Arrowsmith School

Last updated
Arrowsmith School
Arrowsmith School Logo.svg
Address
Arrowsmith School
245 St. Clair Avenue West

,
Toronto
, ,
Coordinates 43°41′08″N79°24′20″W / 43.6856°N 79.4056°W / 43.6856; -79.4056
Information
School type Private, Co-educational day school for children with specific learning disabilities
MottoStrengthen Your Brain. Be At Your Best.
Founded1980 (1980)
Principal Shelley Woon
Grades 1 – 12
Language English
Website school.arrowsmith.ca

The Arrowsmith School is a private school in Toronto, Ontario, for children in Grades 1 to 12 with learning disabilities (also referred to as "specific learning difficulties"). [1] The original Arrowsmith School was founded in Toronto in 1980 by Barbara Arrowsmith Young. A second location was opened in May 2005 in Peterborough, Ontario. The Eaton Arrowsmith School, which is modelled on the Toronto school and founded by Howard Eaton, was opened in 2005 in Vancouver, British Columbia with two further branches established in Canada and one in the United States between 2009 and 2014.

Contents

The school's methodology, known as the Arrowsmith Program, was founded by Arrowsmith Young in 1978 from exercises that she had begun devising for herself in 1977 and which she has said enabled her to overcome her own severe learning difficulties. Her own struggle with learning disability and the rationale for her program are described in her 2012 book The Woman Who Changed Her Brain. According to Arrowsmith Young, her methodology is based on research into the principle of neuroplasticity, which suggests that the brain is dynamic and constantly rewiring itself. [2] The program has been incorporated into other public and private schools in Canada, the United States, Australia, and New Zealand, [3] but has drawn skepticism and criticism from several cognitive psychologists and neuroscientists. [4]

History

Barbara Arrowsmith Young and her then-husband, Joshua Cohen founded the original Toronto school in 1980 to teach learning disabled children using the program and exercises that Arrowsmith Young had begun devising for herself in 1978 and which she claimed enabled her to overcome her own severe learning difficulties. [5] The original school was housed in a rented building on Yorkville Ave. According to Arrowsmith Young's autobiographical account in her 2012 book, The Woman Who Changed Her Brain, she used her middle name for the school in honor of her paternal grandmother (born Louie May Arrowsmith in 1883), who as a young girl had been one of the pioneer settlers of Creston, British Columbia. The Toronto school gradually expanded, and in 1991 she and Cohen decided to open a second school in Brooklyn, New York and wind down the Toronto school. However, by 1994 the New York school had folded, and the marriage of Arrowsmith Young and Cohen had ended. She returned to Toronto and re-opened the school there, this time in a rented building on Yonge St. [2]

The school eventually moved to its present location, a converted house on St. Clair Avenue in the Forest Hill neighborhood of Toronto. [6] Barbara Arrowsmith Young remains its Director and owner as she does of a second, smaller branch in Peterborough, Ontario which opened in 2005. [3] Both branches saw increasing numbers of students from outside Canada following Arrowsmith Young's 2012 speaking tour to New Zealand, Australia, and the United Kingdom to promote her book The Woman Who Changed Her Brain. In October 2012, international students made up about a third of the student population of the Peterborough branch (seven from Australia, one student from the United Arab Emirates, and one from the United States). [7]

In 2005 Howard Eaton opened the Eaton Arrowsmith School in Vancouver which is modelled on the Arrowsmith School in Toronto. The Eaton Arrowmith School subsequently established further branches in British Columbia at Victoria in 2009 and White Rock in 2012. [8] Eaton then established a branch in the United States at Redmond, Washington, the Eaton Arrowsmith Academy, which opened in September 2014. [9] Eaton is the owner and Director of all four Eaton Arrowsmith schools.

Curriculum and tuition fees

Full-time day students, who form the core of the Toronto school's student body, follow a curriculum which devotes two periods of the school day to mathematics and English, the only two academic subjects taught at the school. The remainder of their time (six periods per day) is taken up with carrying out the cognitive remediation exercises known as the Arrowsmith Program. [4] [10]

The school had 75 students (in Grades 1 to 12) enrolled in the full-time day program in 2009. It also runs part-time programs for both children and adults. The school's annual tuition fees for full-time day students is $30,000. [11]

Arrowsmith Program

The main section of the Arrowsmith School in Toronto. Arrowsmith School.jpg
The main section of the Arrowsmith School in Toronto.

