British PGA Matchplay Championship

British PGA Matchplay Championship

Tournament information
Location	York, England
Established	1903
Course(s)	Fulford Golf Club
Tour(s)	European Tour
Format	Match play
Prize fund	£40,000
Final year	1979
Tournament record score
Score	10 and 8 Henry Cotton (1932)
Final champion
Des Smyth
Location Map
Fulford GC Location in England Show map of England Fulford GC Location in North Yorkshire Show map of North Yorkshire

The British PGA Matchplay Championship was a match play golf tournament that began in 1903 and ran until 1979. Between 1903 and 1969, the event was sponsored by the now defunct British newspaper the News of the World , ^[1] and was commonly known by the paper's name. Initially organised as the championship of British professionals, the event came to include invited players from other countries – in particular from around the Commonwealth (it was won on four occasions by Australia's Peter Thomson, a record number of victories shared with Dai Rees and James Braid). On occasion, American professionals also took part, notably in 1949 when eight members of the victorious U.S. Ryder Cup side accepted invites to the event, Lloyd Mangrum reaching the semi-finals.

For many years, the event had the richest prize fund in British golf, and certainly in the pre-First World War era, can be considered to have been a "major" championship of its day, as at the time, the British professionals were considered the best players in the world – in 1907 the four semi-finalists were the Great Triumvirate of Harry Vardon, J. H. Taylor and James Braid, along with Ted Ray, who would go on to win both the British and U.S. Opens.

After World War II, the event provided several notable British and Irish players, like Christy O'Connor Snr, Eric Brown and Dave Thomas, with their greatest triumphs, and also became a showcase for the matchplay strength of Neil Coles, who was at least a semi-finalist eleven times in eighteen years, a remarkable achievement considering the field normally comprised 64 and on occasion 128 players.

The tournament was also often notable for remarkable runs to the later stages by veteran players – Max Faulkner was a semi-finalist in 1967 aged 51 and reached the quarter-finals three years later, and in 1969 Dai Rees reached the final aged 56. However, following the establishment of the British PGA Championship (at stroke play) in 1955, the matchplay version lost some of its importance, and the matchplay format fell out of favour with sponsors, who could not guarantee that the final day would feature any "big-name" players to attract a television audience, nor either that the matches would finish at times to coincide with limited scheduled slots for live transmission. The tournament remained an official money event on the European Tour from its first season in 1972, but was discontinued following the 1979 event when a replacement sponsor could not be found after Sun Alliance moved to supporting the stroke play championship instead. ^{[1] [2]} The last champion was Irishman Des Smyth, who beat a youthful Nick Price in the final.

History

1903

The tournament was announced in August. £200 had been given by the News of the World to the PGA for the competition. The final stage would be at Sunningdale Golf Club from 13 to 15 October and would be a knock-out match-play contest by 32 professionals. Qualification was by a series of 36-hole stroke-play competitions; one for each of the five PGA sections. The number of qualifiers from each section was based on the membership of that section. The Southern section had 16 qualifiers, the Midland and Northern sections had 5 each, the Scottish section 4 and the Irish section 2. The matches in the final stage were over 18 holes except for the final which was over 36 holes. Extra holes were played in the event of a tied match. The winner received £100, the runner-up £30, losing semi-finalists £15 and losing quarter-finalists £10. ^[3] The semi-finalists also received medals: the winner gold, the runner-up silver and the losing semi-finalists bronze.

In the first round Jack White, third in the 1903 Open Championship lost to Tom Williamson. Later in the day Tom Vardon who had been second in the Open lost to Ted Ray. ^[4] In the quarter-finals James Braid beat Alfred Toogood at the 19th hole. In the semi-finals Braid won the first two holes against J.H. Taylor and won 4&2. Ray beat George Coburn 4&3 in the other match. They had been level after 7 holes but Ray won the next 4 to take a convincing lead. ^[5] In the final Braid led by 1 hole after the first round. In the afternoon Braid won 3 of the first 5 holes to go 4 up and, although Ray won the next two, Braid eventually won 4&3. ^[6]

1914

The final stages were planned for Oxhey Golf Club on 6, 7 and 8 October with the same format and prize money as previously. In mid-August the PGA cancelled the tournament. The Western section had played their qualification tournament on 9 July at which Charles and Ernest Whitcombe qualified.

