Coetus Internationalis Patrum

Last updated

The Coetus Internationalis Patrum (Latin: International Group of Fathers) was the most important and influential interest group of the "conservative" or "traditionalist" minority at the Second Vatican Council. [1]

Contents

Organization and membership

During the first session of the council, they acted informally as an unnamed "study group" of individual Council fathers of traditionalist orientation. [2] Between the first and second sessions of the council, Archbishops Marcel Lefebvre (Superior CSSp) and Geraldo de Proença Sigaud (Diamantina, Brazil) and Bishop José Maurício da Rocha (Bragance, Brazil)[ failed verification ] decided to organize a more formal group of like-minded bishops. [3] The group soon established a steering committee, of archbishops Lefebvre and Proença Sigaud, bishops Luigi Maria Carli (Segni), Antônio de Castro Mayer (Campos, Brazil). and the Abbot of Solesmes, Jean Prou OSB. [4] After the second session of the council, the group came formally into existence, issuing a circular letter, signed by archbishops Lefebvre, Proença Sigaud, Cabana (Sherbrooke, Quebec, Canada), Silva Santiago (Concepción, Chile (emeritus)), Lacchio (Changsha, China) and Cordeiro (Karachi, Pakistan), which announced a group of Council fathers attached to the traditions of the Church. [5]

Sources close to the organization report it had 250 members [6] out of the approximately 2,400 bishops attending the Council at any given time. [7] Other studies describe it either as having 16 "core members" [8] or as having 5 members in the steering committee, 55 general members, and 9 supporting cardinals. [4] In addition to the Council fathers, there were also theologians who formed a minor group that helped formulate the group's responses on issues being discussed in the council. [9] On specific topics they were able to gather additional adherents among the Council fathers; they obtained 435 signatures on a petition calling for an explicit condemnation of communism. [10]

Issues

As a member of the Preparatory Commission for the Second Vatican Council, Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre had taken part in the discussions about the draft documents submitted to the bishops for consideration at the council. His concerns with these proposals led to the formation of the study group to deal with a number of issues at the council. A primary element of their agenda was opposition to the principle of episcopal collegiality, which they feared could undermine papal primacy [11] and the rights of individual bishops. [12] They thought there should be a specific condemnation of communism [13] and that there should be a separate Council document elevating the status of the Blessed Virgin Mary, not merely a chapter in Lumen gentium . [14]

Continuing complaints from the group about the presence of Protestant observers led Pope Paul VI, who was "concerned not to alienate the traditionalists", to ask Cardinal Augustin Bea "if perhaps the presence of the 'separated brethren' and their 'mentality' were 'excessively dominating the council, thus diminishing its psychological freedom.' (He) emphasized that protecting 'the coherence of the teaching of the Catholic Church' was more important than pleasing the observers.'" After thus consulting Cardinal Bea, the Pope decided not to disinvite the observers. [15]

Influence

Their influence on the outcome of the council was decidedly mixed. Their opposition to the principle of episcopal collegiality, and specifically to the granting of greater authority to conferences of bishops, made it difficult for them to work effectively with the national and regional bishops' conferences. [16] Some have seen the Group's opposition to collegial decision-making also had an effect on their reluctance to achieve consensus by developing compromise positions. [17]

They did, however, have more success using other channels. The Group had many contacts in the Papal Curia who shared their traditionalist point of view, and in the early years of the Council they were effective in using these back channels to make their opinions known at the highest levels. [18] In the later years of the council, they produced an almost uninterrupted flood of modi (amendments) to the proposals before the council. [19] These moves were not always successful; between the third and fourth sessions the group was repudiated by Cardinal Cicognani, the Vatican Secretary of State, for their divisive influence on the assembly. [20]

On specific issues, they failed to defeat the constitution on the liturgy, which introduced the vernacular and gave greater authority to episcopal conferences, or the decree on ecumenism, which some say undermined the traditional belief that the Catholic Church was the unique path to salvation. [21] Their petition insisting on a condemnation of communism in the constitution on the Church in the Modern World was only slightly more successful; it led to the insertion of a footnote which referred to an earlier papal condemnation of communism, without mentioning the word. [13] Perhaps their greatest success involved a last minute papal intervention, where Pope Paul VI insisted on the insertion of an explanatory note into the document on the Church, which significantly weakened the force of its claims for collegiality. [22]

Later Reemergence

In October 2019, shortly before the opening of the Synod of Bishops for the Pan-Amazon region, an anonymous group of bishops and Catholic laypeople calling itself the Coetus Internationalis Patrum Working Group released a text, claiming that four theses drawn from the Synod's Instrumentum Laboris or Working Document were unacceptable as they contradicted points of Catholic doctrine. [23]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Marcel Lefebvre</span> French traditionalist Catholic archbishop (1905–1991)

Marcel François Marie Joseph Lefebvre was a French Catholic archbishop who greatly influenced modern traditional Catholicism. In 1970, he founded the Society of Saint Pius X (SSPX), a community to train seminarians, in the village of Écône, Switzerland. In 1988, he was excommunicated from the Catholic Church for consecrating four bishops against the express prohibition of Pope John Paul II.

