Free-to-play

Last updated

Free-to-play (F2P or FtP) video games are games that give players access to a significant portion of their content without paying. Free-to-play is distinct from traditional commercial software, which requires a payment before using the game or service. It is also separate from free games, usually referred to as freeware, which are entirely costless. Free-to-play's model is sometimes derisively referred to as free-to-start due to not being entirely free. [1]

Contents

There are several kinds of free-to-play business models. The most common is based on the freemium software model, in which users are granted access to a fully functional game but are incentivised to pay microtransactions to access additional content. Sometimes the content is entirely blocked without payment; other times it requires immense time 'unlocking' it for non-paying players, and paying the fee speeds the unlocking process. Another method of generating revenue is to integrate advertisements into the game.

The model was first popularly used in early massively multiplayer online games targeted towards casual gamers, before finding wider adoption among games released by major video game publishers to combat video game piracy.

Categories

There are several kinds of free-to-play games:

Game mechanics

In-game items can be purely cosmetic, enhance the power of the player, accelerate progression speed, and many more. A common technique used by developers of these games is for the items purchased to have a time limit; after this expires, the item must be repurchased before the user can continue. Another commonly seen mechanic is the use of two in-game currencies: one earned through normal gameplay, and another which can be purchased with real-world money. The second, "premium" currency is sometimes given out in small amounts to non-paying players at certain times, such as when they first start the game, complete a quest, or refer a friend to the game. Many browser games have an "energy bar" that depletes when the player takes actions. These games then sell items such as coffee or snacks to refill the bar. [6]

Free-to-play games are free to install and play, but once the player enters the game, the player is able to purchase content such as items, maps, and expanded customization options. [7] Some games, such as id Software's Quake Live , [8] also use in-game advertising to provide income for free-to-play games. In addition to making in-game items available for purchase, EA integrates in-game advertising into its games. In August 2007, EA completed a deal with Massive Incorporated, which lets Massive update and change in-game advertising in real-time within EA games. [9] Independent game developer Edmund McMillen has claimed that he makes most of his money from sponsors by placing advertisements into the introduction of a game and the game's title screen.

History

Matt Mihaly created the first known business model of exchanging virtual items for money in an online game, in 1997 for the flagship title Achaea, Dreams of Divine Lands for his corporation originally Achaea LLC that later became Iron Realms Entertainment. [10] The free-to-play business model in online games was later realized by Nexon in South Korea to a degree first catching more major media attention at the time. [11] [12] The first Nexon game to use it, QuizQuiz, was released in October 1999. Its creator Lee Seungchan would go on to create MapleStory. [13]

The free-to-play model originated in the late 1990s and early 2000s, coming from a series of highly successful MMOs targeted towards children and casual gamers, including Furcadia , Neopets , RuneScape , [14] [15] MapleStory , and text-based dungeons such as Achaea, Dreams of Divine Lands . [16] Known for producing innovative titles, small independent developers also continue to release free-to-play games.

Free-to-play games are particularly prevalent in countries such as South Korea and the People's Republic of China. [7] [17] Microtransaction-based free-to-play mobile games and browser games such as Puzzle & Dragons , Kantai Collection and The Idolmaster Cinderella Girls also have large player populations in Japan. [18] In particular, the Nikkei Shimbun reported that Cinderella Girls earns over 1 billion yen in revenue monthly from microtransactions. [19] Electronic Arts first adopted the free-to-play concept in one of its games when it released FIFA Online in Korea. [9]

In the late 2000s, many MMOs transitioned to the free-to-play model from subscriptions, [20] including subscription-based games such as The Lord of the Rings Online: Shadows of Angmar , Age of Conan: Hyborian Adventures , Dungeons & Dragons Online , [21] and Champions Online . [7] This move from a subscription based model to a free-to-play one has proven very beneficial in some cases. Star Wars: The Old Republic is a good example of a game that transitioned from subscription to free-to-play. [2] Turbine as of September 10, 2010 has given an F2P with Cash shop option to The Lord of the Rings Online which resulted in a tripling of profit. [22] Sony Online Entertainment's move to transition EverQuest from a subscription model into a hybrid F2P/subscription game was followed by a 125% spike in item sales, a 150% up-tick in unique log-ins, and over three times as many account registrations. [23]

