| Catone | |
|---|---|
| Opera by George Frideric Handel | |
 Title page of the libretto, 1732 | |
| Librettist | after Pietro Metastasio |
| Language | Italian |
| Premiere | |
Catone (Cato, HWV A7) is an Italian opera by George Frideric Handel. It is one of Handel's nine pasticcio works made up of music and arias by other composers than him. The opera was first performed at the King's Theatre, Haymarket, London, on 4 November 1732.
The libretto was written by Metastasio.
A first version of his libretto was set to music by Leonardo Vinci whose opera premiered in Rome on 19 January 1728. [1] However, Metastasio's Catone in Utica was initially received with mixed feelings. While Naples's audiences had just accepted Dido's death in the flames at the end of Didone abbandonata (1724), Rome's were unwilling to watch Cato's agonizingly slow death which spanned the last two scenes of the opera, and unwilling to do without the expected "lieto fine". Neither were they impressed by the scene set in a disused sewer. Metastasio therefore revised his libretto (in particular the last act). In this second version Cato's death is simply reported and all that remains of the "acquedotti antichi" is the entrance to it, with a fountain dedicated to the goddess Isis. [2] This second version was set to music by Leo, whose opera premiered on 26 December 1728 in Venice. [3] [4]
Handel's Catone is primarily based on Leo's opera, and therefore on the second version of the libretto, to which further cuts and adjustments were made. For instance, the character of Fulvio is completely edited out in Handel's version. [5]
The subject of the opera, set in Utica, is the suicide of Cato the Younger (95 BC – April 46 BC) as he refuses to submit to Cesar.
Cesar has crossed the Rubicon and taken over the power of Rome by force. Cato, fervent champion of the republic, fled to Utica after the defeat and death of Pompey, his ally against Cesar. Despite his overwhelming military superiority, Cesar tries to win Cato as a friend; his marriage to Cato's daughter Marzia, who secretly loves him, might win Cato over. However, Cato has already promised Marzia to the Numidian prince Arbace. Emilia, widow of Cato's late-ally Pompey, also intrigues against Marzia's marriage to Cesar. Cato, unable to give up his law-abiding principles and seeing no way out of his face-off with Cesar, commits suicide in accordance with his Stoic philosophy.
| Role | Description | Voice type | Premiere cast, 2 November 1732 [6] |
|---|---|---|---|
| Catone | Cato the Younger | contralto castrato | Senesino |
| Marzia | Daughter of Catone, secretly in love with Cesare | soprano | Signora Strada |
| Emilia | Widow of Pompeo | soprano | Signora Celeste Gismondi |
| Arbace | Prince of Numidia, friend of Catone and lover of Marzia | contralto | Signora Bertolli |
| Cesare | Julius Caesar | bass | Montagnana |
The surviving London score of Handel's arrangement, now in the Staats- und Universitätsbibliothek Hamburg collection, is clearly based on a London copy of Leo's opera, confirming that Handel used Leo's opera as a starting point. This London copy of Leo's Catone in Utica, now in the possession of the Royal Academy of Music, was originally owned by Sir John Buckworth.
Sir John Buckworth was one of the directors of the Royal Academy in 1726 and a member of the directorate of the Opera of the Nobility in 1733, and would have known Handel. He also happens to be the dedicatee of Porpora's Semiramide which, just like Leo's Catone, was premiered at the Teatro San Giovanni Grisostomo (Venice) during the 1728–29 season. Buckworth also owned a copy of Porpora's Semiramide. He could have brought it back with him from Italy along with the copy of Leo's Catone. [2]
However, Handel also travelled to Italy during that season to recruit new singers for London. Therefore, he could have come across Leo's Catone in Utica when it was performed there and he could have taken the music back to England with him. [7]
In any case, whether brought back to London by Handel or Buckworth, the London copy of Leo's Catone in Utica, contains Handel's pencilled notes relating to cuts and changes made in the recitatives and to the elimination of the role of Fulvio. [2]
From Leo's score, Handel has kept essential parts of the recitatives, the overture, a sinfonia from the ritornello of the choir "Gia il mondo ti cede intero" and nine arias (originally 12 arias were kept, but 3 were later also removed). The rest, however, was swapped for arias by Hasse, Porpora and Vinci, three of the most fashionable opera composers of the time.