The Arrowsmith Program (a registered trademark) refers to the Arrowsmith School's methodology which is also available under license to students in some public and private schools in Canada, the United States, Australia and New Zealand. [12] Collectively more than 65 schools in these four countries use the program. [13] According to the Arrowsmith School's official website, the program can be used by children and adults with learning disabilities such as dyslexia, dyscalculia and dysgraphia who have at least average intelligence, but it is not suitable for people who have an autism spectrum disorder or an acquired brain injury. [14]

History and methodology

The program was founded by Barbara Arrowsmith Young while she was a graduate student at the Ontario Institute for Studies in Education. As a child she had exceptional visual and auditory memory, but it was coupled with several severe deficits in other areas, including dyslexia, dyscalculia, and problems with spatial reasoning, logic, and kinesthetic perception. In 1977–1978 she developed a series of remedial exercises which she says helped her to overcome her own disabilities rather than merely compensate for them. According to Arrowsmith Young, she based the program on Mark Rosenzweig's work on neuroplasticity and on the work of Alexander Luria and his theories about the relationship between the neurodynamic processes in different functional systems of the brain. [2] [5]

In their 2015 audit of 15 remedial programs for specific learning difficulties for the New Zealand organization SPELD, [lower-alpha 1] George Dawson and Stephanie D'Souza gave basic descriptions of the nineteen areas of cognitive processing which the Arrowsmith Program is intended to improve as well as descriptions of some of its remediation exercises. In their introduction Dawson and D'Souza stated that the Arrowsmith Program is licensed on a for-profit payment basis with detailed descriptions of its exercises not publicly available and that their descriptions were based on Arrowsmith Young's own account in The Woman Who Changed Her Brain. [16]

The deficit areas for which Dawson and D'Souza were able to provide basic descriptions of the Arrowsmith remedial exercises included:

In their report, Dawson and D'Souza describe the remediation exercises for nine out of the nineteen areas as "vague", "not clear" or unspecified in Arrowsmith Young's book. [16] These include:

At the conclusion of the audit Dawson and D'Souza noted that evidence for the program's efficacy is documented via testimonials from some of the students and their parents and in several research reports, although none have been published in peer-reviewed academic journals. In the authors' opinion:

The Arrowsmith programme claims to be founded on neuroscience research. This is true in the sense that Arrowsmith Young continually refers back to localisation of (dys)function as described by Luria when describing the development of her cognitive exercises. However, it is not the case that (present) neuroscience research actually supports the use of Arrowsmith's particular exercises to remediate learning disabilities. [16]

Skepticism, evaluation and criticism

Norman Doidge, a Canadian psychiatrist and psychoanalyst devoted one of the chapters in his 2008 book The Brain That Changes Itself to Barbara Arrowsmith Young and the Arrowsmith Program. In it he recounts Arrowsmith Young's own struggle to overcome her learning disabilities and how she developed the program. The chapter also includes several brief case histories of children and adults who Doidge says were significantly helped by the program, although no quantifiable data is presented. [17] He described her approach as "an important discovery" and one that had "major implications for education". [5] However, as Doidge also acknowledged in the chapter, the Arrowsmith Program has been controversial. Widespread doubt and criticism has emerged from several psychologists, neuroscientists and learning experts. This has centered on the lack of scientific evidence used by the program to demonstrate its efficacy and on its underlying rationale which its critics say represents an oversimplification and misapplication of neuroscientific concepts. [4]

Coinciding with Barbara Arrowsmith Young's speaking tour of Australia in 2012, the Catholic Education Office in Sydney announced that it would begin a pilot study involving 20 learning disabled students in their last two years of high school who would be offered the Arrowsmith Program for two years beginning in 2013. If it proved successful, the program would be extended to thousands of children in Catholic schools, including those in younger grades. The cost to parents whose children had been selected for the pilot study would be A$8000 for two years, over and above the normal school fees. [18] Several Australian academics were critical of the move. Dr Emma Burrows, a neuroscientist at the Florey Institute in Melbourne, and cognitive scientists Anne Castles and Max Coltheart at Macquarie University pointed out that the "evidence" supporting the program's claims of success was anecdotal rather than based on studies using randomized control trials and published in peer-reviewed academic journals. [18] [19] [20] Both Castles and Coltheart have also criticised the Arrowsmith Program and other "brain training" programs such the Dore Programme and Brain Gym as based on an oversimplification of neuroplasticity and other neuroscientific concepts. [21] [22] [23]