The movement of free-to-play MMOs into the mainstream also coincided with experimentation with other genres as well. The model was picked up by larger developers and more diverse genres, with games such as Battlefield Heroes , [9] Free Realms , Quake Live and Team Fortress 2 [8] appearing in the late 2000s. The experimentation was not successful in every genre, however. Traditional real time strategy franchises such as Age of Empires and Command & Conquer both attempted free-to-play titles. Age of Empires Online was shut down in the midst of a tiny player base and stagnant revenue, [24] and Command & Conquer: Generals 2 was shut down in alpha due to negative reactions from players. [25]

In 2011, revenue from free-to-play games overtook revenue from premium games in the top 100 games in Apple's App Store. [26] The percentage of people that spend money on in-game items in these games ranges from 0.5% to 6%, depending on a game's quality and mechanics. Even though this means that a large number of people will never spend money in a game, it also means that the people that do spend money could amount to a sizeable number due to the fact that the game was given away for free. [26] Indeed a report from mobile advertising company firm SWRV stated that only 1.5 percent of players opted to pay for in-game items, and that 50 percent of the revenue for such games often came from just ten percent of players. [27] Nevertheless The Washington Post noted that the developers of two such games, Supercell ( Clash of Clans ) and Machine Zone ( Game of War: Fire Age ), were able to afford Super Bowl commercials in 2015 featuring big-name celebrities (respectively Liam Neeson and Kate Upton). [27] [28] [29] The latter, Game of War, was in fact, part of a roughly $40 million campaign starring Upton.

As of 2012, free-to-play MOBAs, such as League of Legends , Dota 2, Heroes of the Storm , and Smite have become among the most popular PC games. [30] The success in the genre has helped convince many video game publishers to copy the free-to-play MOBA model. [31] [32]

During 2015, Slice Intelligence tracked people that bought products in mobile video games, and these players spent an average of $87 in free-to-play games. [33] The highest spending per player in 2015 was in Game of War: Fire Age , where the players that bought products on average spent $550. [34]

Comparison with traditional model

The free-to-play model has been described as a shift from the traditional model in the sense that previously, success was measured by multiplying the number of units of a game sold by the unit price, while with free-to-play, the most important factor is the number of players that a game can keep continuously engaged, followed by how many compelling spending opportunities the game offers its players. With free games that include in-game purchases, two particularly important things occur: first, more people will try out the game since there is zero cost to doing so and second, revenue will likely be more than a traditional game since different players can now spend different amounts of money that depend on their engagement with the game and their preferences towards it. Player populations that spend money on free-to-play games can be broken up into terms that borrow from gambling: "whales" which typically are the smallest segment, up to around 10% of players, but are willing to spend the most on a game; "dolphins" which represent a larger portion of around 40% of players who spend some money but not as much as whales; and "minnows", representing about half the population, who spend the barest amount to maintain activity. [35] [36] As a result of this distribution, whales typically provide most of the revenue in free to play games, and in some cases, 50% of the revenue comes from 0.15% of players ("white whales") in one report. [37] [38] It is not unlikely for a very few players to spend tens of thousands of dollars in a game that they enjoy. [26]

On the PC in particular, two problems are video game piracy and high system requirements. The free-to-play model attempts to solve both these problems by providing a game that requires relatively low system requirements and at no cost, and consequently provides a highly accessible experience funded by advertising and micropayments for extra content or an advantage over other players. [8]

