Council of Winchester (1070)

Last updated

The Council of Winchester was a church council convened in April 1070 by William the Conqueror and three papal legates: Ermenfrid, Bishop of Sion, Cardinal John Minutus, and Peter. It deposed Stigand, Archbishop of Canterbury, and several other native English bishops and abbots and left their offices free to be filled by William's largely Norman appointees, thereby transforming the highest levels of the English Church. It also promulgated a large number of measures relating to ecclesiastical practice in England, of which some parallel aspects of the Gregorian Reforms advocated by the Papacy in the late 11th century. [1]

Contents

Background

When Duke William of Normandy, known in English history as William the Conqueror, successfully invaded England in 1066, he did so with support from the Papacy which he had probably gained, in part, by the argument that the English Church stood in dire need of reform from without. [2] Both William and the Pope, Alexander II, wished to clear up irregularities in the effective administration of the Church, though they differed as to the authority that the Pope was entitled to exercise over secular rulers, William wishing to retain in England the same independence in such matters that he already enjoyed in Normandy. [3] During the years 1068 to 1070 William was much occupied in establishing his rule over England against the opposition of many of his Anglo-Saxon subjects, culminating in an abortive uprising in Yorkshire and the consequent Harrying of the North, and an attempted invasion by king Sweyn Estrithson of Denmark. [4] Some of his opponents were bishops, whom even he could not deprive of their offices so easily as laymen. [5]

One especially thorny problem was the position of the Archbishop of Canterbury, Stigand, whose legitimacy in that office was for several reasons doubtful and who before the Conquest had in secular affairs been a supporter of the House of Godwin. [6] In early 1070 the Pope, apparently at William's invitation, sent three legates to England: Ermenfrid, Bishop of Sion; Cardinal John Minutus, priest of Santa Maria in Trastevere; and Peter, probably also a cardinal and priest of San Crisogono. Once in England they issued summonses – of which the text of one, to Bishop Wulfstan of Worcester, survives – to appear at a church council in Winchester. [7] Wulfstan's summons was issued in the names of Peter and John only, which raises the possibility that Ermenfrid's position was subordinate to them. [8]

Sources

Drawing from a late 11th-century manuscript, the Ramsey Benedictional (Paris, Bibliotheque nationale de France, ms. Latin 987, f. 111r), showing William the Conqueror's second coronation in the Old Minster, Winchester on 4 April 1070 Ramsey Benedictional.png
Drawing from a late 11th-century manuscript, the Ramsey Benedictional (Paris, Bibliothèque nationale de France, ms. Latin 987, f. 111r), showing William the Conqueror's second coronation in the Old Minster, Winchester on 4 April 1070
Stigand, Archbishop of Canterbury, depicted on the Bayeux Tapestry Bayeux Tapestry scene31 detail Stigand.jpg
Stigand, Archbishop of Canterbury, depicted on the Bayeux Tapestry

No full report of the proceedings at Winchester has survived, [9] though we do have a set of capitula or headings relating to the canons of a church council which can probably be identified with this one. [1] Some account of it can also be found in Milo Crispin's Vita Lanfranci, a letter from Lanfranc to Alexander II, the profession of Remigius de Fécamp to Lanfranc, the Worcester Chronicle , and the chronicles of John of Worcester, William of Malmesbury (the Gesta Pontificum Anglorum ) and Orderic Vitalis. [10]

Coronation

On 4 April, Easter Day, William was crowned for the second time at Winchester's Old Minster (his first coronation having been at Westminster Abbey on Christmas Day 1066) [11] with the papal legates officiating. [12] There is no mention of any swearing of oaths by or to the king, and William's legitimacy continued to rest on his first coronation, [13] the ceremony's purpose being not to establish but to reaffirm his authority and his status as a favoured son of the Church. [12]

Council

On 7 or 11 April 1070 the council itself was convened [14] under the presidency of the king alone, according to the Vita Lanfranci, or of the king in association with the legates, according to Orderic. [15] William's intention, John of Worcester tells us, was to "appoint men of his own race [to] strengthen his position in the newly acquired kingdom", and in order to achieve this he "stripped of their offices many bishops and abbots who had not been condemned for any obvious reason, whether of conciliar or secular law". [16]

The most prominent of the council's victims was Archbishop Stigand. He had remained in office up to this point in William's reign partly, it may be, because of his great wealth and influence, and partly because he was of an advanced age and could hardly live forever. However, the Pope was implacably opposed to him, excommunicating him and referring to him in a letter to William as "a source of evil". [5] [6] At Winchester he faced charges of having originally gained Canterbury uncanonically when the previous archbishop, Robert of Jumièges, fled the country without abdicating or being deposed; of having then been confirmed in office not by a legitimate pope but by an antipope, Benedict X; and of having held both Canterbury and the bishopric of Winchester in plurality, contrary to the canons of the Church. His deposition by the council can have surprised few observers, and he spent the short remainder of his life imprisoned in Winchester, dying in February 1072.