According to a January 2015 announcement from the Archdiocese of Sydney, the two-year school trial in Sydney had "outstanding results". The Arrowsmith Program was incorporated into the Sydney Catholic School system in 2015 and expanded to include both primary and secondary school students. The data on which the evaluation was based were not provided in the announcement. [24] The trial itself was strongly criticized by neuroscientists as misguiding. They contend the Arrowsmith school's claims of being research-based are unfounded. Dr Burrows was further reported to have expressed concern after directly inquiring with Barbara Arrowsmith for evidence and learning that neuroscientists were not involved with the Arrowsmith Program. [25]

In Canada, neuroscientist Adele Diamond and cognitive psychologist Linda Siegel—both based at the University of British Columbia in Vancouver—have expressed concerns similar to those of Castles and Coltheart. [4] [26] Both appeared in the 2008 a CBC documentary about the Arrowsmith program. Fixing My Brain which was filmed at the Arrowsmith School in Toronto. A portion of Siegel's highly critical commentary was removed by the documentary's producers prior to broadcast after Arrowsmith Young's lawyers threatened the CBC with a lawsuit for libel. [27] [lower-alpha 2] Siegel was also the author of a 2003 report to the Vancouver School Board (VSB) on the efficacy of The Arrowsmith program. At the time, VSB was running a three-year trial of the program, funded in part by the Vancouver Foundation. According to Howard Eaton, the owner and Director of the Eaton Arrowsmith schools, Siegel's report had been influential in the VSB's decision to discontinue the pilot program. [28]

Siegel's study compared the outcomes after eight months for children with learning disabilities at two Vancouver elementary schools. In one school the children received the Arrowsmith Program. In the other, the children were enrolled in an Extended Learning Assistance Class (ELAC) which focused on reading and writing. Siegel found that the superior performance of the Arrowsmith children on the comprehension and spelling measures was statistically significant. However, she found no statistically significant differences on the other measures, although she stated that on those measures "ELAC performed at higher levels than Arrowsmith, often by a relatively large amount". [lower-alpha 3] Howard Eaton has stated that there were multiple problems with the design, sampling, and statistical analysis in Siegel's study, something which Siegel has also conceded. [29] In 2013 Eaton co-authored a re-analysis of Siegel's data with professors William Lancee and Darren Irwin. [lower-alpha 4] Their conclusion was that the higher performance of the ELAC students in Siegel's study was not statistically significant. [28]

See also

Notes

  1. SPELD is a private non-profit organisation supporting children with specific learning disabilities in New Zealand. [15] Dawson and D'Souza's audit was supervised by David Moreau (Research Fellow) and Karen Waldie (Associate Professor) at the Centre for Brain Research and School of Psychology, University of Auckland. [16]
  2. According to the film's producer, two sentences from Siegel were removed: "I think the Arrowsmith Program is a fraud. I think they're taking money from people and not showing any improvement in any kind of any objective way." The remainder of her commentary was left intact. [27]
  3. Quoted in Eaton, Howard (2013). "Siegel's Study: Points For Comment". [28]
  4. William Lancee is head of psychiatry research at Toronto's Mount Sinai Hospital and has also authored evaluations of the Arrowsmith Program for the Toronto Catholic District School. [30] [31] Darren Irwin is a professor in the Department of Zoology at the University of British Columbia. [32]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dyslexia</span> Specific learning disability characterized by troubles with reading

Dyslexia, previously known as word blindness, is a learning disability that affects either reading or writing. Different people are affected to different degrees. Problems may include difficulties in spelling words, reading quickly, writing words, "sounding out" words in the head, pronouncing words when reading aloud and understanding what one reads. Often these difficulties are first noticed at school. The difficulties are involuntary, and people with this disorder have a normal desire to learn. People with dyslexia have higher rates of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), developmental language disorders, and difficulties with numbers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cognitive neuroscience</span> Scientific field