Free-to-play is newer than the pay to play model, and the video game industry is still attempting to determine the best ways to maximize revenue from their games. Gamers have cited the fact that purchasing a game for a fixed price is still inherently satisfying because the consumer knows exactly what they will be receiving, compared to free-to-play which requires that the player pay for most new content that they wish to obtain. The term itself, "free-to-play", has been described as one with a negative connotation. One video game developer noted this, stating, "Our hope—and the basket we're putting our eggs in—is that 'free' will soon be disassociated with [sic] 'shallow' and 'cruddy'." However, another noted that developing freeware games gave developers the largest amount of creative freedom, especially when compared to developing console games, which requires that the game follow the criteria as laid out by the game's publisher. [8] Many kinds of revenue are being experimented with. For example, with its Free Realms game targeted to children and casual gamers, Sony makes money from the product with advertisements on loading screens, free virtual goods sponsored by companies such as Best Buy, a subscription option to unlock extra content, a collectible card game, a comic book, and micropayment items that include character customization options. [8]

In 2020, a study from Germany concluded that some free-to-play games use the "money illusion" as a form to hide the true cost of products. When they examined the game Fortnite, they found that since the in-game currency does not have a unique exchange rate, it can conceal the true cost of an in-game purchase, resulting in players potentially paying more than they realize. [39] In 2021 the study was used to take legal action against Epic Games, the publisher of Fortnite. [40]

Pay-to-win

In some games, players who are willing to pay for special items, downloadable content, or to skip cooldown timers may be able to gain an advantage over those playing for free who might otherwise hardly be able to access said items. Such games are called "pay-to-win" by critics. In general a game is considered pay-to-win when a player can gain any gameplay advantage over their non-paying peers. Market research indicates that pay-to-win mechanics are considered much more acceptable by players in China than in Western countries, possibly because Chinese players are more habituated to recurring costs associated with gaming, such as gaming café fees. [41]

A common suggestion for avoiding pay-to-win is for payments to only be used to broaden the experience without affecting gameplay. [42] For example, some games, such as Dota 2 , Fortnite Battle Royale, and StarCraft II , only allow the purchase of cosmetic items, meaning that a player who has spent money on the game will still be on the same level as a player who has not. Others suggest finding a balance where a game encourages players to pay for extra content that enhances the game without making the free version feel limited by comparison. [43] This theory is that players who do not pay for items would still increase awareness of it through word of mouth marketing, which ultimately benefits the game indirectly. [41] [44]

In response to concerns about players using payments to gain an advantage in the game, titles such as World of Tanks have explicitly committed to not giving paying players any advantages over their non-paying peers, while allowing the users buying the "gold" or "premium" ammo and expendables without paying the real money. However, features affecting gameplay and win rate, such as purchasing a 100% crew training level, a premium account, premium vehicles, and converting experience points to free experience points, remain available for the paying customers only. [45] [46]

Nagging

In single-player games, another concern is the tendency for free games to constantly request that the player buy extra content, in a similar vein to nagware and trialware's frequent demands for the user to 'upgrade'. Payment may be required in order to survive or continue in the game, annoying or distracting the player from the experience. [8] Some psychologists, such as Mark D. Griffiths, have criticized the mechanics of freemium games as exploitative, drawing direct parallels to gambling addiction. [47]

Purchases by children

The ubiquitous and often intrusive use of microtransactions in free-to-play games has sometimes caused children to either inadvertently or deliberately pay for large amounts of virtual items, often for drastically high amounts of real money. In February 2013, Eurogamer reported that Apple had agreed to refund a British family £1700.41 after their son had purchased countless microtransactions whilst playing the F2P game Zombies vs. Ninjas. [48]

Outlook

Pointing to the disruptive effect of free-to-play on current models, IGN editor Charles Onyett has said "expensive, one-time purchases are facing extinction". He believes that the current method of paying a one-time fee for most games will eventually disappear completely. [7] Greg Zeschuk of BioWare believes there is a good possibility that free-to-play would become the dominant pricing plan for games, but that it was very unlikely that it would ever completely replace subscription-based games. [17] Developers such as Electronic Arts have pointed to the success of freemium, saying that microtransactions will inevitably be part of every game. [49] While noting the success of some developers with the model, companies such as Nintendo have remained skeptical of free-to-play, preferring to stick to more traditional models of game development and sales. [50] In February 2015 Apple began featuring popular non-freemium software on the App Store as "Pay Once & Play", describing them as "Great Games with No In-App Purchases ... hours of uninterrupted fun with complete experiences". [51] [52]

See also

Related Research Articles

A virtual economy is an emergent economy existing in a virtual world, usually exchanging virtual goods in the context of an online game, particularly in massively multiplayer online games (MMOs). People enter these virtual economies for recreation and entertainment rather than necessity, which means that virtual economies lack the aspects of a real economy that are not considered to be "fun". However, some people do interact with virtual economies for "real" economic benefit.