Other bishops were likewise purged, either at Winchester or at a further council held at Windsor just a few weeks later at Whitsun. Stigand's brother Æthelmær, Bishop of Elmham, was deposed, perhaps for being married; Leofwine, Bishop of Lichfield, who was guilty of the same offence and who had ignored his summons to the council, was excommunicated preparatory to deposition; Æthelric, Bishop of Selsey, was found guilty of unknown offences, deposed and imprisoned; and Æthelwine, Bishop of Durham, who had fled to the Scottish court on the collapse of the 1069 Northern rebellion, was outlawed. Only three native English bishops were left in office. According to John of Worcester many abbots were also deposed at Winchester, and Marc Morris believes that the abbots of Abingdon, St Albans and St Augustine's, Canterbury were among them. [17] [18] They may also have made the first moves towards transferring the see of Dorchester on Thames to Lincoln. [19]

The gist of further provisions of the council can be gleaned from their surviving capitula, assuming these to relate to Winchester in 1070. So for example, the Mass was not to be celebrated with ale or water rather than with wine, nor with brass chalices, altars were only to be made of stone, baptisms were to take place only at Easter or Whitsun except in case of emergency, and ordinations only on Ember days, clergy were not to marry or live with concubines, and were not to buy their ordinations. [1] Further, no bishop was to hold more than one see, penances for crimes were to be decided by bishops only, [20] runaway monks were to be excommunicated and not admitted into the secular priesthood or the army, [21] sees held in plurality were forbidden, annual diocesan synods were to be held, archdeacons appointed, and tithes paid. [22] The overall policy observable here is the one followed in English church legislation for the next seventy years: to enforce celibacy, fight simony, and so far as possible remove churchmen from secular affairs. [23]

Outcome

Unsurprisingly, when William came to appoint replacements for the purged Anglo-Saxon bishops he mainly chose Normans, for the most part chaplains in the chapel royal or churchmen otherwise well known to him. Lanfranc, Abbot of St Stephen's, Caen, was raised to the archbishopric of Canterbury, and Walchelin, a canon of Rouen, to Winchester. One exceptional case was the bishopric of Durham, to which William appointed a Lotharingian, Walcher. Of the papal legates, John and Peter crossed to Normandy at Whitsun, where John remained. Ermenfrid presided over the Council of Windsor at Whitsun, then followed his brother-legates to Normandy where he helped to persuade Lanfranc to accept his archbishopric. [24]

Footnotes

  1. 1 2 3 Pfaff 2009, p. 103.
  2. ↑ Morris 2012, pp. 142–143, 237.
  3. ↑ Stenton 1971, p. 658.
  4. ↑ "William I [known as William the Conqueror]". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.). Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/29448.(Subscription or UK public library membership required.)
  5. 1 2 Morris 2012, p. 238.
  6. 1 2 Cowdrey 2012.
  7. ↑ Bates 2018, pp. 334–335.
  8. ↑ Whitelock, Brett & Brooke 1981, p. 564.
  9. ↑ Stenton 1971, p. 660.
  10. ↑ Whitelock, Brett & Brooke 1981, pp. 569–574.
  11. ↑ Biddle, Martin (2018). The Search for Winchester's Anglo-Saxon Minsters. Oxford: Archaeopress. p. 60. ISBN   9781784918576 . Retrieved 14 June 2023.
  12. 1 2 Morris 2012, p. 236.
  13. ↑ Bates 2018, p. 336.
  14. ↑ Baxter, Stephen (2007). The Earls of Mercia: Lordship and Power in Late Anglo-Saxon England. Oxford: Oxford University Press. p. 276. ISBN   9780199230983 . Retrieved 14 June 2023.
  15. ↑ Bates 2018, p. 337.
  16. ↑ "Æthelmaer". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.). Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/101200.(Subscription or UK public library membership required.)
  17. ↑ Morris 2012, pp. 238–240.
  18. ↑ Bates 2018, pp. 334–335, 337.
  19. ↑ Whitelock, Brett & Brooke 1981, p. 566.
  20. ↑ Barlow 1979, p. 124.
  21. ↑ Gerrard, Daniel M. G. (2017). The Church at War: The Military Activities of Bishops, Abbots and Other Clergy in England, c. 900–1200. London: Routledge. p. 160. ISBN   9781472423757 . Retrieved 15 June 2023.
  22. ↑ Bates 2018, pp. 337–338.
  23. ↑ Barlow 1979, pp. 123–124.
  24. ↑ Bates 2018, pp. 334, 336, 338.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ealdred (archbishop of York)</span> Archbishop of York from 1060 to 1069