1919

The arrangements for the 1919 tournament were sorted out at a late stage. In mid-July it was decided that the number of qualifiers for the final stage would be increased from 32 to 64 and the "News of the World" agreed to increase the prize money. The West of England section had already played their qualifying competition under the impression there were 2 places available. They were allocated 4 in the new system. Other sections were allocated the following places: Southern 26, Northern 12, Midland 10, Scotland 5, Welsh 4, Eastern 2 and Irish 1. The tournament was extended to a fourth day with the 32 18-hole first round matches played on the first day. The losing quarter-finalists received £12 10s, third round losers £10, second round losers £7 10s and first round losers £5. Prize money totalled £590.

1921

Prize money was increased to £750 with the winner receiving £200, the runner-up £50, the losing semi-finalists £30, the losing quarter-finalists £15 and third round losers £12 10s.

1925

Prize money was increased to £1,040 with the winner receiving £300, the runner-up £100, the losing semi-finalists £50, the losing quarter-finalists £25 and prizes of £15, £10 and £5 for losers in the first three rounds.

1935

Prize money was increased to £1,250 with the losing quarter-finalists receiving £27 10s and prizes of £20, £15 and £7 10s for losers in the first three rounds.

1939

The final stages were planned for St George's Hill Golf Club from 12 to 15 September with the same format and prize money as previously. Qualifying events had been completed when the PGA cancelled the tournament in early September on the outbreak of World War II.

1940

The cancelled 1939 event was re-arranged for Royal Mid-Surrey Golf Club from 30 April to 3 May. The 64 qualifiers for the 1939 tournament were invited although a number were unable to play.

1945

The 1945 event was arranged at short notice and there were no qualifying events. There were 149 entries and the tournament was played at Walton Heath Golf Club from 23 to 27 July. 21 matches were played on the first day to reduce the field to 128. There were 64 matches on the second day and then two rounds were played each day. The final was played over 18 holes for the first time. Both New and Old courses were used for the last-128 and last-64 rounds. Total prize money was £2,000 with the winner receiving £600, the runner-up £200, semi-finalists £100, quarter-finalists £50 and prizes of £30, £15 and £10 for those reaching the last-64 stage.

1946

The 1946 tournament reverted to the earlier format with 64 players qualifying for the knock-out stage played from 25 to 28 September. The final was over 36 holes. Prize money remained at £2,000 with £550 for the winner, £250 for the losing finalist and £120 for the losing semi-finalists.

1947

Prize money was increased to £2,500 with £750 for the winner and £250 for the losing finalist.

1949

Eight American golfers who had played in the 1949 Ryder Cup were added to the 64 qualifiers. The 8 were: Skip Alexander, Jimmy Demaret, Bob Hamilton, Dutch Harrison, Clayton Heafner, Lloyd Mangrum, Johnny Palmer and Sam Snead. The additional players meant that 8 preliminary match had to be played to reduce the field to 64. These matches were played on 20 September, extending the event to a fifth day. Total prize money was £2,620.

1950

The 1949 winner (Dai Rees) and the 1950 Open Champion (Bobby Locke) were exempted from qualifying. Locke did not play but with 64 players reaching the final stage through the sectional qualifying events there were 65 qualifiers. This meant that one preliminary match was needed; the match being played the day before the main event started. Total prize money was £2,530.

1951

The 1950 winner (Dai Rees) and the 1951 Open Champion (Max Faulkner) were exempted from qualifying. With a total of 66 players reaching the final stage, two preliminary matches were played the day before the main event started.

1953

The leaders in the Order of Merit were exempted, increasing the number of qualifiers to 76. 12 first-round matches were played to reduce the field to 64. Total prize money was £2,650.

1955

The leader 10 in the Order of Merit were exempted. 10 first-round matches were played to reduce the field to 64. Total prize money was increased to £3,000, although the first prize remained unchanged at £750.

