Sita Air Flight 601 (ST601/STA601) was a Nepalese domestic passenger flight, operated by Sita Air from Tribhuvan International Airport in Nepal's capital Kathmandu to Tenzing-Hillary Airport in Lukla. On 28 September 2012, the Dornier 228 serving the route crashed while attempting an emergency landing at Kathmandu shortly after takeoff, killing all 19 people on board.
The final report, published by the Nepal's Aircraft Accident Investigation Commission (NAICC), determined that a thrust reduction occurred during the take-off roll, but the cause of the anomaly could not be determined. Subsequent crew inability to maintain speed above stall speed, followed by the insufficient height of the aircraft, led to the aircraft crashing.
Accident
Flight 601 took off from Tribhuvan International Airport at 06:17 local time. It was the first flight to depart from Tribhuvan International Airport that day. While at an altitude of 50 feet (15m), the pilot reported technical issues with the aircraft, and requested to fly back to the airport.[1] Flight crews reported to Kathmandu that the aircraft[2][3] may have hit a vulture.[4] This was noticed by Kathmandu's air traffic controller, as the aircraft began to sway and do unusual manoeuvres. Three minutes after take-off, on the way back to the airport, the aircraft descended near Manohara River. It then nose-dived, narrowly missed a slum and crashed on the banks of the Manohara River and caught fire. The front part of the fuselage was completely destroyed.[1]
Immediately after the crash, Tribhuvan Airport's fire brigade were quickly deployed. Dozens of army personnel and rescue personnel rushed to the scene of the crash, though some reports said the fire brigade took more than half-an hour. Eyewitnesses stated that several people survived the crash and were screaming for help inside the burning wreckage. Local residents wanted to help, but were afraid that if they directed water onto the engine it might explode. When emergency services arrived at the crash site, most parts of the plane were completely destroyed. All 19 people on board perished in the accident.[4]
Aircraft
9N-AHA at Lukla Airport in 2011
The aircraft involved in the accident was a twin turboprop Dornier 228-202, registration 9N-AHA, serial number 8123. Before it was sold to Sita Air,[5] it was acquired by Holiday Express in 1987. It later entered the Australian registration of VH-NSH and then the American registration of N2255E for G M Hock Construction. It was sold to Executive World Airways as F-ODZG and in 1990 it was sold to Air Caraïbes.[6]
Passengers and crew
Most of the passengers were foreigners, travelling to Lukla for trekking in the Himalaya. The British Embassy in Nepal confirmed that at least 7 Britons were on the flight. The youngest British victim was 27 whilst the oldest was 60. At least 5 Chinese nationals and 7 Nepalis were on board the flight.[7][8][9][10][11]
Nationality
Fatalities
Total
Passengers
Crew
Nepal
4
3
7
China
5
0
5
United Kingdom
7
0
7
Total
16
3
19
Investigation
The Nepal Civil Aviation Authority was ordered to investigate the crash with assistance from the British Air Accidents Investigation Branch. Investigators started to collect evidence related to the crash. Both the flight data recorder and the cockpit voice recorder were recovered. During its takeoff roll, the weather in Tribhuvan was in good condition with good visibility. Based on interviews by eyewitnesses, the aircraft was on fire while it was crashing to the ground.[1]
A relative of Flight 601's co-pilot said he had warned that flights on the airline were routinely overloaded and that a nearby slum attracted birds to the runway. However, Sagar Acharya, the airline's head of flight safety, denied the aircraft was carrying too much weight. Most reports stated that the aircraft suffered a bird strike shortly after taking off from Tribhuvan. Conflicting reports stated that it had struck a black eagle, while others stated that it had hit a vulture. This bird strike report was confirmed by the air traffic controller on duty, as the air traffic controller stated that the pilot contacted Tribhuvan's Tower for an intention for emergency landing due to "technical glitches", possibly due to a bird strike. Based on the ATC statements, the right engine of Flight 601 might have been hit by a bird and caught fire. Investigators later focused on the bird strike theory.[1]
Investigators later stated that the impact of the bird strike might have caused the pilot to become nervous. The aircraft later caught fire, and in an attempt to douse the fire, the pilot attempted an emergency landing on Manohara river, but somehow nose-dived and crashed onto the football ground.[12]
Based on preliminary report published on 30 September 2012, the bird collided with the right hand engine at about 50 feet above ground causing some part to separate from the engine. The part later impacted the vertical tail and disabled the rudder, severing the controls of the plane. The plane then began to turn sharply. It then went out of control and subsequently crashed.