<i>Peritus</i> Invited expert at a church council

Peritus is the title given to Roman Catholic theologians attending an ecumenical council to give advice. At the Second Vatican Council, some periti accompanied individual bishops or groups of bishops from various countries. Others were formally appointed advisers to the whole council.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">André Siegfried</span> French academic, geographer and political writer

André Siegfried was a French academic, geographer and political writer best known to English speakers for his commentaries on American, Canadian, and British politics.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ernesto Ruffini</span>

Ernesto Ruffini was an Italian cardinal of the Catholic Church who served as Archbishop of Palermo from 1945 until his death, and was elevated to the cardinalate in 1946 by Pope Pius XII.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Philippe Poirrier</span> French historian

Philippe Poirrier, born in 1963, is a French historian, specialist in French contemporary cultural history.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Albert Ndongmo</span>

Albert Ndongmo was Bishop of Nkongsamba in Cameroon between June 1964 and January 1973. In 1970 he was arrested, accused of treasonous dealings with rebels, and sentenced to death by a military tribunal. His sentence was later commuted to life imprisonment, of which he served five years before the President ordered his release. After being released he moved to Rome and then to Canada, where he spent the rest of his life.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Christian Delporte</span> French historian (born 1958)

Christian Delporte, is a French historian specialized in political and cultural history of France in the twentieth century, including the history of media, image and political communication.

Claude Mossé was a French historian specializing in the history of Ancient Greece.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jean-Philippe Warren</span> Canadian sociologist from Quebec (born 1970)

Jean-Philippe Warren is a Canadian sociologist from Quebec.

Jean-Philippe Genet is a French medievalist, specialist of England.

Habib Tawa in Tripoli, Lebanon is a French historian, journalist and mathematician.

Augustin Fliche was a 20th-century French historian who mainly dealt with the history of the Church in the Middle Ages. He was a professor at the University of Montpellier and also visiting professor at the University of Leuven in 1925–1927 and 1946–1947.

<i>Études</i> (journal) Academic journal

Études is a historic Roman Catholic journal published by the Society of Jesus (Jesuits). It was established by Ivan Gagarin in 1856. Its editor is François Euvé. Each issue is printed as a journal and published online on Cairn.info.

Daniel Moulinet is a French priest and historian, professor of contemporary history at the Catholic University of Lyon.

Pierre-Jean Souriac is a contemporary French historian, a Lecturer in Modern History at Jean Moulin University Lyon 3.

Jeanne Gaillard was a French historian and a member of the French Resistance during the Second World War.

Jean-Édouard-Lucien Rupp was a French prelate of the Catholic Church who served as Bishop of Monaco from 1962 to 1971 and then worked in the diplomatic service of the Holy See until he retired in 1980.

Stéphane François is a French political scientist who specializes on radical right-wing movements. He also studies conspiracy theories, political ecology and countercultures.

Philippe Levillain was a French historian and academic. He specialized in the history of Catholicism and the papacy and notably wrote a historic encyclopedia of the papacy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jean-Claude Perrot</span> French historian (1928–2021)

Jean-Claude Perrot was a French historian. He specialized in urban history, economic politics, demography, and statistics. His studies focused around 18th-Century France and he was a professor at the Sorbonne University Association and the School for Advanced Studies in the Social Sciences. He was also President of the French Institute for Demographic Studies.

