Nietzschean Zionism

Last updated
German Philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche Nietzsche.jpg
German Philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche

Nietzschean Zionism was a movement arising from the influence that the German philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche had on Zionism and several of its influential thinkers. [1] Zionism was the movement for the attainment of freedom for the Jewish people through the establishment of a Jewish state. [2] Friedrich Nietzsche's philosophy was popular among Jewish intellectuals, and therefore incorporated into Zionism effortlessly. [3]

Contents

Friedrich Nietzsche's influence was expressed itself by a desire to move away from the Jewish past into an empowering future for the Hebraic New Man, the adoption of his ideas necessitating the Jews to surpass the antiquarian Jewish identity that had a rabbinical consciousness at its center. [1] The philosopher's influence on the Zionists can then be thought of as an existential revolution–that is, it focused on the renewal of the Jewish identity, the adoption of aesthetic values, and enhancing the will for life. [4] The Zionist revolution emphasized that “the new Jews," the concept of which was similar to Nietzsche's “new European man,” should choose to go to Zion or stay in Europe. [3] Theodor Herzl, “the author and the vision of the Jewish State,” viewed Zionism as the arrival of an authentic image of the Jew in a state without the idea of God or any dogmatization, [3] exhibiting a very similar format to that of Nietzsche's libertarianism or anti-dogmatism. [3]

Figures

Theodor Herzl

Zionist Leader Theodor Herzl Theodor Herzl retouched.jpg
Zionist Leader Theodor Herzl

Theodor Herzl, founder and president of the Zionist Organization, which helped establish a Jewish state, felt ambivalent about Friedrich Nietzsche's ideology, owing to Nietzsches history of mental health issues. [5] [3]

David Ben-Gurion, under a portrait of Theodor Herzl, is proclaiming Israel's independence Declaration of State of Israel 1948.jpg
David Ben-Gurion, under a portrait of Theodor Herzl, is proclaiming Israel's independence

Even so, Herzl's idea of the “new Jew” was profoundly similar to that of Nietzsche's “new European man” or Übermensch . [3] The character Jacob Samuel from Herzl's play Das Neue Ghetto resembles Zarathustra from Nietzsche's philosophical novel Thus Spoke Zarathustra. [3] Jacob's ideals surpass those of the herd mentality. He is proud and demonstrates no resentment, seeks to implement no values and morals, and is on a journey of overcoming his old self–Zarathustra had already displayed his ideals. [3] In Der Judenstaat, Herzl states, “If I wish to substitute a new building for an old one, I must demolish before I construct.” Nietzsche originally in On The Genealogy of Morals states, “If a temple is to be erected, a temple must be destroyed.” [3] Hence, Nietzsche's ideology on a journey toward authenticity may have heavily influenced Herzl in both his novels and personal life. [3]

Herzl refers to Plato, Arthur Schopenhauer, Immanuel Kant, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel, Aristotle, Ludwig Feuerbach, Franz Brentano, Johann Gottlieb Fichte, and Friedrich Wilhelm Joseph Schelling in his Jugendtagebuch. [3] Also, in his diary he quotes several Enlightenment philosophers such as Voltaire, Jean-Jacques Rousseau, and Immanuel Kant. [3] Nietzsche was not mentioned in either case. Also, Nietzsche's “European man” could not be generalized to the situation of the Jews in Europe. [3] Since the Jewish population was unable to assimilate and prosper in Europe, Herzl then believed that the Jew could reach authenticity elsewhere, namely in Zion. [3] If so, his ideology does not align with Nietzsche's “European man”, as Nietzsche's purpose is to surpass values and morals, not to move elsewhere to find authenticity. [3] Even though Nietzsche may have influenced Herzl's ideals, he may have been a temporary scaffold into creating the image of genuine authenticity. [3]

Buber

Professor Martin Buber Martin Buber 1963c.jpg
Professor Martin Buber

Martin Buber, who is claimed to be responsible for incorporating Friedrich Nietzsche into German Zionism, thought that Nietzsche portrayed the role of an individual able to create and go beyond himself. [6] This he believed to be necessary for the Jewish renaissance. [7] The two thousand years of the Jewish diaspora, Buber maintained, transformed physical energy into spiritual energy within the Jews. [4] The essential drive of the Jewish renaissance was to release the spiritual energy–something that Nietzsche wrote extensively on, believing that conserving the spirit internalizes one's instincts which are then turned against oneself. [4] Nietzsche thought the correct action to take after de-spiritualization is to advance one's aesthetic drive. [4] This, in turn, was a consequence of the Jewish renaissance. [4] In relation to Buber, he created an exhibition of contemporary Jewish art. [4] Buber's vision emphasized the notion of reconciling the Jewish people to a life of creativeness, happiness, and healthiness. [4] These values that Buber believed in may have been influenced by Friedrich Nietzsche's aesthetic work The Birth of Tragedy . [8] Buber was well aware that Nietzsche used the philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer to mold his authentic self; likewise, Buber used Nietzsche for the same reason. [4] Buber, after reaching and understanding the personal authenticity that Nietzsche extensively emphasized, jettisoned the philosopher from his life, as Buber believed that for one to grow truly fond of Nietzsche one must desert him. [4]