Investigators inspected the CCTV footage of the crash, and noticed that a flash had occurred on the right engine of Flight 601, approximately 5 seconds before rotation. An eyewitness, a professional pilot, reported that he noticed that the aircraft had an unsuccessful attempt to lift the aircraft. The nose did lift up however with the tail of the plane nearly struck the ground. The NAAIC then found that the crew called "V1" prematurely, thus the aircraft couldn't get airborne. The NAAIC then reported that the aircraft was not able to maintain 77 KIAS in level flight suggesting that one engine had failed and the other had suffered a power loss of at least 13%.[13] An analysis later was made by the NAAIC:[14][additional citation(s) needed]
"It is possible that the bird momentarily disturbed the air flow into the engine before it was struck by the propeller, causing a surge and the suspected flame seen in the CCTV footage, but the engine manufacturer considered this unlikely. The manufacturer considered that if the bird had been sufficiently close to the air intake to disturb the air flow it would have been sucked in. If the flame seen in the CCTV and accompanying 'bang' heard on the CVR were evidence of an engine surge, then another possible cause is a fuel flow problem. However, the manufacturer also commented that this type of engine was very resistant to surge."
Later investigation found that the propellers of Flight 601 were not on feathered position and were operating normally. The investigation revealed that the engine had not lost all power but was operating at low power. Thrust levers in the cockpit was also revealed that there were no engines that had been shut down by the crew during the incident. No bird remains were found inside the engines. However, there was evidence that the black kite had been struck by the propellers.[13]
According to the load sheet of Flight 601, the flight took off with a takeoff mass of 5,834 kilograms (12,862lb) and an estimated landing mass of 5,698 kilograms (12,562lb). The load sheet indicated that no luggage had been loaded, surveillance videos however showed luggage of about 80 kilograms (180lb) was loaded and not removed before the aircraft departed the stand. Thus the takeoff weight was corrected to 5,914 kilograms (13,038lb) while using Nepal's standard weights for passengers, thus the aircraft was overloaded. However, overloading alone can not explain the performance problem, as further analysis revealed that a grossly overloaded aircraft would have had a better performance than 9N-AHA during the accident flight.[13]
Sound analysis of the cockpit voice recorder and flight data recordings revealed that the drag produced by the propeller exceeded the thrust produced. The investigation later stated: "The drag on an engine at flight idle is greater than the drag on an inoperative engine (OEI), and in the case of 9N-AHA where the flight idle fuel flow was incorrectly set too low, the drag would have been even greater at idle (in excess of 350 kilograms (770lb) of drag – reference section 1.16.2). It is therefore possible that at about 6,200 kilograms (13,700lb) with one engine at 100% power and one engine at flight idle, there would have been insufficient thrust to maintain 77 kt, and the additional drag on one side would have affected controllability more than in the OEI case"[13]
Investigators stated that the power loss occurred at 70 KIAS, while V1 was at 83 KIAS. When a power loss occurred below V1, the crew should have rejected the take off. The crew seemed to not be aware of the power loss. The aircraft continued to accelerate, though at a lower rate than during previous takeoffs, became airborne at 86 KIAS above V2 and continued to accelerate for about 2 seconds, at which point the speed began to continuously decay. NAAIC stated that the crew possibly didn't recognize the power loss because it occurred gradually and progressively rather than instantaneously.[13]
If an aircraft malfunction occurred on takeoff or above V1, the airport allows flight crews to continue the takeoff or land back on the runway should it be long enough to safely bring the aircraft to a stop. A long runway was available during the incident, which should have been sufficient to bring the aircraft to a halt. However, the crew opted to not choose this option and continued their flight. The investigation stated that the crew were likely opted not to land back to the airport because of company policy to continue their flight for an engine malfunction at or above V1.[13]
"No faults were found with either of the engines, there was no evidence of a bird ingestion into the engine. Both engines were producing low power at impact, both propellers were in their normal operating range. However, an insidious power reduction occurred starting at 70 KIAS which went unnoticed by the crew. Following lift off the pitch attitude was set too high for the aircraft to maintain V2, the aircraft's speed fell below V2 requiring more thrust than available to accelerate again. The investigation was unable to determine the cause of the thrust reduction."