Mobile game Video game played on a mobile device

A mobile game is a video game that is typically played on a mobile phone. Historically, the term refers to all games that are played on any portable device, including from mobile phone, tablet, PDA to handheld game console, portable media player or graphing calculator, with and without networkability. The earliest known game on a mobile phone was a Tetris variant on the Hagenuk MT-2000 device from 1994.

Pogo.com Web based video gaming service

Pogo.com is a free online gaming website that offers over 50 casual games from brands like Hasbro and PopCap Games. It offers a variety of card and board games to puzzle, sports and word games. It is owned by Electronic Arts and is based in Redwood Shores, California.

<i>Achaea, Dreams of Divine Lands</i>

Achaea, Dreams of Divine Lands is a roleplay-focused, text-based multi-user dungeon (MUD) released on September 9, 1997. It was published by Achaea LLC, now known as Iron Realms Entertainment. Achaea is operated by collecting the revenue through a microtransaction system, which allows payment for the acquisition of in-game benefits.

Freemium Business model and software licensing scheme in which the basic form of a product is free of charge but additional features requires payment

Freemium, a portmanteau of the words "free" and "premium", is a pricing strategy by which a basic product or service is provided free of charge, but money is charged for additional features, services, or virtual (online) or physical (offline) goods that expand the functionality of the free version of the software. This business model has been used in the software industry since the 1980s. A subset of this model used by the video game industry is called free-to-play.

Microtransactions, often abbreviated as MTX, are a business model where users can purchase virtual goods with micropayments. Microtransactions are often used in free-to-play games to provide a revenue source for the developers. While microtransactions are a staple of the mobile app market, they are also seen on PC software such as Valve's Steam digital distribution platform, as well as console gaming.

Downloadable content (DLC) is additional content created for an already released video game, distributed through the Internet by the game's publisher. It can either be added for no extra cost or it can be a form of video game monetization, enabling the publisher to gain additional revenue from a title after it has been purchased, often using some type of microtransaction system.

Roblox is an online game platform and game creation system developed by Roblox Corporation. It allows users to program games and play games created by other users. Created by David Baszucki and Erik Cassel in 2004 and released in 2006, the platform hosts user-created games of multiple genres coded in the programming language Lua. For most of Roblox's history, it was relatively small, both as a platform and a company, due to both co-founder Baszucki's lack of interest in press coverage and it being "lost among the crowd" in a large number of platforms released around the same time. Roblox began to grow rapidly in the second half of the 2010s, and this growth has been accelerated by the COVID-19 pandemic.

Virtual goods are non-physical objects and money purchased for use in online communities or online games. Digital goods, on the other hand, may be a broader category including digital books, music, and movies. Virtual goods are intangible by definition.

<i>Candy Crush Saga</i> 2012 free-to-play match-three puzzle video game

Candy Crush Saga is a free-to-play match-three puzzle video game released by King on April 12, 2012, for Facebook; other versions for iOS, Android, Windows Phone, and Windows 10 followed. It is a variation of their browser game Candy Crush.

<i>Game of War: Fire Age</i> 2013 massively multiplayer online strategy video game

Game of War: Fire Age is a 2013 freemium mobile massively multiplayer online strategy video game developed and published by Machine Zone. The game had a high-profile advertising campaign and was one of the top-grossing apps in 2014 and 2015.