1956

The number of qualifiers from the sectional events was reduced so that there were just 64 contestants in the final stage. The quarter-finals and semi-finals were extended to 36 holes, the event being played over 5 days from 11 to 15 September.

1957

The format was changed, with the first round matches being over 36 holes, spread over two days. The quarter-finals and semi-finals were reduced again to 18 holes, although the final was still over 36 holes.

1958

The format was changed again. All matches were reduced to 18 holes and the event reduced from 5 days to 4. One round was played on the first two days, the third round and quarter-finals were played on the third day with the semi-finals and final on the final day. This was only the second final, after 1945, to be contested over 18 holes.

1962

Sectional qualifying was dropped and replaced by local qualifying on the two days prior to the knock-out stage. Two courses were used. There was a sudden-death playoff to get exactly 64 qualifiers.

1964

12 players who had competed in the Carling World Open the previous week were exempted from qualifying so that only 52 qualified through local qualifying.

Winners

Year	Winner	Score	Runner-up	Winner's share (£)	Venue	Ref.
Sun Alliance Match Play Championship
1979	Des Smyth	1 up	Nick Price	6,660	Fulford
1978	Mark James	3 and 2	Neil Coles	8,000	Dalmahoy	[7]
1977	Hugh Baiocchi	6 and 5	Brian Huggett	4,000	Stoke Poges	[8]
1976	Brian Barnes	4 and 3	Craig Defoy	3,500	Kings Norton	[9]
1975	Eddie Polland	23 holes	Peter Butler	3,500	Lindrick	[10]
Benson & Hedges Match Play Championship
1974	Jack Newton	2 and 1	Cesar Sanudo	3,500	Downfield	[11]
1973	Neil Coles (3)	2 holes	Doug McClelland	3,500	Hillside	[12]
1972	John Garner	7 and 6	Neil Coles	3,500	Moor Park
1971: No tournament
Long John Scotch Whisky Match Play Championship
1970	Tommy Horton	3 and 2	Ronnie Shade	2,000	Moor Park	[13]
News of the World Match Play Championship
1969	Maurice Bembridge	6 and 5	Dai Rees	1,250	Walton Heath	[14]
1968	Brian Huggett	1 up	John Panton	1,250	Walton Heath	[15]
1967	Peter Thomson (4)	4 and 3	Dai Rees	1,250	Walton Heath	[16]
1966	Peter Thomson (3)	2 and 1	Neil Coles	1,250	Walton Heath	[17]
1965	Neil Coles (2)	19 holes	Lionel Platts	1,250	Walton Heath	[18]
1964	Neil Coles	3 and 2	Peter Butler	1,250	Walton Heath	[19]
1963	Dave Thomas	3 and 2	John MacDonald	1,250	Turnberry	[20]
1962	Eric Brown (2)	19 holes	Ross Whitehead		Walton Heath	[21]
1961	Peter Thomson (2)	3 and 1	Ralph Moffitt		Walton Heath
1960	Eric Brown	20 holes	Harry Weetman	750	Turnberry	[22]
1959	David Snell	3 and 2	Harry Weetman	750	Royal Birkdale	[23]
1958	Harry Weetman (2)	1 up	Bernard Hunt	750	Walton Heath	[24]
1957	Christy O'Connor Snr	5 and 4	Tom Haliburton	750	Turnberry	[25]
1956	John Panton	1 up	Harry Weetman	750	Royal Liverpool	[26]
1955	Ken Bousfield	4 and 3	Eric Brown	750	Walton Heath	[27]