Nepal Airlines Corporation, formerly known as Royal Nepal Airlines, is the flag carrier of Nepal. Founded in 1958, it is the oldest airline of the country. Out of its main base at Tribhuvan International Airport, Kathmandu, the airline operates domestic services within Nepal and medium-haul services in Asia. The airline's first aircraft was a Douglas DC-3, used to serve domestic routes and a handful of destinations in India. The airline acquired its first jet aircraft, Boeing 727s, in 1972. As of February 2023, the airline operates a fleet of six aircraft. Since 2013, the airline has been on the list of air carriers banned in the European Union.
Yeti Airlines Pvt. Ltd. is an airline based in Kathmandu, Nepal. The airline was established in May 1998 and received its air operator's certificate on 17 August 1998. Since 2019, Yeti Airlines is the first carbon neutral airline in Nepal and South Asia. It is the parent company of Tara Air. As of 2022, Yeti Airlines was the second-largest domestic carrier in Nepal, after Buddha Air.
Buddha Air Pvt. Ltd is an airline based in Jawalakhel, Lalitpur, Nepal, near Patan. It operates domestic as well as international services within Nepal and India, serving mainly large towns and cities in Nepal. It operates 33 routes to 14 destinations in Nepal and to Varanasi, India. Its main base is Tribhuvan International Airport, Kathmandu. It was the largest domestic carrier in terms of passengers carried in 2023.
Tribhuvan International Airport is an international airport located in Kathmandu, Bagmati, Nepal. It has a tabletop runway, a domestic terminal and an international terminal. As a main international airport, it connects Nepal to over 40 destinations in 17 countries.
Pokhara Airport is a domestic airport serving Pokhara in Nepal. Pokhara Airport will be gradually replaced by Nepal's third international airport, Pokhara International Airport, in 2023. While most operations were transferred to the new airport on 1 January 2023, the STOL-operations to Jomsom are still operated from this airport.
Tenzing-Hillary Airport, also known as Lukla Airport, is a domestic airport and altiport in the town of Lukla, in Khumbu Pasanglhamu, Solukhumbu District, Koshi Province of Nepal. It gained worldwide fame as it was rated the most dangerous airport in the world for more than 20 years by a program titled Most Extreme Airports, broadcast on The History Channel in 2010.
Sita Air is an airline based in Kathmandu, Nepal, operating domestic services within Nepal. The airline was established in 2003. The airline's main base is Tribhuvan International Airport with hubs at Pokhara Airport and Nepalgunj Airport.
Jomsom Airport is a domestic airport located in Jomsom serving Mustang District, a district in Gandaki Province in Nepal. It serves as the gateway to Mustang District that includes Jomsom, Kagbeni, Tangbe, and Lo Manthang, and Muktinath temple, which is a popular pilgrimage for Nepalis and Indian pilgrims.
Yeti Airlines Flight 101 was a domestic flight in Nepal, that crashed on final approach to Tenzing-Hillary Airport in the town of Lukla in eastern Nepal on 8 October 2008. The De Havilland Canada DHC-6 Twin Otter Series 300 registered as 9N-AFE originated from Tribhuvan International Airport in Kathmandu.