Video game monetization is the type of process that a video game publisher can use to generate revenue from a video game product. The methods of monetization may vary between games, especially when they come from different genres or platforms, but they all serve the same purpose to return money to the game developers, copyright owners, and other stakeholders. As the monetization methods continue to diversify, they also affect the game design in a way that sometimes leads to criticism.

Buy-to-play (B2P) is a revenue model for video games that can only be played by purchasing the game, as opposed to there being a subsequent subscription fee for playing the game. Buy-to-play, while a form of premium games, generally apply to games where there is continued ongoing content or support from the developer or publisher well beyond the period of purchase, such as through maintenance of online servers or through the production of ongoing content and expansions, as often the case in massively multiplayer online games (MMO). This support is monetized through additional microtransactions or through an ongoing subscription fee. Microtransactions are becoming evermore entwined with the Buy-to-play revenue model as most recent games allow for some sort of additional purchase. For example, buy-to-play title Guild Wars 2 allows players to purchase additional in-game items with microtransactions, while Destiny 2 lets users purchase season passes for additional content.

A gacha game is a genre of video games that implement the gacha mechanic. Similar to loot boxes in video games, gacha games induce players to spend in-game currency to receive a random virtual item. Most of these games are free-to-play mobile games, where the gacha serves as an incentive to spend real-world money.

Loot box Redeemable virtual item as video game prizes

In video games, a loot box is a consumable virtual item which can be redeemed to receive a randomised selection of further virtual items, or loot, ranging from simple customization options for a player's avatar or character, to game-changing equipment such as weapons and armor. A loot box is typically a form of monetisation, with players either buying the boxes directly or receiving the boxes during play and later buying "keys" with which to redeem them. These systems may also be known as gacha and integrated into gacha games.

In the video game industry, games as a service (GaaS) represents providing video games or game content on a continuing revenue model, similar to software as a service. Games as a service are ways to monetize video games either after their initial sale, or to support a free-to-play model. Games released under the GaaS model typically receive a long or indefinite stream of monetized new content over time to encourage players to continue paying to support the game. This often leads to games that work under a GaaS model to be called "living games" or "live games", since they continually change with these updates.

Battle pass Type of video game monetization

In the video game industry, a battle pass is a type of monetization approach that provides additional content for a game usually through a tiered system, rewarding the player with in-game items for playing the game and completing specific challenges. Inspired by the season pass ticketing system and originating with Dota 2 in 2013, the battle pass model gained more use as an alternative to subscription fees and loot boxes beginning in the late 2010s. Battle passes tend to offer free passes, which are available to all users, and a premium pass that require annual or seasonal charges in exchange for enhanced items and cosmetics.

Epic Games Store Digital video game storefront

The Epic Games Store is a digital video game storefront for Microsoft Windows and macOS, operated by Epic Games. It launched in December 2018 as both a website and a standalone launcher, of which the latter is required to download and play games. The storefront provides a basic catalog, friends list management, matchmaking, and other features. Epic Games has further plans to expand the feature set of the store front but it does not plan to add as many features as other digital distribution platforms, such as discussion boards or user reviews, instead using existing social media platforms to support these.

History of mobile games

The popularisation of mobile games began as early as 1997 with the introduction of Snake preloaded on Nokia feature phones, demonstrating the practicality of games on these devices. Several mobile device manufacturers included preloaded games in the wake of Snake's success. By the early 2000s, the technical specifications of handsets had matured to the point where downloadable applications could be supported, however mainstream adoption continued to be hampered by market fragmentation between different devices, operating environments, and distributors.