1954	Peter Thomson	38 holes	John Fallon	750	St Andrews	[28]
1953	Max Faulkner	1 up	Dai Rees	750	Ganton	[29]
1952	Fred Daly (3)	4 and 3	Flory Van Donck	750	Walton Heath	[30]
1951	Harry Weetman	5 and 4	Jimmy Adams	750	Royal Liverpool
1950	Dai Rees (4)	7 and 6	Frank Jowle	750	Carnoustie	[31]
1949	Dai Rees (3)	1 up	Henry Cotton	750	Walton Heath	[32]
1948	Fred Daly (2)	4 and 3	Laurie Ayton, Jnr	750	Royal Birkdale
1947	Fred Daly	3 and 2	Flory Van Donck	750	Royal Lytham & St Annes	[33]
1946	Henry Cotton (3)	8 and 7	Jimmy Adams	550	Royal Liverpool	[34]
News of the World Match Play
1945	Reg Horne	4 and 3	Percy Alliss	600	Walton Heath	[35]
1941–1944: No tournament due to World War II
1940	Henry Cotton (2)	37 holes	Alf Padgham	300	Royal Mid-Surrey	[36]
1939: No tournament
1938	Dai Rees (2)	4 and 3	Eddie Whitcombe	300	Walton Heath	[37]
1937	Percy Alliss (2)	3 and 2	Jimmy Adams	300	Stoke Poges	[38]
1936	Dai Rees	1 up	Ernest Whitcombe	300	Oxhey	[39]
1935	Alf Padgham (2)	3 and 2	Percy Alliss	300	Royal Mid-Surrey	[40]
1934	Jack Busson	2 up	Charles Whitcombe	300	Walton Heath	[41]
1933	Percy Alliss	5 and 4	Mark Seymour	300	Purley Downs	[42]
1932	Henry Cotton	10 and 8	Alf Perry	300	Moor Park	[43]
1931	Alf Padgham	5 and 4	Mark Seymour	300	Royal Mid-Surrey	[44]
1930	Charles Whitcombe (2)	4 and 2	Henry Cotton	300	Oxhey	[45]
1929	Abe Mitchell (3)	8 and 7	Philip Rodgers	300	Wentworth	[46]
1928	Charles Whitcombe	4 and 2	Henry Cotton	300	Stoke Poges	[47]
1927	Archie Compston (2)	8 and 7	James Braid	300	Walton Heath	[48]
1926	Sandy Herd (2)	38 holes	Jack Bloxham	300	Royal Mid-Surrey	[49]
1925	Archie Compston	3 and 1	George Gadd	300	Moor Park	[50]
1924	Ernest Whitcombe	3 and 2	George Gadd	200	St George's Hill	[51]
1923	Reg Wilson	4 and 2	Thomas Renouf	200	Walton Heath	[52]
1922	George Gadd	5 and 4	Fred Leach	200	Sunningdale	[53]
1921	Bert Seymour	40 holes	Jack Gaudin	200	Oxhey	[54]
1920	Abe Mitchell (2)	3 and 2	Josh Taylor	100	Mid-Surrey	[55]
1919	Abe Mitchell	1 up	George Duncan	100	Walton Heath	[56]
1914–1918: No tournament due to World War I
1913	George Duncan	3 and 2	James Braid	100	Walton Heath	[57]
1912	Harry Vardon	1 up	Ted Ray	100	Sunningdale	[58]
1911	James Braid (4)	1 up	Ted Ray	100	Walton Heath	[59]
1910	James Sherlock	8 and 6	George Duncan	100	Sunningdale	[60]
1909	Tom Ball	7 and 5	Sandy Herd	100	Walton Heath	[61]
1908	J.H. Taylor (2)	2 up	Fred Robson	100	Mid-Surrey	[62]
1907	James Braid (3)	4 and 2	J.H. Taylor	100	Sunningdale	[63]
1906	Sandy Herd	8 and 7	Charles Mayo	100	Notts	[64]
1905	James Braid (2)	4 and 3	Tom Vardon	100	Walton Heath	[65]
1904	J.H. Taylor	5 and 3	Alfred Toogood	100	Mid-Surrey	[66]
1903	James Braid	4 and 3	Ted Ray	100	Sunningdale	[6]

See also

• Volvo World Match Play Championship – another matchplay championship played in the United Kingdom, which has been an official money event on the European Tour since 2004.

