of crimes and imprisoned at a disproportionately higher rate in Australia, as well as being over-represented as victims of crime. As of September 2019, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander prisoners represented 28% of the total adult prisoner population, while accounting for 2% of the general adult population. Various explanations have been given for this over-representation, both historical and more recent. Federal and state governments and Indigenous groups have responded with various analyses, programs and measures.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Punishment in Australia</span>

    Punishment in Australia arises when an individual has been accused or convicted of breaking the law through the Australian criminal justice system. Australia uses prisons, as well as community corrections. When awaiting trial, prisoners may be kept in specialised remand centres or within other prisons.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Kyam Maher</span> Australian politician

    Kyam Joseph Maher is an Australian politician and lawyer who has been Attorney-General of South Australia and the Leader of the Government in the Legislative Council since March 2022. He was appointed to a casual vacancy in the South Australian Legislative Council for the South Australian Branch of the Australian Labor Party on 17 October 2012. He previously served in the Cabinet of South Australia between 2015 and 2018 and was the Leader of the Government in the Legislative Council between 2016 and 2018.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Juvenile detention in the Northern Territory</span>

    Juvenile detention in the Northern Territory is administered by Territory Families, since a departmental reorganisation following the Labor victory at the August 2016 Northern Territory general election. Juvenile detention is mostly operated through two facilities - the Alice Springs Juvenile Holding Centre in Alice Springs, and the Don Dale Juvenile Detention Centre in eastern Darwin. These had previously been administered by the Department of Correctional Services. A juvenile is a child between the age of 10 and 17.

    The Royal Commission into the Protection and Detention of Children in the Northern Territory is a Royal Commission established in 2016 by the Australian Government pursuant to the Royal Commissions Act 1902 to inquire into and report upon failings in the child protection and youth detention systems of the Government of the Northern Territory. The establishment of the commission followed revelations broadcast on 25 July 2016 by the ABC TV Four Corners program which showed abuse of juveniles held in the Don Dale Juvenile Detention Centre in Darwin.

    Chanston James "Chansey" Paech is an Australian politician. He is a Labor Party member of the Northern Territory Legislative Assembly since 2016, representing the electorate of Namatjira until 2020 and Gwoja thereafter. He is of Arrente, Arabana and Gurindji descent.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Lidia Thorpe</span> Australian politician (born 1973)

    Lidia Alma Thorpe is an Australian independent politician. She has been a senator for Victoria since 2020 and is the first Aboriginal senator from that state. She was a member of the Australian Greens until February 2023 when she quit the party over disagreements concerning the proposed Indigenous Voice to Parliament. She had also served as the Greens' deputy leader in the Senate from June to October 2022.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Custody Notification Service</span> Hotline for Aboriginal Australians in custody

    A Custody Notification Service (CNS), sometimes referred to as a Custody Notification Scheme, is a 24-hour legal advice and support telephone hotline for any Indigenous Australian person brought into custody, connecting them with lawyers from the Aboriginal legal service operating in their state or territory. It is intended to reduce the high number of Aboriginal deaths in custody by counteracting the effects of institutional racism. Legislation mandating the police to inform the legal service whenever an Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander person is brought into custody is seen as essential to ensure compliance and a clear record of events. Where Custody Notification Services have been implemented, there have been reductions in the numbers of Aboriginal deaths in custody.

    Indigenous treaties in Australia are proposed binding legal agreements between Australian governments and Australian First Nations. A treaty could recognise First Nations as distinct political communities, acknowledge Indigenous Sovereignty, set out mutually recognised rights and responsibilities or provide for some degree of self-government. As of 2023, no such treaties are in force, however the Commonwealth and all states except Western Australia have expressed support previously for a treaty process. However, the defeat of the Voice referendum has led to a reversal by several state liberal and national parties in their support for treaty and a much more ambigious expressed position by state Labor parties and governments.

    <i>Love v Commonwealth</i> 2020 case in High Court of Australia

    Love v Commonwealth; Thoms v Commonwealth is a High Court of Australia case that held that Aboriginal Australians could not be classified as aliens under section 51(xix) of the Australian Constitution. The case was decided on 11 February 2020.

    <span class="mw-page-title-main">Jacinta Nampijinpa Price</span> Australian activist and politician

    Jacinta Yangapi Nampijinpa Price is an Australian politician from the Northern Territory. She has been a senator for the Northern Territory since the 2022 federal election. She is a member of the Country Liberal Party, a politically conservative party operating in the Northern Territory affiliated with the national Coalition. She sits with the National Party in federal parliament. She has been the Shadow Minister for Indigenous Affairs since April 2023.