Ramechhap Airport is a domestic airport serving the municipality of Manthali, the district headquarters of Ramechhap District located in the Tamakoshi River valley in Bagmati Province in Nepal. As of October 2022, most flights to Lukla Airport are operated from Ramechhap Airport.
Agni Air Flight 101 was a regional flight between Kathmandu and Lukla, Nepal, that crashed on 24 August 2010, killing all 14 people on board. Twenty minutes after take-off, the flight crew had reported a technical problem. Contact with the aircraft was lost shortly after. The aircraft crashed 50 miles (80 km) south of Kathmandu.
Tara Air Pvt. Ltd. is an airline headquartered in Kathmandu, Nepal. It is a subsidiary of Yeti Airlines. Tara Air was formed in 2009 using aircraft from the Yeti Airlines fleet and is based at Tribhuvan International Airport, with a secondary hub at Nepalgunj Airport. The airline operates scheduled flights and air charter services with a fleet of STOL aircraft, previously provided by Yeti Airlines. Its operations focus on serving remote and mountainous airports and airstrips.
Summit Air, formerly known as Goma Air, is an airline based in Kathmandu, Nepal. The airline operates from short takeoff and landing airstrips in the Western parts of Nepal. The airline received the first of two Let 410 aircraft, financed by the Czech Republic Export Bank., in October 2014, and initially only used them on flights to Lukla and Jomsom.
Centurion Air Cargo Flight 164 was a chartered international cargo flight, flying from Bogota's El Dorado International Airport while en route to Miami International Airport. The flight was operated by Kalitta Air and the aircraft was wet leased by Centurion Air Cargo. On 7 July 2008, the aircraft, a Boeing 747-209BSF registered as N714CK, crashed shortly after takeoff. All aboard suffered injuries, but none were killed. Two people on the ground were killed after the plane slammed into a farm. The crash was the second crash of a Boeing 747 in 2008 in Kalitta Air service, after a previous accident at Brussels in May.
US-Bangla Airlines Flight 211 was a scheduled international passenger flight from Shahjalal International Airport in Dhaka, Bangladesh, to Tribhuvan International Airport in Kathmandu, Nepal, that crashed on 12 March 2018 while landing, killing 51 of the 71 people aboard. The aircraft, a 76-seat Bombardier Q400 operated by US-Bangla Airlines, burst into flames after the crash. The 20 surviving passengers were seriously injured from the impact and the fire. At the time of the accident, it was the deadliest aviation disaster involving a Bangladeshi airline, and the deadliest incident involving the Bombardier Dash 8 Q400.
Olympic Airways Flight 411 was a flight from Ellinikon International Airport bound for John F. Kennedy International Airport and operated by Olympic Airways using a Boeing 747-200. On August 9, 1978, the flight came close to crashing in downtown Athens. Despite maneuvers near the edge of the flight envelope, none of the 418 passengers and crew suffered serious injury.
On 31 July 1993, a Dornier 228 passenger turboprop operated by Nepalese airline Everest Air crashed in Tanahun District near Chule Ghopte hill, Nepal. The crash killed all of the 19 passengers and crew on board.
Kalitta Air Flight 207 (K4207/CKS207) was a scheduled cargo flight between John F. Kennedy Airport to Bahrain International Airport with a technical stopover at Brussels. On May 25, 2008, the Boeing 747-200 overran Runway 20 during takeoff at Brussels Airport, causing the aircraft to split into 3 main pieces. The occupants sustained minor injuries.
Lufthansa Cargo Flight 8533 was a scheduled cargo flight from Tribhuvan International Airport in Nepal to Indira Gandhi International Airport in India operated by Lufthansa Cargo's Indian subsidiary Hinduja Cargo Services. On 7 July 1999, the Boeing 727 operating the flight impacted Champadevi hills at 7,500 feet, 15 kilometres and crashed with no survivors amongst the 5 occupants on board.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply. Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.