References

1. "Matchplay's days could be numbered" . Reading Evening Post. Reading, England. 3 August 1979. p. 28. Retrieved 10 June 2020– via British Newspapers Archive.
2. "Now Euro stars chase record £1.8m in circuit cash bonanza" . Coventry Evening Telegraph. Coventry, England. 20 December 1979. p. 33. Retrieved 10 June 2020– via British Newspapers Archive.
3. "Golf – Professional Golfers' Association". The Times. 3 August 1903. p. 10.
4. "Golf – The professional tournament – Defeat of Jack White and Tom Vardon". The Glasgow Herald . 14 October 1903. p. 12.
5. "Golf – The great professional tournament – Braid and Ray the finalists". The Glasgow Herald . 15 October 1903. p. 11.
6. "Golf – The great professional tournament – Success of James Braid". The Glasgow Herald . 16 October 1903. p. 15.
7. "Cool James has first home win". The Glasgow Herald . 3 July 1978. p. 17.
8. "Brilliant Baiocchi". The Glasgow Herald . 23 May 1977. p. 17.
9. "Barnes champion". The Glasgow Herald . 6 September 1976. p. 22.
10. "Great season for Irish". The Glasgow Herald . 8 September 1975. p. 19.
11. "Newton powers his way to title". The Glasgow Herald . 16 September 1974. p. 5.
12. "Coles leaves his game to do the talking". The Glasgow Herald . 28 May 1973. p. 4.
13. "Match-play victory ends Horton's string of second places". The Glasgow Herald . 31 August 1970. p. 5.
14. "Bembridge overwhelms Rees in final". The Glasgow Herald . 8 September 1969. p. 4.
15. "Panton fails gallantly in match-play title attempt". The Glasgow Herald . 9 September 1968. p. 6.
16. "Thomson equals Braid's record in match-play". The Glasgow Herald . 11 September 1967. p. 5.
17. "Thomson's victory in match-play – Third triumph since 1964". The Glasgow Herald . 12 September 1966. p. 5.
18. "Coles keeps match-play title – Victory in final at nineteenth". The Glasgow Herald . 6 September 1965. p. 4.
19. Crawley, Leonard (7 September 1964). "Mechanical Coles proves worthy champion". The Daily Telegraph. p. 9 – via Newspapers.com.
20. "Match-play title for Thomas – Run of near misses ended". The Glasgow Herald . 9 September 1963. p. 9.
21. "Brown fights back to match-play title – Second win in three years". The Glasgow Herald . 10 September 1962. p. 4.
22. "Brown match-play champion – Great final with Weetman". The Glasgow Herald . 12 September 1960. p. 3.
23. "Match-play title for Snell – Chance of Ryder Cup place". The Glasgow Herald . 14 September 1959. p. 9.
24. "H Weetman regains match-play title – End of fine week's golf". The Glasgow Herald . 15 September 1958. p. 4.
25. "O'Connor's comfortable win in match-play final – Power and stamina decisive". The Glasgow Herald . 16 September 1957. p. 11.
26. "Panton wins match-play championship – Brilliant pitch to last green". The Glasgow Herald . 17 September 1956. p. 4.
27. "British match title final – Bousfield's win". The Glasgow Herald . 19 September 1955. p. 4.
28. "Second hole costly for Fallon". The Glasgow Herald . 4 October 1954. p. 4.
29. "Match-play title for Faulkner – Rees's record bid frustrated". The Glasgow Herald . 21 September 1953. p. 9.
30. "Third victory for Daly – Match-play title". The Glasgow Herald . 22 September 1952. p. 7.
31. "DJ Rees wins match-play title for fourth time". The Glasgow Herald . 25 September 1950. p. 6.
32. "Third match-play title for DJ Rees". The Glasgow Herald . 26 September 1949. p. 3.
33. "Professional golf "double" – Daly wins match-play title". The Glasgow Herald . 29 September 1947. p. 5.
34. "Adams well beaten at Hoylake – Cotton match-play champion". The Glasgow Herald . 30 September 1946. p. 2.
35. "Golf – R Horne wins at Walton Heath". The Glasgow Herald . 28 July 1945. p. 6.