It is to be noted though that Handel's Catone also includes a couple of arias – maybe three – by Vivaldi. [8] [9]
Handel's artistic involvement in Catone is disputed. On the one hand, as several of the singers Handel worked with in London had previously sung Hasse's, Porpora's and Vinci's music, these swaps may have been arie di baule or, at least, arias taken from the singers' repertoires, rather than creative choices made by Handel (who is thought by some to have solely reshaped the recitatives and transposed arias by other composers). [7] For instance, Cesare's arias "Non paventa del mar le procelle", taken out of Porpora's 1730 Siface, and "È ver che all'amo intorno", taken out of Porpora's 1731 Poro, were both already sung by Montagnana in Porpora's original productions. [10] [11]
On the other hand, Handel's arrangement of Catone might provide a prime example of how he addressed the characterisation of the roles, both musically and dramatically. The drastic reduction of the long recitatives might have been indispensable for the London audience. The technical possibilities, the voice range and the artistic and creative possibilities of the singers would have influenced the selection of arias. But, although he was opposed to them for the sake of drama, Handel also had to adhere to a number of conventions, such as the distinction between first, second and third roles and the position of each singer in the opera company (reflected in the amount of their respective fee), all of which would have influenced the musical structure, as well as the number, type and position of each singer's aria. The bass Montagnana, for example, was an exceptional singer and Handel could not possibly expect him to accept a minor role. Therefore, the role of Cesar, that Leo had originally written for the soprano Domenico Gizzi, was given to him and consequently showcase arias for bass had to be inserted. The role of Arbace, which Leo wrote for Farinelli, was reduced to the point of being unrecognizable, Francesca Bertolli being unable to sing the original arias. Celeste Gismondi seems to have only sung arias she had already proven herself with. [12] [2] And, even though Anna Maria Strada could easily take on Lucia Facchinelli's prima donna part, she was still given an additional aria (Carestini's well-known showcase "Vo solcando un mar crudele" from Vinci's Artaserse), a choice which weakens the ending of the opera both dramatically and musically. (The end in Leo's opera, focuses on Cesare, who, though victorious in the battle, acclaims the moral victory of his opponent Cato and his suicide, and angrily throws down his own laurels and storms out of stage.) [12] [2]
Finally, Handel, obviously concerned with showcasing the new vocal stars of his opera company to the London public (especially at the beginning of the season), might have approved or made aria choices, that, if not relevant from a dramatic point of view, would have made sense commercially. [13] [14]
Scholars have suggested that the sinfonia (overture) and at least two arias of Leo's original work may be spurious. [15]
| Pasticcio aria [13] | Pasticcio singer | Composer | Original opera | Original aria [13] | Original singer |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| "Con sì bel nome in fronte" (Catone) | Senesino | Leo | Catone in Utica (1728) | "Con sì bel nome in fronte" (Catone), act 1, sc.1 [16] | Nicolò Grimaldi |
| "Non ti minaccio sdegno" (Marzia) | Anna Maria Strada | Leo | Catone in Utica (1728) | "Non ti minaccio sdegno" (Marzia), act 1, sc.2 [16] | Lucia Fachinelli |
| "Un raggio di speme" (Arbace) | Francesca Bertolli | Hasse | Dalisa (1730) | "Un raggio di stella" (Enrico), act 3, sc.3 [17] | Antonio Pasi |
| "Pensa di chi sei figlia" (Catone) | Senesino | Leo | Catone in Utica (1728) | "Pensa di chi sei figlia" (Catone), act 1, sc.5 [16] | Nicolò Grimaldi |