Cognitive neuroscience is the scientific field that is concerned with the study of the biological processes and aspects that underlie cognition, with a specific focus on the neural connections in the brain which are involved in mental processes. It addresses the questions of how cognitive activities are affected or controlled by neural circuits in the brain. Cognitive neuroscience is a branch of both neuroscience and psychology, overlapping with disciplines such as behavioral neuroscience, cognitive psychology, physiological psychology and affective neuroscience. Cognitive neuroscience relies upon theories in cognitive science coupled with evidence from neurobiology, and computational modeling.

Rehabilitation of sensory and cognitive function typically involves methods for retraining neural pathways or training new neural pathways to regain or improve neurocognitive functioning that have been diminished by disease or trauma. The main objective outcome for rehabilitation is to assist in regaining physical abilities and improving performance. Three common neuropsychological problems treatable with rehabilitation are attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), concussion, and spinal cord injury. Rehabilitation research and practices are a fertile area for clinical neuropsychologists, rehabilitation psychologists, and others.

Dyscalculia is a disability resulting in difficulty learning or comprehending arithmetic, such as difficulty in understanding numbers, learning how to manipulate numbers, performing mathematical calculations, and learning facts in mathematics. It is sometimes colloquially referred to as "math dyslexia", though this analogy is misleading as they are distinct syndromes.

Developmental disorders comprise a group of psychiatric conditions originating in childhood that involve serious impairment in different areas. There are several ways of using this term. The most narrow concept is used in the category "Specific Disorders of Psychological Development" in the ICD-10. These disorders comprise developmental language disorder, learning disorders, motor disorders, and autism spectrum disorders. In broader definitions ADHD is included, and the term used is neurodevelopmental disorders. Yet others include antisocial behavior and schizophrenia that begins in childhood and continues through life. However, these two latter conditions are not as stable as the other developmental disorders, and there is not the same evidence of a shared genetic liability.

A reading disability is a condition in which a person displays difficulty reading. Examples of reading disabilities include: developmental dyslexia, And alexia,

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Brain Gym International</span> Brain training and body movement programme

Brain Gym is a proprietary brain training and body movement programme. It is widely considered to be pseudoscience.

Brain training is a program of regular activities purported to maintain or improve one's cognitive abilities. The phrase “cognitive ability” usually refers to components of fluid intelligence such as executive function and working memory. Cognitive training reflects a hypothesis that cognitive abilities can be maintained or improved by exercising the brain, analogous to the way physical fitness is improved by exercising the body. Cognitive training activities can take place in numerous modalities such as cardiovascular fitness training, playing online games or completing cognitive tasks in alignment with a training regimen, playing video games that require visuospatial reasoning, and engaging in novel activities such as dance, art, and music.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Learning disability</span> Range of neurodevelopmental conditions

Learning disability, learning disorder, or learning difficulty is a condition in the brain that causes difficulties comprehending or processing information and can be caused by several different factors. Given the "difficulty learning in a typical manner", this does not exclude the ability to learn in a different manner. Therefore, some people can be more accurately described as having a "learning difference", thus avoiding any misconception of being disabled with a possible lack of an ability to learn and possible negative stereotyping. In the United Kingdom, the term "learning disability" generally refers to an intellectual disability, while conditions such as dyslexia and dyspraxia are usually referred to as "learning difficulties".

<i>The Brain that Changes Itself</i>

The Brain That Changes Itself: Stories of Personal Triumph from the Frontiers of Brain Science is a book on neuroplasticity by psychiatrist and psychoanalyst Norman Doidge.