    References

    1. ↑ Australian Institute of Criminology, The age of criminal responsibility, September 2005 (Canberra).
    2. ↑ R v CRH (Unreported, NSW Court of Criminal Appeal, Smart, Hidden and Newman JJ, 18 December 1996); C (A Minor) v DPP [1995] 2 WLR 383, 401-2; BP v R, SW v R [2006] NSWCCA 172 (1 June 2006).
    3. 1 2 "Experts back call to raise age of criminal responsibility to 16". SBS Australia. 22 November 2018.
    4. 1 2 3 4 Creek, Simon; Nims, Siobhan (30 July 2020). "Quick Facts: The age of criminal responsibility in Australia and youth incarceration". Welcome to Mondaq. Retrieved 6 August 2020.
    5. 1 2 "Review of the age of criminal responsibility (2020)". Australian Human Rights Commission. 26 February 2020. Retrieved 6 August 2020. PDF
    6. 1 2 "Council of Attorneys-General – Age of Criminal Responsibility Working Group Review". Law Council of Australia. 29 July 2020. Retrieved 6 August 2020. PDF
    7. ↑ "AMA calls for age of criminal responsibility to be raised to 14 years of age". Australian Medical Association. 25 March 2019. Retrieved 12 April 2019.
    8. 1 2 Zwartz, Henry; Dunstan, Joseph (26 July 2020). "The push to raise Australia's minimum age of criminal responsibility". ABC News. Retrieved 6 August 2020.
    9. 1 2 Cunneen, Chris (22 July 2020). "Ten-year-olds do not belong in detention. Why Australia must raise the age of criminal responsibility". The Conversation. Retrieved 6 August 2020.
    10. ↑ "age of criminal responsibility". RACP. Retrieved 6 August 2020.
    11. ↑ Ralston, Nick; Whitbourn, Michaela (27 July 2020). "Age of criminal responsibility to remain at 10 until at least 2021". The Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved 6 August 2020.
    12. ↑ Richards, Stephanie (28 July 2020). "Move to lift criminal age on hold as SA waits for national decision". InDaily. Retrieved 6 August 2020.
    13. 1 2 Richards, Stephanie (4 July 2022). "Greens push to lift SA's criminal age from 10". InDaily . Retrieved 13 October 2022.
    14. ↑ Goldsworthy, Terry (1 September 2022). "Why we should not rush to raise the age of criminal responsibility in Australia". The Conversation . Retrieved 13 October 2022.
    15. 1 2 3 Holland, Lorelle; Toombs, Maree (2 August 2022). "Raising the age of criminal responsibility is only a first step. First Nations kids need cultural solutions". The Conversation . Retrieved 13 October 2022.
    16. ↑ Keoghan, Sarah; Whitbourn, Michaela (26 July 2020). "Council of Attorney's-General to urge change of age for criminal responsibility". The Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved 6 August 2020.
    17. ↑ National Agreement on Closing the Gap (PDF), July 2020, retrieved 4 August 2020
    18. ↑ York, Keva (20 February 2020). "In My Blood It Runs documentary exposes how education system is failing Aboriginal children". ABC News. Retrieved 6 August 2020.
    19. ↑ "Why Australia is facing calls to stop jailing 10-year-olds". BBC News. 21 August 2020. Retrieved 23 August 2020.
    20. ↑ Allam, Lorena (20 August 2020). "Australian Capital Territory votes to raise age of criminal responsibility from 10 to 14". the Guardian. Retrieved 23 August 2020.
    21. ↑ "Criminal responsibility age to be raised from 10 to 14 if ACT Labor re-elected, after Government endorses reform - ABC News". ABC (Australian Broadcasting Corporation). 20 August 2020. Retrieved 23 August 2020.
    22. ↑ Jenkins, Keira (20 August 2020). "ACT agrees to raise age of criminal responsibility". NITV. Retrieved 23 August 2020.
    23. ↑ Knowles, Rachael (5 October 2021). "WA Labor passes motion to raise the age". National Indigenous Times . Retrieved 13 October 2022.
    24. ↑ Dennien, Matt (15 March 2022). "Bill to raise age of criminal responsibility to 14 in Qld rejected by committee". Brisbane Times . Retrieved 13 October 2022.
    25. ↑ MacDonald, Lucy (8 June 2022). "Tasmania set to be first jurisdiction to raise minimum age of children in youth detention". ABC News. Retrieved 13 October 2022.
    26. ↑ Morgan, Thomas (13 October 2022). "NT government to introduce laws raising the age of criminal responsibility and reforming adult mandatory sentencing". ABC News. Retrieved 13 October 2022.
    27. ↑ "Archived copy" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 25 March 2012. Retrieved 12 October 2012.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: archived copy as title (link)
    28. 1 2 Criminal Code Act 1995 (series)
    29. ↑ "NT sets date for changing age of criminal responsibility, but advocates call for more changes". ABC News. 24 July 2023. Retrieved 12 October 2023.
    30. ↑ "WALW - Criminal Code Act Compilation Act 1913 - Home Page". www.legislation.wa.gov.au.

    Further reading

    This page is based on this Wikipedia article
    Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
    Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.