Betteridge's law of headlines

Last updated

Betteridge's law of headlines is an adage that states: "Any headline that ends in a question mark can be answered by the word no." It is named after Ian Betteridge, a British technology journalist who wrote about it in 2009, although the principle is much older. [1] [2] It is based on the assumption that if the publishers were confident that the answer was yes, they would have presented it as an assertion; by presenting it as a question, they are not accountable for whether it is correct or not. The adage does not apply to questions that are more open-ended than strict yes–no questions. [3]

Contents

The maxim has been cited by other names since 1991, when a published compilation of Murphy's law variants called it "Davis's law", a name that also appears online without any explanation of who Davis was. [4] [5] [6] [7] It has also been referred to as the "journalistic principle" and in 2007 was referred to in commentary as "an old truism among journalists". [8] [9] [10]

History

Betteridge's name became associated with the concept after he discussed it in a February 2009 article, which examined a previous TechCrunch article that carried the headline "Did Last.fm Just Hand Over User Listening Data to the RIAA?" ( Schonfeld 2009 ):

This story is a great demonstration of my maxim that any headline which ends in a question mark can be answered by the word "no." The reason why journalists use that style of headline is that they know the story is probably bullshit, and don't actually have the sources and facts to back it up, but still want to run it. [1]

A similar observation was made by British newspaper editor Andrew Marr in his 2004 book My Trade, among Marr's suggestions for how a reader should interpret newspaper articles:

If the headline asks a question, try answering 'no'. Is This the True Face of Britain's Young? (Sensible reader: No.) Have We Found the Cure for AIDS? (No; or you wouldn't have put the question mark in.) Does This Map Provide the Key for Peace? (Probably not.) A headline with a question mark at the end means, in the vast majority of cases, that the story is tendentious or over-sold. It is often a scare story, or an attempt to elevate some run-of-the-mill piece of reporting into a national controversy and, preferably, a national panic. To a busy journalist hunting for real information a question mark means 'don't bother reading this bit'. [11]

Studies

A 2016 study of a sample of academic journals (not news publications) that set out to test Betteridge's law and Hinchliffe's rule (see below) found that few titles were posed as questions and of those, few were yes/no questions and they were more often answered "yes" in the body of the article rather than "no". [12]

A 2018 study of 2,585 articles in four academic journals in the field of ecology similarly found that very few titles were posed as questions at all, with 1.82 percent being wh-questions and 2.15 percent being yes/no questions. Of the yes/no questions, 44 percent were answered "yes", 34 percent "maybe", and only 22 percent were answered "no". [13]

In 2015, a study of 26,000 articles from 13 news sites on the World Wide Web, conducted by a data scientist and published on his blog, found that the majority (54 percent) were yes/no questions, which divided into 20 percent "yes" answers, 17 percent "no" answers and 16 percent whose answers he could not determine. [14]

Question headlines

Phrasing headlines as questions is a tactic employed by newspapers that do not "have the facts required to buttress the nut graph". [15] [3] Roger Simon characterized the practice as justifying "virtually anything, no matter how unlikely", giving "Hillary to Replace Biden on Ticket?" and "Romney to Endorse Gay Marriage Between Corporations?" as hypothetical examples of such a practice. [16] [17] Many question headlines were used, for example, in reporting of Bharatiya Janata Party in-fighting in 2004, because no politicians went on record to confirm or deny facts, such as "Is Venkaiah Naidu on his way out?" [18] Because this implication is known to readers, guides giving advice to newspaper editors state that so-called "question heads" should be used sparingly. [19]

Freelance writer R. Thomas Berner calls them "gimmickry". [20] Grant Milnor Hyde observed that they give the impression of uncertainty in a newspaper's content. [21] When Linton Andrews worked at the Daily Mail after the First World War, one of the rules set by Lord Northcliffe was to avoid question headlines, unless the question itself reflected a national issue. [22]

Question headlines are not legally sound when it comes to avoiding defamation. [23] The Supreme Court of Oklahoma held in 1913, in its decision in Spencer v. Minnick, that "A man cannot libel another by the publication of language the meaning and damaging effect of which is clear to all men, and where the identity of the person meant cannot be doubted, and then escape liability through the use of a question mark." [24] [23] The use of question headlines as a form of sensationalism has a long history, including the 9 June 1883, headline in Joseph Pulitzer's New York World , "Was It Peppermint Mary?" [25] The story, about a jewellery store that had tried to prevent its female employees from flirting with people outside the store, only mentioned "Peppermint" Mary at the end of the piece as an employee who might possibly have caused this and did not answer the question. [25]

The New York World also famously used a question headline for hedging when editors were unsure of their facts, when it reported the outcome of the 1916 United States presidential election. [26] [27] When other New York City newspapers ran statement headlines on 8 November 1916 saying "Hughes Is Elected" ( The Evening Sun , final edition the night before), "Hughes Is Elected by Narrow Margin" ( The Sun ), "Hughes Is Elected by Majority of 40" ( The New York Herald ), "Hughes the Next President" ( The Journal of Commerce ), "Hughes Sweeps State" ( New York Tribune ) and "Nation Swept by Hughes!" ( New York American ), the World ran one with a question headline, "Hughes Elected in Close Contest?" [28]

