Tilly Norwood

Last updated

AI-generated character Tilly Norwood Tilly Norwood.jpg
AI-generated character Tilly Norwood

Tilly Norwood is an artificial intelligence (AI)-generated character created in 2025 by Xicoia, the AI division of the production company Particle6 Group. Norwood's debut work, "AI Commissioner", was criticised by reviewers for The Guardian, PC Gamer, and The A.V. Club. An announcement at the September 2025 Zurich Film Festival that Norwood was about to be signed by a talent agency attracted strong criticism from Hollywood actors and firms, prompted allegations of personality rights violations, and led to arguments over the impact of the character on production costs in the media industry.

Contents

History

Norwood was created by Xicoia, the AI division of Particle6, a production company founded by Dutch actress-turned-producer Eline Van der Velden in 2015. [1] An Instagram account under Norwood's name, with posts dating back to the 6th of May 2025, [2] had gained 50,000 followers by October 3 [3] and featured AI-generated modelling shots, selfies, and epic film scenes. [4] Van der Velden stated in July 2025 that she intended Norwood to be the next Scarlett Johansson or Natalie Portman [5] and later that audiences were more interested in a film's story than whether its actors were real. [6] Particle6 has stated that using Norwood could cut production costs by 90%. [7]

The "AI Commissioner" comedy sketch

On 30 July 2025, a film named "AI Commissioner" featuring and crediting Norwood as an actress [8] was released, a comedy sketch created with ten AI software tools and written by ChatGPT. [9] "AI Commissioner" featured 16 AI-generated characters in all. [10] Writing in September 2025, Stuart Heritage of The Guardian described it as technically competent but "relentlessly unfunny to watch," with "sloppily written, woodenly delivered dialogue", [11] and that Norwood's teeth kept "blurring into a single white block." [11] Joshua Wolens of PC Gamer wrote that Norwood's exaggerated mouth movements gave the impression "that her skeleton was about to leave her body," [12] while William Hughes of The A.V. Club wrote that the sketch's attempt at mimicking human body and mouth movements produced "such a hideous uncanny valley effect" that it gave them "a full-on case of the screaming fantods". [13] By October 2, the sketch had been viewed more than 700,000 times on YouTube. [14]

Eline van der Velden Eline van der Velden.jpg
Eline van der Velden

By September, videos had been released depicting Norwood on a red carpet, crying on the sofa of The Graham Norton Show, and starring in mock trailers for sci-fi, fantasy, horror, and action films. [7] Xicoia was officially announced on 27 September 2025, at the Zurich Summit, part of the Zurich Film Festival; [15] [16] there, van der Velden presented on Norwood and later joined a panel with Verena Puhm, head of Luma AI's Studio Dream Lab LA. They suggested that media companies were quietly embracing AI and that public announcements of AI-generated works were imminent. Van der Velden claimed that studios had dropped their objections by May after being opposed in February, and that multiple talent agencies were considering representing Norwood. [16] The latter claim was printed as fact by Deadline Hollywood under the headline "Talent Agents Circle AI Actress Tilly Norwood", causing massive controversy. [17]

Reactions

Reception

Actresses Melissa Barrera, Kiersey Clemons, and Natasha Lyonne suggested boycotting any agency who signed Norwood, [18] [19] while Mara Wilson asked why none of the "hundreds of living young women" who went into Norwood could be hired instead [20] and Bronson Pinchot worried that Norwood could take his job. [21] Emily Blunt described Norwood as "really, really scary", [19] while Sophie Turner, Toni Collette, Ralph Ineson, and Ariel Winter also expressed disapproval [2] [18] [22] and Lukas Gage, Odessa A'zion, and Trace Lysette joked that Norwood was incompetent and unpleasant to work with. [18] Jenelle Riley, Nicholas Alexander Chavez, and the American union SAG-AFTRA have stated that they did not consider Norwood an actress [23] [18] [24] and The Gersh Agency and WME both announced that they would not sign Norwood. [17] Whoopi Goldberg and Charlie Fink expressed scepticism that AI could replace jobs. [24] [25] A post on Deadline Hollywood 's Instagram account about Norwood also sparked varying levels of criticism from Adelaide Kane, Eiza González, Katie Cassidy, Jewel Staite, Lucy Hale, and Stephen Sean Ford. [26]