The Center for Research, Evaluation and Awareness of Dyslexia is a university-based program at Pittsburg State University in Pittsburg, Kansas, United States. It was established in 1996 to develop strategies for the prevention and remediation of reading disabilities, search for strategies that will lead to the improvement of remedial processes, provide educators and parents with current and appropriate knowledge regarding reading/learning disabilities, provide interdisciplinary evaluations of readers of all ages, promote the concerns relevant to reading disabilities and educate the general public regarding issues pertaining to reading/learning disabilities.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Is Google Making Us Stupid?</span> Magazine article by technology writer Nicholas G. Carr

Is Google Making Us Stupid? What the Internet Is Doing to Our Brains! is a magazine article by technology writer Nicholas G. Carr, and is highly critical of the Internet's effect on cognition. It was published in the July/August 2008 edition of The Atlantic magazine as a six-page cover story. Carr's main argument is that the Internet might have detrimental effects on cognition that diminish the capacity for concentration and contemplation. Despite the title, the article is not specifically targeted at Google, but more at the cognitive impact of the Internet and World Wide Web. Carr expanded his argument in The Shallows: What the Internet Is Doing to Our Brains, a book published by W. W. Norton in June 2010.

Mental disorders diagnosed in childhood can be neurodevelopmental, emotional, or behavioral disorders. These disorders negatively impact the mental and social wellbeing of a child, and children with these disorders require support from their families and schools. Childhood mental disorders often persist into adulthood. These disorders are usually first diagnosed in infancy, childhood, or adolescence, as laid out in the DSM-5 and in the ICD-11.

The history of dyslexia research spans from the late 1800s to the present.

Educational neuroscience is an emerging scientific field that brings together researchers in cognitive neuroscience, developmental cognitive neuroscience, educational psychology, educational technology, education theory and other related disciplines to explore the interactions between biological processes and education. Researchers in educational neuroscience investigate the neural mechanisms of reading, numerical cognition, attention and their attendant difficulties including dyslexia, dyscalculia and ADHD as they relate to education. Researchers in this area may link basic findings in cognitive neuroscience with educational technology to help in curriculum implementation for mathematics education and reading education. The aim of educational neuroscience is to generate basic and applied research that will provide a new transdisciplinary account of learning and teaching, which is capable of informing education. A major goal of educational neuroscience is to bridge the gap between the two fields through a direct dialogue between researchers and educators, avoiding the "middlemen of the brain-based learning industry". These middlemen have a vested commercial interest in the selling of "neuromyths" and their supposed remedies.

Educational Therapy is a form of therapy used to treat individuals with learning differences, disabilities, and challenges. This form of therapy offers a wide range of intensive interventions that are designed to resolve learners' learning problems. These interventions are individualized and unique to the specific learner.

There are a variety of disabilities affecting cognitive ability. This is a broad concept encompassing various intellectual or cognitive deficits, including intellectual disability, deficits too mild to properly qualify as intellectual disability, various specific conditions, and problems acquired later in life through acquired brain injuries or neurodegenerative diseases like dementia.

Barbara Arrowsmith Young is a Canadian author, entrepreneur and lecturer. She is the founder of the Arrowsmith School in Toronto and the controversial Arrowsmith Program which forms the basis of the school's teaching method. In 2012 she published The Woman Who Changed Her Brain which combines an autobiographical account of her own severe learning disabilities and the method she developed to overcome them with case studies of learning disabled children who she claims overcame similar problems by using her method.

Anne Castles is a cognitive scientist of reading and language, with a particular focus on reading development and developmental dyslexia.

Linda S. Siegel is an American-born psychologist and academic known for her research into the cognitive aspects of learning disabilities. She is Professor Emeritus in the Department of Educational and Counselling Psychology, and Special Education at the University of British Columbia in Vancouver, Canada where she held the Dorothy C. Lam Chair in Special Education.