References

  1. Pereira, Chris (March 23, 2015). "Here's Why Nintendo's CEO Dislikes the Term "Free-to-Play"". GameSpot . Retrieved August 22, 2018.
  2. 1 2 Tack, Daniel (October 12, 2013). "The Subscription Transition: MMORPGs and Free-To-Play". Forbes magazine. Retrieved October 16, 2020.
  3. Lejacq, Yannick (December 13, 2012). "Freemium Games Make Up 80% Of $10B Mobile App Market In 2012: Flurry Report". The International Business Times. Retrieved December 17, 2012.
  4. Gill, Bobby (December 14, 2012). "'Freemium' Games Pave the Way to Riches for App Developers". Archived from the original on January 3, 2013. Retrieved December 17, 2012.
  5. LeJacq, Yannick (September 15, 2012). "Something For Nothing: How The Videogame Industry Is Adapting To A 'Freemium' World". The International Business Times. Retrieved December 17, 2012.
  6. Davis, Justin (July 20, 2012). "The Dark Future of Freemium Games, and How We Can Avoid It". IGN Entertainment, Inc. Retrieved December 17, 2012.
  7. 1 2 3 4 Onyett, Charles (August 2, 2011). "Death of the Disc-Based Game". IGN. Retrieved August 5, 2011.
  8. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Meer, Alec (March 12, 2009). "Is free really the future of gaming?". TechRadar. Retrieved August 5, 2011.
  9. 1 2 3 Evans, Dean (January 21, 2008). "Free EA games herald greater in-game advertising". TechRadar. Retrieved August 5, 2011.
  10. Hrodey, Matt (October 25, 2019). "Meet the man who invented microtransactions years before Oblivion's horse armour". PCGamesN . Retrieved October 25, 2019.
  11. Kong, Lily; O'Connor, Justin (May 19, 2009). Creative Economies, Creative Cities: Asian-European Perspectives. Springer Science & Business Media. p. 38. ISBN   9781402099496 . Retrieved April 5, 2017.
  12. Wolf, Mark J. P.; Iwatani, Toru (May 22, 2015). Video Games Around the World. MIT Press. p. 512. ISBN   9780262328494 . Retrieved April 5, 2017.
  13. "세계 최초 넥슨의 부분유료화 이야기". 게임플 (in Korean). Retrieved April 5, 2017.
  14. Griliopoulos, Dan (June 27, 2012). "The Longest Game: The Making of RuneScape". PCGamesN. Retrieved June 27, 2012.
  15. "RuneScape in Guinness World Records!". RuneScape News. Jagex. August 22, 2008. Retrieved August 22, 2008.
  16. Davis, Steven (2009), Protecting Games, p. 228, ISBN   978-1-58450-670-6
  17. 1 2 Kelly, Neon (May 11, 2010). "BioWare on subscriptions vs free-to-play". VideoGamer. Retrieved August 5, 2011.
  18. 2013-09-27, ツイート数は「パズドラ」より「艦これ」 【ゲームの課金についてのツイート分析】, MarkeZine
  19. "Idolmaster Mobile Game Earns 1 Billion Yen a Month". Anime News Network . September 27, 2012. Retrieved July 19, 2013.
  20. Daniel Tack (October 9, 2013). "The Subscription Transition: MMORPGs And Free-To-Play". Forbes. Retrieved February 3, 2014.
  21. "Warcry.com Article". Massively.com. July 31, 2009. Archived from the original on February 2, 2014. Retrieved January 2, 2012.
  22. "News – Turbine: Lord of the Rings Online Revenues Tripled As Free-To-Play Game". Gamasutra. Retrieved January 2, 2012.
  23. Reahard, Jef (April 17, 2012). "SOE trumpets EverQuest's F2P success". Joystiq. Archived from the original on February 2, 2015. Retrieved June 15, 2013.
  24. Alexa Ray Corriea (August 19, 2013). "Age of Empires Online's lack of new content drove revenue loss". Polygon. Retrieved February 3, 2014.
  25. Michael McWhertor (October 29, 2013). "EA cancels Command & Conquer, closes development studio". Polygon. Retrieved February 3, 2014.
  26. 1 2 3 Valadares, Jeferson (July 11, 2011). "Free-to-play Revenue Overtakes Premium Revenue in the App Store". Flurry. Archived from the original on August 10, 2011. Retrieved August 5, 2011.