Chaim Weizmann

Israel's First President Chaim Weizmann Flickr - Government Press Office (GPO) - President Chaim Weizmann.jpg
Israel's First President Chaim Weizmann

Chaim Weizmann, leader of the Zionist movement and future first president of the State of Israel, was influenced by the writings of Friedrich Nietzsche, [9] believing that the Jews lacked power and seeing in Zionism a phenomenon that would steer the Jews toward power and freeing themselves. [10] Whether Weizmann's intention was conscious or not, his ideas relate to Nietzsche's idea of Übermensch . Although he believed that the Jews contained sufficient intellect to understand and incorporate the writings of Nietzsche into their lives, Weizmann believed this could not be done by all people. [10]

Max Nordau

Portrait of Max Nordau Portrait of Max Nordau.jpg
Portrait of Max Nordau

Max Nordau, cofounder of the Zionist Organization, was uncertain about Friedrich Nietzsche's philosophy. [11] Nietzsche received his first detailed critique from Nordau himself, although most of the arguments were against Nietzsche's character and not so much against his ideology. [4] His critique against Friedrich Nietzsche focused much on the philosopher's mental health, since Nietzsche suffered from syphilis. [4] Nietzsche's followers were also critiqued by Nordau. [4] He believed that they were “imbecile criminals” and a group of “simpletons.” [4] Lastly, Nordau found it unfortunate that the “manic” German philosopher was even considered a philosopher in the first place. [4]

Nordau, unlike Nietzsche, esteemed the values of the Enlightenment, whereas Nietzsche wanted to reevaluate values that the Enlightenment did not have in its agenda. [4] Much of Nordau's ideas resembled ideas from Nietzsche's text, namely the enrichment and expansion of European culture. [4]

Over time, Max Nordau began to self reflect on his inauthentic Jewish marginality. [4] He later dropped his Enlightenment ideals since they clashed with those of Zionism, as Zionism was a particularist movement, while The Enlightenment was a universal one. [4] His inauthentic Jewish marginality would then become an authentic one when taking up Zionist thinking. [4] Due to Nietzsche's ideals being synonymous with Zionism, Nietzsche now became more relevant in Nordau's life. [4] As his life progressed, he became closer to Nietzsche's ideology and was even influenced by Nietzsche's essay on history, as were many Zionists. [4]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Zionism</span> Movement supporting a Jewish homeland

Zionism is a nationalist movement that espouses the establishment of, and support for a homeland for the Jewish people centered in the area roughly corresponding to what is known in Jewish tradition as the Land of Israel on the basis of a long Jewish connection and attachment to that land.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Max Nordau</span> Zionist leader, physician, author, and social critic (1849–1923)

Max Simon Nordau was a Zionist leader, physician, author, and social critic.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Martin Buber</span> German-Israeli philosopher (1878–1965)

Martin Buber was an Austrian Jewish and Israeli philosopher best known for his philosophy of dialogue, a form of existentialism centered on the distinction between the I–Thou relationship and the I–It relationship. Born in Vienna, Buber came from a family of observant Jews, but broke with Jewish custom to pursue secular studies in philosophy. He produced writings about Zionism and worked with various bodies within the Zionist movement extensively over a nearly 50 year period spanning his time in Europe and the Near East. In 1923, Buber wrote his famous essay on existence, Ich und Du, and in 1925, he began translating the Hebrew Bible into the German language reflecting the patterns of the Hebrew language.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ahad Ha'am</span> Hebrew essayist and Zionist thinkers

Asher Zvi Hirsch Ginsberg, primarily known by his Hebrew name and pen name Ahad Ha'am, was a Hebrew journalist and essayist, and one of the foremost pre-state Zionist thinkers. He is known as the founder of cultural Zionism. With his vision of a Jewish "spiritual center" in Eretz Israel, his views regarding the purpose of a Jewish state contrasted with those of prominent figures within the Zionist movement such as Theodor Herzl, the founder of political Zionism. Unlike Herzl, Ahad Ha'am strived for "a Jewish state and not merely a state of Jews".