Ealdred was Abbot of Tavistock, Bishop of Worcester, and Archbishop of York in early medieval England. He was related to a number of other ecclesiastics of the period. After becoming a monk at the monastery at Winchester, he was appointed Abbot of Tavistock Abbey in around 1027. In 1046 he was named to the Bishopric of Worcester. Ealdred, besides his episcopal duties, served Edward the Confessor, the King of England, as a diplomat and as a military leader. He worked to bring one of the king's relatives, Edward the Exile, back to England from Hungary to secure an heir for the childless king.

Ælfheah, more commonly known today as Alphege, was an Anglo-Saxon Bishop of Winchester, later Archbishop of Canterbury. He became an anchorite before being elected abbot of Bath Abbey. His reputation for piety and sanctity led to his promotion to the episcopate and, eventually, to his becoming archbishop. Ælfheah furthered the cult of Dunstan and also encouraged learning. He was captured by Viking raiders in 1011 during the siege of Canterbury and killed by them the following year after refusing to allow himself to be ransomed. Ælfheah was canonised as a saint in 1078. Thomas Becket, a later Archbishop of Canterbury, prayed to Ælfheah just before his murder in Canterbury Cathedral in 1170.

Pope Alexander II, born Anselm of Baggio, was the head of the Roman Catholic Church and ruler of the Papal States from 1061 to his death in 1073. Born in Milan, Anselm was deeply involved in the Pataria reform movement. Elected according to the terms of his predecessor's bull, In nomine Domini, Anselm's was the first election by the cardinals without the participation of the people and minor clergy of Rome. He also authorized the Norman Conquest of England in 1066.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lanfranc</span> Italian jurist and theologian, Archbishop of Canterbury from 1070 to 1089

Lanfranc, OSB was a celebrated Italian jurist who renounced his career to become a Benedictine monk at Bec in Normandy. He served successively as prior of Bec Abbey and abbot of St Stephen's Abbey in Caen, Normandy and then as Archbishop of Canterbury in England, following its conquest by William the Conqueror. He is also variously known as Lanfranc of Pavia, Lanfranc of Bec, and Lanfranc of Canterbury. In his lifetime, he was regarded as the greatest theologian of his generation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stigand</span> Archbishop of Canterbury from 1052 to 1070

Stigand was an Anglo-Saxon churchman in pre-Norman Conquest England who became Archbishop of Canterbury. His birth date is unknown, but by 1020 he was serving as a royal chaplain and advisor. He was named Bishop of Elmham in 1043, and was later Bishop of Winchester and Archbishop of Canterbury. Stigand was an advisor to several members of the Anglo-Saxon and Norman English royal dynasties, serving six successive kings. Excommunicated by several popes for his pluralism in holding the two sees, or bishoprics, of Winchester and Canterbury concurrently, he was finally deposed in 1070, and his estates and personal wealth were confiscated by William the Conqueror. Stigand was imprisoned at Winchester, where he died.

Robert of Jumièges was the first Norman Archbishop of Canterbury. He had previously served as prior of the Abbey of St Ouen at Rouen in Normandy, before becoming abbot of Jumièges Abbey, near Rouen, in 1037. He was a good friend and adviser to the king of England, Edward the Confessor, who appointed him bishop of London in 1044, and then archbishop in 1051. Robert's time as archbishop lasted only about eighteen months. He had already come into conflict with the powerful Earl Godwin and, while archbishop, made attempts to recover lands lost to Godwin and his family. He also refused to consecrate Spearhafoc, Edward's choice to succeed Robert as Bishop of London. The rift between Robert and Godwin culminated in Robert's deposition and exile in 1052.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thomas of Bayeux</span> Archbishop of York from 1070 to 1100