Following this criticism, Van der Velden released a statement in which she stated that Norwood was "not a replacement for a human being, but a creative work." [15] Moises Mendez II of Out dismissed this "vapid bullshit", arguing that "Nobody wants AI actresses." [27] The British union Equity and the Canadian union ACTRA also condemned Norwood. [28]

Commentary

Charles Pulliam-Moore of The Verge argued that Norwood's introduction was a stunt to normalize "AI actors" despite Norwood essentially being a digital puppet. [29] Christopher Zara of Fast Company wrote that Norwood's Wikipedia talk page featured passionate arguments about whether to describe Norwood as an actress, or even to use the pronoun she , which he said offered "a fascinating window into the semantic debates that our society is facing more broadly" as a result of spending increasing amounts of screen time with anthropomorphic AI-generated objects. [4]

Straight Arrow News compared Tilly Norwood to Aki Ross, a CGI character from 2001 that was similarly intended to become a "digital star" and appear in multiple films, [30] while The Conversation likened her to the posthumous use of footage of Carrie Fisher for Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker in 2019 [31] and the Los Angeles Times likened Norwood to Hatsune Miku. [32] Scottish actress Briony Monroe alleged that her likeness and mannerisms had gone into Norwood, and stated that she was consulting Equity regarding the matter. [33] Indie musician Stella Hennen said that Norwood was her "doppleganger" in a viral TikTok video that featured a side-by-side comparison of Hennen and Norwood. [34]

The University of Southern California's Entertainment Technology Center's AI media director Yves Bergquist dismissed the idea of AI actors, on the grounds that there were no successful AI musicians, [35] though Fiona Sturges of The Independent pointed out that Velvet Sundown had amassed a million plays on Spotify before they were revealed as AI-generated. [36] Both Sturges and The Herald 's Derek McArthur pointed out that Norwood was cheaper than Hollywood actors, [37] though Jessica Karl of Bloomberg News pointed out that AI was expensive to generate. [38]