36. "Thrilling golf final – Cotton beat Padgham at 37th hole". The Glasgow Herald . 4 May 1940. p. 3.
37. "Rees's second success in three years – Match-play title and £500". The Glasgow Herald . 17 September 1938. p. 3.
38. "Half in 2 beats gallant Scot – Victory for Alliss in £1,250 tourney". The Glasgow Herald . 20 September 1937. p. 3.
39. "Fine victory for Rees – Five down and wins on last green – E Whitcombe collapses in £1250 tournament". The Glasgow Herald . 19 September 1936. p. 3.
40. "Padgham beats Alliss – In thrilling final at Richmond – Close of the £1250 tournament". The Glasgow Herald . 14 September 1935. p. 3.
41. "Busson's great win – Thrilling finish to £1250 tourney – Close game with Whitcombe". The Glasgow Herald . 22 September 1934. p. 17.
42. "Golf – Alliss defeats Seymour – Final to £1250 tournament". The Glasgow Herald . 23 September 1933. p. 17.
43. "Cotton's record victory – Brilliant play in £1040 tournament – Perry defeated 10 and 8". The Glasgow Herald . 24 September 1932. p. 16.
44. "Golf – Padgham beats Seymour – In final of £1040 tourney". The Glasgow Herald . 26 September 1931. p. 18.
45. "Golf – The £1040 tournament – Whitcombe beats Cotton in final". The Glasgow Herald . 27 September 1930. p. 4.
46. "Abe Mitchell wins – Big victory in final of £1040 tournament". The Glasgow Herald . 21 September 1929. p. 16.
47. "Best post-war golf match – Final of the £1040 tournament – C Whitcombe's magnificent game". The Glasgow Herald . 22 September 1928. p. 12.
48. "Compston the victor – Braid out-played in the final – Youth triumphs in £1040 tournament". The Glasgow Herald . 24 September 1927. p. 12.
49. "Golf – Herd happy – Veteran golfer wins £1040 tournament". The Glasgow Herald . 25 September 1926. p. 15.
50. "The £1040 tournament – Compston's crowning triumph". The Glasgow Herald . 26 September 1925. p. 8.
51. "Golf – E R Whitcombe wins £750 tournament – Victory for the west". The Glasgow Herald . 11 October 1924. p. 15.
52. "The £750 tournament – Wilson wins extraordinary final". The Glasgow Herald . 6 October 1923. p. 15.
53. "£750 tournament final – George Gadd's great victory". The Glasgow Herald . 7 October 1922. p. 12.
54. "The £750 tournament – Seymour beat Gaudin in record final". The Glasgow Herald . 8 October 1921. p. 4.
55. "The £590 tournament – Mitchell wins for the second time". The Glasgow Herald . 9 October 1920. p. 9.
56. "Golf – The £590 tournament – Victory of Abe Mitchell". The Glasgow Herald . 3 October 1919. p. 13.
57. "Professional golf – The £400 tournament – George Duncan beats James Braid". The Glasgow Herald . 10 October 1913. p. 9.
58. "Golf – The £400 tournament – Keen contest in the final – Vardon beats Ray". The Glasgow Herald . 5 October 1912. p. 15.
59. "Golf – The £400 tournament – Braid beats Ray". The Glasgow Herald . 6 October 1911. p. 15.
60. "Golf – The "News of the World" tournament – Victory of Sherlock". The Glasgow Herald . 7 October 1910. p. 15.
61. "The professional golf tournament – Victory of Tom Ball". The Glasgow Herald . 8 October 1909. p. 9.
62. "Golf – The £240 tournament – Taylor beats Robson after an exciting match". The Glasgow Herald . 9 October 1908. p. 12.
63. "Golf – The Professional tournament – Braid's fine victory". The Glasgow Herald . 18 October 1907. p. 12.
64. "Golf – Professional golfers' tournament – £100 prize easily won by Herd". The Glasgow Herald . 5 October 1906. p. 15.
65. "Golf – The Professional tourney – Victory of J Braid". The Glasgow Herald . 6 October 1905. p. 11.
66. "Golf – Professional tournament – Taylor v Toogood in the final". The Glasgow Herald . 7 October 1904. p. 12.

External links

• Coverage on the European Tour's official site