  27. 1 2 Peterson, Andrea. "How two 'free' games made enough money to buy Super Bowl Ads". Washington Post. Retrieved February 28, 2015.
  28. Hayward, Andrew (February 9, 2015). "Freemium Field Test: Game of War Fire Age is even less exciting than its generic Kate Upton commercials". Macworld. Retrieved February 21, 2015.
  29. "Clash of Clans". Archived from the original on March 12, 2016. Retrieved March 12, 2016.
  30. Gaudiosi, John (July 11, 2012). "Riot Games' League Of Legends Officially Becomes Most Played PC Game In The World". Forbes . Retrieved November 5, 2012.
  31. Drain, Brendan (July 3, 2012). "The Soapbox: League of Legends is the new World of Warcraft". Joystiq. Archived from the original on February 2, 2015. Retrieved November 5, 2012.
  32. Stapleton, Dan (June 1, 2012). "Valve: We Won't Charge for Dota 2 Heroes". GameSpy. Archived from the original on October 30, 2012. Retrieved July 19, 2012.
  33. Stanton, Taylor. "hardly pocket change: mobile gamers spend an average of $87 on in-app purchases". Slice Intelligence. Archived from the original on September 13, 2016. Retrieved December 12, 2016.
  34. "Game of War's paying players spent an average of $550 on its in-app purchases in 2015". VentureBeat. April 1, 2016. Retrieved July 24, 2018.
  35. Lovell, Nicholas (November 16, 2011). "Whales, Dolphins and Minnows – the beating heart of a free-to-play game". GamesBrief . Retrieved March 16, 2021.
  36. Davidovici-Nora, Myriam (2014). "Paid and free digital business models innovations in the video game industry". Digiworld Economic Journal. 94: 83–102.
  37. Johnson, Eric (February 26, 2014). "A Long Tail of Whales: Half of Mobile Games Money Comes From 0.15 Percent of Players".
  38. Carmichael, Stephanie (March 14, 2013). "What it means to be a 'whale' — and why social gamers are just gamers". Venture Beat . Retrieved December 20, 2016.
  39. https://www.wiwi.europa-uni.de/de/forschung/publikationen-projekte/dp/_dokumente/415_Schoeber_Stadtmann.pdf
  40. https://lawstreetmedia.com/tech/parent-sues-epic-games-over-minor-using-real-money-on-virtual-fortnite-items/
  41. 1 2 Huang, Eustance (May 30, 2018). "Americans largely won't pay to win a video game — but Chinese gamers will". CNBC. Retrieved August 12, 2020.
  42. Charles Onyett (August 13, 2012). "Separating Free-to-Play and Pay to Win". IGN . Retrieved January 2, 2014.
  43. Pritpaul Bains and Theresa Delucci (August 9, 2013). "Gaming Roundup: What's Wrong With Free-to-Play?". Tor books. Archived from the original on April 9, 2015. Retrieved January 2, 2014.
  44. Adams, Ernest (December 19, 2013). Fundamentals of Game Design. New Riders. ISBN   978-0-13-343571-9.
  45. Kris Graft (June 3, 2013). "Wargaming kicks 'pay-to-win' monetization to the curb". GamaSutra. Retrieved January 30, 2014.
  46. Jenna Pitcher (June 3, 2013). "Wargaming axes pay-to-win model in favor of free-to-win". Polygon. Retrieved January 30, 2014.
  47. Mike Rose (July 9, 2013). "Chasing the Whale: Examining the ethics of free-to-play games". Gamasutra. Retrieved February 3, 2014.
  48. Phillips, Tom (February 28, 2013). "Parents refused refund by Apple after son spends £1700 on free iPad game".
  49. Eddie Makuch (July 30, 2012). "Freemium is the future, says EA". GameSpot. Retrieved February 3, 2014.
  50. Eddie Makuch (February 3, 2014). "Nintendo: Free-to-play is hurting our hardware business". GameSpot. Retrieved February 3, 2014.
  51. Clover, Juli (February 12, 2015). "Apple Promotes Games Without In-App Purchases in App Store". MacRumors. Retrieved June 5, 2016.
  52. Paul, Ian (February 13, 2015). "Apple highlights games without in-app purchases in the App Store". Macworld. Retrieved June 5, 2016.