Universal basic income in the Netherlands

Last updated

The issue of the universal basic income gained prominence on the political agenda in Netherlands between the mid-1970s and mid-1990s [1] [2] but it has disappeared from the political agenda over the last fifteen years.

Contents

History

Femke Halsema in 2010 Femke Halsema twist.jpg
Femke Halsema in 2010

The political discussion on basic income was initiated in 1975 by Leo Jansen, an MP for the progressive Christian Political Party of Radicals (PPR) and Vrije Universiteit professor J. P. Kuiper. In 1977 the issue had been incorporated in the election manifestos of the PPR. The idea was also endorsed by several smaller trade unions of the Federation of Dutch Labour Unions. [2]

In 1985, the Scientific Council for Government Policy, an independent think tank of the Dutch government, endorsed a partial basic income. [3] However, the council's proposals were never acted upon. The PPR and the trade unions which favoured the basic income rejected the Council's proposals because the proposed basic income would be too low and implementation would be accompanied by abolition of the minimum wage. [2] The proposal of the Scientific Council broadened, however, the debate and the issue is debated upon in the social-democratic Labour Party, the conservative liberal People's Party for Freedom and Democracy and the progressive liberal Democrats 66, but these parties did not adopt the basic income in their programs. In 1989 the PPR merged into the GreenLeft, with the Pacifist Socialist Party (PSP), the Communist Party of the Netherlands (CPN) and the Evangelical People's Party. In early 1990s the GreenLeft was ambiguous to the idea of a basic income, not endorsing it in its 1989 election manifesto, [2] but debating the issue in several publications. [4]

In 1992 the debate is re-opened by the Bureau for Economic Policy Analysis, an economic advisory body of the government, which like the Scientific Council endorsed a low basic income as part of simplified social security system. By 1995 the basic income was a prominent issue on the Dutch political agenda. The issue continued to be debated by political parties; the Labour Party debated the issue in its 1994 election manifesto but still rejected it. [5] The GreenLeft, however, endorsed a negative income tax in its 1994 election manifesto, which in the long term could be made into a basic income, according to the party. [6] In 1994 D66 minister Hans Wijers publicly favoured the basic income, leading to negative reactions by his colleagues in cabinet. [2] D66 endorsed his position in 1995, [7] but did not incorporate it in its 1998 election manifesto. [8]

After the success of the first cabinet-Kok to implement its agenda of "work, work, work" and increase the levels of employment the debate about the basic income lost attention and momentum. A welfare state policy oriented at the activation of the unemployed became accepted by nearly all parties. [9]

In 2006, Femke Halsema, leader of the GreenLeft, endorsed a partial basic income [10] and her ideas were taken over in the party's 2006 election manifesto. [11]

Academic background

A prominent Dutch academic in the academic debate on the basic income is Robert Jan van der Veen  [ nl ], who also participated in the September group of Philippe van Parijs. [2] [12] [13]

See also

Related Research Articles

GroenLinks is a green political party in the Netherlands. It was formed on 1 March 1989 from the merger of four left-wing parties: the Communist Party of the Netherlands, the Pacifist Socialist Party, the Political Party of Radicals and the Evangelical People's Party, which shared left-wing and progressive ideals and earlier co-operated in Regenboog-coalition for the 1989 European Parliament election.

The Greens (Netherlands) Political party in the Netherlands

The Greens is a political party in the Netherlands. It advocates for Green politics, an unconditional basic income and emphasises its anti-militarism.

Femke Halsema Dutch former political leader of GroenLinks and mayor of Amsterdam

Femke Halsema is a Dutch politician and filmmaker. On 27 June 2018, she was appointed Mayor of Amsterdam and began serving a six-year term on 12 July 2018. She is the first woman to hold the position on a non-interim basis. She previously was a member of the House of Representatives for the leftist green party GroenLinks from 1998 to 2011, and served as the party's parliamentary leader from 2002 to 2010.

Political Party of Radicals Political party in Netherlands

The Political Party of Radicals was a progressive Christian and green political party in the Netherlands. The PPR played a relatively small role in Dutch politics and merged with other left-wing parties to form GreenLeft in 1991.

Flemish Diamond

The Flemish Diamond is the Flemish reference to a network of four metropolitan areas in Belgium, three of which are in the central provinces of Flanders, together with the Brussels Capital Region. It consists of four agglomerations which form the four corners of an abstract diamond shape: Brussels, Ghent, Antwerp and Leuven. Over five million people live in this area, with a population density of about 600 per square kilometre in 2002.

Roel van Duijn

Roeland Hugo Gerrit (Roel) van Duijn is a Dutch politician, political activist and writer. He was a founder of Provo and the Kabouterbeweging. He was alderman for the Political Party of Radicals and later wardcouncillor for the GreenLeft.

Paul Rosenmöller

Paul Rosenmöller is a Dutch television presenter, politician, and former trade unionist. Between 1989 and 2003, he was member of the Dutch House of Representatives for GroenLinks ('GreenLeft') and was party leader from 1994. Since June 2019 he is a member of the Senate for GroenLinks.

Jolande Sap Dutch politician

Johanna Catharina Maria "Jolande" Sap is a former Dutch politician and former educator and civil servant. A member of GroenLinks (GL), she replaced Wijnand Duyvendak as a member of the House of Representatives on 3 September 2008, after his resignation. She had temporarily been replacing Mariko Peters from the previous day who was on parental leave. From 16 December 2010 to 5 October 2012 she was party leader as well as parliamentary leader in the House of Representatives, replacing Femke Halsema who announced her retirement from politics as of that date.