This was the result of a last-minute intervention by then World journalist Herbert Bayard Swope, who, having received a tip from gambling friends that Charles Evans Hughes might not in fact win, persuaded Charles M. Lincoln, the managing editor of the paper, to reset the headline in between editions, inserting a question mark. [29] [30] Confusingly, below the question headline the World still had a picture of Hughes captioned "The President-Elect" but the question headline did indeed turn out to have the answer "no", as President Woodrow Wilson was re-elected, which the World finally announced in a headline two days later. [26] [28]

Advertisers and marketers prefer yes/no question headlines that are answered "yes", as a reader that immediately answers "no" to a question headline on an advertisement is likely to skip over the advertisement entirely. [31] The most famous example of such a question headline in advertising is "Do you make these mistakes in English?", written to advertise Sherwin Cody's English-language course and used from 1919 to 1959, which (with readers answering "yes" they did make the mistakes that the advertisement proceeded to outline) was measured as more successful than non-yes/no-question alternatives. [32] [33]

Victor Schwab, a partner in the advertising agency that worked for Cody, published an analysis of the aspects of the headline (as Schwab 1939) attempting to look at it scientifically and using ten years' worth of revenue and customer enquiry data for both it and a statement headline that Cody had also used. [32] [33] He noted amongst other things that working in its favour was the question addressing the reader using the second person. [34] A 2013 study into computer-mediated communication came to a similar conclusion, finding that question headlines posted to Twitter and eBay increased click-through rates in comparison to statement headlines and that questions that address or reference the reader have statistically significant higher click-through rates than rhetorical or general questions. [35] [36]

Hinchliffe's rule

In the field of particle physics, the concept is known as Hinchliffe's rule, after physicist Ian Hinchliffe, who stated that if a research paper's title is in the form of a yes–no question, the answer to that question will be "no". [37] [38] The adage led into a humorous attempt at a liar paradox by a 1988 paper, written by physicist Boris Kayser under the pseudonym "Boris Peon", which bore the title: "Is Hinchliffe's Rule True?" ( Peon 1988 ). [39] [38]

See also

Related Research Articles

Journalism is the production and distribution of reports on the interaction of events, facts, ideas, and people that are the "news of the day" and that informs society to at least some degree of accuracy. The word, a noun, applies to the occupation, the methods of gathering information, and the organizing literary styles.

"Yes, Virginia, there is a Santa Claus" is a line from an editorial by Francis Pharcellus Church. Written in response to a letter by eight-year-old Virginia O'Hanlon asking whether Santa Claus was real, the editorial was first published in the New York newspaper The Sun on September 21, 1897.

Murphy's law is an adage or epigram that is typically stated as: "Anything that can go wrong will go wrong." In some formulations, it is extended to "Anything that can go wrong will go wrong, and at the worst possible time."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sturgeon's law</span> "Ninety percent of everything is crap"

Sturgeon's law is an adage stating "ninety percent of everything is crap". It was coined by Theodore Sturgeon, an American science fiction author and critic, and was inspired by his observation that, while science fiction was often derided for its low quality by critics, most work in other fields was low-quality too, and so science fiction was thus no different.

<i>The Independent</i> British online daily newspaper

The Independent is a British online newspaper. It was established in 1986 as a national morning printed paper. Nicknamed the Indy, it began as a broadsheet and changed to tabloid format in 2003. The last printed edition was published on Saturday 26 March 2016, leaving only the online edition.

News style, journalistic style, or news-writing style is the prose style used for news reporting in media, such as newspapers, radio and television.

<i>Salon.com</i> American progressive news and opinion website

Salon is an American politically progressive and liberal news and opinion website created in 1995. It publishes articles on U.S. politics, culture, and current events.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Andrew Marr</span> British journalist

Andrew William Stevenson Marr is a British journalist and broadcaster. Beginning his career as a political commentator, he subsequently edited The Independent newspaper from 1996 to 1998 and was political editor of BBC News from 2000 to 2005.

The headline is the text indicating the content or nature of the article below it, typically by providing a form of brief summary of its contents.

A rhetorical question is a question asked for a purpose other than to obtain information. In many cases it may be intended to start a discourse, as a means of displaying or emphasizing the speaker's or author's opinion on a topic.

Vox populi is a Latin phrase that literally means "voice of the people". It is used in English in the meaning "the opinion of the majority of the people". In journalism, vox pop or man on the street refers to short interviews with members of the public.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">David Marr (journalist)</span> Australian journalist

David Ewan Marr FAHA is an Australian journalist, author and progressive political and social commentator. His areas of expertise include the law, Australian politics, censorship, the media and the arts. He writes for The Monthly, The Saturday Paper and Guardian Australia.

<i>The Andrew Marr Show</i> British TV series or programme

The Andrew Marr Show is a Sunday morning talk show presented by Andrew Marr. It was broadcast on BBC One from 2005 to 2021.