Thomas of Bayeux was Archbishop of York from 1070 until 1100. He was educated at Liège and became a royal chaplain to Duke William of Normandy, who later became King William I of England. After the Norman Conquest, the king nominated Thomas to succeed Ealdred as Archbishop of York. After Thomas' election, Lanfranc, Archbishop of Canterbury, demanded an oath from Thomas to obey him and any future Archbishops of Canterbury; this was part of Lanfranc's claim that Canterbury was the primary bishopric, and its holder the head of the English Church. Thomas countered that York had never made such an oath. As a result, Lanfranc refused to consecrate him. The King eventually persuaded Thomas to submit, but Thomas and Lanfranc continued to clash over ecclesiastical issues, including the primacy of Canterbury, which dioceses belonged to the province of York, and the question of how York's obedience to Canterbury would be expressed.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gisa (bishop of Wells)</span> 11th-century Bishop of Wells

Gisa was Bishop of Wells from 1060 to 1088. A native of Lorraine, Gisa came to England as a chaplain to King Edward the Confessor. After his appointment to Wells, he travelled to Rome rather than be consecrated by Stigand, the Archbishop of Canterbury. As bishop, Gisa added buildings to his cathedral, introduced new saints to his diocese, and instituted the office of archdeacon in his diocese. After the Norman Conquest, Gisa took part in the consecration of Lanfranc, the new Archbishop of Canterbury, and attended Lanfranc's church councils. His tomb in Wells Cathedral was opened in the 20th century and a cross was discovered in his tomb.

Grimketel was an English clergyman who went to Norway as a missionary and was partly responsible for the conversion of Norway to Christianity. He initiated the beatification of Saint Olaf. On his return to England he became Bishop of Selsey and also for a time Bishop of Elmham. He was accused, by some, of being guilty of simony.

Æthelric was the second to last medieval Bishop of Selsey in England before the see was moved to Chichester. Consecrated a bishop in 1058, he was deposed in 1070 for unknown reasons and then imprisoned by King William I of England. He was considered one of the best legal experts of his time, and was even brought from his prison to attend the trial on Penenden Heath where he gave testimony about English law before the Norman Conquest of England.

Stigand was the last Bishop of Selsey, and first Bishop of Chichester.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Accord of Winchester</span> 11th-century document from England dealing with the primacy of Canterbury in the English Church

The Accord of Winchester is the 11th-century document that establishes the primacy of the archbishop of Canterbury over the archbishop of York.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Remigius de Fécamp</span> 11th-century Bishop of Lincoln

Remigius de Fécamp was a Benedictine monk who was a supporter of William the Conqueror.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Walkelin</span> 11th-century Bishop of Winchester

Walkelin was the first Norman Bishop of Winchester. He began the construction of Winchester Cathedral in 1079 and had the Old Minster demolished. He reformed the cathedral's administration, although his plan to replace the monks with priests was blocked by the Archbishop of Canterbury, Lanfranc. Walkelin was important in beginning St Giles's Fair in Winchester and was greatly active in national politics. For example, he signed the Accord of Winchester, was involved in the Council of London in 1075, and sought to resolve a conflict between Anselm of Canterbury and William II. He was regent of England for a few months at the end of his life.

Godfrey was a medieval Bishop of Chichester. The first Bishop of Chichester was Stigand, who died in 1087; it seems that he was followed by Godfrey. Confusion over the succession was generated by William of Malmesbury, who suggested that Stigand was succeeded by a Bishop William.

Leofwin was a medieval Bishop of Lichfield.

Events from the 1070s in England.

The Council of London in 1075 was a council of the Catholic Church in England held by the new Norman archbishop of Canterbury Lanfranc five years after his installation. Other attendees included Gisa, Bishop of Wells and William the Norman. The Council of London produced several decrees, these were known as the "Canons of the Council of London AD 1075".

The Canterbury–York dispute was a long-running conflict between the archdioceses of Canterbury and York in medieval England. It began shortly after the Norman Conquest of England and dragged on for many years. The main point of the dispute was over whether Canterbury would have jurisdiction, or primacy, over York. A number of archbishops of Canterbury attempted to secure professions of obedience from successive archbishops of York, but in the end they were unsuccessful. York fought the primacy by appealing to the kings of England as well as the papacy. In 1127, the dispute over the primacy was settled mainly in York's favour, for they did not have to submit to Canterbury. Later aspects of the dispute dealt with concerns over status and prestige.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Coronations of William the Conqueror and Matilda</span> Initiation rite performed to William I of England in 1066

The coronation of William the Conqueror as King of England took place at Westminster Abbey, London, on 25 December 1066, following the Norman Conquest of England. It was the first coronation which can be proved to have been held at Westminster. In May 1068, William's wife, Matilda of Flanders, was also crowned at the abbey. At Easter in 1070, William was crowned for a second time at Winchester by three papal legates, to confirm the acceptance of his rule by the Catholic Church.

References

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.