References

  1. "What are Specific Learning Difficulties: About Dyslexia". British Dyslexia Association. Archived from the original on 2014-04-14. Retrieved 2014-04-22.
  2. 1 2 3 Arrowsmith Young, Barbara (2012). The Woman Who Changed Her Brain. pp. 7, 16, 139, 161–162, 187–188. Simon and Schuster. ISBN   9781451607932
  3. 1 2 ArrowsmithSchool.org. Participating Schools: Arrowsmith School Peterborough. Retrieved 6 June 2015.
  4. 1 2 3 4 Barmak, Sarah (25 January 2013). "Can a controversial learning program transform brains?". The Globe and Mail . Retrieved 4 June 2015.
  5. 1 2 3 Doidge, Norman (2008). Chapter 2: "Building Herself a Better Brain", The Brain That Changes Itself: Stories of Personal Triumph from the Frontiers of Brain Science. Penguin. ISBN   9780141038872
  6. George, Lianne (7 November 2008). "Dumbed down" , Maclean's . Retrieved 6 June 2015.
  7. McCormick, Rob (9 October 2012). "Global reach at school for learning disabled" Archived 2015-06-06 at the Wayback Machine . Peterborough Examiner . Retrieved 6 June 2015.
  8. EatonArrowsmithSchool.com. About us. Retrieved 6 June 2015.
  9. Shen, Molly (25 November 2014). "New take on learning disabilities: change the brain" Archived 2014-11-28 at the Wayback Machine . KOMO News. Retrieved 6 June 2015.
  10. Arrowsmithschool.org. org/arrowsmithschool-toronto/ cognitive-programs.html The Arrowsmith School Full Time Day Program [ permanent dead link ]. Retrieved 8 June 2015.
  11. "Tuition & Assessment Fees".
  12. ArrowsmithSchool.org. Trademarks. Retrieved 9 June 2015.
  13. ArrowsmithSchool.org. Arrowsmith Program: Participating schools. Retrieved 6 June 2015.
  14. ArrowsmithSchool.org. Background: Suitable students. Retrieved 6 June 2015.
  15. Brooking, Keren (March 2010). "Outside the mainstream" Archived 2015-06-13 at the Wayback Machine . Education Review. Retrieved 8 June 2015.
  16. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 Dawson, George and D'Souza, Stephanie (23 March 2015). "Behavioural Interventions to Remediate Learning Disorders: A Technical Report" Archived 2015-06-14 at the Wayback Machine . Speld.org.nz.
  17. Clark, Elaine and Pompa, Janiece L. (2011). "Advances in Neuroscience and Reading Disabilities". The Oxford Handbook of School Psychology, pp. 183–184. Oxford University Press. ISBN   0195369807
  18. 1 2 Han, Esther (15 May 2012). "Proof hurdle for 'brain training'". Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved 9 June 2015.
  19. Sydney Morning Herald (11 May 2012). "Experts question effectiveness of program". Retrieved 4 June 2015.
  20. Tarica, Elisabeth (18 June 2012). "Brain program heads this way". Sydney Morning Herald . Retrieved 4 June 2015.
  21. "Can Barbara Arrowsmith-Young's cognitive exercises change your brain?". Amanda Hooton. Good Weekend. 21 April 2017.
  22. Castles, Anne and McArthur, Genevieve (April 2013). "'Brain-training'...or learning as we like to call it". Learning Difficulties Australia Bulletin, Vol. 45, No 1. Retrieved 4 June 2015.
  23. Coltheart, Max (March 2014). "Neuromyths" Archived 2018-04-06 at the Wayback Machine . SPELD NSW Newsletter. Retrieved 4 June 2015.
  24. Archdiocese of Sydney (12 Jan 2015). "Brain "Workout" Program Scores Dramatic Results in Sydney CEO Trials". Retrieved 9 June 2015.
  25. "Proof hurdle for 'brain training'". Esther Han. The Sydney Morning Herald. 15 December 2012.
  26. Wickelgren, Ingrid (May/June 2013). "Calisthenics for a Child's Mind" Archived June 14, 2015, at the Wayback Machine . Scientific American Mind , pp. 39–45
  27. 1 2 Hill, M. F. (29 December 2008). "Education expert calling her lawyer". Vancouver Sun . Retrieved 31 May 2015.
  28. 1 2 3 Eaton, Howard (2013). "Siegel's Study: Points For Comment" Archived 2014-12-03 at the Wayback Machine . EatonArrowsmithSchool.com. Retrieved 9 June 2015.
  29. Manning, Rob (15 January 2014). "Oregon Charter School Considers 'Arrowsmith Program'. Oregon Public Broadcasting. Retrieved 9 June 2015.
  30. Gordon, Andrea (25 February 2009). "One school's belief in a fixable brain". Toronto Star . Retrieved 8 June 2015.
  31. Arrowsmithschool.org. Admissions. Retrieved 8 June 2015.
  32. University of British Columbia, Zoology Department. Darren Irwin. Retrieved 9 June 2015.

Further reading