| "Non paventa del mar le procelle" (Cesare) | Montagnana | Porpora | Siface (1730) | "Non paventa del mar le procelle" (Libanio), act 1, sc.10 [10] | Montagnana |
| "Priva del caro sposo" (Emilia) | Celeste Gismondi | Porpora | Germanico in Germania (1732) | "Priva del caro sposo" (Rosmonda), act 2, sc.9 [18] | Angelo Maria Monticelli |
| "Vaghe labbra voi fingete"" (Emilia) | Celeste Gismondi | Hasse | Ulderica (1729) | "Vaghe labbra voi ridete" (Roderico), act 2, sc.6 [19] | Carestini |
| "È follia se nascondete" (Marzia) | Anna Maria Strada | Leo | Catone in Utica (1728) | "È follia se nascondete" (Marzia), act 1, sc.15 [16] | Lucia Fachinelli |
| "Mi conosci e sai chi sono?" (Catone) | Senesino | Leo | Catone in Utica (1728) | Mi conosci e sai chi sono?" (Catone), act 2, sc.2 [16] | Nicolò Grimaldi |
| "Vaghe luci, luci belle" (Arbace) | Francesca Bertolli | Vivaldi | Ipermestra (1727) | "Vaghe luci, luci belle" (Linceo), act 1, sc.1 [20] | Lucia Lanzetti |
| "Agitato da più venti" (Cesare) | Montagnana | Vivaldi | ? | ? | ? |
| "So che nascondi" (Cesare) | Montagnana | Vivaldi | Orlando Furioso (1727) | "Benché nasconda" (Astolfo), act 2, sc.2 | Gaetano Pinetti |
| "Dovea svenarti all'ora" (Catone) | Senesino | Leo | Catone in Utica (1728) | "Dovea svenarti all'ora" (Catone), act 2, sc.13 [16] | Nicolò Grimaldi |
| "Fra tanti pensieri" (Emilia) | Celeste Gismondi | Hasse | Demetrio (1732) | "Fra tanti pensieri" (Cleonice), act 1, sc.3 [21] | Bordoni-Hasse |
| "Confusa, smarrita spiegarti vorrei" (Marzia) | Anna Maria Strada | Leo | Catone in Utica (1728) | "Confusa, smarrita spiegarti vorrei" (Marzia), act 3, sc.2 [16] | Lucia Fachinelli |
| "Quando piomba improvvisa saetta" (Arbace) | Francesca Bertolli | Porpora | Poro (1731) | "Quando piomba improvvisa saetta" (Gandarte), act 2, sc.15 [22] | Anna Bagnolesi |
| "È ver che all'amo intorno" (Cesare) | Montagnana | Porpora | Poro (1731) | "È ver che all'amo intorno" (Timagene), act 2, sc.10 [22] | Montagnana |
| "Vede il nocchier la sponda" (Emilia) | Celeste Gismondi | Hasse | Euristero (1732) | "Vede il nocchier la sponda" (Ormonte), act 2, sc.10 [23] | Caffarelli |
| "Per darvi alcun pegno" (Catone) | Senesino | Leo | Catone in Utica (1728) | "Per darvi alcun pegno" (Catone), act 3, sc.12 [16] | Nicolò Grimaldi |
| "Vo solcando un mar crudele" (Marzia) | Anna Maria Strada | Vinci | Artaserse (1730) | "Vo solcando un mar crudele" (Arbace), act 1, sc.15 [24] | Carestini |
The opera was only performed five times, on 4, 7 11, 14 and 18 November 1732. [4]
The Daily Advertiser from 6 November 1732 reports that:
There were present a very numerous Audience; and Signora Celeste Gismondi, who lately arriv'd here, perform'd a principal Part in it with universal Applause. We hear that this Opera was not compos'd by Mr Handell, but by some very eminent Master in Italy. [6]
However, having been to the premiere of Catone at the King's Theatre, the 1st Earl of Bristol wrote in a letter:
I am just come from a long, dull, and consequently tiresome Opera of Handel's, whose genius seems quite exhausted. […] The only thing I liked in it was our Naples acquaintance, Celestina; who is not so pretty as she was, but sings better than she did.
According to the commercial release sheet of the 2017 Glossa recording (GCD 923511):
The pasticcio's plot functions admirably, the arias are stunning, both individually and collectively [and it] is a feast of sparkling crowd-pleasing virtuosity. [26]
Farinelli was the stage name of Carlo Maria Michelangelo Nicola Broschi, a celebrated Italian castrato singer of the 18th century and one of the greatest singers in the history of opera. Farinelli has been described as having had soprano vocal range and as having sung the highest note customary at the time, C6.
Pietro Antonio Domenico Trapassi, better known by his pseudonym of Pietro Metastasio, was an Italian poet and librettist, considered the most important writer of opera seria libretti.