Jewish political movements refer to the organized efforts of Jews to build their own political parties or otherwise represent their interest in politics outside the Jewish community. From the time of the siege of Jerusalem by the Romans to the foundation of Israel the Jewish people had no territory, and, until the 19th century they by-and-large were also denied equal rights in the countries in which they lived. Thus, until the 19th century effort for the emancipation of the Jews, almost all Jewish political struggles were internal, and dealt primarily with either religious issues or issues of a particular Jewish community.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cultural Zionism</span>

Cultural Zionism is a strain in the concept of Zionism that valued creating a centre in historic Palestine with its own secular Jewish culture and history, including language and historical roots, rather than other Zionist ideas such as political Zionism. The man considered to have founded the concept of cultural Zionism is Asher Ginsberg, better known as Ahad Ha'am. With his secular vision of a Jewish "spiritual center" in Israel, he confronted Theodor Herzl. Unlike Herzl, the founder of political Zionism, Ha'am strived for "a Jewish state and not merely a state of Jews".

<i>The Old New Land</i> 1902 novel published by Theodor Herzl

The Old New Land is a utopian novel published in German by Theodor Herzl, the founder of political Zionism, in 1902. It was published six years after Herzl's political pamphlet, Der Judenstaat and expanded on Herzl's vision for a Jewish return to the Land of Israel, which helped Altneuland become one of Zionism's establishing texts. It was translated into Yiddish by Israel Isidor Elyashev, and into Hebrew by Nahum Sokolow as Tel Aviv, a name then adopted for the newly founded city.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jewish Territorial Organization</span> Jewish political movement (1903–1925)

The Jewish Territorial Organisation, known as the ITO, was a Jewish political movement which first arose in 1903 in response to the British Uganda Offer, but which was institutionalized in 1905. Its main goal was to find an alternative territory to that of Palestine, which was preferred by the Zionist movement, for the creation of a Jewish homeland. The organization embraced what became known as Jewish Territorialism also known as Jewish Statism. The ITO was dissolved in 1925.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Theodor Herzl</span> Father of modern political Zionism (1860–1904)

Theodor Herzl was an Austro-Hungarian Jewish journalist and political activist who was the father of modern political Zionism. Herzl formed the Zionist Organization and promoted Jewish immigration to Palestine in an effort to form a Jewish state.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">First Zionist Congress</span> 1897 event in Basil, Switzerland

The First Zionist Congress was the inaugural congress of the Zionist Organization (ZO) held in Basel, from August 29 to August 31, 1897. 208 delegates and 26 press correspondents attended the event. It was convened and chaired by Theodor Herzl, the founder of the modern Zionism movement. The Congress formulated a Zionist platform, known as the Basel program, and founded the Zionist Organization. It also adopted the Hatikvah as its anthem.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Influence and reception of Friedrich Nietzsche</span>

Friedrich Nietzsche's influence and reception varied widely and may be roughly divided into various chronological periods. Reactions were anything but uniform, and proponents of various ideologies attempted to appropriate his work quite early.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Types of Zionism</span> Different approaches to the subject of creating a Jewish homeland

The principal common goal of Zionism was to establish a homeland for the Jewish people. Zionism was produced by various philosophers representing different approaches concerning the objective and path that Zionism should follow.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">William Hechler</span>

William Henry Hechler was an English Restorationist Anglican clergyman; eschatological writer; crusader against antisemitism; promoter of Zionism; and aide, counselor, friend and legitimiser of Theodor Herzl, the founder of modern Zionism.

<i>Ost und West</i> German magazine (1901–1923

Ost und West was a German magazine meant to bridge cultural and political divides between Eastern and Western European Jews. The magazine, headquartered in Berlin, operated from 1901 to 1923. It was founded by Leo Winz and David Trietsch.

Labor Zionism or socialist Zionism refers to the left-wing, socialist variation of Zionism. For many years, it was the most significant tendency among Zionists and Zionist organizations, and was seen as the Zionist sector of the historic Jewish labor movements of Eastern Europe and Central Europe, eventually developing local units in most countries with sizable Jewish populations. Unlike the "political Zionist" tendency founded by Theodor Herzl and advocated by Chaim Weizmann, Labor Zionists did not believe that a Jewish state would be created by simply appealing to the international community or to powerful nations such as the United Kingdom, Germany, or the former Ottoman Empire. Rather, they believed that a Jewish state could only be created through the efforts of the Jewish working class making aliyah to the Land of Israel and raising a country through the creation of a Labor Jewish society with rural kibbutzim and moshavim, and an urban Jewish Proletariat.