Bram van Ojik Dutch diplomat, politician, and activist

Abraham "Bram" van Ojik is Dutch politician and diplomat of the GreenLeft (GL) party and activist. Since 23 March 2017 he has been a member of the House of Representatives. He previously served in the House from 1993 to 1994, and from 2012 to 2015. In the latter three years he also served as leader of GroenLinks. He had also been an Envoy of the Netherlands for human migration since 20 October 2015.

The League of Communists in the Netherlands was a communist political party in the Netherlands.

Jesse Klaver Dutch politician

Jesse Feras Klaver is a Dutch politician serving as a member of the House of Representatives since 2010 and Leader of GroenLinks since 2015. Prior to this, he chaired the youth union of the Christelijk Nationaal Vakverbond from 2009 to 2010.

2017 Dutch general election

General elections were held in the Netherlands on Wednesday 15 March 2017 to elect all 150 members of the House of Representatives.

2021 Dutch general election General election held in the Netherlands

General elections were held in the Netherlands from 15 to 17 March 2021 to elect all 150 members of the House of Representatives.

The Dutch municipal elections of 2018 were held on 21 March in 335 municipalities in the Netherlands. This election determined the composition of the municipal councils for the following four years. The election coincided with the Intelligence and Security Services Act referendum.

We Are Here (collective) Human rights campaign of migrants in Amsterdam

We Are Here is a collective of migrants based in Amsterdam, the Netherlands, which campaigns for human rights for its members and all undocumented migrants. The asylum seekers have in many cases had their applications to remain in the Netherlands denied but they either cannot go back or refuse to return to their country of origin. They ask for access to social services such as medical care and housing. The group formed in 2012 and by 2015 contained over 200 migrants from around 15 countries.

Pieter Grinwis Dutch politician

Pieter A. Grinwis is a Dutch politician, who has been serving as a member of the House of Representatives on behalf of the Christian Union since March 2021. He previously served as a municipal councilor in The Hague and assisted the party in the House of Representatives and the Senate.

Senna Maatoug Member of the Dutch House of Representatives

Senna Maatoug is a Dutch civil servant and politician, who has been a member of the House of Representatives since the 2021 general election. She is a member of the green political party GroenLinks.

A process of cabinet formation took place following the 2021 Dutch general election, leading to the formation of the Fourth Rutte cabinet in 2022. The coalition consists of People's Party for Freedom and Democracy (VVD), Democrats 66 (D66), Christian Democratic Appeal (CDA) and Christian Union (CU), the same parties that formed the preceding Third Rutte cabinet. It was the longest formation in Dutch history.

References

  1. Vanderborght, Yannick (2005). The Basic Income Guarantee in Europe: The Belgian and Dutch Back Door Strategies. The Ethics and Economics of the Basic Income Guarantee. Ashgate. pp. 257–81. ISBN   978-0-7546-4188-9. In no other advanced European welfare state has the BIG [i.e., Basic Income Guarantee] debate been so broad and lively as in the Netherlands. Since 1975, the idea of a basisinkomen has been discussed within many Dutch political parties, trade unions, social organizations, and even at the governmental level.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Pels, Dick; Robert J. van der Veen (1995). Het Basisinkomen: Sluitstuk van de Verzorgingsstaat. Amsterdam: Van Gennep. p. 7. ISBN   90-5515-031-2. Het heeft twintig jaar geduurd, twintig jaar van vallen en opstaan, maar anno 1995 is het basisinkomen--een onvoorwaardelijke, niet aan arbeidsprestatie gebonden inkomensgarantie voor iedere burger--een volwassen politiek ideaal geworden. [Trans: It has taken twenty years, twenty years of ups and downs, but in the year 1995 the basic income--an unconditional guaranteed income for every citizen which is not linked to work--has become a mature political ideal.]
  3. WRR (1985). Waarborgen voor zekerheid : een nieuw stelsel van sociale zekerheid in hoofdlijnen (in Dutch). Wetenschappelijke Raad voor het Regeringsbeleid. ISBN   90-12-05038-3 . Retrieved 2009-01-03.
  4. Hans Schoen (ed.) (1992). Tijd voor zelfstandigheid : rapport van de commissie sociale zekerheid (in Dutch). Amsterdam: GroenLinks.CS1 maint: extra text: authors list (link)
  5. Wöltgens, Thijs; Marcel van Dam; Jos de Beus; et al. "Wat Mensen Bindt" (in Dutch). PvdA. Retrieved 2009-01-18.
  6. "De wereld als woning. Verkiezingsprogramma 1994" (in Dutch). GroenLinks. Retrieved 2009-01-18.
  7. (in Dutch) F. Empel and K. Versteegh "D66 wil de sociale zekerheid vervangen door basisinkomen [ permanent dead link ]," in NRC 6-3-1995.
  8. "Bewogen in Beweging" (in Dutch). D66. Retrieved 2009-01-18.
  9. Handler, Joel (2004). Social Citizenship and Welfare in the United States and Western Europe . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp.  169–179.
  10. Halsema, Femke; Ineke van Gent (2006-09-06). "GroenLinks presenteert manifest 'Vrijheid eerlijk delen'" (in Dutch). GroenLinks. Archived from the original on 2010-12-29. Retrieved 2009-01-03.
  11. Vendrik, Kees; Bart Snels; et al. "Groei Mee" (in Dutch). GroenLinks. Retrieved 2009-01-18.
  12. Robert J. van der Veen (2004) "Basic income versus wage subsidies: Competing instruments in an optimal tax model with a maximin objective" in Economics and Philosophy 20:1 147-183.
  13. Robert J. van der Veen (1998) "Real freedom versus reciprocity: Competing views on the justice of unconditional basic income" in Political Studies 46:1 140-163.