References

  1. ↑ Roy, Philippe (2012), "Le Coetus Internationalis Patrum au concile Vatican II: genèse d'une dissidence ?", Histoire@Politique. Politique, Culture, Société (in French), Paris (18): 2 [43], ISSN   1954-3670
  2. ↑ Roy, Philippe (2012), "Le Coetus Internationalis Patrum au concile Vatican II: genèse d'une dissidence ?", Histoire@Politique. Politique, Culture, Société (in French), Paris (18): 5 [46], ISSN   1954-3670
  3. ↑ Roy, Philippe (2012), "Le Coetus Internationalis Patrum au concile Vatican II: genèse d'une dissidence ?", Histoire@Politique. Politique, Culture, Société (in French), Paris (18): 5–6 [46–47], ISSN   1954-3670
  4. 1 2 Roy-Lysencourt, Philippe (2014), Les Membres du Coetus Internationalis Patrum au Concile Vatican II: Inventaire des Interventions et Souscriptions des Adherents et Sympathisants, Liste des Signataires d'occasion et des Théologiens, Instrumenta Theologica (in French), vol. 37, Leuven: Maurits Sabbe Library, Faculty of Theology and Religious Studies, KU Leuven / Peeters, pp. 483–4, ISBN   9789042930872
  5. ↑ Roy, Philippe (2012), "Le Coetus Internationalis Patrum au concile Vatican II: genèse d'une dissidence ?", Histoire@Politique. Politique, Culture, Société (in French), Paris (18): 9 [50], ISSN   1954-3670
  6. ↑ A Biography of Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre, by Father Ramón Anglés
  7. ↑ O'Malley, John W., S. J. (2008), What Happened at Vatican II (Kindle ed.), Cambridge: Harvard University Press, location 455, ISBN   978-0-674-03169-2 {{citation}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  8. ↑ Wilde, Melissa J. (2007), Vatican II: A Sociological Analysis of Religious Change, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, ISBN   978-0-691-11829-1
  9. ↑ Roy, Philippe (2012), "Le Coetus Internationalis Patrum au concile Vatican II: genèse d'une dissidence ?", Histoire@Politique. Politique, Culture, Société (in French), Paris (18): 7–8 [48–49], ISSN   1954-3670
  10. ↑ Wilde, Melissa J. (2004), "How Culture Mattered at Vatican II: Collegiality Trumps Authority in the Council's Social Movement Organizations" (PDF), American Sociological Review, 69 (4): 589, doi:10.1177/000312240406900406, S2CID   144049244, archived from the original (PDF) on 2010-06-22, retrieved 2015-06-11
  11. ↑ Wrighton, Basil (1984), Collegiality: error of Vatican II (2), Society of Saint Pius X (District of the USA)
  12. ↑ Wilde, Melissa J. (2004), "How Culture Mattered at Vatican II: Collegiality Trumps Authority in the Council's Social Movement Organizations" (PDF), American Sociological Review, 69 (4): 582–583, doi:10.1177/000312240406900406, S2CID   144049244, archived from the original (PDF) on 2010-06-22, retrieved 2015-06-11
  13. 1 2 O'Malley, John W., S. J. (2008), What Happened at Vatican II (Kindle ed.), Cambridge: Harvard University Press, location 5209-5210, ISBN   978-0-674-03169-2 {{citation}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  14. ↑ Wilde, Melissa J. (2004), "How Culture Mattered at Vatican II: Collegiality Trumps Authority in the Council's Social Movement Organizations" (PDF), American Sociological Review, 69 (4): 594–596, doi:10.1177/000312240406900406, S2CID   144049244, archived from the original (PDF) on 2010-06-22, retrieved 2015-06-11
  15. ↑ Priest who was present at the start reviews bold ecumenical vision of Vatican II, John L Allen Jr, January 31, 2003, Word from Rome, National Catholic Reporter
  16. ↑ Wilde, Melissa J. (2004), "How Culture Mattered at Vatican II: Collegiality Trumps Authority in the Council's Social Movement Organizations" (PDF), American Sociological Review, 69 (4): 577, 590–591, doi:10.1177/000312240406900406, S2CID   144049244, archived from the original (PDF) on 2010-06-22, retrieved 2015-06-11
  17. ↑ Wilde, Melissa J. (2004), "How Culture Mattered at Vatican II: Collegiality Trumps Authority in the Council's Social Movement Organizations" (PDF), American Sociological Review, 69 (4): 599, doi:10.1177/000312240406900406, S2CID   144049244, archived from the original (PDF) on 2010-06-22, retrieved 2015-06-11
  18. ↑ Roy, Philippe (2012), "Le Coetus Internationalis Patrum au concile Vatican II: genèse d'une dissidence ?", Histoire@Politique. Politique, Culture, Société (in French), Paris (18): 8 [49], ISSN   1954-3670
  19. ↑ Roy, Philippe (2012), "Le Coetus Internationalis Patrum au concile Vatican II: genèse d'une dissidence ?", Histoire@Politique. Politique, Culture, Société (in French), Paris (18): 8 [49], ISSN   1954-3670, un flot presqu'ininterrompu de modi
  20. ↑ Roy, Philippe (2012), "Le Coetus Internationalis Patrum au concile Vatican II: genèse d'une dissidence ?", Histoire@Politique. Politique, Culture, Société (in French), Paris (18): 12 [53], ISSN   1954-3670
  21. ↑ Roy, Philippe (2012), "Le Coetus Internationalis Patrum au concile Vatican II: genèse d'une dissidence ?", Histoire@Politique. Politique, Culture, Société (in French), Paris (18): 14–15 [55–56], ISSN   1954-3670
  22. ↑ Roy, Philippe (2012), "Le Coetus Internationalis Patrum au concile Vatican II: genèse d'une dissidence ?", Histoire@Politique. Politique, Culture, Société (in French), Paris (18): 15 [56], ISSN   1954-3670
  23. ↑ Pentin, Edward (1 October 2019). "Group Releases Propositions Challenging 'Unacceptable' Elements of Synod Working Doc". National Catholic Register. Retrieved 5 October 2019.

Further reading

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.