Muphry's law is an adage that states: "If you write anything criticizing editing or proofreading, there will be a fault of some kind in what you have written." The name is a deliberate misspelling of "Murphy's law".

The Telegraph was an evening newspaper published in Brisbane, Queensland, Australia. It was first published on 1 October 1872 and its final edition appeared on 5 February 1988. In its day it was recognised as one of the best news pictorial newspapers in the country. Its Pink Sports edition was a particularly excellent production produced under tight deadlines. It included results and pictures of Brisbane's Saturday afternoon sports including the results of the last horse race of the day.

Yes and no, or similar word pairs, are expressions of the affirmative and the negative, respectively, in several languages, including English. Some languages make a distinction between answers to affirmative versus negative questions and may have three-form or four-form systems. English originally used a four-form system up to and including Early Middle English. Modern English uses a two-form system consisting of yes and no. It exists in many facets of communication, such as: eye blink communication, head movements, Morse code, and sign language. Some languages, such as Latin, do not have yes-no word systems.

<i>The Sun</i> (United Kingdom) British tabloid newspaper

The Sun is a British tabloid newspaper, published by the News Group Newspapers division of News UK, itself a wholly owned subsidiary of Lachlan Murdoch's News Corp. It was founded as a broadsheet in 1964 as a successor to the Daily Herald, and became a tabloid in 1969 after it was purchased by its current owner. The Sun had the largest daily newspaper circulation in the United Kingdom, but was overtaken by freesheet rival Metro in March 2018.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Clickbait</span> Web content intended to entice users to click on a link

Clickbait is a text or a thumbnail link that is designed to attract attention and to entice users to follow ("click") that link and read, view, or listen to the linked piece of online content, being typically deceptive, sensationalized, or otherwise misleading. A "teaser" aims to exploit the "curiosity gap", providing just enough information to make readers of news websites curious, but not enough to satisfy their curiosity without clicking through to the linked content. Clickbait headlines often add an element of dishonesty, using enticements that do not accurately reflect the content being delivered. The "-bait" suffix makes an analogy with fishing, where a hook is disguised by an enticement (bait), presenting the impression to the fish that it is a desirable thing to swallow.

<i>Baltimore Afro-American</i> Newspaper in Baltimore, Maryland

The Baltimore Afro-American, commonly known as The Afro or Afro News, is a weekly African-American newspaper published in Baltimore, Maryland. It is the flagship newspaper of the AFRO-American chain and the longest-running African-American family-owned newspaper in the United States, established in 1892.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Katie Benner</span> American journalist

Katie Benner is an American reporter for The New York Times covering the United States Department of Justice.

References

  1. 1 2 Betteridge 2009.
  2. ↑ "The Macalope Weekly: Pointless Exercises". Macworld . 11 August 2012. Retrieved 12 May 2019.
  3. 1 2 Murtha 2015.
  4. ↑ Bloch 1991, p. 163.
  5. ↑ Anvari 2006
  6. ↑ "List of variants of Murphy's Law" . Retrieved 12 May 2019.
  7. ↑ Liberman 2006.
  8. ↑ Götz 1997, Journalistic Principle.
  9. ↑ ""It's an old truism among journalists..."". MeatRobot.org.uk. 4 December 2007. Retrieved 12 May 2019.
  10. ↑ "The Vitamin B scam. Don't trust Boots". 22 November 2007. Retrieved 12 May 2019.
  11. ↑ Marr 2004, p. 253.
  12. ↑ Cook & Plourde 2016.
  13. ↑ Mola 2017, p. 11.
  14. ↑ Linander 2015.
  15. ↑ Berthon et al. 2019, p. 257.
  16. ↑ Paul & Moss 2015, p. 275.
  17. ↑ Simon 2012.
  18. ↑ Saxena 2006, pp. 95–96.
  19. ↑ Saxena 2006, p. 95.
  20. ↑ Berner 2007, p. 233.
  21. ↑ Hyde 1931, p. 154.
  22. ↑ Andrews 1964, p. 106.
  23. 1 2 Sack 1999, pp. 2–48.
  24. ↑ Oklahoma 1913.
  25. 1 2 Juergens 2015, pp. 63–64.
  26. 1 2 Kahn 1965, p. 181.
  27. ↑ Gies 1979, p. 64.
  28. 1 2 O'Keefe 2013, p. 154.
  29. ↑ Kahn 1965, pp. 52, 181.
  30. ↑ Ellis 1975, p. 305.
  31. ↑ Zacher 1961, p. 118.
  32. 1 2 De Voe 1956, pp. 198, 262.
  33. 1 2 Battistella 2009, pp. 6, 39–40.
  34. ↑ Battistella 2009, pp. 40.
  35. ↑ Jarrett 2013.
  36. ↑ Lai & Farbrot 2013.
  37. ↑ Carroll 2006.
  38. 1 2 Shieber 2015.
  39. ↑ Sher 2013.

Sources

Further reading

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.