<i>Die Welt</i> (Herzl) Zionist newspaper, founded by Theodor Herzl

Die Welt was a weekly newspaper founded by Theodor Herzl in May 1897 in Vienna. It was designed to promote Zionism and boldly proclaimed itself to be a Judenblatt (Jew-paper). From 1897 to 1914 it was the principal organ of the Zionist movement. From 1897 to 1900, the paper was edited by Erwin Rosenberger.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Second Zionist Congress</span>

The Second World Zionist Congress met in Basel, Switzerland on 28 August 1898. and was the second meeting of the Zionist Organisation. The World Zionist Congress brought together delegates from across the world to raise funds, lobby support and create the institutions that would one day form the modern day Jewish State known as Israel, which was established in 1948. The Congress met every year from 1897 to 1901. The main focus of the Second Congress, as set out by its chair, Theodor Herzl, was to engage with Jewish communities in the diaspora and encourage them to adopt Political Zionism.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sixth Zionist Congress</span> World Zionist Congress

The Sixth Zionist Congress was held in Basel, opening on August 23, 1903. Theodor Herzl caused great division amongst the delegates when he presented the "Uganda Scheme", a proposed Jewish colony in what is now part of Kenya. Herzl died the following year.

Zionist antisemitism is the phenomenon in which individuals, groups, or governments support the Zionist movement and the State of Israel while simultaneously holding antisemitic views about Jews. In some cases, Zionism may be promoted for explicitly antisemitic reasons. The prevalence of antisemitism has been widely noted within the Christian Zionist movement, whose adherents may hold antisemitic and supersessionist beliefs about Jews while also supporting Zionism for eschatological reasons. Antisemitic right-wing nationalists, particularly in Europe and the United States, sometimes support the Zionist movement because they wish for Jews to be expelled, or for Jews to emigrate to Israel, or because they view Israel as a supremacist ethnno-state to be admired and held up as a model for their own countries.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Herzl's Mauschel and Zionist antisemitism</span>

Herzl's Mauschel and Zionist antisemitism refers to a virulently anti-Semitic diatribe or screed entitled Mauschel ("Kike/Sheeny/Yid/Ikey") and its place within early Zionist discourse. It was penned by Theodor Herzl and published in 1897, a little over a month after the conclusion of the First Zionist Congress. The text appeared in his newspaper Die Welt, which was to become the principal outlet for the Zionist movement down to 1914. It is often taken, since its publication, to be emblematic of an antisemitic strain of thinking in Zionism.

References

  1. 1 2 Aschheim, Steven E. (1992). The Nietzsche Legacy in Germany 1890-1990. University of California Press. p.  102. ISBN   978-0-520-07805-5.
  2. Katz, Steven T. (1992). Historicism, the Holocaust, and Zionism. NYU Press. pp. 289–299.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 Golomb, Jacob (2004). ""Thus Spoke Herzl": Nietzsche's Presence in Theodor Herzl's Life and Work". Nietzsche and Zion. Ithaca; London: Cornell University Press. pp. 23–45. JSTOR   10.7591/j.ctv5qdjn7.6.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 Golomb, Jacob (2004). Nietzsche and Zion. Cornell University Press. pp. 46–64, 159–188.
  5. "Theodor Herzl". The Herzl Institute. Retrieved 12 November 2018.
  6. Mendes-Flohr, Paul (2001). "Zarathustra as a Prophet of Jewish Renewal: Nietzsche and the Young Martin Buber". Revista Portugesa de Filosofia. 57: 103–111 via JSTOR.
  7. Aschheim, Steven E. (1992). The Nietzsche Legacy in Germany 1890-1990. University of California Press. p.  105. ISBN   978-0-520-07805-5.
  8. Aschheim, Steven E. (1992). The Nietzsche Legacy in Germany 1890-1990. University of California Press. p.  107. ISBN   978-0-520-07805-5.
  9. Aschheim, Steven E. (1992). The Nietzsche Legacy in Germany 1890-1990. University of California Press. p.  103. ISBN   978-0-520-07805-5.
  10. 1 2 Reinharz, Jehuda (1983). "The Shaping of a Zionist Leader Before the First World War". Journal of Contemporary History. 18: 205–231 via JSTOR.
  11. "Zionism and Israel - Max Nordau Biography". www.zionism-israel.com. Retrieved 2018-11-18.