References

  1. Lodderhose, Diana (25 September 2025). "Eline Van Der Velden, Founder Of AI Indie Particle6, Launches AI Talent Studio Xicoia For "Hyperreal Digital Stars"". Deadline. Retrieved 30 September 2025.
  2. 1 2 "Meet Tilly Norwood, the AI 'Actress' Drawing Backlash from Emily Blunt, Whoopi Goldberg and the Screen Actors Guild". People.com. Retrieved 30 September 2025.
  3. "And the Oscar goes to Tilly Norwood? AI's leading lady spooks Hollywood". www.thetimes.com. 3 October 2025. Retrieved 3 October 2025.
  4. 1 2 "Tilly Norwood already has a Wikipedia page, and not even the editors are sure what to call it". Fast Company . Retrieved 2 October 2025.
  5. Middleton, Richard (30 July 2025). "How a UK prodco is building the first AI star". Broadcast International . Retrieved 30 September 2025.
  6. Barraclough, Leo (28 September 2025). "AI Actress Tilly Norwood Debuts at Zurich Summit as Industry Grapples With Emerging Tech: We Want Her 'to Be the Next Scarlett Johansson'". Variety . Retrieved 30 September 2025.
  7. 1 2 "'Hollywood is desperate to hire my AI actress'". www.telegraph.co.uk. Retrieved 30 September 2025.
  8. Kaufman, Anna. "AI actor Tilly Norwood looks startlingly real. Hollywood is not amused". USA TODAY. Retrieved 2 October 2025.
  9. Zahn, Jennifer (29 September 2025). "AI Actress Tilly Norwood and the Backlash, Explained". Vulture . Retrieved 30 September 2025.
  10. Gorman, Steve; Broadway, Danielle; Chmielewski, Dawn; Broadway, Danielle (1 October 2025). "Hollywood performers union condemns AI-generated 'actress' Tilly Norwood". Reuters. Retrieved 1 October 2025.
  11. 1 2 Heritage, Stuart (30 September 2025). "Tilly Norwood: how scared should we be of the viral AI 'actor'?". The Guardian. ISSN   0261-3077 . Retrieved 30 September 2025.
  12. Joshua Wolens (29 September 2025). "The AI industry's latest curse on humanity is a fake 'actress' it wants to turn into 'the next Scarlett Johansson'". PC Gamer. Retrieved 30 September 2025.
  13. "This latest "AI actress" sales pitch is giving us a serious headache". AV Club. Retrieved 2 October 2025.
  14. Darley, James (2 October 2025). "What the AI Actor Tilly Norwood Means for the Future of Film". aimagazine.com. Retrieved 2 October 2025.
  15. 1 2 Seibold, Witney (29 September 2025). "Who Is Tilly Norwood? Hollywood's Controversial AI-Generated Actress Explained". /Film . Retrieved 30 September 2025.
  16. 1 2 Goodfellow, Melanie (27 September 2025). "Talent Agents Circle AI Actress Tilly Norwood As Studios Quietly Embrace AI Technology – Zurich Summit". Deadline . Retrieved 30 September 2025.
  17. 1 2 Quah, Nicholas (2 October 2025). "The Real Stakes Behind a Synthetic Star". Vulture. Retrieved 4 October 2025.
  18. 1 2 3 4 Garner, Glenn (28 September 2025). "Melissa Barrera, Lukas Gage & More React To AI Actress Tilly Norwood As Some Suggest Agency Boycott: "Read The Room"". Deadline. Retrieved 1 October 2025.
  19. 1 2 Pulver, Andrew (30 September 2025). "Emily Blunt and Sag-Aftra join film industry condemnation of 'AI actor' Tilly Norwood". The Guardian. ISSN   0261-3077 . Retrieved 1 October 2025.
  20. Ritman, Alex (29 September 2025). "AI Actress Tilly Norwood Draws Backlash From Melissa Barrera, Lukas Gage and More Hollywood Names as Creator Defends Her as a 'New Tool' and 'Not a Replacement for a Human Being'". Variety. Retrieved 1 October 2025.
  21. "Tilly Norwood, you give actor Bronson Pinchot the creeps!". Los Angeles Times. 3 October 2025. Retrieved 3 October 2025.
  22. "Emily Blunt, SAG Slam 'AI Actress' Tilly Norwood After Claims It's Seeking Representation". Toofab. Retrieved 1 October 2025.
  23. Riley, Jenelle (29 September 2025). "AI Creation Tilly Norwood Isn't an 'Actress' — So Don't Call Her That". Variety. Retrieved 1 October 2025.
  24. 1 2 "Hollywood celebrities outraged over new 'AI actor' Tilly Norwood". BBC News. 30 September 2025. Retrieved 1 October 2025.
  25. Cunningham, Kyndall (4 October 2025). "The AI-generated actress that has Hollywood panicking". Vox. Retrieved 4 October 2025.
  26. "What's All This Noise About an AI Actress?". Esquire. 1 October 2025. Retrieved 3 October 2025.
  27. "Tilly Norwood is no actor—she's an AI harbinger of doom". www.out.com. Retrieved 3 October 2025.
  28. Bryant, Jacob (2 October 2025). "AI Actress Tilly Norwood Rejected by More Acting Unions as 'Nothing but Lines of Code'". TheWrap. Retrieved 2 October 2025.
  29. Pulliam-Moore, Charles (4 October 2025). "Tilly Norwood is a gen AI psyop". The Verge. Retrieved 5 October 2025.
  30. Felton, Kennedy (29 September 2025). "AI actress Tilly Norwood may become first to sign with a talent agency". Straight Arrow News. Retrieved 3 October 2025.
  31. Scrivens, Nicholas (3 October 2025). "'AI actor' Tilly Norwood is dividing Hollywood – but real acting requires humanity". The Conversation. Retrieved 3 October 2025.
  32. "Fake actor deepens anxiety over AI in Hollywood". Los Angeles Times. 2 October 2025. Retrieved 3 October 2025.
  33. "Meet Tilly Norwood, the AI-generated actress facing backlash in Hollywood". ITV . Retrieved 3 October 2025.
  34. Lindsay, Kate (2 October 2025). "The Controversial A.I. Actress Looks Exactly Like Me. I'm Horrified". Slate. Retrieved 4 October 2025.
  35. "Tilly Norwood, fully AI 'actor,' blasted by actors union SAG-AFTRA for 'devaluing human artistry'". NBC News. 30 September 2025. Retrieved 1 October 2025.
  36. "'AI actor' Tilly Norwood is an anti-art abomination – and a studio executive's dream". The Independent. 2 October 2025. Retrieved 2 October 2025.
  37. "The next Scarlett Johansson has a slight problem, she doesn't actually exist". The Herald. 2 October 2025. Retrieved 2 October 2025.
  38. "Tilly Norwood Is Expensive, Even for Hollywood". Bloomberg News . Retrieved 3 October 2025.