Opera seria is an Italian musical term which refers to the noble and "serious" style of Italian opera that predominated in Europe from the 1710s to about 1770. The term itself was rarely used at the time and only attained common usage once opera seria was becoming unfashionable and beginning to be viewed as something of a historical genre. The popular rival to opera seria was opera buffa, the 'comic' opera that took its cue from the improvisatory commedia dell'arte.
Giovanni Bononcini was an Italian Baroque composer, cellist, singer and teacher, one of a family of string players and composers.
Davide Perez was an Italian opera composer born in Naples of Italian parents, and later resident court composer at Lisbon from 1752. He staged three operas on librettos of Metastasio at Lisbon with huge success in 1753, 1754, and 1755. Following the 1755 Lisbon earthquake, Perez turned from opera mostly to church music.
Gioacchino Conti, best known as Gizziello or Egizziello, was an Italian soprano castrato opera singer.
Max Emanuel Cenčić is a Croatian countertenor. He was a member of the Vienna Boys' Choir.
Catone in Utica is an opera libretto by Metastasio, that was originally written for Leonardo Vinci's 1727 opera. Following Vinci's success, Metastasio's text was used by numerous composers of the baroque and classical eras for their own operas, including Pietro Torri (1736), Antonio Vivaldi (1737), Giovanni Battista Ferrandini (1753) and J. C. Bach (1761).
Geminiano Giacomelli was an Italian composer.
Carlo Scalzi was an Italian castrato who had an active performance career in major opera houses in Italy from 1718-1738. He was also heard in London in 1733–1734 where he notably created the role of Alceste in the world premiere of George Frideric Handel's Arianna in Creta. The librettist Pietro Metastasio described Scalzi as a "very unique singer" and likened his voice to that of the famous castrato Farinelli.
Anna Girò, also known as l'Annina del Prete Rosso, la Nina del Prete Rosso, or l'Annina della Pietà, was the stage name of Anna Maria(?) Maddalena Tessieri, an Italian mezzo-soprano/contralto of the 18th century. She is best remembered for her numerous collaborations with composer Antonio Vivaldi who wrote operatic roles for her. She is the singer who performed the greatest number of Vivaldi's operas, the one who kept them in her repertoire the longest time and who made them known across the largest geographical area.
Franco Maximiliano Fagioli is an Argentine operatic countertenor.
Artaserse is an opera in three acts composed by Johann Adolph Hasse to an Italian libretto adapted from that by Metastasio by Giovanni Boldini first shown in Venice on 11 February 1730.
Telemaco, ossia L'isola di Circe is a 1718 opera by Alessandro Scarlatti to a libretto by Carlo Sigismondo Capece, court poet to Queen Maria Casimira of Poland, living in exile in Rome, for the Teatro Capranica in Rome, where it was premiered during the carnival season. The opera was revived in 2005 by the Schwetzingen Festival and the Deutsche Oper am Rhein.
Celeste Gismondi, originally known as Celeste Resse and nicknamed La Celestina, was an Italian soprano opera singer, who performed a major role in the première of some works by George Frideric Handel, including Orlando.
Alessandro nell'Indie is a libretto in three acts by Pietro Metastasio. It was set to music around ninety times firstly by Leonardo Vinci, whose version premiered in Rome on 2 January 1730. The libretto was the fourth of five that Metastasio wrote for the Teatro delle Dame in Rome between 1727 and 1730. The work was dedicated to the Stuart pretender to the British throne, James Francis Edward Stuart, then resident in Rome.
Siface re di Numidia is a libretto in three acts by Pietro Metastasio. It is a reworking of La forza della virtù by de:Domenico David and was Metastasio's first work as a librettist. it was first performed with a setting to music by Francesco Feo on 13 May 1723 at the Teatro San Bartolomeo, Naples.
Siroe re di Persia is a libretto in three acts by Pietro Metastasio. Set to music by Leonardo Vinci, it was first performed on 2 February 1726 at the Teatro San Giovanni Grisostomo, Venice. It was subsequently set to music at least 35 times by different composers.
Demetrio is an opera libretto in three acts by Pietro Metastasio. It was first performed to music composed by Antonio Caldara on 4 November 1731 during celebrations of the name day of the Holy Roman Emperor Charles VI in Vienna. Different composers later used it when composing operas named Alceste, Cleonice and Demetrio, rè della Siria. With over fifty settings it was one of Metastasio's most popular works.
